2 Samuel Chapter 21 Read as one passage

2 Samuel 21:18–19

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

18Some time later at Gob, there was another battle with the Philistines. At that time Sibbecai the Hushathite killed Saph, a descendant of Rapha. 19Once again there was a battle with the Philistines at Gob, and Elhanan son of Jair the Bethlehemite killed the brother of Goliath the Gittite, the shaft of whose spear was like a weaver’s beam.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers this verse was a short line of honour in a roll of heroes. Its main points:

  • The Philistine threat recurred. 'Again' and 'once more' tell of a war that kept flaring up. David's reign was secured through repeated hard fighting on the western border.
  • David's men carried the fight. Just before this (v. 17) David nearly died and his men swore he would no longer go out to battle, calling him 'the lamp of Israel'. This verse shows a loyal officer, Sibbecai from David's own Judahite home region, taking on the danger and winning.
  • The enemy's reputation raised the victory. Saph is defined by his link to 'the Rapha', the remembered race of fearsome champions. To kill one of them was to overcome the most legendary threat the old traditions knew of. The faithful men of the king's circle receive the glory.
  • Memory and honour. Such lists preserved the names of warriors and their families, which mattered in a society where honour was held by clans. A Hushathite family could point to this line as part of its standing.

From the study of 2 Samuel 21:18.

Verse by verse

  1. 18Some time later at Gob, there was another battle with the Philistines. At that time Sibbecai the Hushathite killed Saph, a descendant of Rapha.

    On another occasion, as the long-running war with the Philistines flared up yet again, there was fighting at Gob, an unknown spot on the frontier that Chronicles remembers as Gezer. That was when Sibbecai, a man of the Hushah clan from David's home country around Bethlehem and one of David's elite warriors, struck down and killed Saph. Saph was no ordinary soldier. He was one of the 'born ones of the Rapha'. That means he belonged to the line or warrior band that traced itself to the legendary Rephaim, the dreaded ancient champions Israel remembered as huge men of old. Defeating such a man counted as a famous victory.

    The verse is the second of four short, matching reports (vv. 15–22). Each tells how one of David's men, not David himself, killed one of the four Rapha-champions of Gath. The verse does not describe Saph's size, weapons or appearance. What makes him notable is whose line or group he belonged to.

    Full study →
  2. 19Once again there was a battle with the Philistines at Gob, and Elhanan son of Jair the Bethlehemite killed the brother of Goliath the Gittite, the shaft of whose spear was like a weaver’s beam.

    "And the fighting with the Philistines broke out yet again at Gob. Elhanan, son of Jair (the text's 'Jaare-oregim' is probably a copying slip), a man of Bethlehem, struck down Goliath of Gath, the one whose spear shaft was like a weaver's rod."

    This is one short entry in a list of four Philistine champions from Gath, 'born to the Rapha', who were killed 'by the hand of David and by the hand of his servants' (v.22). The verb is the ordinary battle-report word for a killing blow. The description of the spear repeats, word for word, the description of Goliath's spear in 1 Samuel 17:7. The phrase pictures a weaver's loom rod: a heavy shaft, possibly fitted with a cord and loop for throwing, a weapon that looked foreign and frightening.

    As the Hebrew of Samuel stands (and the ancient Greek translation agrees), the man killed is Goliath himself, not 'the brother of Goliath'. The words 'the brother of' in many English Bibles come from the parallel in 1 Chronicles 20:5, which reads 'Lahmi the brother of Goliath'. Whether Chronicles preserves the original wording or smooths over a difficulty is a real, unresolved question (see debates and textual notes). The verse says plainly that one of David's Bethlehemite warriors is credited with killing a champion called Goliath of Gath.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v18

    the giant / the giants (KJV, WEB, YLT, ESV, NLT)

    hārāphāh

    What we hear
    A huge, perhaps monstrous or fairy-tale being. Some readers also take it as an individual described as gigantic.
    What they heard
    A name or title, 'the Rapha', linked to the Rephaim, a remembered people or warrior-lineage famed for size and prowess. It names Saph's lineage or group. It does not say how tall he was.
  • in v18

    sons of / descendants of

    yəlîdê

    What we hear
    Biological sons or a direct bloodline.
    What they heard
    'Born-ones of'. It can mean descendants, but the word often means those born into a household, such as house-born servants. So it may mean membership in a group attached to 'the Rapha' rather than strict descent.
  • in v19

    killed the brother of Goliath

    vayyakh … et Golyat ("struck … Goliath")

    What we hear
    Readers assume the Hebrew of 2 Samuel says Elhanan killed Goliath's brother, so the verse fits easily with 1 Samuel 17.
    What they heard
    The Hebrew of Samuel says Elhanan struck 'Goliath the Gittite'. 'Brother of' is taken from 1 Chronicles 20:5 and added by translators (KJV marks it in italics; some modern versions print it without marking).
Every word
  1. וַֽיְהִי֙

    vayhî · H1961

    and it was / and it came to pass · v18, v19

    A standard storytelling formula that opens a new episode. It marks a scene change, not a precise date (KJV: 'and it came to pass').

