Exodus Chapter 21 Read as one passage

Exodus 21:23–24

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

23But if a serious injury results, then you must require a life for a life— 24eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot,

What the first hearers heard

To Israelites hearing this law, the verse said several things at once:

  • Unintended harm is still real harm. The striker meant to hit someone else, yet if his blow brings disaster on the woman, the community may not treat it as a minor matter settled by a fine. A life has been lost, and the answer must be weighed in lives.
  • A pregnant woman, and what she carries, is under the law's protection. Even in the "no disaster" case of v. 22, the striker pays her husband. Verse 23 raises the stakes when the outcome is grave.
  • Justice is proportional and personal. The phrase "in place of" assured hearers that the penalty would match the loss. Unlike Hammurabi's law, it would not fall on the offender's innocent daughter and would not vary with the victim's rank.
  • This is the court's business. The settlement is framed in the legal language of "giving" and assessment that runs through the chapter. It belongs to judges and community, not to a family's private vengeance.

The formula is short, rhythmic and easy to remember, and it went on to be quoted throughout Israel's legal tradition (Lev 24:17–21; Deut 19:21).

From the study of Exodus 21:23.

Verse by verse

  1. 23But if a serious injury results, then you must require a life for a life—

    "But if disaster does strike — if the blow proves deadly — then you shall give a life in place of the life that was lost."

    The verse finishes a two-part case. Two men are fighting, and one of them hits a pregnant woman who is standing nearby. Verse 22 covers the outcome where her child or children come out but no disaster follows. There the striker pays whatever the woman's husband claims, as the judges assess it. Verse 23 is the mirror case: if disaster does follow. The word for it, 'asôn, is rare. In its only other uses Jacob dreads it as something that could kill his youngest son and send his father to the grave in grief. So the word points to a deadly or grievous outcome, not a bruise. Who suffers it, the mother only or possibly her child, is not stated, and readers have disagreed since ancient times.

    The ruling is stated as an equation: nefesh (a living being, a life) set taḥat ("in the place of", "in exchange for") nefesh. The verb is "give", the same verb used one verse earlier for paying the fine. So the sentence sounds like settling a debt: what was lost must be matched by something of equal weight, no more and no less. The sudden "you" (singular) may speak to the offender ("you shall give") or to the community and its judges who must see the matter settled.

    This is the opening line of the famous series that continues "eye for eye, tooth for tooth" (vv. 24–25). The first hearers understood it as a principle a court applies: the penalty fits the harm, it falls on the offender himself and not on his family, and a human life is not reduced to a fine. Whether "life for life" was carried out literally or could be settled by an equivalent payment in such a case is a real and ancient question (see debates).

    Full study →
  2. 24eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot,

    Grammatically this verse is the middle of a sentence. Verse 23 begins: "If harm happens, you shall give life in place of life." Verse 24 continues the list of what is to be given, and verse 25 finishes it with burn, wound and bruise.

    So the full sense is: "[you shall give] an eye in the place of an eye, a tooth in the place of a tooth, a hand in the place of a hand, a foot in the place of a foot."

    What the first hearers heard was a measure, not a mood. The repeated word taḥat means "in place of, as the equivalent of". The rhythm of eye/eye, tooth/tooth works like a legal maxim: the penalty must equal the harm. It must not be less, as if a poor man's eye did not count. It must not be more, the way a blood feud spirals when a family avenges a tooth with a life. The list moves from the gravest injury (the eye) to a lesser one (the tooth), and verse 25 goes down to a bruise, so the point is proportion at every level.

