Jeremiah Chapter 23 Read as one passage
Jeremiah 23:18–22
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
18But which of them has stood in the council of the LORD to see and hear His word? Who has given heed to His word and obeyed it? 19Behold, the storm of the LORD has gone out with fury, a whirlwind swirling down upon the heads of the wicked. 20The anger of the LORD will not turn back until He has fully accomplished the purposes of His heart. In the days to come you will understand this clearly. 21I did not send these prophets, yet they have run with their message; I did not speak to them, yet they have prophesied. 22But if they had stood in My council, they would have proclaimed My words to My people and turned them back from their evil ways and deeds.”
What the first hearers heard
To people in Jerusalem around 600 BC, the verse cut through a confusing situation. Several prophets claimed to speak for YHWH, and they contradicted each other. The popular ones promised safety, and Jeremiah said they were wrong.
The verse gave the hearers a test drawn from their own world of kings and courts: a herald can only announce what he heard in the throne room. Everyone knew the image of YHWH enthroned among his heavenly attendants from worship and from older prophetic stories such as Micaiah's (1 Kgs 22). Its force was both legal and personal. The peace-prophets had no access, so they had no message, so their "Thus says YHWH" was forgery.
The verse also set up the contrast Jeremiah goes on to draw. If they had stood in the council, they would have turned the people from their evil ways (23:22). A message that comforts people who despise God (v. 17) shows by its content that it did not come from the council. The decree that actually issues from YHWH's presence is the storm of verse 19. The verse also implicitly backs Jeremiah's own claim, since he was told he would "stand before" YHWH (15:19).
From the study of Jeremiah 23:18.
Verse by verse
-
18But which of them has stood in the council of the LORD to see and hear His word? Who has given heed to His word and obeyed it?
Full study →"After all, which of them has ever stood among the attendants in YHWH's inner council, the assembly around his throne where his decisions are made, and actually seen and heard the word decided there? Which of them has ever strained to catch his word and really heard it?"
The questions expect the answer none of them. In verse 17 the prophets assure people who scorn God, "YHWH has said: you will have peace." Jeremiah's reply is a matter of credentials. A real prophet is like a royal herald who has stood in the king's council chamber, watched the deliberation, and been sent out with the decree. These men were never in the room. Their "peace" is a vision of their own hearts (v. 16). The word that really goes out from the council is the one announced in the next breath: a storm of YHWH's fury bursting on the heads of the wicked (v. 19).
The Hebrew word for "council" (sod) also means "secret" or "confidential counsel". To stand in YHWH's sod is to be in on his private decisions, as Amos says: "YHWH does nothing without revealing his sod to his servants the prophets" (Amos 3:7).
-
19Behold, the storm of the LORD has gone out with fury, a whirlwind swirling down upon the heads of the wicked.
Full study →Look! Yahweh's own storm, his burning rage, has already been let loose. A tempest twisting and spinning in on itself, and it will come whirling down, right onto the heads of those who are in the wrong.
The verse is built as a picture of the God of the storm coming out to battle. "Storm" and "rage" stand side by side as two names for one thing: the storm is Yahweh's anger in visible form. "Has gone out" is stated as done. The storm has left his presence and is on its way, even though it has not yet struck. The second line repeats the storm word ("yes, a tempest!") and uses the same verb twice, "whirling... it will whirl down," so the sound of the line imitates its motion. That verb can also mean writhing in pain, so the twisting of the wind and the agony it brings are heard together.
The target matters. "Upon the head of the guilty" answers, word for word, what the prophets of peace had been telling Jerusalem in verse 17: "No harm will come upon you." Jeremiah's reply is that harm is coming upon them, onto their own heads. The "guilty" are not distant pagans. They are the religious insiders who promised safety, and the people who wanted to hear it. The next verse completes the thought: this anger will not turn back until it has done everything God intends, and only afterward will they understand.
-
20The anger of the LORD will not turn back until He has fully accomplished the purposes of His heart. In the days to come you will understand this clearly.
