Amos Chapter 5 Read as one passage

Amos 5:22–23

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

22Even though you offer Me burnt offerings and grain offerings, I will not accept them; for your peace offerings of fattened cattle I will have no regard. 23Take away from Me the noise of your songs! I will not listen to the music of your harps.

What the first hearers heard

For worshippers at Bethel or Gilgal, this verse turned their religious world upside down. They believed that offering the right animals in the right way, at the right shrine, secured the favour of YHWH, the God who had brought them out of Egypt and was, they assumed, on their side. Amos takes each kind of sacrifice in turn (the costly whole offering, the tribute of grain, the joyful shared feast) and says God will refuse it. He uses the cult's own formal language ("I will not accept") and the language of a king's attention ("I will not look").

For them the message was not that sacrifice is meaningless in itself. It was that YHWH's acceptance could not be bought while the courts in the town gate were corrupt and the poor were being stripped of land and grain. Worship could not cover for injustice; it made the injustice worse. The verse belongs to a single speech (5:21–24) whose climax is the call for justice and righteousness to flow without stopping. In the following verses (5:25–27), and in the book as a whole, the refusal leads to a threat of exile "beyond Damascus." In other words, the festivals they trusted to secure their future were no protection against the coming disaster (fulfilled when Assyria destroyed the northern kingdom in 722 BC).

From the study of Amos 5:22.

Verse by verse

  1. 22Even though you offer Me burnt offerings and grain offerings, I will not accept them; for your peace offerings of fattened cattle I will have no regard.

    "For even if you send up to Me your whole burnt offerings, the ones that rise entirely in smoke, and your gifts of tribute, the grain offerings, I will not accept them as pleasing; I will not credit them to you. And the feast-offering of your stall-fattened animals, the celebration meal of well-being, I will not so much as look at."

    The verse goes through the three main kinds of sacrifice Israel knew: the offering wholly given to God (the burnt offering), the tribute of grain, and the shared feast in which the worshipper ate with God. For each one God refuses the response the ritual was designed to get. "Accept" is the priests' own formal word for an offering that counts, and God withholds it. "Look" is about God's face: he will not even turn toward the feast. The offerings are lavish (fattened animals), they are offered correctly, and they are offered "to Me", to Israel's own God. The verse does not say why they are refused. The surrounding chapter does: in 5:7 and 10–12 these same worshippers turn justice into bitterness, take grain levies from the poor, take bribes and push the needy aside in the town gate. Verse 24 then names what God actually wants: "let justice roll on like waters." Read with verses 21 and 23, God is shutting every sense: no smelling (v. 21), no accepting or looking (v. 22), no hearing (v. 23).

    Full study →
  2. 23Take away from Me the noise of your songs! I will not listen to the music of your harps.

    "Get it off me — that roar of your songs! The praise-music of your harps I will not hear."

    God speaks in his own voice, and he speaks to Israel as one person: "you" is singular here, after the plural "you" of verses 21–22. The first word is a blunt command: remove it, take it away. "From upon me" adds the sense of something pressing on God that he wants lifted off, the way Pharaoh once begged for a plague to be taken "from upon me."

    What is to be removed is Israel's festival singing. God does not call it "song". He calls it hāmôn, a word for the roar of a crowd, the din of an army camp, the crash of the sea. The careful, joyful music of the pilgrim feasts at Bethel and Gilgal is, to him, just crowd-noise.

    The second line repeats the point with the instruments. The zimrâ, the praising music the psalms call for ("raise a song, sound the timbrel, the sweet lyre with the harp", Ps 81:2), played on many hand-held stringed instruments, gets no hearing. "I will not hear" means "I will not receive it": in Israel's worship, for God to "hear" was for him to accept and answer.

