Exodus Chapter 21 Read as one passage
Exodus 21:28–29
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
28If an ox gores a man or woman to death, the ox must surely be stoned, and its meat must not be eaten. But the owner of the ox shall not be held responsible. 29But if the ox has a habit of goring, and its owner has been warned yet does not restrain it, and it kills a man or woman, then the ox must be stoned and its owner must also be put to death.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite farmers and village elders, who settled disputes at the town gate, this verse answered a practical and painful question: what do we do when a neighbour's ox kills someone?
It told them three things:
- Human life has to be answered for, even when no person is to blame. The ox is executed by the community in the same way as a human killer. Hearers who knew the story of Noah would have heard Genesis 9:5, where God says he will require human lifeblood even from animals. A death could not simply be written off as an accident.
- The killer cannot become a profit. No one eats the meat or sells it. The animal is destroyed entirely, which keeps the owner or anyone else from benefiting from a death.
- An owner is not punished for what he could not foresee. If the ox had no history of goring, the owner loses the animal but nothing more: no execution, no ransom, no damages. Guilt follows knowledge and negligence. The very next verse makes that clear by sharply increasing the penalty for an owner who was warned and did nothing.
Compared with the neighbouring cultures' laws, which settled such deaths in silver, this ruling marked Israel's justice as shaped by a God who treats human blood as sacred.
From the study of Exodus 21:28.
Verse by verse
-
28If an ox gores a man or woman to death, the ox must surely be stoned, and its meat must not be eaten. But the owner of the ox shall not be held responsible.
Full study →"And when an ox gores a man, or a woman, and that person dies, the ox must without fail be stoned to death, the way the community executes a killer. No one may eat its flesh. But the ox's owner is clear: no further claim stands against him."
The verse sets out the basic case of a known legal problem. An ordinary ox, with no history of violence, suddenly attacks and kills a person. The victim may be a man or a woman, and the law treats the two the same. The Hebrew doubles the verb ("stoning, it shall be stoned") to stress that the sentence is certain. Stoning was not a way of putting down a dangerous animal. It was the penalty for human capital crimes, carried out by the people together. The animal that shed human blood is handled as a killer, in line with God's word in Genesis 9:5 that he will require a human's lifeblood "from every animal."
Its carcass, normally a large amount of food and money, may not be eaten or salvaged. The killer is destroyed outright. The owner loses a valuable working animal, but because he had no warning that it was dangerous, he is legally "clean" (naqi): he faces no death penalty, no ransom and no damages. The next verse changes that verdict completely when the owner had been warned.
-
29But if the ox has a habit of goring, and its owner has been warned yet does not restrain it, and it kills a man or woman, then the ox must be stoned and its owner must also be put to death.
Full study →"But suppose the ox was already a known gorer. It had shown this 'yesterday and the day before', that is, it had a track record. Formal testimony about it had been put on record against its owner, and still he did not keep it under guard. Then it kills a man or a woman. In that case the ox is to be stoned, as a killer is stoned, and its owner too has forfeited his life."
Three things change between this verse and the one before it. In v.28 the owner is "clean" and loses only his animal. Here the owner (1) owns an animal that is by habit a gorer, (2) has been formally put on notice, and (3) failed in his duty to keep it guarded. Knowing of the danger and then doing nothing makes the death partly his doing. The penalty is equal whether the victim is a man or a woman.
The sentence "he shall be put to death" is real, but the next verse qualifies it at once: the victim's family may instead set a ransom for his life (kōfer), and he must pay whatever they set. The law is saying two things together. A human life is not something to be settled by a standard fine, so the owner's life is the measure of the debt. Yet the owner is not a murderer, so his life may be redeemed.
Where the English drifted
-
in v28
quit (KJV: "the owner of the ox shall be quit")
naqi
- What we hear
- Today "quit" sounds like the verb "to stop" or "to leave," so the line can read as if the owner "quits" something.
- What they heard
- Clear, discharged, free of legal obligation. It is the same sense as being "quits" with someone or "acquitted." The owner owes nothing further.
-
in v28, v29
ox
shor
- What we hear
- In modern English an "ox" is usually a castrated draft steer.
- What they heard
- A single head of cattle of any kind: bull, steer or working beast. Hebrew does not specify castration. The law is about any bovine that gores, which is why the WEB has "bull."
