Genesis Chapter 35 Read as one passage

Genesis 35:21–22

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

21Israel again set out and pitched his tent beyond the Tower of Eder. 22While Israel was living in that region, Reuben went in and slept with his father’s concubine Bilhah, and Israel heard about it. Jacob had twelve sons:

What the first hearers heard

For Israelites hearing the ancestral stories, this verse did several things:

  • It walked them through their own land. The stops on Jacob's route (Bethel, the road to Ephrath, the Flock Tower, Hebron) were places they knew. Their founding father had camped among them while the land was still only promised.
  • It showed the ancestor as a shepherd. Israel's ancestors were remembered as tent-dwelling herders (compare Deut 26:5, 'a wandering Aramean was my father'). A camp by a shepherds' tower fitted that picture.
  • It brought in the name 'Israel' at a turning point. After Rachel's death the narrator starts calling the patriarch by the name the nation itself bore. The household is being seen as the people in embryo, and the next verse goes on to list the twelve sons.
  • It set up the next scene. Listeners knew that tribal standing was at stake. Reuben's act 'in that land' (v. 22) is later given as the reason he lost the firstborn's place (Gen 49:3–4; 1 Chr 5:1). The verse sets the stage for that loss.
  • It may have carried a further echo. By the 8th century BC, Micah could call Jerusalem 'Tower of the Flock' and attach royal and shepherd hopes to it (Mic 4:8). Later readers who knew both texts sometimes linked them. Genesis itself, however, makes no such connection.

From the study of Genesis 35:21.

Verse by verse

  1. 21Israel again set out and pitched his tent beyond the Tower of Eder.

    Israel pulled up his tent pegs and moved on. He stretched out his tent again, this time past the Flock Tower.

    The verse is plain, but it carries more than English shows:

    • Who is moving. For the first time the storyteller calls Jacob by his new name, Israel. This comes right after he has buried Rachel, his best-loved wife, by the road to Ephrath and set up a pillar over her grave (vv. 19–20). The grieving widower is presented as the head of the house that will become a nation. The same name appears again in the next verse, when Reuben's offence reaches him: "and Israel heard."
    • How he moves. The two verbs give the rhythm of a herder's life. First he pulls up the stakes and breaks camp. Then he stretches out the goat-hair tent over its poles at the next site. This is not a journey with a final destination. It is the next stage of the seasonal movement of a man whose wealth is on four legs.
    • Where he stops. "Eder" is not a mystery name. It is the ordinary Hebrew word for flock. Migdal-Eder means "Flock Tower", a raised lookout from which shepherds watched for wolves, lions and thieves. Jacob camps beyond it: past the tower, further south, on the road from Bethlehem-Ephrath toward Hebron, where he will finally reach his father Isaac (v. 27).

    Put together: the bereaved patriarch, now called Israel, keeps leading his household and flocks through the land promised to him. He camps near a shepherds' watchtower. This is where the next crisis in his family will happen (v. 22).

    Full study →
  2. 22While Israel was living in that region, Reuben went in and slept with his father’s concubine Bilhah, and Israel heard about it. Jacob had twelve sons:

    Jacob, now called Israel, the father of the people, has pitched his tents beyond Migdal Eder ("Tower of the Flock") near Bethlehem. Rachel, his favourite wife, has just died giving birth to Benjamin. While the clan was settled there, Reuben, the firstborn and natural heir to lead the family, went and lay with Bilhah. She was not a stranger but his father's secondary wife: Rachel's former maid, mother of two of his half-brothers, a recognised member of his father's household and bed. To an ancient hearer this was more than sexual misconduct. It invaded the father's most private domain and could be read as an heir trying to take his father's place early. The Hebrew says nothing about what Bilhah wanted. Later Jewish retellings treated her as a victim.

    Then comes one short clause: "and Israel heard." Nothing more. No outburst, no punishment, no comment. The narrator lets the silence hang, and the scribes who copied the text left a paragraph gap in the middle of the verse at this point. The account will not be settled until Jacob's deathbed blessing (49:3–4), where Reuben loses his first place for "going up onto his father's bed."

