Exodus Chapter 21 Read as one passage
Exodus 21:22–23
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
22If men who are fighting strike a pregnant woman and her child is born prematurely, but there is no further injury, he shall surely be fined as the woman’s husband demands and as the court allows. 23But if a serious injury results, then you must require a life for a life—
What the first hearers heard
To Israelites living under this covenant law, the verse said several concrete things:
- Violence pays for what it causes, even when it was not aimed. A man in a fight cannot shrug off harm to a bystander. If his blow causes a pregnant woman to lose or deliver her child, he owes her household.
- The pregnancy matters legally. The loss, or endangering, of the child is a real injury to the family, not a side issue. The child in the womb is called by the ordinary word for a child.
- The injured family has a voice, and the claim has a limit. The husband names what he claims, and arbiters keep it fair. This blocked both cheap dismissals and revenge-driven overcharging.
- This is one step of a graded ruling. Verse 22 covers the case without ason (disaster). Verse 23 begins "but if there is ason", and then the principle of equivalence applies. Hearers would take v. 22 as the "lesser" outcome, though the text leaves exactly whose harm marks the line for its later interpreters to decide.
The law follows the shape of its ancient neighbors, but it sets damages case by case instead of by social class, and it puts the guilty man himself, not his relatives, under the principle of equivalence.
From the study of Exodus 21:22.
Verse by verse
-
22If men who are fighting strike a pregnant woman and her child is born prematurely, but there is no further injury, he shall surely be fined as the woman’s husband demands and as the court allows.
Full study →"Now suppose two men are brawling, and in the struggle they knock into a pregnant woman, so that the child she carries comes out of her womb, but no deadly disaster follows. Then the man responsible must pay a fine without fail. The woman's husband, as head of the household, sets out the amount he claims, and the man pays it under the oversight of arbiters, who see that the claim is fair."
What the original holds that English often flattens:
- The injury was an accident. The men were fighting each other, not attacking her. Even so, the law holds the one who struck her fully liable.
- "Her children come out" uses the plain word for a child and the plain verb for leaving the womb. The Hebrew does not say whether the child lives or dies. Some translations say "premature birth" and others say "miscarriage", and both are interpretations.
- "No disaster" uses a rare word for serious, probably fatal, harm. The text does not say whose harm it means. The answer decides how verse 22 relates to verse 23's "life for life".
- The penalty is a fine, not a vague "punishment". It is paid to the household that suffered the loss. The husband's claim sets the amount, but arbiters check it.
-
23But if a serious injury results, then you must require a life for a life—
Full study →"But if disaster does strike — if the blow proves deadly — then you shall give a life in place of the life that was lost."
The verse finishes a two-part case. Two men are fighting, and one of them hits a pregnant woman who is standing nearby. Verse 22 covers the outcome where her child or children come out but no disaster follows. There the striker pays whatever the woman's husband claims, as the judges assess it. Verse 23 is the mirror case: if disaster does follow. The word for it, 'asôn, is rare. In its only other uses Jacob dreads it as something that could kill his youngest son and send his father to the grave in grief. So the word points to a deadly or grievous outcome, not a bruise. Who suffers it, the mother only or possibly her child, is not stated, and readers have disagreed since ancient times.
The ruling is stated as an equation: nefesh (a living being, a life) set taḥat ("in the place of", "in exchange for") nefesh. The verb is "give", the same verb used one verse earlier for paying the fine. So the sentence sounds like settling a debt: what was lost must be matched by something of equal weight, no more and no less. The sudden "you" (singular) may speak to the offender ("you shall give") or to the community and its judges who must see the matter settled.
This is the opening line of the famous series that continues "eye for eye, tooth for tooth" (vv. 24–25). The first hearers understood it as a principle a court applies: the penalty fits the harm, it falls on the offender himself and not on his family, and a human life is not reduced to a fine. Whether "life for life" was carried out literally or could be settled by an equivalent payment in such a case is a real and ancient question (see debates).
Where the English drifted
-
in v22
mischief (KJV)
ason
- What we hear
- Playful naughtiness, pranks.
- What they heard
- Disaster or serious harm, very likely death (compare Gen 42:38).
-
in v22
he shall be surely punished (KJV)
anosh ye'anesh
- What we hear
- Some unspecified punishment, possibly physical or prison.
- What they heard
- He must certainly pay a money fine.
-
in v22
gives birth prematurely / her child is born prematurely
veyatse'u yeladeyha
- What we hear
- A premature but living baby, as in a modern neonatal ward.
