Nehemiah Chapter 11 Read as one passage
Nehemiah 11:25–35
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
25As for the villages with their fields, some of the people of Judah lived in Kiriath-arba, Dibon, Jekabzeel, and their villages; 26in Jeshua, Moladah, and Beth-pelet; 27in Hazar-shual; in Beersheba and its villages; 28in Ziklag; in Meconah and its villages; 29in En-rimmon, Zorah, Jarmuth, 30Zanoah, Adullam, and their villages; in Lachish and its fields; and in Azekah and its villages. So they settled from Beersheba all the way to the Valley of Hinnom. 31The descendants of Benjamin from Geba lived in Michmash, Aija, and Bethel with its villages; 32in Anathoth, Nob, Ananiah, 33Hazor, Ramah, Gittaim, 34Hadid, Zeboim, Neballat, 35Lod, and Ono; and in the Valley of the Craftsmen.
What the first hearers heard
For the community rebuilding after the exile, this list was more than geography. Each town name tied a living family to land promised long before. Pomegranate Spring recalled Simeon's old share in the south. Zorah brought the Samson stories to mind, and Jarmuth recalled Joshua's battles in the hills.
Hearing these names read out said that Judah's people were not just a small group around a rebuilt temple. They were again, at least in claim and in part in fact, the people of the land "from Beersheba to the Valley of Hinnom" (11:30). The list worked as a record of who belonged where, alongside the family lists of Ezra–Nehemiah, and as a quiet statement that the old inheritance had not lapsed.
From the study of Nehemiah 11:29.
Verse by verse
-
25As for the villages with their fields, some of the people of Judah lived in Kiriath-arba, Dibon, Jekabzeel, and their villages;
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
26in Jeshua, Moladah, and Beth-pelet;
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
27in Hazar-shual; in Beersheba and its villages;
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
28in Ziklag; in Meconah and its villages;
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
29in En-rimmon, Zorah, Jarmuth,
Full study →"…and in Pomegranate Spring, and in Zorah, and in Jarmuth…"
This verse is one link in a list (Nehemiah 11:25–30) of towns outside Jerusalem where the people of Judah lived after the return from exile. Each name comes after the same "and in…", like a roll-call of places.
- En-rimmon ("Spring of the Pomegranate") lay in the southern dry country, a short way north of Beersheba. The book of Joshua lists it as one of Simeon's old towns.
- Zorah was in the low hills west of Jerusalem, looking out over the valley toward Philistine land. Every hearer knew it as the hometown of Samson's family.
- Jarmuth was nearby, an ancient walled city whose king had fought against Joshua.
In one line the list moves from the Negev up into the western hills. All three names come from the old lists in Joshua 15 of the land given to Judah. To the first hearers the point was clear: the people of Judah were living again across the land their ancestors had been given, not only in Jerusalem. The next verse sums it up: "from Beersheba all the way to the Valley of Hinnom."
-
30Zanoah, Adullam, and their villages; in Lachish and its fields; and in Azekah and its villages. So they settled from Beersheba all the way to the Valley of Hinnom.
Full study →The list carries on from verse 25: some of the people of Judah lived in…
…Zanoah and Adullam, together with the open villages clustered around them; Lachish, together with the countryside it controlled; Azekah, together with its "daughter" villages that depended on it. So the people of Judah settled ("pitched camp") across the whole stretch of land from Beersheba in the far south up to the Valley of Hinnom, the ravine under Jerusalem's walls that formed Judah's old northern border.
The verse is a map in words. Every town is pictured with what belongs to it: villages, open land, "daughters". The closing line gives the range from south to north, and its endpoints are deliberate. "Beersheba" is the land's traditional southern edge. The Valley of Hinnom is the exact line where Judah's tribal territory ended and Benjamin's began, which is why the next verse switches to Benjamin. The names would have carried weight. Lachish and Azekah were the last two fortresses still standing when Babylon crushed Judah (Jeremiah 34:7), and now Judahites were living there again. The verb chosen for "settled" is the ordinary word for an army or a travelling people setting up camp, the word used again and again for Israel's camps in the wilderness. It may hint that this resettlement was still unfinished, or that the returned community was retracing the old story of camping and then entering the land. The Valley of Hinnom is simply a place on the map here, with no thought of the afterlife.