    This is law for the community's judges. It is not permission for an injured man to take revenge himself. The case in view is two men fighting who injure a bystander, a pregnant woman (vv. 22–23). The immediate context also uses the same "in place of" language for payment: a master frees his slave "in place of his eye" (v. 26), and an owner pays "ox in place of ox" (v. 36). So the verse states the principle of exact equivalence. Whether that equivalent was ever, or always, carried out on the offender's body, or usually paid as its value, was debated in antiquity and still is.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v23

    mischief (KJV, YLT)

    'asôn

    What we hear
    Playful naughtiness, pranks, minor trouble-making.
    What they heard
    A calamity, probably deadly or grievous, the kind of disaster Jacob feared would kill Benjamin (Gen 42:38).
  • in v23

    life for life (and the 'eye for eye' series it heads)

    nefesh taḥat nefesh

    What we hear
    A licence for personal revenge, or a picture of crude, bloodthirsty justice.
    What they heard
    A court-administered principle of equal value. The penalty must match the harm, fall on the offender alone, and not exceed the loss. It limited retaliation rather than encouraging it.
  • in v24

    an eye for an eye

    ʿayin taḥat ʿayin

    What we hear
    A slogan for personal revenge: "you hurt me, so I get to hurt you back". It is often treated as the harsh opposite of mercy, as in "an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind".
    What they heard
    A legal standard for judges: the penalty must be the equivalent of the injury, no more and no less, and the same for every free person. Its job was to replace private revenge and to cap it. In this chapter the same "in place of" wording also covers compensation given as the equivalent of a loss.
Every word
  1. וְאִם־

    ve'im · H518

    and if · v23

    Opens the second half of a two-part case law. Verse 22 said 'and there is no disaster', and this clause answers it: 'but if there is disaster'. The 'and' here works as a contrast ('but'), as most translations recognise.

  2. אָס֖וֹן

    'asôn · H611

    harm, disaster, fatal mishap · v23

    A rare word for a calamity that strikes someone, probably a deadly or grievous one. It is the hinge of the case: with no 'asôn the striker pays a fine (v. 22), and with 'asôn the talion formula applies. The verse does not say who suffers it, the woman or (on some readings) the child, and that is one of the main points of debate.

  3. יִהְיֶ֑ה

    yihyeh · H1961

    to be, happen · v23

    'There is' or 'it happens'. The imperfect form here describes a possible situation in law ('should there be'). The main pause mark of the verse falls on this word and closes the 'if' clause.

  4. וְנָתַתָּ֥ה

    venātattāh · H5414

    to give, pay · v23

    'Then you shall give.' The grammatical form (a perfect verb after 'and', which in law carries a future sense of obligation) states what must follow. It is the same verb used in v. 22 for paying the fine ('he shall give'), so the language of settlement continues. The sudden switch to 'you' is striking. It could be the offender who gives, or the court or community who imposes the penalty.

  5. נֶ֖פֶשׁ

    nefesh · H5315

    life, living being, person · v23

    The life given in settlement. Here it means a life, a living person, and not an immaterial 'soul'.

  6. תַּ֥חַת

    taḥat · H8478

    under; in place of, in exchange for · v23, v24

    The word of equivalence: one thing put in the place of another. Elsewhere in this same chapter it marks repayment and compensation ('ox for ox', v. 36; 'free on account of his eye', v. 26).

  7. עַ֚יִן

    ʿayin · H5869

    eye · v24

    The injured eye, put first as the most valuable and most easily destroyed body part. It is the object of the verb "you shall give" carried over from verse 23, so the sense is "[you shall give] an eye…".

  8. שֵׁ֖ן

    shen · H8127

    tooth · v24

    A lesser injury than an eye. Putting it next to the eye shows the rule scales up and down. Minor harm gets a minor penalty, not the same penalty as major harm.

  9. יָ֚ד

    yad · H3027

    hand · v24

    The hand, which was a person's means of working and earning. Losing a hand meant losing a living, so the injury had economic weight as well as bodily weight.

  10. רֶ֖גֶל

    regel · H7272

    foot · v24

    The foot, needed to walk, herd and work fields. With the hand, it stands for the whole working body.

The world behind it

The law collection. Exodus 21:1–23:33, often called the "Book of the Covenant", is mostly made of case laws in the form "if X happens, then Y". Its neighbours in the ancient Near East wrote laws the same way. Exodus 21:18–36 deals with bodily injury: fights, injured slaves, goring oxen. Cases like these were heard by elders and judges at the town gate, not settled by private revenge.