  2. אַֽחֲרֵי־

    ʾaḥărê · H0310A

    after · v18

    'After', joined to the next word to make 'after this'.

  3. כֵ֔ן

    khēn · H3651C

    so, thus · v18

    With the previous word, 'after this'. It points back to the fight with Ishbi-benob (vv. 15–17). In this collection of separate episodes it means 'on another occasion', not 'the next day'.

  4. ע֧וֹד

    ʿôd · H5750

    again, still · v18, v19

    'Again'. It ties this clash to the run of Philistine battles in the list (v. 15 'there was war again'). The Philistine conflict kept recurring.

  5. הַמִּלְחָמָ֛ה

    hammilḥāmāh · H4421

    war, battle · v18, v19

    'The war' or 'the fighting', with the definite article: the long-running warfare with the Philistines that flared up again at one more spot.

  6. בְּג֖וֹב

    bəGôv · H1359

    Gob · v18, v19

    'At Gob', a place mentioned only here and in v. 19. Nobody knows where it was. Chronicles has Gezer.

  7. עִם־

    ʿim · H5973A

    with · v18, v19

    After a word for war, 'with' means 'against': war with the Philistines.

  8. פְּלִשְׁתִּ֑ים

    pəlishtîm · H6430G

    Philistines · v18, v19

    The Philistines, the sea-peoples who settled the southern coastal plain (Gath, Gaza, Ashkelon, Ashdod, Ekron). They were Israel's chief military rival in the time of Saul and David.

  9. אָ֣ז

    ʾāz · H0227A

    then, at that time · v18

    'Then'. It points to the deed the episode is remembered for, and the same word recurs in this hero list.

  10. הִכָּ֗ה

    hikkāh · H5221

    strike, strike down · v18, v19

    'Struck (down)'. In battle accounts this verb normally means a fatal blow, so 'killed' (BSB) or 'slew' (KJV) is right.

  11. סִבְּכַי֙

    Sibbəkhay · H5444

    Sibbecai · v18

    An Israelite warrior, listed among David's 'Thirty' (1 Chr 11:29) and as commander of the army division on duty in the eighth month (1 Chr 27:11).

  12. הַחֻ֣שָׁתִ֔י

    haḤushātî · H2843

    Hushathite · v18

    'The Hushathite': a man of Hushah, a Judahite clan or village connected with the Bethlehem area (1 Chr 4:4). So the champion is a Judahite from David's home region.

  13. אֶת־

    ʾet · H0853

    (direct object marker) · v18, v19

    Untranslated marker showing that Saph receives the blow.

  14. סַ֕ף

    Saph · H5593

    Saph · v18

    The Philistine champion's name. Chronicles has 'Sippai'. The same consonants can mean 'threshold' or 'basin', but no one knows if that matters for a foreign name.

  15. אֲשֶׁ֖ר

    ʾăsher · H0834A

    who, which · v18

    'Who [was]'. It opens the note that explains why killing this man was worth recording.

  16. בִּילִדֵ֥י

    bîlîdê · H3211

    born ones, offspring · v18

    'Among the born-ones of'. It can mean natural descendants, but elsewhere in the Bible the word often means someone born into a household, such as a home-born servant. So it may mean belonging to a group, not just family descent.

  17. הָרָפָֽה

    hārāphāh · H7497A

    the Rapha · v18

    'The Rapha', with the article. It is a name or title tied to the Rephaim, a legendary race of tall ancient warriors. Saph is placed in that line. The text does not describe his size.

  18. אֶלְחָנָן

    Elchanan · H0445G

    Elhanan · v19

    A personal name meaning 'God has been gracious'. An Elhanan of Bethlehem also appears in David's elite 'Thirty' (2 Sam 23:24, 'son of Dodo'), and he may be the same man.

  19. בֶּן־

    ben · H1121A

    son of · v19

    'Son of', giving the father's name, the usual way an Israelite was identified.

