Isaiah Chapter 3 Read as one passage
Isaiah 3:9–10
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
9The expression on their faces testifies against them, and like Sodom they flaunt their sin; they do not conceal it. Woe to them, for they have brought disaster upon themselves. 10Tell the righteous it will be well with them, for they will enjoy the fruit of their labor.
What the first hearers heard
To Jerusalem's elite, the verse was an indictment that needed no investigation, because the evidence was on their own faces. The officials, judges and elders who ran the city had stopped bothering to hide their exploitation of the poor (3:14–15). Isaiah's charge was that this openness was itself a confession. Their shamelessness, and perhaps their open favouritism in court, testified against them before YHWH's court had even opened.
Calling them 'like Sodom' was an insult and a threat at the same time. Isaiah's hearers had no more damning comparison and no image of more complete destruction. Isaiah had already named the city's rulers 'rulers of Sodom' (1:10), and here he explains why: like Sodom, they do evil in the open.
The funeral cry ʾôy mourned them as if they were already dead. The closing clause made a point that verses 10–11 then spell out: YHWH's judgment would not be arbitrary. The disaster coming on Jerusalem (famine, the loss of competent leaders, social chaos, the death of its men in war) would be the payment their own deeds had earned. For the faithful minority in the city, the righteous of verse 10, this was reassurance. The collapse would fall where it was earned, and the righteous would 'eat the fruit of their deeds' differently.
From the study of Isaiah 3:9.
Verse by verse
-
9The expression on their faces testifies against them, and like Sodom they flaunt their sin; they do not conceal it. Woe to them, for they have brought disaster upon themselves.
Full study →What their faces show is already testifying against them in court. They announce their sin as openly as Sodom did and don't even try to cover it. Mourn for them, for their very lives! They have paid themselves in full, and what they have earned is ruin.
The verse is set in a courtroom. The first witness is the leaders' own faces. The Hebrew phrase means 'what can be recognized in their faces': the brazen, unashamed look of people who have stopped blushing. Hebrew readers would also catch an echo of a legal idiom, 'to recognize faces', which meant showing favouritism in court. So their faces show their shamelessness and also recall their bent justice.
Next, they announce their sin. The verb is the ordinary one for making news public, the same one used for prophets delivering a message. They do this 'like Sodom', the city whose wickedness was public and whose end was total. Hiding a sin at least admits it is shameful; they have given up even that.
The verse ends with ʾôy, the cry of mourners at a funeral, said over 'their nefesh': their whole selves, their lives. The reason is a bitter piece of bookkeeping. The verb gāmal means to carry something through to completion or to pay someone what is due. They have paid themselves, and the payment is rāʿāh. That one Hebrew word means both 'evil' and 'disaster', so the evil they did comes back as the disaster they suffer. No one else had to bring the charges, and no one else needed to hand out the sentence.
-
10Tell the righteous it will be well with them, for they will enjoy the fruit of their labor.
Full study →"Announce it about the one who is in the right: it is good, it will go well with him. For people like that will eat the harvest their own conduct has grown."
The verse is a short public announcement in the middle of a courtroom-style judgment on Jerusalem. The verb is plural, so a group is told to spread the message, though the verse doesn't say who. The word for "righteous" is singular: the righteous one, a type of person who stands for everyone who has kept faith with God and neighbor while the city's leaders robbed the poor. The message is just two Hebrew words, kî ṭôv, "that (it is) good." It is the opposite of the "evil" or "disaster" (ra') that verse 9 says the guilty have brought on themselves and that verse 11 pronounces on the wicked.
The reason follows in a farming picture. Deeds are like seed, and a person ends up eating whatever crop they produce. The word for "deeds" is the same one used two verses earlier for Jerusalem's "deeds against the LORD" (3:8). Both groups' actions bear fruit. The rebels reap ruin, and the righteous reap food to live on. In a chapter where God threatens to cut off "all supply of bread and water" (3:1), and where the rulers have "devoured the vineyard" of the poor (3:14), "they will eat" is a concrete promise. When God strips the city bare, the faithful will not be swept away with the guilty. The verse states the good outcome as already settled and grounds it in what the righteous have actually done. It does not promise a life free of trouble or a payout for hard work.
