Daniel Chapter 2 Read as one passage

Daniel 2:10–11

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

10The astrologers answered the king, “No one on earth can do what the king requests! No king, however great and powerful, has ever asked anything like this of any magician, enchanter, or astrologer. 11What the king requests is so difficult that no one can tell it to him except the gods, whose dwelling is not with mortals.”

What the first hearers heard

The court tales of Daniel 1–6 were told among Jews living under foreign empires: Babylonian, Persian and then Hellenistic (Greek). For them this verse was a moment of high suspense and quiet satire. The most prestigious experts of the most learned empire on earth stand before its most powerful king and admit, under threat of death, that every human craft fails here. Every kind of sacred specialist is named: Egyptian-style lector-priests, Babylonian exorcists, Chaldean diviners. None of them can do it.

Hearers who knew Genesis would recognise the pattern at once: a foreign king, a troubling dream, failed ḥarṭummîm, and a young Hebrew exile waiting in the wings. Joseph's story is about to be replayed in Babylon. The experts' own words do the theological work. They say "there is not a human on the earth" who can do this, and in the next verse that only gods "whose dwelling is not with flesh" could. Daniel answers by saying that the God of heaven does reveal mysteries, and reveals them to a captive Judean.

For an exiled or occupied people, the message was that the knowledge and power of empires have a ceiling, and that their God, whom the empire did not take seriously, sees past it. The flattering titles ("great and mighty king") also set up the chapter's turn: in the dream Daniel interprets, every great kingdom is shattered by a stone "cut without hands" (vv. 34–35, 44).

From the study of Daniel 2:10.

Verse by verse

  1. 10The astrologers answered the king, “No one on earth can do what the king requests! No king, however great and powerful, has ever asked anything like this of any magician, enchanter, or astrologer.

    The Chaldean scholars answered, standing before the king as court custom required, and said: "There is not a mortal anywhere on the dry ground of this earth who could lay out what the king is demanding. That is exactly why no king — great and mighty as kings are — has ever put a demand like this to any lector-priest, any exorcist, or any Chaldean scholar."

    The speakers are the elite experts of Babylon, the most famous centre of divination in the ancient world. They are answering a death threat (v. 9), and their reply is part protest and part flattery. They do not say "we won't"; they say "no one can" (yûkal). They back this up with a precedent: in the whole history of kingship, no ruler has ever asked his experts to tell him a dream as well as interpret it. Even the royal titles they use, "great and mighty", are the language Mesopotamian kings used of themselves, here used to suggest that this king has gone beyond all reasonable kingly demands.

    The three job titles together cover all the sacred expertise of the day:

    • the lector-priest (ḥarṭōm, an Egyptian title that recalls Pharaoh's experts in the Joseph story);
    • the exorcist (ʾāšap, the Babylonian incantation-priest);
    • the Chaldean scholar-diviner.

    Under the surface the wording sets up the rest of the chapter. "There is not a human on the earth" will be answered in v. 28 with "there is a God in heaven who reveals mysteries." The verb "to show/declare" (ḥăwāʾ), which no human can do here, is exactly what Daniel will do once God has revealed the matter to him. The experts are right about the limits of human skill. Their mistake, spelled out in the next verse, is to think the gods never come near "flesh".

    Full study →
  2. 11What the king requests is so difficult that no one can tell it to him except the gods, whose dwelling is not with mortals.”

    "This thing the king keeps demanding is heavy, too weighty for anyone to carry. There isn't anybody else who could set it out in the king's presence. Only gods could, and gods don't make their home among creatures of flesh and blood."

    The speakers are Babylonian court experts with a death sentence hanging over them, and this is their last argument. They use careful palace language ("before the king," never "to you") but they are really giving up. The word for the request pictures a load too heavy to lift. It does not say the request is merely unusual. Their answer has two flat denials, one at each end: no other person exists who can do this, and no divine residence exists among human beings. "Flesh" here is not a moral word. It simply names what people are: bodily, mortal, on the wrong side of the gap between earth and the gods. So the professionals admit that their craft cannot reach the source of this knowledge. The sentence ends on "is not," which leaves the king nothing to work with, and in the next verse he orders them all killed.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v10

    astrologer (KJV, for ʾāšap)

