Deuteronomy Chapter 29 Read as one passage
Deuteronomy 29:4–7
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
4Yet to this day the LORD has not given you a mind to understand, eyes to see, or ears to hear. 5For forty years I led you in the wilderness, yet your clothes and sandals did not wear out. 6You ate no bread and drank no wine or strong drink, so that you might know that I am the LORD your God. 7When you reached this place, Sihon king of Heshbon and Og king of Bashan came out against us in battle, but we defeated them.
What the first hearers heard
To Israelites hearing this in the covenant setting, the verse was a shock. After the long list of wonders, they might expect Moses to say "and so you know the LORD." He says the opposite: you saw everything and understood nothing that mattered. Miracles had not produced loyalty. The wilderness record of complaints at Massah, the golden calf, and refusing to enter the land at Kadesh (Deut 9:7–24) proved it.
The verse worked in several ways:
- Humbling. Israel could not claim it had earned the land through spiritual insight (compare 9:4–6: "not because of your righteousness").
- Urgent. "Until this day" turns the covenant day into a moment of decision. Right after this, Moses says "keep the words of this covenant" (29:9) and "you are standing today, all of you, before the LORD" (29:10).
- Looking ahead. Deuteronomy expects that the problem will continue after the conquest (31:27–29), and it also promises a cure from God himself: "the LORD your God will circumcise your heart… so that you will love the LORD" (30:6). The heart God had not yet given in 29:4 is the heart he promises to give in 30:6.
Later Israel heard this verse as the first statement of a lasting theme. The prophets took up its language (Isa 6:9–10; Jer 5:21; Ezek 12:2), and Jeremiah's and Ezekiel's promises of a new heart (Jer 24:7; 31:33; Ezek 36:26) answer it.
From the study of Deuteronomy 29:4.
Verse by verse
-
4Yet to this day the LORD has not given you a mind to understand, eyes to see, or ears to hear.
Full study →"And yet, through all of it, YHWH has not given you a mind that truly grasps, eyes that truly see, or ears that truly listen and obey. Not even now, on this very day."
The verse turns sharply on verse 3. Moses has just said: your own eyes saw the plagues, the testings, the signs and wonders. Now he says that those same people were never given eyes to see. The contrast is between looking at events and perceiving what they meant: that YHWH was their God, carrying them, as the next verses spell out (29:5–6: forty years of clothes that did not wear out, so "that you may know that I am the LORD your God").
Each part of the person is named with what it is for:
- a heart (the Hebrew "heart" is mainly the place of thinking and deciding) for knowing, meaning recognising and acknowledging YHWH, not just holding facts about him;
- eyes for seeing through events to their meaning;
- ears for hearing, which in Deuteronomy means hearing and heeding, as in "Hear, O Israel."
Understanding is described as something YHWH gives, the same verb used for gifts like the land and the manna. Moses is not excusing Israel; the whole speech holds them responsible. He is saying that the knowledge that leads to loyalty does not come automatically from seeing miracles.
The closing "until this very day" stands at the end of the sentence in Hebrew for weight. It means not even yet, and also points to today, the covenant day at Moab, as the moment when things must change. Later in the speech God promises to "circumcise your heart" (30:6), and that promise answers this verse.
-
5For forty years I led you in the wilderness, yet your clothes and sandals did not wear out.
Full study →"I — the LORD — made you walk, step by step, for forty years through the empty steppe-land. In all that time the wool cloaks you wrapped yourselves in by day and slept under by night never frayed into rags and fell off you, and the leather sandal tied to each of your feet never wore through and dropped away."
Moses is the speaker, but in this verse his voice turns into God's own "I". Verse 6 makes that explicit: "so that you might know that I am the LORD your God." The verb is "made you walk", which leads straight to the sandals: a whole generation walked, and their footwear did not give out. The word for "wore out" is the everyday word for cloth turning threadbare. The cloak was the large outer wrap that many people relied on as their only blanket. The sandal was the cheapest and quickest thing to wear out. Each half of the verse adds "from upon you" and "from upon your foot", which pictures clothing that should have fallen away in tatters still hanging on the body. Partway through, the address changes from "you all" to a singular "you": "your sandal, on your foot." The whole assembly is spoken to as if each person, or Israel as one person, were in view.
