1 Samuel Chapter 28 Read as one passage
1 Samuel 28:15–19
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
15Then Samuel said to Saul, “Why have you disturbed me by bringing me up?” “I am deeply distressed,” replied Saul. “The Philistines are fighting against me, and God has turned away from me. He no longer answers me, either by prophets or by dreams. So I have called on you to tell me what to do.” 16“Why do you consult me,” asked Samuel, “since the LORD has turned away from you and become your enemy? 17He has done exactly what He spoke through me: The LORD has torn the kingdom out of your hand and given it to your neighbor David. 18Because you did not obey the LORD or carry out His burning anger against Amalek, the LORD has done this to you today. 19Moreover, the LORD will deliver Israel with you into the hand of the Philistines, and tomorrow you and your sons will be with me. And the LORD will deliver the army of Israel into the hand of the Philistines.”
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers this verse would have been chilling on several levels.
- The king had become what he had banned. Saul enforced the Torah's ban on mediums (28:3), and now he breaks it himself. His slide from rejected king to someone seeking guidance from the dead finishes here. Later Israelite writers read it exactly this way. 1 Chronicles 10:13–14 says Saul died "for his unfaithfulness … and also for consulting a medium, seeking guidance, and did not seek guidance from YHWH."
- God's silence was a verdict. In a world where kings went to war only with a divine answer, "he no longer answers me" meant that the kingdom had lost its divine backing. Hearers would have caught the contrast with David, who in the same kind of distress "asks" and is answered (23:2–4; 30:6–8).
- The dead belong to the dead. Samuel's first word, the language of a disturbed grave, confirms that calling up the dead violated the order of things. Even if it works, it brings no help. The prophet comes up only to repeat the judgment he gave while alive.
- Prophetic word holds beyond death. Samuel's word against Saul (ch. 15) is not undone by Samuel's death. Ben Sira later celebrated this: "even after he had fallen asleep he prophesied, and made known to the king his end" (Sirach 46:20). Whatever hearers believed about the woman's arts, the story makes YHWH's decision final.
- A king with no exit. The 'narrow place' image would have landed hard. Saul is trapped between an army and a closed heaven. The next night he will die on Gilboa with his sons (ch. 31).
From the study of 1 Samuel 28:15.
Verse by verse
-
15Then Samuel said to Saul, “Why have you disturbed me by bringing me up?” “I am deeply distressed,” replied Saul. “The Philistines are fighting against me, and God has turned away from me. He no longer answers me, either by prophets or by dreams. So I have called on you to tell me what to do.”
Full study →The dead prophet speaks first, and his first words are a complaint: "Why have you shaken me out of my rest by hauling me up?" The verb is the one ancient tomb inscriptions used to curse anyone who would disturb the dead. Samuel speaks like a man pulled from his grave, brought up out of the earth where all the dead lay.
Saul's answer pours out of a man cornered on every side: "I am in a terribly tight place." Hebrew pictures distress as being hemmed in with no room to move. "The Philistines are at war with me," and the army is already camped across the valley, with battle at dawn. "And God has turned away from upon me." These are the same words the narrator used when the Spirit of the LORD left Saul (16:14). The presence that once rested on him like a mantle has lifted. "He no longer answers me," where "answer" is the formal word for God's reply when someone asks for a ruling. Saul has tried the lawful channels and they have all gone silent: "neither through the prophets nor through dreams." He quietly leaves out the Urim, the priestly lots that v.6 mentions. "So I summoned you, to make me know what I am to do."
Saul wants a battle plan. The verse sets up a painful irony. The king who once expelled the necromancers has turned necromancer himself, to ask a dead man for the guidance God would not give. And the man he calls up is the prophet who had already told him that God had rejected him (ch. 15). Samuel's answer (vv.16–19) will not tell him what to do. It will tell him what is about to happen to him.
-
16“Why do you consult me,” asked Samuel, “since the LORD has turned away from you and become your enemy?
Full study →Samuel answers Saul's desperate explanation with a question that takes it apart: "So why, then, are you asking me, when Yahweh himself has turned aside from you and has become your opponent?"
