Genesis Chapter 35 Read as one passage

Genesis 35:16–21

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

16Later, they set out from Bethel, and while they were still some distance from Ephrath, Rachel began to give birth, and her labor was difficult. 17During her severe labor, the midwife said to her, “Do not be afraid, for you are having another son.” 18And with her last breath—for she was dying—she named him Ben-oni. But his father called him Benjamin. 19So Rachel died and was buried on the way to Ephrath (that is, Bethlehem). 20Jacob set up a pillar on her grave; it marks Rachel’s tomb to this day. 21Israel again set out and pitched his tent beyond the Tower of Eder.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelites hearing the ancestral stories, this verse began the account of how the twelfth son, Benjamin, entered the world. He was the only one of Jacob's sons born in the land of Canaan and not in Paddan-aram. The household is complete only at the cost of Rachel's life.

The verse would have worked on several levels:

  • Narrative irony. Rachel's long struggle to bear children, and her desperate cry in 30:1, find a tragic fulfillment. The hearer is left to feel it; the narrator does not comment.
  • Contrast. It comes straight after God's blessing at Bethel, "be fruitful and multiply" (35:11). Fruitfulness arrives, and with it loss. The promise goes forward through grief.
  • Landmarks and tribes. Rachel's tomb near Ephrath was a real place known to later Israelites. The story explained a familiar roadside monument and connected the "Rachel tribes" (Joseph's sons Ephraim and Manasseh, and Benjamin) with the territory where it stood. Later, Jeremiah could picture Rachel weeping for her exiled children from that region (Jer 31:15).
  • Shared experience. Every family knew women who had died in hard labor. The matriarch's death gave that common grief a place in Israel's founding story.

From the study of Genesis 35:16.

Verse by verse

  1. 16Later, they set out from Bethel, and while they were still some distance from Ephrath, Rachel began to give birth, and her labor was difficult.

    Jacob's household broke camp and moved on from Bethel, the "House of God", where God had just renewed his promise that nations would come from Jacob. They were heading south, and there was still a stretch of road ahead of them (the Hebrew uses an old measure of distance whose exact length is now lost) before they could reach Ephrath. There, out on the road, short of any town, Rachel went into labor, and the labor was hard: heavy, severe, dangerous. The Hebrew says "bear" twice ("Rachel bore, and it went hard in her bearing"), so the line stays on the labor itself.

    The first hearers would have caught the weight of it. Rachel, the beloved wife who had once cried, "Give me children, or I shall die" (30:1), and who had named Joseph "May the LORD add another son" (30:24), is finally receiving that second son. But "hard labor" was the phrase every ancient listener knew could end in a mother's death. The scene moves from the place of God's promise to a roadside birth, and it prepares for the death and roadside burial in the following verses.

    Full study →
  2. 17During her severe labor, the midwife said to her, “Do not be afraid, for you are having another son.”

    At the worst point of a dangerous labor, while Rachel was struggling hard to bring the child out, the midwife leaned in and told her: "Don't be afraid. This one is a son too. He's yours."

    The narrator has already said twice that the birth was hard (the same Hebrew root in v.16 and again here), so the reader knows the danger is real. The midwife's words are the ordinary comfort of the birthing room, said to a woman in mortal danger. But the word "too" reaches back years. When Rachel finally bore her first son after long barrenness, she named him Joseph, "May he add," and prayed, "May the LORD add to me another son" (Gen 30:24). Now the midwife tells her, in effect, that her prayer is answered: here is the other son. Rachel, who once cried to Jacob, "Give me children, or I die" (Gen 30:1), receives the son she asked for and dies in giving him birth (v.18). The good news is real, and so is the grief. The verse holds both without explaining them away.

    Full study →
  3. 18And with her last breath—for she was dying—she named him Ben-oni. But his father called him Benjamin.

    At the very moment her life was ebbing out of her, while she was drawing her last breaths (and she did die), Rachel named the boy Ben-oni: "son of my sorrow", the child of my pain and mourning. The same sounds could also mean "son of my strength", the child of the last strength I had. With her final words she gave him a name bound up with her death. But his father, Jacob, answered her with another name: Binyamin, "son of the right hand." The right hand stood for strength, favor and the place of honor, and the word also meant "the south," where this son, the only one born in the land of Canaan, came into the world. The mother's name is grief. The father's name turns that grief into blessing. The story keeps both, so that every time Benjamin's name was spoken, it also remembered the woman who died giving him life.

    Full study →
  4. 19So Rachel died and was buried on the way to Ephrath (that is, Bethlehem).

    And so Rachel died. She was buried beside the road that leads to Ephrath, the place known to us as Bethlehem.

