Ecclesiastes Chapter 5 Read as one passage

Ecclesiastes 5:11–13

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

11When good things increase, so do those who consume them; what then is the profit to the owner, except to behold them with his eyes? 12The sleep of the worker is sweet, whether he eats little or much, but the abundance of the rich man permits him no sleep. 13There is a grievous evil I have seen under the sun: wealth hoarded to the harm of its owner,

What the first hearers heard

To its first hearers, people schooled in Israel's wisdom tradition, where wealth was often seen as the reward of diligence and wisdom (e.g. Prov 10:4, 22), this verse offered a sober, almost dry observation drawn from ordinary household life. Anyone who had watched a family prosper knew the pattern: the bigger the estate, the longer the table.

The verse belongs to a short unit (5:10–12 in English) on the restlessness of wealth:

  • the lover of money is never filled (5:10);
  • the increase is eaten by others, and the owner gets only the view (5:11);
  • the labourer sleeps well, while the rich man's abundance robs him of sleep (5:12).

It does not condemn wealth as sinful. It deflates the hope that more wealth will bring more good to the one who owns it. In Qoheleth's larger argument this clears the ground for his repeated positive advice: the real gift is to eat, drink and find enjoyment in one's toil as God allows (5:18–20). Being able to actually eat the good, not just look at it, is what matters.

From the study of Ecclesiastes 5:11.

Verse by verse

  1. 11When good things increase, so do those who consume them; what then is the profit to the owner, except to behold them with his eyes?

    As the good multiplies, the mouths multiply. So what does the owner's success actually get him, except the chance to look at it?

    Qoheleth (the Teacher) builds the first half on a sound-play. Birvot… rabbu, "in the growing-many… they grow many": every increase in prosperity ("the good," meaning wealth and well-being in general) is matched by an increase in "its eaters." In his world the picture is literal. A richer man has a bigger household: more servants, workers, stewards, relatives, guests, dependents and officials, all fed from his stores. Wealth does not pile up quietly. It arrives already spoken for.

    The second half is a rhetorical question that expects the answer "next to nothing." The word for what he gains, kishron, means success or skill and the advantage it brings. The question is not only "what profit?" but "what does all his successful effort come to for him?" The answer narrows to one owner and one thin benefit: "the seeing of his eyes." Many eat, and the one who owns only looks. The verse does not say whether he enjoys the view or not. Elsewhere Qoheleth says the eye "is not satisfied with seeing" (1:8), though "the sight of the eyes" is better than restless craving (6:9). Either way, gazing at wealth is not the same as having the good of it.

    The verse continues 5:10 (the lover of money is never satisfied by money) and sets up 5:12: the labourer eats a little or a lot and sleeps sweetly, while the rich man's abundance keeps him awake.

    Full study →
  2. 12The sleep of the worker is sweet, whether he eats little or much, but the abundance of the rich man permits him no sleep.

    Sweet, sweet as honey, is the sleep of the man who works the ground, whether he has had a little to eat that day or a lot. But the rich man's fullness, the gorged stomach and the heaped-up surplus alike, will not leave him alone. It gives him no rest and does not let him sleep.

    The verse sets two men side by side at night. The first is "the one who works", most naturally a field laborer, the man whose labour, as 5:9 has just said, ends up serving the king. Whatever his table held, his sleep comes and it is good. The second is the rich man. The word for what he has, śābāʿ, means "fullness, plenty, satiety". Coming straight after "little or much he eats", it first suggests a man lying awake on an overfull stomach. In a paragraph about loving money, goods that multiply along with the people who eat them, and wealth hoarded to its owner's harm (5:10–13), it also means his surplus and the watchfulness it demands. The grammar makes the abundance itself the actor: it will not let him rest. The verb carries an echo of the Hebrew word for "rest". The verse opens on sleep (a noun) and closes on sleep (a verb), with the two men held between.

    Full study →
  3. 13There is a grievous evil I have seen under the sun: wealth hoarded to the harm of its owner,

    "There is a sick kind of misfortune I have watched happen in this world: wealth that its owner guards carefully, and that turns out to be his own harm."