- What they heard
- 'Her children come out.' Nothing is said about timing, viability or survival. In the ancient world a birth forced by a blow would often not survive, whatever the law intended.
-
in v22
no further injury
velo yihyeh ason
- What we hear
- Beyond the early birth, no one was hurt at all.
- What they heard
- 'And there is no disaster.' There is no word 'further', and it is not said whose disaster is meant.
-
in v23
mischief (KJV, YLT)
'asôn
- What we hear
- Playful naughtiness, pranks, minor trouble-making.
- What they heard
- A calamity, probably deadly or grievous, the kind of disaster Jacob feared would kill Benjamin (Gen 42:38).
-
in v23
life for life (and the 'eye for eye' series it heads)
nefesh taḥat nefesh
- What we hear
- A licence for personal revenge, or a picture of crude, bloodthirsty justice.
- What they heard
- A court-administered principle of equal value. The penalty must match the harm, fall on the offender alone, and not exceed the loss. It limited retaliation rather than encouraging it.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v22
This verse doesn't settle the debate in either direction
- What's often taught
- This verse is often cited as decisive on the status of the unborn. One side says it proves the fetus was only property, since a fine is paid. The other says the Hebrew clearly means a premature birth, with 'life for life' protecting the child equally.
- What the text supports
The verse is a ruling on accidental injury during a brawl. It is not about a deliberate ending of a pregnancy. Its key phrases are ambiguous:
- veyatse'u yeladeyha says only 'her children come out'. It names neither miscarriage nor premature birth.
- ason ('disaster') does not say whose harm is meant.
Both main readings have real evidence (see the debates section): the ancient law parallels and ancient translations support miscarriage, while the Hebrew vocabulary leaves room for a live birth. Ancient readers themselves disagreed; the Septuagint made the fetus's development the deciding factor. Each side's reading is plausible, but neither can claim the plain sense of the text as proof.
- Where the English feeds it
- Translations settle the question inside the text: 'gives birth prematurely' (NIV, NASB, BSB, WEB) or 'miscarriage' (NRSV, NJPS). English readers then take one interpretation for what the Hebrew says. Adding 'further' to 'no further injury' tilts the reading further.
Every word
-
וְכִֽי־
vekhi · H3588A
and if, when · v22
Opens a new legal case: 'Now when…'. In these laws, kî introduces a main case, and 'im ('if', v. 23) introduces its sub-cases.
-
יִנָּצ֣וּ
yinnatsu · H5327A
to struggle, fight · v22
A two-sided brawl, men grappling with each other, as with the two Hebrews in Exod 2:13. The setting is a fight, not a planned attack on the woman.
-
אֲנָשִׁ֗ים
anashim · H0582
men · v22
Plural of 'man' (ish). Two or more men. It is not specified which of them hits her.
-
וְנָגְפ֜וּ
venagfu · H5062
to strike, push, knock · v22
'And they strike/knock into' her. The word covers a blow or a shove (an ox goring, v. 35). The impact is a side effect of the fight; it is not aimed at the pregnancy.
-
אִשָּׁ֤ה
ishah · H0802G
woman, wife · v22
A woman. Verse 22 later shows she is married, since her husband is the one who claims the payment.
-
הָרָה֙
harah · H2030A
pregnant · v22
An adjective, 'pregnant'. Her pregnancy is what makes this case different from the general assault law in vv. 18–19.
-
וְיָצְא֣וּ
veyatse'u · H3318M
to go out, come out · v22
'And they come out.' The ordinary verb for leaving, used of a live birth (Gen 25:25–26) and also of a stillborn child (Num 12:12). By itself it does not say whether the child lives or dies.
-
יְלָדֶ֔יהָ
yeladeyha · H3206
child, offspring · v22
'Her children', plural. Most likely a general plural, meaning 'whatever offspring she carries' (one or twins). The child in the womb is called by the ordinary word for a child.
-
וְלֹ֥א
velo · H3808
not · v22
Negates the next clause: 'and there is not…'.
-
יִהְיֶ֖ה
yihyeh · H1961
to be, happen · v22, v23
'There is / it happens.' Together with 'ason: 'no disaster occurs'.
-
אָס֑וֹן
ason · H0611
-
עָנ֣וֹשׁ
anosh · H6064
to fine · v22
The verb doubled for emphasis ('fining'): the payment is certain and cannot be avoided.
-
כַּֽאֲשֶׁ֨ר
ka'asher · H0834D
just as, according as · v22
'According to what…': the size of the fine depends on the claim that follows.
