1 Samuel Chapter 17 Read as one passage

1 Samuel 17:10–11

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

10Then the Philistine said, “I defy the ranks of Israel this day! Give me a man to fight!” 11On hearing the words of the Philistine, Saul and all the Israelites were dismayed and greatly afraid.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers this verse gives the story its central conflict in one word: taunt/reproach (ḥārap̄). Everything that follows answers it.

  • Shame on Israel. "Saul and all Israel" hear these words and are "dismayed and greatly afraid" (v. 11). The tall king who should have been Israel's champion (1 Sam 9:2) stays in his camp. The verse puts the whole nation's honour on the line, and shows it going undefended.
  • Shame on God. In Israel's theology the ranks of Israel belonged to YHWH. So David reframes the insult at once ("the ranks of the living God", vv. 26, 36) and calls the coming fight YHWH's: "the battle is the LORD's" (v. 47). Later readers would hear the same pattern in the Assyrian envoy who "taunted the living God" before Jerusalem (2 Kgs 19:4, 16), with the same verb and the same divine title.
  • Reversal. The Philistine's "this very day", "give me a man" and "let us fight" are all answered point by point. The day becomes YHWH's day (v. 46), the "man" turns out to be a "youth" (v. 42), and the combat ends with the champion's own sword (v. 51).
  • Later hearers. In exile and after, when Israel was "a reproach to our neighbours" (Ps 44:13; 79:4), this story taught that the taunts of more powerful enemies do not have the last word. The God whose people are mocked takes the reproach as his own.

From the study of 1 Samuel 17:10.

Verse by verse

  1. 10Then the Philistine said, “I defy the ranks of Israel this day! Give me a man to fight!”

    And the Philistine spoke again: "I, I myself, here and now heap scorn on the drawn-up battle lines of Israel, this very day! Hand me over a man, and let the two of us fight it out, man against man."

    The pronoun 'I' is spelled out for emphasis: one man setting himself against a whole army. The verb for 'defy' is really a verb of taunting or publicly shaming. Its past-tense form works like "I hereby...", so the insult is done by saying it. His target is the visible lines of soldiers standing in formation on the opposite hillside, listening. "This very day" makes it a formal, dated declaration made before witnesses. The command "give me" is plural, addressed to the whole Israelite army, as if they owed him an opponent and could not produce one. "A man" means a champion, someone to match the "man of the in-between" (v. 4) who has walked out into the valley between the armies. The closing "let us fight together" means one-on-one combat with the whole war staked on the outcome (v. 9).

    The first hearers knew how this worked. A challenge left unanswered disgraced the army, its king, and the God whose battle lines these were. The story then turns his words against him. David calls these same lines "the ranks of the living God" (v. 26), names YHWH "the God of the ranks of Israel, whom you have taunted" (v. 45), and answers with the Philistine's own phrase: "This very day the LORD will deliver you into my hand" (v. 46).

    Full study →
  2. 11On hearing the words of the Philistine, Saul and all the Israelites were dismayed and greatly afraid.

    When Saul, and with him the whole army of Israel, heard this Philistine's speech (his offer of single combat and his open taunt, "I defy the ranks of Israel today; give me a man!"), they were broken inside: their nerve snapped, and they were terrified, utterly afraid.

    The sentence puts Saul first. He was the tall king the people had asked for so that he would "go out before us and fight our battles", and he is the first one the taunt overwhelms. The two verbs, shattered and afraid, are the very pair Moses and Joshua had told Israel never to give in to before an enemy ("do not fear and do not be dismayed"). An Israelite listener would hear the reversal at once: God's army is doing exactly what it was told not to do. Nobody has struck a blow yet. A Philistine's words alone have already beaten them.

    This is the low point that the rest of the story answers. Soon a shepherd boy will hear "these same words" and react in the opposite way.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v10

    defy

    ḥērap̄tî (from ḥārap̄)

    What we hear
    To resist, disobey, or stand up against someone, as in 'defying authority' or 'defying the odds'.
    What they heard
    To taunt, insult, publicly heap scorn on. It is a shaming act aimed at an enemy's honour, here done as a formal pre-battle provocation. The Philistine is not resisting Israel. He is mocking it.
  • in v11

    dismayed

    chatat (vayyechattu)

    What we hear
    Disappointed, concerned, upset: a mild emotional reaction ('I was dismayed to hear the news').
    What they heard
    Shattered, broken: losing all nerve in terror. The root is used of nations and things being smashed (Isa 7:8; 30:31; Jer 48:20).
Every word
  1. וַיֹּ֙אמֶר֙

    wayyōʾmer · H0559

    and he said · v10

    The ordinary verb for speaking, in the form Hebrew uses to move a story forward. It brings in a second speech from the champion, adding to the challenge he has just set out in verses 8–9.

  2. הַפְּלִשְׁתִּ֔י

    happəlištî · H6430G

    the Philistine · v10, v11

    The narrator calls him by his ethnic label, 'the Philistine', far more often than by his name Goliath. That keeps him in view as the face of a whole enemy people and, as David will soon say, of an 'uncircumcised' outsider to Israel's covenant.