    The Hebrew is very spare. Two quick verbs, she died and she was buried, close the scene begun in verse 18, where Rachel names her newborn "Son of my sorrow" with her last breath. The words on Rachel's own name carry no comment and no lament. The plain sentence carries the weight. Her name means "Ewe", and the woman who once cried "Give me children, or I shall die" (30:1) has died giving birth to the child she longed for.

    Was buried is passive and names no one. Burial came quickly, as it had to. The place is the point. She was laid by the road, in open country partway between Bethel and Ephrath (v. 16 says they still had "some distance" to go). She was not taken to the family cave at Machpelah where Abraham, Sarah and later Leah and Jacob lay. Jacob's beloved wife rests alone at a roadside, and in the next verse he sets up a standing stone so the spot will not be lost.

    Ephrath is the old name of the locality, closely tied to a Judahite clan. The words "that is, Bethlehem" are the narrator turning to the audience to say: you know this place, it is Bethlehem. To a Hebrew ear that name meant "House of Bread". It was the town that would later be David's home. The verse quietly pins Israel's grieving ancestral mother to a known landmark on Israel's own map.

    Full study →
  5. 20Jacob set up a pillar on her grave; it marks Rachel’s tomb to this day.

    Jacob, grieving, stood up a standing stone over the place where he had buried Rachel. Hebrew uses one root twice here, roughly "he made stand a thing-that-stands." It was not a carved column or a building. It was a single upright stone fixed in the ground, the kind of marker people in the ancient Near East put up so that a burial place, and the name of the person in it, would not be forgotten.

    Rachel had died giving birth to Benjamin on the road to Ephrath (35:16–19). She was buried where she fell, away from the family tomb at Machpelah. Without a marker her grave by the road would have disappeared. So Jacob, who had once raised stones to mark meeting God at Bethel and making a treaty with Laban, raised his last stone for the wife he loved most.

    Then the storyteller turns to his own audience: "That is the Stone of Rachel's Grave, still there today." The landmark they know by that name, he says, is the one Jacob set up. Rachel's name stays fixed on the land her children would inherit.

    Full study →
  6. 21Israel again set out and pitched his tent beyond the Tower of Eder.

    Israel pulled up his tent pegs and moved on. He stretched out his tent again, this time past the Flock Tower.

    The verse is plain, but it carries more than English shows:

    • Who is moving. For the first time the storyteller calls Jacob by his new name, Israel. This comes right after he has buried Rachel, his best-loved wife, by the road to Ephrath and set up a pillar over her grave (vv. 19–20). The grieving widower is presented as the head of the house that will become a nation. The same name appears again in the next verse, when Reuben's offence reaches him: "and Israel heard."
    • How he moves. The two verbs give the rhythm of a herder's life. First he pulls up the stakes and breaks camp. Then he stretches out the goat-hair tent over its poles at the next site. This is not a journey with a final destination. It is the next stage of the seasonal movement of a man whose wealth is on four legs.
    • Where he stops. "Eder" is not a mystery name. It is the ordinary Hebrew word for flock. Migdal-Eder means "Flock Tower", a raised lookout from which shepherds watched for wolves, lions and thieves. Jacob camps beyond it: past the tower, further south, on the road from Bethlehem-Ephrath toward Hebron, where he will finally reach his father Isaac (v. 27).

    Put together: the bereaved patriarch, now called Israel, keeps leading his household and flocks through the land promised to him. He camps near a shepherds' watchtower. This is where the next crisis in his family will happen (v. 22).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v17

    thou shalt have this son also (KJV)

    ki gam zeh lakh ben

    What we hear
    A prediction in the future tense, as if the midwife promises Rachel she will live to have and raise this son, or a vague assurance about something still to come.
    What they heard
    A Hebrew sentence with no verb: "for this one too is a son for you." It announces what is happening now. The midwife can see or tell that the child is a boy, and she points at him ("this one"). It makes no promise that Rachel will survive.
  • in v18

    as her soul was departing

    betset nafshah

    What we hear
    Her immaterial soul, a separate spiritual part of her, was leaving her body and going somewhere else.
    What they heard
    Her life or breath was going out of her: she was breathing her last and dying. Nefesh is the living, breathing self, and 'the nefesh going out' is an idiom for dying (cf. Jer 15:9, 'she has breathed out her nefesh').
  • in v20

    pillar

    maṣṣēḇâ / maṣṣeḇet

    What we hear
    A built column, often of dressed or decorated stone, that holds up a roof or stands as an architectural feature. Some readers also picture the domed building now called 'Rachel's Tomb' near Bethlehem.
    What they heard
    A single upright stone, a monolith, set on end in the ground as a marker. Here it is a grave stele keeping Rachel's name and burial place in view. It held nothing up and was no building.
  • in v21

    the Tower of Eder / Migdal Eder

    migdal ʿēder

    What we hear
    A place with an unexplained proper name, 'Eder' or 'Edar', and possibly a tall fortified tower like a castle keep.
    What they heard
    'Flock Tower': a herders' lookout or shelter from which shepherds watched their animals. 'Eder' is the everyday word for a flock, so any Hebrew listener heard the meaning.
Every word
  1. וַיִּסְעוּ

    vayyis'u · H5265

    to set out, journey · v16, v21

    Literally 'pull up' tent pegs: the ordinary word for a nomadic household breaking camp and moving on. The plural takes in Jacob's whole clan, flocks and all, not Jacob alone.