    ʾāšap

    What we hear
    Someone who reads horoscopes from the positions of the stars and planets.
    What they heard
    An exorcist or incantation-priest (Akkadian āšipu) who diagnosed spiritual causes of illness and misfortune and drove them off with spoken spells and rituals.
  • in v10

    astrologers (BSB, for kasdāy)

    kasdāy

    What we hear
    Horoscope-readers, or simply a nationality ('Chaldeans').
    What they heard
    A class of learned Babylonian scholar-diviners. Their skills included reading celestial omens but also interpreting dreams, ritual and ancient written lore. In this verse the word is a professional title.
  • in v10

    magician

    ḥarṭōm

    What we hear
    A stage illusionist or a storybook wizard.
    What they heard
    A lector-priest: a temple professional who read and performed sacred ritual texts, respected for both learning and supposed supernatural power. The title comes from Egypt and recalls Pharaoh's experts in Genesis 41.
  • in v10

    therefore (KJV)

    kol-qŏbēl dî

    What we hear
    A conclusion: no one can do it, so as a result no king has asked.
    What they heard
    'Inasmuch as, because': the experts offer the unbroken lack of precedent as their evidence that the task is impossible.
  • in v11

    a rare thing (KJV, WEB); precious (YLT)

    yaqqirah

    What we hear
    An uncommon request, seldom met with, or something valuable.
    What they heard
    A heavy, weighty matter, and so a hard one. The experts are saying the demand is beyond what people can carry out, not that it is scarce or treasured.
  • in v11

    flesh (KJV, WEB, ESV)

    bisra

    What we hear
    Humanity's sinful side, or the body as opposed to the soul.
    What they heard
    Mortal, bodily creatures as a class, in contrast to gods. It says nothing about sin and draws no line between body and soul.
Every word
  1. עֲנ֨וֹ

    ʿănô · H6032

    they answered · v10

    Opens the reply to the king's ultimatum in v. 9. This is the experts' second protest; their first answer (v. 7) was simply to ask again to be told the dream.

  2. כַשְׂדָּאֵ֤י

    kasdāʾê · H3779

    the Chaldeans · v10

    Here it names the whole body of Babylonian court scholars speaking as one group. It is a professional label, not just a nationality. The same word comes back at the end of the verse as one class of expert in a list.

  3. קֳדָם־

    qŏdām · H6925

    before, in front of · v10, v11

    Court language: you speak 'before' a king, not simply 'to' him. The word pictures the experts standing in the royal presence, where their lives are at stake.

  4. מַלְכָּא֙

    malkāʾ · H4430

    the king · v10, v11

    Nebuchadnezzar. The word 'king' comes four times in this verse and the experts never use his name. They keep to the formal third person: 'the king's matter', 'any king'.

  5. וְאָ֣מְרִ֔ין

    wəʾāmərîn · H0560

    and saying · v10

    A participle (an '-ing' verb form) after the past-tense 'answered'. This is the normal Aramaic way to introduce speech, like 'answered and said'.

  6. לָֽא־

    lāʾ · H3809

    not · v10, v11

    Negates the existence word that follows: 'there is not'. It comes first for emphasis.

  7. אִיתַ֤י

    ʾîtay · H0383

    there is · v10, v11

    Aramaic word for existence. 'There is not a human…' sets up a contrast the chapter answers later. In v. 28 Daniel picks up the same word: 'there is (ʾîtay) a God in heaven who reveals mysteries.'

  8. אֲנָשׁ֙

    ʾĕnāš · H0606

    human being, person · v10

    A generic human, a mortal. The point is that no one of the human kind can do this, which prepares for v. 11, where only 'gods' could.

  9. עַל־

    ʿal · H5922

    upon, on · v10

    Spatial 'on' here, meaning 'on the earth' (the supplied dictionary gloss 'since' does not fit this verse).

  10. יַבֶּשְׁתָּ֔א

    yabbeštāʾ · H3007

    the dry land, the earth · v10

    Literally 'the dry ground', meaning the inhabited world where humans live. It quietly sets the earthly realm against the heavenly one that v. 11 brings in ('gods, whose dwelling is not with flesh').

  11. דִּ֚י

    dî · H1768

    who, that · v10, v11

    Relative word: 'a human … who could…'.

  12. מִלַּ֣ת

    millat · H4406

    word, matter · v10, v11

    'The king's matter': what the king is demanding, which is to tell him both the dream and what it means. Like the Hebrew dābār, millâ covers both 'word' and 'affair, thing'.

  13. יוּכַ֖ל

    yûkal · H3202

    is able, can · v10

    Their claim is about ability, not willingness: no one is capable of this. It answers the king's charge in v. 9 that they are stalling on purpose.

  14. לְהַחֲוָיָ֑ה

    ləhaḥăwāyâ · H2324

    to declare, to make known · v10, v11

    'To show, set out, disclose.' This verb runs through Daniel 2 (vv. 4, 6, 7, 9, 11, 16, 24, 27): the whole chapter turns on who can actually 'show' the dream and its meaning.

