Isaiah Chapter 22 Read as one passage

Isaiah 22:15–19

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

15This is what the Lord GOD of Hosts says: “Go, say to Shebna, the steward in charge of the palace: 16What are you doing here, and who authorized you to carve out a tomb for yourself here—to chisel your tomb in the height and cut your resting place in the rock? 17Look, O mighty man! The LORD is about to shake you violently. He will take hold of you, 18roll you into a ball, and sling you into a wide land. There you will die, and there your glorious chariots will remain—a disgrace to the house of your master. 19I will remove you from office, and you will be ousted from your position.

What the first hearers heard

To people in Jerusalem around 701 BC, this was a shocking public act. A prophet was sent, in the name of the divine Commander, to confront by name the most powerful official below the king, at a moment of national emergency.

  • It cut through court power. The man who controlled access to the king was himself summoned before a higher King. The messenger formula made Isaiah God's envoy, outranking the palace chief.
  • The wording set its tone. "This steward" and the missing family line signalled disdain before any charge was read. The title "steward / one who serves" reminded hearers that even this office was service held on behalf of the Davidic king and, behind him, of God.
  • It set up a reversal. The verse opens a unit in which Shebna's self-made monument (v.16) brings on his removal (vv.17–19), and the office, robe and key pass to Eliakim, "my servant" (vv.20–22). Even Eliakim's position is shown to be fragile (vv.23–25). Hearers would take this as a lesson about Jerusalem's leadership: titles, tombs and fortifications do not secure anyone apart from trust in YHWH.

From the study of Isaiah 22:15.

Verse by verse

  1. 15This is what the Lord GOD of Hosts says: “Go, say to Shebna, the steward in charge of the palace:

    "This is the word of the Sovereign, YHWH, Commander of the armies: Go, march straight in to that steward, this Shebna, the man who runs the king's palace."

    The verse is a royal dispatch. "Thus says" is how a king's messenger began, and the sender is God as commander of armies, at the very moment Jerusalem's officials were preparing their own defences. The double command "go, enter" sends Isaiah into Shebna's presence, in his own office, without delay.

    The official is named with deliberate coolness. He is "this steward", close to "this fellow". The word for steward means "one who serves": a powerful appointee, but a servant all the same. His name comes with no father or family, and then his grand title: "who is over the house", chief officer of the Davidic palace and second only to the king. The Hebrew even allows the second "to" to be heard as "against": go to Shebna, and against him. The reason follows at once (v.16). This servant has been cutting himself a lordly tomb high in the rock. He will be thrown down and replaced by Eliakim, whom God calls "my servant".

    Full study →
  2. 16What are you doing here, and who authorized you to carve out a tomb for yourself here—to chisel your tomb in the height and cut your resting place in the rock?

    God sends Isaiah to confront Shebna, the chief royal official, apparently at the site where Shebna's tomb is being cut. The prophet fires two questions, both built on the same blunt idiom: "What have you got here? And who have you got here?" In other words: what claim, what roots, what family do you have in this place? Israelites expected to be buried with their ancestors in a family tomb. Here a man with no fathers lying "here" is carving out a family tomb "here", in the most prestigious ground in Jerusalem.

    The word "here" rings three times, like a finger pointing at the rock. Then comes the accusation: "that you have hewn yourself a tomb here!" It is stonecutter's language, the sound of chisels quarrying a chamber out of solid limestone.

    Then the prophet seems to turn to the bystanders and describes Shebna in the third person, in an elevated, almost sing-song style that mocks him: "Hewing his tomb on the height! Engraving in the rock a house for himself!" "On the height" means high up and conspicuous, and in Isaiah height is where pride puts itself before God brings it down. "Engraving" is fine work: a dressed façade, perhaps his name and titles cut into stone. "A dwelling" makes the tomb his permanent residence, his "eternal home".

    The verse is built so that it can be reversed. The next lines announce that the LORD will grab this "mighty man", wind him up like a ball and hurl him into a wide land to die there (vv. 17–18). The splendid house in the rock will never hold its owner.

