Exodus Chapter 21 Read as one passage

Exodus 21:24–25

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

24eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot, 25burn for burn, wound for wound, and stripe for stripe.

What the first hearers heard

To Israelites hearing the covenant laws, this line did several things at once:

  • It put justice in the court's hands. The penalty was set by the community's judges (compare v. 22, "as the judges determine"; Deut 19:18–21). The injured family did not decide it, so feud and escalation were cut off.
  • It capped the penalty. One eye at most for an eye, one tooth at most for a tooth. In a world where a wound could be avenged with death (Gen 4:23), that was a limit on punishment, not a call for it.
  • It set a minimum. A rich or powerful man could not treat a poor man's eye as a minor matter. In Hammurabi's laws the value of an injury depended on the victim's class. Here, among free Israelites, the same measure applied to everyone.
  • It put a value on the body. Every part of the person, from the eye down to a tooth, a burn or a bruise, had a weight the law recognised. In this setting even injury to a pregnant woman caught up in other men's fight counted.

Did Israelite courts actually put out eyes? The text does not say, and no biblical narrative records it. The word "in place of" is also used for money and freedom in the same chapter, and Numbers 35:31 seems to assume ransom was possible for anything short of murder. Both suggest the formula may often have worked as a standard of value for settlement. Leviticus 24:19–20 ("as he has done, so it shall be done to him") and Deuteronomy 19:21 are worded more literally, though. The first hearers knew the principle with certainty. The method of carrying it out may have varied.

From the study of Exodus 21:24.

Verse by verse

  1. 24eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot,

    Grammatically this verse is the middle of a sentence. Verse 23 begins: "If harm happens, you shall give life in place of life." Verse 24 continues the list of what is to be given, and verse 25 finishes it with burn, wound and bruise.

    So the full sense is: "[you shall give] an eye in the place of an eye, a tooth in the place of a tooth, a hand in the place of a hand, a foot in the place of a foot."

    What the first hearers heard was a measure, not a mood. The repeated word taḥat means "in place of, as the equivalent of". The rhythm of eye/eye, tooth/tooth works like a legal maxim: the penalty must equal the harm. It must not be less, as if a poor man's eye did not count. It must not be more, the way a blood feud spirals when a family avenges a tooth with a life. The list moves from the gravest injury (the eye) to a lesser one (the tooth), and verse 25 goes down to a bruise, so the point is proportion at every level.

    This is law for the community's judges. It is not permission for an injured man to take revenge himself. The case in view is two men fighting who injure a bystander, a pregnant woman (vv. 22–23). The immediate context also uses the same "in place of" language for payment: a master frees his slave "in place of his eye" (v. 26), and an owner pays "ox in place of ox" (v. 36). So the verse states the principle of exact equivalence. Whether that equivalent was ever, or always, carried out on the offender's body, or usually paid as its value, was debated in antiquity and still is.

    Full study →
  2. 25burn for burn, wound for wound, and stripe for stripe.

    "A burn in exchange for a burn, a wound in exchange for a wound, a welt in exchange for a welt."

    This verse finishes the legal formula that began in 21:23 ("life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot"). Verse 24 named parts of the body that can be lost for good. Verse 25 names injuries that heal but leave a mark: the scorch of fire, the bruised or split flesh of a blow, and the raised streak a fist, stick or lash leaves on the skin. Each pair uses the same word twice, joined by taḥat, "in the place of". The effect is a strict balance. Whatever the response to an injury is, it must be the same size and kind as the injury, never more.

