Joshua Chapter 19 Read as one passage
Joshua 19:41–44
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
41The territory of their inheritance included Zorah, Eshtaol, Ir-shemesh, 42Shaalabbin, Aijalon, Ithlah, 43Elon, Timnah, Ekron, 44Eltekeh, Gibbethon, Baalath,
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers this verse did several things.
- It recorded title. Town lists in Joshua 13–19 work like a land register. They state which clans have a God-given claim to which places. Naming Zorah, Eshtaol and Ir-shemesh as Dan's naḥalah said that these towns belonged to Dan by divine allotment.
- It set up a sad outcome. Hearers knew that Dan did not stay here. Verse 47 and Judges 18 tell of the migration north from these very towns. The list shows what Dan was given, and the story that follows shows how much of it Dan let go.
- It recalled familiar places. "Zorah and Eshtaol" were a stock pair tied to Samson and the Danite scouts. "Sun-City" kept alive the Canaanite past of the land Israel had taken over.
From the study of Joshua 19:41.
Verse by verse
-
41The territory of their inheritance included Zorah, Eshtaol, Ir-shemesh,
Full study →"And the land that made up their allotted family holding, the share YHWH assigned them by lot to keep from generation to generation, was this: Zorah, Eshtaol, and Sun-City…"
The verse begins the town list for Dan, the seventh and last tribe to receive land by lot at Shiloh (v. 40). The word translated "territory" is literally "border", but here it means the land inside the border, because Dan gets no boundary line, only a list of towns. "Their inheritance" is not something received when someone died. It is the clan's permanent, God-assigned share of the land. The first three towns sit close together in the low hill country west of Jerusalem, around the Sorek Valley. Zorah and Eshtaol are a pair that Israel's storytellers named again and again: they bracket Samson's life (Judges 13:25; 16:31) and were the starting point of Dan's later move north (Judges 18). Ir-shemesh, "City of the Sun", carries an old Canaanite name for the sun and is very probably the town better known as Beth-shemesh, "House of the Sun".
-
42Shaalabbin, Aijalon, Ithlah,
Full study →"…and Fox-town (Shaalabbin), and Deer-town (Aijalon), and Ithlah,"
This verse is three entries in a register. It continues the list of towns that made up the inheritance (naḥalah, the family's permanent share of land) of the tribe of Dan, which began in verse 41 with Zorah, Eshtaol and Ir-shemesh. Each name is joined by a simple "and." In this kind of list that means "these too belong to Dan's share."
The names would have meant more to the first hearers than they do to us. Shaalabbin probably meant "place of foxes" or "jackals." Aijalon meant "place of deer." Both are country names taken from the animals of the scrubby low hills. Aijalon was also a famous strategic site. It commanded the valley through which the main road climbed from the coast to Gibeon and Jerusalem. It was where Joshua had told the moon to stand still (Joshua 10:12), and it had been a Canaanite town for centuries before that. Shaalabbin, which is the Shaalbim of Judges and Kings, stood a few kilometres away at the same valley mouth. Ithlah appears nowhere else, and its site is unknown. It was a small place whose name survives only in this list.
Placed next to Judges 1:34–35 and Joshua 19:47, the verse says more than "here are three towns." These were the lowland towns God assigned to Dan. Yet the Amorites kept Aijalon and Shaalbim for a long time, and Dan was eventually pushed out and migrated north. The list records Dan's rightful share, and the land still had to be held.
-
43Elon, Timnah, Ekron,
Full study →"…and Elon (probably 'Terebinth Town', named for a landmark tree), and Timnah, the border town in the Sorek valley where Samson would later court a Philistine bride, and Ekron, the great Philistine royal city on the coastal plain…"
The verse is part of a list of towns given to the tribe of Dan (Josh 19:40–46). Each name is joined by 'and', so the list reads like walking across the land town by town. The three towns run roughly from the eastern foothills westward, down the Sorek valley toward the coast. The list moves from small villages to a Philistine capital. Ekron was a city Israel did not control. Naming it here records a God-given claim that Dan was still expected to make good. Later, Hebrew hearers might also catch the sound of 'uprooting' in Ekron's name, a pun the prophet Zephaniah would use.
-
44Eltekeh, Gibbethon, Baalath,
Full study →"…and Eltekeh, and Gibbethon, and Baalath…"
This verse is three entries in a longer list (Joshua 19:41–46) of the towns assigned to the tribe of Dan. In Hebrew each name begins with "and", so the list reads like an inventory being read out item by item. The three towns lie in the western lowlands, on the border with the Philistine city of Ekron:
- Eltekeh. A town later given to Levite families. Centuries later the Assyrian king Sennacherib fought an Egyptian army on its plain.