Full study →The LORD's anger, pictured in the previous verse as a storm already sent out, will not turn around and come home with its work unfinished. It will keep going until God has done what he decided to do, until he has made his plans stand, the way he makes a promise stand. Those plans are the settled purposes of his heart: not passing moods or feelings, but what he has deliberately made up his mind to do (in Hebrew the "heart" is mainly the seat of thinking and will). Then the tone changes from warning to prediction: later on, once all this has happened, you (the whole people, and the prophets who promised you peace) will look back into it and understand it fully and clearly. The repeated wording ("understand it with understanding") stresses that the insight will be complete and undeniable. It will also be insight gained only by looking back, after events have shown whose word was true. "The latter days" here means "the days after this," the time after the judgment has fallen, not the end of the world.
-
21I did not send these prophets, yet they have run with their message; I did not speak to them, yet they have prophesied.
Full study →"I never commissioned those prophets as my envoys, and yet off they ran, like royal couriers racing out with a dispatch. I never spoke a word to them, and yet they stood up and delivered oracles in my name."
The line is built as two matched halves, and each half sets God's denial against the prophets' own action. God's side: he did not send them (no commission, no authority) and did not speak to them (no message, no content). Their side: they ran (they took the messenger's role with energy and urgency) and they prophesied (they performed the full public act of speaking for God). The repeated emphatic "they" ("but they ran… but they prophesied") marks the whole operation as their own initiative.
The picture comes from the royal court. A king's runners carried his letters through the realm, and a messenger's words counted only because he had been sent and handed the message. These prophets are couriers who never stood before the king (v. 18, 22, "stood in my council") and never received a dispatch, yet they are on the road shouting "Thus says the king!" Their haste and confidence prove nothing. What they "prophesied" was not chiefly prediction. It was the reassuring message of v. 17, "You will have peace," given to a people God was calling to turn from evil (v. 22).
-
22But if they had stood in My council, they would have proclaimed My words to My people and turned them back from their evil ways and deeds.”
Full study →"But if they really had stood among my attendants in my private council, the inner court where I make my decisions known, they would have made my people hear my words, not their own dreams. And those words would have turned my people around and led them off the evil road they keep walking, away from the corrupt practices that make up their lives."
The verse is a counterfactual: it describes what would have happened. Verse 21 has just said God never sent these prophets, so verse 22 is an accusation dressed as a hypothesis. It also sets out the test by which they fail. Two things mark a true prophet. The first is about where they have been: they have stood in God's council the way a royal servant stands before the throne, and so have heard the king's actual decision. The second is about what their words produce: they turn people back. The verse uses the causative forms of two verbs, so the prophet makes the people hear and makes them turn. Hearing in God's council should lead to repentance among God's people.
The last phrase is deliberately heavy: "from their evil way, and from the evil of their deeds." Hebrew repeats the same root, evil way and evil of their doings. It echoes Jeremiah's earlier sermons ("amend your ways and your deeds," 7:3). It also contrasts with the false prophets, who "strengthen the hands of evildoers so that no one turns from his evil" (23:14) and tell people "no disaster will come upon you" (23:17). Their message made people comfortable on the wrong road. A word from God's council would have turned them off it.
Where the English drifted
-
in v18
counsel (KJV: "stood in the counsel of the LORD")
sod
- What we hear
- Advice or a plan, as in 'God's counsel' meaning his wisdom or guidance.
- What they heard
- An assembly or inner circle a person can stand in: the heavenly council around YHWH's throne, along with the confidential decisions made there.
-
in v18
his word
devaro
- What we hear
- The Bible, or God's word as written Scripture in general.
- What they heard
- A particular decree spoken in the council and carried out orally by a prophet. In context it is the coming judgment (v. 19), not 'peace'.
-
in v19
the wicked
resha'im
- What we hear
- Obviously evil people, villains, usually outsiders to the community of faith.
- What they heard
- The guilty party, those in the wrong before the divine judge. Here that means Judah's own prophets and the people who trusted their promises of peace.