    This is the last in a series of refusals that runs through the senses. God will not smell the festivals (v.21), will not accept or even look at the offerings (v.22), and will not hear the songs (v.23). Every way into his presence is closed. The next line gives the reason and the alternative. Instead of this torrent of music, "let justice roll on like waters, and righteousness like a stream that never dries up" (v.24).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v22

    meat offerings (KJV)

    minḥah

    What we hear
    An offering of animal flesh.
    What they heard
    A gift or tribute, here almost certainly the grain offering of flour, oil and incense, which contained no meat at all.
  • in v22

    peace offerings

    shelem

    What we hear
    A sacrifice offered to make peace with, or win reconciliation from, an offended God.
    What they heard
    A 'well-being' or communion offering: a festive shared meal before God, expressing an already-good relationship (thanksgiving, a vow fulfilled, freewill joy). In Leviticus atonement belongs mainly to other offerings.
  • in v23

    viols (KJV)

    nəbālîm

    What we hear
    Violins or bowed string instruments like those in an orchestra.
    What they heard
    Hand-held plucked stringed instruments (a harp or large lyre) of the ancient Near East. Bowed instruments did not exist in Amos's world.
  • in v23

    noise

    hămôn

    What we hear
    Unpleasant or badly performed sound, as if God objected to the style, volume or quality of the music.
    What they heard
    The roar or din of a crowd, army or sea. God takes music that was probably excellent and calls it mere crowd-roar because of the injustice of the people singing it (vv. 11–12, 24). It is a moral judgment, not an aesthetic one.
Every word
  1. כִּ֣י

    ki · H3588

    for, indeed, that · v22

    Joined to the next word, it opens the clause with force: 'For even if…' / 'Yes, though…'. It ties this verse to the 'I hate, I despise' of verse 21, so it carries on the same speech.

  2. אִם־

    ʾim · H518

    if · v22

    'If' / 'even if'. With כִּי it makes a concession: whatever you offer, the verdict stays the same. The common meaning of the pair, 'but rather / except', does not fit here.

  3. תַּעֲלוּ־

    taʿalu · H5927

    go up; (causative) offer up · v22

    'You make go up', the standard verb for sending an offering up as smoke from the altar. The tense points to an ongoing practice: whenever you offer. It shares its root with the next noun, so the line reads 'you send up your sendings-up'.

  4. לִ֥י

    li

    to me · v22

    The offerings really are addressed to Israel's God. That is the sting: God is refusing worship directed at himself.

  5. עֹל֛וֹת

    ʿolot · H5930

    burnt offering (lit. 'that which goes up') · v22

    The whole burnt offering. The entire animal (except the hide) was burned so that it all 'went up' to God, which made it the costliest kind of animal offering and the one most fully given to God.

  6. וּמִנְחֹתֵיכֶ֖ם

    u-minḥoteikhem · H4503

    gift, tribute; grain offering · v22

    'And your gift-offerings'. Here it probably means the grain offering of flour, oil and incense that went with animal sacrifices, but the word still carries its basic sense of tribute brought to a superior. 'Your' marks these as their offerings, not God's.

  7. לֹ֣א

    loʾ · H3808

    not · v22, v23

    A flat, unqualified negation.

  8. אֶרְצֶ֑ה

    ʾertseh · H7521

    accept with favour, be pleased with · v22

    'I will not accept.' This is the technical temple word for an offering being formally received and credited to the worshipper (Lev 1:4; 22:21–27). God refuses the very verdict the ritual was meant to secure.

  9. וְשֶׁ֥לֶם

    ve-shelem · H8002

    well-being / peace / fellowship offering · v22

    'And the well-being offering of…'. This is the sacrifice most of which the worshipper ate at a festive meal with family and guests. It is the only place in the Hebrew Bible where the word appears in the singular; everywhere else it is plural (shelamim).

  10. מְרִיאֵיכֶ֖ם

    meriʾeikhem · H4806

    fatling, fattened animal · v22

    'Your fatlings': animals kept and fed up specially for slaughter, a luxury product. The word points to the wealth of the people offering them (compare Amos 6:4, 'calves from the stall').

  11. אַבִּֽיט׃

    ʾabbit · H5027

    look, regard, pay attention to · v22

    'I will not look.' God will not even turn his eyes toward the feast. After smell in verse 21 and before hearing in verse 23, this is the sense of sight being shut.

  12. הָסֵ֥ר

    hāsēr · H5493

    remove, take away, turn aside · v23

    A command addressed to one person ("you" singular): "Take it away! Get it out of here!" The same verb is used for putting away foreign gods and removing cult objects, and Pharaoh uses it with the next word when he begs Moses to remove a plague (Exod 10:17).

  13. מֵעָלַ֖י

    mēʿālay · H5921

    from upon me, off me, away from me · v23

    Literally "from upon me". The phrase is used when something weighs on someone or presses on them, and here it adds a sense of "get this off me". The songs are treated as a burden God wants lifted off, not as a gift he enjoys.

