Deuteronomy Chapter 21 Read as one passage
Deuteronomy 21:19–20
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
19his father and mother are to lay hold of him and bring him to the elders of his city, to the gate of his hometown, 20and say to the elders, “This son of ours is stubborn and rebellious; he does not obey us. He is a glutton and a drunkard.”
What the first hearers heard
To Israelite hearers this verse laid out a fixed procedure for a family crisis that threatened the household's survival. Its main points:
- Parents do not judge their own child. However great the father's authority at home, a capital case belonged to the town's elders in public. The family is part of the covenant community and answers to it.
- Father and mother act together. Both must agree and both must act. A father alone could not bring the charge, and neither could a mother alone. That made the procedure harder to abuse, for example by an angry father, or (as some suggest) by a father favouring the son of another wife (compare the inheritance law just before this, in 21:15–17).
- The matter becomes public. Bringing the son 'out' to the gate exposed the family's shame. Together with the warning in verse 21 ('all Israel will hear and fear'), it shows that defying parents was treated as a threat to the whole community's order, not a private quarrel.
The hearers would also have caught Deuteronomy's recurring pattern: offenders and evidence are 'brought out' to the gate, before the elders (17:5; 22:15, 21, 24; 25:7).
From the study of Deuteronomy 21:19.
Verse by verse
-
19his father and mother are to lay hold of him and bring him to the elders of his city, to the gate of his hometown,
Full study →If a son keeps defying his father and his mother, and their discipline has failed (v18), then both parents together are to physically take hold of him. The verb is the one used for arresting a man or capturing a town. They are to bring him out, from inside the family home into the open, and hand him over to the elders of his own town, the heads of its families who sit as its court, at the town gate, the public square where cases were heard. All of this happens in his own community, among people who know him.
The verse is about procedure. Father and mother, acting jointly and with equal standing, may not deal with the case privately. The authority to judge lies outside the home, with the town's public court. The verdict and the sentence follow in verses 20–21.
-
20and say to the elders, “This son of ours is stubborn and rebellious; he does not obey us. He is a glutton and a drunkard.”
Full study →Father and mother stand together at the town gate, where the elders sit as judges. They point to their son, who is standing there, and make a formal accusation in one voice:
"This one here, our own son, is a balker and a defier. Like an ox that will not take the yoke, he keeps turning away. Like Israel in the wilderness, he keeps defying those over him. He is not someone who hears our voice. He hears it and will not act on it, and has gone on that way despite our discipline. He is a worthless squanderer who eats through what we have, and a guzzler of drink."
Every description is a Hebrew participle, a verb form for an ongoing condition. They describe what he has become, not something he did once. The first pair, "stubborn and defiant," uses the same words Deuteronomy uses for Israel's rebellion against God, so the son mirrors in one household what Israel did to its divine Father. The last pair, "squanderer and drunkard," is evidence the elders can check. It is the wasteful, drinking-house life that Proverbs warns will shame a father and ruin a household. "Our voice" is singular: mother and father speak as one authority. And this son who "does not hear" will become the lesson by which, in the next verse, "all Israel will hear and fear."
Where the English drifted
-
in v19
the gate
sha'ar
- What we hear
- A door or opening in a wall or fence.
- What they heard
- The town's gate complex, which served as its courthouse and public square, where the elders sat to judge.
-
in v19
elders
zeqenim
- What we hear
- Elderly people, or the elected board of a church.
- What they heard
- The heads of the town's extended families, acting as its governing council and local court.
-
in v19
the gate of his place (KJV/WEB/YLT)
sha'ar meqomo
- What we hear
- An unclear phrase; perhaps the gate of his own house.
- What they heard
- The gate court of his hometown, the community he belongs to.
-
in v20
glutton
zolel
- What we hear
- Someone who overeats: a private appetite problem.
- What they heard
- A worthless, wasteful reveller who squanders the household's goods. The word covers waste, debauchery and bringing shame on one's father, with poverty as the result (Prov 23:20–21; 28:7).
-
in v20
son
ben
- What we hear
- Readers often picture a young child who talks back or misbehaves.
