Hosea Chapter 8 Read as one passage

Hosea 8:4–6

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

4They set up kings, but not by Me. They make princes, but without My approval. With their silver and gold they make themselves idols, to their own destruction. 5He has rejected your calf, O Samaria. My anger burns against them. How long will they be incapable of innocence? 6For this thing is from Israel—a craftsman made it, and it is not God. It will be broken to pieces, that calf of Samaria.

What the first hearers heard

To listeners in Samaria, this verse denied the two things that held the state together.

  • The throne had no divine backing. Every usurper would have claimed God's favour, probably with oracles and sacrifices at the royal shrines. Hosea says flatly that God did not send them and does not "know" them. The coups were human politics, not divine choice. This leads on to 13:10–11: "Where now is your king, to save you?... I gave you a king in My anger, and took him away in My wrath."
  • The religion had no divine backing either. The gold and silver that God had given (2:8) had been turned into objects of worship. Verse 6 drives it home: "a craftsman made it; it is not God."
  • The claim of relationship was hollow. Coming right after "My God, we know you!" (8:2) and "they have transgressed My covenant" (8:1), the verse works like a charge in a covenant lawsuit. Israel says it knows God, while choosing rulers and making gods without Him.
  • The end was coming. "Cut off" was the Torah's language for being removed from the covenant people. For hearers watching Assyria advance, it pointed to losing the land, the wealth, the calf and the nation itself, which happened within a generation (722 BC).

The verse calls for neither a political programme nor private piety. It confronts a nation with the fact that its most basic institutions were self-made and therefore had no future.

From the study of Hosea 8:4.

Verse by verse

  1. 4They set up kings, but not by Me. They make princes, but without My approval. With their silver and gold they make themselves idols, to their own destruction.

    They, the people and their power-brokers, have been crowning kings, and none of it came from Me. They have been installing commanders and officials, and I never recognised them as Mine. They took their silver and their gold, the very wealth I gave them, and shaped it into images for themselves. The result, as surely as if they had planned it, is that it will all be cut off.

    The verse puts Israel's two great institutions side by side: the throne and the shrine. Both are human-made. The people "made kings" just as they "made idols". God's verdict on the first is "not from Me" and "I did not know them". In Hebrew, to "know" someone in a covenant setting means to recognise, own and stand behind them. This line answers Israel's cry two verses earlier, "My God, we know you!" They claim the relationship. He refuses to put His name to their choices. "Princes" means the officers and ministers of state, the class that staged one coup after another, not royal sons. The final clause is bitter irony. "So that" states the outcome as if it were the aim: by making gods out of God's own gifts, they were in effect working toward their own removal. The verb "cut off" is the Torah's word for being severed from the covenant people. What is cut off may be Israel as a single body, or the silver and gold and the calf they became. The Hebrew leaves the singular "it" open, and both outcomes follow in the next verses.

    Full study →
  2. 5He has rejected your calf, O Samaria. My anger burns against them. How long will they be incapable of innocence?

    "Your bull-calf is thrown away in disgust, Samaria. He has spurned it, as you spurned the good. My nostrils are hot with anger against them. How long, how long, will they be unable to come clean, unable even to bear clean hands?"

    Hosea speaks to Samaria, the royal capital, as a woman, and points at "your calf". This is the gleaming young-bull image that has stood at the heart of the northern kingdom's official worship since Jeroboam I. The first verb, zanach, repeats verse 3 exactly. Israel "spurned" the good, and now its chosen substitute is spurned, flung away as something repulsive. The Hebrew is compact enough that it can be heard as God's verdict ("He has rejected your calf") or as a command ("Cast it off!"). Either way the idol is finished.

    Then God himself breaks in with "my anger". The Hebrew picture is a burning nose, the snort of rage. The same phrase was used at Sinai over the first golden calf, so the scene is old: a calf, and the LORD's anger blazing. The verse ends in the voice of lament: "Until when?" The people who once cried "How long?" to God now hear God saying it about them. What they cannot attain is niqqayon, being clean of guilt: clean hands, acquittal. It does not mean naivety. The phrasing ("they are not able [for] cleanness") can also mean they cannot stand being clean. They are not only stained. They seem unable to put up with being anything else.