The verse is evidence. Verse 4 has just said the people still lack "a heart to understand." Verses 5–6 set out what they should have understood: for forty years they lived outside the normal economy of farms, looms and markets, eating no ordinary bread and drinking no wine, and still they were clothed and shod. The point is that they should know who has been looking after them.
-
6You ate no bread and drank no wine or strong drink, so that you might know that I am the LORD your God.
Full study →"Bread, you never ate. Wine and beer, you never drank. That was so you would come to know, from your own experience, that I, YHWH, am your God."
Moses is reminding the people of their forty years in the wilderness, and in the middle of his speech God's own voice breaks through: "I led you" (v. 5), "I am the LORD your God" (v. 6). The verse is not saying the people went hungry. They were fed every day. But they were not fed with what farmers eat. Bread is the product of ploughing, harvest, threshing, milling and baking. Wine needs vineyards tended for years. Beer (the word behind "strong drink" probably means barley beer, not spirits) needs grain fields and brewing. None of these is possible for a people on the move without land of their own.
So for a whole generation, the ordinary staples that people grow and make for themselves were missing. In their place was manna, the "bread from heaven" that arrived fresh every morning. That gap was deliberate (so that). The goal was not head knowledge but recognition born of experience: that this particular God, known by his name YHWH, had kept them alive and was their God, and that they were his people. Coming just before the covenant was renewed in Moab, the verse says in effect: You have already lived on my provision for forty years. You know who I am. Now pledge yourselves to me.
-
7When you reached this place, Sihon king of Heshbon and Og king of Bashan came out against us in battle, but we defeated them.
Full study →"Then you arrived here, at this very place. Sihon, king of Heshbon, and Og, king of Bashan, marched out to meet us in battle, and we struck them down."
Moses is reminding the people of things they saw for themselves. Earlier in this speech he has called up the plagues in Egypt and forty years of being kept alive in the wilderness (vv. 2–6). Now he comes to the most recent events, which this audience fought in themselves only months earlier. The journey ends at "this place", the camp in the plains of Moab where they are standing as he speaks.
The two kings came out, the usual phrase for an army marching from its city to fight. Their aggression is the point: Israel did not start these wars. Sihon ruled a strong city on the plateau. Og ruled Bashan, a rich land of walled towns, and was remembered as the last of the giant Rephaim. They were the most frightening opponents Israel had met.
"We struck them" does not mean a narrow win. The Hebrew verb means blows that strike down and kill, and the fuller accounts say both kings and their armies were wiped out (Deut 2:33; 3:3).
Notice the shift in pronouns. Verse 6 ended with God speaking: "that you might know that I am the LORD your God." Then the voice slips back to Moses: "you came… they came out to meet us… we struck them." Moses stands among the people as one of the fighters, and the victory belongs to all of them together. The next verse (v. 8) draws the conclusion. Their land is now Israelite land, already handed out to Reuben, Gad and half of Manasseh. It is proof that the God who now asks them to swear loyalty in this covenant has already kept his promises on the ground where they stand.
Where the English drifted
-
in v4
heart
lev
- What we hear
- The seat of emotions and affection, as opposed to the 'head'.
- What they heard
- The inner person as the place of thought, understanding, memory and decision. A 'heart to know' is a mind able to understand and commit.
-
in v4
to know / to understand
lada'at (yada')
- What we hear
- Intellectual comprehension: grasping information or an explanation.
- What they heard
- Recognising and acknowledging someone through experience, here YHWH as Israel's God (29:6). The word has a covenant sense of recognising whose people you are.
-
in v4
ears to hear
'oznayim lishmoa' (shama')
- What we hear
- The ability to take in or listen to a message.
- What they heard
- Ears that hear *and heed*. In Deuteronomy, shama' is the ordinary word for obeying ('Hear, O Israel').
-
in v5
shoe (KJV)
na'al
- What we hear
- An enclosed leather or fabric shoe.
- What they heard
- A sandal: a sole tied to the foot with thongs, the ordinary footwear of the ancient Near East and the first thing to wear through on desert ground.
-
in v5
wilderness
midbar
- What we hear
- Forest or wild nature, or (with 'desert') sand dunes.