-
31The descendants of Benjamin from Geba lived in Michmash, Aija, and Bethel with its villages;
Full study →And the Benjaminites lived from Geba onward: in Michmash, in Ai, and in Bethel with the hamlets around it.
Nehemiah 11 records how the community back from exile was spread across the land. One in ten moved into Jerusalem by lot (11:1). The rest lived in the surrounding towns. Verses 25–30 list where the people of Judah settled, ending "from Beersheba all the way to the Valley of Hinnom." This verse opens the matching list for the tribe of Benjamin.
The Hebrew has no verb here. "Lived" is carried over from verse 25, which is why some English versions put "dwelt" in brackets. The verse starts with Geba, a town every Judean knew as the old northern edge of the kingdom ("from Geba to Beersheba"). The phrase "from Geba" probably works like "from Beersheba" in the line before: it marks where Benjamin's area begins. It could also mean "Benjaminites from Geba," naming where the settlers came from.
The towns named sit in a tight cluster in the hills north of Jerusalem. Michmash faces Geba across a gorge and is where Jonathan raided the Philistines. Aija is another spelling of Ai, "the ruin." Bethel, "house of God," was Jacob's shrine and later the royal sanctuary of the northern kingdom. Here it appears simply as a town with its "daughters." That is the Hebrew way of describing the small villages that clustered around and depended on a main town.
For the first readers, these familiar names placed the returned people back on their ancestors' land, town by town.
-
32in Anathoth, Nob, Ananiah,
Full study →This verse continues a list: "…the people of Benjamin lived in Michmash, Aija, Bethel and its villages, in Anathoth, Nob and Ananiah, Hazor, Ramah, Gittaim…" The Hebrew is just three town names with no verb or preposition. The sense "lived in" comes over from verse 31.
The names are bare, but they would have meant something to the first readers:
- Anathoth was a priestly town north-east of Jerusalem. The priest Abiathar was banished there, and it was the home of Jeremiah. While Babylon was besieging Jerusalem, Jeremiah bought a field there to show that fields would one day be bought and sold in the land again (Jeremiah 32).
- Nob was the old "city of the priests" on the ridge overlooking Jerusalem. David received the holy bread there, and Saul later massacred its priests.
- Ananiah was a town north of the city, probably modern Beit Hanina. It is named nowhere else in the Bible. Its name contains God's name, "Yah", though what the first part means is uncertain ("Yah has answered" or "Yah has covered").
So the verse says this: families of Benjamin were once more living in the circle of towns just north of Jerusalem, places with long priestly and prophetic memories, now resettled after the exile. The text records this without comment. The echoes are left to readers who know the earlier stories.
-
33Hazor, Ramah, Gittaim,
Full study →Among the places where people of the tribe of Benjamin settled after the return from exile were Hazor, a small hill village a few miles north-west of Jerusalem whose name means 'enclosure' or 'settlement' (not the famous Canaanite city in Galilee); Ramah, 'the Height', a hilltop town on the main road north of Jerusalem, remembered as the old border fortress and as the place where captives were gathered for Babylon; and Gittaim, 'Two Winepresses', a farming town further west toward the lowlands. The verse is one line in a roll-call. Each name records a place where families from Benjamin were living again on the land of their ancestors.
-
34Hadid, Zeboim, Neballat,
Full study →The verse continues a list that starts in verse 31: the people of Benjamin lived from Geba onward, in… Here the list reaches three towns in the western foothills: Hadid (perhaps 'Sharp Height', a hilltop town just east of Lod), Zeboim ('Hyenas', a village whose exact site is now lost and which is not the Zeboiim destroyed with Sodom), and Neballat (a town whose name still survives in the village of Beit Nabala). Read with the verses around it, the point is that families of Benjamin back from exile had spread west from their old heartland north of Jerusalem. They settled down the slopes toward the coastal plain, as far as Lod, Ono and the Valley of the Craftsmen (v. 35). For the first readers, each name was a real place on the map, and naming it claimed it as part of the restored people's home.
-
35Lod, and Ono; and in the Valley of the Craftsmen.
Full study →"Lod and Ono, and the Valley of the Craftsmen."