Several things in the Hebrew are easy to miss in English:
- "Asking" is the oracle word. Saul has "asked" Yahweh through dreams, priestly lots and prophets and been met with silence (v. 6). Now he "asks" a dead prophet through a forbidden medium. The verb is the same one in Saul's name (Shaʾul, "asked-for") and in the people's request for a king ("the king you asked for," 12:13). Samuel's "why do you ask me?" means: a prophet is only Yahweh's mouth. If Yahweh will not speak, I have nothing to tell you.
- "Turned aside" is Saul's own word from the verse before. Samuel confirms Saul's diagnosis and recalls the earlier moment when "the spirit of Yahweh turned aside from Saul" (16:14) and came to rest on David.
- "From upon you" pictures divine favour as something that once rested on Saul and has now lifted off.
- "Your adversary" is a rare word for an opponent in conflict. On the night before the battle of Gilboa, with the Philistines lined up against Saul, it means Yahweh is no longer fighting for Saul. He stands on the other side. (The ancient Greek translation instead reads "has gone over to your neighbour," anticipating "your neighbour David" in the next verse. Either way, Yahweh has changed sides.)
The question needs no answer. It sets up the verdict that follows in vv. 17–19: the kingdom torn away, and Saul and his sons dead by tomorrow.
-
17He has done exactly what He spoke through me: The LORD has torn the kingdom out of your hand and given it to your neighbor David.
Full study →"Yahweh has done to you exactly what he declared through me, by my own hand as his messenger. Yahweh has ripped the kingship out of your grip, as surely as you once tore my robe, and has handed it to another man from your own circle: to David."
Samuel's words are the reply to a desperate king. Saul has broken his own ban on necromancy, consulting the dead, in order to get one more word from the prophet. What he hears is not new. It is the sentence spoken years earlier at Gilgal (1 Samuel 15:28), repeated almost word for word, with the anonymous "fellow" now given a name. The verbs speak of the event as finished: God has done it, has torn it, has given it. Saul still sits on the throne, but the decision has already been carried out. The "hand" language is deliberate. The word came by Samuel's hand, and the kingdom is taken from Saul's hand. The prophet was only ever the carrier of the verdict, so Saul cannot get the kingdom back by summoning him. "Tear" is a cloth-ripping word, and it brings back the scene of the torn robe. The one who receives the kingdom is Saul's rēaʿ: a peer and associate, a man who had served at his court and married his daughter, and whom Saul had hunted as a rival.
-
18Because you did not obey the LORD or carry out His burning anger against Amalek, the LORD has done this to you today.
Full study →"Because you would not listen to the voice of Yahweh, the voice that spoke to you through me, and because you would not carry out the sentence of his blazing anger against Amalek, the judgment you were appointed to put into effect, for that reason Yahweh has done this to you. What he once spoke has now come true, and it lands on you today."
The verse is a verdict with two parts, joined by "therefore." The first part makes two charges. Saul did not respond to God's voice, and that failure came out in one concrete act: he left God's judgment on Amalek unfinished. "Burning anger," literally "the burning of his nose," is not a passing mood here. It names a declared sentence that Saul, as king, was supposed to carry out. The second part gives the result, and it reuses the same verb: Saul did not do God's anger, so God has done this thing to Saul. The punishment is shaped like the failure.
Two details tie the moment to the past. "Listen to the voice of Yahweh" repeats Samuel's accusation in 1 Samuel 15 word for word. There Saul admitted he had listened to the people's voice instead. And "today" recalls Samuel's words then: "Yahweh has torn the kingdom from you today." The sentence passed years before is now being carried out, on the night before the battle in which Saul will die.
-
19Moreover, the LORD will deliver Israel with you into the hand of the Philistines, and tomorrow you and your sons will be with me. And the LORD will deliver the army of Israel into the hand of the Philistines.”
Full study →"And so — because of all this — Yahweh will hand over not only you but Israel too, together with you, into the power of the Philistines. And tomorrow, you and your sons will be with me, down here among the dead. Yes, and the very army of Israel camped on that mountain: Yahweh will hand it over into the power of the Philistines."
This is the last thing the dead Samuel says, and it carries on from the charge in verse 18. Saul did not carry out God's judgment on Amalek, so judgment now falls on him. The words that frame the verse ("Yahweh will give… into the hand of the Philistines") are Israel's usual phrase for God winning its battles. Here it is turned around: God is fighting against Saul's Israel. It also mirrors the start of Saul's story, when God promised that "about this time tomorrow" he would send a man to save Israel "from the hand of the Philistines" (9:16). Now it is "tomorrow" again, and Israel goes into that hand.