- What they heard
- Dry, unsettled steppe and rocky scrubland with no towns or farms, where ordinary supplies could not be replaced.
-
in v6
strong drink
šēkār
- What we hear
- Hard liquor or spirits, something much stronger than wine.
- What they heard
- A fermented drink other than grape wine, most likely barley beer and possibly date or fruit wine. It was intoxicating but not distilled, and often no stronger than wine.
-
in v7
smote / struck (and "defeated")
nakah (hiphil)
- What we hear
- "Smote" sounds archaic or comic, or suggests a supernatural punishment from heaven. "Defeated" sounds like simply winning, as in a game or an election.
- What they heard
- The ordinary verb for striking blows. In battle it means striking down and killing the enemy. The parallel accounts say Sihon's and Og's forces were destroyed until no survivor was left (Deut 2:33–34; 3:3).
Every word
-
וְלֹֽא־
ve-lo · H3808
and not · v4, v5, v6
The 'and' here works as 'yet' or 'but'. It sets this verse against verse 3: you saw the great signs with your own eyes, *and yet* you were not given eyes that truly see. The negation comes first, so the sentence opens on what is missing.
-
נָתַן֩
natan · H5414
give · v4
A completed action ('has given'), looking back over the forty years. Understanding is described as something YHWH gives, like the manna, the water and the land. The verse does not say Israel lacked the organs. It says they lacked the gift of using them rightly.
-
יְהוָ֨ה
YHWH · H3068
the LORD (Yahweh) · v4, v6
Israel's God, called by his covenant name. He is the one who gave the signs in verse 3, and here he is the one who has not yet given the understanding to match them.
-
לָכֶ֥ם
lakhem · H9036
to you (plural) · v4
'You' is plural: the whole assembled people as one body. The generation that left Egypt and their children standing at Moab are treated as a single 'you'.
-
לֵב֙
lev · H3820
heart, mind · v4
The inner person, where thinking, understanding, deciding and commitment happen. It is mainly the organ of thought and will, not of feeling. A 'heart to know' is a mind able to grasp what has happened and respond to it.
-
לָדַ֔עַת
lada'at · H3045
to know · v4, v6
An infinitive with 'to' ('for knowing'), saying what the heart is for. Knowing here means recognising and acknowledging. Two verses later the purpose of the wilderness years is given as 'that you may know that I am the LORD your God' (29:6).
-
וְעֵינַ֥יִם
ve-'einayim · H5869
and eyes · v4
A dual form, meaning a pair of eyes. It picks up 'your eyes saw' in verse 3: the same eyes that watched the plagues and the sea have not yet been given the power to see what those events meant.
-
לִרְא֖וֹת
lir'ot · H7200
to see · v4
'For seeing.' Here this means seeing through to the meaning of what was seen, not just physical sight, which Israel plainly had.
-
וְאָזְנַ֣יִם
ve-'oznayim · H0241
and ears · v4
A dual: a pair of ears. Together with heart and eyes, this completes the picture of the whole person taking in God's acts and words.
-
לִשְׁמֹ֑עַ
lishmoa' · H8085
to hear · v4
'For hearing.' In Deuteronomy, shama' regularly means to hear and heed, as in 'Hear, O Israel' (6:4). Ears 'to hear' are ears that listen and obey, not only ears that register sound.
-
עַ֖ד
'ad · H5704
until, up to · v4
Marks a limit in time: 'up to'. Whether things change after that limit is the open question of the verse (see Debates).
-
הַיּ֥וֹם
hayyom · H3117
the day · v4
With 'this' it means 'today'. In Deuteronomy 'today' is a loaded word: it is the day of the covenant ceremony in the plains of Moab, repeated again and again in 29:10–15.
-
הַזֶּֽה׃
hazzeh · H2088
this · v4, v7
'This very day.' It places the phrase at the end of the sentence, where it carries weight: up to the very moment Moses is speaking.
-
וָאוֹלֵ֥ךְ
va'olekh · H1980
and I led / made to walk · v5
This is the causative form of the ordinary verb 'to walk': 'I made you walk', 'I led you on foot'. The narrative verb form presents the forty years as one completed act of guidance. The 'I' is God himself, as v. 6 confirms ('that I am the LORD your God'), even though Moses is the one speaking.