- What they heard
- A son of any age who still belongs to the household. Here the evidence (heavy drinking and wasteful revelling) and the failed discipline point to an adolescent or young adult.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v20
Not a toddler talking back
- What's often taught
- This law is often summarised as the Bible commanding parents to have a child stoned for being disobedient or talking back.
- What the text supports
The law really does prescribe death (v.21), and it should not be softened. But the case it describes is narrower than 'a disobedient child':
- Who: a ben ('son'), whose described behaviour, persistent heavy drinking and wasteful revelling (zolel vesove), fits an adolescent or young adult, not a small child.
- What: a settled character, not one act. Every description is a participle for an ongoing condition, and v.18 says parental discipline has already been tried and has failed.
- Evidence: 'squanderer and drunkard' is public, observable behaviour that, according to Proverbs 23:20–21, drains the family's livelihood.
- Process: the parents cannot act alone. Both mother and father must agree and speak together, bring him to the elders at the town gate, and accuse him in his presence. The community decides and carries out the sentence.
The law is severe by any standard, but its target is a grown son's persistent, wasteful defiance that threatens the household, judged through a public process that limits the father's power.
- Where the English feeds it
- 'Son' is easily heard as 'child,' and 'glutton' sounds like a private eating habit. Both make the case sound smaller and more domestic than the Hebrew, which describes a profligate reveller of age to frequent drinking houses. 'Does not obey us' can sound like a single act, where the participles describe an established pattern.
Every word
-
וְתָ֥פְשׂוּ
ve-tafesu · H8610
and they shall seize · v19
A forceful verb for grabbing and holding, used elsewhere for capturing cities or arresting a man. Its form carries on the 'if' of verse 18: if the son is like this, then the parents shall take hold of him. It is plural, so both parents act together.
-
ב֖וֹ
vo · H9033
on him / him · v19
The preposition be- ('in, on') with 'him'. With this verb it marks the thing grabbed (as in Deut 9:17, 'I grasped the two tablets'). The son is physically held.
-
אָבִ֣יו
aviv · H0001G
his father · v19
The head of the household, who normally ruled the family. Here he cannot act alone.
-
וְאִמּ֑וֹ
ve-immo · H0517
and his mother · v19
The mother is named as a co-actor, with the same standing as the father. She lays hold of the son, brings him out, and in verse 20 speaks against him. In the Hebrew the accent puts a pause here, closing the first half of the verse.
-
וְהוֹצִ֧יאוּ
ve-hotsi'u · H3318H
and they shall bring out · v19
The causative form of 'go out': they make him go out. He is taken from the private household into public view, where the community's court can deal with him.
-
אֹת֛וֹ
oto · H0853
him (object marker) · v19
A grammatical marker with 'him' attached. It shows the son is the one being brought out.
-
אֶל־
el- · H0413
to, toward · v19, v20
Shows where they are going: to the elders.
-
זִקְנֵ֥י
ziqnei · H2205G
elders of · v19, v20
The senior heads of families who made up the town council and court. They were not simply old men, and not church officers.
-
עִיר֖וֹ
iro · H5892B
his city/town · v19, v20
His own settlement, usually a walled village or small town. Its elders are his neighbours and kin.
-
שַׁ֥עַר
sha'ar · H8179G
gate of · v19
The town gate complex: the public square and chambers where elders met, heard cases and witnessed legal acts. 'To the gate' means 'to court'.
-
מְקֹמֽוֹ׃
meqomo · H4725
his place · v19
'Place' here means the town where he lives, his hometown. The case is heard locally, by the people who know the family.
-
וְאָמְר֞וּ
ve'ameru · H0559
and they shall say · v20
The subject is both parents together (v.19: 'his father and his mother'). This is their formal statement before the court, spoken jointly. It is a legal declaration, not a passing complaint.
-
בְּנֵ֤נוּ
benenu · H1121A
our son · v20
'Our son.' The word says nothing about age. The behaviour described (heavy eating and drinking) and the failed discipline in v.18 fit an adolescent or young adult who is still part of the household, not a small child.
-
זֶה֙
zeh · H2088
this · v20
'This one here.' The parents point him out in person before the court. The son is present and identified.