    Qoheleth (the Hebrew name of the speaker, "the Gatherer" or "the Teacher") is reporting a case he has observed. The verse starts and ends on the same Hebrew word, ra'ah: "evil" at the start and "harm" at the end. The bad thing he sees is the bad thing that falls on the owner. He calls it a "sick evil," a misfortune like a disease that eats away at a person. This is not a lecture on sin. It is a diagnosis of something sickening.

    The wealth is described as "kept" or "guarded," with the same verb used for guarding a flock or holding valuables in safekeeping. The owner holds onto it and protects it, presumably so that it will protect him. The irony is that the guarded wealth "guards" him toward misfortune. The surrounding verses show what that looks like: the rich man cannot sleep for his abundance (v.12), and then the whole fortune disappears in one bad venture, so that when his son is born there is nothing in his hand to give (v.14). He came into the world naked and will leave the same way (v.15). The harm may be the anxiety of guarding, the crash of losing, or both. In either case the wealth meant for security became the source of his trouble.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v11

    those who consume them / its consumers

    'okheleyha

    What we hear
    Consumers in the economic sense: buyers or market demand, or people who 'use up' products.
    What they heard
    Literally 'its eaters': the people fed from the owner's prosperity, such as household, servants, dependents, guests and officials. These are mouths at his table.
  • in v11

    goods

    hattovah

    What we hear
    Merchandise or manufactured products, as in 'goods and services'.
    What they heard
    'The good': prosperity, wealth and well-being in general, with Qoheleth's overtone of the good one ought to enjoy.
  • in v12

    the abundance of the rich

    haśśābāʿ leʿāshîr

    What we hear
    The rich man's money and possessions, so that he lies awake worrying about his investments.
    What they heard
    "Fullness, satiety, plenty": a word at home with eating one's fill. Following "whether he eats little or much", it includes the rich man's overfull stomach as well as his surplus goods. The image is physical as well as financial.
  • in v13

    evil ("a grievous evil")

    ra'ah

    What we hear
    Moral wickedness, something sinister or demonic, a sin that someone commits.
    What they heard
    A bad thing, a misfortune, something wrong with how life turns out. Here it is a painful irony of experience, not a wicked act. The same word at the end of the verse is translated "harm."
  • in v13

    sore (KJV: "a sore evil")

    cholah

    What we hear
    Aching or tender, as in a sore muscle. Or, colloquially, upset ("sore about it").
    What they heard
    "Sick, ailing," and so grievous or severe. In 17th-century English "sore" meant "severe, grievous" and also suggested pain, which was a reasonable match.
Every word
  1. בִּרְבוֹת֙

    birvot · H7235A

    to multiply, become many · v11, v12

    The preposition 'in/when' joined to a verbal noun: 'in the growing-many of', meaning 'as it multiplies'. It sets up a sound-play with the next verb (rabah / rabbu): the more it multiplies, the more they multiply.

  2. הַטּוֹבָ֔ה

    hattovah · H2896C

    good, goods, prosperity, welfare · v11

    'The good', meaning prosperity or wealth in general, not 'goods' as objects for sale. There is irony here: Qoheleth's word for good fortune and enjoyment is the very thing that slips away from its owner.

  3. רַבּ֖וּ

    rabbu · H7231

    to be or become many · v11

    'They have become many': a completed, typical result. A related root echoes birvot, so the sound itself makes the point that growth in wealth and growth in mouths go together.

  4. אוֹכְלֶ֑יהָ

    'okheleyha · H0398

    to eat · v11, v12

    'Its eaters': people who literally eat from the owner's prosperity, such as household members, servants, workers, dependents, guests and hangers-on, and perhaps officials who take their share. These are mouths to feed, not shoppers in a market.

  5. וּמַה־

    umah · H4100

    and what? · v11

    Brings in a rhetorical question that expects the answer 'nothing, or almost nothing'. Qoheleth often uses questions like this ('what profit…?', 1:3; 3:9).

  6. כִּשְׁרוֹן֙

    kishron · H3788

    skill, success, advantage · v11

    'Success' or 'advantage': what the owner actually gains from his success. The word appears only in Ecclesiastes (also 2:21; 4:4), and its root means 'to be fit, to succeed'.