The middle line has no verb in Hebrew: "Tomorrow, you and your sons, with me." It is blunt, like a sentence passed in court. "With me" is spoken by a man who has just come "up from the earth" (28:13–15). It means: by tomorrow night you will be dead, in the place where I am. It is about the shared realm of the dead, not a verdict on heaven or hell. The king's fall pulls everything down with him: his sons, his people, his army.
Where the English drifted
-
in v15
bringing me up
leha'alot oti
- What we hear
- Many readers picture Samuel summoned down from heaven, where they assume the righteous dead are.
- What they heard
- The dead, good and bad alike, were below the earth in Sheol. Samuel is brought up out of the ground (v.13, 'coming up out of the earth'). The scene reflects Israel's early picture of the afterlife, not later ideas of heaven for the righteous.
-
in v15
disturbed / disquieted
hirgaztani (ragaz)
- What we hear
- Interrupted or inconvenienced, as in 'sorry to disturb you.'
- What they heard
- Made to quake, roused from rest. This is the standard term for violating the repose of the dead, used in tomb curses.
-
in v15
God has departed from me
elohim sar me'alai
- What we hear
- It can be heard as loss of personal salvation, or as the emotional sense that God feels far away.
-
in v16
the LORD
YHWH (Yahweh)
- What we hear
- A general title of respect for God, interchangeable with 'God' in the previous verse.
- What they heard
- The personal covenant name of Israel's God. Samuel deliberately uses it after Saul has spoken only of 'God' (Elohim), naming the God who chose Saul, gave him commands and has now rejected him.
-
in v17
neighbor / neighbour
rēaʿ
- What we hear
- Someone who lives near you, or a friendly person nearby.
- What they heard
- A fellow, associate or peer: someone in your own circle or community. Here it means David, a member of Saul's court and family by marriage who had become his rival.
-
in v17
rent (KJV)
qāraʿ
- What we hear
- Payment for using property, or at best an odd poetic word.
- What they heard
- Tore or ripped, a violent physical action used for tearing cloth.
-
in v18
fierce wrath / burning anger
charon af
- What we hear
- An emotional outburst, rage felt inside God.
- What they heard
- A declared judgment that was to be put into effect. The idiom pictures anger at full heat ("burning of the nose"), but you can "do" or "carry out" it only because it stands for a sentence passed on Amalek, with Saul named to carry it out.
-
in v19
the LORD will deliver Israel
natan beyad
- What we hear
- In church English "deliver" usually means rescue, so "the LORD will deliver Israel" can sound like a promise of salvation.
- What they heard
- "Give into the hand of": hand over, surrender to the enemy. This is a promise of defeat.
-
in v19
you and your sons will be with me
'immi
- What we hear
- Reunion with the righteous prophet in heaven, so Saul was saved; or, if the figure was a demon, company in hell.
- What they heard
- "You will be where I am, among the dead." Samuel has come up from the underworld. All the dead, righteous or not, were thought to share Sheol, so this is a death sentence, not a statement about eternal destiny.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v19
"With me" is about death, not where Saul spent eternity
- What's often taught
- Because the righteous prophet Samuel says Saul and his sons "will be with me", some teach that Saul was finally saved and joined Samuel in paradise. Others, who believe the figure was a demon, read "with me" as meaning Saul went to hell.
- What the text supports
In the Hebrew, Samuel has just come up from the earth and complains of being "brought up" (28:13–15). In early Israelite thought all the dead went down to Sheol, a shared underworld for the righteous and the wicked alike (Job 3:13–19; Eccl 9:2–10). "Tomorrow you and your sons [will be] with me" therefore means: by tomorrow you will be dead, where I am. The same phrase covers Saul and his faithful son Jonathan without distinction, which shows it is about the fact and timing of death, not reward or punishment. The verse is a sentence of death and defeat for Saul's house. It gives no information about Saul's eternal destiny either way.
- Where the English feeds it
- "Be with me" in modern Christian English strongly suggests a reunion after death (compare "today you will be with me in paradise", Luke 23:43). That makes it easy to hear a heaven-or-hell destination that the Hebrew 'immi does not express.
Every word
-
וַיֹּ֤אמֶר
vayyomer · H0559
and he said · v15, v16
Ordinary narrative 'and he said.' The narrator, not the woman, introduces the speaker: the story itself names him Samuel.