This verse ends the list of towns where the people of Benjamin settled after the return from exile (Neh 11:31–35). It names two old towns that always appear together, Lod and Ono. Both sit where the hills come down to the coastal plain, northwest of Jerusalem. The list then adds a place called Ge-harashim, the "Valley of the Craftsmen." Its name says it was known for a community of skilled smiths, carpenters and stonecutters. 1 Chronicles 4:14 traces the name to a family of artisans: "for they were craftsmen."
For the first hearers, these were real places and real families. They marked the western edge of where Benjaminites lived. That frontier lay far from the rebuilt city, near the "plain of Ono," where Nehemiah's enemies had tried to lure him away (Neh 6:2). Whether the craftsmen's valley is a third place or another name for the area around Ono is not certain. The Hebrew can be read either way.
Where the English drifted
-
in v30
the Valley of Hinnom
gêʾ hinnōm
- What we hear
- Readers who know that 'Gehenna' (Hinnom) became a name for hell may hear an ominous or judgment overtone.
- What they heard
- A real ravine at Jerusalem's south-west edge that served as the border between Judah and Benjamin. Here it is a neutral geographical limit, 'as far north as Jerusalem'.
-
in v30
encamped
wayyaḥănû (ḥānāh)
- What we hear
- Pitching tents for a short or recreational stay; temporary squatters.
- What they heard
- To halt and set up somewhere, as armies or Israel in the wilderness did. It can mean taking up residence (Isaiah 29:1). It describes settling down. It does not have to mean a short stay, though it may carry an echo of the wilderness camps or of settlement that was not yet secure.
-
in v31
children of Benjamin (KJV, WEB)
benei vinyamin
- What we hear
- Young people or kids belonging to Benjamin
- What they heard
- Members of the tribe of Benjamin: adult households, i.e. "Benjaminites"
-
in v34
Zeboim
ṣəbōʿîm
- What we hear
- A reader who knows the KJV may think of 'Zeboim', the city destroyed with Sodom and Gomorrah (Deut 29:23; Hos 11:8), and suppose the Benjaminites resettled a cursed site.
- What they heard
- A different name, spelled with the guttural letter ʿayin and probably meaning 'hyenas'. It belonged to an ordinary village in Benjamin, likely near Lod.
Every word
-
וּבְעֵ֥ין
uve'ein · H5884
and in En- (spring of) · v29
Made up of 'and' + 'in' + 'ein', the common Hebrew word for a spring of water, which begins many place names. It carries on the chain of 'and in…' phrases that runs from verse 25, listing where the people of Judah lived.
-
וּבְצָרְעָ֖ה
uvetsar'ah · H6881
and in Zorah · v29
Zorah was a town in the low hills west of Jerusalem (the Shephelah), best known as the hometown of Samson's family (Judges 13:2). Its mention moves the list from the Negev north-west into those hills.
-
וּבְיַרְמֽוּת׃
uveyarmut · H3412G
and in Jarmuth · v29
Jarmuth was an old city in the Shephelah, a few miles south of Zorah. Its king was one of the five who fought Joshua (Joshua 10:3). It ends this verse's short group of towns. Verse 30 goes on with the list.
-
זָנֹ֤חַ
zānōaḥ · H2182
Zanoah · v30
A town in the Shephelah, the low hill country west of Judah's highlands (Joshua 15:34), probably Khirbet Zanu. Men of Zanoah repaired Jerusalem's Valley Gate in Nehemiah 3:13. Like the other names in this list it has no 'in' attached; the verb 'lived in' carries over from v. 25.
-
עֲדֻלָּם֙
ʿădullām · H5725
Adullam · v30
A Shephelah town best known for the cave where David hid from Saul (1 Samuel 22:1), later fortified by Rehoboam (2 Chronicles 11:7). Here it is simply one of the places Judahites lived.
-
וְחַצְרֵיהֶ֔ם
wəḥaṣrêhem · H2691
and their villages · v30
'And their enclosures', meaning the small unwalled settlements that belonged to Zanoah and Adullam. The plural 'their' covers both towns.
-
לָכִישׁ֙
lākîš · H3923
Lachish · v30
Tell ed-Duweir, once Judah's second city after Jerusalem. The Assyrians (701 BC) and then the Babylonians (588–586 BC) destroyed it. Listing it here shows Judahites living again on a famous ruined site.