-
אֶתְכֶ֛ם
etkhem · H0853
you (object, plural) · v5
The object marker with a plural 'you'. It addresses the whole assembly standing on the plains of Moab as the people who were led, even though most of the adults who left Egypt had died in the wilderness.
-
אַרְבָּעִ֥ים
arba'im · H0705
forty · v5
The fixed length of the wilderness period, one year for each day of the spies' mission (Num 14:33–34). It is about a generation, long enough for any ordinary cloak or sandal to wear out many times over.
-
שָׁנָ֖ה
shanah · H8141
year · v5
Singular after 'forty', as Hebrew normally writes it. Used here as a measure of time ('for forty years').
-
בַּמִּדְבָּ֑ר
bammidbar · H4057
in the wilderness · v5
The dry, rocky steppe south and east of Canaan. It has no towns and no fields, though scrub can support flocks for part of the year. Food, water and goods could not be replaced there in the usual ways.
-
בָל֤וּ
valu · H1086
wore out, grew old · v5
'They wore out', meaning they grew threadbare and fell apart from age and use. It is the normal word for cloth wearing out, and it is used of a worn-out body too (Gen 18:12).
-
שַׂלְמֹֽתֵיכֶם֙
salmoteikhem · H8008
your cloaks / garments · v5
The large outer wrap of woven wool. People wore it by day and slept under it at night, and for many it was the most valuable thing they owned. The plural 'your' covers every Israelite's cloak.
-
מֵעֲלֵיכֶ֔ם
me'aleikhem · H5921
from upon you · v5
Literally 'from on you'. Cloth that wears out falls away from the body in rags. This phrase pictures the cloaks still hanging whole on the people who wore them.
-
וְנַֽעַלְךָ֥
vena'alkha · H5275
and your sandal · v5
A leather sole tied on with thongs. Here the address switches to a singular 'you', as if Moses were speaking to each listener, or to Israel as one person. Sandals were the first thing to give out on rough desert ground.
-
רַגְלֶֽךָ׃
raglekha · H7272
your foot · v5
Singular 'your foot', with a singular 'your'. With the matching 'from upon you' it ends the verse on a picture of the body still covered and protected after forty years of walking.
-
לֶ֚חֶם
leḥem · H3899
bread, food · v6
Ordinary bread baked from grain that people farmed, harvested and milled. It comes first in the sentence for emphasis: 'Bread, you did not eat.' Their daily food had been manna, which Exodus calls 'bread from heaven'. Here the word means the ordinary bread that comes from the soil.
-
אֲכַלְתֶּ֔ם
ʾăkaltem · H0398
to eat · v6
'You (plural) ate.' The verb form looks back over the whole forty years as one completed stretch of time. The 'you' is the assembled people as a whole, including a generation that was mostly not born yet when the march began.
-
וְיַ֥יִן
wəyayin · H3196
wine · v6
'And wine': fermented grape wine, the everyday drink of settled farming life in Canaan. It needs vineyards, years of tending and a fixed home.
-
וְשֵׁכָ֖ר
wəšēkār · H7941
beer, intoxicating drink · v6
'And beer/fermented drink': an intoxicating drink brewed from grain (barley beer) or possibly from dates or other fruit. It was not distilled liquor. Like wine, it belongs to a settled farming economy.
-
שְׁתִיתֶ֑ם
šətîtem · H8354
to drink · v6
'You (plural) drank.' It mirrors 'you ate'. Together the two verbs cover the whole ordinary diet of a farming people.
-
לְמַ֙עַן֙
ləmaʿan · H4616
in order that · v6
'So that, for the purpose that.' It turns the list of things they lacked into a deliberate plan. The forty years without ordinary food had a goal.
-
כִּ֛י
kî · H3588
that · v6
Introduces what is to be known: 'that…'.
-
אֲנִ֥י
ʾănî · H0589
I · v6
'I.' Moses has been speaking, but now the voice is God's own, as already in the previous verse ('I led you'). Moses speaks God's words in the first person.
-
אֱלֹהֵיכֶֽם׃
ʾĕlōhêkem · H0430
God (your God) · v6
'Your (plural) God.' This names the covenant relationship: YHWH is God to this people in particular, and they belong to him.