    Full study →
  3. 17Look, O mighty man! The LORD is about to shake you violently. He will take hold of you,

    "Look! Yahweh is about to hurl you, toss and hurl you with a real hurling, you big man! He is about to bundle you up and grip you tight." The sentence carries on into v.18: "…and wind you up tight like a ball, and sling you into a wide land. There you will die."

    Several things in the Hebrew are lost in a flat English sentence:

    • The sound is the motion. The verb and its noun repeat the same root, and the verb form doubles the syllables: meṭalṭelkā ṭalṭēlāh. You hear the whirling throw. The second half does the same: ‘ōṭəkā ‘āṭōh, "wrapping you, wrapping." Hebrew repeats a root like this to say "really, thoroughly, without fail."
    • It is imminent. Both verbs are participles introduced by "Look!", Hebrew's way of saying this is starting now.
    • The image is a man treated as a thing. One sense of the doubled verb is shaking or tossing back and forth, and the word that follows usually means wrapping, as with a cloth or garment. Together they suggest someone shaken loose, rolled up like a bundle or a slingstone, and thrown. Some translators take the second verb as "seize firmly" instead. Either way, Yahweh grips him in order to throw him.
    • "Man" is a put-down. The powerful palace official is not addressed by his title. He is called geber, "man," a word with overtones of strength. In this setting it is ironic: "you strong man," "you big shot."
    • The contrast with v.16. Shebna was having a grand tomb cut into the rock "on high," a permanent resting place meant to fix his name in Jerusalem forever. Yahweh's answer is the opposite of fixed: he will be pried loose, flung out of the land, and die where no tomb awaits him.
    Full study →
  4. 18roll you into a ball, and sling you into a wide land. There you will die, and there your glorious chariots will remain—a disgrace to the house of your master.

    The LORD will wrap you up, wind you tight, bundle you round and round, the way a strip of cloth is wound into a turban, until you are nothing but a ball. Then he will throw you into a land that stretches wide on every side, an open foreign country where a man vanishes without trace. There, out there, you will die. You will not lie in the fine rock tomb you cut for yourself in Jerusalem. And there too will end up the chariots that displayed your importance, the state vehicles you rode to show your rank. You, the man of weight (kavod), will turn out to be the lightweight (qalon), the disgrace of your master's house. You were made steward of the king's household to add honor to it, and you have only shamed it.

    The Hebrew stacks the verb "wind/wrap" three times for force. It probably mocks the official's turban, his badge of office. It plays "heavy" honor off against "light" disgrace. And it sets two "there"s against the "here" of verse 16 ("What are you doing here... that you have hewn yourself a tomb here?"). The man who tried to make himself permanent is rolled up, thrown away and forgotten.

    Full study →
  5. 19I will remove you from office, and you will be ousted from your position.

    "I will shove you off the spot where you stand. From your post at the king's side you will be torn down like a wall."

    God is speaking to Shebna, the royal steward "over the house" of King Hezekiah (v.15). This was the most powerful office in the kingdom after the king himself. Both nouns, translated "office" and "position", literally mean a place where one stands. That reflects how a royal court worked: officials served by standing before the king. The verse is a picture of a courtier at his post being forcibly removed from it.

    The first verb is a physical shove, not a polite removal. The second is a demolition verb, normally used for tearing down walls, altars and cities. That is pointed. Shebna had carved himself a grand tomb high in the rock (v.16), trying to make his name permanent. Instead God will knock him from his feet and wreck him like a building.

    Halfway through, the speaker changes from "I" to "he". The prophet may be shifting to speak about God, or it may simply mean "you will be torn down" with no agent named. Either way, the overthrow comes from God. The next verse names his replacement: "My servant, Eliakim son of Hilkiah."