    Full study →
  3. 6For this thing is from Israel—a craftsman made it, and it is not God. It will be broken to pieces, that calf of Samaria.

    Here is why God has thrown out Samaria's calf (verse 5): this thing came from Israel itself. It was not given from heaven. It came out of Israel's own workshops. A craftsman, a hired artisan with his tools, made it, so it is no god. It is not the God who brought Israel out of Egypt, and it is not any kind of god at all. The kingdom's founders presented these bull images with the words "Here are your gods (or: your God), O Israel" (1 Kings 12:28). Hosea answers flatly: not God, this.

    Then comes the end the prophet sees ahead: splinters, that is what it will become, the calf of Samaria. The young-bull image stood for divine strength and was the pride of the northern kingdom's royal religion. Under its gold covering it was carved wood, and it will be reduced to chips and broken bits, perhaps fit only for the fire. "Splinters" is placed first in the Hebrew for impact. The rare word may also hint at flames, recalling Moses burning the first golden calf at Sinai. The thing Israel made to secure its future will not even survive.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v4

    I knew it not (KJV); compare ESV

    lōʾ yādāʿtî

    What we hear
    God was unaware of it, or it happened behind His back.
    What they heard
    I did not acknowledge, recognise or endorse them. It is covenant language for owning someone as one's own. Hosea 5:3 says plainly that God knows everything Ephraim does.
  • in v4

    princes

    śārîm (verb hēśîrû)

    What we hear
    The king's sons, royal heirs.
    What they heard
    High officials, governors and military commanders, the governing class around the king, from which the coup leaders came.
  • in v4

    that they may be cut off

    ləmaʿan yikkārēt

    What we hear
    A statement of purpose, as if Israel meant to be destroyed or God's aim was simply to destroy.
    What they heard
    Ironic result: the outcome is phrased as if it were the goal. Their idol-making will end in their being cut off. The Hebrew verb is also singular ('it/he'), which most translations turn into 'they'.
  • in v4

    idols

    ʿăṣabbîm

    What we hear
    In much church usage, anything loved more than God (money, career, relationships).
    What they heard
    Physical cult images made in workshops from metal and wood, chiefly the calf of Samaria, and possibly meant as images of Israel's own God rather than of foreign gods.
  • in v5, v6

    calf

    ʿegel

    What we hear
    A baby cow, small, meek and harmless.
    What they heard
    A young bull in its prime, a standard ancient image of divine strength and fertility. Hosea may also be using the word with some scorn: a metal bullock, not the Mighty One.
  • in v5

    innocence / purity

    niqqayon

    What we hear
    Childlike naivety, not knowing about evil, or sexual or moral spotlessness.
    What they heard
    Being clean of guilt: clean hands, or being cleared and acquitted (the root is used in law for 'going unpunished'). The question is whether Israel can ever be cleansed of its guilt.
Every word
  1. הֵם

    hēm · H1992

    they · v4

    A separate pronoun is not needed in Hebrew, because the verb already says 'they'. Adding it points a finger: 'They, they themselves', the people and their power-brokers, not God.

  2. הִמְלִיכוּ

    himlîkû · H4427A

    to reign; (causative) make king · v4

    'They made kings' or 'they crowned kings'. The causative form says the people were the ones doing the king-making. Hebrew has no tenses in the English sense, so this can cover a repeated pattern ('they keep making kings').

  3. וְלֹא

    wəlōʾ · H3808

    and not · v4, v5, v6

    The 'and' works as 'but' here: they did it, but not with God's backing.

  4. מִמֶּנִּי

    mimmennî · H4480A

    from me · v4

    'From me' marks where something comes from. The kingship did not start with God or come from Him. The contrast is with kings named by a prophet speaking for God (Jeroboam I, Jehu).