  14. הֲמ֣וֹן

    hămôn · H1995

    din, roar, tumult; crowd, multitude · v23

    A word for the roar of a crowd, an army camp or the sea. Calling festival singing hāmôn shrinks carefully made liturgy down to crowd-noise, a racket.

  15. שִׁרֶ֑יךָ

    šîreykā · H7892

    song · v23

    "Your songs", plural. The sung part of the festival worship at shrines such as Bethel and Gilgal. Amos elsewhere calls them "the songs of the temple" (8:3) and says they will be turned into lament (8:10).

  16. וְזִמְרַ֥ת

    wəzimrat · H2172

    melody, music, playing (in praise) · v23

    "And the music of…". This is a word from worship language for festive, praising music, often played on instruments. The second line is set beside "the din of your songs" and makes the same point again: the voices and the instruments are both rejected.

  17. נְבָלֶ֖יךָ

    nəbāleykā · H5035

    harp / large lyre (a stringed instrument) · v23

    "Your harps", plural. The nēbel was a hand-held stringed instrument used both in worship and at elite banquets. In 6:5 Amos mocks the rich who "improvise to the sound of the nēbel" while the nation falls apart.

  18. אֶשְׁמָֽע׃

    ʾešmāʿ · H8085

    hear, listen, heed · v23

    "I will not hear". In worship language, God "hearing" means receiving and answering favorably. Refusing to hear means refusing to accept the worship at all. This is a refusal, not a matter of not noticing the music.

The world behind it

When and where. Amos, a herder and tree-tender from Tekoa in Judah, preached in the northern kingdom of Israel during the reign of Jeroboam II (about 760 BC). It was a time of military security and wealth for the elite: winter and summer houses, ivory-inlaid furniture, banquets (3:15; 6:4–6). It also saw debt-slavery, land loss and corrupt courts for small farmers (2:6–8; 5:10–12). Worship flourished at the royal shrines of Bethel and Gilgal and at Beersheba (4:4–5; 5:4–5; 7:13).

How the sacrifices worked. Each sacrifice named here had a distinct role:

  • The burnt offering (ʿolah) was burned whole. Nothing came back to the worshipper.
  • The grain offering (minḥah) was a gift of flour, oil and incense, often presented alongside animal sacrifices.
  • The well-being offering (shelem/shelamim) was mostly eaten by the worshipper's household and guests at a sacred meal. For ordinary farming families this was one of the few times they ate meat.

The ritual aimed at God's "acceptance" (ratson). The worshipper laid a hand on the animal, and the priest judged whether the offering was acceptable (Lev 1:3–4; 7:18; 22:21–25). An offering "not accepted" had failed.

How it landed. Amos's hearers expected the prophet to curse their enemies and bless their festivals (compare 5:18–20 on the "Day of the LORD"). Instead the prophet speaks for God as a king refusing his own subjects' tribute, using the priests' own vocabulary. The "fattened animals" point straight at the wealthy class Amos accuses elsewhere: the "cows of Bashan" who crush the needy (4:1), and those who eat "calves from the stall" (6:4). The grain on the altar recalls the grain extracted from the poor (5:11).

From the study of Amos 5:22.

Where scholars differ

in v22

Did Amos reject sacrifice altogether, or only sacrifice offered alongside injustice?

  • Amos opposed the sacrificial system itself; true worship for him was ethical, not ritual.

    The refusal here is total and unconditional. Amos 5:25 ('Did you bring me sacrifices… forty years in the wilderness?') seems to imply sacrifice was not part of Israel's founding relationship with God (compare Jer 7:22). This was the classic view of 19th–early 20th century critical scholarship.

  • Amos rejects sacrifice as practised by people who commit injustice; the negation is rhetorical ('not this, but this').

    Hebrew often uses absolute 'not A but B' to mean 'B far more than A' (compare Hos 6:6, which spells out the comparison: 'rather than'). The speech climaxes in v. 24 with justice, not a reform of ritual. Elsewhere the same prophets assume a legitimate temple. Most current commentators (e.g., Paul, Jeremias) hold some form of this view.

  • Amos targets the specific northern shrines (Bethel, Gilgal) and their royal cult.