-
סוֹרֵ֣ר
sorer · H5637
stubborn, turning aside · v20
A participle (a verb form describing an ongoing state), so it means 'one who keeps turning away.' Hosea uses the same verb for a stubborn heifer that will not take the yoke (Hos 4:16). The picture is of balking at guidance, more than a single act of disobedience.
-
וּמֹרֶ֔ה
umoreh · H4784
-
אֵינֶ֥נּוּ
enennu · H0369
he is not · v20
A negative with 'he' attached: 'he is not [one who]...' It denies a lasting characteristic, not a single occasion.
-
שֹׁמֵ֖עַ
shomea · H8085H
hearing, heeding · v20
'Hearing.' In Hebrew, to hear someone's voice means to heed and act on it. The son keeps refusing to listen. This repeats v.18, where discipline has already been tried and failed.
-
בְּקֹלֵ֑נוּ
beqolenu · H6963A
to our voice · v20
'Our voice' in the singular: father and mother speak as one authority. The mother's word carries the same weight as the father's.
-
זוֹלֵ֖ל
zolel · H2151B
glutton, squanderer · v20
One who wastes and devours: a reckless, worthless reveller who uses up what the household has. Proverbs 23:20–21 sets this word next to 'drunkard' and warns that such people end up poor.
-
וְסֹבֵֽא׃
vesove · H5433B
and a drunkard · v20
'And a guzzler,' a heavy drinker. The related noun means beer or strong drink. Like the other descriptions, it names a habit and a way of life.
The world behind it
Family and court in ancient Israel. An Israelite household was large: a father, his wife or wives, sons and their families, and dependants. It was the basic economic and legal unit. The father normally kept order inside it. Above it stood the clan and the town, run by the elders (heads of families). They met in the gate complex, where several excavated Iron Age gates have benches and side rooms for exactly this purpose.
Limiting a parent's power. In some ancient societies a father had near-total power over his children; Roman law famously gave him power of life and death. Here the parents may accuse but not execute. They must bring the son before the public court. Other ancient Near Eastern law also required a court for drastic action against a son. The Laws of Hammurabi (§§168–169) let a father disinherit a son only after judges investigate, and the son is pardoned for a first serious offence. Deuteronomy's law is harsher in its sentence but similar in demanding a public procedure.
The mother's role. The mother is named alongside the father at every step: she seizes him, brings him out, and in verse 20 testifies ('this son of ours'). This matches the fifth commandment ('honour your father and your mother', Deut 5:16) and the laws against striking or cursing either parent (Exod 21:15, 17; Lev 20:9; Deut 27:16).
What kind of son. The charge in verse 20, 'glutton and drunkard', suggests a son old enough to waste the family's goods and threaten its survival and inheritance (compare Prov 23:20–21; 28:7). It does not describe a disobedient small child.
From the study of Deuteronomy 21:19.
Where scholars differ
in v19
Does this law limit parental power, or reinforce it?
-
It limits it. Parents lose the right to punish privately and must go through the public court.
Parents must bring the son 'out' to the elders, and the townsmen, not the parents, carry out the sentence (v21). Both parents must agree. The law parallels ANE laws requiring judges before a father can disinherit (Laws of Hammurabi §§168–169). Held by many commentators, e.g. Driver and Tigay.
-
It reinforces it. The community backs parental authority with the death penalty.
Verse 20 records no investigation, only the parents' statement. Verse 21 follows at once with stoning and a warning to all Israel. Honour of parents is a covenant obligation with severe sanctions elsewhere (Exod 21:15, 17).
in v19
Do the elders actually try the case, or only receive and ratify the parents' accusation?
-
The elders act as a court and judge the case.
The parents are directed to the elders at the gate, the normal place of judgment (Ruth 4; Amos 5:15), and Deuteronomy elsewhere requires witnesses and inquiry (17:4–6; 19:15).
-
The elders mainly witness and ratify; the parents' joint testimony is decisive.
The text gives the elders no line and no verdict. It moves straight from the parents' declaration (v20) to the townsmen stoning (v21).
in v19
Was this law ever applied?