  5. הֵשִׂירוּ

    hēśîrû · H7786

    to rule as prince; (causative) make officials · v4

    'They installed princes': they set up the high officials and army commanders (śārîm) who ran the state and led its coups. In sound it is close to hēsîrû, 'they removed', so it may be a quiet pun: the men they installed were soon pushed out.

  6. יָדָעְתִּי

    yādāʿtî · H3045

    to know · v4

    'I did not know' in the covenant sense: I did not recognise them, acknowledge them or own them as mine. It does not mean God was unaware. In 5:3 He says, 'I know Ephraim; Israel is not hidden from me.'

  7. כַּסְפָּם

    kaspām · H3701G

    silver, money · v4

    'Their silver'. Silver was the money of the day, weighed out rather than minted. Hosea 2:8 says God gave them this silver and gold, and they spent it on Baal.

  8. וּזְהָבָם

    ûzəhābām · H2091

    gold · v4

    'And their gold'. Silver and gold together stand for national wealth, the prosperity of the years under Jeroboam II, now turned into cult objects.

  9. עָשׂוּ

    ʿāśû · H6213H

    to make · v4, v6

    'They made'. The plain word for manufacturing sets up verse 6: 'a craftsman made it; it is not God.' Kings and gods alike are things Israel has produced.

  10. לָהֶם

    lāhem · H9038

    for them(selves) · v4, v5

    'For themselves'. It echoes the self-made kings: everything here is made by them and for them, not received from God.

  11. עֲצַבִּים

    ʿăṣabbîm · H6091

    idol, shaped image · v4

    Physical images, shaped and overlaid with metal. In context it chiefly means the calf of Samaria (verses 5–6) and the other cult images of the northern kingdom.

  12. לְמַעַן

    ləmaʿan · H4616

    for the sake of, so that · v4

    Usually 'in order that'. Here it is bitterly ironic: the result is stated as if it were the goal. In effect they made idols 'in order to' be destroyed, the way someone 'works hard to ruin himself'.

  13. יִכָּרֵת

    yikkārēt · H3772I

    to cut; (passive) be cut off · v4

    'It/he will be cut off', the standard phrase for being wiped out or removed from the community. The singular may mean Israel as one body (as in verse 3, 'an enemy will pursue him'), or the silver and gold, or the idol.

  14. זָנַח֙

    zanach · H2186

    to reject, spurn, cast off · v5

    A strong word for pushing something away in disgust. It repeats 8:3, where 'Israel has spurned the good'. Now the calf is spurned in turn. Who does the rejecting is unclear (see debates). Read as it stands, the subject is most likely God.

  15. עֶגְלֵ֣ךְ

    ʿeglekh · H5695

    calf, young bull · v5, v6

    'Your calf'. The 'your' is feminine because Samaria, a city, is addressed as a woman. This is the bull image of the northern kingdom's official worship, which goes back to Jeroboam I's golden calves (1 Kings 12:28–29).

  16. שֹֽׁמְר֔וֹן

    shomeron · H8111

    Samaria · v5, v6

    Called on directly ('O Samaria'). The name means the royal capital and also the whole northern kingdom that the capital stands for.

  17. חָרָ֥ה

    charah · H2734

    to burn, be hot · v5

    'Has become hot.' Hebrew's normal verb for anger flaring up. The form describes a fire that is already lit.

  18. אַפִּ֖י

    ʾappi · H639

    nose, nostrils; anger · v5

    Literally 'my nose'. Hebrew pictures anger as hot, flaring nostrils. Here God speaks in the first person ('my').

  19. עַד־

    ʿad · H5704

    until · v5

    Opens the lament phrase 'until when?'

  20. מָתַ֕י

    matay · H4970

    when? · v5

    With 'ad it makes 'How long?', the standard cry of lament and frustration in the Psalms and the prophets (e.g. Psalm 13:1–2). Here God is the one saying it.

