Ezekiel Chapter 24 Read as one passage
Ezekiel 24:21–24
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
21Tell the house of Israel that this is what the Lord GOD says: ‘I am about to desecrate My sanctuary, the pride of your power, the desire of your eyes, and the delight of your soul. And the sons and daughters you left behind will fall by the sword.’ 22Then you will do as I have done: You will not cover your lips or eat the bread of mourners. 23Your turbans will remain on your heads and your sandals on your feet. You will not mourn or weep, but you will waste away because of your sins, and you will groan among yourselves. 24‘Thus Ezekiel will be a sign for you; you will do everything that he has done. When this happens, you will know that I am the Lord GOD.’
What the first hearers heard
For the exiles by the Chebar canal, this was devastating news delivered through a living picture. They had just watched their prophet lose his wife and refuse to mourn. Now they learned that his silence was their future.
- Their last certainty removed. Exiled as they were, many still trusted that Jerusalem and its temple would stand and that they might soon return (cf. Jer 28–29). God now says he himself is taking the sanctuary's holiness away. The thing they were proud of, loved to look at and longed to protect would be violated.
- Covenant language they would recognise. "The pride of your power" comes straight from the curses of Leviticus 26, so the catastrophe is presented as the covenant working as warned, not as the God of Israel losing to Babylon's gods.
- The loss of family. Many of them had children and relatives inside the besieged city. The verse turns the theology into a family tragedy: those you left behind will die by the sword.
- Preparation, not just punishment. The wider passage (vv. 24, 27) says that when the news comes, "you will know that I am the LORD", and Ezekiel's enforced muteness will end (fulfilled in 33:21–22). The verse prepares the exiles to read the fall of Jerusalem as God's deliberate act, the necessary ground for the hope of restoration that Ezekiel preaches after chapter 33.
From the study of Ezekiel 24:21.
Verse by verse
-
21Tell the house of Israel that this is what the Lord GOD says: ‘I am about to desecrate My sanctuary, the pride of your power, the desire of your eyes, and the delight of your soul. And the sons and daughters you left behind will fall by the sword.’
Full study →Ezekiel has just lost his wife. God told him she would be taken and forbade him to mourn her in the usual way, and the stunned exiles have asked what his strange behaviour means. Now God gives the answer, through the prophet, as a herald repeats his king's words:
"Tell the whole family of Israel that the sovereign LORD has spoken: Look, I myself am about to strip my own holy house of its holiness and hand it over to be violated. That temple is the glory you leaned on for security, the thing you were proud of and sure could never fall. It is what your eyes loved to look at, the one thing your whole heart ached over and wanted spared. And the sons and daughters you had to leave behind in Jerusalem when you were deported will be cut down by the sword."
Several things carry the force of the original. God is the one who acts: the Babylonians will burn the building, but the Hebrew says I am profaning my sanctuary, so this is judgment and not defeat. The phrase "the pride of your power" is the exact wording of the covenant curse in Leviticus 26:19 ("I will break the pride of your power"), so a priest-prophet's hearers would recognise a warning coming true. "The delight of your eyes" is the very phrase God used five verses earlier for Ezekiel's wife. Whatever Ezekiel's wife was to him, the temple is to them, and they are about to lose it just as suddenly. The last of the three descriptions comes from a root meaning "to spare, to feel tender compassion". It probably carries an irony: the thing Israel's heart longs to have spared is exactly what God, throughout this book, has said he will not spare. Finally, the grief becomes concrete and personal. It is not only a building but their own children who will fall.
-
22Then you will do as I have done: You will not cover your lips or eat the bread of mourners.
Full study →"And you will act exactly as I have acted. You will not draw your cloak across your face to veil your mouth and beard, as mourners and disgraced people do. And you will not eat the food that neighbours bring to comfort a house of death."
Ezekiel is speaking to fellow exiles in Babylonia. That morning his wife, "the delight of his eyes," had died, and he went about with his turban on and his sandals on his feet. He did not veil his face, did not eat the comfort meal, and did not weep aloud. Shocked, the people asked what it meant. This verse is part of his answer.