    Then the story moves on, almost abruptly: "Now the sons of Jacob were twelve." The full list follows, and Reuben is still named first as "Jacob's firstborn." The family is complete, and the son who should hold it together has just broken it.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v21

    the Tower of Eder / Migdal Eder

    migdal ʿēder

    What we hear
    A place with an unexplained proper name, 'Eder' or 'Edar', and possibly a tall fortified tower like a castle keep.
    What they heard
    'Flock Tower': a herders' lookout or shelter from which shepherds watched their animals. 'Eder' is the everyday word for a flock, so any Hebrew listener heard the meaning.
  • in v22

    concubine

    pilegesh

    What we hear
    A mistress or kept woman: an informal, unmarried and somewhat illicit sexual partner, often pictured as part of a harem.
    What they heard
    A secondary wife, in a recognised and binding union within the household. Bilhah had been given to Jacob 'as a wife' (30:4) and her sons became full tribal ancestors. That status is exactly why Reuben's act was so grave: she belonged to his father's house and bed.
Every word
  1. וַיִּסַּ֖ע

    wayyissaʿ · H5265

    pull up (stakes); set out, journey · v21

    The basic picture is pulling up tent pegs, so it means breaking camp and moving on to the next stopping place. The verb form carries the story forward: after the burial and the pillar (v. 20), the household moves again.

  2. יִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל

    yiśrāʾēl · H3478

    Israel · v21, v22

    The man Jacob, not yet the nation. This is the first time the narrator uses his new name (given in 32:28 and confirmed in 35:10). It does so right after Rachel's death, and it keeps the name through v. 22.

  3. וַיֵּ֣ט

    wayyēṭ · H5186

    stretch out, spread, pitch · v21

    To stretch out tent cloth over poles and pull the ropes tight. Together with the first verb it gives the herder's rhythm of life: pull up the pegs, then stretch the tent out somewhere new.

  4. אָֽהֳל֔וֹ

    ʾohŏlô · H0168

    tent · v21

    His tent, which here stands for his whole camp. A herder's tent was woven from black goat hair and was the centre of the household. The written consonants have an older spelling of 'his'.

  5. מֵהָ֖לְאָה

    mēhālʾāh · H1973

    further on, beyond · v21

    Literally 'from further on', a fixed way of saying 'beyond'. He camps on the far side of the tower, as seen from the direction he was travelling, that is, south of it.

  6. לְמִגְדַּל־

    lĕmigdal- · H4029

    tower (of) · v21

    A migdal is a tower or raised lookout. Here the l- does not mean 'to'; together with the previous word it gives 'beyond'. The tower is the landmark that fixes where the camp was.

  7. וַיְהִ֗י

    vayhi · H1961

    and it was / it came to pass · v22

    The standard opening for a new scene in Hebrew storytelling: 'Now it happened…'. It ties the episode to the time and place just described, Jacob's camp beyond Migdal Eder.

  8. בִּשְׁכֹּ֤ן

    bishkon · H7931

    to dwell, settle, camp · v22

    'While [Israel] was dwelling/camping'. The word is used of settling somewhere, often for a while, here of a herding clan's encampment. It sounds a lot like the next key verb, shakhav ('lay'), and the two may echo each other: Israel settles, and Reuben lies down.

  9. בָּאָ֣רֶץ

    ba'arets · H776

    in the land, region · v22

    A local region, here the area around Migdal Eder near Bethlehem (35:19–21), not 'the earth'.

  10. הַהִ֔וא

    hahi · H1931

    that · v22

    Demonstrative: 'that [land]', pointing back to the place named in v. 21.

  11. וַיֵּ֣לֶךְ

    vayyelekh · H1980

    and he went · v22

    'Reuben went'. The movement is deliberate: he goes to Bilhah's tent. The narrator does not stop to explain. BSB's 'went in' adds a nuance the Hebrew only implies.

  12. רְאוּבֵ֔ן

    re'uven · H7205

    Reuben · v22

    Jacob's firstborn, by Leah (29:32). As the eldest son he was heir to leadership of the family, which makes his act all the more serious (see 35:23; 49:3–4).

  13. וַיִּשְׁכַּ֕ב֙

    vayyishkav · H7901

    and he lay (with) · v22

    The ordinary Hebrew way to describe sexual intercourse. Here it is followed by the object marker 'et rather than the preposition 'im ('with'), which some read as harsher, as something done to her (see studies).

