Judges Chapter 9 Read as one passage
Judges 9:50–57
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
50Then Abimelech went to Thebez, encamped against it, and captured it. 51But there was a strong tower inside the city, and all the men, women, and leaders of the city fled there. They locked themselves in and went up to the roof of the tower. 52When Abimelech came to attack the tower, he approached its entrance to set it on fire. 53But a woman dropped an upper millstone on Abimelech’s head, crushing his skull. 54He quickly called his armor-bearer, saying, “Draw your sword and kill me, lest they say of me, ‘A woman killed him.’” So Abimelech’s armor-bearer ran his sword through him, and he died. 55And when the Israelites saw that Abimelech was dead, they all went home. 56In this way God repaid the wickedness that Abimelech had done to his father in murdering his seventy brothers. 57And God also brought all the wickedness of the men of Shechem back upon their own heads. So the curse of Jotham son of Jerubbaal came upon them.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers, this short verse built suspense. They had just heard about the horror at Shechem's tower and the confident run of verbs, and they knew where the story ended. Thebez was a name with associations: generations later, Joab could expect King David to remember "Thebez" as the place where a woman killed a careless commander from the wall (2 Sam 11:21).
The verse belongs to the book's wider argument about kingship gone wrong. Gideon had said Israel's king was the LORD (8:23). His son took the throne by murder and spent his short reign making war on Israelite towns. The rapid march and capture show a man at the height of his power, so that the next verses can show how suddenly God brings him down. The hearers learned that violence like Abimelech's carries its own punishment, and that it can come from the hand of a single unnamed woman.
From the study of Judges 9:50.
Verse by verse
-
50Then Abimelech went to Thebez, encamped against it, and captured it.
Full study →Abimelech has just burned about a thousand men and women alive in the stronghold of Shechem (9:49). Straight from that, the self-made king, whose name means "my father is king", marches his army to Thebez, a hill town in Manasseh a few hours' walk northeast of Shechem. He sets up his siege camp in front of it, and he takes the town.
The Hebrew packs this into seven words and three quick verbs: went, camped, captured. The pace sounds like an unstoppable winning streak. The narrator also names Thebez twice, which makes the reader keep an eye on the place. The capture is not complete. A fortified tower inside the town still holds out (v. 51). The same verb that described taking Shechem (v. 45) is used here, so hearers expect another massacre by fire. Instead, Thebez is where a woman on the tower drops a millstone on him (v. 53), and Israel remembered it that way for generations (2 Sam 11:21).
-
51But there was a strong tower inside the city, and all the men, women, and leaders of the city fled there. They locked themselves in and went up to the roof of the tower.
Full study →But inside the city there stood a fortified keep, a 'tower of strength'. Abimelech had already taken Thebez, but not all of it. Every man and every woman, together with the town's citizen-lords (the same kind of landholding body that had once made Abimelech king at Shechem), ran to that one building for refuge. They shut the door behind them and barred themselves in, then climbed up onto the tower's flat roof.
To anyone who had just heard verses 46–49 the scene is ominous. At Shechem the people had also crowded into a tower stronghold, and Abimelech burned it over their heads, killing about a thousand men and women. The story seems ready to repeat itself, and verse 52 shows Abimelech going for the door with fire again. But this time the people are not trapped below. They are on the roof, above him, and from there a single woman will drop a millstone and crush his skull (v. 53). The man who killed his seventy brothers 'on one stone' (9:5) dies by a stone. The verse is the calm before that reversal: a whole town in one strong tower, door shut, standing on the roof.
-
52When Abimelech came to attack the tower, he approached its entrance to set it on fire.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
53But a woman dropped an upper millstone on Abimelech’s head, crushing his skull.
Full study →As Abimelech walks up to the door of the tower at Thebez with fire in hand, ready to burn everyone inside as he had just done at Shechem, one woman on the roof picks up the upper stone of her hand mill and hurls it down onto his head, and she shatters his skull.
The stone is not a giant wheel. It is the loaf-shaped stone a woman pushed back and forth every morning to grind the family's flour. Its everyday name was literally "the rider," because it rode on the larger stone beneath it. So the weapon is ordinary housework, and the person using it is no soldier and is never named. The Hebrew stresses that she is "one woman." The man who killed his seventy brothers "on one stone" is brought down by one woman and one stone. What is struck is his head, the head of the man who had taken power by murder, and the verb for what happens to his skull is the same one Hebrew uses for crushing and oppressing the weak.