-
וּשְׂדֹתֶ֔יהָ
ûśədōtêhā · H7704
and its fields · v30
'And its open lands': the countryside, farmland and pasture under the town's control. 'Its' is feminine because Hebrew treats cities as feminine.
-
עֲזֵקָ֖ה
ʿăzēqāh · H5825
Azekah · v30
Tel Azekah, overlooking the Elah Valley where David fought Goliath (1 Samuel 17:1). Along with Lachish, it was one of the last Judahite strongholds still standing against Babylon (Jeremiah 34:7).
-
וּבְנֹתֶ֑יהָ
ûbənōtêhā · H1323
and its daughters (dependent villages) · v30, v31
Literally 'and her daughters'. This is the regular Hebrew idiom for the smaller settlements that depended on a 'mother' town for defence, market and law.
-
וַיַּחֲנ֥וּ
wayyaḥănû · H2583
and they encamped / settled · v30
The verb usually used for pitching camp, as Israel did in the wilderness. Here it sums up the whole list: the Judahites 'camped', that is settled, across this stretch of land. It may hint at an echo of Israel's camps or at settlement that was not yet secure (see debates).
-
מִבְּאֵֽר־
mibbəʾēr · H884
from Beer- · v30
'From' plus the first half of the name Beer-sheba, 'well of seven' or 'well of the oath' (Genesis 21:31). It marks the southern end of the settled area.
-
עַד־
ʿad · H5704
as far as, until · v30
Marks the far end of the range: 'all the way to'.
-
גֵּֽיא־
gêʾ · H1516
valley (of) · v30, v35
A steep-sided ravine. It is linked to the next word: 'valley of'.
-
הִנֹּֽם׃
hinnōm · H2011
Hinnom · v30
A personal or family name of unknown meaning. The ravine bordering Jerusalem on the south and west carried this name, and it formed the old boundary between Judah and Benjamin (Joshua 15:8; 18:16). It marks the northern end of the range.
-
וּבְנֵ֥י
u-venei · H1121
and sons of, descendants of · v31
"Sons of Benjamin" is the usual Hebrew way to say "members of the tribe of Benjamin." It means adult families, not children. The "and" moves the list on from Judah's towns (vv. 25–30) to Benjamin's.
-
בִנְיָמִ֖ן
vinyamin · H1144
Benjamin · v31
The tribe of Benjamin. Its old territory lay just north of Jerusalem. Along with Judah and Levi, it made up most of the community that came back from exile (Ezra 1:5).
-
מִגָּ֑בַע
mi-gava‘ · H1387
from Geba · v31
Geba (the name means "hill") was a town about 9 km (6 miles) north-northeast of Jerusalem. The prefix "from" can mark a starting point ("from Geba onward"), like "from Beersheba" in v. 30. It can also mark where people came from ("Benjaminites from Geba"). Both readings are possible. See the debates.
-
מִכְמָ֣שׂ
mikhmas · H4363
Michmash · v31
A town across a steep ravine from Geba. It was the scene of Jonathan's raid on the Philistines (1 Samuel 13–14). Returnees from Michmash are counted in Ezra 2:27 and Nehemiah 7:31.
-
וְעַיָּ֔ה
ve-‘ayyah · H5857
and Aija (Ai) · v31
Another form of the name Ai ("the ruin"). It also appears as Aiath in Isaiah 10:28. Ezra 2:28 counts "the men of Bethel and Ai" together. Which ancient site was meant in the Persian period is uncertain.
-
וּבֵֽית־
u-veit- · H1008
and Beth- (house of) · v31
The first half of the compound name Bethel, "house of God."
-
עֲנָת֥וֹת
ʿănātôt · H6068
Anathoth · v32
A Benjaminite town a few kilometres north-east of Jerusalem, listed as one of the places where people of Benjamin settled after the return from exile. It was a priestly town, the home of the priest Abiathar and later of the prophet Jeremiah.
-
נֹ֖ב
nōḇ · H5011
Nob · v32
A town on the heights just north or north-east of Jerusalem, remembered as the 'city of priests' where David got the holy bread and where Saul had the priests killed. Here it is simply named again as a place Benjaminites lived in.
-
עֲנָֽנְיָֽה׃
ʿănanyâ · H6055
Ananiah · v32
A town that appears only here in the Bible, usually located at modern Beit Hanina, north-west of Jerusalem. The verse ends here, but the list of settlements carries on into verse 33.