-
שְׁמוּאֵל֙
shemu'el · H8050G
-
אֶל־
el · H0413
to · v15
Samuel speaks to Saul directly. The medium drops out of the conversation from here on.
-
שָׁא֔וּל
sha'ul · H7586G
-
לָ֥מָּה
lammah · H4100
why? · v15, v16
'For what (reason)?' A reproachful question, not a request for information. Samuel will ask the same 'why' again in v.16.
-
הִרְגַּזְתַּ֖נִי
hirgaztani · H7264
you have made me tremble / disturbed me · v15
Literally 'you have made me quake.' This is the stock word for disturbing the dead in their resting place, the same verb used in ancient tomb curses: 'do not disturb me.'
-
לְהַעֲל֣וֹת
leha'alot · H5927H
-
אֹתִ֑י
oti · H0853
me (object) · v15, v17, v19
The object marker with 'me.' Samuel names himself as the one brought up against his will.
-
צַר־
tsar · H6887B
to be narrow / in distress · v15
'It is tight, narrow.' In Hebrew, distress is a feeling of being hemmed in with no room to move. That matches Saul exactly: an enemy army in front of him and heaven shut above him.
-
לִ֨י
li · H9030
to me · v15
'For me.' The phrase 'tsar li' means 'I am in a tight place.'
-
מְאֹ֜ד
me'od · H3966
very, exceedingly · v15
An intensifier: 'very.' This is the extreme of Saul's predicament.
-
וּפְלִשְׁתִּ֣ים׀
uphelishtim · H6430G
-
נִלְחָמִ֣ים
nilchamim · H3898A
fighting · v15
A participle, meaning an ongoing state: 'are at war with me' right now. Battle is expected the next day.
-
וֵֽאלֹהִ֞ים
ve'elohim · H0430G
and God · v15
With a singular verb this means the God of Israel. Saul says 'God,' but Samuel's reply uses the covenant name YHWH (v.16). Two verses earlier the woman had used the same word, elohim, for the ghostly figure 'coming up out of the earth' (v.13).
-
סָ֤ר
sar · H5493H
-
מֵֽעָלַי֙
me'alai · H5921A
from upon me · v15, v16, v18
Literally 'from upon me,' as though God had once rested on him like a covering. Samuel throws the exact phrase back at him in v.16, 'turned away from upon you.'
-
וְלֹֽא־
velo · H3808
and not · v15, v18
Negation.
-
עָנָ֣נִי
anani · H6030B
-
ע֗וֹד
od · H5750
any more, still · v15
'No longer.' It implies that God once did answer him.
-
גַּ֤ם
gam · H1571
also / neither · v15, v19
Paired 'gam … gam': 'neither … nor.' The two channels are listed one after the other.
-
בְּיַֽד־
beyad · H3027J
by the hand of · v15, v17, v19
'By the hand of' means 'through the agency of.' Prophets are the instruments God answers through.
-
הַנְּבִיאִם֙
hannevi'im · H5030
the prophets · v15
Spokesmen for God whom a king could ask for a divine verdict, especially before battle. The spelling is shortened (no yod before the final mem).
-
בַּ֣חֲלֹמ֔וֹת
bachalomot · H2472
by dreams · v15
Dreams were an accepted way for God to reveal himself in Israel and across the ancient Near East. Saul leaves out the third channel named in v.6, the Urim.
-
וָאֶקְרָאֶ֣ה
va'eqra'eh · H7121G
and I have called · v15
'So I called you.' This is an unusual form of the narrative verb with an extra -ah ending. It probably adds emphasis or a sense of resolve: 'so I summoned you.'
-
לְךָ֔
lekha · H9031
to you · v15, v18
'For you / to you.' Samuel is the one being summoned.
-
לְהוֹדִיעֵ֖נִי
lehodi'eni · H3045
to make known to me · v15
'To cause me to know.' Saul wants specific instructions, the kind a king expected from an oracle.
-
אֶעֱשֶֽׂה׃
e'eseh · H6213A
I shall do · v15, v17, v18
'What I should do' or 'what I am to do.' Saul is asking for tactics or a plan, not comfort. Samuel's answer will be a verdict instead (vv.16–19).