The verse is short and blunt. The very next lines show that Abimelech understood the shame. Dying, he orders his armor-bearer to run him through "so they will not say, 'A woman killed him.'" They said it anyway, as 2 Samuel 11:21 shows.
-
54He quickly called his armor-bearer, saying, “Draw your sword and kill me, lest they say of me, ‘A woman killed him.’” So Abimelech’s armor-bearer ran his sword through him, and he died.
Full study →With his skull crushed by a hand-millstone that a woman dropped from the tower, Abimelech uses his last moments not to save his life but to shape how his death will be told. He calls in a hurry to the lad who carries his weapons, his personal squire, and says: "Draw your sword and finish me off, or people will say of me, 'A woman — she killed him!'" His attendant runs him through, and he dies.
The verse is full of irony that the first hearers would not have missed:
- Stone for stone. Abimelech had murdered his seventy brothers "on one stone" (9:5). Now a stone kills him.
- A woman's tool. The upper millstone was the hand-stone a woman turned every day to grind the family's flour, the most domestic object in the house. It brings down the man who called himself king.
- The story he couldn't stop. He uses his last breath to keep a woman's name off his death, and fails. Generations later Joab still tells it as "a woman threw an upper millstone on him" (2 Sam 11:21).
The flat closing "and he died" makes way for the narrator's verdict two verses later: this is how God paid back Abimelech's evil against his father's house (9:56–57).
-
55And when the Israelites saw that Abimelech was dead, they all went home.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
56In this way God repaid the wickedness that Abimelech had done to his father in murdering his seventy brothers.
Full study →And so God sent Abimelech's evil back to him: the harm he had done to his own father when he slaughtered his seventy brothers.
The verb pictures something being turned back to where it came from. God does not invent a fresh punishment. He makes Abimelech's own violence come home. The Hebrew word for "evil" covers both the crime and the disaster, so Abimelech's wickedness becomes his ruin: what he did is what happens to him.
The crime is described as done to his father. Gideon was already dead, but wiping out a man's sons destroyed his house, his name and his legacy. The son named "my father is king" took a crown his father had refused, and paid for it with his father's whole family.
The sentence looks back over the story. Abimelech killed his brothers "on one stone" (9:5), and he died when a woman dropped a millstone on his head (9:53). God had sent "an evil spirit" between him and his allies so that the blood of the seventy would "come upon" him (9:23-24). Now the narrator says it is done. This is the first half of a two-part verdict: verse 57 adds that the men of Shechem, who paid for the murders, also had their evil returned "on their own heads", and Jotham's curse came true.
-
57And God also brought all the wickedness of the men of Shechem back upon their own heads. So the curse of Jotham son of Jerubbaal came upon them.
Full study →"And every bit of the harm the men of Shechem had done, God sent back down on their own heads, and Jotham's curse, spoken by the son of Jerubbaal, arrived upon them."
The sentence puts their evil first for emphasis, and says all of it. The Hebrew word for "evil" means both the wrong a person does and the disaster that comes of it. So the crime the Shechemites committed, funding and backing Abimelech's slaughter of Gideon's seventy sons, became the disaster they suffered when their city was razed and a thousand people burned alive in its tower. God "made it return": the verb pictures something thrown out that comes back to land on the thrower. "On their head" is the language of blood-guilt, the guilt for shed blood falling back on the one who shed it.
The second half names the other force at work. Years earlier, Jotham, the one son who escaped, stood on Mount Gerizim (the mountain of blessing in Israel's tradition) and called down a curse: if Shechem had betrayed Jerubbaal's house, fire would come out from Abimelech and consume them, and fire from them would consume Abimelech. That curse has now "come" to them, as if it had been travelling toward them all along. The verse completes a pair. Verse 56 settled Abimelech's account, and verse 57 settles Shechem's. The narrator sums up the whole bloody chapter as an exact, God-driven reversal: the house that murdered was destroyed, the city that paid for the murder was destroyed, and the spoken word of the wronged survivor proved true.
Where the English drifted
-
in v51
tower
migdal
- What we hear
- A tall, narrow structure such as a spire, bell tower or lookout.
- What they heard
- A fortified keep or citadel: a massive building inside the city that could hold the entire population, with one barred door and a flat roof people could stand on.
-
in v51
leaders (of the city)
baʿalei haʿir
- What we hear
- A small group of officials or rulers.