  20. יַעְרֵי

    Yaarei · H3296

    Jaare- · v19

    First part of the father's name. It looks like 'forests of', but 1 Chr 20:5 has 'Jair', which suggests the original name was Jair/Jaor.

  21. בֵּית

    Beit · H1022

    Beth- · v19

    First part of 'Bethlehemite' ('house of bread'). These letters matter for the textual question, because Chronicles appears to read some of them as part of a name, 'Lahmi'.

  22. גָּלְיָת

    Golyat · H1555

    Goliath · v19

    Goliath, the name given to the champion of Gath in 1 Sam 17:4, 23. In Hebrew Samuel he is directly the object of Elhanan's blow.

  23. הַגִּתִּי

    haGitti · H1663

    the Gittite · v19

    'The man from Gath', one of the five main Philistine cities. Verse 22 says these champions were 'born to the Rapha in Gath'.

  24. וְעֵץ

    veets · H6086J

    and the wood of, shaft · v19

    'And the wood of', meaning the wooden shaft of the spear, as opposed to its iron head.

  25. חֲנִיתוֹ

    chanito · H2595

    his spear · v19

    'His spear': a thrusting spear or javelin. The phrase that follows is word-for-word the description of Goliath's spear in 1 Sam 17:7.

  26. כִּמְנוֹר

    kimnor · H4500

    like a beam (of a loom) · v19

    'Like the beam/rod of', a part of a loom. The comparison may refer to the spear's thickness or to a loop-and-cord fitting that looked like a loom rod (see studies).

  27. אֹרְגִים

    oregim · H0707

    weavers · v19

    'Weavers', a participle used as a noun. 'A weavers' beam' was a familiar household picture of a heavy rod with cords tied to it.

The world behind it

Where this verse sits. 2 Samuel 21–24 is an appendix: a carefully arranged collection of stories, lists and poems placed at the end of David's story, not in time order. Verses 15–22 form a small list of four exploits against 'those born to the Rapha in Gath' (v. 22). So the phrase 'after this' marks only a new item in the list, not a fixed point in time.

The Philistine frontier. The Philistines held the coastal plain, with Gath (modern Tell es-Safi) as the city closest to Judah. Fighting with them went on for generations along the low hill country between the plain and Judah's highlands. Gezer, the place named in Chronicles, was a key fortress on that border.

Champions and the Rephaim. In the ancient Near East battles could centre on single combat between champions, and killing a famous enemy champion brought great honour (compare 1 Samuel 17). Israel's traditions remembered the Rephaim as a tall, fearsome race of the land's former inhabitants, survivors of which lived on in Philistine cities (Josh 11:22: Anakim remained 'in Gaza, in Gath, and in Ashdod'). Older texts from Ugarit use the related word for heroic, even semi-divine, warrior-ancestors. When an Israelite audience heard that Saph was 'of the born-ones of the Rapha', they heard that he belonged to that legendary breed of enemy. That made Sibbecai's deed worth recording among the honours of David's men.

From the study of 2 Samuel 21:18.

Where scholars differ

in v18

Who or what is 'the Rapha' (hārāphāh)?

  • An individual ancestor, perhaps a famous giant of Gath, whose sons or descendants were these four champions.

    The singular with the article, and v. 22 'these four were born to the Rapha in Gath', read most naturally as a single father figure. This is the traditional reading behind KJV 'the giant' and NIV/BSB 'Rapha'.

  • A collective name for the Rephaim, the remembered race of tall ancient warriors, of which Philistine Gath kept a remnant.

    1 Chronicles 20:4 reads 'the Rephaim'. Deuteronomy 2–3 and Joshua 11:22 place Rephaim/Anakim survivors in Philistine cities, and v. 20 describes one of the group as exceptionally tall with extra fingers and toes.

  • The patron, or patron-god, of an elite Philistine warrior guild whose members were 'born into the household' of Rapha.

    *Yālîd* commonly means a house-born servant (Gen 17:12; Lev 22:11). Ugaritic texts know *rpu*/*rpum* as heroic warrior-ancestors and a divine figure. Willesen (1958) argued for a 'corps' at Gath, and some major commentaries (e.g. McCarter) consider it possible. Critics note that the evidence is indirect and that the biblical writer at least understood a lineage of very large men.

in v18

Where was the battle: Gob or Gezer?

  • Gob is original: a real but now unidentified place near the Philistine frontier.