-
in v19
whirlwind (KJV)
sa'ar / se'arah
- What we hear
- A tornado or narrow funnel of wind.
- What they heard
- A violent tempest or gale, the storm of the divine warrior. The spinning motion comes from the verb mitcholel beside it, not from the noun itself.
-
in v20
in the latter days (KJV, WEB, ESV); in the last days (NASB)
be'acharit hayyamim
- What we hear
- The end times: the final period of world history before Christ's return.
- What they heard
- 'In the after-part of the days,' meaning later on, in days to come. Here it means once the judgment now being announced has actually happened.
-
in v20
the thoughts of his heart (KJV)
mezimmot libbo
- What we hear
- God's inner feelings or musings.
- What they heard
- The deliberate plans and decisions of God's mind and will. The Hebrew 'heart' is mainly the organ of thinking and deciding.
-
in v20
ye shall consider it perfectly (KJV)
titbonenu vah binah
- What we hear
- You will think about it flawlessly, or just reflect on it.
- What they heard
- You will see into it and understand it thoroughly. The doubled wording adds emphasis; it does not claim perfect knowledge.
-
in v21
prophesied
nibba'u (naba')
- What we hear
- Predicted the future.
- What they heard
- Delivered oracles as God's spokesman: public speech claiming divine authority. Here the content was mostly reassurance about the present ('you will have peace,' v. 17), not forecasts.
-
in v21
they ran
ratsu (ruts)
- What we hear
- They ran off, or simply moved quickly or were eager.
- What they heard
- They ran as messengers do: took up the courier's role and rushed out with a 'message' to deliver.
-
in v22
stood in my counsel (KJV)
sod
- What we hear
- Received advice or guidance from God; was open to his counsel.
- What they heard
- Was present in God's council, the inner assembly at his throne, and so heard the confidential decisions made there. The word is about access and presence before it is about advice.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v21
'They ran before I sent them' isn't about bad timing
- What's often taught
- The verse is often preached as a warning against 'running ahead of God': people who begin a ministry or step into a role before God's appointed time, or without proper preparation or recognition.
- What the text supports
The Hebrew does not say they ran before they were sent, as if a commission was coming later. It says flatly that God never sent them (lo' shalachti) and never spoke to them (lo' dibbarti). Their 'running' is the courier's dash with a message (ruts), and that message was false: 'You will have peace' (v. 17), given to a people steeped in injustice and idolatry (vv. 10–14). Verse 22 gives the test: a prophet who had stood in God's council would have carried God's words and turned the people from their evil ways.
What the popular reading gets right is that zeal and activity do not prove a divine commission. But the verse's concern is the source and content of a message claimed as God's word, not timing, readiness or formal credentials. These men held the recognized office of prophet. What they lacked was a word from God.
- Where the English feeds it
- Translations that add 'these prophets… have run' with no context, or NLT's 'run around', can make 'running' sound like restless haste or overeagerness, which invites a lesson about patience rather than about false messages.
Every word
-
כִּי
ki · H3588A
for, because, indeed · v18
Ties this question to verse 17. The prophets are promising 'peace' in YHWH's name, and the reason that claim is empty follows here. It can also simply add emphasis: 'Why, who has stood…?'
-
מִי
mi · H4310
who? · v18
A question that expects a negative answer, the kind that means 'nobody'. Here it means none of the peace-prophets. Whether it also means 'no human at all' is debated (see debates).
-
עָמַד
ʿamad · H5975G
to stand · v18, v22
To stand as an attendant stands before a king: present, on duty, waiting for orders. The perfect tense asks whether any of them has ever actually been there.
-
בְּסוֹד
be-sod · H5475
in the council / confidential circle of · v18, v22
'In the council of', meaning the inner assembly around YHWH's throne where decisions are talked over and decrees are issued. It is a place a person attends, and the private deliberation that happens there.
-
יְהוָה
YHWH · H3068G
Yahweh (the LORD) · v18, v19, v20
Israel's God, named personally. The council belongs to him; he presides as king.