- What they heard
- The 'owners' or 'lords' of the city: its landholding citizens, the body that decided the town's affairs. It is the same formula used for the 'lords of Shechem' throughout Judges 9.
-
in v53
millstone / upper millstone
pelach rekhev
- What we hear
- A huge round stone wheel like those in water mills or animal-driven grain mills, far too heavy for one person to lift, which makes the scene sound like a miracle or a crane job.
- What they heard
- The upper stone of a household saddle quern: an elongated, loaf-shaped stone that one person pushed back and forth on a larger lower stone. It was heavy but portable, a woman's everyday kitchen tool.
-
in v53
all to brake (KJV)
vattarits
- What we hear
- An ungrammatical phrase, perhaps 'in order to break,' or a typo.
- What they heard
- Shattered, broke in pieces. KJV's "all to-brake" is good older English for "utterly broke apart."
-
in v54
the young man (his armourbearer)
na'ar
- What we hear
- A youth or teenager, someone defined by being young.
- What they heard
- A personal attendant or squire, a dependent who serves a warrior. Youth is often part of it, but the word mainly marks rank and role.
-
in v56
rendered (KJV)
wayyāšeb (šûb, causative)
- What we hear
- Depicted, performed, provided or made into something ('rendered a verdict', 'rendered an image').
- What they heard
- 'Gave back, sent back, returned.' God returned Abimelech's evil to him.
-
in v56
wickedness
rāʿâ
- What we hear
- A moral fault only: bad character or a bad deed, with God then imposing some separate punishment.
- What they heard
- Evil done and evil suffered. The same word covers the crime and the disaster, so 'God returned the evil' means the harm itself came back on the man who caused it.
-
in v57
evil / wickedness
rā'āh
- What we hear
- An abstract moral quality, or for 'evil' something sinister and almost demonic; in any case only the wrong that was done.
- What they heard
- Both the harm someone does and the harm that falls on them. One word covers the crime and its disastrous result, which is exactly how this verse can say their 'evil' was 'returned' to them.
-
in v57
curse
qəlālāh
- What we hear
- A swear word, or a magic hex that works by itself.
- What they heard
- A formal, conditional call for harm, spoken by the wronged party against those who betrayed loyalty. It was expected to take effect because the wrong was real and God would act, which is why the verse pairs it with 'God returned'.
-
in v57
render (KJV)
hēšîb
- What we hear
- To depict, process or produce something (as in 'rendering' an image).
- What they heard
- In KJV English, 'render' meant to give back or pay back. The Hebrew means 'caused to return'.
Every word
-
וַיֵּ֥לֶךְ
wayyēlek · H1980
and he went · v50
The ordinary verb for going or walking, here meaning a march with an army. The 'and' form moves the story straight on from the burning of Shechem's tower (v. 49): one campaign leads directly into the next.
-
אֲבִימֶ֖לֶךְ
ʾăbîmelek · H40
Abimelech · v50, v53, v56
The name means 'my father is king'. That is pointed, because his father Gideon had refused to be king (8:23). It also sounds a little like the verb just before it (wayyēlek … ʾăbîmelek), so 'the king-man marched' rings in the ear. He has made himself king by killing his seventy brothers (9:5), and he is now fighting his own towns.
-
אֶל־
ʾel- · H413
to, toward · v50, v54, v57
Gives the direction of the march: toward Thebez.
-
תֵּבֵ֑ץ
tēbēṣ · H8405
Thebez · v50
A town in the hill country of Manasseh, usually placed at modern Tubas, about 15 km (9 miles) northeast of Shechem. It appears only here and in the retelling of Abimelech's death at 2 Samuel 11:21.
-
וַיִּ֥חַן
wayyiḥan · H2583
and he camped · v50
In a military story, chanah means setting up an army's camp in front of a town, which is the first stage of a siege. With the preposition 'in/at' (be-) it means 'camped against'.
-
וַֽיִּלְכְּדָֽהּ׃
wayyilkədāh · H3920
and he captured it · v50
Lakad means to seize, capture or trap. The suffix 'it' (literally 'her') is feminine and refers to the city, as Hebrew normally treats cities. The town falls, but a fortified tower inside it holds out (v. 51), and that tower is where he dies.
-
וּמִגְדַּל־
u-migdal · H4026
and a tower of · v51
A fortified tower or keep, a solid stone building rather than a slender spire. The 'and' marks a contrast with v. 50: Abimelech took the city, but there was still this stronghold inside it.