  21. יוּכְל֖וּ

    yukhlu · H3201

    to be able, prevail, endure · v5

    'They will (not) be able'. It takes a noun directly, with no verb after it, so something has to be supplied: 'able to reach' or 'able to bear'. Compare Isaiah 1:13, where God says 'I cannot [bear] iniquity'.

  22. נִקָּיֹֽן׃

    niqqayon · H5356

    cleanness, innocence, freedom from guilt · v5

    Being clean of guilt: clean hands, being cleared or acquitted. It does not mean naivety. Israel's hands are not clean, and they seem unable to become clean or even to tolerate cleanness.

  23. כִּ֤י

    ki · H3588

    for, because, indeed · v6

    Links this verse to verse 5 ('He has rejected your calf, O Samaria'): here is the reason the calf is rejected. It opens the argument.

  24. מִיִּשְׂרָאֵל֙

    miyyisraʾel · H3478

    from Israel · v6

    The preposition 'from' marks origin: the calf came out of Israel, not from God. Placed first for emphasis: its source is human and home-grown. The phrase could also attach to the end of verse 5 ('…incapable of innocence—they are from Israel!').

  25. וְה֔וּא

    wehuʾ · H1931

    and it / he · v6

    'And it'—pointing at the calf with some contempt: 'even this thing', 'it, too'. KJV's 'it also' and YLT's 'even it' catch the emphatic tone.

  26. חָרָ֣שׁ

    ḥarash · H2796

    craftsman, artisan · v6

    A skilled worker in wood, metal or stone. Not insulting in itself, but in this setting it lands hard: a god with a maker's name on it is no god.

  27. אֱלֹהִ֖ים

    ʾelohim · H430

    God, god(s) · v6

    Can mean the God of Israel or 'a god / gods'. Both senses work at once: the calf is not Israel's God, and it is no god at all. It echoes 1 Kings 12:28 and Exodus 32:4, where the calves are presented as 'your elohim, O Israel'.

  28. שְׁבָבִ֣ים

    shevavim · H7616

    splinters, fragments · v6

    A word found only here in the Hebrew Bible. Most take it as splinters or chips, fitting an image with a wooden core overlaid with metal. Some link it to a word for 'flames'. Placed first for emphasis: 'Splinters—that's what it will be.'

  29. יִֽהְיֶ֔ה

    yihyeh · H1961

    will be, will become · v6

    Future: the calf will end up as splinters. A prediction of destruction, not a description of the present.

The world behind it

Hosea's Israel. Hosea preached in the northern kingdom (called Israel or Ephraim, capital Samaria) from about 750 BC until shortly before Assyria destroyed it in 722 BC. After the long, wealthy reign of Jeroboam II, the throne fell into chaos. In roughly 25 years there were six kings, and four were assassinated by their successors (2 Kings 15–17):

  • Zechariah, killed after six months by Shallum
  • Shallum, killed after one month by Menahem
  • Menahem's son Pekahiah, killed by Pekah, one of his own officers
  • Pekah, killed by Hoshea, the last king

Each faction also courted either Assyria or Egypt (Hos 7:11; 8:9). Menahem bought Assyrian backing with a thousand talents of silver squeezed from the wealthy (2 Kgs 15:19–20).

How kingship was supposed to work. In Israel's tradition the king was God's choice, usually announced by a prophet, then confirmed by the people (Deut 17:15; 1 Sam 10; 16). The northern kingdom's founder, Jeroboam I, and the dynasty-founder Jehu both had a prophetic word behind them. The usurpers of Hosea's day had only swords and backers. All over the ancient Near East a king's right to rule rested on the claim that a god had chosen him, so "not from Me" was an attack on legitimacy itself.

Throne and calf. From the beginning the northern state rested on two pillars set up by Jeroboam I: an independent monarchy and royal sanctuaries with golden calves at Bethel and Dan, presented with the words "Here are your gods, O Israel, who brought you up out of Egypt" (1 Kgs 12:26–33). Hosea names the "calf of Samaria" in the next verse (8:5–6). By pairing kings and idols in one verse, Hosea strikes at both foundations of the state at once.