    The traditional Hebrew text reads Gob twice (vv. 18–19). An obscure name is less likely to be invented by a scribe than a famous one like Gezer.

  • Gezer (or another known site) is original, and 'Gob' is a copying corruption.

    1 Chronicles 20:4 reads Gezer, Greek manuscripts vary, and Gob is attested nowhere else. Similar-looking names nearby (Nob in v. 16, Gath in v. 20) offer routes for confusion.

in v19

Who killed Goliath: David (1 Sam 17) or Elhanan (2 Sam 21:19)?

  • Chronicles preserves the original: Elhanan killed Lahmi, Goliath's brother, and the Hebrew of Samuel is damaged.

    The consonants of 'Beth-lehemite [obj.] Goliath' and '[obj.] Lahmi brother of Goliath' are close, so a copying slip is plausible. Samuel's text is known to be damaged elsewhere, even in this very verse ('oregim'). Held by Keil–Delitzsch, Archer and many conservative scholars.

  • Samuel's reading is older: an Elhanan tradition about a champion named Goliath was later attached to David, or the name Goliath was later added to the anonymous 'Philistine' of 1 Sam 17.

    1 Samuel 17 names Goliath only twice and otherwise says 'the Philistine'. The LXX supports Samuel's present wording. 'Lahmi' is otherwise unknown and looks drawn from 'Bethlehemite'. The Chronicler is known to smooth over difficulties. Held by McCarter, Halpern and many critical scholars.

  • Elhanan and David are the same person: Elhanan was his personal name, David his throne name or title.

    Both are Bethlehemites. The Targum and rabbinic tradition identify Elhanan with David. Honeyman (JBL 1948) argued that Israelite kings had throne names (compare Solomon/Jedidiah, 2 Sam 12:24–25). Against this: the warrior lists treat Elhanan as one of David's men, and his father is not called Jesse.

  • There were two champions called Goliath, or 'Goliath' was a title for a type of Gath champion.

    Proposed to keep both texts without emendation. There is little direct evidence for it.

in v19

What does 'like a weaver's beam' describe?

  • Size: the shaft was as thick and heavy as a loom beam.

    The plain sense of the comparison. In 1 Sam 17:7 it sits next to the weight of the spearhead (600 shekels of iron), which stresses mass.

  • Shape and fittings: a javelin with a cord and loop for throwing, resembling the heddle rod of a loom.

    Yadin (PEQ 1955) pointed to Aegean and Greek throwing-loop javelins (the later Greek ankylē). The comparison would explain an unfamiliar foreign weapon through a familiar household object.

Sources
  • Brown–Driver–Briggs Hebrew Lexicon (BDB) s.v. רָפָא II / רְפָאִים, יָלִיד, נָכָה, גֹּב
  • HALOT (Koehler–Baumgartner) s.v. רָפָה II, רְפָאִים, יָלִיד
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible 9, 1984), on 2 Sam 21:15–22
  • Folker Willesen, 'The Philistine Corps of the Scimitar from Gath', Journal of Semitic Studies 3 (1958)
  • Folker Willesen, 'The Yālīd in Hebrew Society', Studia Theologica 12 (1958)
  • Ugaritic Rephaim texts, KTU 1.20–1.22 and KTU 1.108
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Samuel 21
  • Sara Japhet, I & II Chronicles (OTL), on 1 Chr 20:4–8
  • Parallel texts: 1 Chronicles 20:4; 11:29; 27:11; 4:4; 2 Samuel 23:27; Deuteronomy 2:10–11, 20–21; 3:11; Joshua 11:22
  • Masoretic Text (Leningrad Codex) of 2 Sam 21:19 and 1 Chr 20:5
  • Septuagint, 2 Kingdoms 21:19
  • Vulgate, 2 Samuel 21:19
  • Targum Jonathan to Samuel, 2 Sam 21:19
  • BDB s.v. מָנוֹר, אָרַג, נָכָה
  • HALOT s.v. מָנוֹר; גׇּלְיַת
  • S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel (2nd ed., 1913), on 2 Sam 21:19
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible 9, 1984)
  • C. F. Keil & F. Delitzsch, Commentary on the Old Testament: Samuel
  • Y. Yadin, 'Goliath's Javelin and the מנור ארגים', Palestine Exploration Quarterly 87 (1955)
  • A. M. Honeyman, 'The Evidence for Regnal Names among the Hebrews', JBL 67 (1948)
  • B. Halpern, David's Secret Demons (2001)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Sam 21:15–22

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).