  14. אֶת־

    et · H853

    [direct-object marker] · v22

    Marks Bilhah as the grammatical object of 'lay'. It has no English equivalent. Its use here instead of 'with' has drawn comment (see studies).

  15. בִּלְהָ֖ה֙

    bilhah · H1090

    Bilhah · v22

    Rachel's maidservant, whom Rachel gave to Jacob as a wife-substitute. She was mother of Dan and Naphtali (30:3–8). Rachel has just died (35:16–20).

  16. פִּילֶ֣גֶשׁ

    pilegesh · H6370

    concubine, secondary wife · v22

    A woman bound to a man in a recognised but lower-ranking marriage. Calling Bilhah this here stresses that she belongs to the father's household and bed.

  17. אָבִ֑֔יו

    aviv · H1

    his father · v22

    'Of his father'. The words 'his father's concubine' are exactly what makes the act so serious: it violates the father's sexual domain and his authority.

  18. וַיִּשְׁמַ֖ע

    vayyishma · H8085

    and he heard · v22

    'And Israel heard [of it]'. The sentence stops there. No reaction is recorded, and the silence is pointed (see studies).

  19. בְנֵֽי־

    venei · H1121

    sons of · v22

    Sons, in the sense of the founding heads of the later tribes.

  20. יַעֲקֹ֖ב

    ya'aqov · H3290

    Jacob · v22

    The narrator switches from 'Israel' back to 'Jacob' as the family register begins.

  21. שְׁנֵ֥ים

    shenayim · H8147

    two · v22

    Part of the number 'two [and] ten', i.e. twelve.

  22. עָשָֽׂר׃

    asar · H6240

    ten · v22

    Completes 'twelve'. Benjamin has just been born (35:18), so the family is now complete, and the count comes straight after an act that threatens its order.

The world behind it

Herders on the move. Jacob lived as a seminomadic herder: a man with large flocks who moved between grazing grounds and camped near towns and wells, without owning a city. His household lived in black goat-hair tents, which were pulled down and set up again at each stop. Genesis records these moves like an itinerary, and the stops trace the hill-country spine of the promised land: Shechem, Bethel, Ephrath/Bethlehem, Migdal Eder, Hebron.

Flock towers. Herders and farmers in ancient Israel built stone towers as lookouts and shelters. These were not castles. Some were plain fieldstone structures where a shepherd could watch the flock and spend the night. 2 Chronicles 26:10 mentions towers built in the wilderness for livestock. Because such towers were common, 'Flock Tower' could have been the name of more than one place.

Where was it? Genesis places it after Rachel's grave on the way to Ephrath (Bethlehem) and before Mamre/Hebron. The location of Rachel's grave is itself debated: 1 Samuel 10:2 puts it on the border of Benjamin, north of Jerusalem, while later tradition puts it near Bethlehem. Micah 4:8 uses 'Tower of the Flock' as a poetic title for Jerusalem's royal hill. Jerome, writing around AD 390, knew of a 'tower of the flock' about a mile from Bethlehem. The exact site is unknown.

The next verse. "While Israel was living in that land" (v. 22) points back to this camp. There Reuben slept with Bilhah, who had been Rachel's servant and was Jacob's concubine. In the ancient Near East, taking a ruler's or father's concubine could be a claim to his position (compare Absalom in 2 Sam 16:21–22 and Adonijah in 1 Kgs 2:13–22). So this quiet travel notice introduces a challenge to Israel's leadership right after Rachel's death.

From the study of Genesis 35:21.

Where scholars differ

in v21

Where was Migdal Eder?

  • Near Bethlehem, between Rachel's grave and Hebron.

    The order of the narrative (Ephrath/Bethlehem in v. 19, then the tower, then Mamre/Hebron in v. 27). Jerome places a 'tower of the flock' about a mile from Bethlehem, and Christian pilgrim tradition followed him.

  • At or near Jerusalem.

    Micah 4:8 uses 'Tower of the Flock' in parallel with the Ophel, Jerusalem's royal hill. Mishnah Sheqalim 7:4 uses 'between Jerusalem and Migdal Eder' as a radius around the city. 1 Sam 10:2 puts Rachel's grave north of Jerusalem in Benjamin, which would move the whole route north.

