Isaiah Chapter 5 Read as one passage

Isaiah 5:19–20

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

19to those who say, “Let Him hurry and hasten His work so that we may see it! Let the plan of the Holy One of Israel come so that we may know it!” 20Woe to those who call evil good and good evil, who turn darkness to light and light to darkness, who replace bitter with sweet and sweet with bitter.

What the first hearers heard

To Isaiah's hearers in Jerusalem, this verse would have sounded like a recognisable quotation of their neighbours, perhaps even of themselves. These were the confident, well-off people who heard the prophet's talk about God's "work" and "plan" and the "Holy One of Israel" and joked about it: Let's see it, then.

Isaiah does not argue with them. He mourns them with a funeral "woe." He shows that their demand for speed and proof is itself the sin. It is the same people dragging guilt along with cart ropes (5:18) who dare the judgment to hurry. The wordplay would not be lost on them. The words they used in mockery (hurry, work, plan, see, know) are the very words with which the prophet describes their coming ruin and the exile that will finally teach them to "know."

For those who did listen, the oracle drew a line. The faithful wait without demanding that God hurry (28:16, "whoever trusts will not be in haste"). The scoffers demand haste and will get it.

From the study of Isaiah 5:19.

Verse by verse

  1. 19to those who say, “Let Him hurry and hasten His work so that we may see it! Let the plan of the Holy One of Israel come so that we may know it!”

    "…woe to those who keep saying: 'Come on, let him get moving! Let this "work" of his hurry up and happen, so we can see it for ourselves. Let this "plan" of the Holy One of Israel get closer and actually arrive, so we can find out what it is!'"

    The verse finishes the "woe" that begins in verse 18, so it is part of a lament over people who are as good as dead. The speakers are not atheists. They are people who have heard Isaiah's warnings so often that they now jeer at them. Almost every key word they use is the prophet's own vocabulary thrown back at him:

    • "his work" answers Isaiah's charge that they "do not see the work of his hands" (5:12);
    • "the plan" is Isaiah's word for God's settled, unstoppable purpose;
    • "the Holy One of Israel" is Isaiah's signature title for God, here said with a sneer.

    The Hebrew is insistent and mock-eager. Two "hurry" verbs come one after the other, and unusual emphatic endings ("let it hasten!", "let it come!") give the sense of "Well, go on then!" The two "hurry" roots are the same pair Isaiah uses in his son's sign-name, "Swift the spoil, speedy the plunder" (8:1–3). The scoffers ask for exactly the speed with which the Assyrian armies will in fact arrive (5:26, "swiftly, speedily it comes").

    Their stated aim, "so that we may see… so that we may know," is a demand for proof before they will believe. It is also tragic irony. They will indeed see and know God's work, but by living through it, since "my people go into exile for lack of knowledge" (5:13). Verse 18 gives the picture: they are dragging their guilt behind them like a cart on ropes while they dare the punishment to come.

    Full study →
  2. 20Woe to those who call evil good and good evil, who turn darkness to light and light to darkness, who replace bitter with sweet and sweet with bitter.

    "Ah, the funeral cry over them! These are people who make a habit of looking at what is bad and declaring 'Good!', and looking at what is good and declaring 'Bad!'. They go beyond words and arrange things so that darkness passes for light and light passes for darkness, so that what is bitter and harmful is served up as sweet and what is sweet and wholesome is treated as bitter."

    The verse opens with hoy, the wail mourners raised over a corpse. Isaiah raises it over people who are alive and doing well, and in doing so declares them as good as dead. The verbs are participles, which describe a kind of person by what they habitually do: 'the sayers', 'the setters'. This is their settled practice, not a single lapse.

    The three pairs climb through the human faculties:

    • Judgment and speech: good and bad. This is the verdict a judge or counsellor gives.
    • Sight: light and darkness. This is how a person sees the world.
    • Taste: sweet and bitter. This is the gut sense of what is wholesome and what is harmful.

    Each pair turns back on itself, because calling wrong 'right' always ends up calling right 'wrong'. The verb also shifts from saying to setting or making. These people do not just misname things. They reorder reality so that their labels hold.