-
יָשִׁ֤ית
yashit · H7896G
to set, impose · v22
'Lays / imposes.' The husband sets out the amount he claims.
-
עָלָיו֙
alav · H5921A
upon him · v22
'On him', the man who caused the injury.
-
בַּ֣עַל
ba'al · H1167H
husband, master, owner · v22
'The husband of.' Ba'al is a standard word for husband, meaning the legal head of the household, who brings claims on its behalf.
-
וְנָתַ֖ן
venatan · H5414N
to give, pay · v22, v23
'And he shall give', meaning he pays the amount.
-
בִּפְלִלִֽים׃
bifelilim · H6414
judges, arbiters; assessment · v22
'By/through pelilim.' Traditionally 'through judges', so the husband's demand is checked by arbiters. Some scholars read it as 'by assessment', meaning a fair valuation. Either way the claim is not left wholly to the husband.
-
וְאִם־
ve'im · H518
and if · v23
Opens the second half of a two-part case law. Verse 22 said 'and there is no disaster', and this clause answers it: 'but if there is disaster'. The 'and' here works as a contrast ('but'), as most translations recognise.
-
נֶ֖פֶשׁ
nefesh · H5315
life, living being, person · v23
The life given in settlement. Here it means a life, a living person, and not an immaterial 'soul'.
-
תַּ֥חַת
taḥat · H8478
The world behind it
Where this law sits. Exodus 21:1–23:19 is the "Book of the Covenant", a collection of case laws (mishpatim). Each law states a situation ("when…") and then the ruling. This verse belongs to a group of laws about violent injury: men fighting with fists (vv. 18–19), a master beating his slaves (vv. 20–21), this case, and then the "eye for eye" principle (vv. 23–25).
Neighboring law codes dealt with the same situation. Older law collections from Mesopotamia and Anatolia also legislated for a pregnant woman struck by a man:
- Laws of Hammurabi §209–214 (Babylon, c. 1750 BC): striking a free man's daughter so that she loses her fetus costs 10 shekels. If she dies, the striker's own daughter is put to death. Lower-class and slave women carry lower tariffs.
- Hittite Laws §17: fines graded by the month of pregnancy.
- Middle Assyrian Laws A §50–52: heavier penalties, in some cases a life owed for the fetus.
Israelite hearers would have known this kind of law. Exodus differs in a few ways. The fine is not a fixed sum; it is claimed by the husband and checked by arbiters. There are no class tariffs. And vv. 23–25 make the guilty man himself answerable, instead of punishing his daughter.
The household and the claim. In Israel the household was the basic legal and economic unit, and its head (ba'al, "husband") brought claims for it. Children carried the family line and its inheritance, so losing one, or having one endangered, was a loss to the whole house. That is why the husband sets out the claim.
"Life for life." The next verse states the principle of proportion: the penalty must match the harm, no more and no less. Num 35:31 forbids taking a ransom payment for a murderer. That implies payment was normal for other injuries, and later Jewish tradition read the eye-for-eye laws as money compensation.
From the study of Exodus 21:22.
Where scholars differ
in v22
Does 'her children come out' describe a miscarriage or a live premature birth?
-
Miscarriage: the child dies, a fine is paid, and v. 23 covers harm to the woman.
Every ancient Near Eastern parallel (Hammurabi §209–214, Hittite §17, Middle Assyrian A §50–52) deals with miscarriage. The Septuagint, Vulgate, Josephus and the rabbis all read it this way. A birth forced by trauma would rarely survive in antiquity. A fine fits loss to the household. Held by many critical commentators (e.g. Sarna, Propp) and reflected in NRSV and NJPS.
-
Live (premature) birth: if mother and child are unharmed, a fine; if either is harmed, the principle of equivalence applies.
Hebrew does not use its usual words for miscarriage (shakal, nefel). Yatsa' is used of live births. Yeled normally means a living child. The unspecified 'ason' can cover either the mother or the child. Argued by Cassuto and others, and reflected in NIV, NASB and BSB.
in v22
Whose 'harm' (ason) is meant in vv. 22–23?
-
The woman's only.
Rabbinic tradition and Josephus. It fits the miscarriage reading, with the death of the fetus already given and the woman's fate as the variable.
-
Either the woman or the child.
The Hebrew has no 'to her'. The Septuagint itself applied the harm to the fetus. It fits the live-birth reading.
in v22
What does bifelilim mean?
-
'Through judges/arbiters': a third party checks the husband's claim.
Deut 32:31; Job 31:11, 28; Josephus's judges setting the fine; KJV and most versions.