The scenario. The case is a bystander injured during a brawl. The striker did not intend to hurt her. That sets it apart from deliberate murder (21:12, 14) and from accidental killing, where the killer could flee to a place of refuge (21:13). Ancient readers noticed this in-between status. It is partly why later Jewish interpreters asked whether "life for life" here meant death or a payment.

Neighbouring laws on the same case. Striking a pregnant woman was a standard case in ancient Near Eastern law:

  • Laws of Hammurabi §§209–214 (Babylon, c. 1750 BC) set fines for causing a miscarriage, graded by the woman's social class. If a free man's daughter died, the striker's own daughter was to be put to death (§210).
  • Middle Assyrian Laws A §§21, 50–52 also fine for miscarriage. In some cases they apply a kind of talion, "they shall do to him as he did to her", and require "full payment of a life" for the fetus.
  • Hittite Laws §§17–18 fix the fine by the stage of pregnancy.

Against this background two features of Exodus stand out. The "life for life" falls on the offender himself, not on his daughter, and the formula carries no class sliding scale. Hammurabi's law of "eye for eye" applied only between free men; injuring a commoner cost a fine (§§196–199).

The talion principle. "Like for like" (in Latin, lex talionis) existed in Mesopotamian law before Israel. In its setting it was a principle of proportion. It limited what an injured family could claim and stopped blood feuds from escalating, and it was administered by a court. Josephus (Antiquities 4.280), writing in the first century AD, says the injured party could accept money in place of a matching injury. Jesus quotes the "eye for eye" series in Matthew 5:38 when addressing personal retaliation.

From the study of Exodus 21:23.

Where scholars differ

in v23

Who suffers the 'disaster': the woman only, or the woman or her child?

  • Miscarriage reading: v. 22 describes a miscarriage (fine), and v. 23 concerns harm to the woman herself.

    Every surviving ancient Near Eastern parallel (Hammurabi §§209–214, Middle Assyrian Laws A §§50–52, Hittite §§17–18) treats this case as a miscarriage with a fine, plus a heavier penalty if the woman dies. The Vulgate and Josephus read it this way. Held by many critical commentators (e.g. Childs, Propp, Sarna's discussion of the parallels).

  • Premature-birth reading: v. 22 describes a live early birth, and the 'disaster' of v. 23 can fall on either the mother or the child.

    'Her children come out' uses yāṣā', a verb used for live births (Gen 25:25–26). Yeled ('child') is the ordinary word for a born child. The Hebrew words for miscarriage (shākal, nefel) are not used. 'asôn has no stated subject and so could apply to both. Reflected in BSB, NIV and ESV rendering v. 22 as a premature birth. Defended by some evangelical scholars (e.g. Cassuto among earlier commentators, and others since).

  • Formed/unformed reading: the penalty depends on whether the fetus was fully developed.

    The Septuagint and Philo. Ancient, but it depends on the Greek translators' interpretation rather than on the Hebrew wording.

in v23

Did 'life for life' mean literal execution or an equivalent payment?

  • Literal: the offender forfeits his life.

    The plain wording. Num 35:31 forbids accepting ransom for a murderer, which shows ransom was a live option and was barred in murder cases. Josephus (Ant. 4.278) says the striker dies if the woman dies.

  • A formula of equal value that could be settled by compensation.

    The verb is 'give', as in the fine of v. 22 and the ransom of v. 30. Taḥat marks repayment elsewhere in the chapter (v. 36). The identical phrase in Lev 24:18 means replacing an animal. Exod 21:30 allows a ransom even where the law says the ox's owner 'shall die'. The striker did not intend this harm, and accidental killers were otherwise spared (21:13). Rabbinic debate (b. Sanhedrin 79a–b) records Rabbi Judah the Prince taking it as money.

in v23

Who is the 'you' in 'you shall give'?

  • The offender: 'you (the guilty party) shall give a life'.