-
וַתָּבֹ֖אוּ
vattavo'u · H0935
come, go in, arrive · v7
"And you came / arrived." Plural "you": Moses speaks to the whole people as one group. The verb form carries the story forward, picking up the wilderness journey from verses 5–6 and bringing it to where they now stand.
-
אֶל־
'el- · H0413
to, toward · v7
Marks where they arrived: "to" this place.
-
הַמָּק֣וֹם
hammaqom · H4725
place, standing-place, site · v7
"The place": here a plain geographical word for the spot where Israel is camped, the plains of Moab across the Jordan from Jericho. In Deuteronomy the same word also names "the place the LORD will choose" for worship, but that meaning does not apply here.
-
וַיֵּצֵ֣א
vayyetse' · H3318
go out, come out · v7
"And he came out." In war stories this is the usual verb for an army marching out of its city or territory to fight. The verb is singular even though two kings follow: Hebrew often matches the verb to the first name in a list.
-
סִיחֹ֣ן
Sichon · H5511
Sihon · v7
The Amorite king who refused Israel passage and attacked them at Jahaz (Num 21:21–24; Deut 2:26–33). His defeat was the first conquest of land.
-
מֶֽלֶךְ־
melekh- · H4428
king · v7
"King of": a local ruler of a city and its surrounding territory, not an emperor. Still, these were real powers whose defeat counted for a great deal.
-
חֶ֠שְׁבּוֹן
Cheshbon · H2809
Heshbon · v7
Sihon's capital on the Transjordan plateau, east of the north end of the Dead Sea. According to Num 21:26 he had taken it from Moab.
-
וְע֨וֹג
ve'Og · H5747
Og · v7
"And Og": king of Bashan, called the last of the Rephaim, a people remembered as giants. His huge iron bed was remembered too (Deut 3:11). His name stood for a fearsome enemy.
-
הַבָּשָׁ֧ן
habbashan · H1316
Bashan · v7
"The Bashan", a fertile, well-watered high plain north of the Yarmuk River (today's Golan and Hauran). It was famous for strong cattle, oaks and walled cities (Deut 3:4–5; Ps 22:12; Amos 4:1).
-
לִקְרָאתֵ֛נוּ
liqra'tenu · H7122
to meet, encounter · v7
Literally "to meet us", "to confront us". The word is neutral in itself (it is also used for welcoming a guest). Paired with "for battle", it means a hostile confrontation. Note the "us": Moses now counts himself among the people.
-
לַמִּלְחָמָ֖ה
lammilchamah · H4421
-
וַנַּכֵּֽם׃
vannakkem · H5221
strike, strike down, defeat · v7
"And we struck them (down)." Used of war, this verb means landing deadly blows: defeating and killing, not just pushing back. The parallel accounts say both kings and their armies were destroyed (Deut 2:33–34; 3:3).
The world behind it
A covenant ceremony at the edge of the land. Deuteronomy 29–30 is set on the plains of Moab, just before Israel crosses the Jordan, where Moses leads a covenant renewal (29:1, "besides the covenant he made with them at Horeb"). Verses 2–8 follow a pattern found in ancient Near Eastern treaties, especially Hittite treaties of the second millennium BC: the overlord first recounts what he has done for his vassal (a "historical prologue") and only then lays down obligations. Here YHWH's acts are listed: Egypt, the wilderness, clothes and sandals that did not wear out, and the victories over Sihon and Og.
One "you" across the generations. Most adults who left Egypt had died in the wilderness (Deut 2:14–16). Even so, Moses says "your eyes saw" (29:3) to the people in front of him. In Israel's corporate way of thinking, the people is one body across generations; the same idea appears in 5:3 ("not with our fathers… but with us, who are all of us here alive today"). This verse's "not given to you" applies to that whole body.
Forty years and a teacher's mind. Rabbinic tradition linked this verse to the forty years of 29:5: "a person does not fully grasp his teacher's mind until forty years" (Babylonian Talmud, Avodah Zarah 5b; Rashi on this verse). On that reading, "until this day" marks the end of a long apprenticeship.
From the study of Deuteronomy 29:4.
Where scholars differ
in v4
Does 'until this day' mean the lack continues, or that it ends today?