-
It was a real, if rare, procedure.
The detailed procedure and its ANE parallels, and one Talmudic sage's claim to have seen such a son's grave (b. Sanh. 71a).
-
It was mainly a teaching law, meant to stress the seriousness of honouring parents.
No biblical narrative records its use. Rabbinic conditions made it nearly impossible to apply, and another opinion in b. Sanh. 71a says it 'never was and never will be'.
in v20
Is 'glutton and drunkard' the actual offence, or an illustration of the general rebellion?
-
It is the concrete, checkable offence: the son is wasting the household's resources.
Verse 18 speaks only of not listening. Verse 20 adds behaviour the elders could verify. Proverbs 23:20–21 and 28:7 link the same words to poverty and to shaming one's father, which fits a threat to the family's economy and old-age support.
-
It is a stock description that makes 'rebellious' vivid. The core charge is persistent rejection of parental authority.
The phrase is a fixed pair from wisdom literature. Rebellion is the main theme throughout (v.18 and 'stubborn and rebellious' in v.20), and the participles describe character more than particular acts.
-
The phrase may be a later addition to an older law (a view argued, for example, by E. Bellefontaine).
The phrase is absent from v.18, uses wisdom-literature vocabulary from Proverbs, and comes after the accusation formula is already complete. This is a judgment about how the text was composed, with no manuscript evidence. All ancient witnesses include the phrase.
in v20
Was this law actually carried out, or did it work mainly as a public warning?
-
It was a real legal procedure.
It follows the same pattern as other laws involving elders at the gate (Deut 19:12; 22:15–21; 25:7–9). Josephus and Philo present it as practicable, and the Temple Scroll restates it.
-
It worked mainly as a deterrent and teaching text, rarely or never applied.
Verse 21 stresses that 'all Israel will hear and fear.' There is no recorded case in the Hebrew Bible. Later rabbinic law made the conditions almost impossible to meet (Mishnah Sanhedrin 8), and b. Sanhedrin 71a records the view that it never happened. This rabbinic evidence is centuries later than Deuteronomy.
in v20
Does the charge against Jesus, 'a glutton and a drunkard' (Matt 11:19; Luke 7:34), allude to this verse?
-
Yes. The slur implicitly puts Jesus in the category of the rebellious son who deserves death.
The pairing is distinctive and matches Deut 21:20 and Prov 23:20–21. Jesus' opponents also questioned his relationship to family and authority (Mark 3:21, 31–35).
-
It is a common insult with no specific legal reference.
The Greek words (*phagos kai oinopotēs*) do not match the Septuagint's wording of Deut 21:20 (*symbolokopōn oinophlygei*). The Gospel context contrasts Jesus' table fellowship with John the Baptist's fasting, not a legal charge.
Sources
- BDB s.v. תָּפַשׂ
- HALOT s.v. תפשׂ
- HALOT s.v. זָקֵן
- HALOT s.v. שַׁעַר
- HALOT s.v. מָקוֹם
- Jeffrey H. Tigay, JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (1996), on 21:18–21
- S. R. Driver, Deuteronomy (ICC)
- Laws of Hammurabi §§168–169
- Mishnah Sanhedrin 8:1–5; Babylonian Talmud Sanhedrin 71a
- Sifre Deuteronomy on 21:18–21
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Deut 21:18–21
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Deut 21:19; Vulgate, Deut 21:19
- BDB s.v. סָרַר, מָרָה, זָלַל, סָבָא
- HALOT s.v. זלל, סבא, סרר
- Septuagint, Deuteronomy 21:20 (ἀπειθεῖ καὶ ἐρεθίζει … συμβολοκοπῶν οἰνοφλυγεῖ)
- Vulgate, Deuteronomy 21:20
- Temple Scroll 11Q19 col. 64:2–6
- Josephus, Antiquities 4.260–265
- Philo, On the Special Laws 2.232
- E. Bellefontaine, 'Deuteronomy 21:18–21: Reviewing the Case of the Rebellious Son,' JSOT 13 (1979)
- J. H. Tigay, JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (1996)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).