  3. אֲנִ֗י

    ʾănî · H0589

    I · v10

    Hebrew verbs already carry their subject, so adding the separate pronoun 'I' is emphatic: 'I myself', 'I, and no one else'. It is swagger: one man setting himself against a whole drawn-up army.

  4. חֵרַ֛פְתִּי

    ḥērap̄tî · H2778A

    to taunt, reproach · v10

    'I heap scorn on', 'I publicly insult'. The past-tense (perfect) form is used here for an act carried out by the very words that announce it: 'I hereby taunt'. It is a ritual insult meant to shame the enemy and goad them into answering.

  5. אֶת־

    ʾet- · H0853

    [direct object marker] · v10, v11

    An untranslatable particle marking 'the ranks of Israel' as the direct target of the insult.

  6. מַעַרְכ֥וֹת

    maʿarḵôt · H4634

    battle line, rank · v10

    The lines of soldiers 'set in order' for battle, here Israel's troops drawn up on their hillside facing the Philistine line across the valley (vv. 2–3, 21). The plural is the whole formation. David picks up the same word when he calls them 'the ranks of the living God' (vv. 26, 36).

  7. יִשְׂרָאֵ֖ל

    yiśrāʾēl · H3478

    Israel · v10, v11

    The people as a whole, here as a fighting force under Saul. Insulting Israel's ranks also insulted Israel's God, as the story will make explicit.

  8. הַיּ֣וֹם

    hayyôm · H3117L

    the day, today · v10

    With 'this' following, it means 'today, this very day'. It dates the insult and makes it formal and public.

  9. הַזֶּ֑ה

    hazzeh · H2088

    this · v10

    'This very day.' The phrase comes back in David's reply: 'This very day the LORD will hand you over to me' (v. 46). The narrator turns the Philistine's own words around on him.

  10. תְּנוּ־

    tənû- · H5414G

    give · v10

    A plural command addressed to the whole Israelite army: 'You lot, hand over...' It treats Israel as if it owed him a man, and implies they can't produce one.

  11. לִ֣י

    lî · H9030

    to me · v10

    'To me', 'for me'. Hand a man over to me, send one out to face me.

  12. אִ֔ישׁ

    ʾîš · H0376G

    man · v10

    Here 'a man' means a fighting man, a champion fit to match him. The story plays on the word. The Philistine himself is introduced as 'the man of the in-between' (v. 4), the champion who steps into the gap between the armies. When an answer does come, it is a 'youth' (naʿar, vv. 33, 42), not the kind of 'man' he demanded.

  13. וְנִֽלָּחֲמָ֖ה

    wənillāḥămâ · H3898A

    to fight · v10

    'And let us fight.' The 'we' form is an invitation or resolve, and the verb form here carries the idea of fighting one another. It turns the demand into a dare: send him and we'll settle it.

  14. יָֽחַד׃

    yāḥad · H3162A

    together, jointly · v10

    From the root for 'one': 'the two of us, together', man against man. It does not mean cooperating. It means meeting each other in one combat, the two of us settling it for everyone.

  15. וַיִּשְׁמַ֤ע

    vayyishma' · H8085

    and he heard · v11

    Plain hearing: the taunt reached their ears and sank in. The verb is singular ('he heard') although two subjects follow. Hebrew often does this when the first-named subject is in focus, so Saul stands at the front of the scene.

  16. שָׁאוּל֙

    sha'ul · H7586

    Saul · v11

    Israel's king, named first. He was the man taller than everyone else (9:2; 10:23) and the king the people had asked for to 'go out before us and fight our battles' (8:20). He is the obvious one to answer a giant's challenge, and he is the first to hear it and be afraid.

  17. וְכָל־

    vekhol · H3605

    and all · v11

    'And all of'. Nobody in the camp is left out of the panic.

  18. דִּבְרֵ֥י

    divrei · H1697

    words of · v11

    The Philistine's speech: the challenge to single combat (vv. 8–9) and the open defiance of v. 10. These are not neutral words. They are a public insult meant to shame Israel.

  19. הָאֵ֑לֶּה

    ha'elleh · H428

    these · v11

    'These words', pointing back to the speech just quoted. In v. 23 David will hear 'the same words' (kadd'varim ha'elleh) and react the opposite way.

  20. וַיֵּחַ֥תּוּ

    vayyechattu · H2865

    and they were shattered / dismayed · v11

    From a root meaning to be broken or shattered. Used of people, it means losing nerve completely, being broken inwardly by terror. It is much stronger than modern English 'dismayed'.

  21. וַיִּֽרְא֖וּ

    vayyir'u · H3372

    and they feared · v11

    Plain fear of danger, here fear of the giant and of defeat. Together with 'shattered' it echoes, in reverse, the stock command 'do not fear and do not be dismayed'.

  22. מְאֹֽד׃

    me'od · H3966

    exceedingly, greatly · v11

    An intensifier: 'very much'. Their fear is total. The same phrase 'they feared greatly' comes back in v. 24, when the men run from Goliath.