-
חָצ֥וֹר
ḥāṣôr · H2674
Hazor (place name) · v33
A Benjaminite village north-west of Jerusalem, usually identified with Khirbet Hazzur. It is not the large Canaanite city of Hazor in Galilee. The name comes from the word for an enclosure or walled settlement, and several towns in Israel shared it. A small vertical stroke (paseq) after the word in the Hebrew text simply marks a slight pause between names. It does not change the meaning.
-
רָמָ֖ה
rāmâ · H7414
Ramah, "height" · v33
Ramah of Benjamin, modern er-Ram, about 8 km (5 miles) north of Jerusalem on the main ridge road. The name means 'height', which fits its hilltop site. Jewish hearers would have remembered it as the border fortress of the divided kingdom, and as the place where Judean captives were gathered for exile in 586 BC (Jeremiah 40:1).
-
גִּתָּֽיִם
gittāyim · H1664
Gittaim, "two winepresses" · v33
A town whose name is the Hebrew word for 'winepress' (gat) with a dual ending, so 'two winepresses' or 'double Gath'. Its exact site is uncertain. Because it is listed with Hadid, Lod and Ono, it probably lay in the low hills toward the coastal plain. Some scholars place it near Ramla. It is the town the Beerothites fled to in 2 Samuel 4:3.
-
חָדִ֥יד
ḥādîd · H2307
-
צְבֹעִ֖ים
ṣəbōʿîm · H6650G
Zeboim (place name) · v34
A Benjaminite settlement named, it seems, after hyenas (Hebrew ṣābûaʿ, 'hyena'). Its site is unknown, but because it is listed between Hadid and Neballat it was probably in the same area near Lod. It is not the Zeboiim destroyed along with Sodom.
-
נְבַלָּֽט׃
nəballāṭ · H5041
Neballat (place name) · v34
A town mentioned only here in the Bible. The Arab village of Beit Nabala, a few kilometres northeast of Lod, keeps the name. It continues the list of western Benjaminite towns that ends with Lod and Ono in the next verse.
-
לֹ֥ד
lōd · H3850
Lod · v35
A town on the edge of the coastal plain, about 18 km (11 miles) southeast of modern Tel Aviv. It is the Lydda of Acts 9:32–38 and today's city of Lod. Here it is one of the last places in the list of towns where people of Benjamin lived.
-
וְאוֹנ֖וֹ
wəʾônô · H0207
and Ono · v35
A town a few kilometres north of Lod, usually placed at Kafr ʿAna (modern Or Yehuda). Its name has the prefix 'and' attached, which joins it to Lod as a pair. The two towns are named together elsewhere too (1 Chr 8:12; Ezra 2:33).
-
הַחֲרָשִֽׁים׃
haḥărāšîm · H2796
craftsman, artisan, smith · v35
'The craftsmen': skilled workers in metal, wood or stone. Together with 'valley' it forms the place name Ge-harashim, 'Valley of the Craftsmen'. The name says the place was known for a community of artisans.
The world behind it
Who lived where. Nehemiah 11 records how Jerusalem was filled again. One in ten of the people moved into the city by lot (11:1–2), and the rest stayed in "their towns" (11:3, 20). Verses 25–30 list the Judean towns and verses 31–36 the Benjamite ones.
A list shaped by Joshua. The Judean list follows the order and areas of Joshua 15: first the Negev (Kiriath-arba, Dibon, Beersheba, Ziklag, En-rimmon), then the Shephelah, the low hills between the Judean highlands and the coastal plain (Zorah, Jarmuth, Zanoah, Adullam, Lachish, Azekah). This verse is where the list crosses from the first area into the second.
The political problem. In the Persian period (5th century BC) the small province of Yehud (Judah) seems to have reached only from around Beth-zur in the south to Bethel in the north. Hebron, Beersheba and much of the southern Shephelah were then under Edomite/Arab (later "Idumean") control, as archaeology and Aramaic ostraca from the area suggest. So it is debated whether these towns were really inside the province (see debates). Either way, the list sets the community within the borders of its ancestral inheritance.
From the study of Nehemiah 11:29.