- Gibbethon ("mound" or "height"). Also a Levite town. In the time of the kings it was still a Philistine stronghold that Israel's armies besieged.
- Baalath ("the Lady" or "Mistress"). It carries an old Canaanite goddess title in its name, and Solomon later fortified it.
The verse is not about a spiritual idea. It records a territorial claim: these places were assigned to Dan. Other texts show that much of this land stayed out of Danite hands. The Amorites and Philistines pressed Dan back (Judges 1:34), and in the end most of the tribe moved far north (Joshua 19:47; Judges 18).
Where the English drifted
-
in v41
coast (KJV)
gevul
- What we hear
- A seashore or coastline.
- What they heard
- A border, and by extension the territory inside it. Zorah, Eshtaol and Ir-shemesh are inland hill towns, nowhere near the sea.
-
in v41
inheritance
naḥalah
- What we hear
- Property passed on when someone dies.
- What they heard
- A permanent family or tribal landholding, here assigned by lot from YHWH, the land's owner. It was meant to stay in the clan from generation to generation.
Every word
-
וַיְהִ֖י
vayhi · H1961
and it was · v41
The ordinary verb 'to be' in the form Hebrew uses to carry a narrative or list forward ('and it was'). Here it simply introduces the list: 'their territory was / consisted of…'. It carries no special weight.
-
גְּב֣וּל
gevul · H1366
border; territory · v41
Basically a boundary line, and by extension the area that the boundary encloses. Since a list of towns follows rather than a boundary description, the sense here is 'territory', the land held.
-
נַחֲלָתָ֑ם
naḥalatam · H5159
inheritance, allotted holding · v41
'Their allotment': the land assigned to Dan's clans by lot (v. 40), meant to stay in their families from generation to generation. The 'their' refers back to the clans of Dan.
-
צָרְעָ֥ה
tsor'ah · H6881
Zorah · v41
A town on a ridge above the north side of the Sorek Valley, in the low hills west of Jerusalem. Later remembered as the hometown of Samson's family (Judges 13:2).
-
וְאֶשְׁתָּא֖וֹל
ve'eshta'ol · H847
and Eshtaol · v41
A town near Zorah. The two are almost always named together in the Bible as a pair ('between Zorah and Eshtaol', Judges 13:25; 16:31). Its exact site is uncertain.
-
וְעִ֥יר
ve'ir · H5905
and city (of) · v41
'And City-of…', the first half of a two-word place name. 'Ir' is the common word for a settlement, usually a walled one.
-
וְשַֽׁעֲלַבִּ֥ין
veshaʿalabbin · H8169
and Shaalabbin (Shaalbim) · v42
A town in the low hills (the Shephelah) north-west of the Aijalon valley. Its name probably comes from shuʿal, 'fox' or 'jackal', so roughly 'place of foxes'. The 'and' carries on the list of Danite towns that began in verse 41.
-
וְאַיָּל֖וֹן
veʾayyalon · H0357
and Aijalon · v42
The best-known town on the list. It guarded the valley of Aijalon, the main pass from the coastal plain up to the hill country around Jerusalem. The name comes from ʾayyal, 'deer' or 'stag', so roughly 'place of deer'.
-
וְיִתְלָֽה׃
veyitlah · H3494
and Ithlah (Jethlah) · v42
A Danite town mentioned only here. Nobody knows for certain where it was. Its name may come from a root meaning 'to hang' or 'to be raised up', perhaps describing a town on a height, but that is a guess. The large pause mark under the last word ends the verse, and the list carries on in verse 43.
-
וְאֵיל֥וֹן
ve'eilon · H0356
and Elon · v43
A town in Dan's allotted land. The name sounds like the Hebrew word for a great tree (terebinth or oak), so it probably means something like 'Terebinth Town'. The word 'and' links it into a continuing list of towns.
-
וְתִמְנָ֖תָה
vetimnatah · H8553
and Timnah · v43
Timnah, a town in the Sorek valley on the border between Dan and Judah. The ending -ah is a Hebrew suffix meaning 'toward'. In a list like this it has frozen into the name as people said it, which is why the KJV spells it 'Thimnathah'. This is the Timnah of the Samson stories.
-
וְעֶקְרֽוֹן׃
ve'ekron · H6138
and Ekron · v43
Ekron was one of the five chief Philistine cities, on the coastal plain at the edge of Dan's allotment. Putting it in Dan's list claims it as Israelite land, even though the Philistines held it for most of Israel's history.