The verb is a forecast, not an order. When the news comes that God has let his own sanctuary be defiled and destroyed, the temple that was the exiles' pride and their eyes' delight, and that the sons and daughters they left in Jerusalem have died by the sword, the exiles will behave just as he did. The usual rites of grief will not happen. No face will be veiled, no neighbour will bring bread, no one will wail. This will not be because they do not care. The disaster will be too total and too deserved for the ordinary forms of mourning. As the next verse says, they will instead "waste away" in their guilt and groan quietly to one another. The verse turns the absence of mourning into the loudest sign of all.
-
23Your turbans will remain on your heads and your sandals on your feet. You will not mourn or weep, but you will waste away because of your sins, and you will groan among yourselves.
Full study →"Your turbans, your fine headwear, will still be wound on your heads, and your sandals still on your feet. You will not raise the funeral wail, and you will not weep. Instead you will slowly rot away inside your guilt and its consequences, and you will groan to one another with a low, wordless moan."
In Israel, death was answered with set public actions. You took off your headdress and put dust on your head, went barefoot, covered your upper lip, ate food brought by neighbours, and joined the loud lament and weeping. Ezekiel has just acted out the opposite. His wife, "the delight of his eyes," has died, and at God's command he keeps his turban and sandals on and holds no funeral. Here he tells his fellow exiles that they will do the same when news comes that the Temple, their "delight," and the sons and daughters they left behind in Jerusalem have fallen.
The headdress named here comes from a word meaning "beauty." The people keep their small beauty on their heads while losing their great one (the Temple, called "the joy of their glory" in v.25). In place of the public, shared grieving that helped a community through death, there will be the decay that the covenant curse of Leviticus 26:39 had warned of: "rotting away in their iniquity in the lands of their enemies." What is left is a low, animal-like groan passed from neighbour to neighbour. The grief is real and deep, but it has no words, no ritual and no comfort.
-
24‘Thus Ezekiel will be a sign for you; you will do everything that he has done. When this happens, you will know that I am the Lord GOD.’
Full study →"So Ezekiel will stand among you as a living portent. Everything he has done, you yourselves will do. And when it arrives, you will be forced to recognize that I, the Master, Yahweh, have done this."
The exiles have just watched their priest-prophet lose his wife, "the delight of your eyes" (v. 16). They watched him keep his turban on and his sandals laced. He did not cover his lip, the customary sign of mourning, and he did not eat the meal neighbours bring to a grieving house. Baffled, they asked what it meant for them (v. 19). This verse is the end of God's answer.
The word for "sign" (mofet) means a portent: a strange, unsettling token whose reality is still to come, and which guarantees that it will. Ezekiel's bereavement acted out in advance what is about to happen to them. Their own "delight of the eyes," the temple in Jerusalem, is about to be profaned. The sons and daughters they left behind will fall by the sword (v. 21). When that news reaches them, they will do what he did. This is a prediction, not a command. They will not perform the rites of mourning. Instead they will waste away inwardly under their guilt and groan to one another (v. 23).
"When it comes" ties all of this to a real event they will live through. The final clause, the refrain of the whole book, says what the disaster will teach. It will not show that their God has been defeated. It will force them to admit that the catastrophe was his own act, announced beforehand by the man he named. This is the only place in the message where God calls his prophet by name, and that name means "God strengthens."
Where the English drifted
-
in v21
profane / desecrate (KJV, WEB 'profane')
ḥālal (mĕḥallēl)
- What we hear
- To use vulgar or blasphemous language, or to show disrespect.
- What they heard
- To move something from the category 'holy, set apart for God' into 'common', taking away its protected sacred status so that it lies open to violation. Here God himself does this to the temple, through the invading army.
-
in v21
that which your soul pitieth (KJV, WEB)
maḥmal napšĕkem
- What we hear
- Something you feel sorry for, perhaps with a sense of looking down on it; 'soul' as the spiritual part of a person.
- What they heard
- What your whole living self tenderly cares for and longs to see spared: the object of protective affection.
-
in v21
the pride of your power
gĕʾôn ʿuzzĕkem
- What we hear
- Purely sinful arrogance about one's own strength.
- What they heard
- The eminence or glory that made you feel strong and safe. It can be legitimate glory, but here it is tinged with misplaced confidence. It is also a direct echo of the covenant curse in Leviticus 26:19.
-
in v22
cover your lips
ʿatah ʿal-safam
- What we hear
- Keeping silent, or putting a hand over the mouth.