Where the English drifted
-
in v9
Woe unto their soul (KJV)
ʾôy lənapšām
- What we hear
- A warning about the fate of their immortal soul after death.
-
in v9
like Sodom
kisdōm
- What we hear
- A specific reference to homosexual acts, through the English word 'sodomy'.
- What they heard
- Sodom was the byword for wickedness so blatant and complete that it led to total destruction. Isaiah uses it for Jerusalem's open injustice and shamelessness (compare 1:10–17). Here the point is that the sin is flaunted publicly.
-
in v9
they have rewarded evil unto themselves (KJV)
gāməlû lāhem rāʿāh
- What we hear
- 'Rewarded' sounds like receiving something good.
- What they heard
- They have dealt out or repaid to themselves what their deeds earned, and it is harm.
-
in v10
the righteous
ṣaddîq
- What we hear
- Morally pure or religious people, or people with right standing before God in the later theological sense.
- What they heard
- The person who is "in the right" because they keep their obligations of justice and loyalty to God and neighbor. In this chapter that means people who are not among the leaders who rob the poor.
-
in v10
enjoy the fruit of their labor (BSB) / the rich reward they have earned (NLT)
pərî ma'aləlêhem yō'khēlû
- What we hear
- A payoff for working hard, like career success or wages earned.
- What they heard
- "They will eat the fruit of their deeds": they will live with the natural results of how they have acted. In the verses around it the same idiom is used for destruction, and here it means survival when Jerusalem is judged.
Every word
-
הַכָּרַ֤ת
hakkārat · H1971
look, recognition · v9
A rare noun that occurs only here. It comes from the verb 'to recognize', so it means 'what can be recognized' in a face: its look or expression. It is grammatically feminine, and it is the subject of 'has testified'.
-
פְּנֵיהֶם֙
pənêhem · H6440
face(s) · v9
'Their faces.' In Hebrew the face is where a person's stance shows: shame, defiance, favour. Verse 15 picks the word up again when the leaders 'grind the faces of the poor'.
-
עָ֣נְתָה
ʿānətāh · H6030
to answer; to testify · v9
Literally 'has answered'. Followed by 'against' (bə-), it is courtroom language: to give evidence against someone (as in Deut 19:16, 18). Their own faces stand up as the witness for the prosecution.
-
בָּ֔ם
bām
against them · v9
The preposition bə- with 'them'. After the verb ʿānāh it marks the person the testimony is aimed at: 'against them'.
-
וְחַטָּאתָ֛ם
wəḥaṭṭāʾtām · H2403
-
כִּסְדֹ֥ם
kisdōm · H5467
like Sodom · v9
Sodom was Israel's byword for a city so corrupt that the outcry against it reached heaven (Gen 18:20–21) and that was wiped out. The comparison here is about doing evil openly, and it also hints at the same end.
-
הִגִּ֖ידוּ
higgîdû · H5046
to declare, announce, tell · v9
'They have announced.' This is the ordinary verb for making something known publicly, and the same verb used for prophets announcing a message. The irony is that they broadcast their own sin.
-
לֹ֣א
lōʾ · H3808
not · v9
Plain negation of the verb that follows.
-
כִחֵ֑דוּ
kiḥēdû · H3582
to hide, conceal · v9
'They have not concealed it.' This restates the previous clause from the negative side. Even hiding a sin admits that it is shameful, and they no longer do even that.
-
א֣וֹי
ʾôy · H188
woe! alas! · v9
A cry of lament, the kind used at funerals. The prophet mourns them as people already doomed. It is a cry of grief more than a curse.
-
לְנַפְשָׁ֔ם
lənapšām · H5315
life, self, person · v9
'To their nefesh': to their very selves, their lives. It means the whole living person who will bear the disaster, not an inner immortal part kept apart from the body.
-
כִּֽי־
kî · H3588
for, because · v9, v10
Introduces the reason for the woe.
