Job Chapter 13 Read as one passage

Job 13:4–5

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

4You, however, smear with lies; you are all worthless physicians. 5If only you would remain silent; for that would be your wisdom!

What the first hearers heard

To the first hearers of Job, this was a shocking reversal. The friends speak the standard wisdom of the day: the righteous do well and the wicked suffer. The audience would have expected that view to be the "healthy" one. Job calls it a fake cure. He says their teaching is spread over his wound to cover it, not to heal it, and that it is sheqer, falsehood. In Israel that word carried the weight of false witness in court and of false prophets promising peace.

The verse also helps set up the legal contest that runs through chapter 13. Job is going to argue his case before God (v. 3). He has just disqualified his friends as both doctors and witnesses. Verses 7-11 go further and warn them that God himself will rebuke people who lie to defend him. The audience learns that defending God with untruth is not piety, a lesson the book's ending confirms (42:7-8).

From the study of Job 13:4.

Verse by verse

  1. 4You, however, smear with lies; you are all worthless physicians.

    "But you, all of you, are plasterers of falsehood, healers whose medicine is nothing."

    Job has just said (v. 3) that he wants to take his case straight to God, the Almighty. Now he swings round to face his three friends with the same strong "but": But I, I will speak to God... but you... The picture is a sick man and his doctors. Job sits covered in sores (2:7-8). His friends came as healers to treat and comfort him (2:11). Their "treatment" has been a coat smeared over the wound, the way a healer daubs on a plaster or salve. But what they spread on is falsehood: the claim that his suffering proves he has sinned. It covers the sore with a tidy explanation and leaves the real problem untouched. So Job calls them healers of nothing. The word he uses is the one the prophets used to mock idols as empty "nothings". The verse ends on "all of you": no friend is excused. In the next verses he says that their best medicine would be silence (v. 5), and that their falsehood is worse because it is told on God's behalf (vv. 7-8).

    Full study →
  2. 5If only you would remain silent; for that would be your wisdom!

    "If only, if only you would shut your mouths completely! Then your silence would pass for wisdom, the only wisdom you have shown."

    Job uses the old Hebrew wish formula "who will give…?", meaning "oh that…!". It is the same cry he uses when longing to find God or to have his words carved in rock. Here he turns it on his three friends. He doubles the verb for silence ("being silent, be silent"): he does not want them to tone it down, he wants them to stop altogether. The verb is the one used for deliberately holding one's tongue, and it calls up a proverb every sage knew: "Even a fool who keeps silent is considered wise" (Proverbs 17:28). So the barb is double-edged. Silence really would be the wise and skilful thing to do. But Job is also saying their silence is the only wisdom they could ever show, because their speeches have shown none. The line ends on the word wisdom, the very thing the friends claim to own as heirs of the old tradition (compare 12:2, "wisdom will die with you!"). It probably also looks back to the beginning of the story, when the friends sat with him seven days and said nothing (2:13). Those silent days were the one time they got it right. The verse follows straight on from v. 4, where Job calls them "plasterers of lies" and "worthless healers". The point is: healers who can only do harm should at least do no more. And it leads into v. 6: now that they are quiet, they should listen to his case.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v4

    forgers of lies (KJV, WEB, YLT 'forgers of falsehood')

    tofelei shaqer

    What we hear
    Counterfeiters, people who fake documents or signatures, or at most people who make up stories.
    What they heard
    'Smearers' or 'plasterers' of falsehood: people who daub a coat of untruth over something, like plaster on a wall or salve on a wound. It is part of the same medical picture as the 'physicians' that follow.
  • in v5

    wisdom

    ḥokmâ

    What we hear
    Inner depth, spiritual insight, or intellectual brilliance.
    What they heard
    Practical skill and sound judgment, shown in how a person acts and speaks. Here it is specifically the skill of knowing when not to speak, the sages' ideal of restrained speech.
  • in v5

    hold your peace (KJV)

    heḥĕrîš

    What we hear
    Keep inner calm or stay peaceful; or, from wedding vows, 'stay quiet forever'.
    What they heard
    Simply to keep silent, to refrain from speaking or answering. 'Peace' in this old English idiom means quiet, not tranquillity or reconciliation.
Every word
  1. וְאוּלָם

    we'ulam · H0199

    but, however · v4

    A strong 'but' that sets up a sharp contrast. Verse 3 also opens with ulam ('But I, to the Almighty I will speak'), so the two verses line up: 'But I... but you...' Job turns away from God for a moment to face his friends.

  2. אַתֶּם

    'attem · H0859D

    you (masculine plural) · v4

    An emphatic 'you', placed first. Hebrew doesn't need the pronoun with a participle, so spelling it out points the finger: 'As for you...' It is set against the 'I' of verse 3.

  3. טֹפְלֵי־

    tofelei · H2950

    to smear, plaster over · v4

    A participle used as a noun, 'smearers of / plasterers of'. It is a picture of daubing a coat over something: plaster on a wall, ointment on a wound. Their words are a coating spread over Job's case that covers it without dealing with it.

  4. שָׁקֶר

    shaqer · H8267

    falsehood, deception · v4

    What they smear on is 'falsehood': statements that do not match reality. Job means their claim that his suffering proves his guilt. In verses 7–8 he says outright that this is falsehood spoken on God's behalf.

  5. רֹפְאֵי

    rofe'ei · H7495

    to heal; healer, physician · v4

    Another participle used as a noun, 'healers of'. The friends came to treat a sick man (2:11). Job grants them the role and then empties it: they are healers whose treatment does nothing.

  6. אֱלִל

    'elil · H0457

    worthlessness, nothing; (elsewhere) idol · v4

    Here it means 'nothingness, worthlessness', not 'idol'. 'Healers of nothing' are healers whose remedies are empty. The word is often used to mock idols as 'nothings', so it carries contempt.