- What they heard
- Veiling the moustache and lower face with cloth, a recognised public sign of mourning, shame or uncleanness.
-
in v22
bread of men
leḥem ʾanashim
- What we hear
- An obscure phrase: ordinary food? food for men only?
- What they heard
- The meal tied to bereavement: most likely food that other people brought to comfort mourners, or (if the text is emended) "mourners' bread."
-
in v23
tires (KJV)
pe'er
- What we hear
- Wheels on a vehicle.
- What they heard
- A headdress or turban, often a festive one; 'tire' was short for 'attire.'
-
in v23
pine away (KJV, WEB)
maqaq (nemaqqotem)
- What we hear
- To long or yearn for something you have lost.
- What they heard
- To rot, fester, decay slowly, as wounds or flesh do. It echoes the covenant curse of Leviticus 26:39.
-
in v23
mourn one toward another (KJV)
naham
- What we hear
- The same mourning that was just ruled out, now done together, which sounds contradictory.
- What they heard
- To groan or growl, a low wordless sound. It is the opposite of the formal lament (saphad) that is ruled out.
-
in v24
sign
mofet
- What we hear
- An indicator or signpost, or a miraculous proof. NLT's 'example' suggests a moral model to imitate.
- What they heard
- A portent: an unsettling, extraordinary token, often a person's own life or conduct, that acts out a coming event in advance and guarantees it.
-
in v24
you will know
vidatem (yada)
- What we hear
- To come to an inner belief, or to learn a piece of information.
- What they heard
- To be forced, by events actually lived through, to acknowledge who is acting. Recognition that comes from experience, not a private conviction.
-
in v24
the Lord GOD
adonai YHWH
- What we hear
- Two general titles for the deity, 'Lord' and 'God,' one after the other.
- What they heard
- A title, 'the Master,' followed by Israel's God's personal covenant name, Yahweh. The capitals in 'GOD' stand for the name, which Jewish reading tradition voiced as 'Elohim' here.
Every word
-
אֱמֹר
ʾĕmōr · H0559
say · v21
A command to Ezekiel: 'Say!' The prophet now explains the sign the exiles have just asked about (v. 19).
-
לְבֵית
lĕbêt · H1004
house, household · v21
'To the house of': Israel pictured as one extended family. Ezekiel is speaking to the exiles in Babylon, but they stand for the whole people.
-
יִשְׂרָאֵל
yiśrāʾēl · H3478
Israel · v21
In Ezekiel, the covenant people as a whole, here mainly the Judean exiles sitting in front of him.
-
כֹּה
kōh · H3541
thus · v21
Opens the standard messenger formula: what follows is the very wording of the sender.
-
אֲדֹנָי
ʾădōnāy · H0136
Lord, my Lord · v21, v24
A title of sovereign mastery. Paired with the divine name, it is Ezekiel's favourite way of introducing God's speech (more than 200 times).
-
יְהוִה
YHWH · H3069
Yahweh · v21, v24
God's personal covenant name. After 'Adonai' it was read aloud as 'Elohim' so that 'Adonai' would not be said twice, which is why English prints 'Lord GOD'.
-
הִנְנִי
hinnî · H2005
look, I · v21
'Here I am…': it points dramatically at the speaker. Followed by a participle, it means something is about to happen.
-
מְחַלֵּל
mĕḥallēl · H2490
profaning, desecrating · v21
'Am about to profane': God himself will take away the temple's protected, holy status and hand it over to be violated. The participle (a verb form for ongoing or impending action) makes it imminent. It is already under way.
-
אֶת־
ʾet · H0853
[object marker] · v21
Untranslatable marker of the definite direct object.
-
מִקְדָּשִׁי
miqdāšî · H4720
sanctuary, holy place · v21
'My sanctuary': the Jerusalem temple. God still calls it his, and that is exactly why profaning it is a deliberate act of his own judgment and not a defeat.
-
גְּאוֹן
gĕʾôn · H1347
pride, majesty, eminence · v21
'The pride of': something that rises high and that people glory in. It sits between legitimate glory and arrogant over-confidence, and here it leans toward the confidence the people placed in the temple.
-
עֻזְּכֶם
ʿuzzĕkem · H5797
strength, might, stronghold · v21
'Your strength': the temple as the people's source of security, almost a fortress they were sure could not fall. The phrase as a whole echoes Leviticus 26:19.