-
תִּשְׁאָלֵ֑נִי
tishʾaleni · H7592
you ask me · v16
'You ask me.' The verb is the standard word for seeking an oracle (a divine answer). It is the same verb used when Saul 'inquired of Yahweh' in 28:6, and it sounds like Saul's own name, Shaʾul, 'asked-for'. The 'me' is stressed: why come to me, of all people?
-
וַיהוָ֛ה
waYHWH · H3068
and Yahweh · v16, v17, v18, v19
In v. 15 Saul said 'God' (Elohim). Samuel answers with the personal covenant name, Yahweh. The word order puts Yahweh first in the clause: 'when Yahweh himself has…'
-
וַיְהִ֥י
wayhi · H1961
and he became · v16
'And has become.' This marks a change of state. Yahweh has not just withdrawn. He has moved from Saul's side to the opposing side.
-
עָרֶֽךָ׃
ʿarekha · H6145
your adversary · v16
'Your adversary, your opponent.' This is a rare word, probably borrowed from Aramaic. With the Philistines lined up against Saul (v. 15), the point is that Yahweh now stands among the forces opposed to him. The Greek translation reads 'with your neighbour' here instead (see textual notes).
-
ל֔וֹ
lô · H9033
to him / for him · v17
As written, this reads "to him" or "for himself". Because Samuel is speaking to Saul, many scholars and the Greek translation read "to you". Another view takes it as "for himself": God acted for his own purpose. See the textual notes.
-
כַּאֲשֶׁ֖ר
kaʾăšer · H0834D
just as, according as · v17, v18
This introduces the match between word and event: what happened corresponds exactly to what was said. It is a stock phrase in Israel's histories for prophecies coming true.
-
דִּבֶּ֣ר
dibber · H1696G
speak, declare · v17
"He spoke." The form looks back to an earlier announcement, chiefly Samuel's sentence on Saul in 1 Samuel 15:28 (and 13:13–14).
-
וַיִּקְרַ֨ע
wayyiqraʿ · H7167
tear, rip, rend · v17
"And [he] has torn." It is a violent, physical verb, the word for ripping cloth. It deliberately recalls the day Saul tore Samuel's robe (15:27–28).
-
הַמַּמְלָכָה֙
hammamlākâ · H4467
kingdom, royal rule, reign · v17
"The kingship": the office and right to rule over Israel, including the hope of a dynasty, more than a piece of land.
-
וַֽיִּתְּנָ֖הּ
wayyittĕnāh · H5414G
give · v17, v19
"And [he] has given it." The feminine "it" points back to the kingdom. The tearing and the giving are one act: God takes from one man and hands to another.
-
לְרֵעֲךָ֥
lĕrēʿăkā · H7453
fellow, companion, another person · v17
"To your fellow": another man from Saul's own circle. Samuel used the same deliberately vague word in 15:28 without naming anyone. The word means a fellow Israelite or associate, not the man next door.
-
לְדָוִֽד׃
lĕdāwid · H1732
David · v17
"To David": the name finally attached to the "fellow" of 15:28, added as an explanation. It is the first time Samuel names David to Saul as his replacement.
-
שָׁמַ֙עְתָּ֙
shama'ta · H8085H
hear, listen, obey · v18
"You listened." With "to the voice of" it means listening that turns into doing. Saul heard the order clearly in 1 Samuel 15. What he failed to do was act on it.
-
בְּק֣וֹל
beqol · H6963A
voice, sound · v18
"To the voice of." This repeats Samuel's charge in 1 Sam 15:19–22 word for word, and it echoes Saul's own excuse in 15:24: "I feared the people and listened to their voice."
-
חֲרוֹן־
charon · H2740
burning, heat (of anger) · v18
"The burning of." It comes from the root for "burn, be hot" and marks the anger as at its fiercest.
-
אַפּ֖וֹ
appo · H0639G
nose, nostril; anger · v18
"His nose," meaning his anger. The picture is of flaring, heated nostrils. Together the phrase means "his blazing anger." It refers to God's declared judgment on Amalek in 1 Sam 15:2–3.
-
בַּעֲמָלֵ֑ק
ba'amalek · H6002G
Amalek · v18
"On/against Amalek." This is the desert people who attacked Israel after the Exodus (Exod 17; Deut 25:17–19). The name stands for the whole people.