-
וְאֶלְתְּקֵ֥ה
ve'eltekeh · H0514
and Eltekeh · v44
A town in the coastal lowland given to the tribe of Dan. It is later named as a town given to Levite families (Joshua 21:23). The 'and' (ve-) joins it to the list of towns that runs through verses 41–46.
-
וְגִבְּת֖וֹן
vegibbeton · H1405
and Gibbethon · v44
A town in Dan's lowland territory. The name probably means something like 'mound' or 'height'. It too became a Levite town (Joshua 21:23). In the books of Kings it is a Philistine-held stronghold that Israel's armies besieged.
-
וּבַעֲלָֽת׃
uva'alat · H1191
and Baalath · v44
A town of Dan whose name means 'Lady' or 'Mistress', the feminine form of ba'al ('lord, owner'). Solomon later fortified a town of this name (1 Kings 9:18). The large pause mark (silluq) and the end-of-verse mark close the verse, but the list carries on into verse 45.
The world behind it
Where Dan's lot lay. The towns of vv. 41–46 cover the strip between Judah, Ephraim and the coastal plain: the Shephelah (the low foothills west of Jerusalem) and the valleys of Sorek and Aijalon leading down toward Joppa (v. 46). This was a corridor between the highlands and the coast. It was fought over by the older Canaanite towns and later by the Philistines.
Overlap with Judah. Zorah and Eshtaol also appear in Judah's list (Josh 15:33), and Beth-shemesh is on Judah's northern border (15:10) and is a Levitical city of Judah (21:16). The same towns turn up under different tribes because the border region changed hands, and because Dan did not keep its hold (see below).
Dan's failure to hold the lot. Right after the list, Joshua notes that the territory "was lost to them" (v. 47, Hebrew literally "went out from them"), and Dan took Leshem/Laish in the far north. Judges 1:34 says the Amorites pushed Dan back into the hills. Judges 18 tells how Danite men "from Zorah and Eshtaol" scouted out Laish and migrated there. Samson's story (Judges 13–16) is set in the same few square miles, among Danites still living around Zorah and Eshtaol under Philistine pressure. For an ancient hearer, then, the names in this verse called up a story: the allotment Dan was given, and the allotment Dan could not keep.
From the study of Joshua 19:41.
Where scholars differ
in v41
Is Ir-shemesh the same town as Beth-shemesh?
-
Yes, they are two names for one town (most scholars).
Both names mean 'sun city/house' and lie in the same area beside Zorah and Eshtaol. Beth-shemesh is never listed separately in Dan's list. 'Har-heres' ('Mount of the Sun') in Judg 1:35 is named with Aijalon and Shaalbim, as here in v. 42. Beth-shemesh is also grouped with Shaalbim in 1 Kgs 4:9.
-
They are separate or uncertain sites.
The two names are different, and Beth-shemesh is credited to Judah and the Levites (Josh 15:10; 21:16). Some cautious atlases mark the identification as probable, not certain.
in v41
What period does Dan's town list come from?
-
It reflects an early tribal allotment.
The book presents the list as the allotment at Shiloh. Its overlap with Judah fits a contested border zone that Dan later abandoned (Judg 1:34; 18).
-
It was drawn from a later administrative list (since A. Alt and others).
The towns overlap heavily with Judah's district lists (Josh 15) and with Solomon's second district (1 Kgs 4:9, which names Shaalbim and Beth-shemesh). This suggests that the list may preserve a later administrative roster arranged in tribal form.
in v42
Where was Ithlah?
-
The site is unknown.
The name appears only here and has not been found in any later Arabic place name. Most atlases mark it with a question mark or leave it off.
-
It lay somewhere in the Aijalon–Timnah lowland, between the towns listed beside it.
Town lists in Joshua often follow geographic clusters. Ithlah comes between Aijalon (v. 42) and Elon and Timnah (v. 43), and scholars have offered ruins in that area on that basis. These are educated guesses, not firm identifications.
in v42
What is Dan's town list based on?
-
It comes from a later list of administrative districts, perhaps from the monarchy, reused to describe Dan's share.
Many Danite towns also appear in Judah's district lists (Joshua 15) and in Solomon's districts (1 Kings 4:9 names Shaalbim). Scholars such as Albrecht Alt and Yohanan Aharoni argued that lists like this reflect later arrangements of the kingdom.
-
It keeps an early memory of Dan's original area in the lowlands, before the tribe moved north.
Joshua 19:47, Judges 1:34–35 and Judges 18 all link Dan with Zorah, Eshtaol and the Aijalon area before the move to Laish. The list fits that early stage, whatever its later editing.
in v43
Where was Elon?