-
מַחְמַד
maḥmad · H4261
delight, precious thing · v21
'The delight of': what the eyes love to rest on. It is the exact phrase used of Ezekiel's wife in v. 16, which ties the sign to its meaning.
-
עֵינֵיכֶם
ʿênêkem · H5869
eyes · v21
'Your eyes' (a form for a natural pair). The temple was something they loved to look at.
-
וּמַחְמַל
ûmaḥmal · H4263
object of compassion / tender longing · v21
'And the object of tender feeling of': this word occurs only here in the Bible. It comes from ḥāmal, 'to feel for, to spare', so it means what your inner self aches over and wants to protect. It also rhymes with maḥmad.
-
נַפְשְׁכֶם
napšĕkem · H5315
life, self, throat, desire · v21
'Your nefesh': your whole living self with its cravings and attachments. It is not an immaterial soul set against the body.
-
וּבְנֵיכֶם
ûbĕnêkem · H1121
sons · v21
'And your sons': literal children and relatives of the exiles who were still in Jerusalem.
-
וּבְנוֹתֵיכֶם
ûbĕnôtêkem · H1323
daughters · v21
'And your daughters': the loss reaches whole families, not only the fighting men.
-
אֲשֶׁר
ʾăšer · H0834
who, which · v21, v22, v24
Relative word: 'whom'.
-
עֲזַבְתֶּם
ʿăzabtem · H5800
leave, leave behind, forsake · v21
'You left behind': they stayed in Jerusalem when you were deported in 597 BC. It describes what happened. It does not accuse the exiles of abandoning them.
-
בַּחֶרֶב
baḥereb · H2719
sword · v21
'By the sword': death in war, here at the hands of the Babylonian army. The sword is one of Ezekiel's recurring instruments of judgment (cf. ch. 21).
-
יִפֹּלוּ
yippōlû · H5307
fall · v21
'They will fall': the ordinary Hebrew way of saying someone is killed in battle. It is stated as certain.
-
וַעֲשִׂיתֶ֖ם
vaʿasitem · H6213A
do, make · v22, v24
"And you will do." The verb form, joined with "and," points to the future. It is a prediction of how the exiles will act when the news reaches them, not an instruction about what they should do. YLT's "ye have done" puts it in the past and misses this.
-
עַל־
ʿal- · H5921A
upon, over · v22, v23
"Over." It goes with the verb "wrap": to wrap something over the moustache, meaning to veil the lower face.
-
שָׂפָם֙
safam · H8222
moustache, upper lip · v22
The moustache and upper-lip area, including the beard around the mouth. It stands first in its clause for emphasis. Covering it was a known gesture of grief, shame or uncleanness.
-
לֹ֣א
loʾ · H3808
not · v22, v23
Negates the act of covering. In v. 17 the same wording was a command to Ezekiel. Here, after "you will do," it describes what they will not do.
-
תַעְט֔וּ
taʿtu · H5844A
wrap, cover, enwrap · v22
"You will wrap/veil." The verb is used for wrapping oneself in a garment. Here it means drawing a cloak or headcloth across the lower face, the posture of a mourner or of a person in disgrace.
-
וְלֶ֥חֶם
veleḥem · H3899H
bread, food · v22
"And bread of…" It means food in general, not only loaves. Here it is food tied to a particular social occasion, the meal for the bereaved.
-
אֲנָשִׁ֖ים
ʾanashim · H0582
men, people · v22
"Of men/people." Taken as it stands, it most likely means food that other people bring to the bereaved, the meal neighbours provided to comfort them. Many scholars think the original word was ʾonim, "mourners" (see textual notes).
-
תֹאכֵֽלוּ׃
tokhelu · H0398
eat · v22
"You will eat." Together with the negative: you will not take part in the comfort meal. There will be no ritual way of being consoled.
-
וּפְאֵרֵכֶ֣ם
ufe'erekhem · H6287
headdress, turban · v23
'And your headdresses.' A wrapped head-covering, named with a root that means beauty or splendour. Keeping it on means not taking it off for mourning. It points back to Ezekiel's own turban in v.17.
-
רָאשֵׁיכֶ֗ם
rasheikhem · H7218A
head · v23
'Your heads.' In mourning, people bared the head or threw dust on it. Here the heads stay covered and dressed.