-
in v29
warned (BSB, NIV, ESV, NASB); informed (NLT)
hu'ad
- What we hear
- Someone mentioned to the owner that his animal was dangerous, a friendly or informal caution.
- What they heard
- Formal testimony was given against him, a notice on record and before witnesses that fixed his legal knowledge of the danger. Mesopotamian parallels have local authorities deliver it.
Every word
-
וְכִֽי־
vekhi · H3588A
and if, when · v28
Opens a new main legal case ("if/when such-and-such happens…"). In this law collection כִּי introduces the main scenario and אִם ("if") introduces the variations, as v.29 does next.
-
יִגַּ֨ח
yiggach · H5055
to gore, butt with horns · v28
The ox strikes with its horns. The verb is used of horned animals pushing and thrusting (Deut 33:17; Dan 8:4). Here it is a single, unforeseen attack, as the contrast with the habitual gorer in v.29 shows.
-
שׁ֥וֹר
shor · H7794
ox, bull, head of cattle · v28, v29
A single head of cattle, the farmer's most valuable working animal for ploughing and threshing. It is indefinite: "an ox," any ox.
-
אֶת־
et · H0853
[object marker] · v28
Marks "a man" as the one gored. It has no English equivalent.
-
אִ֛ישׁ
ish · H0376G
man, person · v28, v29
A male human victim, free and of either age. Slaves are treated separately in v.32.
-
א֥וֹ
o · H0176A
or · v28, v29
"Or." The law spells out that the case is the same whichever sex the victim is.
-
אִשָּׁ֖ה
ishah · H0802G
woman · v28, v29
A female victim. Naming her explicitly puts a woman's life on exactly the same footing as a man's in this law. Verse 31 extends the same rule to sons and daughters.
-
וָמֵ֑ת
vamet · H4191
to die · v28, v29
"And he dies." The death is stated as its own step after the goring. The penalty is triggered by a death, not by an injury.
-
סָק֨וֹל
sakol · H5619
to stone · v28, v29
The verb repeated in its unconjugated form before the main verb, a Hebrew way of saying "surely, without fail": the stoning is not optional.
-
וְלֹ֤א
velo · H3808
and not · v28, v29
A flat prohibition: "and not…"
-
יֵאָכֵל֙
ye'akhel · H0398
it shall be eaten · v28
Passive "shall be eaten," here followed by an object marker, so in effect "one shall not eat its flesh." No one, owner or anyone else, may eat the carcass.
-
בְּשָׂר֔וֹ
besaro · H1320
flesh, meat · v28
"Its flesh," meaning the meat of the carcass. An ox's body was a large amount of food and a lot of money, and all of it is forfeited.
-
וּבַ֥עַל
uva'al · H1167G
owner, master, lord · v28, v29
"And the owner of": the person to whom the ox belongs. In law texts the word means simply the property holder. It has nothing to do with the god Baal here.
-
נָקִֽי׃
naki · H5355A
clean, free, exempt, innocent · v28
"Clear, free." The owner carries no further legal liability. He is not executed and owes no ransom or compensation. Beyond losing the animal, he walks away with no penalty.
-
וְאִ֡ם
ve'im · H0518A
and if · v29
Opens a sub-case of the law in v.28. Verse 28 began with kî ("when"), the main case; 'im ("but if") introduces a variation on it, the usual way these case laws are built.
-
נַגָּ֨ח
naggach · H5056
given to goring · v29
This word pattern names a habit or trait: not an ox that gored once but "a gorer". It appears only here and in v.36, and it matches the Akkadian legal term for a known gorer (nakkāpû).
-
ה֜וּא
hu · H1931
it · v29
Stands in for the verb "is": "an ox, a gorer it [is]". It presents the goring as what the animal is known to be.
-
מִתְּמֹ֣ל
mittemol · H8543
from yesterday · v29
The first half of a fixed phrase meaning "previously, before now". Here it sets up a track record that came before the fatal incident.
-
שִׁלְשֹׁ֗ם
shilshom · H8032
day before yesterday · v29
Literally "three days ago". Together with temol it is an idiom for "in the past, heretofore" (Gen 31:2; 1 Sam 21:5). Later rabbis took the 'three' as part of a three-strikes rule (see debates).