    Amos 4:4–5 and 5:4–6 mock pilgrimage to these sites specifically; 7:10–17 shows conflict with Bethel's priest; the book's frame (1:2) has YHWH roaring from Zion. Some see this as a contributing factor rather than the whole explanation, since 5:21–24 itself names injustice, not location.

in v22

What does 'shelem/shelamim' mean, and how should it be translated?

  • 'Peace/well-being offering', from shalom (wholeness, welfare).

    Septuagint σωτήριον ('for welfare/deliverance'); the joyful, communal character of the meal in Lev 3 and 7.

  • 'Fellowship/communion offering', stressing the shared meal between God, priest and worshipper.

    The division of portions in Lev 7:11–36; Deut 12:7 ('eat before the LORD your God and rejoice'). This is the NIV's choice.

  • 'Concluding' or 'payment/completion' offering, from shillem ('pay, complete').

    Some scholars (e.g., Levine) note its frequent place at the end of a ceremony and its link to vow-payment (Prov 7:14). This is a minority view, but it has a philological basis.

in v23

Does Amos reject worship and sacrifice as such, or only worship offered by people who practice injustice?

  • Amos rejects the sacrificial system itself. Israel's true relationship with God never required it.

    The very next verses ask, "Did you bring me sacrifices and offerings for forty years in the wilderness?" (5:25), which some read as expecting "no". Amos mocks pilgrimage outright ("Come to Bethel and transgress", 4:4–5), and the rejection in vv. 21–23 is total, with no conditions stated. This view was influential in 19th- and early 20th-century scholarship.

  • Amos rejects worship cut off from justice. The "not this but that" form is a strong way of saying "that matters far more than this", not a call to abolish worship.

    Isa 1:15 rejects even prayer in the same terms, yet no one thinks Isaiah meant to abolish prayer. Amos himself prays (7:2, 5). Hos 6:6 ("steadfast love and not sacrifice") is paired with "knowledge of God more than burnt offerings", which shows the form compares rather than abolishes. Verse 24 gives the condition, and verse 23 rejects the music, which is not something the law commanded at all. Most recent commentators (e.g. Paul, Jeremias, Andersen & Freedman) lean this way, while stressing how radical the rejection is for that time.

in v23

What instrument was the nēbel?

  • An angular or arched harp.

    Traditional rendering. Harps are well attested in Egypt and Mesopotamia. Josephus distinguishes the nabla (twelve strings, played with the fingers) from the kinnyra (ten strings, played with a plectrum, a small pick).

  • A larger, lower-pitched lyre (a cousin of the kinnôr).

    Iron Age images from Israel and the Levant show many lyres and almost no harps. The constant pairing with kinnôr suggests two members of the same family, the way a violin and a cello belong together.

  • A lute-like instrument or other form with a rounded resonating body.

    Proposed from the identical word nēbel, "jar / skin bottle", possibly naming a bulging sound-box. This is suggestive but speculative.

Sources
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. רָצָה, מִנְחָה, שֶׁלֶם, מְרִיא, נָבַט
  • Shalom M. Paul, Amos (Hermeneia, 1991)
  • Hans Walter Wolff, Joel and Amos (Hermeneia, 1977)
  • Francis I. Andersen & David Noel Freedman, Amos (Anchor Bible, 1989)
  • Jörg Jeremias, The Book of Amos (OTL, 1998)
  • Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible, 1991), on ʿolah, minḥah, shelamim and ratson
  • Gary A. Anderson, 'Sacrifice and Sacrificial Offerings (OT)', Anchor Bible Dictionary
  • Baruch Levine, In the Presence of the Lord (1974), on shelamim
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Amos 5:22
  • Vulgate (Weber-Gryson), Amos 5:22
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Amos 5:21–24
  • BDB s.v. הָמוֹן, זִמְרָה, נֵבֶל, סוּר, שָׁמַע
  • HALOT s.v. הָמוֹן; זִמְרָה I; נֵבֶל II
  • Francis I. Andersen & David Noel Freedman, Amos (Anchor Yale Bible, 1989)
  • Joachim Braun, Music in Ancient Israel/Palestine (2002)
  • Josephus, Antiquities 7.306 (nabla and kinyra)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Amos 5:23
  • Vulgate, Amos 5:23
  • STEPBible / supplied morphological data (TAHOT)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).