Isaiah Chapter 19 Read as one passage

Isaiah 19:8–10

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

8Then the fishermen will mourn, all who cast a hook into the Nile will lament, and those who spread nets on the waters will pine away. 9The workers in flax will be dismayed, and the weavers of fine linen will turn pale. 10The workers in cloth will be dejected, and all the hired workers will be sick at heart.

What the first hearers heard

To Judeans in Isaiah's time, this verse painted a scene they could picture, since many knew Egypt by reputation or by trade. The Nile fishing grounds that fed a nation were falling silent, and the men who worked them were holding a funeral for their trade.

The message landed on several levels:

  • Egypt is not a safe refuge. Judah's politicians wanted an Egyptian alliance. Isaiah shows the source of Egypt's strength, its river, giving out. The fishermen here, and the flax workers and weavers in v. 9, are the visible signs of a country unable to save itself.
  • Israel's God rules Egypt's river. In Egypt the Nile flood was tied to the gods and to Pharaoh's role in keeping cosmic order. Here the drying comes as part of the LORD's coming against Egypt (v. 1). The dying fish would also call up the Exodus plagues.
  • The language of Israel's own grief applied to Egypt. "Lament and mourn" was the formula Isaiah had used for Jerusalem's fall (3:26), and "mourn… wither" is the language of drought-stricken land (24:4; 33:9). Egypt is put under the same judgment-language as Israel.

It also matters what comes later in the chapter. Isaiah 19 does not end in ruin. Verses 18–25 envision Egypt turning to the LORD, an altar to him in Egypt, and the startling line "Blessed be Egypt my people" (v. 25). The fishermen's grief belongs to a judgment that is not the oracle's last word.

From the study of Isaiah 19:8.

Verse by verse

  1. 8Then the fishermen will mourn, all who cast a hook into the Nile will lament, and those who spread nets on the waters will pine away.

    "And the fishermen will raise their moaning lament; every man who throws his hook into the Nile will go into mourning; and the crews who spread their great nets across the water will wilt and wither away."

    The verse belongs to a picture of Egypt's river failing (v. 5–10). The Nile drops, its canals go foul, the reeds and riverside fields dry up and blow away (v. 7). Now the people who lived off the river take their turn. Isaiah names the fishing trade as a whole ("the fishermen") and then splits it in two: the hook fishers and the net crews. That covers everyone, from the poor man with a line to the organised boat teams.

    The three verbs climb. First comes a voiced lament, the moaning of grief. Then comes mourning, which in that world meant public funeral customs: wailing, torn clothes, sackcloth, dust. The livelihood is treated as a dead relative. Last, the net men wither. Hebrew uses that verb mostly for drooping vines and dried-out fields, the same fate verse 7 gave the Nile reeds. With the river gone, the men themselves wilt like the plants around them. In Hebrew the three verbs all begin with the same throat sound ('anu… 'avlu… 'umlalu), which strings the grief together by sound.

    For an Israelite listener the words also carried echoes. "Lament and mourn" is the very pair Isaiah used for Jerusalem's ruined gates (Isaiah 3:26). Egypt's fish dying in the Nile recalls the Exodus plague (Exodus 7:21). Egypt, the great power Judah was tempted to trust, was itself completely dependent on a river that the God of Israel could dry up.

    Full study →
  2. 9The workers in flax will be dismayed, and the weavers of fine linen will turn pale.

    And they will be publicly shamed — those who work the flax, the fine combed fibre, and those who weave the white linen.

    The verse continues a chain of disasters that start with the Nile drying up (vv. 5–7). The flood stops, the reeds and the riverside fields wither, the fishermen mourn (v. 8). Now the blow lands on Egypt's proudest industry. Flax was the plant behind Egyptian linen, prized across the ancient world. Combed refers to the skilled step of pulling the fibre through toothed combs until only the fine strands remain. White stuff is the bleached linen that came off the looms, the cloth of priests, nobles and export trade.

    "Be ashamed" here is not a guilty conscience. It is the humiliation of having your livelihood vanish in front of everyone, when the thing you relied on fails you. KJV's "confounded" meant this in 1611: thrown into ruin and confusion. The future tense continues the prophet's forecast: this will happen.

    The final word carries an image of whiteness either way. In the traditional Hebrew text the weavers make white cloth. In the oldest surviving Isaiah manuscript, from Qumran, they themselves "turn white", pale with dread. The workers of white linen go white in the face.

    Full study →
  3. 10The workers in cloth will be dejected, and all the hired workers will be sick at heart.

    "Egypt's supports (or: her weavers) will be smashed to pieces, and everyone who lives on wages will be sick to the core of their being."