  7. לִבְעָלֶ֔יהָ

    livʿaleyha · H1167G

    owner, master, possessor · v11, v13

    'To its owner'. The form is plural, but Hebrew regularly uses this plural form of 'owner' for one person (compare Exod 21:29). The 'his eyes' at the end of the verse confirms that one owner is meant.

  8. כִּ֖י

    ki · H3588B

    except (with אִם) · v11

    First half of the fixed phrase ki 'im, 'except' or 'but only'.

  9. אִם־

    'im · H0518B

    except (with כִּי) · v11, v12

    Completes 'except'. It narrows the owner's gain down to a single thin thing.

  10. רְא֥וּת

    re'ut (written re'it) · H7212

    sight, seeing · v11

    'The seeing of': the act of looking, nothing more. The word does not say whether the looking is enjoyed or bitter. The point is that seeing is not having or using.

  11. עֵינָֽיו׃

    ʿeinav · H5869A

    eye(s) · v11

    'His (two) eyes.' The owner's eyes, which according to 1:8 and 4:8 are never satisfied, are left with only the view of his wealth.

  12. מְתוּקָה֙

    mətûqāh · H4966

    sweet · v12

    Placed first for emphasis: "Sweet is…". The word is used of honey and pleasant food, and also of anything that is good to experience. Here the worker's sleep is something he enjoys and is refreshed by.

  13. שְׁנַ֣ת

    shənat · H8142

    sleep · v12

    "The sleep of", tied grammatically to the next word. Ordinary nightly sleep, the rest that follows a day's work.

  14. הָעֹבֵ֔ד

    hāʿōbēd · H5647

    to work, serve, till · v12

    "The one who works", a participle (a verb used as a noun) with "the". It means someone whose life is physical labour, very likely working the soil. It echoes 5:9, where the king is "served" (ne'ebad, the same root) by the cultivated field.

  15. מְעַ֥ט

    məʿaṭ · H4592

    a little · v12

    A little: the lean side of the laborer's uncertain table.

  16. וְהַשָּׂבָע֙

    wəhaśśābāʿ · H7647

    plenty, fullness, satiety · v12

    "But the fullness". The root means being satisfied or filled, especially with food. The noun means plenty or abundance. Right after "eats little or much", it suggests the rich man's full belly, and it also stands for his surplus wealth.

  17. לֶֽעָשִׁ֔יר

    leʿāshîr · H6223

    rich · v12

    "Belonging to the rich man". The prefix le- marks whose the fullness is. The rich man is set against the laborer, the one who has more than enough against the one who works.

  18. אֵינֶ֛נּוּ

    ʾênennû · H0369

    there is not; not · v12

    "It is not". The negative carries the pronoun "it", which points back to the fullness. That makes the abundance itself the thing keeping him awake.

  19. מַנִּ֥יחַֽ

    mannîaḥ · H5117

    to rest; (this form) to let, leave, allow · v12

    "Letting, allowing". It comes from the root for "rest". This form normally means "leave alone, permit", but the sound of "rest" is still there: his plenty gives him no rest and does not leave him alone to sleep.

  20. ל֖וֹ

    lô

    to him · v12

    "Him": the rich man is the one his own fullness will not leave alone.

  21. לִישֽׁוֹן׃

    lîshôn · H3462

    to sleep · v12

    "To sleep". The verse ends on the same idea it began with (the noun sleep at the start, the verb sleep at the end), framing the contrast between the two men.

  22. יֵ֚שׁ

    yesh · H3426

    there is, existence · v13

    Simply asserts that something exists: "there is." It opens Qoheleth's report the way an observer opens a case file: here is something real that happens.

  23. רָעָ֣ה

    ra'ah · H7451

    evil, bad thing, misfortune · v13

    A bad thing, a misfortune, something wrong with how life goes. It is not mainly moral wickedness. The same word comes back at the end of the verse, so the verse opens and closes on "evil/harm."

  24. חוֹלָ֔ה

    cholah · H2470

    be sick, be weak; grievous · v13

    A participle (a verb used as a describing word) from "to be sick": literally "a sick evil," meaning a sickening, painful misfortune. The picture is of an ailment, not only of something serious.