-
עֹז֮
ʿoz · H5797
strength · v51
Strength or might. Joined to 'tower' it means 'tower of strength', i.e. a fortified tower or citadel. It is the same phrase Proverbs 18:10 and Psalm 61:3 use as a picture of refuge.
-
הָיָ֣ה
hayah · H1961
was · v51
'There was'. A background statement that pauses the action to describe the scene before the story moves on.
-
בְתוֹךְ־
betokh · H8432
in the midst of · v51
Inside, in the middle of. The tower stood within the walls, as a last line of defense once the outer city had fallen.
-
הָעִיר֒
haʿir · H5892
the city · v51
The walled town of Thebez named in v. 50. An ʿir was a settlement with walls, often a small one by modern standards.
-
וַיָּנֻ֨סוּ
vayyanusu · H5127
and they fled · v51
They ran for refuge. This is the ordinary Hebrew word for flight from danger, often used of running to a place of safety.
-
שָׁ֜מָּה
shammah · H8033
there, thither · v51
'There', with the ending that shows direction ('to there'), pointing back to the tower.
-
כָּל־
kol · H3605
all · v51, v57
Every one. It stresses that the whole population crowded into the one building.
-
הָאֲנָשִׁ֣ים
haʾanashim · H0582
the men · v51, v57
The men. Grammatically this is the plural of ʾish, 'man'. Strong's files it under ʾenosh.
-
וְהַנָּשִׁ֗ים
vehannashim · H0802
and the women · v51, v53, v54
The women. Naming them sets up v. 53, where one woman on this roof kills Abimelech.
-
בַּעֲלֵ֣י
baʿalei · H1167
lords, owners, citizens of · v51
Literally 'owners' or 'masters' of the city: the landholding citizens who made the town's decisions. This is the phrase chapter 9 keeps using for the 'lords of Shechem' who made Abimelech king.
-
וַֽיִּסְגְּר֖וּ
vayyisgeru · H5462
and they shut · v51
They closed and secured the door. 'Door' is understood rather than written. The verb covers both closing and locking or barring.
-
בַּעֲדָ֑ם
baʿadam · H1157
behind them, about them · v51
Literally 'around them' or 'on their behalf'. With 'shut' it is a set Hebrew expression for shutting a door behind yourself so that you are closed in (compare Genesis 7:16; 2 Kings 4:4).
-
וַֽיַּעֲל֖וּ
vayyaʿalu · H5927
and they went up · v51
They climbed up, presumably by inside stairs or ladders, to the highest and most defensible point.
-
עַל־
ʿal · H5921
onto · v51, v53
Upon, onto: the place they climbed to.
-
גַּ֥ג
gag · H1406
roof of · v51
The flat roof, which in this world was usable space you could stand on. From it the defenders could throw things down on attackers (v. 53).
-
וַתַּשְׁלֵ֞ךְ
vattashlekh · H7993
to throw, cast, fling · v53
"And she threw." The verb means throwing or hurling, not simply letting go. Standing above Abimelech on the tower, she flung the stone down at him. The opening "and" carries the story straight on from verse 52: he walks up to the door to burn it, and she throws.
-
אַחַ֛ת
achat · H0259
-
פֶּ֥לַח
pelach · H6400
slice, piece, slab · v53
A cut piece or segment. Elsewhere it is a slice of pomegranate (Song 4:3) or a piece of fig cake (1 Sam 30:12). Joined to rekhev it names the loaf-shaped upper grinding stone. It may also mean a broken piece of one (see debates).
-
רֶ֖כֶב
rekhev · H7393
upper millstone (literally 'rider') · v53
From the verb "to ride." This is the top stone that "rides" back and forth on the larger bottom stone of a hand mill. Its everyday name is a chariot word (rekhev also means chariotry), which is why Young's Literal Translation has "a piece of a rider."
-
רֹ֣אשׁ
rosh · H7218
head; top; chief · v53, v57
The literal head. In Hebrew, as in English, rosh can also mean "chief" or "leader," and Abimelech had grabbed rule over Shechem by violence. Verse 57 says God brought the Shechemites' evil back "on their heads." The physical blow fits that idea of a crime coming back on the one who did it.
-
וַתָּ֖רִץ
vattarits · H7533
to crush, shatter; to oppress · v53
"And she crushed." The verb form is feminine, and the only feminine subject in the sentence is the woman, since both millstone words are masculine. So it is she who crushes, through the stone. The same verb is used elsewhere for oppressing the weak (1 Sam 12:3-4; Deut 28:33).