-
וְיֵרֶא
ve-yere · H7200G
and see / perceive · v18
The short (jussive) form after 'and' marks purpose or result: 'so that he saw / might see'. Prophets 'saw' as well as heard. Compare Micaiah: 'I saw YHWH sitting on his throne' (1 Kgs 22:19).
-
וְיִשְׁמַע
ve-yishmaʿ · H8085G
and hear · v18, v22
Continues the purpose: to hear what was decided. Seeing and hearing together make the prophet an eyewitness and an ear-witness of the throne room.
-
אֶת־
et- · H0853
[marks the direct object] · v18, v21, v22
Not translated. It marks 'his word' as what is seen and heard.
-
דְּבָרוֹ
devaro · H1697G
his word, matter, message · v18, v22
The actual decree or message settled in the council, which a true prophet carries out as a herald carries a royal edict.
-
הִקְשִׁיב
hiqshiv · H7181
to pay close attention, give ear · v18
An intensive word for listening: pricking up the ears and attending closely. It suggests the alert courtier who catches every word of the king.
-
הִנֵּה
hinneh · H2009
look, behold · v19
A word that grabs attention, like pointing and shouting 'Look!' It puts the storm in front of the hearers as if it were already in sight on the horizon.
-
סַעֲרַת
sa'arat · H5591B
-
חֵמָה
chemah · H2534
heat, rage, wrath · v19
Literally 'heat', from a root meaning 'to be hot'. It is the burning anger of a wronged judge. It stands next to 'storm' as a second name for the same thing: the storm is the wrath. Translations that say 'with fury' or 'in wrath' smooth this into an adverb.
-
יָצְאָה
yatse'ah · H3318G
go out, go forth · v19
'Has gone out', a completed action. The storm has already been let loose from Yahweh's presence. The judgment is spoken of as settled fact even though it has not yet struck.
-
מִתְחוֹלֵל
mitcholel · H2342J
whirling, twisting itself · v19
A form of the verb chul meaning 'whirl, spin, writhe' (the same root is used of dancing and of labor pains). The form describes the wind turning in on itself, a swirling, twisting storm.
-
עַל
'al · H5921A
upon, against · v19
'Upon': the storm comes down on its targets. It echoes, with bitter irony, the false prophets' promise in v.17 that 'no harm will come upon you' (same preposition).
-
רֹאשׁ
rosh · H7218A
head · v19
'Head', singular, applied to a group. It pictures the blow landing directly on each person, and in Hebrew idiom something 'on the head' of a person is the consequence that is theirs to bear (compare 'his blood be on his head').
-
רְשָׁעִים
resha'im · H7563
-
לֹא
lo · H3808
not · v20, v21
A flat negation placed first for emphasis: the very first thing heard is 'Not!' It cuts against the false prophets' promise in v.17 that 'no harm will come upon you.'
-
יָשׁוּב
yashuv · H7725
-
אַף־
af · H639
nose, nostril; anger · v20
Literally 'nose.' Hebrew speaks of anger through the image of flaring, snorting nostrils. Here it means God's judicial anger against covenant-breaking Judah, the force behind the storm of v.19.
-
עַד־
ad · H5704
until · v20
Sets the limit of the anger: it runs until a goal is reached. The anger has a purpose and an end point; it is not endless.
-
עֲשֹׂתוֹ
asoto · H6213
to do, make, carry out · v20
'His doing,' a verbal noun with 'his': until he has done or carried out. It is the first of a pair of verbs that together stress complete execution.
-
הֲקִימוֹ
haqimo · H6965
-
מְזִמּוֹת
mezimmot · H4209
-
לִבּוֹ
libbo · H3820
heart, mind, will · v20
In Hebrew the 'heart' is mainly where a person thinks, decides and plans, not mainly where they feel. 'The purposes of his heart' means what God has firmly made up his mind to do.
-
בְּאַחֲרִית
be'acharit · H319
end, latter part, outcome, sequel · v20
'In the after-part of.' The word means the later part or outcome of something, what comes afterward. It does not mean the end of the world.