-
It is the same place as Elon-beth-hanan of 1 Kings 4:9, somewhere near Shaalbim and Aijalon.
1 Kings 4:9 groups Elon-beth-hanan with Shaalbim (Shaalabbin, Josh 19:42) and Beth-shemesh, the same area as this list.
-
Its location is simply unknown.
No site has been confirmed by an inscription or a surviving ancient name. Proposals such as Khirbet Wadi ʿAlin remain guesses.
in v43
Did Israel ever hold Ekron?
-
Ekron was allotted but never really controlled by Dan or Judah. The list is a claim, not a description of who held it.
Josh 13:2–3 counts Philistine land as 'remaining'. Judg 1:34 says Dan was kept out of the plain. Ekron is still Philistine in 1 Sam 5–7, 2 Kgs 1, Assyrian records and the Ekron inscription.
-
Judah may have controlled it briefly.
The Hebrew of Judg 1:18 says Judah captured Ekron, and 1 Sam 7:14 says cities 'from Ekron to Gath' were restored to Israel. But the Septuagint of Judg 1:18 reads the opposite, and nothing dug up at the site shows Israelite control.
in v44
Where were Eltekeh, Gibbethon and Baalath located?
-
Eltekeh = Tell esh-Shalaf (north of Yavneh); Gibbethon = Tel Malot (Tell el-Melat), near Gezer.
These fit the order of the list, next to Timnah and Ekron, and Sennacherib's route in 701 BC. Gibbethon's position near Gezer suits its role as a Philistine border fortress in 1 Kings.
-
The identifications remain uncertain, and Baalath's site is unknown.
No inscription found at any of these sites names the town. The once-favoured identification of Eltekeh with Khirbet el-Muqanna' collapsed when an inscription proved that site was Ekron. Baalath's location rests only on its being listed with Gezer and Beth-horon (1 Kings 9:17–18) and on Josephus.
in v44
What period does Dan's town list reflect?
-
It preserves an early tribal claim from before Dan migrated north.
The narrative itself (19:47; Judges 1:34; 18) presents Dan as once assigned this southern area and then pushed out.
-
It reflects a later administrative arrangement, perhaps from the monarchy.
Several of these towns appear among royal or administrative sites (Baalath in 1 Kings 9:18; nearby towns in Solomon's second district, 1 Kings 4:9). Some scholars, following Albrecht Alt, link Joshua's town lists to administrative districts of the kingdom period.
Sources
- BDB and HALOT s.v. גְּבוּל, נַחֲלָה, צׇרְעָה, אֶשְׁתָּאוֹל, עִיר שֶׁמֶשׁ
- Amarna letter EA 273 (Ṣarḫa, Ayaluna)
- Y. Aharoni, The Land of the Bible: A Historical Geography
- A. Alt, 'Judas Gaue unter Josia' (on the town lists of Joshua)
- R. G. Boling & G. E. Wright, Joshua (Anchor Bible)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Josh 19:40–48
- Oxford English Dictionary s.v. 'coast' (obsolete sense 'border, frontier')
- BDB s.v. שַׁעַלְבִים, אַיָּלוֹן, יִתְלָה
- HALOT s.v. שַׁעַלְבִים; אַיָּלוֹן; יִתְלָה
- Anchor Bible Dictionary, articles 'Aijalon', 'Shaalbim', 'Ithlah'
- A. F. Rainey & R. S. Notley, The Sacred Bridge
- W. L. Moran, The Amarna Letters, EA 273
- BDB s.v. אֵלוֹן, תִּמְנָה, עֶקְרוֹן
- HALOT s.v. אֵילוֹן, תִּמְנָה, עֶקְרוֹן
- Gitin, Dothan & Naveh, 'A Royal Dedicatory Inscription from Ekron', Israel Exploration Journal 47 (1997)
- Kelm & Mazar, excavation reports on Tel Batash (Timnah)
- Aharoni, The Land of the Bible: A Historical Geography
- Walton, Matthews & Chavalas, IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Joshua 19
- Rainey & Notley, The Sacred Bridge
- BDB s.v. אֶלְתְּקֵה, גִּבְּתוֹן, בַּעֲלָת
- HALOT s.v. אֶלְתְּקֵה, גִּבְּתוֹן, בַּעֲלָת
- Sennacherib's annals (Rassam Cylinder / Chicago-Taylor Prism), 701 BC campaign: Altaqû and Tamna
- Sargon II reliefs, Khorsabad: siege of Gabbutunu
- Josephus, Antiquities 8.152
- Anchor Bible Dictionary, entries 'Eltekeh', 'Gibbethon', 'Baalath'
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).