-
אֶת־
et · H0853
[marks the direct object] · v53, v56, v57
This word has no English equivalent. It marks "his skull" as the thing crushed.
-
גֻּלְגָּלְתּֽוֹ
gulgolto · H1538
skull; head (also 'head' in counting people) · v53
"His skull." The word comes from a root meaning "round" or "roll." Its Aramaic relative gives the name Golgotha, "place of the skull." Here it is plain and physical: his skull is broken.
-
וַיִּקְרָ֨א
vayyiqra · H7121
and he called · v54
Abimelech calls out to his attendant. He is lying with a crushed skull, so this is a dying man's summons. The narrative verb form carries the story straight on from the millstone in v. 53.
-
מְהֵרָ֜ה
mehērah · H4120
quickly, in haste · v54
The hurry is the point. He has only moments, and he spends them on how his death will be told, not on surviving.
-
הַנַּ֣עַר
hanna'ar · H5288
young man, servant, attendant · v54
His personal retainer or squire. The word names a role and a rank, a dependent who serves a fighting man, more than a precise age.
-
נֹשֵׂ֣א
nosē · H5375
carrying, bearer of · v54
An active participle (a verb used like a noun or adjective) that makes a title: 'the one who carries.' Together with the next word it is the set term for an armor-bearer.
-
כֵלָ֗יו
kēlav · H3627
his gear, implements, weapons · v54
Kli is a broad word for any made object: vessel, tool, equipment. Here it means his war-gear: shield, spare weapons, armor.
-
וַיֹּ֤אמֶר
vayyomer · H559
and he said · v54
Brings in his last words.
-
לוֹ֙
lo
to him · v54
Spoken straight to the armor-bearer.
-
שְׁלֹ֤ף
shelof · H8025
draw (out) · v54
A command: pull the sword from its sheath. It is short and urgent.
-
חַרְבְּךָ֙
ḥarbekha · H2719
your sword · v54
'Your' sword, a man's weapon in a man's hand. That is exactly the death he wants in place of the one he has already been given.
-
וּמ֣וֹתְתֵ֔נִי
umotetēni · H4191
and put me to death, finish me off · v54
A stronger form of 'die' that means 'make dead, dispatch.' It is often used for finishing off someone already mortally wounded. The Amalekite in 2 Sam 1:9 uses the same form when he reports Saul's request: 'stand over me and finish me off.'
-
פֶּן־
pen · H6435
lest, so that not · v54
Gives the purpose of the request: to head off a particular story about him.
-
לִ֖י
li
of me, about me · v54
'About me.' The preposition here means 'concerning.'
-
הֲרָגָ֑תְהוּ
haragathu · H2026
-
וַיִּדְקְרֵ֥הוּ
vayyidqerēhu · H1856
and he pierced him through · v54
Daqar means to run through or stab deeply (compare Num 25:8; 1 Sam 31:4). The servant obeys at once, and the narrator gives it a single verb.
-
וַיָּ֣שֶׁב
wayyāšeb · H7725
and he caused to return / brought back / repaid · v56, v57
The causative form of the common verb 'to turn, return': God made something go back to where it came from. It opens the narrator's closing verdict on the whole Abimelech story, and the picture is of harm sent back to its source, not a new penalty brought in from outside.
-
אֱלֹהִ֔ים
ʾĕlōhîm · H430
-
רָעַ֣ת
rāʿat · H7451
evil, wickedness, harm, disaster · v56, v57
'The evil of Abimelech' means both the wrong he committed and the harm he did. The same word can mean the disaster that comes back on him, so the wrong itself turns into the punishment. It repeats the 'evil spirit' (ruaḥ rāʿâ) God sent in 9:23.
-
אֲשֶׁ֤ר
ʾăšer · H834
which, that · v56
Introduces the description of exactly which evil is meant.
-
עָשָׂה֙
ʿāśâ · H6213
he did, made · v56
A completed act: 'which he had done'. It stresses that Abimelech himself did the deed. What comes back to him is his own doing.
-
לְאָבִ֔יו
lĕʾābîw · H1
to his father · v56
The crime is described as done *to his father*, even though the father was already dead (8:32). Wiping out a man's sons destroyed his house, his name and his future, so murdering the brothers was an attack on Jerubbaal (Gideon) himself.