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v15

    treasurer (KJV, WEB)

    sōkēn

    What we hear
    A finance officer who keeps the accounts or the treasury.
    What they heard
    A senior administrator or steward, a royal appointee with broad authority. The word's root means 'to serve, be of use'. Money was at most one part of the job.
  • in v15

    over the house (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    ʾăšer ʿal-habbāyit

    What we hear
    Someone who manages a household, like a butler or housekeeper.
    What they heard
    The formal title of the highest official of the royal court, roughly the king's chief minister or chief of staff.
  • in v15

    Hosts

    ṣĕbāʾôt

    What we hear
    Crowds, or people who receive guests. For many readers it is an empty liturgical word.
    What they heard
    Armies: God as commander of heaven's forces (and Israel's).
  • in v16

    "high place" (interlinear gloss for marom)

    marom

    What we hear
    Bible readers associate 'high places' with the hilltop shrines (bamot) condemned in Kings, so they may think Shebna is building at a cult site or doing something idolatrous.
    What they heard
    Simply 'the height': an elevated, conspicuous spot on the slope. Through Isaiah's usage it also hints at proud self-exaltation. It has nothing to do with shrines.
  • in v17

    will surely cover thee (KJV)

    ‘ōṭəkā ‘āṭōh

    What we hear
    God will protect or shelter you, as in being 'covered' by God.
    What they heard
    God will wrap you up (or seize you firmly), bundling you like an object about to be flung away. It is part of the judgment, not protection.
  • in v17

    a mighty captivity (KJV)

    ṭalṭēlāh gāber

    What we hear
    Being taken prisoner and marched off by an army.
    What they heard
    A violent hurling, a throw. Exile is the result (v.18), but the word itself pictures being thrown, and 'mighty' probably belongs to the ironic address 'O man/strong man'.
  • in v17

    O mighty man (BSB; similar ESV, NIV)

    gāber

    What we hear
    A respectful or admiring title.
    What they heard
    A cutting, ironic address: the high official stripped of his title and called 'man', perhaps 'big man', just as he is thrown away.
  • in v18

    the shame of thy lord's house (KJV)

    qelon beit adonekha

    What we hear
    Read aloud, 'lord's house' is easily heard as 'the LORD's house', meaning God's Temple, as if Shebna had defiled the sanctuary.
    What they heard
    'Your master's house': the royal household and dynasty of the human king (Hezekiah) whom Shebna served as steward. The form is plural, as Hebrew commonly does for a respected master, but it refers to one human lord.
  • in v18

    chariots of thy glory

    markevot kevodekha

    What we hear
    'Glory' sounds spiritual or heavenly, as in God's chariots of glory or a glorious future.
    What they heard
    'The chariots of your prestige': the state chariots that showed off Shebna's social weight and rank at court. Kavod here is human status, and the verse turns it into its opposite, qalon ('lightness, disgrace').
  • in v18

    violently turn and toss thee like a ball (KJV); whirl you around and around

    tsanof yitsnafekha tsenefah kaddur

    What we hear
    A picture of spinning and flinging, like a hammer-thrower or a child tossing a ball.
    What they heard
    'Wrap you up, wind you tight' into a compact bundle, the way cloth is wound into a turban. The ball image is about being reduced and compacted, and then thrown (the throwing comes from v. 17 and the context).
  • in v19

    state (KJV: 'from thy state shall he pull thee down')

    maʿămād

    What we hear
    A nation or government, or a condition ('a state of mind').
    What they heard
    One's standing or post: rank and attendance at the royal court.
Every word
  1. כֹּה

    koh · H3541

    thus, so · v15

    Opens the standard messenger formula ('Thus says…'), the way a royal envoy began reading out his master's words. It tells the hearer that what follows is not Isaiah's opinion but a dispatch from a higher king.

  2. אָמַר

    ʾāmar · H0559

    to say · v15

    Perfect form, 'has said / says': the decision has already been spoken in the divine council, and the prophet now delivers it.

  3. אֲדֹנָי

    ʾădōnāy · H0136

    Lord, Master · v15

    The title 'my Lord / the Sovereign'. Placed before the divine name, it stresses God's rank as master, fitting an oracle that deals with a servant who has overreached.

  4. יְהוִה

    YHWH · H3069

    YHWH, Yahweh · v15

    The personal name of Israel's God. After 'Adonai' it is pointed with the vowels of 'Elohim' so readers would not say 'Adonai Adonai', which is why English prints 'Lord GOD' in capitals.