    This is the last line of a picture of Egypt's economy falling apart because the Nile has failed (vv. 5–10). The river dries up, the canals stink, and the reeds wither. The fishermen mourn (v. 8). The flax-workers and the weavers of fine white linen go pale (v. 9). Then this verse finishes the scene. Its first line uses a rare word. It may mean Egypt's foundations or pillars, the leading men who hold the country up. It may mean her weavers, the people who string the loom. If it means pillars, the verse runs from the top of society to the bottom. If it means weavers, it completes the roll-call of ruined trades. Either way the people are crushed, a word for something ground to pieces, and also for a broken spirit. In the second line the hired labourers, who own nothing and eat what they earn each day, are grieved in their nefesh. That is despair in the self that hungers and fears for its life, because the wage that fed them has disappeared. The verse shows the whole working nation of Egypt, from its supporting pillars to its day-labourers, ruined together once the river they all depended on stops.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v8

    mourn

    'āval

    What we hear
    To feel sad inwardly, to grieve privately.
    What they heard
    To carry out mourning: public, audible customs of grief such as wailing, sackcloth, dust and torn garments, as at a funeral.
  • in v8

    languish / pine away

    'umlal (from 'āmal)

    What we hear
    To be stuck and neglected ('languishing in prison'), to lack energy, or to yearn emotionally ('pine for').
    What they heard
    To wilt, droop and wither like a plant without water. The verb mostly describes vines, crops and land in drought.
  • in v8

    brooks (KJV)

    ye'ōr

    What we hear
    Small streams or creeks.
    What they heard
    The Nile, Egypt's one great river, and its canals.
  • in v8

    angle (KJV)

    ḥakkāh

    What we hear
    A geometric angle or corner.
    What they heard
    A fishhook. Early modern English 'angle' meant a hook, which is where 'angler' comes from.
  • in v9

    ashamed / confounded

    bôš

    What we hear
    "Ashamed" sounds like feeling guilty about wrongdoing. "Confounded" sounds like being puzzled or confused.
    What they heard
    Publicly humiliated and disappointed. The workers lose face because the thing they relied on, the Nile and their trade, has failed. No moral fault is implied.
  • in v9

    weavers of white cotton (ESV)

    ḥôrāy

    What we hear
    Egyptian weavers working cotton, the familiar modern fabric.
    What they heard
    Almost certainly white (bleached) linen. Flax-linen was Egypt's textile, and cotton does not appear to have been a significant Egyptian crop in Isaiah's day. The Septuagint renders the word "fine linen (byssus)".
  • in v9

    networks (KJV, YLT)

    ḥôrāy

    What we hear
    Netting or mesh, which a reader might even link to the fishermen's nets in v. 8.
    What they heard
    White cloth. Or, in the Qumran reading, "they grow pale".
  • in v10

    soul ("grieved in soul")

    nefesh

    What we hear
    An inner spiritual part of a person, separate from the body, that is sad.
    What they heard
    The whole living self as a creature with needs: throat, appetite, life. 'Grieved of nefesh' is deep, bodily distress at the level of survival.
  • in v10

    pillars / foundations

    shatot

    What we hear
    Literal stone columns or the foundations of buildings being knocked down.
    What they heard
    Either the 'supports' of society, its leading men (as in Psalm 11:3), or possibly 'weavers.' The masculine plural 'crushed' that goes with it points to people.
Every word
  1. וְאָנוּ֙

    ve'ānû · H0578

    to lament, groan · v8

    A rare verb for voiced grief: moaning, keening. The form looks past ('and they lamented') but with the 'and' in front it points forward in prophecy: 'and they will lament.' It opens the verse with the sound of grief.

  2. הַדַּיָּגִ֔ים

    haddayyāgîm · H1771

    fisherman · v8

    Fishermen as a trade, people who live by fishing. 'The fishermen' names the whole group first. The next two lines split it into hook fishers and net fishers.

  3. וְאָ֣בְל֔וּ

    ve'āvlû · H0056

    to mourn · v8

    The usual Hebrew verb for observing mourning: the public customs of grief such as wailing, torn clothes, sackcloth and dust. It is not just a private feeling. Paired with 'lament', it makes a fixed couple also found in Isaiah 3:26.

  4. כָּל־

    kol- · H3605

    all, every · v8, v10

    'All' who fish with hooks. Nobody in the trade escapes. It stresses that the collapse is total.

  5. מַשְׁלִיכֵ֥י

    mashlîkhê · H7993

    to throw, cast · v8

    A participle (a verb used as a noun): 'the casters', meaning those who habitually throw out a line. It describes them by what they do every day.