-
שִׁבְעִ֥ים
šibʿîm · H7657
-
אֶחָֽיו׃
ʾeḥāyw · H251
his brothers · v56
'His brothers' (half-brothers by other mothers). Killing your own brothers was the worst possible breach of kinship duty, and the word makes the crime as personal as it gets.
-
שְׁכֶ֔ם
šəkem · H7927
Shechem · v57
The old Canaanite-Israelite city between Mount Gerizim and Mount Ebal. It was home to Abimelech's mother's clan and to the temple of Baal-berith, whose silver paid for the murders (9:4).
-
וַתָּבֹ֣א
wattābō' · H0935
and it came · v57
'And it came' is feminine because its subject is the feminine noun 'curse'. The curse is pictured arriving at them, as if it had been on its way since Jotham spoke it.
-
קִֽלֲלַ֖ת
qilălat · H7045
curse · v57
A solemn spoken call for harm to fall on wrongdoers. Here it means Jotham's conditional curse in 9:19–20: fire would consume both Abimelech and Shechem if they had acted in bad faith.
-
יוֹתָ֥ם
yôtām · H3147
-
בֶּן־
ben- · H1121
son of · v57
This identifies Jotham by his father. It reminds the reader that the crime was against Jerubbaal's household, the family Shechem owed loyalty to (9:16–18).
-
יְרֻבָּֽעַל׃
yərubbā'al · H3378
Jerubbaal · v57
Gideon's other name, explained in 6:32 as 'let Baal contend [with him]'. Chapter 9 uses this name for him throughout, which sharpens the irony that the city of Baal-berith destroyed the house of the man who tore down Baal's altar.
The world behind it
Why Thebez? The text never says. Most commentators guess that Thebez had joined Shechem's revolt under Gaal (9:26–41), or was simply one of the towns Abimelech meant to bring under control. The story does not explain it because its interest is elsewhere: the downfall of a king who took power by killing his brothers.
Towns and towers. Iron Age hill towns usually had an outer wall and, in many cases, a strong inner citadel or tower (migdal). Defenders fell back to it once the outer wall was breached. "Capturing" a town could therefore mean taking the streets and houses while the citadel still held. That is exactly the situation in vv. 50–51, and the reader needs to picture it to follow what comes next.
Siege practice. An army "encamping against" a town cut it off from its fields and water and got ready to break in by force or starve it out. Abimelech's quick success at Thebez makes him overconfident. In v. 52 he goes right up to the tower door to burn it, as he had done at Shechem, and comes within reach of the defenders on the roof.
The larger frame. Jotham's fable and curse (9:7–20) predicted that fire would come out from Abimelech and from Shechem and consume each other. The narrator closes the episode by saying that God repaid Abimelech's crime against his seventy brothers (9:56–57). This verse is the last step before that repayment.
From the study of Judges 9:50.
Where scholars differ
in v50, v51
Where was Thebez?
-
Modern Tubas, about 15 km (9 miles) northeast of Shechem
The name survives in the modern one, and Eusebius' Onomasticon puts 'Thebes' 13 Roman miles from Neapolis toward Scythopolis. Most reference works accept this.
-
A copying error for Tirzah (Tell el-Far'ah North)
The two names look alike in Hebrew script, and Tirzah was an important nearby town. No manuscript supports this reading, so it remains a minority guess.
in v50
Why did Abimelech attack Thebez?
-
Thebez had joined Shechem's revolt
The attack follows directly on the crushing of Shechem (9:42–49), which suggests a mopping-up campaign. The text does not say so outright.
-
The narrator leaves the reason out on purpose
The story cares about divine retribution (9:56–57), not military reasons. Leaving out a cause makes the attack look like more of Abimelech's unchecked violence.
in v51
Who are the 'baʿalei of the city' in relation to 'the men and the women'?
-
A distinct group: the city's landholding citizens or ruling lords, listed in addition to the general population.
In Judges 9 the formula consistently means the civic body of Shechem that acts politically (9:2–3, 6, 18, 23). The separate 'and all' (*vekhol*) suggests an added category.
-
A summary phrase: 'all the men and women, that is, all the citizens of the city'.
Hebrew lists can end with a summary. Some translations (e.g. KJV 'all they of the city', NIV) read it that way. Elsewhere baʿalim can mean the citizenry generally (e.g. 1 Samuel 23:11–12, 'men of Keilah').
in v53
Was the stone a whole upper millstone or a broken fragment of one?