-
וְהוּעַ֤ד
vehu'ad · H5749B
it has been testified / formal warning given · v29
A passive verb with no named subject: "testimony was given". It means a solemn notice, the kind given before witnesses, not a casual remark. The owner is now on record as knowing.
-
יִשְׁמְרֶ֔נּוּ
yishmerennu · H8104I
he guards / keeps watch over it · v29
"He does not keep it", meaning he does not keep the animal under watch and control (penned, tethered, supervised). The same verb is used for guarding property or a person in someone's care. (The supplied gloss "look at" is too weak here.)
-
וְגַם־
vegam · H1571
and also · v29
"And also", "as well". It is emphatic: unlike v.28, where the owner is "clean", here the guilt reaches past the animal to the man.
The world behind it
Part of the "Book of the Covenant." Exodus 21–23 is Israel's oldest collection of case law. It is written as "if/when X happens, then Y," the same format as the law collections of Mesopotamia. Exodus 21:28–32 deals with an ox that kills a person, and vv.33–36 with an ox or pit that kills another animal.
The ox in village life. An ox pulled the plough and trod out the grain. For a household it was a major asset, a large part of its wealth and its means of producing food. Losing one, and its meat as well, was a real economic blow even when no other penalty followed.
A famous case across the region. Older law collections cover the same situation:
- Laws of Eshnunna §54 (about 1800 BC): if an ox is known to gore, the authorities have notified its owner, and he does not control it and it kills a man, the owner pays two-thirds of a mina of silver.
- Laws of Hammurabi §250–252 (18th century BC): if an ox gores a man in the street with no prior warning, "there is no claim." If the owner was warned and did nothing, he pays half a mina for a free man, or a third of a mina for a slave.
In both, the matter is settled with money and nothing happens to the ox. Exodus agrees that an unwarned owner owes nothing, but it adds something the others lack: the ox itself is stoned in every case, and for the negligent owner (v.29) the starting penalty is death, though a ransom may be set instead (v.30). Scholars such as Moshe Greenberg and J. J. Finkelstein have taken this difference as the clearest sign that biblical law treats human life as belonging to a different category from property. Shedding human blood creates a guilt that money alone does not settle, even when an animal sheds it (Gen 9:5–6).
Why stoning. Stoning was carried out by the community and from a distance. In Exod 19:13 an animal that touches Sinai is stoned or shot "so that no hand touches it." The same logic fits here. The killer is removed by the whole people, and no one has to handle a creature that carries bloodguilt.
From the study of Exodus 21:28.
Where scholars differ
in v28
Why is the ox stoned rather than simply killed or left alive?
-
The ox bears bloodguilt for taking a human life. Killing it answers for human blood, which is sacred.
Gen 9:5 ("from every animal I will require it"). The penalty is stoning, which is used for human capital crimes. The Mesopotamian laws, which settle such cases in silver and leave the ox alone, differ sharply (Greenberg, "Some Postulates of Biblical Criminal Law"; Finkelstein, *The Ox That Gored*, who sees the ox as having violated the order of creation by killing a human, who stands above it).
-
Mainly removal of danger or pollution: the community gets rid of a dangerous or defiling animal without anyone touching it.
In Exod 19:13 animals that touch Sinai are stoned or shot "so that no hand touches it." Stoning keeps distance. The ox is killed even when it has no history of goring, which fits a concern to clear away bloodguilt that would otherwise rest on the land (compare Num 35:33).
in v28
Why may its meat not be eaten?
-
It is a natural consequence: an animal killed by stoning was not properly slaughtered and drained of blood, so its carcass is already forbidden.
Exod 22:31; Lev 17:15; Deut 14:21 forbid eating animals not properly slaughtered.
-
It is a separate ban: the killer is condemned and no one may benefit from it at all.
If the meat were already forbidden, there would be little reason to state the ban here. Early rabbinic interpretation (Mekhilta; b. Bava Kamma 41a) applies the ban even to an ox slaughtered properly after the verdict and extends it to any profit. Many modern commentators (e.g. Sarna) note the punitive and symbolic sense.
in v28
What exactly is the owner "clear" (naqi) of?
-
Free of personal penalty: no death sentence and no ransom, in contrast with the warned owner of vv.29–30.
The structure of vv.28–30 sets the unwarned owner (naqi) against the warned owner ("shall be put to death," or pay a ransom). The legal uses of naqi elsewhere mean "exempt" (Num 32:22; Deut 24:5).