    The first hearers would have caught a deliberate echo. "Wound" and "welt" are the exact pair Lamech used when he boasted of killing a man for a wound and a youth for a welt, and of avenging himself seventy-seven times (Genesis 4:23–24). Here that pair is matched one to one. In context the formula is a court's measure, part of laws given to be applied by judges (21:22). It is not a private licence to hit back. Elsewhere in the same chapter, ordinary injuries are settled by paying for lost work and healing (21:18–19), and the same word taḥat means compensation (21:26–27, 36). So it is genuinely debated whether "burn for burn" was ever carried out on the body or always meant "the equivalent of a burn". On either reading the verse says that every harm, down to a bruise, is answerable, and that justice is capped at the value of the harm done.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v24

    an eye for an eye

    ʿayin taḥat ʿayin

    What we hear
    A slogan for personal revenge: "you hurt me, so I get to hurt you back". It is often treated as the harsh opposite of mercy, as in "an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind".
    What they heard
    A legal standard for judges: the penalty must be the equivalent of the injury, no more and no less, and the same for every free person. Its job was to replace private revenge and to cap it. In this chapter the same "in place of" wording also covers compensation given as the equivalent of a loss.
  • in v25

    burn for burn, wound for wound (the 'eye for an eye' formula)

    taḥat

    What we hear
    A licence for personal revenge, or a byword for harsh, primitive justice: 'you hurt me, so I hurt you'.
    What they heard
    A rule of exact equivalence applied through judges, which limits the response to the size of the harm. In the same chapter taḥat also means compensation of equal value (21:26, 36). Its main thrust was to stop escalation such as Lamech's, not to require cruelty.
  • in v25

    stripe (KJV, YLT, ESV, BSB)

    ḥabbûrāh

    What we hear
    A band or line of colour, as on a flag or a shirt.
    What they heard
    The raised, discoloured welt left on skin by a blow or a lash.
Every word
  1. עַ֚יִן

    ʿayin · H5869

    eye · v24

    The injured eye, put first as the most valuable and most easily destroyed body part. It is the object of the verb "you shall give" carried over from verse 23, so the sense is "[you shall give] an eye…".

  2. תַּ֣חַת

    taḥat · H8478

    under; in place of, instead of · v24, v25

    The hinge of the formula. It means one thing standing in the place of another, an equivalent. In this same chapter it describes payments and compensation ("ox in place of ox", v. 36; freedom "in place of his eye", v. 26).

  3. שֵׁ֖ן

    shen · H8127

    tooth · v24

    A lesser injury than an eye. Putting it next to the eye shows the rule scales up and down. Minor harm gets a minor penalty, not the same penalty as major harm.

  4. יָ֚ד

    yad · H3027

    hand · v24

    The hand, which was a person's means of working and earning. Losing a hand meant losing a living, so the injury had economic weight as well as bodily weight.

  5. רֶ֖גֶל

    regel · H7272

    foot · v24

    The foot, needed to walk, herd and work fields. With the hand, it stands for the whole working body.

  6. כְּוִיָּה֙

    kəwiyyāh · H3555

    burn, scorch-mark · v25

    The burn injury a person has caused, the mark left on skin by fire or a hot object. It comes first in the verse and opens the list of injuries that heal but leave a mark.

  7. פֶּ֖צַע

    peṣaʿ · H6482

    wound, bruise · v25

    An injury from a blow, a bruise or split in the flesh. It is the same word Lamech uses when he boasts of killing a man 'for my wound' (Genesis 4:23).

  8. חַבּוּרָ֕ה

    ḥabbûrāh · H2250

    welt, weal, stripe, bruise · v25

    The swollen, discoloured streak raised by a blow or a lash. It is the lightest of the three injuries, the kind of mark a fist or stick fight leaves.

The world behind it

The case in view. Exodus 21:22–25 deals with two men fighting who strike a pregnant woman so that "her children come out". If there is no ʾason (serious harm), the striker pays a fine set by the husband and confirmed by judges or assessors (pelilim). If there is harm, the "life for life, eye for eye…" formula applies. Verse 24 is the heart of that second ruling. It is not a free-standing command about personal conduct.