    In its setting, the 'bad' being blessed is concrete. Wealthy men were joining field to field until the poor had no land (5:8), and judges were acquitting the guilty for a bribe and stripping the innocent of their rights (5:23). The images also echo the chapter around them. God's vineyard gave sour grapes instead of sweet ones (5:2). Those who turn light into darkness will see the land itself go dark (5:30).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v19

    counsel (KJV, WEB)

    'ēṣāh

    What we hear
    Advice, guidance, or a lawyer or therapist.
    What they heard
    A decided plan or purpose: God's settled decree, which in Isaiah is certain to be carried out.
  • in v19

    the Holy One

    qədôš

    What we hear
    A morally pure, pious being.
    What they heard
    The utterly other, set-apart God whose majesty is dangerous to the guilty and who shows his holiness by judging justly (5:16; 6:3–5). In this verse the title is very likely quoted sarcastically.
  • in v20

    Woe to

    hoy

    What we hear
    An archaic, formal curse, roughly 'a curse on', or a vague sense of misfortune as in 'woe is me'.
    What they heard
    The wail raised at a funeral ("Ah, my brother!"). A prophet who cried hoy over living people was in effect mourning them in advance and announcing their death. It is grief and verdict together.
  • in v20

    evil

    ra'

    What we hear
    Extreme, monstrous or demonic wickedness, a category apart from ordinary wrongdoing.
    What they heard
    The ordinary word for 'bad': harmful, wrong, rotten, disastrous, as well as wicked. In this chapter the 'evil' being called good is mostly everyday injustice: land-grabbing, bribery and denying the innocent their rights.
Every word
  1. הָאֹמְרִים

    hā'ōmərîm · H0559

    the ones saying · v19, v20

    A participle with the article, picking up the "woe" of verse 18: "[Woe to] those who keep saying." The participle describes a habit. This is what these people keep saying, not a single remark.

  2. יְמַהֵר

    yəmahēr · H4116A

    to hurry, hasten · v19

    "Let it hurry" (or "let him hurry"). A taunting wish. This is the same root as the first element of Isaiah's sign-name for his son, Maher-shalal-hash-baz, "Swift the spoil, speedy the plunder" (8:1–3).

  3. יָחִישָׁה

    yāḥîšāh · H2363A

    to make haste · v19

    "Let it make haste!" There is an extra -ah ending, normally used with "I/we" forms to express eagerness, and it is unusual on a third-person verb. It gives the line a mock-eager, insistent tone: "Come on, let it hurry up!"

  4. מַעֲשֵׂהוּ

    ma'ăśēhû · H4639G

    his work, deed · v19

    "His work," meaning what God does in history. Here it is the judgment Isaiah has been announcing. It echoes 5:12, where the people "do not see the work of his hands."

  5. לְמַעַן

    ləma'an · H4616

    so that, in order that · v19

    Introduces the purpose: they say they want proof before they will take the threat seriously.

  6. נִרְאֶה

    nir'eh · H7200G

    we may see · v19

    "So we can see [it]." It is ironic, because Isaiah has just said they do not see God's work (5:12), and he will be sent to a people who "keep seeing but do not perceive" (6:9).

  7. וְתִקְרַב

    wətiqrab · H7126G

    and let it draw near · v19

    The verb is feminine, agreeing with "plan" (a feminine noun), which comes later in the clause. "Let it come close."

  8. וְתָבוֹאָה

    wətābô'āh · H0935G

    and let it come · v19

    "And let it arrive!" This verb has the same insistent -ah ending as yāḥîšāh. "Draw near and come" builds up to arrival, said as a dare.

  9. עֲצַת

    'ăṣat · H6098

    counsel, plan, purpose · v19

    "The plan of": God's decided purpose, which Isaiah keeps saying will surely happen (14:24–27; 46:10). The scoffers use the prophet's own key word to mock it.

  10. קְדוֹשׁ

    qədôš · H6918G

    holy (one) · v19

    "The Holy One of": God as utterly other, set apart, and dangerous to the guilty. On the scoffers' lips it is very likely a sarcastic quotation of Isaiah's favourite title for God.

