John Chapter 9 Read as one passage
John 9:28–29
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
28Then they heaped insults on him and said, “You are His disciple; we are disciples of Moses. 29We know that God spoke to Moses, but we do not know where this man is from.”
What the first hearers heard
For John's first readers, this verse put a painful choice into words. Following Jesus could mean losing one's place in the synagogue community (9:22, 34). The leaders frame the choice as Jesus or Moses, newcomer or ancient tradition.
The story is built to undercut that framing. Earlier in the Gospel, Moses is a witness who points to Jesus (1:17, 45; 5:45–47). The law came through Moses, and grace and truth came through Jesus Christ. Readers would hear deep irony when men claiming Moses abuse a man whose eyes had just been opened by the one Moses wrote about.
They would also see the healed beggar as a model. He is insulted, shamed and finally expelled, yet he keeps bearing witness. And Jesus seeks him out afterward (9:35–38). The insult "you are his disciple" turns out to be true, and an honor.
From the study of John 9:28.
Verse by verse
-
28Then they heaped insults on him and said, “You are His disciple; we are disciples of Moses.
Full study →Unable to win the argument, the religious leaders turn on the healed man with open verbal abuse. They shower him with insults meant to shame him in front of everyone. The insult they choose is a label: "You — you're that fellow's disciple!" They will not even say Jesus' name. "That one" pushes him away with contempt. Then they set up the opposite pole: "But we — disciples of Moses is what we are."
In the Greek both "you" and "we" are spelled out for emphasis, so the line is built as a boundary: him on the wrong side, them on the right. "Disciple" here is not a churchly word. It means a pupil attached to a teacher's school. They are saying that the man has enrolled with an upstart nobody, while they belong to the school of Moses, Israel's lawgiver, through whom God spoke and whose authority no one disputes.
The man had just asked them sarcastically, "Do you also want to become his disciples?" They take the label he hinted at, accept it for him, and throw it back as an accusation. For John's readers the line is heavy with irony. In this Gospel, Moses is a witness for Jesus ("he wrote about me," 5:46). The people loudly claiming Moses are the ones refusing what Moses pointed to.
-
29We know that God spoke to Moses, but we do not know where this man is from.”
Full study →"We are the ones who know this: it was to Moses that God has spoken. That word still stands and still binds us. But this fellow? We have no idea where he comes from: who sent him, or what authority, if any, stands behind him."
The speakers are the Jerusalem authorities questioning the man born blind for the second time. They have just insulted him and drawn the line: "You are his disciple; we are disciples of Moses" (v. 28). Here they give their reason. God's speech to Moses is certain. It is in the perfect tense, done and still in force. Moses spoke with God "mouth to mouth", and his word is written in the Torah. Against that stands "this one", unnamed and pushed aside, whose credentials they cannot trace. "From where" (pothen) is not about his hometown. In John it is the question of whether Jesus is from God. The sentence is built as a neat pair, "we know … we do not know", and the man born blind turns it around at once: "That's the amazing thing! You don't know where he is from, and yet he opened my eyes" (v. 30). The reader of John already knows the answer the authorities lack: Jesus is "from above", sent by the Father. So their confident admission of ignorance is the very blindness Jesus names at the end of the chapter (9:39–41).
Where the English drifted
-
in v28
His disciple (capital H, BSB)
mathētēs ekeinou
- What we hear
- Capitalizing "His" makes the phrase sound respectful, as if the speakers acknowledged Jesus' dignity.
- What they heard
- "That fellow's disciple." The speakers avoid naming Jesus and use the pronoun to dismiss him.
-
in v28
disciple
mathētēs
- What we hear
- A religious word for a committed Christian believer ("discipleship").
- What they heard
- An ordinary word for a pupil or adherent of any teacher or school. The Pharisees use it of themselves as students of Moses.
-
in v29
where this man is from / where he comes from
pothen estin
- What we hear
- His hometown or geographical background, as if they did not know he came from Nazareth or Galilee.