  2. מִבֵּית

    mibbet · H1008

    from Beth- (house of) · v16

    'From' plus 'house of', the first half of the place name. They are leaving the spot where God has just spoken to Jacob and renewed the promise of many descendants (35:9–15).

  3. וַיְהִי

    vayhi · H1961

    and it was · v16, v17, v18

    The common storytelling formula that opens a new scene: 'and it came about'. It slows the narrative to set up the circumstances of what happens next.

  4. עוֹד

    'od · H5750

    still, yet · v16

    'There was still...': they had not arrived. The word stresses that the birth caught them on the road, short of any town or settled help.

  5. כִּבְרַת

    kivrat · H3530

    a stretch, a measure of distance · v16

    An old word for a distance whose exact length is now unknown (it also appears in Gen 48:7 and 2 Kgs 5:19). It means a certain stretch of road, neither clearly 'a little way' nor clearly 'far'.

  6. הָאָרֶץ

    ha'arets · H776

    the land, ground · v16

    Here simply 'ground, terrain' as something you walk across: 'a stretch of ground'. It does not mean 'the earth' or 'the Land' in any theological sense.

  7. לָבוֹא

    lavo · H935

    to come, to enter · v16

    'To come to', to arrive at. Together with the words before it: 'still a stretch of ground left to reach...'

  8. אֶפְרָתָה

    'efratah · H672

    Ephrath(ah) · v16, v19

    Either the name Ephrathah or Ephrath with the Hebrew ending that means 'toward' (the stress on the middle syllable fits 'toward Ephrath'). A gloss in v.19 identifies it with Bethlehem; later the clan of Ephrathah is linked with Bethlehem (Ruth 1:2; 4:11; Micah 5:2).

  9. וַתֵּלֶד

    vatteled · H3205

    and she bore / gave birth · v16, v17

    The verb for bearing a child. The baby is not actually delivered until v.18, so here it means the start of the process: 'she went into labor'.

  10. רָחֵל

    rachel · H7354

    Rachel ("ewe") · v16, v19, v20

    Jacob's best-loved wife, for years unable to have children (30:1), who had begged for 'another son' when naming Joseph (30:24). Her name means 'ewe', a fitting name for a shepherd family.

  11. וַתְּקַשׁ

    vatteqash · H7185

    to be hard, severe · v16, v17

    From the root for 'hard, heavy, harsh' (the same root as a 'stiff' neck or a 'harsh' word). The verb form here describes her state: 'she had it hard'. Verse 17 repeats the root ('in her hard labor'), so the narrator dwells on how severe it was.

  12. וַתֹּ֨אמֶר

    vattomer · H559

    and she said · v17

    The speaker is a woman, the midwife. Hers are the only words spoken in the birth scene before Rachel's dying naming in v.18.

  13. לָ֤הּ

    lah · H9034

    to her · v17

    Addressed to Rachel herself. This is spoken comfort, said directly into her ear in labor.

  14. אַל־

    al- · H408

    do not (prohibition) · v17

    The word Hebrew uses for an immediate, urgent "don't". It is a plea for this moment, not a general rule.

  15. תִּ֣ירְאִ֔י

    tir'i · H3372

    to fear, be afraid · v17

    Feminine "you": "don't be afraid." This is plain fear of danger and death in a difficult birth, not religious awe. It is ordinary human comfort, the same thing midwives say in 1 Sam 4:20.

  16. כִּֽי־

    ki- · H3588

    for, because · v17, v18

    Gives the reason she should take heart: the news about the child.

  17. גַם־

    gam- · H1571

    also, too, even · v17

    "This one too": it points back to Joseph, Rachel's first son, whose name was her prayer for one more son (Gen 30:24). The single word says that her prayer has been answered.

  18. זֶ֥ה

    zeh · H2088

    this (one) · v17

    Masculine "this one", pointing at the child. It suggests the midwife can already see or tell that the baby is a boy.