  6. בַיְא֖וֹר

    vay'ôr · H2975

    Nile, river (channel) · v8

    'Into the Nile.' The word was borrowed from Egyptian and in Hebrew almost always means the Nile or its branches and canals. The river whose drying v. 5–7 described is the fishermen's whole workplace.

  7. חַכָּ֑ה

    ḥakkāh · H2443

    fishhook · v8

    A fishhook on a line. In Hebrew it comes at the end of its clause, after 'into the Nile': 'casters, into the Nile, of a hook.' This is the small-scale, often one-man way of fishing.

  8. וּפֹרְשֵׂ֥י

    ûfōrsê · H6566

    to spread out · v8

    'And the spreaders of': a participle for those who spread out nets. The verb is used for spreading wings, hands or cloth, and here for opening a net across the water.

  9. מִכְמֹ֛רֶת

    mikhmōret · H4365

    fishing net, seine · v8

    A large fishing net, probably a seine (a long net dragged through the water) or a casting net. It stands for the larger, organised side of the industry, next to the hook.

  10. עַל־

    'al- · H5921

    upon, over · v8

    'Upon' the water. It pictures the net laid out over the surface.

  11. פְּנֵי־

    pnê- · H6440

    face, surface · v8

    Literally 'face of'. 'The face of the waters' is a common Hebrew phrase for the surface (compare Genesis 1:2).

  12. מַ֖יִם

    mayim · H4325

    water(s) · v8

    The waters the nets once spread over. In context they are shrinking (v. 5–6), which is why the work fails.

  13. אֻמְלָֽלוּ׃

    'umlālû · H0535

    to wither, be feeble, languish · v8

    A verb mostly used for plants and fields that wilt and droop. The net fishermen 'wither' just as the reeds and crops did in v. 7. The people end up sharing the fate of the dried-up vegetation.

  14. וּבֹ֛שׁוּ

    ûbōšû · H954

    be ashamed, be put to shame · v9

    "And they will be put to shame." The verb form carries on the string of future events in vv. 5–8. It means public failure and disappointment: what these people relied on lets them down. It is not about guilt. It governs both groups in the verse.

  15. עֹבְדֵ֥י

    ʿōbədê · H5647

    work, serve, till · v9

    "Workers of": a participle (a verb used as a noun) tied to the next word, so it means the people who work flax for a living. These are the labourers and craftsmen of Egypt's linen industry.

  16. פִשְׁתִּ֖ים

    pištîm · H6593

    flax, linen · v9

    Flax, the plant and its fibre, here as the raw material of linen. The plural refers to the stalks or the fibre as a commodity. Flax was Egypt's signature crop and depended entirely on the Nile.

  17. שְׂרִיק֑וֹת

    śərîqôt · H8305

    combed, hackled · v9

    "Combed" or "hackled": flax fibre drawn through toothed combs to separate the fine strands for spinning. The word occurs only here. It marks the high-value end of the process, not just raw stalks.

  18. וְאֹרְגִ֖ים

    wəʾōrəgîm · H707

    weave; weaver · v9

    "And weavers": the people who turn spun thread into cloth on the loom. They are the last link in the chain that starts with the river.

  19. חוֹרָֽי׃

    ḥôrāy · H2355

    white cloth · v9

    "White stuff", most likely bleached white linen. It is related to ḥûr, the white fabric of Esther 1:6 and 8:15. The Qumran scroll reads it instead as a verb, "they grow pale". Either way the picture is whiteness: white cloth, or white faces.

  20. וְהָי֥וּ

    vehayu · H1961

    and they will be · v10

    This form points to the future: 'and they shall be.' It carries on the chain of things that will happen as the Nile fails (vv. 5–9). The 'and' ties this verse to the list of ruined trades just before it.

  21. שָׁתֹתֶ֖יהָ

    shatoteha · H8356

    foundations, pillars (disputed: 'weavers') · v10

    'Her shatot.' 'Her' is Egypt, which Hebrew treats as feminine. The word is very rare. It means either 'foundations/pillars,' a picture for the leading men who hold the country up (compare Psalm 11:3), or 'weavers,' which would carry on the textile workers of v. 9. The adjective that goes with it is masculine plural, which suggests people are meant, not literal stonework.

  22. מְדֻכָּאִ֑ים

    medukka'im · H1792

    crushed, broken in pieces · v10

    A passive form: 'having been crushed,' 'pulverized.' The verb is used for grinding something to bits and also for a crushed spirit, so it covers economic ruin and inner collapse together.