-
הַיָּמִים
hayyamim · H3117
days · v20
With the previous word: 'in the after-part of the days,' meaning 'later on, in days to come.' In context this means once the judgment has actually fallen.
-
תִּתְבּוֹנְנוּ
titbonenu · H995
consider, discern, gain insight · v20
A reflexive form of the verb 'understand': to look into something closely until it becomes clear. The 'you' is plural: the people (and their prophets) who will see the truth only after events prove it.
-
בָהּ
vah · H9034
in/into it · v20
'Into it.' The feminine 'it' most naturally means 'the matter' in general (Hebrew often uses the feminine for that). It may also point back to the storm (se'arah, a feminine noun) of v.19.
-
בִּינָה
binah · H998
understanding, insight · v20
A noun from the same root as the verb before it: literally 'you will understand it with understanding.' Hebrew uses this kind of echo for emphasis, so it means 'you will understand it clearly, fully.'
-
שָׁלַ֥חְתִּי
shalachti · H7971
-
הַנְּבִאִ֖ים
hanneviʾim · H5030
the prophets · v21
The definite article points back to the prophets just condemned (vv. 9–20), those promising 'peace'. So English 'these prophets' is a fair rendering. God does not deny that they are prophets by profession, only that he sent them.
-
וְהֵ֣ם
vehem · H1992
and they · v21
Hebrew verbs already carry their subject, so adding the pronoun 'they' is emphatic: 'but *they*, on their own'. It sets the prophets' action against God's non-action.
-
רָ֑צוּ
ratsu · H7323
they ran · v21
To run, and in particular to run as a courier carrying a message (2 Sam 18:19–27). The picture is messengers dashing out with a dispatch that was never handed to them.
-
דִבַּ֥רְתִּי
dibbarti · H1696
I spoke · v21
God gave them no words. The verb is related to 'my words' (devarai) in v. 22, the thing a true prophet would have carried.
-
אֲלֵיהֶ֖ם
'aleihem · H0413
to them · v21
'To them', meaning addressed to them directly. A prophet is first someone who has been spoken to, and only then someone who speaks.
-
נִבָּֽאוּ׃
nibba'u · H5012
they prophesied · v21
They delivered oracles, speaking publicly as God's mouthpiece with formulas like 'thus says the LORD' (compare v. 31, 'they wag their tongues and declare, The LORD declares'). The word is about claiming to speak for God, not mainly about foretelling.
-
וְאִֽם־
ve'im · H0518A
and if · v22
Opens a condition. Verse 21 has just said God did not send these prophets, so the 'if' describes something that did not happen: 'but if they had…'. The 'and' works here as 'but'.
-
עַמִּ֔י
ʿammi · H5971A
people, kin-group · v22
'My people' is the language of the covenant. Even while judgment is coming, God still calls them his own. The prophets have failed people who belong to him.
-
מִדַּרְכָּ֣ם
midarkam · H1870G
way, road, conduct · v22
'From their way.' A road you walk on, standing for a settled pattern of living. Hebrew has the singular 'way' here, which BSB turns into the plural 'ways'.
-
הָרָ֔ע
haraʿ · H7451H
-
וּמֵרֹ֖עַ
umeroaʿ · H7455
badness, evil quality · v22
'And from the badness of…' An abstract noun from the same root as 'evil' just before it. Repeating the sound drives the point home: evil way, evil of their deeds.
-
מַֽעַלְלֵיהֶֽם׃
maʿaleleihem · H4611
The world behind it
Jeremiah's conflict with the "peace" prophets. Jeremiah worked in Jerusalem from about 627 to 586 BC, the last decades before Babylon destroyed the city. Other prophets, many of them attached to the temple and the royal court, kept announcing shalom ("peace, well-being, safety"). They meant that Jerusalem was safe and Babylon would be beaten (Jer 6:14; 8:11; 14:13; ch. 28, where Hananiah predicts the exiles will return within two years). Jeremiah 23:9–40 is a collection of sayings against these prophets. Verse 18 is the heart of his case: how do you tell a true message from a false one?