Every word
-
ἐλοιδόρησαν
eloidorēsan · G3058
to revile, abuse verbally · v28
They let loose a burst of verbal abuse, an attempt to shame him in public. The aorist tense presents the outburst as a single event. It marks the point where the questioning turns into open hostility.
-
αὐτὸν
auton · G0846
him · v28
The man who had been born blind and was now healed. He is the target of the abuse.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v28
Joins the abuse to what they say. The words that follow are the content of the reviling.
-
εἶπον
eipon · G2036
said · v28
Introduces their retort, which answers the man's sarcastic question in 9:27, "Do you also want to become his disciples?"
-
σὺ
sy · G4771
you · v28
Greek does not need this pronoun because the verb already shows the person. Using it adds stress: "YOU are the one who is his disciple." It singles the man out.
-
μαθητὴς
mathētēs · G3101
disciple, pupil, adherent · v28
A student attached to a particular teacher. They mean this as an accusation: the man has signed up with the wrong master.
-
εἶ
ei · G1510
you are · v28, v29
A present-tense statement of where he belongs. They treat his loyalty as already fixed.
-
ἐκείνου
ekeinou · G1565
of that one · v28
"That one," "that fellow." They avoid saying Jesus' name and push him away with the pronoun. In their mouths it is dismissive, not reverent.
-
ἡμεῖς
hēmeis · G2249
we · v28
Another emphatic pronoun, set directly against "you": "but WE...". The group is drawing a boundary between itself and him.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, however · v28, v29
Marks the contrast between the two halves: his teacher against theirs.
-
τοῦ
tou · G3588
the · v28, v29
The article before a personal name is normal Greek and is left untranslated. It sets "Moses" next to the nameless "that one."
-
Μωϋσέως
Mōuseōs · G3475
Moses · v28, v29
The lawgiver. To them he stood for the Torah and for authority from God beyond question, so claiming him meant claiming the high ground.
-
ἡμεῖς
hēmeis · G3165
we · v29
Greek verbs already show who is acting, so adding the pronoun puts weight on it: "*We* know." It sets the authorities, as Moses' disciples (v. 28), against the healed man and against "this one."
-
οἴδαμεν
oidamen · G6063
we know · v29
Settled, confident knowledge, the kind a person does not expect to revise. It is the authorities' third "we know" in the chapter (see v. 24), and John makes a point of their confidence.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754
that · v29
Introduces what they know: the fact that God spoke to Moses.
-
λελάληκεν
lelalēken · G2980
has spoken · v29
This is the Greek perfect tense: God spoke to Moses in the past, and that speech still stands as binding revelation in the Torah. The point is not just "God once talked to Moses" but "God has spoken, and that settles things."
-
θεός
theos · G2316
God · v29
The God of Israel, who spoke at Sinai. He is the subject of the verb, placed at the end of the clause.
-
τοῦτον
touton · G3778
this one · v29
"This one" or "this fellow". They do not say Jesus' name, and the word is dismissive. It comes first in its clause, directly opposite "to Moses": Moses on one side, "this one" on the other.
-
οὐκ
ouk · G3756
not · v29
A plain factual "not", negating the knowing.
-
πόθεν
pothen · G4159
from where, whence · v29
"From where": origin or source. Here the question is less his hometown than whose authority stands behind him, God's or someone else's. In John, Jesus' "whence" is a recurring theme.
The world behind it
Honor and shame in public. The scene is a public hearing (9:13–34). A man born blind, who had been a beggar with no education or standing (9:8, 34), keeps answering the authorities with growing boldness and finally with sarcasm (9:27). In a culture where honor was won or lost in public exchanges, a low-status man was beating recognized teachers at their own game. Verbal abuse (loidoria) was the expected response: it shamed the challenger and restored the pecking order.
Teachers and their schools. In the ancient world, being a "disciple" meant attaching yourself to a teacher and his tradition. Philosophers, John the Baptist and the Pharisees all had disciples. The Pharisees saw themselves as faithful interpreters of the Torah handed down from Moses. Matthew 23:2 says they "sit on Moses' seat." "Disciples of Moses" therefore claims both identity and authority to interpret.