-
The whole upper handstone.
Rekhev on its own means the upper millstone (Deut 24:6). Pelach can mean a cut slab or segment, not necessarily something broken. Iron Age upper quern stones were elongated and loaf-shaped and could fairly be called a "slab." Many modern versions (ESV, NASB, NIV, BSB) follow this view.
-
A broken piece of a millstone.
Pelach means "slice" or "piece" elsewhere (Song 4:3; 1 Sam 30:12). The Septuagint (klasma, 'broken piece'), the Vulgate (fragmen) and the KJV ("piece of a millstone") all read it as a fragment.
in v53
Is the 'one woman' meant to echo the 'one stone' of Abimelech's crime (9:5, 18)?
-
Yes, it is deliberate retributive wordplay.
The words "one" (achat) and "stone" recur, and verses 56-57 say explicitly that the evil was repaid. Hebrew narrative often signals fitting punishment through repeated words. Many commentators on Judges note the link.
-
Possibly incidental.
After a noun, achat often just means "a certain," and the word for stone in 9:5 (even) is not the word used here (pelach rekhev). The echo is one of idea more than of exact wording.
in v54
Does the narrator share Abimelech's view that dying by a woman's hand is shameful, or is it being turned against him?
-
The narrative simply uses the shared cultural assumption: being killed by a woman was humiliating, and that humiliation is part of his punishment.
Judg 4:9 treats Sisera's falling to a woman as a loss of honor for Barak. Jdt 16:5–6 uses the same theme. 2 Sam 11:21 remembers the woman's role as the notable feature of his death.
-
The narrator ironizes Abimelech's contempt. The woman is the agent of God's justice, and his attempt to escape her credit fails.
Judges repeatedly shows women defeating strong men (Jael, the woman of Thebez). Verses 56–57 say God brought about this repayment. His dying words survive only as the story he wanted to suppress (2 Sam 11:21). These two views are not mutually exclusive, and many commentators hold both.
in v56
How can Abimelech have killed 'seventy' brothers when Jotham survived?
-
'Seventy' is a round, symbolic number for the whole house of Gideon, not an exact body count.
Seventy commonly stands for a complete group in the Bible (Gen 46:27; Exod 24:1; 2 Kgs 10:1), and the narrator uses it repeatedly in this chapter (8:30; 9:2, 4, 5, 18, 24) alongside the 'seventy shekels' (9:4).
-
Gideon had seventy sons besides Abimelech. Abimelech killed sixty-nine, and the text counts the intended victims as seventy.
8:30-31 lists seventy sons and then Abimelech separately. 9:5 says he killed 'seventy men on one stone, but Jotham was left', which can be read as the total house with one exception.
in v56
Why does the narrator say 'God' (Elohim) rather than 'the LORD' (YHWH) throughout this chapter?
-
It is a deliberate literary choice. In this story Israel's covenant God is not openly involved: there are no prophets, no deliverer and no crying out to YHWH. God acts from behind the scenes as the universal judge who requites bloodshed.
YHWH appears often in Judges 6-8 but not in chapter 9. The divine acts here are indirect: an 'evil spirit' (9:23) and retribution (9:56-57). Commentators such as Block and Webb draw out this contrast.
-
The name difference reflects the source or tradition the chapter came from rather than a theological point.
Older critical scholarship often explained shifts between divine names by different sources. Some commentators (e.g. Boling) think the Abimelech story was an older Shechem-centred tradition taken into the book.
in v56
Is the 'evil spirit' of 9:23 a demon or a spirit of discord?
-
It is a disposition of hostility and distrust that God allowed or sent between the parties, not a personal demon.
'Spirit' (ruaḥ) often means a mood or disposition (e.g. Num 5:14, 'spirit of jealousy'). In 9:23 the result is that the Shechemites 'dealt treacherously' with Abimelech.
-
It is a spirit-being under God's control, comparable to the 'evil spirit from the LORD' that troubled Saul.
1 Sam 16:14 and 1 Kgs 22:19-23 describe spirits sent by God to carry out judgment.
in v57
Does Jotham's curse work by its own power, or only through God?
-
Older scholarship held that a spoken curse was believed to carry power of its own: once uttered, it worked automatically.
Scholars such as Johannes Pedersen and Sigmund Mowinckel pointed to the vivid language of curses 'coming', 'clinging' and 'alighting' (e.g. here, wattābō'), and to Near Eastern magical incantation texts.