  • Unknown, and possibly several sites with the name.

    Flock towers were common (2 Chr 26:10), so the name may describe a type of structure. No archaeological site has been securely identified.

in v21

Why does the narrator start calling Jacob 'Israel' here?

  • A deliberate literary signal.

    It comes right after Rachel's death and frames Reuben's offence as an act against 'Israel', the head of the clan (v. 22). It also leads into the list of the twelve sons who become the tribes. Commentators such as Wenham and Sarna note the significance of the timing.

  • A result of how the sources were combined.

    Source critics observe that one narrative strand prefers 'Israel' and another 'Jacob'. The alternation that follows (e.g. Gen 37; 42–46) is explained by the combining of sources rather than by intent in every instance.

in v22

Why did Reuben do it?

  • A political move: an attempt by the firstborn to claim his father's authority early.

    Biblical parallels in which taking a ruler's concubine signals a claim to succeed him (Absalom, 2 Sam 16:21–22; Abner, 2 Sam 3:7; Adonijah, 1 Kgs 2:13–25). The emphasis on 'his father's concubine' and the stripping of Reuben's firstborn rights (Gen 49:3–4) fit this.

  • A household-rivalry move: with Rachel dead, preventing Rachel's maid Bilhah from becoming Jacob's favourite over Reuben's mother Leah.

    The timing straight after Rachel's death (35:16–20). Reuben's earlier efforts for Leah (the mandrakes, 30:14). The rabbinic 'moved the bed' tradition (b. Shabbat 55b) builds on this motive.

  • Simple lust or loss of self-control.

    Jacob calls him 'unstable as water' (Gen 49:4). Testament of Reuben and Jubilees frame it as desire after seeing Bilhah bathe.

in v22

Did Reuben actually have intercourse with Bilhah?

  • Yes; the text describes intercourse.

    Shakhav with a woman is the standard term for intercourse. Gen 49:4 says 'you went up to your father's bed… defiled it.' The Septuagint, Jubilees and Testament of Reuben all assume it.

  • No; he only disturbed or moved his father's bed (a rabbinic reading).

    Babylonian Talmud Shabbat 55b and related midrash, which note that Reuben is still counted among the twelve in the very next clause. This is an interpretive defence of a tribal father rather than a reading of the wording.

in v22

Was Bilhah a willing partner?

  • The text presents it as an act done to her, possibly by force.

    The object-marker construction (shakhav 'et) also appears in the Dinah and Tamar assaults (Gen 34:2; 2 Sam 13:14). Jubilees 33 has Bilhah asleep, then crying out.

  • The text does not say; her consent is not its concern.

    The object construction also appears in non-violent contexts. The narrative frames the wrong only as against the father (49:4), which reflects its patriarchal focus rather than a statement about Bilhah.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. נָסַע, נָטָה, הָלְאָה, עֵדֶר
  • HALOT s.v. מִגְדָּל, עֵדֶר
  • Gordon J. Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Nahum Sarna, Genesis (JPS Torah Commentary)
  • Victor P. Hamilton, The Book of Genesis 18–50 (NICOT)
  • Claus Westermann, Genesis 12–36
  • Targum Pseudo-Jonathan and Targum Onqelos to Genesis 35:21
  • Mishnah Sheqalim 7:4
  • Micah 4:8; 2 Chronicles 26:10; 1 Samuel 10:2
  • Jerome, Liber de situ et nominibus locorum Hebraicorum (Latin version of Eusebius' Onomasticon)
  • Septuagint Genesis 35:16–21 (Rahlfs; NETS)
  • Alfred Edersheim, The Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah, Book II ch. 6
  • BDB s.v. שָׁכַב, פִּילֶגֶשׁ, שָׁמַע
  • HALOT s.v. פִּילֶגֶשׁ
  • Septuagint Genesis 35:22
  • Mishnah Megillah 4:10
  • Babylonian Talmud Shabbat 55b
  • Jubilees 33:1–20
  • Testament of Reuben 1–4
  • Laws of Hammurabi §158
  • Gordon Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Nahum Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Gen 35:22

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).