-
וְנַֽעֲלֵיכֶם֙
vena'aleikhem · H5275
sandal · v23
'And your sandals.' Mourners normally took off their sandals and went barefoot (2 Sam 15:30; Mic 1:8).
-
בְּרַגְלֵיכֶ֔ם
beragleikhem · H7272
foot · v23
'On your feet' (the Hebrew form means a pair of feet). The sandals stay on, so this outward sign of grief is missing too.
-
תִסְפְּד֖וּ
tispedu · H5594
to lament, wail (in mourning rites) · v23
'You will lament.' This is the formal, public funeral lament: wailing, beating the breast, singing dirges, often with hired mourners. It is not simply feeling sad.
-
תִבְכּ֑וּ
tivku · H1058
to weep · v23
'You will weep': shedding tears out loud. Paired with the formal lament, it covers both the ritual and the personal side of grief, and both are missing.
-
וּנְמַקֹּתֶם֙
unemaqqotem · H4743
to rot, fester, waste away · v23
'And you will rot away.' The verb describes slow decay, as of a wound or rotting flesh. It deliberately echoes the covenant curse in Leviticus 26:39.
-
בַּעֲוֹנֹ֣תֵיכֶ֔ם
ba'avonoteikhem · H5771G
iniquity, guilt, punishment · v23
'In your iniquities.' The word covers the wrong done, the guilt it leaves, and its consequences. The preposition can mean 'in' (sunk in them) or 'because of' them.
-
וּנְהַמְתֶּ֖ם
unehamtem · H5098
to growl, groan, moan · v23
'And you will groan.' The verb is used for a lion's low growl and the roar of the sea. Here it is a deep, wordless moan, not a lament with words.
-
אִ֥ישׁ
'ish · H0376I
man, each one · v23
'Each one': the first half of the Hebrew idiom for 'to one another.'
-
אֶל־
'el · H0413
to, toward · v23
'To, toward.' The groaning is directed at the people around them, not offered up in public ritual.
-
אָחִֽיו׃
'achiv · H0251I
brother, kinsman, fellow · v23
'His brother,' meaning his fellow exile, not only a blood brother. 'Each man to his brother' means 'to one another.'
-
וְהָיָ֨ה
vehayah · H1961
and he will be / become · v24
This verb form points to the future: 'and so Ezekiel will be.' It wraps up the explanation God has just given (vv. 22–23) and turns the prophet himself into the message.
-
יְחֶזְקֵ֤אל
yechezqel · H3168
Ezekiel ('God strengthens' / 'may God make strong') · v24
The prophet's personal name. It appears only twice in the whole book, here and in 1:3. Everywhere else God calls him 'son of man' (that is, 'human one'). Using his name here puts weight on the man himself, with his own bereavement, as the sign.
-
לָכֶם֙
lakhem · H9036
to you / for you (plural) · v24
Addressed to the whole community of exiles. The sign is put on show for them, and it is about them.
-
לְמוֹפֵ֔ת
lemofet · H4159
portent, wonder, ominous sign · v24
'For a portent.' Ezekiel's behaviour is a living preview of a disaster still to come, and a pledge that it will come. It is not a miracle and not just an illustration.
-
כְּכֹ֥ל
kekhol · H3605
according to all · v24
'Just as, in every respect.' The match will be complete: every refusal to mourn listed in vv. 17 and 22–23 will be repeated by the people.
-
בְּבֹאָ֕הּ
bevoah · H935
-
וִֽידַעְתֶּ֕ם
vidatem · H3045
and you will know · v24
Recognition that comes through experience. When events turn out as the sign said, the exiles will be forced to see who was behind them.
-
כִּ֥י
ki · H3588
that · v24
Introduces what they will come to know.
-
אֲנִ֖י
ani · H589
I · v24
An emphatic 'I.' The speaker steps forward: the disaster is not chance and not the victory of Babylon's gods. It is my doing.
The world behind it
Date and situation. Ezekiel 24 opens on the 10th day of the 10th month of the 9th year of King Jehoiachin's exile (24:1–2), January 588 BC by the usual reckoning. That was the day Nebuchadnezzar's army began its siege of Jerusalem (cf. 2 Kgs 25:1). Ezekiel was a priest living among Judean deportees at Tel-abib by the Chebar canal in Babylonia. They had been taken there in 597 BC with King Jehoiachin, the nobility and the craftsmen (2 Kgs 24:14–16). Many had left parents, children and other relatives in Jerusalem.