The divine council. People across the ancient Near East pictured the high god ruling from a throne, surrounded by an assembly of heavenly beings who stood in attendance, talked over matters and carried out decrees. Ugaritic texts (from Syria, about 1300 BC) speak of the "assembly of El", and Mesopotamian texts of the assembly of the gods that fixes destinies. Israel's Scriptures use the same picture with YHWH as the one supreme king. In 1 Kings 22:19–23, Micaiah reports seeing "YHWH sitting on his throne, and all the host of heaven standing beside him" while they discuss how to bring down King Ahab. In Isaiah 6 the prophet overhears the throne room ask, "Whom shall I send?" Psalm 82, Job 1–2 and Zechariah 3 show similar scenes.
In this picture a prophet is a messenger of the court. Ancient royal messengers were sent out from the king's presence and spoke in his name ("Thus says the king…"). That is why Israelite prophecy so often opens with "Thus says YHWH." Jeremiah's hearers would have heard the question as a sharp challenge: Have these men been admitted to the palace at all? Then where did they get their message?
From the study of Jeremiah 23:18.
Where scholars differ
in v18
Is 'who?' aimed only at the false prophets, or does it mean no human being can stand in YHWH's council?
-
It targets the peace-prophets: none of *them* has stood there, though a true prophet like Jeremiah has.
Verse 22 assumes the council is open to true prophets ('if they had stood in my council, they would have proclaimed my words'). Jeremiah is promised he will 'stand before' YHWH (15:19), and Amos 3:7 and 1 Kgs 22 show prophets with access. BSB, NIV and ESV build this reading in with 'of them / among them'.
-
It is a wisdom-style question meaning no mortal at all has access to God's council, perhaps a later scribal comment.
Similar questions expect a universal 'no one': Job 15:8 ('Have you listened in the council of God?'), Isa 40:13–14, Prov 30:4. On this reading v. 18 is in tension with v. 22, which is why some commentators (e.g., McKane, Carroll) treat it as a secondary insertion.
in v18
Does the final shamaʿ mean 'heard' or 'obeyed'?
-
'Heard', meaning actually received the message.
It parallels 'see and hear his word' in the first half, and the whole verse is about access to the council and receiving its message (vv. 16, 21–22).
-
'Obeyed', meaning heeded and acted on it.
Shamaʿ often means obey, and v. 22 links true prophecy with turning people from evil. BSB takes this line.
in v19
Do verses 19–20 belong here, or were they copied in from 30:23–24?
-
They are secondary here, inserted from ch. 30 (or both are drawn from a common stock of sayings).
Verses 19–20 interrupt the flow from v.18 to v.21, which reads smoothly ('Who has stood in the council?... I did not send these prophets'). An identical doublet elsewhere suggests an editor placed them. This view is held by several critical commentators (e.g. McKane, Holladay, with variations).
-
They are in place, as the actual content of the council word.
Verse 18 asks who has heard Yahweh's word in the council. Verses 19–20 then give that word: a storm, not peace. This answers the false prophets' 'no harm will come upon you' (v.17) by reusing their own preposition 'upon'. Reuse of oracles is typical of Jeremiah (e.g. Lundbom).
in v19
What does the final verb yachul mean?
-
'Whirl / swirl down'.
It is the same root as mitcholel earlier in the line, so it continues the storm's motion and creates deliberate sound-play (BSB, NASB, NIV).
-
'Burst / fall heavily'.
A looser contextual rendering of the storm's impact (ESV, WEB, Vulgate erumpens).
-
'Writhe / cause pain' or 'endure, remain'.
The root has a well-attested sense of writhing in pain (KJV 'grievously'), and a separate sense 'be firm, last' (Job 20:21; Ps 10:5), followed by YLT's 'stayeth'.
in v19
Who are 'the guilty' (resha'im)?
-
Mainly the false prophets.
The whole section 23:9–40 is directed against the prophets, and v.11 calls prophet and priest godless.
-
The prophets together with the people who followed them.