-
Also a note of loss: the owner leaves "empty" of his property and gets nothing from it.
Shimon ben Zoma in b. Bava Kamma 41a reads naqi as "he went out clean of his property," which connects it with the ban on profit. The root נקה can mean "emptied out."
in v29
Was the negligent owner actually executed, or is "shall be put to death" a statement of liability that was normally settled by ransom?
-
Liability, normally ransomed: the owner's life is forfeit in principle, and v.30 expects the matter to be settled by kōfer.
Verse 30 follows at once and assumes the ransom option. This is the only place the Torah allows ransom for a life, and it fits a death caused by negligence, not intent (contrast Num 35:31). The Mesopotamian parallels likewise settle by payment. Many modern commentators take this view (e.g. Sarna, Propp, Westbrook).
-
A real capital sentence, with ransom only if the victim's kin chose to accept it.
The wording yûmāt is the ordinary death-penalty formula of the code (21:12–17). Verse 30's "if a ransom is laid on him" is conditional, so the bereaved could refuse. Greenberg argued that biblical law deliberately treats human life as beyond monetary valuation, and this verse sharpens that point against Mesopotamian fines.
-
Rabbinic reading: "death at the hands of Heaven", not by a human court, which imposes only the ransom.
Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael (Nezikin 10) and b. Sanhedrin 15b hold that a human court does not execute the owner of a goring ox. This is ancient interpretation, not the plain wording, but it shows how early readers understood the verse alongside v.30.
in v29
Why is the ox stoned and its meat forbidden, when Mesopotamian law simply fines the owner?
-
Blood-guilt: an animal that sheds human blood is guilty and must be removed (Gen 9:5).
Gen 9:5 says God requires human blood "from every beast". Stoning is the community's execution method, and the ban on eating the meat treats the carcass as tainted.
-
A breach of the created order: the ox has rebelled against human dominion and is treated like a rebel.
J. J. Finkelstein, *The Ox That Gored* (1981), argued that the stoning reflects a cosmology in which the beast that kills its master overturns the order of Gen 1:26–28. Stoning in the Bible is often linked to offences against the community's basic order.
-
Practical and deterrent: destroy the danger and remove any profit from it.
Forbidding the meat means the owner gains nothing from the animal's death. This is consistent with the code's focus on loss and responsibility. Most scholars see this as at most a secondary factor, since a practical aim alone would not explain stoning rather than ordinary slaughter.
in v29
Does "from yesterday, three days ago" set a legal count (three gorings or three days) or simply mean "previously"?
-
Idiom for "previously": it establishes a prior record, not a number.
The same phrase means simply "before, formerly" across the Hebrew Bible (Gen 31:2; Exod 5:7; Ruth 2:11; 1 Sam 21:5).
-
A three-strikes threshold (later Jewish law).
Mishnah Bava Qamma 2:4 defines the forewarned ox (mûʿād) by threes: Rabbi Meir says after goring three times, and Rabbi Judah says when testimony has been given over three days. This is a legitimate legal working-out of the wording, though not its plain idiomatic sense.
Sources
- BDB s.v. נָגַח, סָקַל, נָקִי
- HALOT s.v. נקה / נָקִי
- Laws of Eshnunna §§53–55 and Laws of Hammurabi §§250–252, in M. T. Roth, Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor
- M. Greenberg, "Some Postulates of Biblical Criminal Law" (1960)
- J. J. Finkelstein, The Ox That Gored (1981)
- N. Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Exodus
- W. H. C. Propp, Exodus 19–40 (Anchor Bible)
- Mishnah Sanhedrin 1:4
- Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, Nezikin on Exod 21:28
- Babylonian Talmud Bava Kamma 41a
- Septuagint Exodus 21:28
- Vulgate Exodus 21:28
- BDB s.v. נַגָּח, עוּד, שָׁמַר, תְּמוֹל
- HALOT s.v. עוד (Hiphil/Hophal 'to warn, testify')
- M. T. Roth, Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor (Laws of Eshnunna §§53–55; Laws of Hammurabi §§250–252)
- R. Westbrook, Studies in Biblical and Cuneiform Law
- Mishnah Bava Qamma 1:4; 2:4
- Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, Nezikin 10; b. Sanhedrin 15b
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Exod 21:29; Vulgate Exod 21:29
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).