-
כֵּן֙
ken · H3651C
so, thus · v18
Completes "therefore." The verse has a strict because-therefore shape: the cause comes first, then the result.
-
הַדָּבָ֣ר
haddavar · H1697I
word; thing, matter · v18
"The thing." It means the present disaster: God is silent, the kingdom is torn away, the Philistines are closing in. Davar also means "word," and here the "thing" is the earlier spoken word now coming true (v. 17: "as he spoke through me").
-
הַזֶּ֔ה
hazzeh · H2088
this · v18
"This" thing. It points to what is happening right now, in front of Saul.
-
הַיּ֥וֹם
hayyom · H3117L
day; today · v18
"The day," meaning today. It echoes 1 Sam 15:28, "Yahweh has torn the kingdom of Israel from you today." The "today" spoken years earlier has arrived.
-
יִשְׂרָאֵ֤ל
yisra'el · H3478
Israel · v19
The people as a whole, whose fortunes are tied to their king.
-
עִמְּךָ֙
'immekha · H5973
with you · v19
"Along with you." The king and his people fall together. Saul's disobedience drags the nation into his defeat.
-
וּמָחָ֕ר
umachar · H4279
and tomorrow · v19
"And tomorrow." It is night (28:8), so this points to the coming day's battle on Mount Gilboa (ch. 31). The deadline is immediate.
-
אַתָּ֥ה
attah · H0859
you · v19
"You," set first and stressed. The clause has no verb at all, which makes it blunt.
-
וּבָנֶ֖יךָ
uvaneykha · H1121
-
מַחֲנֵ֣ה
machaneh · H4264
camp, army · v19
"Camp," the army in the field. Israel was encamped at Gilboa (28:4), and the whole force will be overrun.
The world behind it
The night before Gilboa. The Philistines have gathered at Shunem in the Jezreel Valley, and Israel is camped on Mount Gilboa across from them (28:4). Samuel is dead and buried at Ramah (25:1; 28:3). David, whom Samuel anointed in Saul's place, is living among the Philistines. Saul is terrified (28:5). He asks YHWH and gets no answer by dreams, by Urim or by prophets (28:6). Then he disguises himself and goes by night to a woman at Endor who is a baʿalat ʾov, a "mistress of a ghost-pit" or spirit-medium (28:7–8).
Necromancy in Israel and its neighbors. Consulting the dead was widespread in the ancient Near East. Mesopotamian texts describe rituals for raising a ghost (eṭemmu), and the Gilgamesh tradition has Enkidu's ghost brought up through a hole in the ground. The Torah bans the practice outright (Lev 19:31; 20:6, 27; Deut 18:10–11), and Saul himself had "removed the mediums and spiritists from the land" (28:3, 9). The dead were thought to live below, in Sheol, in a still, shadowy state. They could sometimes be roused to give knowledge the living lacked. Disturbing them was a serious violation. Phoenician kings had their sarcophagi inscribed with curses on anyone who would "disturb" them, using the very verb Samuel uses here.
Asking God before war. A king did not go into battle without a divine verdict. In Israel this came through the Urim and Thummim held by the priest's ephod, through prophets, or through dreams. Saul had cut himself off from the priestly channel by massacring the priests of Nob (ch. 22). The one survivor, Abiathar, fled to David with the ephod (22:20; 23:6), and David goes on to receive answers through it (23:9–12; 30:7–8). This history may be why Saul, speaking to Samuel, leaves the Urim off the list he gave in v.6.
From the study of 1 Samuel 28:15.
Where scholars differ
in v15, v16
Was the figure who speaks really Samuel?
-
Yes. The text presents the real Samuel, brought up by God's permission or by God's surprising action.
The narrator, not the woman, says 'Samuel said' (vv.15, 16, 20). The woman's alarm in v.12 suggests something beyond her usual practice. The message matches Samuel's earlier words (15:28) and comes true (ch. 31). Sirach 46:20, Josephus, Pseudo-Philo and Origen (Homily on 1 Kingdoms 28) all take it as Samuel. Most modern commentators (e.g., McCarter, Alter) read the narrative this way.
-
No. It was a demonic impersonation or a deceptive apparition.
This is argued on theological grounds: God would not honor a forbidden rite, and the dead (or the righteous dead) cannot be summoned by a medium. Eustathius of Antioch (*On the Belly-Myther*, against Origen), Tertullian and some Reformation-era interpreters held views of this kind. The text itself never signals deception, so this view rests on doctrine applied to the text.