  19. לָ֖ךְ

    lakh · H9032

    for you, to you (fem.) · v17

    "For you": the son is given to Rachel. In her rivalry with Leah, sons were the measure of a wife's standing (Gen 29–30). This one is hers.

  20. בֵּֽן׃

    ben · H1121

    son · v17

    The last and climactic word: "a son." It sets up the naming in v.18, where Rachel calls him Ben-oni ("son of my sorrow") and Jacob renames him Benjamin ("son of the right hand").

  21. בְּצֵ֤את

    betset · H3318

    in the going out · v18

    An infinitive (a verbal noun, 'the going out') with 'in/when'. It describes something happening right then: while her life was in the act of leaving. Yatsa is the ordinary verb for going out of a place, used here for the life or breath going out of the body.

  22. נַפְשָׁהּ֙

    nafshah · H5315

    her life / breath / self · v18

    Nefesh is the breathing life of a living creature, the self as alive. 'Her nefesh going out' is a Hebrew way of saying she was breathing her last. It does not mean a separate inner being leaving the body (see the study below).

  23. מֵ֔תָה

    metah · H4191

    she died · v18, v19

    The verb form presents her death as a settled fact ('she died'). In this context it covers the dying in progress, so 'she was dying' (BSB) and 'she died' (KJV, YLT) both render it faithfully. Verse 19 then tells the death as a narrative event.

  24. וַתִּקְרָ֥א

    vattiqra · H7121

    and she called · v18

    The usual naming verb. Throughout Genesis 29–30 Rachel and Leah name every one of Jacob's sons; Rachel does so here one last time, with her final breath.

  25. שְׁמ֖וֹ

    shemo · H8034

    his name · v18

    'She called his name' is the full naming formula. In Israel a name was taken as a statement about the child's circumstances or destiny, not just a label.

  26. בֶּן־

    ben- · H1126

    son of · v18

    The first part of the name: 'son of'. In Hebrew names 'son of X' can mean 'son marked by X' or 'son belonging to X'. The supplied data treats Ben-oni as one proper name (H1126); 'ben' itself is the common word for son (H1121).

  27. וְאָבִ֖יו

    ve'aviv · H1

    and his father · v18

    Hebrew puts the subject first here ('but his father…') to set Jacob's action against Rachel's. It is a contrast: she named him one thing, his father named him another.

  28. ל֥וֹ

    lo

    to him / him · v18

    'Called to him' is an ordinary Hebrew way of saying 'named him'. The supplied data tags it with a placeholder number (H9033) for the preposition with a suffix.

  29. בִנְיָמִֽין׃

    Vinyamin · H1144

    Benjamin, 'son of the right hand' · v18

    'Son of the right (hand)', and also 'son of the south', since in Hebrew 'right' also meant south when you faced east. The right hand stood for strength, favor and the place of honor, so the name turns a name of grief into a name of good fortune.

  30. וַתִּקָּבֵר֙

    vattiqqāvēr · H6912

    to bury · v19

    "And she was buried." The verb is passive and names no one who did the burying, though v. 20 shows Jacob marking the grave. Burial follows death straight away, as it did in that climate and culture.

  31. בְּדֶ֣רֶךְ

    bəderekh · H1870

    road, way, journey · v19

    "On the road (of / to)". Rachel is buried beside the route the family was travelling, out in open country, and not in an ancestral family tomb. Verse 16 has already said they were still some distance from Ephrath.

  32. הִ֖וא

    hiwʾ (read hîʾ) · H1931

    she / it / that · v19, v20

    "That is". A feminine pronoun pointing back to Ephrath (Hebrew treats towns as feminine). It brings in a note for the reader that identifies the old name with a place the audience knew.

  33. בֵּ֥ית

    Bêt · H1035

    house of · v19

    The first half of the place name Bethlehem: "house (of)". Many town names began with "house of", for example Bethel, Beth-shemesh and Beth-horon.

  34. וַיַּצֵּ֧ב

    wayyaṣṣēḇ · H5324

    and he set up, erected · v20

    The causative form of the verb 'to stand': Jacob made a stone stand upright. It comes from the same root as the noun 'standing stone' that follows, so the Hebrew says roughly 'Jacob stood up a standing stone.'

  35. יַעֲקֹ֛ב

    yaʿăqōḇ · H3290

    Jacob · v20

    Jacob is named as the one who acts, even though he was renamed Israel just before (35:10) and the next verse calls him 'Israel.' The mourning husband is pictured as the man Jacob.

  36. מַצֵּבָ֖ה

    maṣṣēḇâ · H4676

    standing stone, stele · v20

    A single upright stone set on end as a marker. Here it is a grave marker, the kind of memorial stone that kept a burial place and a name visible in the landscape.