Verse 17 has the prophets speaking to 'everyone who walks in the stubbornness of his heart', and the parallel in 30:23–24 has a wider horizon of judgment on the nation.
in v20
Does 'acharit hayyamim' here point to the end of history or simply to 'afterwards'?
-
Relative sense: 'later on, after these events,' i.e. after the judgment on Judah.
The immediate context is the dispute with the false prophets (vv.17–22). Gen 49:1, Num 24:14 and Deut 31:29 use the phrase for the future of a nation within history. Deut 32:29 links understanding to one's 'latter end.' Most critical commentaries (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom, McKane) and the lexicons (HALOT, TDOT) take this view.
-
A future turning point with a wider, end-of-the-age horizon.
In the doublet at 30:24 the same lines lead into promises of restoration (30:18–31:40). Isa 2:2, Mic 4:1 and Hos 3:5 use the phrase for a decisive future turning. Later Jewish readers, as at Qumran, heard it as end-time language. Some interpreters therefore see the line opening toward a more distant fulfilment, especially in its ch. 30 setting.
in v20
Which setting of the doublet is original, 23:19–20 or 30:23–24?
-
Original in ch. 23, and reused in ch. 30.
It fits tightly between v.18 (the council of the LORD) and vv.21–22 (prophets not sent). Many read it as the very message the false prophets failed to hear.
-
Original in ch. 30, or an independent saying placed in both.
Some scholars see vv.19–20 as interrupting the flow from v.18 to v.21. On this view it was inserted into ch. 23 from a collection of oracles, and the shorter 30:24 (without binah) supports the idea that the ch. 23 form was expanded.
in v21
Were these prophets conscious frauds, or sincere but self-deceived?
-
Sincere but self-deceived: they mistook their own hopes and the nation's assumptions for revelation.
Jeremiah says they speak 'a vision of their own heart' (v. 16) and 'the deceit of their own heart' (v. 26). Their message drew on genuine earlier traditions of Zion's inviolability (compare Isaiah's assurances in 701 BCE, Isa 37:33–35).
-
Knowingly deceptive or at least culpably careless.
'They steal my words from one another' (v. 30); they 'use their tongues' to say 'declares the LORD' (v. 31); they 'strengthen the hands of evildoers' (v. 14); Micah 3:5, 11 links prophetic oracles to payment.
-
The text does not decide motive; its criterion is commission and content, not inner sincerity.
Verse 21 judges by what God did or did not do (send, speak), and v. 22 by the fruit (turning people from evil). Scholars such as J. L. Crenshaw (*Prophetic Conflict*) stress that listeners at the time had no reliable outside test for motive.
in v21
How could hearers tell a sent prophet from an unsent one?
-
By fulfillment.
Deut 18:21–22; Jeremiah himself applies it in 28:9 ('when the word of that prophet comes to pass').
-
By moral content and its effect: a true word confronts sin and calls for repentance.
Jer 23:14, 17, 22; Jer 28:8 (true prophets have historically prophesied war and disaster); Mic 3:5–8.
-
By access to the divine council, which only God can confirm, so the matter is finally left to God.
Jer 23:18, 22; 1 Kgs 22:19–23. Some scholars note that this criterion could not be checked at the time, which is why Jeremiah's conflict with Hananiah ends in a standoff until God acts (Jer 28:10–17).
in v22
Does *sod* here mean God's heavenly assembly or a more personal 'confidence' with God?
-
The heavenly council: the prophet is pictured as standing among God's attendants at the throne.
'Stand' is the posture of courtiers (1 Kgs 22:19). There are close parallels in 1 Kgs 22, Isa 6, Job 15:8 and Ps 89:7, and the council language of 23:18 ('see and hear his word'). This is the majority view in modern commentaries (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom) and in divine-council studies (e.g. E. T. Mullen).
-
Intimate confidence: *sod* stresses private, trusted friendship with God rather than an assembly scene.