  23. עֹ֥שֵׂי

    'osei · H6213A

    doers, makers of · v10

    'Makers of …' or 'those who earn …'. Bound to the next word, it makes a set phrase for people who work for pay.

  24. שֶׂ֖כֶר

    sekher · H7938

    wages, hire · v10

    'Wage(s).' With the word before, 'wage-makers,' that is, hired labourers who live on daily pay and have no land or stores to fall back on. The ancient Greek translators read the same consonants as 'beer.'

  25. אַגְמֵי־

    'agmei · H99

    grieved, sad · v10

    'Grieved of …'. This adjective appears only here. It is almost certainly related to the verb in Job 30:25, 'my soul grieved' (spelled with a different first letter). The Vulgate and KJV instead read a similar-looking noun meaning 'pools, marshes.'

  26. נָֽפֶשׁ׃

    nafesh · H5315G

    soul, life, self, throat, appetite · v10

    'Grieved of nefesh' means sick at heart, distressed in their whole living self. This is the self that hungers and fears for its life, which fits people whose livelihood has just vanished. It does not mean an immaterial soul as distinct from the body.

The world behind it

Isaiah 19 is a "burden" or oracle concerning Egypt (v. 1). It is one of a series of oracles against the nations (Isaiah 13–23). Verses 1–4 describe Egypt's gods trembling, civil war, and handover to a "harsh master." Verses 5–10 describe ecological and economic collapse. Verses 11–15 mock Pharaoh's famous wise counsellors.

Egypt lived or died by the Nile. Almost no rain fell. All farming, food and wealth depended on the yearly flood. Fish from the river, its Delta marshes and the Faiyum lake were a staple for ordinary Egyptians, eaten fresh, dried and salted. Israel remembered this: "We remember the fish we ate in Egypt for nothing" (Numbers 11:5). Herodotus (5th century BC) reports that fish from Lake Moeris brought the royal treasury a silver talent a day in season (Histories 2.149). Egyptian tomb art shows both hook-and-line fishing and large seines hauled by teams from papyrus boats, which are the two methods this verse names.

Egyptians themselves feared exactly this scenario. The Egyptian Prophecy of Neferti describes a time of chaos when "the river of Egypt is empty, the water is crossed on foot." The Admonitions of Ipuwer paints a similar collapse. A failed Nile meant cosmic and political disorder. Isaiah uses that recognisable nightmare but credits it to Israel's God rather than to the Nile god Hapi or to Pharaoh's failure.

Why Judah cared. In Isaiah's day (late 8th century BC), Judah's leaders kept looking to Egypt, at that time under Kushite (Nubian) pharaohs, for help against Assyria (Isaiah 20; 30:1–7; 31:1–3). An oracle that pictures Egypt's river, fish, flax and linen industries all collapsing (v. 8–10) tells Judah that Egypt cannot even keep itself alive.

From the study of Isaiah 19:8.

Where scholars differ

in v8

Does 'āval here carry a second sense, 'to dry up'?

  • There is a separate root 'āval II meaning 'be dry', and in drought passages it should be read that way, or at least heard as a pun.

    'Āval often appears with drying and withering (Amos 1:2; Jeremiah 12:4; 23:10; Joel 1:10), and an Akkadian word abālu, 'to dry up', exists. Some lexicographers (e.g. G. R. Driver, D. J. A. Clines) have argued for 'dry up' in some of these texts.

  • There is only one root, 'mourn'. When land 'mourns' in drought, that is figurative language, and the link to drying is poetic rather than a different word.

    K. M. Hayes (*The Earth Mourns*, 2002) argues that the mourning sense fits every occurrence and that biblical poetry naturally describes a ruined land as being in mourning. In Isaiah 19:8 the subjects are human fishermen, so 'mourn' is clearly the main sense either way.

in v8

What historical situation lies behind the Egypt oracle, and is the drying of the Nile literal?

  • Isaiah's own late-8th-century context: Egypt divided and then under Kushite pharaohs, with the 'harsh master' (v. 4) being an Assyrian king or a Kushite ruler.

    Judah's courting of Egypt in Isaiah 20 and 30–31, the civil strife of v. 2, and Assyria's later conquest of Egypt under Esarhaddon (671 BC) and Ashurbanipal.

  • Parts of the chapter were shaped or updated later, with the 'harsh master' identified with a Persian king such as Artaxerxes III (343 BC).

    Some critical commentators judge v. 5–10 and v. 16–25 to be later additions on grounds of style and theme.

  • Whatever the date, the drying Nile is a stock picture of total collapse rather than a forecast of a specific low flood.