-
גָמְל֥וּ
gāməlû · H1580
to deal out fully; to repay; to wean, ripen · v9
'They have dealt out' or 'paid out'. The verb covers carrying something through to completion, which is why it is also used for weaning and ripening, and dealing someone their due. They have handed themselves their own payment. Verse 11 uses the related noun gəmûl, 'what his hands have dealt'.
-
לָהֶ֖ם
lāhem
to/for them · v9
'To themselves.' The people who deal out the harm are the same people who receive it.
-
רָעָֽה׃
rāʿāh · H7451
evil; harm, disaster · v9
The word means both moral evil and the disaster that follows from it. Here the weight falls on disaster, but the double sense is deliberate: their evil comes back to them as calamity.
-
אִמְר֥וּ
'imrû · H0559
say! (plural) · v10
A command given to a group of people, but the verse never says who they are: fellow prophets, heralds, or the listeners themselves. It works like a public announcement: "Make this known."
-
צַדִּ֖יק
ṣaddîq · H6662
righteous, in the right · v10
Grammatically singular ("the righteous one"), but it stands for a type of person. That is why the verse switches to "their" and "they" later. In this chapter it means the people who are not taking part in the leaders' corruption and oppression of the poor.
-
ט֑וֹב
ṭôv · H2895
to be good, go well · v10
Used impersonally: "it is good" or "it goes well." It is the direct opposite of ra' (evil, disaster) in verses 9 and 11. It means good outcome and well-being, not only moral goodness. The perfect form presents the outcome as settled.
-
פְרִ֥י
fərî · H6529
fruit, produce · v10
The harvest of a field, vine or tree. It is a farming picture: actions are like seed, and their results grow out of them the way a crop does.
-
מַעַלְלֵיהֶ֖ם
ma'aləlêhem · H4611
deeds, practices · v10
"Their deeds": conduct, a habitual way of acting. The same word appeared two verses earlier, where Jerusalem's "speech and deeds" were "against the LORD" (3:8). Here the righteous person's deeds bring a different harvest.
-
יֹאכֵֽלוּ׃
yō'khēlû · H0398
they will eat · v10
Literally "eat." They will live off the produce of their own conduct. The form points to the future, or to what reliably happens. The sentence's final word lands on the concrete act of eating, the reverse of the famine and loss of "all supply of bread" threatened in 3:1.
The world behind it
Where the verse sits. Isaiah 3:1–15 is an oracle (a prophetic message) against Jerusalem's ruling class, from the second half of the 8th century BC. It probably dates to the prosperous but socially unequal years of Uzziah, Jotham or Ahaz. YHWH announces that he will remove 'staff and support': food, water, warriors, judges, prophets, elders and advisers (3:1–3). Society will then collapse until no one is willing to rule (3:4–7). Verse 8 gives the verdict: Jerusalem has stumbled because its words and deeds defy 'the eyes of his glory'. Verse 9 then presents the evidence. Verses 10–11 state the principle that deeds bear fruit, and verses 13–15 stage the trial itself. YHWH stands up to accuse the elders and princes: 'the plunder of the poor is in your houses… you grind the faces of the poor.'
Faces and shame. Israel was a society built on honour and shame. A face showed where a person stood: a lifted face meant favour, a fallen face meant anger or disgrace, a covered face meant shame. Being unable to blush was a recognised sign of hardened guilt (Jer 3:3; 6:15; 8:12; Zeph 3:5). Hiding wrongdoing still admitted the community's standards. Doing it openly rejected them. The leaders' faces 'testify' because they no longer show the shame that should be there.
Court procedure. Torah required two or three witnesses for a conviction (Deut 19:15), and a witness 'answered against' the accused. Isaiah makes the accused people's own faces serve as that witness, ahead of YHWH's formal case in verses 13–15. Partiality in judgment, 'recognizing faces', was precisely the sin Torah forbade judges to commit (Deut 1:17; 16:19). This was the class Isaiah is indicting.
Sodom. Isaiah's audience knew Sodom from Genesis 18–19 as the city whose 'outcry' reached heaven and which was destroyed completely. Isaiah had already addressed Jerusalem's leaders as 'rulers of Sodom' (1:10) over blood-stained hands and neglected orphans and widows (1:15–17). In this verse the comparison is about public, unashamed wickedness, and it carries the threat of the same end.