Where scholars differ
in v29
Does the Judean town list (11:25–30) record where people actually lived in Nehemiah's day, or is it an idealized claim to ancestral land?
-
It is mainly idealized or traditional, drawn from Joshua 15 and setting out Judah's rightful territory rather than the real borders of the Persian province.
The towns follow Joshua 15's areas and order. Several (Beersheba, Lachish, Kiriath-arba/Hebron) seem to have lain outside the province of Yehud, in Edomite/Idumean-controlled land. The list leaves out towns known to be in Yehud, such as Tekoa and Beth-zur, and verse 30's 'from Beersheba to the Valley of Hinnom' repeats the classic southern borders.
-
It reflects real Judean settlement, at least in part: Judean families living as communities beyond the official border, or a record from a somewhat later period.
The text says these people actually 'lived' and 'camped' (11:25, 30) in the towns. Borders in the region were not sealed, and Judean communities could live in Idumean-ruled territory. Some scholars date the list to a later stage when the borders had changed.
-
Mixed: a real list of Judean groups and their home towns, organized and framed using the Joshua tradition.
This keeps the list's link to Joshua and its claim to real residence. Commentators such as H. G. M. Williamson and J. Blenkinsopp discuss forms of this combined view.
in v29
Is En-rimmon one town or two (Ain and Rimmon)?
-
One town, 'Spring of Rimmon'. Nehemiah's combined name is the original.
Nehemiah uses one compound name. The identification with Khirbet Umm er-Ramamin points to a single site, and the totals in Joshua 15:32 work better if the names are counted as one.
-
Two nearby places, Ain and Rimmon, as Joshua and Chronicles list them.
Joshua 15:32, 19:7 and 1 Chronicles 4:32 all join the names with 'and', and Joshua 19:7 counts them in a total of 'four towns'.
in v30
Does the list in Nehemiah 11:25–30 describe where Judahites actually lived in Nehemiah's day?
-
It is largely an idealized claim to territory, built from older town lists.
The names closely follow Judah's allotment in Joshua 15. Archaeology and provincial seal impressions place Yehud's southern border near Beth-zur, so Hebron, Lachish and Beersheba were outside the province, in an area with many Edomite/Idumean names in 4th-century ostraca. Scholars such as Lipschits and Finkelstein treat the list as non-historical for the Persian period: either utopian, or reflecting later (possibly Hasmonean) conditions.
-
It records real Judahite communities living outside the provincial borders.
Ethnic settlement need not have matched administrative borders, and some Judahites may never have left the south. Lachish has a Persian-period administrative building (Level I), so the site was occupied. Commentators such as Williamson and Blenkinsopp allow that the list may record Judahites who still identified with Jerusalem, while also recognizing its ideological shaping.
-
It mixes real settlement with traditional boundary language.
The Beersheba-to-Hinnom formula and the Joshua-style naming are traditional, but the list is set among census-like material in Nehemiah 11. Many read it as a real list framed to make a theological and territorial claim.
in v30
Why 'they camped' instead of 'they lived'?
-
It is a deliberate echo of the wilderness and entry into the land.
Ḥānāh is the key verb of Israel's wilderness itinerary (Numbers 33). The return from exile is portrayed elsewhere in Ezra–Nehemiah as a new exodus.
-
It signals settlement that was thin, scattered or insecure.
The towns lay outside Yehud's borders amid other peoples, and the verb used for armies may suggest a fragile, outpost-like presence.
-
It is simply a variation in style meaning 'settled'.
Isaiah 29:1 uses ḥānāh for David residing in Jerusalem, and the verb can mean taking up residence with no special overtone.
in v31
Does "from Geba" mark a starting point or where the settlers came from?
-
A starting point: "lived from Geba onward"
It matches v. 30 directly ("from Beersheba as far as the Valley of Hinnom"), and Geba was the well-known boundary town of Judah (2 Kings 23:8; Zechariah 14:10). Followed by WEB and, as far as can be judged, ESV and NASB.
-
Where they came from: "Benjaminites from Geba lived in Michmash..."
This is the most natural plain reading of the word order. Followed by BSB and NIV.
-
Change the text to "in Geba"
Geba appears in Ezra 2:26 among settled towns, and it would sit naturally in a list of places lived in. But no Hebrew manuscript reads this, and the Hebrew as it stands makes sense.
in v31
Do the settlement lists in Nehemiah 11:25–36 describe where people actually lived in the Persian period?