*Sod* often means a confidential circle or secret (Ps 25:14; Prov 11:13; Amos 3:7). The Septuagint did not render it as 'assembly'. The two views overlap, because in the ancient world the king's council *was* the circle of his confidants.
in v22
Is the condition contrary to fact ('if they had…') or a present challenge ('if they have…, let them…')?
-
Contrary to fact: they did not stand in the council, and the absence of repentance proves it.
It follows directly on v. 21 ('I did not send… I did not speak to them'). Nearly all modern translations read it this way.
-
A present test or challenge: if they truly have stood there, let them prove it by making the people hear and turn.
The verb forms are not marked as unreal, and the YLT renders them in the present. In this reading the verse works as an open criterion, much like Deut 18:21–22 and Jer 28:8–9.
in v22
Is 'turning people from evil' the test of a true prophet, or one sign among others?
-
The decisive test in this passage: the fruit of the message shows where it came from.
It contrasts directly with 23:14 ('so that no one turns from his evil') and 23:17 (the message of peace). Jer 28:8–9 also treats warning prophecy as the normal pattern.
-
One test among several: Deuteronomy also uses fulfilment (18:22) and loyalty to YHWH alone (13:1–5).
Jeremiah himself uses fulfilment as a test for prophecies of peace (28:9). Within 23:9–40, the issues of source (dreams, stolen words) and effect (encouraging evildoers) work together.
Sources
- HALOT s.v. סוֹד
- BDB s.v. סוֹד, קָשַׁב, עָמַד
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 23:16–22
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 21–36 (Anchor Bible)
- W. McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC)
- R. P. Carroll, Jeremiah (OTL)
- H. W. Robinson, 'The Council of Yahweh', JTS 45 (1944)
- F. M. Cross, 'The Council of Yahweh in Second Isaiah', JNES 12 (1953)
- E. C. Kingsbury, 'The Prophets and the Council of Yahweh', JBL 83 (1964)
- E. T. Mullen, The Divine Council in Canaanite and Early Hebrew Literature (1980)
- Masoretic Ketiv/Qere note at Jer 23:18 (BHS apparatus)
- BDB s.v. חוּל, סַעַר, חֵמָה, רָשָׁע
- HALOT s.v. סְעָרָה, חֵמָה, חוּל I
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 23:9–40
- W. McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC), on 23:19–20
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 21–36 (Anchor Bible), on 23:19–20 and 30:23–24
- Rahlfs-Hanhart, Septuaginta, Ieremias 23:19
- Biblia Sacra Vulgata (Weber-Gryson), Hieremias 23:19
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 23 (divine council; storm-god imagery)
- BDB s.v. אַף, מְזִמָּה, אַחֲרִית, בִּין
- HALOT s.v. מְזִמָּה; s.v. אַחֲרִית
- TDOT s.v. 'acharit' (H. Seebass)
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
- W. McKane, Jeremiah (ICC), vol. 1
- J. A. Thompson, The Book of Jeremiah (NICOT)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Jeremiah 23:20
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 23:20
- HALOT s.v. שׁלח, רוץ, נבא, נָבִיא
- BDB s.v. רוּץ (ptc. 'runners, couriers'), שָׁלַח, נָבָא
- J. L. Crenshaw, Prophetic Conflict: Its Effect upon Israelite Religion (1971)
- M. Nissinen, Prophets and Prophecy in the Ancient Near East (SBL Writings from the Ancient World)
- Lachish Ostracon 3 (c. 589 BCE)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 23
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Jer 23:21; Vulgate Jer 23:21
- BDB s.v. סוֹד, עָמַד, שׁוּב (Hiphil), שָׁמַע (Hiphil), רֹעַ, מַעֲלָל
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 21–36 (Anchor Bible), on 23:18–22
- E. T. Mullen, The Divine Council in Canaanite and Early Hebrew Literature
- Septuagint Jeremiah 23:18, 22 (ὑπόστημα / ὑπόστασις)
- Vulgate Jeremiah 23:22 (consilium)
- Supplied OSHB-style morphology and BSB/KJV/WEB/YLT texts
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).