    It follows on from v. 22, where the striker 'shall give'. The verb 'give' naturally describes the one who pays.

  • The community or judge: 'you (Israel) shall impose life for life'.

    Similar talion lists address Israel as 'you' (Deut 19:21, 'your eye shall not pity'). Many translations (NIV, WEB 'take'; BSB 'require'; NASB 'appoint') adopt this reading. Some scholars think the shift in person shows that an older, fixed talion formula has been inserted into the case law.

in v24

Was the formula carried out literally on the offender's body, or did it set the value for compensation?

  • Literal penalty, at least in principle

    Hammurabi's laws (§§196–200) show literal matching injury was a real legal practice in the region. Lev 24:19–20 says "as he has done, so it shall be done to him". Deut 19:21 adds "your eye shall not pity". Josephus (Ant. 4.280) and Philo assume a literal penalty, with Josephus allowing money if the victim agreed. Sadducees are reported to have held the literal view.

  • A standard of value, normally paid as compensation

    In the same chapter taḥat names substitutes and payments: freedom "in place of his eye" (21:26–27), "ox in place of ox" (21:36). Verse 22 sets a fine through judges. Num 35:31 forbids ransom only for murder, which implies it was allowed otherwise. No biblical narrative records maiming as a court penalty. Rabbinic law (m. Bava Kamma 8:1; b. Bava Kamma 83b–84a) and Targum Pseudo-Jonathan read it as monetary.

  • A principle of proportion more than a schedule of penalties

    The list continues mechanically to burns and bruises (v. 25), which are hard to measure literally. It sits awkwardly in a case about a pregnant woman. Many scholars therefore see it as a stock legal formula that states the principle of exact equivalence, leaving judges to apply it.

in v24

In vv. 22–23, whose "harm" (ʾason) triggers the formula: the woman's, the child's, or both?

  • Harm to the woman; the "children coming out" means a miscarriage

    This is the common older Jewish and critical reading. It contrasts a fine for the loss of the fetus with talion for injury to the mother. It is comparable to Hammurabi §§209–210 and other ancient laws on striking a pregnant woman.

  • Harm to either mother or child; "children coming out" means a premature live birth

    The Hebrew yatsaʾ yeladeha ("her children go out") is normally used of live birth, and is not the usual word for miscarriage (shakal). ʾason is not limited to one party. On this reading, the eye-for-eye equivalence applies to injury to the newborn as well.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. אָסוֹן
  • HALOT s.v. אָסוֹן
  • HALOT s.v. נֶפֶשׁ
  • BDB s.v. תַּחַת
  • Laws of Hammurabi §§196–214
  • Middle Assyrian Laws A §§21, 50–52
  • Hittite Laws §§17–18
  • Septuagint Exodus 21:22–23
  • Vulgate Exodus 21:22–23
  • Philo, On the Special Laws 3.108–109
  • Josephus, Antiquities 4.278, 4.280
  • Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, Nezikin 8
  • Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 79a–b; Bava Kamma 83b–84a
  • W. H. C. Propp, Exodus 19–40 (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • B. S. Childs, The Book of Exodus (OTL)
  • N. M. Sarna, Exodus (JPS Torah Commentary)
  • U. Cassuto, A Commentary on the Book of Exodus
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Exod 21:22–25
  • HALOT s.v. תַּחַת
  • Laws of Hammurabi §§196–201, 209–210 (M. Roth, Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor)
  • Laws of Ur-Nammu and Laws of Eshnunna §42 (Roth, Law Collections)
  • Mishnah Bava Kamma 8:1
  • Babylonian Talmud Bava Kamma 83b–84a
  • Josephus, Antiquities 4.280
  • Philo, On the Special Laws 3.181–204
  • Targum Pseudo-Jonathan, Exodus 21:24
  • Septuagint, Exodus 21:22–25
  • B. S. Jackson, Wisdom-Laws: A Study of the Mishpatim of Exodus 21:1–22:16
  • R. Westbrook, Studies in Biblical and Cuneiform Law

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).