  25. רָאִ֖יתִי

    ra'iti · H7200

    see · v13

    "I have seen." This is Qoheleth's usual way of working. He bases his claim on what he has watched happen, not on tradition or revelation.

  26. תַּ֣חַת

    tachat · H8478

    under, beneath · v13

    "Under," the first word of Qoheleth's signature phrase "under the sun."

  27. הַשָּׁ֑מֶשׁ

    hashshamesh · H8121

    sun · v13

    "The sun." Together with "under," it means "in the world of the living, in ordinary human life." It does not mean "without God."

  28. עֹ֛שֶׁר

    'osher · H6239

    wealth, riches · v13

    Wealth or riches in general, meaning accumulated possessions. In the verses around it, this is the money that keeps the rich man awake (v.12) and that is lost in a bad venture (v.14).

  29. שָׁמ֥וּר

    shamur · H8104

    keep, guard, watch over · v13

    "Kept, guarded." It is a passive form of the verb used for guarding a flock, a city or a treasure. It shows wealth held onto and protected. "Hoarded" is a fair reading in this context, but the word itself is broader.

The world behind it

A household economy. In the ancient Near East a wealthy man's wealth was largely his household: land, flocks, stores, and the people who worked them and ate from them. Growing richer meant taking on more servants and slaves, more hired hands, more stewards and managers, more relatives and clients who depended on him, and more guests to host. Solomon's court is the extreme example. Its daily provision was enormous (1 Kgs 4:22–23), and Qoheleth speaks in the voice of a king who "acquired male and female servants" and "had great possessions" (Eccl 2:7–8).

Officials and taxes. Most scholars date Ecclesiastes to the Persian or early Hellenistic period (roughly 5th–3rd century BCE). That was a commercial, money-using economy with royal grants, tax-farming and layers of officials (compare 5:8, "one official is watched by a higher one"). Some commentators (e.g. Seow) think the "eaters" include the people who took a cut of a successful man's income. The verse does not specify, and the household picture works on its own.

Verse numbering. Hebrew Bibles begin chapter 5 one verse later than English Bibles, so this verse is Ecclesiastes 5:10 in the Hebrew text.

From the study of Ecclesiastes 5:11.

Where scholars differ

in v11

Who are the 'eaters' of the increase?

  • Members of the owner's household: servants, workers, relatives and dependents who must be fed.

    This is the ordinary sense of 'eat'. Ancient wealth was organised around the household, and the surrounding verses are about eating (5:12, 5:18). Qoheleth's royal persona acquired many servants (2:7).

  • Hangers-on, flatterers and officials or tax-collectors who take a share of a successful man's income.

    The book is set in a Persian or Hellenistic economy with layers of officials (5:8–9). Commentators such as Seow read the verse against that bureaucratic and commercial setting.

  • A general proverb with no specific group in mind: expenses always rise to meet income.

    The verse is phrased as a proverb with no named group. Many commentators (e.g. Fox, Longman) treat it as a broad observation.

in v11

Is 'the seeing of his eyes' a small real pleasure or pure irony?

  • Bitter irony: the owner gets nothing at all except to watch others eat his wealth.

    The eye is never satisfied (1:8; 4:8). The rhetorical 'what…?' expects 'nothing', and 5:12 goes on to say his abundance robs him of sleep.

  • A modest, real satisfaction, though far less than he imagined.

    Eccl 6:9 rates 'the sight of the eyes' above restless desire, and Qoheleth does sometimes grant small goods. Translations like 'feast their eyes' lean this way.

in v12

Is the rich man's śābāʿ his full stomach or his abundant wealth?

  • Physical satiety: the rich man overeats and cannot sleep.

    It follows directly on "whether he eats little or much". The root's core sense is being filled with food. The Vulgate's saturitas points this way, Sirach 31:20 links gluttony with sleeplessness, and ESV and NASB translate "full stomach".

  • Surplus wealth: anxiety over possessions keeps him awake.