  11. יִשְׂרָאֵל

    yiśrā'ēl · H3478

    Israel · v19

    Israel as God's covenant people. The title ties the holy God to this people, which is exactly why their sin is so serious.

  12. וְנֵדָעָה

    wənēdā'āh · H3045

    and let us know · v19

    "So we may know [it]": know by experience, find out for ourselves. Ironic, since 5:13 says the people go into exile "for lack of knowledge."

  13. ה֣וֹי

    hoy · H1945

    ah! alas! woe! · v20

    The cry mourners raised over a dead body. Opening with it treats the people named next as if they were already dead. This is the fourth of six such cries in Isaiah 5:8–24.

  14. לָרַ֛ע

    lara' · H7451B

    bad, evil · v20

    "To / about the bad." After a verb of saying, the little word 'to' (le-) marks the thing being named, as in "they say of the bad thing, 'Good!'" Ra' is the everyday Hebrew word for what is bad: harmful, wrong or wicked.

  15. ט֖וֹב

    tov · H2896B

    good · v20

    The verdict they give it: "Good!" The word covers good, right, beneficial and pleasant. Calling something tov means approving it.

  16. שָׂמִ֨ים

    samim · H7760H

    to put, set, make · v20

    "Setting, making." The verb moves from naming to doing. With 'as' (le-) after it, it means to make one thing into another or treat it as another. They arrange things so that the false label holds.

  17. חֹ֤שֶׁךְ

    choshekh · H2822

    darkness · v20

    Darkness: the time of danger, confusion and hidden deeds. In Isaiah it is also the darkness of judgment (5:30).

  18. לְאוֹר֙

    le'or · H0216

    as light · v20

    "As light / into light." They present darkness as if it were light. In Isaiah, light goes with the LORD's instruction, justice and saving presence (2:5; 9:2).

  19. מַ֛ר

    mar · H4751

    bitter · v20

    Bitter: first a taste, but in Hebrew also the word for anguish, grief and harm (as in a 'bitter soul').

  20. לְמָת֖וֹק

    lematoq · H4966

    as sweet · v20

    "As sweet." They pass off the harmful thing as pleasant and wholesome. Sweetness was the taste of honey, ripe fruit and, in the poets, God's word (Ps 19:10).

The world behind it

The woe series (5:8–24). After the Song of the Vineyard (5:1–7), Isaiah pronounces a string of "woes" on the leading classes of Judah in the 8th century BC. They are aimed at land-grabbers (5:8), drinkers and revellers (5:11), mockers (5:18–19), people who invert moral values (5:20), the self-wise (5:21), and corrupt judges (5:22–23). The Hebrew hôy ("woe!", "alas!") was the cry of mourners at a funeral (1 Kgs 13:30; Jer 22:18). Opening each line with it treats the people addressed as already dead.

Prosperity and complacency. Under Uzziah and Jotham, Judah enjoyed wealth and relative security. Isaiah's warnings that the vineyard would be stripped (5:5–6) and the people exiled (5:13) sounded far-fetched to comfortable listeners. When disaster does not come at once, prophets get mocked. Compare Jeremiah 17:15 ("Where is the word of the LORD? Let it come!"), Ezekiel 12:22 ("The days grow long and every vision fails"), and Amos 5:18, where people actually long for the Day of the LORD, assuming it will favour them.

How the taunt is answered. The chapter ends (5:26–30) with God whistling for a distant nation that comes "swiftly, speedily." Within a generation Assyria would devastate the northern kingdom (722 BC) and much of Judah (701 BC).

Later echoes. The pattern of scoffers mocking a delayed judgment comes back in 2 Peter 3:3–4 ("Where is the promise of his coming?"). That is a shared theme, not a quotation of Isaiah.

From the study of Isaiah 5:19.

Where scholars differ

in v19

Are the speakers mocking the threat of judgment, or confidently calling for a divine intervention they expect to favour them?

  • Sarcastic scoffing: they deny that Isaiah's threatened judgment will ever come.

    They reuse Isaiah's own vocabulary ("work" from 5:12, "plan", "Holy One of Israel"). There are parallel taunts in Jer 17:15 and Ezek 12:22, and verse 18 pictures them as hauling sin in defiantly. This is the majority view (e.g. Oswalt, Childs, Blenkinsopp).