  37. עַל־

    ʿal · H5921A

    upon, over · v20

    The stone stood on top of or beside the grave and marked the spot. It does not need to mean the stone lay flat on the body.

  38. קְבֻרָתָ֑הּ

    qəḇurātāh · H6900

    burial, grave · v20

    'Her burial place.' The word can mean the act of burying or the grave itself. Here it is the place where she was laid by the road to Ephrath (35:19).

  39. מַצֶּ֥בֶת

    maṣṣeḇet · H4678

    pillar, standing stone (of) · v20

    The same word for 'standing stone' in its linked form, 'the standing stone of.' It is now almost a place name: 'the Stone of Rachel's Grave.'

  40. עַד־

    ʿad · H5704

    until, up to · v20

    Carries the stone's existence forward from Jacob's day into the time of the narrator and his hearers.

  41. הַיּֽוֹם׃

    hayyôm · H3117L

    the day; today · v20

    'The day,' meaning 'today.' The storyteller speaks from a later time and points to a marker his audience could still see or knew of.

  42. יִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל

    yiśrāʾēl · H3478

    Israel · v21

    The man Jacob, not yet the nation. This is the first time the narrator uses his new name (given in 32:28 and confirmed in 35:10). It does so right after Rachel's death, and it keeps the name through v. 22.

  43. וַיֵּ֣ט

    wayyēṭ · H5186

    stretch out, spread, pitch · v21

    To stretch out tent cloth over poles and pull the ropes tight. Together with the first verb it gives the herder's rhythm of life: pull up the pegs, then stretch the tent out somewhere new.

  44. אָֽהֳל֔וֹ

    ʾohŏlô · H0168

    tent · v21

    His tent, which here stands for his whole camp. A herder's tent was woven from black goat hair and was the centre of the household. The written consonants have an older spelling of 'his'.

  45. מֵהָ֖לְאָה

    mēhālʾāh · H1973

    further on, beyond · v21

    Literally 'from further on', a fixed way of saying 'beyond'. He camps on the far side of the tower, as seen from the direction he was travelling, that is, south of it.

  46. לְמִגְדַּל־

    lĕmigdal- · H4029

    tower (of) · v21

    A migdal is a tower or raised lookout. Here the l- does not mean 'to'; together with the previous word it gives 'beyond'. The tower is the landmark that fixes where the camp was.

The world behind it

Moving south through the hill country. After the events at Shechem (ch. 34), Jacob goes to Bethel (about 17 km / 11 miles north of Jerusalem), then moves south toward Hebron, where his father Isaac lives (35:27). The route follows the north–south ridge road. Ephrath/Bethlehem lies about 9 km south of Jerusalem. A clan on the move with flocks travels slowly and camps in the open between towns.

Childbirth in the ancient world. Birth took place at home among women, with a midwife (v.17 shows one was travelling with the household). Death in childbirth was common. A "hard" labor (probably an obstructed or abnormal delivery) was the situation ancient women most feared, and midwives could do little about it. The midwife's words in v.17, "Do not be afraid", are the standard comfort spoken at a dying mother's bedside (compare 1 Sam 4:20, where Phinehas's wife dies in childbirth after the same words).

Why the place matters. Rachel dies "on the way" and is buried by the road (35:19–20; 48:7), not in the family tomb at Machpelah where Abraham, Sarah, Isaac, Rebekah and later Leah lie (49:31). The detail "still a stretch of land to go" explains why: she died before they arrived anywhere. Her roadside pillar became a known landmark (35:20, "to this day"; 1 Sam 10:2).

From the study of Genesis 35:16.

Where scholars differ

in v16

What distance is a kivrah?

  • A specific but now-lost measure, probably moderate (a few kilometres or a couple of hours' walk).

    All three uses are in the fixed phrase 'a kivrah of land', which suggests a standard unit. In 2 Kgs 5:19–21 Gehazi catches Naaman's chariot after Naaman has gone 'a kivrah'. Possible but unproven links to Akkadian distance terms.

  • A general 'short distance'.

    KJV tradition ('a little way'). The context suggests they were close to Ephrath. Rashi records this as one opinion.

  • Not a distance but a season (spring, when the soil is loose like a sieve).

    Genesis Rabbah and Rashi, followed by Jerome's Vulgate 'verno tempore'. This depends on a wordplay with kevarah 'sieve' and is generally considered a later interpretation, not the original meaning.

in v16

Where was Ephrath, and so where was Rachel's tomb?

  • Ephrath is Bethlehem, south of Jerusalem, where the traditional Rachel's Tomb stands.

    The explanatory notes in Gen 35:19 and 48:7 ('that is, Bethlehem'); the Ephrathite clan of Bethlehem (Ruth 1:2; Micah 5:2); Matthew 2:18; continuous tradition since late antiquity.