The world behind it

Where and when. The scene is set in the Iron Age, around the late 11th century BC, in the Valley of Elah. This is a valley in the low hill country (the Shephelah) between Philistine territory on the coast and the Judean highlands. The Philistines camped between Socoh and Azekah, and Israel camped on the facing ridge with the valley between them (17:1–3). The Philistine champion came from Gath, one of the five main Philistine cities, usually identified with Tell es-Safi.

Champion combat. Two armies facing each other across a valley could avoid a costly general battle by sending out champions. Parallels:

  • the Egyptian Story of Sinuhe, where the "strong man of Retenu" challenges Sinuhe. Sinuhe kills him and takes his goods, much as David later takes Goliath's sword.
  • Homer's Iliad (Paris and Menelaus in Book 3, Hector and Ajax in Book 7). Some think this is especially relevant because the Philistines had Aegean origins.
  • Israel's own record of twelve young men from each side at Gibeon (2 Sam 2:14–16), and the duels with the Gath giants (2 Sam 21:15–22).

Honour and shame. Before a fight, warriors traded insults on purpose. The taunt was meant to goad the enemy and to shame them before onlookers. The Philistine repeated his challenge morning and evening for forty days (17:16). Each day without an answer heaped more disgrace on Saul's army. In the ancient Near East, wars were also understood as contests between the peoples' gods (note 17:43, "the Philistine cursed David by his gods"). An insult to Israel's ranks therefore reached Israel's God, and that is exactly how David hears it.

From the study of 1 Samuel 17:10.

Where scholars differ

in v10

Was the champion's offer (vv. 8–10) a real, binding agreement to settle the war, or a ritual provocation?

  • A real convention: representative combat could decide a conflict, and the terms in verse 9 (the loser's people become servants) state its rules.

    Champion fights appear in Egyptian, Greek and biblical sources (Sinuhe; Iliad 3 and 7; 2 Sam 2:14–16). Roland de Vaux's study 'Single Combat in the Old Testament' and Harry Hoffner's article on a possible Hittite parallel treat it as a recognised institution of ancient warfare.

  • Mainly ritual provocation and psychological warfare: the terms were rhetoric and were seldom, if ever, kept.

    Within the story, the Philistines do not become Israel's servants after their champion falls. They run, and a general battle follows (17:51–53). At Gibeon too, the champions' fight led into full battle (2 Sam 2:16–17). There is no clear ancient record of a whole army surrendering because its champion lost.

in v10

Does the challenge reflect a specifically Aegean (Greek-world) custom brought by the Philistines?

  • Yes. The duel, the champion's armour (vv. 5–7) and the pre-battle boasting fit the Aegean world the Philistines came from.

    Philistine material culture shows Aegean links, and Homeric heroes trade insults before single combat in a very similar way. Commentators such as P. Kyle McCarter (Anchor Bible) note the Homeric colouring.

  • Not necessarily. Champion combat and taunting were common across the ancient Near East.

    The Egyptian Story of Sinuhe (early 2nd millennium BC, set in Canaan) has a local champion's challenge with no Aegean connection. Israel's own sources record champion contests between Israelite groups (2 Sam 2).

in v11

Is the shorter Greek version of 1 Samuel 17 (without vv. 12–31, 55–58, 18:1–5) closer to the original, or an abridgement?

  • The shorter Greek form is an older, single coherent account. The Hebrew text later added a second David-and-Goliath tradition.

    In the MT, v. 12 introduces David as if he were new, although he is already Saul's armour-bearer in 16:21. In 17:55–58 Saul asks who David is. Without these sections the story reads smoothly, with v. 11 leading into David's response in v. 32 (e.g. Tov, McCarter, Lust in *The Story of David and Goliath*, 1986).

  • The Hebrew is original, and the Greek translator or its Hebrew source cut the passages to smooth out the apparent contradictions.

    Shortening a text to remove tensions is a known practice, and the omitted sections are exactly the ones that create problems (e.g. Gooding, Barthélemy in the same 1986 volume). Some read the MT as a deliberately layered literary design.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. חָרַף
  • HALOT s.v. חרף I
  • HALOT s.v. מַעֲרָכָה
  • BDB s.v. אִישׁ (ʾîš habbēnayim)
  • Waltke & O'Connor, An Introduction to Biblical Hebrew Syntax §30.5.1 (perfect used for an act done in the saying)
  • Roland de Vaux, 'Single Combat in the Old Testament', in The Bible and the Ancient Near East (1971)
  • Harry A. Hoffner Jr., 'A Hittite Analogue to the David and Goliath Contest of Champions?', CBQ 30 (1968)
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible, 1980)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 17
  • Story of Sinuhe (Middle Kingdom Egyptian)
  • Homer, Iliad books 3 and 7
  • Septuagint 1 Kingdoms 17:10; Psalm 151 superscription (LXX)
  • BDB s.v. חָתַת
  • HALOT s.v. חתת
  • HALOT s.v. ירא
  • BDB s.v. שָׁמַע
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 17:1–11 and the LXX shorter text
  • D. Barthélemy, D. W. Gooding, J. Lust, E. Tov, The Story of David and Goliath: Textual and Literary Criticism (1986)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 17 (representative combat)
  • Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 17:11 (Rahlfs)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).