The temple as a guarantee. Many in Judah believed God would never let his own house fall. Zion's survival of the Assyrian siege in 701 BC had seemed to prove it (Isa 37; Ps 46; 48), and Jeremiah attacks the slogan "the temple of the LORD, the temple of the LORD" (Jer 7:4). Ezekiel had already seen in a vision God's glory leave the defiled temple (chs. 8–11). This verse announces what follows from that: the house without its divine presence would be handed over.
The sign of the wife. In 24:15–18 God tells Ezekiel that "the delight of your eyes" will die suddenly, and that he must not mourn in the customary way. Normally a mourner would take off his turban and sandals, cover his upper lip or mustache, weep aloud, and eat the "bread of men", the food neighbours brought to a house of mourning (vv. 17, 22–23). His wife dies that evening and he obeys. The exiles ask what this means (v. 19), and verse 21 begins the answer. The point (vv. 22–24) is that when the news reaches them, the loss will be too great, or too clearly deserved, for ordinary mourning. They will waste away in their guilt and groan to one another instead. The news finally arrives in 33:21: "The city has fallen."
From the study of Ezekiel 24:21.
Where scholars differ
in v21
Is 'the pride of your power' (gĕʾôn ʿuzzĕkem) praise of the temple or criticism of Israel's confidence in it?
-
Mainly negative: the temple had become an object of false security and arrogant trust.
The phrase repeats the covenant curse of Lev 26:19 and recurs in Ezekiel for things God will break (7:24; 30:6, 18; 33:28). The Septuagint translates gāʾôn with phryagma, 'arrogance'. Jeremiah 7:4 attacks the same trust in the temple.
-
Mainly positive or neutral: the temple was Israel's rightful glory, and the phrase stresses how much they are losing.
It stands in a list with 'delight of your eyes' and 'object of your tender feeling', which are terms of love and not censure. gāʾôn can mean legitimate majesty (Ps 47:4, 'the pride of Jacob whom he loves'). The verse's purpose (vv. 16–24) is to make the size of the loss felt.
-
Deliberately double-edged (a common view among commentators such as Greenberg and Block).
The temple was truly their glory, and that is exactly what made it a dangerous object of trust. The Leviticus echo supplies the judgment, while the parallel phrases supply the grief.
in v21
What does the unique word maḥmal mean?
-
'Object of compassion / what you wish to spare', from ḥāmal.
Normal Hebrew word formation, the Septuagint's 'things your souls spare', and the KJV tradition's 'pitieth'. It fits Ezekiel's repeated use of ḥāmal ('I will not spare/pity').
-
A variant or slip for maḥmad ('delight'), meaning roughly 'longing, desire'.
The word appears nowhere else, sits right after maḥmad, and v. 25 has a general 'longing of their soul'. Many modern versions translate it as 'delight' or 'yearning'.
in v22
Should leḥem ʾanashim be kept as "bread of men" or emended to leḥem ʾonim, "bread of mourners"?
-
Emend to ʾonim, "mourners."
Hos 9:4 has leḥem ʾonim in a mourning context. The Targum and the Vulgate read "mourners." "Bread of men" is otherwise unparalleled. Scholars such as Zimmerli adopt the emendation.
-
Keep the Hebrew: "bread of (other) people," i.e., condolence food.
No Hebrew manuscript reads ʾonim. The same wording appears identically in vv. 17 and 22. Jer 16:7 and 2 Sam 3:35 show others bringing food to mourners. The Septuagint follows the Hebrew. Several major commentators (e.g., Greenberg) keep it.
in v22, v23
Why will the exiles not mourn?
-
Shock and scale: the catastrophe is too vast for ordinary rites.
The whole community is bereaved at once, so no one is free to comfort others. Verse 23 describes numbed, inward groaning instead of public wailing.
-
Judgment makes mourning inappropriate.
Jer 16:5-7 forbids mourning rites for those dying under God's judgment. Verse 23's "waste away in your iniquities" (echoing Lev 26:39) puts the stress on guilt rather than grief.