Expulsion from the synagogue. John 9:22 says the authorities had agreed that anyone confessing Jesus as Messiah would be put out of the synagogue (aposynagōgos). This verse spells that boundary out in words, and 9:34 carries it out: "they cast him out."
From the study of John 9:28.
Where scholars differ
in v28
Does the synagogue expulsion behind this scene (9:22, 34) reflect Jesus' lifetime or conditions when John's Gospel was written?
-
It reflects tensions later in the first century, between Johannine Christians and synagogue leaders, read back into the story of Jesus.
J. Louis Martyn's influential argument links *aposynagōgos* to the Birkat ha-Minim, a synagogue benediction against heretics, dated around 85–90 CE. The sharp "his disciple vs. Moses' disciples" split also fits a later, separated community.
-
Local, informal exclusion was already plausible in Jesus' day, and the Birkat ha-Minim link is weak.
The date, wording and target of the Birkat ha-Minim are uncertain (Reuven Kimelman and others). Discipline and exclusion inside synagogues existed earlier, and the Gospels elsewhere show hostility from local authorities toward Jesus' followers.
in v29
Is "we do not know where he is from" a sincere admission of uncertainty, or a dismissal that hints he is from somewhere bad?
-
It is a cautious, principled agnosticism. They cannot confirm a divine commission and will not accept one on the strength of a sign alone.
Deut 13:1–5 requires signs to be tested against obedience to God's commands. The authorities were genuinely divided (9:16). The pairing with "we know God spoke to Moses" reads as "we stick with what is certain".
-
It is a contemptuous dismissal that implies an illegitimate or even demonic source.
"This one" is unnamed and scornful, and the speakers have just "reviled" the man (9:28). Elsewhere opponents say Jesus "has a demon" (8:48, 52; 10:20) and is "a sinner" (9:24). In the Synoptic Gospels his works are attributed to Beelzebul (Mark 3:22).
in v29
Does the synagogue-expulsion background (9:22) reflect Jesus' lifetime or the later situation of John's community?
-
John tells the story on two levels at once: a scene from Jesus' ministry, and the experience of Jesus-believing Jews expelled from synagogues decades later (often linked to the "blessing against heretics", the Birkat ha-Minim).
J. Louis Martyn, *History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel*. The word ἀποσυνάγωγος ("put out of the synagogue") appears only in John (9:22; 12:42; 16:2), and 16:2 frames it as a future experience of the disciples.
-
A single, empire-wide expulsion decree is unlikely. Local exclusions, or tensions already present in Jesus' lifetime, are a better explanation.
Studies of the Birkat ha-Minim (e.g. R. Kimelman) question its date, wording and target. Others (e.g. A. Reinhartz, and those who stress local disciplinary practice) argue that disciplinary exclusion was possible on a local scale at various times.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. λοιδορέω
- BDAG s.v. μαθητής
- BDAG s.v. ἐκεῖνος
- LSJ s.v. λοιδορέω
- Septuagint Exod 17:2; Num 20:3
- Babylonian Talmud, Yoma 4a ("disciples of Moses")
- J. Louis Martyn, History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel
- R. Kimelman, "Birkat Ha-Minim and the Lack of Evidence for an Anti-Christian Jewish Prayer"
- Raymond E. Brown, The Gospel according to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
- Craig S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
- NA28 apparatus, John 9:28
- BDAG s.v. πόθεν
- BDAG s.v. οἶδα
- BDAG s.v. λαλέω
- BDAG s.v. οὗτος
- LSJ s.v. πόθεν
- LXX Exod 33:11; Num 12:8; Deut 13:1–5; 18:15–22; 34:10; Judg 13:6
- Sirach 45:5; Philo, De Vita Mosis
- Mishnah Shabbat 7:2
- Babylonian Talmud Yoma 4a ("disciples of Moses")
- Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 8, 110 (hidden Messiah)
- R. E. Brown, The Gospel According to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
- C. K. Barrett, The Gospel According to St John
- C. S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
- J. L. Martyn, History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel
- D. B. Wallace, Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics (perfect tense)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).