  5. צְבָאוֹת

    ṣĕbāʾôt · H6635B

    armies, hosts · v15

    'Of armies': YHWH as commander of the heavenly forces (and Israel's). In a chapter about Jerusalem preparing for an Assyrian siege, the title reminds hearers who actually commands the armies.

  6. לֶךְ

    lek · H1980G

    go, walk · v15

    Command, 'Go!' Paired at once with a second command, it gives the order urgency: set out now.

  7. בֹּא

    bōʾ · H0935G

    come, enter · v15

    Command, 'Enter / go in'. Together with 'go' it means 'go right in to him', which implies walking into the official's own office or presence. The prophet confronts him in person.

  8. אֶל

    ʾel · H0413

    to, toward · v15, v18

    Marks where the prophet is to go: to the steward.

  9. הַסֹּכֵן

    hassōkēn · H5532

    steward, administrator · v15

    Literally 'the one who serves / is useful', a participle used as an official title. Related words in the region (Akkadian, Ugaritic, Phoenician) name a governor or high administrator. Here it is a real office of rank, but the word also carries the idea of a servant, someone appointed to serve.

  10. הַזֶּה

    hazzeh · H2088

    this · v15

    'This steward', almost 'this fellow'. Pointing at someone with 'this' instead of using his title respectfully often carries contempt in Hebrew (compare 1 Samuel 10:27, 'How can this one save us?'). Many readers hear scorn here.

  11. עַל

    ʿal · H5921A

    upon, over, against, to · v15

    Most translations take it as 'to', the same as the earlier ʾel. Since ʿal often means 'against', some hear a double edge: go to Shebna, and against him.

  12. שֶׁבְנָא

    šebnāʾ · H7644

    Shebna · v15

    The official's name, given with no father's name or family line. That fits v.16's taunt 'who do you have here?', as if he has no roots in Jerusalem. The name may be a short form of Shebanyahu.

  13. אֲשֶׁר

    ʾăšer · H0834A

    who, which · v15

    Introduces his formal title.

  14. הַבָּיִת

    habbāyit · H1004P

    house, household, palace · v15, v18

    'The house' here is the royal palace and household of the Davidic king. 'Who is over the house' was the title of the highest court official, roughly the king's chief of staff.

  15. מַה־

    mah · H4100

    what? · v16

    Opens a challenging question, not a request for information. With the next word it forms an idiom: 'what do you have here?', meaning 'what business or claim do you have here?'

  16. לְּךָ֥

    lekha · H9031

    to you · v16

    'To you', the Hebrew way of saying 'you have'. 'What is to you here' = 'what stake do you have here?'

  17. פֹה֙

    foh · H6311

    here · v16

    The first of three 'here's in one breath. The word keeps pointing at the spot, as though the prophet were standing at the tomb site and jabbing his finger at it.

  18. וּמִ֣י

    u-mi · H4310

    and who? · v16

    'And who…?' It moves the question from things to people. 'Who do you have here?' asks about kin and family, or about who gave him the right.

  19. כִּֽי־

    ki · H3588A

    that, for · v16

    'That…' It introduces what prompts the question: what claim do you have here, *that* you should hew a tomb here?

  20. חָצַ֧בְתָּ

    ḥatsavta · H2672

    to hew, quarry · v16

    'You have hewn': stonecutter's work, hacking a chamber out of bedrock. The verb form presents the job as done or well under way.

  21. קָ֑בֶר

    qaver · H6913

    grave, tomb · v16

    A tomb, here a rock-cut chamber tomb of the kind wealthy Judeans used, not a pit in the ground. It falls at the end of the clause for emphasis: 'here, a tomb!'

  22. מָרוֹם֙

    marom · H4791

    height · v16

    'On the height': high up on the slope, where everyone can see it. Elsewhere in Isaiah the word is often used for God's own lofty dwelling, so a man placing himself 'on high' has overtones of pride.