-
An ongoing indictment: Israel still lacks this understanding, and Deuteronomy expects the lack to continue until God gives a new heart.
Deut 31:27–29 predicts rebellion after Moses' death. 30:1–6 places heart circumcision after exile. Paul reads the phrase as still true in his day (Rom 11:8). Many critical commentators read 29:4 as the problem to which 30:6 is the answer.
-
A turning point: understanding was lacking up to now, but this covenant day is when it should begin.
Deuteronomy's 'today' marks the covenant moment ('this day you have become the people', 27:9; 29:10–15). The rabbinic reading (b. Avodah Zarah 5b; Rashi) links it to forty years of learning: only after forty years does a student grasp his teacher's mind.
-
Deliberately open: a challenge that can be read either way.
The Hebrew does not say what follows 'until'. In the surrounding speech, Moses both demands a decision today (30:15–20) and predicts failure (31:16–29), so the open phrasing keeps the challenge in place.
in v4
Is God being blamed for withholding understanding, or is Israel being blamed?
-
The verse places the ultimate cause in God: understanding is a divine gift that had not been given, in the same way God 'hardened' Pharaoh and Sihon (Deut 2:30).
The subject of the verb is YHWH. 30:6 presents the cure as something God alone does. Isaiah 6:9–10 and Paul's use in Rom 11:8 develop the idea of divine withholding or hardening.
-
It is a rebuke of Israel phrased as a statement about God; Israel remains fully responsible.
The whole context blames Israel (9:6–24; 29:18–21). Moses earlier wished 'Oh that they had such a heart' (5:29), and he says the word is 'in your heart, so you can do it' (30:14). Hebrew thought commonly says God causes something without removing human responsibility.
in v5
Who is the 'I' who led them, and why does the speaker change?
-
Moses' speech moves straight into God's own words, as prophets often do without saying 'thus says the LORD'.
Verse 6 has 'so that you may know that I am the LORD your God', which only God can say. Amos 2:10 uses almost the same first-person formula on God's lips. Deuteronomy presents Moses as the model prophet (18:15–18).
-
Moses speaks loosely as God's agent: he led them in a human sense, and the voice shades into God's.
Moses did lead Israel physically (Exod 32:34; Num 33:1). Ancient versions such as the Septuagint switch to 'he led', which shows the shift was felt to be awkward. Verse 6 still points to the divine 'I' in the end.
in v5
Is the claim a literal miracle of preservation, or a poetic way of saying God provided everything they needed?
-
Literal: cloaks and sandals were miraculously kept from wearing out.
The plain wording, repeated in Deut 8:4 and Neh 9:21. It sits beside manna, water from the rock and the other wilderness signs. Later Jewish interpretation took it further: Rashi on Deut 8:4, drawing on earlier midrash (Jewish interpretive tradition), says the clouds of glory cleaned the garments and children's clothes grew with them. That expansion is later tradition, not something the text says.
-
Exaggerated or idealised language: through God's provision they never lacked clothing, without implying any single garment lasted forty years.
Deuteronomy uses heightened, sweeping speech for the wilderness elsewhere. Neh 9:21 frames the point as 'they lacked nothing'. Israel did have flocks and goods from Egypt (Exod 12:35–38). Either way, the text's purpose (v. 6) is to show God's care, not to describe how cloth behaves.
in v6
Why does the speaker shift from Moses to God in the first person ('I led you… I am the LORD your God')?
-
Moses speaks as God's prophetic mouthpiece. The slide into God's own 'I' is deliberate and fits Deuteronomy's picture of Moses as the prophet who speaks God's words (18:18).
The same shift happens elsewhere in Deuteronomy (e.g. 11:13–15; 7:4). Old Testament prophets regularly move into the divine 'I' without introduction.
-
The shift reflects how the text was put together. A traditional formula ('that you may know that I am YHWH your God', compare Exodus 16:12) was inserted into Moses' speech as a fixed phrase.
The wording closely matches the manna story in Exodus 16:12. Verse 7 immediately returns to Moses' 'we'.
in v6
Is the main point deprivation (God made them go without) or provision (God fed them miraculously)?