  • Ephrath was a place north of Jerusalem on Benjamin's border, and the 'that is, Bethlehem' notes are a later scribal identification.

    1 Sam 10:2 puts Rachel's tomb 'in the territory of Benjamin at Zelzah'. Jer 31:15 has Rachel weeping in Ramah (north of Jerusalem). Benjamin's tribal territory lay north of Jerusalem. Gen 35:16 puts the event only 'a stretch' beyond Bethel, on the way south.

in v16

Does the narrator intend a reason for Rachel's death?

  • It fulfills Jacob's unwitting oath in 31:32 ('whoever has your gods shall not live'), since Rachel had stolen Laban's household gods.

    Some ancient Jewish interpreters (e.g. Genesis Rabbah) and some modern readers note the verbal link, and the household gods were buried just before this (35:2–4).

  • No cause is given. The death is narrated as tragedy and as the painful irony of 30:1, not as punishment.

    The text itself draws no link. The scene focuses on the birth, the son's naming and the burial. Most modern commentators (e.g. Wenham, Sarna) are cautious about reading in a penalty.

in v17

Is the child already born when the midwife speaks, or is she encouraging Rachel mid-labor?

  • The child is delivered or emerging, and the midwife is announcing his sex.

    The pointing word "this one" (zeh) and the verbless sentence ("this one too is a son for you") sound like an announcement on seeing the child. The parallel in 1 Sam 4:20 ("you have borne a son") comes after the birth. In v.18 Rachel names the child as she dies, so he has been born by then.

  • She is speaking during the final struggle to encourage Rachel to push through, perhaps once the child is partly visible or by anticipation.

    The time phrase "in her having hard labor, in her bearing" places the words during the labor, not after it. The Vulgate and the KJV, following it, read the sentence as future ("you will have"). Hebrew sentences without a verb allow either timing.

in v17

Does "this one too" deliberately echo Rachel's prayer at Joseph's naming (Gen 30:24)?

  • Yes. The narrator means the reader to hear the answer to "may the LORD add to me another son."

    The two verses share key words (ben, "son"; the idea of adding, "another" / "also"), and both concern Rachel's sons. Rachel's earlier cry "Give me children, or I die" (30:1) makes the irony of this scene pointed. Many commentators (Sarna, Wenham, Hamilton) note the link.

  • "Also" may simply mean "in addition to the one you already have," a natural thing for a midwife to say, with no deliberate literary echo.

    gam is a very common word, and the vocabulary does not match exactly (30:24 has acher, "another", not gam). Even so, the reference to Joseph is unavoidable either way. The debate is about how deliberate the echo of the prayer is.

in v18

What did Rachel mean by Ben-oni: 'son of my sorrow' or 'son of my strength'?

  • 'Son of my sorrow / trouble / mourning' (from 'aven)

    Fits the deathbed setting. 'Aven is used of mourning in Deut 26:14 and Hos 9:4. Both the LXX ('son of my pain') and the Vulgate ('son of my sorrow') read it this way. Jacob's renaming makes most sense if the first name sounded ill-omened. This is the majority view.

  • 'Son of my strength / vigor' (from 'on), or a deliberate double meaning

    The form אוֹנִי is spelled exactly like 'my strength' in Gen 49:3. On this reading Rachel names him the child of her last strength, and Jacob's 'son of the right hand' (the hand of strength) affirms and clarifies that sense rather than overturning it. Some medieval Jewish commentators (often cited: Nachmanides) developed this line. It is a minority view, but the spelling makes it genuinely possible.

in v18

What does Jacob's 'Benjamin' mean: 'son of the right hand' or 'son of the south'?

  • 'Son of the right hand': favor, strength, good fortune

    The right hand stands for strength and blessing throughout the Hebrew Bible (Gen 48:13–19; Exod 15:6; Ps 110:1). It makes a clear positive answer to an ill-omened name. The Vulgate glosses it this way.

  • 'Son of the south'

    Yamin also means 'south'. Benjamin was the only son born in Canaan, south of Paddan-aram. Mari texts name a group 'Binu-Yamina' (sons of the south/right) opposite 'Binu-Sim'al' (sons of the north/left). Medieval Jewish commentators such as Rashi offered this sense. Both meanings may be heard at once, since the word itself holds both.

in v18

Is Rachel's death meant to recall Jacob's rash oath about the stolen household gods (Gen 31:32)?

  • Yes, a deliberate literary link

    Jacob said that whoever had Laban's gods 'shall not live'. Rachel had secretly taken them (31:19, 32), and she is the one who dies on the journey. Ancient Jewish interpretation (e.g., in midrashic tradition) drew this connection.