-
Circumstance of exile: the dead are far away and the rites cannot be carried out.
The deaths occur in Jerusalem, and the exiles in Babylonia hear only later (33:21). This is less often held alone, but it is commonly combined with the first two views.
in v23
Is the groaning 'in your iniquities' a sign of repentance?
-
No, it is despair: the curse working itself out without hope.
Naham is a wordless, animal-like groan. Maqaq is the language of curse (Lev 26:39). Nothing in the verse mentions turning back to God.
-
It is the first step toward conviction that later leads to hope.
In Ezekiel 33:10 the exiles repeat the phrase 'we are rotting away in our sins,' and God answers by calling them to turn and live (33:11). Leviticus 26:40-45 also follows the 'rotting' curse with the possibility of confession and covenant remembrance.
in v24
Why will the exiles not mourn when the temple falls?
-
Stunned grief: the shock and size of the disaster will leave them unable to carry out the rites. They will be numb.
Verse 23 describes inward collapse ('you will waste away,' 'groan to one another') instead of outward ritual. Commentators such as Greenberg (Anchor Bible) stress paralysis of the spirit.
-
Mourning would be inappropriate: the judgment is deserved, and lament would wrongly treat it as undeserved misfortune or as a reason to call on God for pity.
'You will waste away in your iniquities' (v. 23) links their state to guilt. The God who forbids mourning is the one bringing the blow (v. 16, 'with a stroke'). Block (NICOT) discusses this line of reading.
-
Practical impossibility: in exile, with the temple gone and deaths too many to count, the normal communal rites could not be performed.
Mourning rites assumed family, community and sanctuary close by. Compare Jer 16:5–7, where a similar ban on mourning goes with a judgment so great that the normal rites stop.
in v24
Is the prophet's suppressed grief commanded of the people, or simply predicted?
-
Predicted: the people will end up in his condition.
The verb forms in vv. 22–24 are future or predictive ('you will do,' 'you will waste away'). Verse 24 calls Ezekiel a portent of what will happen, not a rule to follow.
-
Partly prescriptive: the people are being told how they should respond to deserved judgment.
The Hebrew imperfect can carry obligation, and v. 22 opens 'you will do as I have done.' Most commentators still read the passage as a forecast, given the context.
Sources
- BDB s.v. חָלַל, גָּאוֹן, מַחְמָד, מַחְמָל
- HALOT s.v. חלל I, גָּאוֹן, מַחְמָל
- Daniel I. Block, The Book of Ezekiel: Chapters 1–24 (NICOT)
- Moshe Greenberg, Ezekiel 21–37 (Anchor Bible)
- Walther Zimmerli, Ezekiel 1 (Hermeneia)
- Leviticus 26:19 (Hebrew text) for the phrase gĕʾôn ʿuzzĕkem
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Ezekiel 24:21; Vulgate Ezekiel 24:21
- 2 Kings 24–25; Jeremiah 7 for historical background
- BDB s.v. עָטָה, שָׂפָם, לֶחֶם
- HALOT s.v. שָׂפָם, עטה
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia apparatus, Ezek 24:17, 22
- Targum Jonathan and Vulgate, Ezek 24:17, 22
- W. Zimmerli, Ezekiel 1 (Hermeneia)
- M. Greenberg, Ezekiel 21–37 (Anchor Bible)
- D. I. Block, The Book of Ezekiel 1–24 (NICOT)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, Ezek 24
- BDB s.v. פְּאֵר, סָפַד, מָקַק, נָהַם
- HALOT s.v. מקק, נהם, עָוֺן
- Daniel I. Block, The Book of Ezekiel, Chapters 1–24 (NICOT)
- Leslie C. Allen, Ezekiel 20–48 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Leviticus 26:39-45; Jeremiah 16:5-7; Isaiah 61:3; Proverbs 5:11 (comparative passages)
- HALOT s.v. מוֹפֵת
- BDB s.v. מוֹפֵת; יָדַע; בּוֹא
- W. Zimmerli, Ezekiel 1 (Hermeneia) and 'Knowledge of God according to the Book of Ezekiel'
- D. I. Block, The Book of Ezekiel, Chapters 1–24 (NICOT)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Ezek 24:15–27
- Supplied word-by-word Hebrew data (lemma, Strong's, morphology)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).