-
They are largely ideal or traditional, modelled on Joshua's tribal town lists
Several southern towns (Beersheba, Lachish, Hebron) seem to lie outside Persian Yehud, and parts of the list echo Joshua 15 and 18. A number of commentators (e.g., Blenkinsopp, Williamson) hold views along these lines.
-
They record real places of residence or land claims, though not necessarily the province border
Many of the names overlap with the returnee lists (Ezra 2), which describe real settlements. Judeans could also have lived beyond the formal provincial line.
in v32
Where exactly was Nob?
-
On or near Mount Scopus, just north-east of Jerusalem
Isaiah 10:32 implies Jerusalem was visible from Nob. Scopus fits the line of sight and the route of an army approaching from the north.
-
At or near el-ʿIsawiya or Ras el-Mesharif
These also lie on the ridge north-east of Jerusalem with a view of the city, and they fit the order of towns in Isaiah 10:28–32 and Nehemiah 11:32. No excavation has confirmed any site.
in v32
Does the town list in Nehemiah 11:25–35 describe where people actually lived in Nehemiah's day, or an older or idealised territory?
-
It reflects real settlement in the Persian period
The Benjaminite towns (vv. 31–35) lie mostly inside what is known of the Persian province of Judah (Yehud). Several of them, Anathoth included, also appear in the list of returnees (Ezra 2 / Nehemiah 7).
-
It is at least partly idealised or draws on older lists
The Judahite section (vv. 25–30) names towns as far south as Beersheba, beyond Yehud's likely borders. This suggests that parts of the chapter express claims to ancestral land rather than a current census. The Benjamin section is less affected by this problem.
in v33
Does the town list in Nehemiah 11:25–36 describe where people actually lived in Persian Yehud, or an older or idealised territory?
-
It records real settlement in Nehemiah's time.
It sits within Nehemiah's account of repopulation, and many of the names (Ramah, Geba, Michmash, Lod, Ono) also appear in the returnee lists of Ezra 2 and Nehemiah 7.
-
It reflects older (pre-exilic) tribal territory, or an ideal claim, more than the actual borders of Yehud.
Some towns, especially in the Judah list (Beersheba, Lachish) and probably Lod and Ono, seem to lie outside the province's likely borders in the Persian period. That suggests the list maps a claimed or remembered homeland.
in v33
Where was Gittaim?
-
In the foothills near Lod and Ramla, for example at Ras Abu Hamid.
It is listed next to Hadid, Lod and Ono, and 2 Samuel 4:3 implies it lay at some distance from Beeroth.
-
The site is unknown.
No inscription or excavation has confirmed any proposed site, and several towns named after a 'winepress' (Gath) existed.
in v34
Does the town list in Nehemiah 11:25–35 describe where Jews actually lived in Nehemiah's day, or an older or idealised territory?
-
It reflects actual settlement in the Persian period, perhaps somewhat later than Nehemiah.
Several of the towns (Lod, Hadid, Ono) appear among the returnees in Ezra 2 / Neh 7. The western Benjaminite district was a real zone of Jewish presence, as Neh 6:2 and the later Maccabean activity at Adida show.
-
It is partly idealised, describing territory the community claimed from older tribal tradition rather than strictly within Yehud's borders.
Archaeology suggests the province of Yehud was small. The Lod–Ono area may have been outside it, and some names in the Judah list (vv. 25–30) reach as far as Beersheba, which was then Edomite territory. The list echoes the tribal town lists of Joshua.
in v34
Is the Zeboim of Neh 11:34 the same place as the 'Valley of Zeboim' in 1 Sam 13:18?
-
They are different places.
The valley is near Michmash and 'faces the wilderness' in the east. The Neh 11:34 town is listed among western towns near Lod.
-
There may be a connection, or the name was used in more than one place.
The same Hebrew spelling (ṣəbōʿîm), and Benjaminite territory spans both areas. Because the site is unknown, a link cannot be ruled out.
in v35
Is the 'Valley of the Craftsmen' a separate place, or a description of the area around Ono?