-
The medium staged it, and the narrator reports it from Saul's perspective.
Saul never sees the figure; he relies on the woman's description (vv.13–14). Some rationalizing interpreters, ancient and modern, suggest ventriloquism or trickery. Against this, the narrator's own voice attributes the speech to Samuel, and the prophecy proves accurate.
in v15
Is it significant that Saul says 'God' (Elohim) while Samuel says 'YHWH'?
-
Yes. Saul's distance from the covenant God shows in his speech.
In v.16 Samuel deliberately answers with the covenant name YHWH, repeating Saul's own verb ('YHWH has turned away from upon you'). Some readers also see wordplay with v.13, where elohim describes the figure coming up from the earth.
-
Probably not. The two terms alternate freely in Samuel.
Saul uses both names elsewhere (e.g., 14:37 'Saul asked God'; 28:10 he swears by YHWH). The switch may be stylistic. The evidence is suggestive, not decisive.
in v16
Did the original text say Yahweh became Saul's 'adversary' or went over to his 'neighbour'?
-
'Your adversary' (Masoretic text) is original.
It is the harder reading, and a scribe would hardly invent a rare Aramaic-type word. The Aramaic cognate in Dan 4:19 and the possible use in Ps 139:20 show the word existed.
-
'With your neighbour' (Septuagint) is original or better.
It fits v. 17's 'your neighbour David' and 15:28, and requires only a small letter change. Several modern commentators (e.g. McCarter) adopt it.
in v17
Who is speaking: the real Samuel, or something else?
-
The genuine spirit of Samuel, allowed by God to appear
The narrator repeatedly calls the figure "Samuel" (28:12, 14, 15, 16, 20). The woman is surprised and terrified, which suggests something beyond her usual practice. The message matches Samuel's earlier words exactly and comes true the next day. Sirach 46:20 says Samuel "prophesied after his death". Origen and many modern commentators take the narrative at face value.
-
A deceiving spirit or demonic impersonation
Some early Christian writers (e.g. Tertullian, *On the Soul* 57; Eustathius of Antioch against Origen) argued that God's prophet could not be summoned by a forbidden rite. The Torah's ban on necromancy is cited as evidence that such a practice could not truly reach the dead.
-
Deception or performance by the medium
Only the woman claims to see the figure, and Saul only hears. Some interpreters, ancient and modern, suggest she used her knowledge of Samuel's well-known verdict. Critics answer that the narrator presents the speaker as Samuel and the prediction about "tomorrow" as fulfilled.
in v17
How should the Hebrew lô ("to him") be read?
-
Read "to you" with the Septuagint and some Hebrew manuscripts
Samuel addresses Saul in the second person throughout (vv. 16–19). The Greek, the Latin and some Hebrew manuscripts have "to you". Most modern versions follow this.
-
Keep the Hebrew: "for himself"
"To him / for him" is grammatically possible as "for his own sake/purpose". The harder reading may be original. YLT renders it this way.
-
Keep the Hebrew: "to him" meaning David
This anticipates "your neighbor David" later in the verse. It is grammatically strained, because David has not yet been mentioned.
in v18
Who speaks at Endor? Is this really Samuel?
-
It is genuinely Samuel, allowed by God to speak.
The narrator simply calls the speaker "Samuel" (28:12, 14, 15, 16). The message matches Samuel's earlier words in 1 Sam 15 exactly, and the prediction comes true (ch. 31). The woman's terror (28:12) suggests something happened that she did not expect or control. Sirach 46:20 and Josephus read it this way, as does the Greek of 1 Chr 10:13 by most accounts.
-
It is an impersonation or illusion, often said to be demonic.
Several early Christian writers (e.g. Tertullian, *De anima* 57), and later others, could not accept that a forbidden rite would bring back a true prophet. They pointed to the ban on necromancy (Deut 18:10–12) and to Saul seeing nothing himself, since he relied on the woman's description.
-
The woman staged it.
Some interpreters have suggested fraud or trickery by the medium. Most commentators find this hard to square with the text, which shows her shocked by what appears and does not show her inventing the message.
in v19
Was the figure really Samuel?
-
It was really Samuel, permitted or sent by God.