  15. כָּל־

    kol · H3606

    all (part of the phrase 'because') · v10

    The first part of the fixed phrase kol-qŏbēl dî, 'inasmuch as, because'. The supplied data tags this word as the preposition ל (H9005), which looks like a tagging error (see textual notes).

  16. קֳבֵ֗ל

    qŏbēl · H6903

    in front of; (with kol) because · v10

    With kol and dî it makes 'because / inasmuch as'. It introduces the experts' evidence: no king has ever asked this.

  17. רַ֣ב

    rab · H7229

    great; chief · v10

    'Great', which echoes the standard Mesopotamian royal title 'great king'. The KJV took it as a separate noun, 'lord' (see debates).

  18. וְשַׁלִּ֔יט

    wəšallîṭ · H7990

    ruling, powerful; ruler · v10

    'And mighty / holding power.' Together with rab it flatters: even the greatest and most powerful kings never made such a demand.

  19. כִדְנָה֙

    kidnâ · H1836

    like this · v10

    'Like this' (kə- 'like' + dənâ 'this'): a request of this kind has no precedent.

  20. שְׁאֵ֔ל

    šəʾēl · H7593

    has asked, demanded · v10, v11

    Past tense, looking back over all of history: it has never happened. In v. 11 the same verb describes 'what the king asks'.

  21. חַרְטֹּ֖ם

    ḥarṭōm · H2749

    lector-priest, 'magician' · v10

    A loanword from Egyptian for a priest skilled in sacred texts and ritual. It is the same title as Pharaoh's 'magicians' in the Joseph and Moses stories, so it quietly casts Daniel as a new Joseph.

  22. וְאָשַׁ֥ף

    wəʾāšap · H0826

    exorcist, incantation-priest · v10

    A loanword from Akkadian āšipu: the Babylonian ritual expert who recited incantations against demons and sickness. Not an 'astrologer', as the KJV has it.

  23. יַקִּירָ֔ה

    yaqqirah · H3358

    heavy, weighty, honored, difficult · v11

    "Heavy," so hard to bear or do. The word is feminine to agree with "matter." The point is the difficulty of the demand, not its rarity or value.

  24. וְאָחֳרָן֙

    ve'ochoran · H0321

    another, other · v11

    "And another," in the singular, placed first for emphasis: no other party exists who could do this. It means "anyone else," with the only exception named a few words later.

  25. לָהֵ֣ן

    lahen · H3861

    except, but · v11

    "Except." After a negative it opens the single exception, which turns out to be no help to anyone in the room.

  26. אֱלָהִ֔ין

    'elahin · H0426

    god; plural gods · v11

    "Gods," a true plural with no word for "the." Polytheist professionals are speaking of divine beings as a class, not of the God of Israel.

  27. מְדָ֣רְה֔וֹן

    medarehon · H4070B

    dwelling, home · v11

    "Their dwelling": where someone lives. It is an ordinary word for a place of residence, so the picture is that the gods simply do not live in this neighborhood.

  28. עִם־

    'im · H5974

    with, among · v11

    "With," in the sense of in company with. The denial concerns living alongside people.

  29. בִּשְׂרָ֖א

    bisra · H1321

    flesh, living creatures, humankind · v11

    "The flesh": mortal, bodily creatures as a class, set against the gods. It describes what humans are, frail and mortal, and passes no moral judgment.

The world behind it

Dream interpretation in Babylon. In Mesopotamia, dreams were treated as messages from the gods, and handling them was skilled work. Scholars consulted written dream-omen collections (the Assyrian "Dream Book", known as Ziqīqu). These listed dream images with their outcomes, along the lines of "if a man dreams X, then Y will happen". The whole system assumed the dreamer reported the dream first. Then the expert found the matching entry and gave its meaning, and rituals could be performed to cancel a bad omen. So the experts' claim in this verse is professionally true: their method had no procedure for recovering a dream's content. (See A. L. Oppenheim, The Interpretation of Dreams in the Ancient Near East, 1956.)

Why the king's demand made sense to him. Mesopotamian kings knew their experts could shade their readings, and Assyrian kings sometimes checked diviners against one another. Nebuchadnezzar's logic in v. 9 is the sharpest form of that check: if you can really get secret knowledge from the gods, tell me the dream, and then I will trust your interpretation. The experts' reply in v. 10 answers him with the custom of the profession, "no one has ever asked this", which in effect admits that their knowledge does not reach as far as he is testing.

Court etiquette. Speaking "before the king" (qŏdām malkāʾ) and calling him "the king" instead of "you" were standard marks of deference in Aramaic court speech. A furious absolute monarch had just threatened to have them "cut limb from limb" (v. 5), so their careful, flattering phrasing is a matter of survival.