  7. כֻּלְּכֶם

    kullekhem · H3605

    all (of you) · v4

    'All of you' comes last for emphasis. Eliphaz, Bildad and Zophar are judged together, with no exceptions.

  8. מִֽי־

    mî · H4310

    who? · v5

    The first half of a fixed Hebrew wish formula. On its own it asks 'who?', but together with the next word it no longer asks a real question. It means 'if only…' or 'oh that…'.

  9. יִ֭תֵּן

    yittēn · H5414G

    give · v5

    'Will he give', completing the idiom 'who will give…?' = 'if only!' No giver is in view. The phrase expresses a longing that Job does not expect to be granted. He uses the same formula in 6:8, 14:4, 19:23 and 23:3.

  10. הַחֲרֵ֣שׁ

    haḥărēš · H2790B

    be quiet · v5

    An infinitive (the bare verb-noun, 'being silent') placed before the finite form of the same verb. Hebrew uses this doubling for emphasis: 'utterly', 'completely', 'really'.

  11. וּתְהִ֖י

    ūtəhî · H1961

    to be · v5

    'And it would be', the result of the wish. The unstated subject is the silence itself: 'that silence would count as…'.

  12. לָכֶ֣ם

    lākem · H9036

    to/for you · v5

    'For you' or 'to your credit'. The plural keeps the target on all three friends together.

  13. לְחָכְמָֽה׃

    ləḥokmâ · H2451

    wisdom · v5

    'As wisdom' or 'for wisdom'. Hebrew uses 'be + for' to mean 'turn into' or 'count as'. Their silence would count as the wisdom their speeches have failed to show. This is the word the friends' whole claim to authority rests on, and it ends the line as the punchline.

The world behind it

Where this falls in the book. Job 12–14 is Job's reply to Zophar and closes the first round of speeches. All three friends have argued the same thing: God is just, so suffering is punishment, so Job should confess and repent. The reader knows from chapters 1–2 that this is not why Job is suffering. When Job calls their words "falsehood", the book's own framing backs him, and God says so in 42:7-8 ("you have not spoken of me what is right, as my servant Job has").

Healers and comforters. The friends' visit in 2:11 was a formal sympathy visit, "to console him and to comfort him". In the ancient Near East, visiting the sick and grieving came with expected roles: sitting in silence, lamenting, giving words of comfort. Healers in Israel, Egypt and Mesopotamia treated wounds with salves, plasters and bandages, often alongside prayer. Job turns the friends' role against them. They act like doctors, but all they do is smear a useless coating on the wound. Jeremiah uses the same idea for leaders who "heal the wound of my people lightly" with false assurances (Jer 6:14; 8:11).

From the study of Job 13:4.

Where scholars differ

in v4

What does tafal mean here: 'smear/plaster' or 'slander'?

  • 'Smear, plaster over': Job is picturing a coat or plaster of falsehood.

    Job 14:17 uses the verb for 'plastering over' iniquity. Psalm 119:69 pairs it with sheqer in the same phrase ('smeared lies over me'). Later Aramaic and Hebrew use related forms for plastering. The 'physicians' in the next half suggest a salve or bandage being applied (so Clines, Habel).

  • 'Slander, defame': Job is calling them slanderers who tell lies about him.

    Akkadian ṭapālu means 'to insult, slander', and Psalm 119:69 can be read as slander. Some translators (NIV, NLT, which add 'me') lean this way, reading the verse as an attack on Job's character.

  • Both at once: a smear that is also a slander.

    The friends do insult Job's integrity (e.g. 11:6, 'God exacts of you less than your guilt deserves'), and their false plaster on his wound is also a false charge against him. The poetry may mean both.

in v4

Is there wordplay between 'elil (worthlessness) and El (God) in v. 3?

  • Yes, deliberate: Job will go to El, while the friends offer only elil.

    The two words sit close together and sound alike. The prophets often used elil as a mocking pun against gods (e.g. Psalm 96:5, elohim / elilim).

  • Probably not deliberate.

    Elil is the ordinary word for 'worthless' in a fixed phrase like Zechariah 11:17's 'worthless shepherd', and the two words are a verse apart. The sound-echo may be coincidence.

in v5

Is Job sincerely recommending silence as wise, or sarcastically saying silence is the only wisdom they have?

  • Mainly sarcastic insult: their silence is the only wisdom they could show.

    The surrounding verses are cutting: 'plasterers of lies', 'worthless healers' (13:4), and in 12:2 'wisdom will die with you'. The echo of Prov 17:28 (the fool counted wise by keeping quiet) puts the friends in the fool's place.

  • A serious wisdom point: silence would truly be the wise and fitting response to a sufferer.

    The friends' seven days of silence in 2:13 were the right response. The wisdom tradition truly prizes restraint (Prov 10:19; 17:27). God's verdict in 42:7 confirms their speech was wrong. Many commentators hold that both meanings are meant at once, and the Hebrew allows both.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. טָפַל, אֱלִיל, רָפָא, שֶׁקֶר
  • HALOT s.v. טפל, אֱלִיל
  • D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
  • M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible)
  • Oxford English Dictionary s.v. forge, v. (sense 'to fabricate, invent')
  • BDB s.v. חָרַשׁ II (be silent, deaf)
  • HALOT s.v. חרשׁ II; s.v. חׇכְמָה
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar §113 (infinitive absolute for emphasis), §151 (מִי יִתֵּן wish formula), §47m (paragogic nun)
  • Proverbs 17:27–28; 10:19 (comparison)
  • Septuagint, Job 13:5
  • Vulgate, Job 13:5
  • Instruction of Ptahhotep; Instruction of Amenemope (the 'silent man' ideal)
  • N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (OTL)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).