The narrator says plainly that "Samuel said" (28:15, 16), with no hint of deception. The woman's terrified surprise (28:12) suggests something beyond her usual practice. The prophecy repeats Samuel's earlier words (15:28) and comes true exactly. Sirach 46:20 says Samuel "prophesied after his death", and Josephus (*Antiquities* 6.14) treats it as real. Origen argued this view in his homily on the passage.
-
It was a demon or deceiving spirit impersonating Samuel.
The law condemns necromancy (Deut 18:10–12), so some have reasoned that God would not answer through it, and that the dead are not at a medium's command. This view goes back to some church fathers and was held by several Reformers. It rests mainly on theological reasoning rather than anything in the wording of the narrative.
-
It was the woman's trickery (ventriloquism or staging).
Eustathius of Antioch (*On the Belly-Myther*) argued this, partly from the Greek word *engastrimythos*. Only the woman claims to see the figure, and Saul only hears. But a fraud producing an accurate prophecy of the king's death, against her own interest, is hard to explain on this view.
in v19
Does "tomorrow" mean the literal next day?
-
Yes, the following day.
The scene is set at night (28:8, 25). The armies are already in position (28:4), and chapter 31 picks up with the battle. Chapters 29–30 are set earlier or at the same time, as 29:1 places the Philistines back at Aphek. Within 1 Samuel *machar* usually means the next day (9:16; 20:5, 18).
-
"Soon" or "in the near future".
*Machar* can mean "in time to come" in set phrases (Exod 13:14; Josh 4:6). Some readers who find the order of chapters 28–31 hard to fit into one day prefer this. Most commentators find the literal reading workable.
Sources
- BDB s.v. רָגַז, צַר/צָרַר, סוּר, עָנָה
- HALOT s.v. רגז, צרר I, סור, ענה I
- Tabnit sarcophagus inscription (KAI 13) and Eshmunazar II sarcophagus (KAI 14), Phoenician tomb curses
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8)
- Robert Alter, The David Story
- Brian B. Schmidt, Israel's Beneficent Dead
- Josef Tropper, Nekromantie: Totenbefragung im Alten Orient und im Alten Testament
- Gesenius–Kautzsch–Cowley, Hebrew Grammar §49e (cohortative-shaped wayyiqtol)
- Origen, Homily on 1 Kingdoms 28; Eustathius of Antioch, De engastrimytho
- Josephus, Antiquities 6.327–342; Pseudo-Philo, Liber Antiquitatum Biblicarum 64
- Sirach 46:20; 1 Chronicles 10:13–14 (MT and LXX)
- Vulgate, 1 Samuel (1 Kings) 28:15
- Masoretic Text (Westminster Leningrad Codex), 1 Sam 28:15–17
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), 1 Kingdoms 28:16
- Vulgate, 1 Reg 28:16
- BDB s.v. עָר II; s.v. שָׁאַל; s.v. סוּר
- HALOT s.v. עָר
- S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Sirach 46:20; 1 Chronicles 10:13–14
- BDB s.v. קָרַע
- HALOT s.v. רֵעַ
- HALOT s.v. מַמְלָכָה
- BDB s.v. יָד (bĕyad, 'by the agency of')
- S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel (on 1 Sam 28:17)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), notes on 15:27–28 and 28:17–18
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 28:17 (σοι)
- Sirach 46:20
- Tertullian, De anima 57
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 28 (necromancy)
- BDB s.v. שָׁמַע; כַּאֲשֶׁר
- HALOT s.v. אַף; חָרוֹן; דָּבָר
- 1 Samuel 15:2–3, 9, 19–28
- Exodus 17:8–16; Deuteronomy 13:17; 25:17–19
- 1 Chronicles 10:13–14 (MT and LXX)
- Josephus, Antiquities 6.14.2
- Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone), on the ban (herem)
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 28:18
- BDB and HALOT s.v. נָתַן, יָד, עִם, מָחָר, מַחֲנֶה
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., *I Samuel* (Anchor Bible 8)
- Ralph W. Klein, *1 Samuel* (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Sam 28 (necromancy and ritual pits)
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 28:19; Vulgate, 1 Samuel 28:19
- Josephus, *Antiquities* 6.14
- Origen, *Homily on 1 Kingdoms 28*; Eustathius of Antioch, *De engastrimytho*
- 1 Chronicles 10:13–14
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).