From the study of Isaiah 3:9.
Where scholars differ
in v9
Does hakkārat pənêhem mean 'the expression of their faces' or 'their partiality (in judgment)'?
-
Facial expression: their brazen, unashamed look gives them away.
This is the natural meaning of 'what is recognized in their faces'. It fits the rest of the verse, which is about public display ('they declare… they do not hide'). Brazen faces appear as a sign of sin in Jer 3:3 and Prov 21:29, and the Septuagint's 'shame of their face' points the same way. Most modern commentators and almost all English versions take this view.
-
Partiality: their 'recognizing of faces', meaning favouritism toward the powerful in court, testifies against them.
The verb phrase hikkîr pānîm is a fixed legal idiom for partiality (Deut 1:17; 16:19; Prov 24:23; 28:21), and this noun phrase is its exact nominal form. The Targum reads it this way ('in judgment'), as do several medieval Jewish commentators. The context is about judges and elders (3:2, 14) and an explicit courtroom scene (3:13–15).
-
Deliberate double meaning.
Isaiah often plays on sound and meaning. A phrase that means 'facial look' while echoing 'partiality' would make the leaders' faces both the evidence and a reminder of the crime. This is plausible, but it cannot be proved.
in v10
Are verses 10–11 original to Isaiah's speech, or a later addition?
-
A later wisdom-style insertion
The verses break into a judgment speech on Jerusalem's leaders (3:1–9, 12–15). Their righteous/wicked contrast and "eat the fruit" idiom sound like Proverbs and Psalm 1. Several critical commentators (e.g. Wildberger, Kaiser, Blenkinsopp) regard them as a scribal or wisdom addition qualifying the blanket judgment.
-
Integral to the passage
"Their deeds" (3:8) is picked up in 3:10, the root g-m-l joins 3:9 and 3:11, and Isaiah 1:19–20 already used eat/good language for the obedient. Commentators such as Oswalt read verses 10–11 as Isaiah's own aside, making clear that judgment separates the faithful from the guilty.
in v10
What did the first word originally say?
-
"Say" ('imrû), as in the Hebrew text
Supported by the Masoretic text, apparently by the Qumran scroll, and by the Vulgate. It makes good sense as a command to announce the message.
-
"Happy is" ('ashrê), by emendation
It would match "Woe" in verse 11 exactly and fits the Psalm 1 pattern. But it has no manuscript support.
-
"Bind" ('isrû), as behind the Septuagint
The Greek "Let us bind the righteous" points to a Hebrew text, or a misreading, with s for m. Most scholars see it as a secondary reading, since it does not fit the second half of the verse well.
in v10
"Say TO the righteous" or "Say OF the righteous"?
-
Address: "Say to the righteous"
The traditional reading (KJV, Vulgate, most modern versions): heralds are told to reassure the faithful.
-
Description: "Say of the righteous that it is good"
There is no "to" in the Hebrew. The pattern "X, that good" is the same construction as Gen 1:4 ("God saw the light, that it was good"), where the noun is the subject of the following clause. On this reading the verse is a public declaration about the righteous.
Sources
- BDB s.v. הַכָּרָה, נָכַר, עָנָה, גָּמַל, נֶפֶשׁ
- HALOT s.v. הַכָּרָה; גמל; רָעָה
- Targum Jonathan to Isaiah 3:9
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Isaiah 3:9–10
- Vulgate Isaiah 3:9
- Wisdom of Solomon 2:12
- Epistle of Barnabas 6:7
- Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho
- H. Wildberger, Isaiah 1–12 (Continental Commentary)
- J. N. Oswalt, The Book of Isaiah 1–39 (NICOT)
- J. Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 1–39 (Anchor Bible)
- BDB s.v. צַדִּיק, טוֹב, מַעֲלָל, אָכַל
- HALOT s.v. צַדִּיק; מַעֲלָל
- Rahlfs, Septuaginta, Isaiah 3:9–10
- Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 17, 133, 136–137
- Vulgate, Isaiah 3:10
- K. Koch, "Is There a Doctrine of Retribution in the Old Testament?" (1955; ET 1983)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).