  • No explicit link is made

    Genesis 35 never mentions the oath. The idols were buried at Shechem before this (35:2–4), and the text presents the death simply as the tragedy of a hard labor.

in v19

Where was Rachel's grave: near Bethlehem (south of Jerusalem) or in Benjamin (north of Jerusalem)?

  • Near Bethlehem, as the note in Gen 35:19 and 48:7 states.

    Both Genesis passages identify Ephrath with Bethlehem. Ruth 4:11, Micah 5:2 and 1 Chr 4:4 firmly link Ephrathah with Bethlehem. Matthew 2:18 connects Rachel's weeping with Bethlehem. A tomb near Bethlehem has been venerated continuously since at least the 4th century AD (Bordeaux Pilgrim; Eusebius).

  • North of Jerusalem in Benjamin's territory. On this view "that is, Bethlehem" is a later identification.

    In 1 Sam 10:2 Samuel tells Saul he will meet men "by Rachel's tomb in the territory of Benjamin at Zelzah" on a route that seems to run north of Jerusalem. In Jer 31:15 Rachel's voice is heard "in Ramah", a Benjaminite town about 8 km north of Jerusalem. The Ephrathah clan is also linked with Kiriath-jearim (1 Chr 2:50; Ps 132:6), so "Ephrath" may once have named a wider district that later readers narrowed to Bethlehem.

  • The texts can be reconciled.

    Some argue that Ephrath was a district stretching toward Benjamin's border, that the route in 1 Sam 10 is uncertain, and that Ramah in Jeremiah is a poetic setting (Ramah was a gathering point for exiles, Jer 40:1) rather than the grave site. On this view the Genesis note does not contradict the other texts.

in v19

Is the -āh on אֶפְרָתָה a "toward" ending or part of the name?

  • It is the Hebrew "toward" ending: "the road toward Ephrath".

    This ending is common on place names after verbs or nouns of motion. Verse 16 "to come to Ephrath" may use the same form.

  • It is the longer form of the name, Ephrathah.

    "Ephrathah" occurs where no "toward" sense fits (Ruth 4:11; Micah 5:2; 1 Chr 2:50). The translation is the same either way.

in v20

Where was Rachel's grave: near Bethlehem in Judah, or north of Jerusalem in Benjamin?

  • Near Bethlehem, as Genesis's own note says.

    Gen 35:19 and 48:7 place the burial 'on the way to Ephrath (that is, Bethlehem).' Ephrathah is tied to Bethlehem in Ruth 4:11 and Micah 5:2. Matthew 2:18 links Rachel's weeping with Bethlehem. Christian tradition points to the site north of Bethlehem from at least the 4th century (the Bordeaux Pilgrim, 333 CE; Eusebius's Onomasticon), and the traditional shrine stands there.

  • North of Jerusalem, on the border of Benjamin, with 'that is, Bethlehem' a later explanatory note.

    1 Sam 10:2 places Rachel's tomb 'in the territory of Benjamin at Zelzah,' on Saul's route home from Ramah to Gibeah. Jer 31:15 has Rachel weeping in Ramah (Benjaminite territory). Rachel is the mother of Benjamin, and Gen 35:16 says they were still 'some distance' from Ephrath. Many critical commentators therefore suggest an Ephrath in Benjamin, with the Bethlehem identification added later.

in v20

Was the grave stone purely commemorative, or connected to care for the dead?

  • Simply a memorial and grave marker.

    The text says only that it marks the grave 'to this day.' Absalom's stone (2 Sam 18:18) is explained as keeping a name in memory. Genesis does not describe any offerings at the stone.

  • Part of a wider ancient Near Eastern practice of honouring dead ancestors, possibly including rites at the stone.

    Ugaritic texts (Aqhat) list setting up an ancestral stele among a son's duties alongside other rites for the dead. Phoenician funerary stelae and Israelite family-tomb customs suggest grave markers were places of remembrance and sometimes offerings (compare Deut 26:14, which forbids giving tithe food 'to the dead'). Some scholars, such as K. van der Toorn, read patriarchal grave stones in this light. Genesis 35:20 itself does not say this.

in v21

Where was Migdal Eder?

  • Near Bethlehem, between Rachel's grave and Hebron.

    The order of the narrative (Ephrath/Bethlehem in v. 19, then the tower, then Mamre/Hebron in v. 27). Jerome places a 'tower of the flock' about a mile from Bethlehem, and Christian pilgrim tradition followed him.

  • At or near Jerusalem.

    Micah 4:8 uses 'Tower of the Flock' in parallel with the Ophel, Jerusalem's royal hill. Mishnah Sheqalim 7:4 uses 'between Jerusalem and Migdal Eder' as a radius around the city. 1 Sam 10:2 puts Rachel's grave north of Jerusalem in Benjamin, which would move the whole route north.