From the study of Hosea 8:4.

Where scholars differ

in v4

Which kings does Hosea mean by 'they made kings, but not from Me'?

  • The coups of Hosea's own lifetime (about 752–732 BC).

    Hosea 7:3–7 describes palace plots and says 'all their kings have fallen'. Four of the last six northern kings murdered their predecessors (2 Kgs 15). None of them had a prophetic designation. The surrounding verses deal with current politics: Assyria, Egypt and bribes (8:8–10). This is the view of most modern commentators (for example Wolff, Stuart, Dearman).

  • The whole northern monarchy since its break from David's line.

    Hosea 3:5 looks forward to Israel seeking 'David their king', which implies the northern line is illegitimate. The pairing of king and calf matches Jeroboam I's founding acts (1 Kgs 12:26–33). The difficulty is that Jeroboam I was designated by the prophet Ahijah (1 Kgs 11:29–39), and 1 Kgs 12:24 says the split was 'from Me'.

  • Human kingship as such, as a rejection of God's rule.

    Hosea 13:10–11 ('Give me a king and princes... I gave you a king in My anger') echoes 1 Samuel 8, where asking for a king is a rejection of God. Some see Hosea as opposed to monarchy in principle, though 3:5 complicates this.

in v4

What is the singular subject of 'it will be cut off'?

  • Israel as one body.

    Verse 3 also uses a singular for Israel ('an enemy will pursue him'), and Hebrew often treats a nation as a single person. 'Cut off' is standard for the destruction of a people.

  • The silver and gold, that is, the idol made from it.

    These are the nearest nouns. Verse 6 predicts that the calf 'will be broken to pieces', and Hosea 10:5–6 has the calf carried off to Assyria.

  • The text should read a plural, 'they will be cut off'.

    The Septuagint and Vulgate both have plurals, and the verse's other verbs are plural. Against this, a scribe is more likely to have smoothed a singular into a plural than the reverse.

in v5

Who or what 'rejects' in the first clause?

  • God is the subject: 'He has rejected your calf' (BSB, NASB), or, with a correction, 'I have rejected' (ESV).

    The Masoretic vowels give a perfect verb. The next clause is God's 'my anger', and sudden shifts between persons are common in Hosea. The verb echoes 8:3, where Israel spurned the good: God now spurns Israel's substitute.

  • A command to Samaria: 'Cast off your calf!' (NIV, WEB).

    The Septuagint reads a command (apotripsai). The consonants allow it. Prophets often call on their hearers to put away idols.

  • The calf is the subject: 'Your calf has cast you off' (KJV).

    'Your calf' is the nearest possible subject. The irony would be that the idol abandons its worshippers. But it requires supplying an object ('thee') that is not in the text.

in v5

What does 'they will not be able [for] innocence' mean?

  • They cannot attain or reach cleanness or innocence (KJV 'attain to'; most modern versions 'incapable of').

    The most natural way to fill out a verb that has no infinitive after it. The ancient versions read 'be cleansed'.

  • They cannot bear or tolerate cleanness.

    yakhol with a noun object means 'endure, put up with' in Isaiah 1:13 ('I cannot [bear] iniquity and solemn assembly') and Psalm 101:5. The idea that Israel finds faithfulness intolerable fits Hosea 5:4 ('their deeds do not permit them to return').

  • They cannot be cleared or acquitted, that is, escape punishment.

    The root naqah is used in law for being 'free, unpunished' (Exodus 21:19; Proverbs 6:29). The verse comes in a lawsuit setting (8:1).

in v5

Which calf is 'the calf of Samaria'?

  • The Bethel calf, the national shrine, called Samaria's because Samaria stands for the kingdom.

    Hosea 10:5 speaks of the 'calves of Beth-aven' (Bethel) being mourned by Samaria's inhabitants. The Bible mentions no calf in the capital itself.

  • A separate calf image in the city of Samaria.