The Covenant Code. Exodus 20:22–23:33 is a collection of case laws ("if a man does X, then Y"). It is closely comparable to other ancient Near Eastern law collections. These were the rulings of Israel's local courts, typically elders at the town gate, given within the covenant at Sinai.

The wider legal debate. The older Sumerian and Babylonian law collections set silver payments for bodily injuries: the Laws of Ur-Nammu (c. 2100 BC) and the Laws of Eshnunna (c. 1800 BC) both do this. The Laws of Hammurabi (c. 1750 BC) introduced literal matching injury, but only between free men of the same class. A commoner's eye cost one mina of silver, and a slave's eye half the slave's price. Israel's formula has no such ranking among free persons: an eye is an eye. Exodus does still treat slaves separately. A master who blinds his slave does not lose his own eye. He loses the slave, who goes free (vv. 26–27).

Blood feud. Where there was no strong central court, an injured family took revenge, and revenge tends to escalate. Lamech boasts of killing a man for a wound and of being avenged seventy-sevenfold (Gen 4:23–24). An exact-equivalence formula stated in law and applied by judges blocks that spiral.

Later Jewish practice. By the time of the Mishnah (c. AD 200), rabbinic law interpreted the formula as monetary damages. A person who injured another paid for the damage, pain, healing, lost time and shame (m. Bava Kamma 8:1). The Talmud argues this from Scripture (b. Bava Kamma 83b–84a). One argument is that Numbers 35:31 forbids taking a ransom for a murderer's life, which implies ransom was allowed for lesser injuries. Josephus (late first century AD) describes a literal penalty unless the injured man chose to accept money (Antiquities 4.280). Philo of Alexandria writes in favour of the literal sense. A later note on the ancient Jewish calendar scroll Megillat Taʿanit links a literal reading with the Sadducees (the priestly party). In Jesus' day, then, the formula was a familiar and debated legal principle when he quoted it in Matthew 5:38.

From the study of Exodus 21:24.

Where scholars differ

in v24

Was the formula carried out literally on the offender's body, or did it set the value for compensation?

  • Literal penalty, at least in principle

    Hammurabi's laws (§§196–200) show literal matching injury was a real legal practice in the region. Lev 24:19–20 says "as he has done, so it shall be done to him". Deut 19:21 adds "your eye shall not pity". Josephus (Ant. 4.280) and Philo assume a literal penalty, with Josephus allowing money if the victim agreed. Sadducees are reported to have held the literal view.

  • A standard of value, normally paid as compensation

    In the same chapter taḥat names substitutes and payments: freedom "in place of his eye" (21:26–27), "ox in place of ox" (21:36). Verse 22 sets a fine through judges. Num 35:31 forbids ransom only for murder, which implies it was allowed otherwise. No biblical narrative records maiming as a court penalty. Rabbinic law (m. Bava Kamma 8:1; b. Bava Kamma 83b–84a) and Targum Pseudo-Jonathan read it as monetary.

  • A principle of proportion more than a schedule of penalties

    The list continues mechanically to burns and bruises (v. 25), which are hard to measure literally. It sits awkwardly in a case about a pregnant woman. Many scholars therefore see it as a stock legal formula that states the principle of exact equivalence, leaving judges to apply it.

in v24

In vv. 22–23, whose "harm" (ʾason) triggers the formula: the woman's, the child's, or both?

  • Harm to the woman; the "children coming out" means a miscarriage

    This is the common older Jewish and critical reading. It contrasts a fine for the loss of the fetus with talion for injury to the mother. It is comparable to Hammurabi §§209–210 and other ancient laws on striking a pregnant woman.

  • Harm to either mother or child; "children coming out" means a premature live birth

    The Hebrew yatsaʾ yeladeha ("her children go out") is normally used of live birth, and is not the usual word for miscarriage (shakal). ʾason is not limited to one party. On this reading, the eye-for-eye equivalence applies to injury to the newborn as well.

in v25

Did 'burn for burn, wound for wound' mean physically inflicting the same injury, or setting equal compensation?