  • Unknown, and possibly several sites with the name.

    Flock towers were common (2 Chr 26:10), so the name may describe a type of structure. No archaeological site has been securely identified.

in v21

Why does the narrator start calling Jacob 'Israel' here?

  • A deliberate literary signal.

    It comes right after Rachel's death and frames Reuben's offence as an act against 'Israel', the head of the clan (v. 22). It also leads into the list of the twelve sons who become the tribes. Commentators such as Wenham and Sarna note the significance of the timing.

  • A result of how the sources were combined.

    Source critics observe that one narrative strand prefers 'Israel' and another 'Jacob'. The alternation that follows (e.g. Gen 37; 42–46) is explained by the combining of sources rather than by intent in every instance.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. כִּבְרָה
  • HALOT s.v. כִּבְרָה
  • HALOT s.v. קשׁה
  • Septuagint, Genesis 35:16; 48:7
  • Vulgate, Genesis 35:16; 48:7
  • Genesis Rabbah 82
  • Rashi on Genesis 35:16
  • G. J. Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • N. M. Sarna, Genesis (JPS Torah Commentary)
  • C. Westermann, Genesis 12–36
  • BDB s.v. קָשָׁה (Hiphil: 'have hard labor', Gen 35:17)
  • BDB / HALOT s.v. יָלַד (Piel participle מְיַלֶּדֶת 'midwife')
  • HALOT s.v. גַּם
  • Septuagint, Genesis 35:16–17 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Genesis 35:16–17
  • N. Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis (1989), on 35:16–18
  • G. Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (WBC 2, 1994), on 35:16–20
  • V. Hamilton, The Book of Genesis 18–50 (NICOT, 1995), on 35:16–20
  • Rashi on Genesis 35:17; Genesis Rabbah 82
  • Comparison text: 1 Samuel 4:19–21
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. נֶפֶשׁ
  • HALOT s.v. אָוֶן and אוֹן
  • HALOT s.v. בִּנְיָמִין, יָמִין
  • Septuagint, Genesis 35:18 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Genesis 35:18
  • Mari archives: references to the Binu-Yamina (as discussed in standard Genesis commentaries, e.g., Wenham, Genesis 16–50, WBC; Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis)
  • Rashi and Nachmanides on Genesis 35:18
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Genesis 35:16–20
  • BDB s.v. דֶּרֶךְ, אֶפְרָת, בֵּית לֶחֶם, רָחֵל
  • HALOT s.v. אֶפְרָת / אֶפְרָתָה, בֵּית לֶחֶם, קבר
  • C. Westermann, Genesis 12–36 (Continental Commentary)
  • Anchor Bible Dictionary, articles "Ephrathah", "Bethlehem", "Rachel's Tomb"
  • Eusebius, Onomasticon (on Ephratha/Bethlehem)
  • Itinerarium Burdigalense (Bordeaux Pilgrim, AD 333)
  • Septuagint, Genesis 35:16–21; 48:7
  • Amarna letter EA 290 (disputed reading of a town near Jerusalem)
  • BDB s.v. מַצֵּבָה, נָצַב, קְבוּרָה
  • HALOT s.v. מַצֵּבָה
  • Septuagint, Genesis 35:20 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Genesis 35:20
  • B. S. Childs, "A Study of the Formula 'Until This Day'," JBL 82 (1963)
  • V. P. Hamilton, The Book of Genesis 18–50 (NICOT)
  • KTU 1.17 I (Ugaritic Aqhat epic, duties of the son)
  • Kanaanäische und aramäische Inschriften (KAI), Phoenician mṣbt stelae
  • K. van der Toorn, Family Religion in Babylonia, Syria and Israel
  • Eusebius, Onomasticon; Itinerarium Burdigalense (Bordeaux Pilgrim)
  • BDB s.v. נָסַע, נָטָה, הָלְאָה, עֵדֶר
  • HALOT s.v. מִגְדָּל, עֵדֶר
  • Gordon J. Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Nahum Sarna, Genesis (JPS Torah Commentary)
  • Victor P. Hamilton, The Book of Genesis 18–50 (NICOT)
  • Claus Westermann, Genesis 12–36
  • Targum Pseudo-Jonathan and Targum Onqelos to Genesis 35:21
  • Mishnah Sheqalim 7:4
  • Micah 4:8; 2 Chronicles 26:10; 1 Samuel 10:2
  • Jerome, Liber de situ et nominibus locorum Hebraicorum (Latin version of Eusebius' Onomasticon)
  • Septuagint Genesis 35:16–21 (Rahlfs; NETS)
  • Alfred Edersheim, The Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah, Book II ch. 6

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).