    The surrounding unit is about money, increasing goods, and wealth hoarded to its owner's harm (5:10–13). The noun śābāʿ means "plenty" in Gen 41 and Prov 3:10, and Sirach 31:1–2 describes worry over wealth driving away sleep.

  • Deliberate double meaning.

    Qohelet often uses words with more than one sense. The verse pivots from eating (first half) to wealth (context), and "fullness" covers both. Ben Sira, an early reader in the same tradition, develops both ideas.

in v12

Who is "the one who works"?

  • A free laborer, especially an agricultural worker.

    The Masoretic vowels read a participle, "one working". The root is used for tilling the soil (Gen 2:5; 4:2), and 5:9 speaks of the field being worked for the king. The Vulgate has operanti, "the one who works".

  • A slave or servant.

    The Septuagint reads doulos, "slave", vocalizing the same consonants as ʿebed. That sharpens the contrast with the master, though the Masoretic reading is generally preferred.

in v13

Does the wealth get kept "by" its owner or "for" its owner?

  • "By its owner": the owner himself does the guarding, which harms him (WEB, ESV, NASB; Fox, Seow).

    Hebrew sometimes uses l- with a passive form to mark who does the action (e.g. Gen 14:19, "blessed by God Most High," barukh ... le'El). The point of the verse is the owner's own anxious guarding, which connects with his sleeplessness in v.12.

  • "For its owner": the wealth is stored up for his benefit, yet it turns out to his harm (KJV, YLT; some older commentators).

    The most common meaning of l- is "for, to." This reading also produces a sharp irony: kept for him, to his harm. Using l- to mark the doer is relatively rare.

in v13

What exactly is the "harm"?

  • The loss narrated in v.14: the guarded wealth is wiped out in a bad venture, leaving nothing for the heir.

    Verse 14 begins with "and" and refers back to "that wealth" (ha'osher hahu), which ties it closely to v.13. Most modern commentators read vv.13-17 as one case.

  • The burden of possession itself: anxiety, sleeplessness, people who prey on wealth, and a life spent guarding it.

    Verse 12 has just said that the rich man's surplus does not let him sleep. Verse 17 describes him eating in darkness with much vexation, sickness and anger.

  • Both: the guarding wears him down, and then the loss proves the guarding was useless.

    Qoheleth's cases often pile ironies on top of each other. The "sick" vocabulary appears both here and in v.17, which joins the two.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. כִּשְׁרוֹן, טוֹבָה, רְאוּת
  • HALOT s.v. כִּשְׁרוֹן
  • C. L. Seow, Ecclesiastes (Anchor Bible 18C, 1997)
  • M. V. Fox, A Time to Tear Down and a Time to Build Up: A Rereading of Ecclesiastes (1999)
  • T. Longman III, The Book of Ecclesiastes (NICOT, 1998)
  • R. E. Murphy, Ecclesiastes (Word Biblical Commentary 23A, 1992)
  • Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia (Masoretic ketiv/qere at Eccl 5:10)
  • Rahlfs, Septuaginta (Ecclesiastes 5:10)
  • Vulgate, Ecclesiastes 5:10
  • BDB s.v. שָׂבָע, שׂבע
  • HALOT s.v. נוח (Hiphil B), שָׂבָע, עבד
  • C.-L. Seow, Ecclesiastes (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • M. V. Fox, A Time to Tear Down and a Time to Build Up: A Rereading of Ecclesiastes
  • Septuagint, Ecclesiastes 5:11
  • Vulgate, Ecclesiastes 5:11
  • Sirach 31:1–2, 20
  • BDB s.v. רַע / רָעָה, חָלָה, שָׁמַר, בַּעַל
  • HALOT s.v. חלה I, שׁמר
  • C.-L. Seow, Ecclesiastes (Anchor Bible 18C), on 5:12-16 (Heb)
  • C.-L. Seow, "Linguistic Evidence and the Dating of Qohelet," JBL 115 (1996)
  • Michael V. Fox, A Time to Tear Down and a Time to Build Up: A Rereading of Ecclesiastes
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Ecclesiastes 5:12
  • Vulgate, Ecclesiastes 5:12
  • Phoenician inscriptions of Tabnit and Eshmunazar (KAI 13-14), "under the sun"

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).