-
Provision. The verse belongs to a list of wonders (clothes that did not wear out, food from heaven, victories) that show God's care.
The surrounding vv. 5 and 7–8 are all about benefits God gave. Exodus 16:12 ties 'you shall know' to being filled with bread from heaven.
-
Deprivation as training. Going without normal food was a deliberate humbling meant to teach dependence.
Deuteronomy 8:2–3 says God 'humbled you and let you hunger and fed you with manna… to make you know that man does not live by bread alone'. The negative wording ('you did not eat') points to what was withheld.
-
Both together. The withholding and the miraculous supply are two sides of one lesson.
Deuteronomy 8:3 puts hunger and manna in the same sentence with the same goal of 'knowing'. Most commentators combine the two readings.
in v7
How do the Sihon and Og accounts relate to archaeology, especially at Heshbon?
-
The archaeological record at Tell Hesban counts against a Late Bronze Age kingdom there.
Excavations at Tell Hesban (the Heshbon Expedition, from 1968 on) found little or no Late Bronze Age occupation. Settlement there is mainly Iron Age I and later. Many scholars therefore see the Sihon story as shaped by later Israelite memory and claims to Transjordan territory. Some read the Heshbon victory song in Num 21:27–30 as originally belonging to other conflicts.
-
The evidence does not rule out the tradition.
Some argue that biblical Heshbon in Sihon's time was at a different site, such as Tell Jalul, or that the Amorite "city" was a modest settlement or tent camp that left few remains. Others redate the events. They also point out that absence of remains at one site is weak evidence on its own.
Sources
- BDB s.v. לֵב, יָדַע, שָׁמַע
- HALOT s.v. לֵב; יָדַע
- Hans Walter Wolff, Anthropology of the Old Testament (on lev as the seat of reason and will)
- Herbert B. Huffmon, 'The Treaty Background of Hebrew Yāda'', BASOR 181 (1966)
- Jeffrey H. Tigay, The JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (on 29:3[4] and verse numbering)
- Moshe Weinfeld, Deuteronomy and the Deuteronomic School (treaty form)
- Babylonian Talmud, Avodah Zarah 5b; Rashi on Deut 29:3
- Septuagint, Deuteronomy 29:3
- Romans 11:8; Isaiah 6:9–10; Jeremiah 5:21; Ezekiel 12:2
- BDB s.v. הָלַךְ, בָּלָה, שַׂלְמָה, נַעַל, מִדְבָּר
- HALOT s.v. בלה, שַׂלְמָה, מִדְבָּר
- Jeffrey H. Tigay, JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (1996), on 8:4 and 29:4–5
- Moshe Weinfeld, Deuteronomy and the Deuteronomic School (on treaty form and historical prologue)
- Rashi on Deuteronomy 8:4 (later midrashic tradition)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Deut 29
- P. J. King and L. E. Stager, Life in Biblical Israel (clothing and footwear)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Deut 29:4; Vulgate Deut 29:5
- BDB and HALOT s.v. לֶחֶם, יַיִן, שֵׁכָר, יָדַע, לְמַעַן
- Akkadian šikaru (beer): CAD Š/2 s.v. šikaru
- H. B. Huffmon, 'The Treaty Background of Hebrew Yādaʿ', BASOR 181 (1966)
- J. H. Tigay, JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (1996), on 29:4–5 (Heb.)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Deuteronomy 29
- Exodus 16:4, 12, 15; Deuteronomy 2:6, 28; 8:2–3, 17; 14:26; Joshua 5:11–12 (parallels)
- Septuagint Deuteronomy 29:5 (Gk. numbering); Vulgate Deuteronomy 29:6
- HALOT s.v. נכה (hiphil), יצא, קרא II, בָּשָׁן
- BDB s.v. נָכָה, לִקְרַאת
- Septuagint, Deuteronomy 29:6 (Rahlfs)
- Num 21:21–35; Deut 2:24–3:11 (parallel accounts)
- K. A. Kitchen & P. J. N. Lawrence, Treaty, Law and Covenant in the Ancient Near East (on the historical-prologue form)
- J. H. Tigay, JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (on 29:1–8 and versification)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Deut 2–3 and 29
- Heshbon Expedition reports (L. T. Geraty et al.) on Tell Hesban
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).