Language. From 2:4b ("Then the Chaldeans spoke to the king in Aramaic") the book switches from Hebrew to Aramaic, the international language of the Babylonian and Persian empires, and stays in Aramaic until the end of chapter 7. The verse is therefore set in the very language of the imperial court.

From the study of Daniel 2:10.

Where scholars differ

in v10

Is 'king, great and ruling' (melek rab wəšallîṭ) one king with two descriptions, or three separate kinds of ruler?

  • One king with two descriptions: 'no king, however great and powerful' (most modern versions and commentators).

    It matches standard Mesopotamian royal titles ('great king, mighty king'). The single noun 'king' after 'every' is followed by words that naturally describe it. The Vulgate reads it this way too (magnus et potens).

  • Three nouns: 'no king, lord (chief), or ruler' (KJV, WEB, YLT).

    Both rab and šallîṭ work as nouns elsewhere in Daniel ('chief' in 2:48; 'officer' of Arioch in 2:15), and a list of ranks would widen the claim to every level of authority.

in v10

In Daniel, is 'Chaldean' a nationality or a profession?

  • Mainly a profession in Daniel 2: a class of scholar-diviners.

    It appears in lists of expert types (2:2, 10; 4:7; 5:7, 11), and Greek writers such as Herodotus and Diodorus describe Chaldeans as Babylon's priestly or astrological caste.

  • The ethnic sense remains in the background and sometimes in the foreground.

    Daniel 5:30 calls Belshazzar 'king of the Chaldeans', and 1:4 speaks of 'the language and literature of the Chaldeans'. Some scholars see the professional sense as a later, Hellenistic-era development reflected in the book, while others argue the two senses could coexist earlier, since the Chaldean dynasty sponsored the traditional scholarly class.

in v11

What do the Chaldeans mean by gods "whose dwelling is not with flesh"?

  • A general statement: gods as such live apart from humanity, so no one on earth can get this knowledge.

    This is the plain wording, and most modern translations punctuate it this way, as a description of the gods in general. It also suits the story, since Daniel's reply in 2:28 answers exactly this assumption.

  • A narrower statement: only certain higher gods, who are remote from people, could do this, as distinct from lesser gods nearer to humans.

    Some older commentators argued this because Mesopotamian religion had personal gods and temple gods thought to be close to people, so a blanket denial would be odd. Aramaic has no commas, and "gods who..." could grammatically be restrictive. However, the text itself never mentions two tiers of gods.

  • A line spoken under pressure, not a considered statement of belief: men facing execution reach for the strongest excuse available.

    It explains the mismatch with everyday Babylonian practice, where gods lived in temples and sent omens. The context supports it too: the king has accused them of stalling (2:8–9), and they have just argued that the demand is unprecedented (2:10). This view can be combined with the first.

Sources
  • HALOT (Biblical Aramaic section) s.v. כַּשְׂדַּי, חַרְטֹם, אָשַׁף, חוה, יַבֶּשֶׁת, שַׁלִּיט, קֳבֵל
  • BDB (Aramaic section) s.v. אָשַׁף, חַרְטֹם
  • F. Rosenthal, A Grammar of Biblical Aramaic (on כָּל־קֳבֵל דִּי)
  • J. J. Collins, Daniel (Hermeneia, 1993), on 2:1–12
  • J. E. Goldingay, Daniel (Word Biblical Commentary, 1989)
  • J. A. Montgomery, Daniel (ICC, 1927)
  • A. L. Oppenheim, The Interpretation of Dreams in the Ancient Near East (1956)
  • Herodotus, Histories 1.181–183; Diodorus Siculus 2.29–31 (Chaldeans as Babylonian priestly and astrological class)
  • Genesis 41:8, 24 (Egyptian ḥarṭummîm)
  • BDB, Aramaic section, s.v. יַקִּיר, מְדָר, בְּשַׂר, אִיתַי
  • HALOT, Biblical Aramaic section, s.v. יַקִּיר, מְדָר
  • F. Rosenthal, A Grammar of Biblical Aramaic
  • J. J. Collins, Daniel (Hermeneia, 1993)
  • J. A. Montgomery, The Book of Daniel (ICC, 1927)
  • J. E. Goldingay, Daniel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Greek Daniel: Old Greek and Theodotion, as in Rahlfs and the Göttingen edition
  • Latin Vulgate, Daniel 2:11
  • G. W. E. Nickelsburg, 1 Enoch 1 (Hermeneia), on 1 Enoch 15

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).