    'Calf of Samaria' (v. 6) reads naturally as a local image, and the capital had its own cult (1 Kings 16:32, Ahab's temple of Baal). The 'YHWH of Samaria' inscription at Kuntillet ʿAjrud suggests a worship of the LORD tied to the city.

in v6

What does shevavim mean?

  • Splinters, chips, fragments

    The majority view of lexicons (BDB, HALOT) and Jewish tradition. It fits idols built on wooden cores (Isa 40:20; 44:13–19) and the parallel 'broken' imagery.

  • Flames, sparks

    Links to shavib 'flame' (Job 18:5) and Aramaic shevib (Dan 3:22). It would echo the burning of the golden calf in Exod 32:20. The word is related, but the form and meaning are less certain.

  • Ancient guesses: 'leading astray' (LXX), 'spiders' webs' (Vulgate)

    These show that ancient translators also found the word obscure. Few modern scholars follow them.

in v6

What did the calf represent?

  • An image of YHWH under the bull symbol of strength

    1 Kgs 12:28 presents it as the God 'who brought you up from Egypt'. Bull imagery for deity was common in the region (El as 'Bull' at Ugarit).

  • A pedestal or throne on which the invisible YHWH stood

    Ancient Near Eastern gods are often shown standing on animals. It would parallel the cherubim throne in Jerusalem. Proposed by W. F. Albright and others.

  • In practice merged with Baal worship

    Hosea often blurs calf worship and Baal worship (2:8; 11:2; 13:1–2), suggesting the popular understanding had drifted toward Canaanite religion whatever the official theory.

in v6

Where was 'the calf of Samaria'?

  • The Bethel calf, with 'Samaria' standing for the kingdom

    Hos 10:5 links Samaria's inhabitants with 'the calf of Beth-aven' (a mocking name for Bethel). The royal calves are known only at Bethel and Dan.

  • A calf image in the capital city itself

    The phrase most naturally names the city. Ahab built a Baal temple in Samaria (1 Kgs 16:32), so an image there is possible, but no text explicitly records a calf in Samaria.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. מָלַךְ, שָׂרַר, יָדַע, עָצָב, כָּרַת, מַעַן
  • HALOT s.v. שׂרר, עצב II, עָצָב, כרת
  • H. W. Wolff, Hosea (Hermeneia, 1974)
  • F. I. Andersen & D. N. Freedman, Hosea (Anchor Bible 24, 1980)
  • A. A. Macintosh, Hosea (ICC, 1997)
  • D. Stuart, Hosea–Jonah (Word Biblical Commentary 31)
  • J. A. Dearman, The Book of Hosea (NICOT, 2010)
  • J. H. Walton, V. H. Matthews & M. W. Chavalas, IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Hosea 8:4; Vulgate Osee 8:4
  • 2 Kings 15–17; 1 Kings 11–12 (historical background)
  • BDB s.v. זָנַח, עֵגֶל, נִקָּיוֹן, יָכֹל
  • HALOT s.v. זנח I/II, נִקָּיוֹן
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Hosea 8:5
  • Vulgate, Osee 8:5
  • 1 Kings 12:28–29; Exodus 32
  • Kuntillet ʿAjrud inscriptions ('YHWH of Samaria')
  • Sargon II, Nimrud Prism (spoil from Samaria)
  • F. I. Andersen & D. N. Freedman, Hosea (Anchor Bible)
  • H. W. Wolff, Hosea (Hermeneia)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, Hosea 8
  • BDB s.v. שְׁבָבִים, חָרָשׁ, עֵגֶל
  • HALOT s.v. שְׁבָבִים
  • A. A. Macintosh, Hosea (ICC)
  • D. Stuart, Hosea–Jonah (WBC)
  • Septuagint, Hosea 8:6
  • Vulgate, Osee 8:6
  • 1 Kings 12:26–33; Exodus 32; Hosea 10:5–6; 13:2; Isaiah 40:19–20; 44:9–20

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).