-
A separate settlement, Ge-harashim
1 Chr 4:14 treats Ge-harashim as a named place founded by a family of craftsmen. In a list of towns, a third name is expected. The BSB, NLT and NIV read it this way.
-
A description of where Ono and Lod lay, or of the valley around them
There is no 'and' before the phrase, while Ono has one. That allows it to stand in apposition, renaming what came before ('Ono, that is, the valley of the craftsmen'). Neh 6:2 also speaks of a lowland around Ono ('the plain of Ono').
in v35
Does the list of Benjamin's towns show where people actually lived under the Persians, or an ideal or older territory?
-
It mostly reflects real settlement in Persian times
Ezra 2:33 and Neh 7:37 independently count men of Lod, Hadid and Ono among the returnees. Jewish families could live outside the province's official borders.
-
It partly reflects older or idealised tribal territory
Several places in Neh 11:25–36 seem to lie outside the province of Yehud as reconstructed from archaeology and from 1 Macc 11:34. Some scholars think the list draws on older tribal boundaries, perhaps from the late monarchy, to state a claim to the land.
Sources
- HALOT s.v. עֵין רִמּוֹן, צׇרְעָה, יַרְמוּת
- BDB s.v. עַיִן (compound place names), רִמּוֹן, צׇרְעָה, יַרְמוּת
- Anchor Bible Dictionary, articles 'En-rimmon', 'Zorah', 'Jarmuth'
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16), on Neh 11:25–36
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library), on Neh 11:25–36
- Y. Aharoni, The Land of the Bible: A Historical Geography (town lists of Judah)
- P. de Miroschedji, excavation reports on Tel Yarmut
- O. Lipschits, studies on the borders of Persian-period Yehud
- BDB s.v. חָנָה
- HALOT s.v. חנה I
- HALOT s.v. בַּת (sense: dependent settlement)
- HALOT s.v. חָצֵר
- BDB s.v. שָׂדֶה
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16)
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library)
- O. Lipschits, The Fall and Rise of Jerusalem: Judah under Babylonian Rule
- I. Finkelstein, studies on the Persian-period Yehud lists (e.g. 'Archaeology and the List of Returnees in the Books of Ezra and Nehemiah', PEQ 2008)
- Lachish Ostraca, Letter 4
- Jeremiah 34:7; Joshua 15:8, 33–35; 18:16; 2 Kings 23:10
- R. Hanhart (ed.), Esdrae liber II (Göttingen Septuagint)
- BDB s.v. בַּת, גֶּבַע, עַי
- HALOT s.v. בַּת (daughter-towns), עַיָּה
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra-Nehemiah (Old Testament Library)
- I. Finkelstein & L. Singer-Avitz, "Reevaluating Bethel," ZDPV 125 (2009)
- BDB s.v. עֲנָתוֹת, נֹב, עֲנַנְיָה
- HALOT s.v. עֲנָתוֹת, נֹב, עֲנַנְיָה
- Strong's Concordance H6068, H5011, H6055
- Anchor Bible Dictionary, articles 'Anathoth', 'Nob', 'Ananiah'
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Nehemiah 11
- BDB s.v. חָצוֹר, רָמָה, גִּתַּיִם
- HALOT s.v. חָצוֹר; גַּת
- Anchor Bible Dictionary, articles 'Hazor (Benjamin)', 'Ramah', 'Gittaim'
- Y. Aharoni, The Land of the Bible: A Historical Geography
- BDB s.v. חָדִיד, צְבֹעִים, נְבַלָּט
- HALOT s.v. חָדִיד; צָבוּעַ; נְבַלָּט
- 1 Maccabees 12:38; 13:13 (Adida)
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.203, 13.392 (Adida)
- Mishnah Arakhin 9:6
- Anchor Bible Dictionary, entries 'Hadid', 'Zeboim', 'Neballat'
- N. Na'aman and R. Zadok, publication of the Neo-Assyrian tablets from Tel Hadid
- BDB s.v. לֹד, אוֹנוֹ, גַּיְא, חָרָשׁ
- HALOT s.v. חָרָשׁ; s.v. גֵּיא
- Strong's H3850, H0207, H1516, H2796
- 1 Maccabees 11:34 (transfer of Lydda to Judea)
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra–Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Anchor Bible Dictionary, articles 'Lod', 'Ono', 'Ge-harashim'
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
4 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.