  • Misplaced popular hope: they want God's "work" because they assume it will be victory for Judah, as in Amos 5:18.

    Elsewhere "the work of the LORD" can mean saving deeds, and the eighth-century prophets attack popular confidence in the Day of the LORD. Some commentators combine the two: the scoffers treat any talk of God's plan as something that cannot harm them.

in v19

Is God or "his work" the subject of "hurry / hasten"?

  • God is the subject: "Let him hurry, let him hasten his work."

    Ḥûš in the hiphil stem can take an object. Most English versions read it this way.

  • "His work" is the subject: "Let his work hurry, let it hasten."

    It matches the second line, where the feminine verbs agree with "plan" as subject. This is how the supplied morphological data reads it.

in v20

Where does the prophetic 'hoy' (woe) form come from, and is it mainly a lament or a curse?

  • It comes from the funeral lament. The prophet mourns those whose conduct has already doomed them.

    Hoy is used at actual burials (1 Kgs 13:30; Jer 22:18; 34:5). Waldemar Janzen's study *Mourning Cry and Woe Oracle* (1972) argues the prophetic use grows from this setting, and the death imagery in Isaiah 5:14 (Sheol opening its mouth) fits.

  • It comes from popular wisdom teaching, a 'woe to the one who...' saying that names conduct and its consequences, the mirror image of 'blessed is the one who...'.

    Erhard Gerstenberger (JBL 1962) and others note that the woes describe types of behaviour in a way similar to wisdom sayings, and that v.21 explicitly targets the 'wise'. Some (e.g. Westermann) relate it instead to curse formulas.

  • A blend: by Isaiah's day the form combines a lament's pathos with a judgment announcement.

    In Isaiah 5 the woes are followed by 'therefore' judgment sections (vv. 13, 24), showing the form now functions as an accusation followed by a verdict, whatever its origin. Many recent commentators (e.g. Wildberger, Blenkinsopp) take a mixed view.

in v20

Who exactly are 'those who call evil good'?

  • Judges and officials who pervert legal verdicts.

    Verse 23 names those who 'acquit the guilty for a bribe'. Pronouncing 'good/bad' or 'right/wrong' was the judges' task (1 Kgs 3:9; Prov 17:15; Amos 5:15).

  • Counsellors and sages at court, the policy-makers and 'wise' of Jerusalem.

    Verse 21 follows immediately with 'wise in their own eyes'. Isaiah elsewhere attacks royal advisers whose 'wisdom' leads Judah astray (29:14–15; 30:1–2).

  • The cynical scoffers of v.19, and more broadly anyone in Judah's leading classes who has dulled moral perception.

    Verses 19 and 20 share the same participle ha'omrim ('those who say'). The three pairs (judgment, sight, taste) describe a general corruption of perception, not only a legal act. On this view vv. 19–23 describe one circle of people from several angles.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. עֵצָה; s.v. חוּשׁ; s.v. מַעֲשֶׂה
  • HALOT s.v. עֵצָה; s.v. מהר; s.v. חושׁ
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (Kautzsch–Cowley) §48 on the cohortative -ah ending
  • H. Wildberger, Isaiah 1–12 (Continental Commentary)
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 1–39 (Anchor Bible)
  • B. S. Childs, Isaiah (Old Testament Library)
  • J. N. Oswalt, The Book of Isaiah 1–39 (NICOT)
  • J. D. W. Watts, Isaiah 1–33 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Isaiah 5:19
  • Vulgate Isaiah 5:19
  • BDB s.v. הוֹי, רַע, טוֹב, שׂוּם, מַר, מָתוֹק
  • HALOT s.v. הוֹי; שׂים
  • W. Janzen, Mourning Cry and Woe Oracle (BZAW 125, 1972)
  • E. Gerstenberger, "The Woe-Oracles of the Prophets," JBL 81 (1962)
  • B. S. Childs, Isaiah (OTL)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Isaiah 5:20
  • Vulgate Isaiah 5:20
  • Damascus Document (CD) 1:19

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).