-
'By assessment': the payment follows a fair valuation.
The root p-l-l, 'to assess, arbitrate'; Speiser's study (JBL 1963); the Septuagint's 'with valuation'.
in v23
Who suffers the 'disaster': the woman only, or the woman or her child?
-
Miscarriage reading: v. 22 describes a miscarriage (fine), and v. 23 concerns harm to the woman herself.
Every surviving ancient Near Eastern parallel (Hammurabi §§209–214, Middle Assyrian Laws A §§50–52, Hittite §§17–18) treats this case as a miscarriage with a fine, plus a heavier penalty if the woman dies. The Vulgate and Josephus read it this way. Held by many critical commentators (e.g. Childs, Propp, Sarna's discussion of the parallels).
-
Premature-birth reading: v. 22 describes a live early birth, and the 'disaster' of v. 23 can fall on either the mother or the child.
'Her children come out' uses yāṣā', a verb used for live births (Gen 25:25–26). Yeled ('child') is the ordinary word for a born child. The Hebrew words for miscarriage (shākal, nefel) are not used. 'asôn has no stated subject and so could apply to both. Reflected in BSB, NIV and ESV rendering v. 22 as a premature birth. Defended by some evangelical scholars (e.g. Cassuto among earlier commentators, and others since).
-
Formed/unformed reading: the penalty depends on whether the fetus was fully developed.
The Septuagint and Philo. Ancient, but it depends on the Greek translators' interpretation rather than on the Hebrew wording.
in v23
Did 'life for life' mean literal execution or an equivalent payment?
-
Literal: the offender forfeits his life.
The plain wording. Num 35:31 forbids accepting ransom for a murderer, which shows ransom was a live option and was barred in murder cases. Josephus (Ant. 4.278) says the striker dies if the woman dies.
-
A formula of equal value that could be settled by compensation.
The verb is 'give', as in the fine of v. 22 and the ransom of v. 30. Taḥat marks repayment elsewhere in the chapter (v. 36). The identical phrase in Lev 24:18 means replacing an animal. Exod 21:30 allows a ransom even where the law says the ox's owner 'shall die'. The striker did not intend this harm, and accidental killers were otherwise spared (21:13). Rabbinic debate (b. Sanhedrin 79a–b) records Rabbi Judah the Prince taking it as money.
in v23
Who is the 'you' in 'you shall give'?
-
The offender: 'you (the guilty party) shall give a life'.
It follows on from v. 22, where the striker 'shall give'. The verb 'give' naturally describes the one who pays.
-
The community or judge: 'you (Israel) shall impose life for life'.
Similar talion lists address Israel as 'you' (Deut 19:21, 'your eye shall not pity'). Many translations (NIV, WEB 'take'; BSB 'require'; NASB 'appoint') adopt this reading. Some scholars think the shift in person shows that an older, fixed talion formula has been inserted into the case law.
Sources
- BDB and HALOT s.v. אָסוֹן, פָּלִיל, עָנַשׁ, נָגַף, יָצָא
- U. Cassuto, A Commentary on the Book of Exodus (1967)
- N. Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Exodus (1991)
- W. H. C. Propp, Exodus 19–40, Anchor Bible (2006)
- B. S. Jackson, Wisdom-Laws: A Study of the Mishpatim of Exodus 21:1–22:16 (2006)
- E. A. Speiser, 'The Stem PLL in Hebrew', JBL 82 (1963)
- Laws of Hammurabi §209–214; Hittite Laws §17; Middle Assyrian Laws A §50–52 (M. Roth, Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor)
- Septuagint Exodus 21:22–23
- Philo, On the Special Laws 3.108–109
- Josephus, Antiquities 4.278
- Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, Nezikin 8; Mishnah Bava Qamma 5:4
- Vulgate Exodus 21:22
- BDB s.v. אָסוֹן
- HALOT s.v. אָסוֹן
- HALOT s.v. נֶפֶשׁ
- BDB s.v. תַּחַת
- Laws of Hammurabi §§196–214
- Middle Assyrian Laws A §§21, 50–52
- Hittite Laws §§17–18
- Vulgate Exodus 21:22–23
- Josephus, Antiquities 4.278, 4.280
- Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, Nezikin 8
- Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 79a–b; Bava Kamma 83b–84a
- W. H. C. Propp, Exodus 19–40 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- B. S. Childs, The Book of Exodus (OTL)
- N. M. Sarna, Exodus (JPS Torah Commentary)
- U. Cassuto, A Commentary on the Book of Exodus
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Exod 21:22–25
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).