    Egyptian texts such as the *Prophecy of Neferti* use a dried-up Nile as the classic image of national chaos, and the description of the trades failing one after another reads as poetic description.

in v9

What is the last word: "white cloth" or "they grow pale"?

  • Keep the traditional text: ḥôrāy, "white stuff" (white linen).

    Supported by the Masoretic text, and by the Septuagint ("byssus") and Vulgate ("fine fabrics"), which both read a cloth noun. The root ḥwr gives "white" and the related ḥûr is a white fabric in Esther.

  • Read with 1QIsaᵃ: ḥwrw, "they grow pale".

    Found in the oldest surviving Isaiah manuscript. It gives the verse two parallel clauses, each with its own verb, and the same verb is used in Isa 29:22 for faces going pale. Followed by BSB and some commentators.

  • "Networks / netting" (KJV tradition).

    Based on ḥôr, "hole". This view is now generally abandoned by modern lexicons in favour of the "white" root.

in v9

Does śərîqôt mean "combed (flax)" or describe a separate group of workers?

  • An adjective: "combed flax".

    Followed by most lexicons (BDB, HALOT) and translations. Later Hebrew and Aramaic śrq/srq means "to comb". The Septuagint has "carded or split flax".

  • A noun or participle: "the (women) combers" or "the combed fibres".

    The feminine form does not match the masculine plural pištîm. The Vulgate already renders it as an action ("combing"). Women were heavily involved in textile work.

in v10

Does שָׁתֹתֶיהָ mean 'her foundations/pillars' or 'her weavers'?

  • 'Foundations/pillars': the leading men or supporting classes of Egyptian society.

    Follows the Hebrew vowel points. The same noun in Psalm 11:3 means 'foundations' of the social order. This reading gives a top-to-bottom contrast with the wage-earners, and it leads into the attack on Pharaoh's officials in v. 11. Followed by ESV, NASB, WEB and YLT.

  • 'Weavers': textile workers, continuing v. 9.

    The Septuagint already read a weaving term ('those who set the warp'). Hebrew שְׁתִי means 'warp.' A Coptic word for 'weaver' has been compared. The reading fits the run of trades in vv. 8–10. Followed by NRSV, NIV and BSB. It requires only a change of vowels.

in v10

Is שֶׂכֶר 'wages' or 'beer'?

  • 'Wages': wage-earners, hired labourers.

    Matches the Hebrew vowels and the idiom 'osei sekher. Compare Proverbs 11:18 and Haggai 1:6 for wage language. Followed by almost all modern translations.

  • 'Beer' (shēkār): brewers.

    The Septuagint's 'those who make zythos.' Beer was a staple of the Egyptian economy and depended on Nile-watered barley, so it fits a list of trades. However, it needs different vowels and is a minority view today.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. אָנָה, אָבַל, אָמַל, חַכָּה, מִכְמֹרֶת, יְאֹר
  • HALOT s.v. אנה, אבל I/II, אמל, מִכְמֹרֶת, יְאֹר
  • T. O. Lambdin, 'Egyptian Loan Words in the Old Testament', JAOS 73 (1953)
  • K. M. Hayes, The Earth Mourns: Prophetic Metaphor and Oral Aesthetic (2002)
  • H. Wildberger, Isaiah 13–27 (Continental Commentary)
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 1–39 (Anchor Bible)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Isaiah 19
  • Herodotus, Histories 2.93, 2.149
  • Prophecy of Neferti, in M. Lichtheim, Ancient Egyptian Literature I
  • D. J. Brewer & R. F. Friedman, Fish and Fishing in Ancient Egypt (1989)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Isaiah 19:8; Vulgate, Isaias 19:8
  • BDB s.v. בּוֹשׁ, פֵּשֶׁת, שָׂרִיק, חוֹרָי
  • HALOT s.v. שָׂרִיק, חוֹרָי, חוּר
  • 1QIsaᵃ (Great Isaiah Scroll), Isa 19:9
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Isa 19:9
  • Vulgate, Isa 19:9
  • J. D. W. Watts, Isaiah 1–33 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Herodotus, Histories 2.37, 2.81
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Isa 19:5–10
  • BDB s.v. שָׁת; שֶׂכֶר; אָגֵם; דָּכָא; נֶפֶשׁ
  • HALOT s.v. שָׁת, אָגֵם, שֶׂכֶר
  • Septuagint, Isaiah 19:10 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Isaiah 19:10
  • Hans Wildberger, Isaiah 13–27 (Continental Commentary)
  • John N. Oswalt, The Book of Isaiah 1–39 (NICOT)
  • Joseph Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 1–39 (Anchor Yale Bible)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).