  • Originally literal, bodily retaliation, limited to exact equality.

    Leviticus 24:19–20: 'as he has done, so shall it be done to him… as he has injured a man, so shall he be injured.' Deuteronomy 19:21: 'your eye shall not pity'. The Code of Hammurabi §§196–200 clearly orders literal maiming. Philo of Alexandria (1st century AD) defends equal retaliation. Judges 1:6–7 shows the idea of mirror punishment being understood, though in war, not in court.

  • A principle of equivalence that normally fixed monetary or in-kind compensation.

    In the same passage taḥat means compensation (21:26–27, 36), and nearby injury cases are settled with money (21:18–19, 22, 30). Numbers 35:31–32 forbids ransom only for murder, implying it was allowed for injuries. The Hebrew Bible records no court-ordered maiming. Burns and welts can hardly be reproduced to an exact measure, a point pressed in the Babylonian Talmud (Bava Qamma 83b–84a). The Mekhilta and Mishnah (Bava Qamma 8:1) read the formula as monetary.

  • Bodily retaliation was the injured party's legal right and ceiling, but in practice it was usually bought off with payment.

    Josephus (Antiquities 4.280) says the one who maims suffers the same 'unless the maimed man is willing to accept money'. Scholars of ancient Near Eastern law (e.g. Raymond Westbrook) argue that talion defined the maximum claim, while settlement by ransom was the normal outcome across the region.

in v25

Does the list in 21:23–25 apply to the injured pregnant woman, or is it a general formula quoted in full?

  • It is a standard, pre-existing legal formula quoted in full. Some items (burn, welt) do not fit the case.

    The same formula appears in Leviticus 24 and Deuteronomy 19 in different settings. A burn has no obvious place in a brawl that injures a pregnant woman. The verbs switch to 'you shall give' (second person), which suggests the formula was inserted.

  • It applies to whatever harm follows in the case: to the woman, and on some readings to the child, item by item as relevant.

    The formula is introduced by 'if there is harm' (21:23) and tied grammatically to the case. The list may be meant to cover all kinds of injury that might result, with irrelevant items simply not applying.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. תַּחַת
  • HALOT s.v. תַּחַת
  • HALOT s.v. אָסוֹן
  • Laws of Hammurabi §§196–201, 209–210 (M. Roth, Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor)
  • Laws of Ur-Nammu and Laws of Eshnunna §42 (Roth, Law Collections)
  • Mishnah Bava Kamma 8:1
  • Babylonian Talmud Bava Kamma 83b–84a
  • Josephus, Antiquities 4.280
  • Philo, On the Special Laws 3.181–204
  • Targum Pseudo-Jonathan, Exodus 21:24
  • Septuagint, Exodus 21:22–25
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Exod 21:22–25
  • B. S. Jackson, Wisdom-Laws: A Study of the Mishpatim of Exodus 21:1–22:16
  • R. Westbrook, Studies in Biblical and Cuneiform Law
  • BDB s.v. כְּוִיָּה, פֶּצַע, חַבּוּרָה, תַּחַת
  • HALOT s.v. כְּוִיָּה, פֶּצַע, חַבּוּרָה, תַּחַת
  • Septuagint, Exodus 21:25; Isaiah 53:5
  • Vulgate, Exodus 21:25
  • Code of Hammurabi §§196–201
  • Laws of Eshnunna §§42–47 (monetary compensation for injuries)
  • Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 4.280
  • Philo, On the Special Laws, book 3
  • Mishnah Bava Qamma 8:1
  • Babylonian Talmud Bava Qamma 83b–84a
  • Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, Nezikin 8
  • Nahum Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Exodus
  • William H. C. Propp, Exodus 19–40 (Anchor Bible)
  • Brevard Childs, The Book of Exodus (OTL)
  • Raymond Westbrook, Studies in Biblical and Cuneiform Law

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).