-
Later studies argue that curses in the Hebrew Bible take effect through God and depend on a real wrong. Their 'power' lies in calling on God and in shared social convention, not in magic.
H. C. Brichto, The Problem of 'Curse' in the Hebrew Bible (1963); A. C. Thiselton, 'The Supposed Power of Words' (JTS 1974). Prov 26:2 says a causeless curse does not alight. In this verse the curse's arrival stands right beside 'God returned', and Jotham's curse was explicitly conditional (9:16–20).
in v57
Why does Judges 9 speak only of 'God' (Elohim) and never 'the LORD' (YHWH)?
-
It is deliberate: the narrator signals that Abimelech's kingship and Shechem's Baal-berith politics stand outside YHWH's covenant leadership. God works from behind the scenes in judgment rather than through a deliverer he raises up.
YHWH appears throughout chs. 6–8 and 10 but never in ch. 9. No 'the LORD raised up' formula occurs, and God's acts here are all acts of judgment (9:23, 56, 57). This view appears in literary commentaries such as Webb (NICOT) and Block (NAC).
-
It reflects the source or style of an older, independent Shechem tradition and should not be pressed for theological meaning.
Historical-critical commentators (e.g. Boling, Anchor Bible) note that Judg 9 has distinctive vocabulary and a distinct setting, suggesting it came into the book from separate local material.
Sources
- BDB s.v. חָנָה, לָכַד, תֵּבֵץ
- HALOT s.v. חנה, לכד, תֵּבֵץ
- Eusebius, Onomasticon (entry 'Thebes')
- Anchor Bible Dictionary, 'Thebez'
- R. G. Boling, Judges (Anchor Bible)
- D. I. Block, Judges, Ruth (New American Commentary)
- B. G. Webb, The Book of Judges (NICOT)
- BDB s.v. מִגְדָּל, עֹז, בַּעַל, סָגַר, בַּעַד, גָּג
- HALOT s.v. מִגְדָּל; בַּעַל (citizens, lords of a city)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Judges 9:51
- Vulgate, Judices 9:51
- Eusebius, Onomasticon s.v. Thebes
- G. E. Wright, Shechem: The Biography of a Biblical City (1965)
- Boling, Judges (Anchor Bible)
- Block, Judges, Ruth (NAC)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, Judges 9
- BDB s.v. פֶּלַח, רֶכֶב, רָצַץ, גֻּלְגֹּלֶת
- HALOT s.v. פֶּלַח; רֶכֶב (upper millstone); רצץ
- Deuteronomy 24:6; 2 Samuel 11:21 (inner-biblical parallels)
- Septuagint, Judges 9:53 (A and B traditions)
- Vulgate, Judges 9:53
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judges 9:50-57 (towers, hand mills)
- P. J. King & L. E. Stager, Life in Biblical Israel (on saddle querns and food preparation)
- D. I. Block, Judges, Ruth (NAC), on Judges 9
- Oxford English Dictionary s.v. 'to-' (intensive prefix), for KJV 'all to brake'
- BDB and HALOT s.v. נַעַר, כְּלִי, מוּת (Polel), דָּקַר, הָרַג
- Daniel I. Block, Judges, Ruth (NAC)
- Barry G. Webb, The Book of Judges (NICOT)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judg 9:50–57
- Robert G. Boling, Judges (Anchor Bible)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Judges A and B texts
- BDB s.v. שׁוּב (Hiphil, 'bring back, requite')
- HALOT s.v. שׁוב hif.
- HALOT s.v. רָעָה (evil, wickedness; misfortune, disaster)
- Daniel I. Block, Judges, Ruth (New American Commentary)
- Trent C. Butler, Judges (Word Biblical Commentary)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judges 9
- Panamuwa inscription (KAI 215), Zincirli, for the 'seventy brothers' royal purge parallel
- BDB s.v. רָעָה, שׁוּב, רֹאשׁ, קְלָלָה
- HALOT s.v. רָעָה, שׁוּב (hiphil), קְלָלָה
- H. C. Brichto, The Problem of 'Curse' in the Hebrew Bible (1963)
- A. C. Thiselton, 'The Supposed Power of Words in the Biblical Writings', JTS 25 (1974)
- D. I. Block, Judges, Ruth (NAC)
- B. G. Webb, The Book of Judges (NICOT, 2012)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judg 9
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
2 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.