  23. חֹקְקִ֥י

    ḥoqeqi · H2710

    to cut, engrave, inscribe, decree · v16

    'Carving, engraving'. Finer work than rough hewing: cutting precise shapes or lettering into stone. It has the same poetic -i ending as 'hewing'.

  24. בַסֶּ֖לַע

    va-sela' · H5553H

    crag, cliff, rock · v16

    'In the rock', meaning the cliff face itself. It suggests something solid and lasting, which is exactly what Shebna wants his memorial to be.

  25. מִשְׁכָּ֥ן

    mishkan · H4908

    dwelling · v16

    'A dwelling'. The tomb is spoken of as a house to live in. People commonly thought of graves as the dead person's permanent home, and the word makes his tomb sound like a residence.

  26. לֽוֹ׃

    lo · H9033

    for him · v16

    'For himself'. The verse closes on the same note of self-interest: everything is 'for you… for himself'.

  27. הִנֵּ֤ה

    hinnēh · H2009

    look!, behold · v17

    A word that grabs attention and points at something about to happen. It turns the reproach of v.16 into an announcement: watch what is coming.

  28. יְהוָה֙

    YHWH · H3068

    Yahweh, the LORD · v17

    The personal name of Israel's God stands first as the one who acts. Shebna had acted on his own say-so ("who authorized you?" v.16). Now the real authority over Jerusalem's royal house steps in.

  29. מְטַלְטֶלְךָ֔

    məṭalṭelkā · H2904

    to hurl, cast · v17

    A participle (an ongoing or about-to-happen action) of 'hurl' in a doubled form, ṭal-ṭel, which suggests repeated or violent motion: hurling, tossing, shaking loose. With the ending -kā it means "hurling you." The form occurs only here.

  30. טַלְטֵלָ֖ה

    ṭalṭēlāh · H2925

    a hurling, violent casting · v17

    A noun from the same root, used right after its verb for emphasis: "hurl you a hurling," meaning really, violently hurl. KJV's "captivity" interprets the result (exile, v.18). The word itself is the image of being thrown. It occurs only here.

  31. גָּ֑בֶר

    gāber · H1397

    man, strong man · v17

    "Man," with overtones of strength and manhood. Most read it as direct address, "O man!" or "you strong man!", which here sounds ironic: the powerful official is called simply "man" or "big man" as he is thrown. A minority link it to the hurling ("a mighty hurling" or "as a strong man hurls").

  32. וְעֹטְךָ֖

    wə‘ōṭəkā · H5844

    to wrap; to grasp · v17

    "And [he is] wrapping / seizing you." A participle again, so the action is about to happen. The root usually means to wrap or cover, as with a garment. Some lexicons list a second sense, 'grasp' or 'pick clean'. Either way, Shebna is bundled up or gripped, ready to be thrown, which v.18 develops.

  33. צָנ֤וֹף

    tsanof · H6801

    to wind, wrap up · v18

    The verb repeated in its bare form ('winding') to make the next verb stronger: 'he will wrap you up, and wrap you tight.' This is the verb used for winding cloth into a turban.

  34. צְנֵפָ֔ה

    tsenefah · H6802

    a winding, wrapping · v18

    A noun from the same root, used here only. It closes a three-fold 'wrap... wrap... wrapping' that stresses how tight and final the bundling is. The supplied gloss 'toss' comes from the KJV tradition. The root means winding, not throwing.

  35. כַּדּ֕וּר

    kaddur · H1754B

    ball; like a ball · v18

    The wrapped bundle ends up a ball, small, round and easy to throw. The man who wanted a lasting monument (v. 16) is made into something you fling.

  36. אֶ֖רֶץ

    erets · H0776G

    land, country · v18

    A territory, here a foreign one. The land is not named, but in Isaiah's day this pointed to the open country of Assyria and Mesopotamia, where conquered people were deported.

  37. רַחֲבַ֣ת

    rachavat · H7342H

    wide, broad · v18

    'Wide of...', the first half of a set phrase for open, far-reaching land. It contrasts with the narrow rock tomb Shebna cut for himself.

  38. יָדָ֑יִם

    yadayim · H3027Q

    hands; sides · v18

    Literally 'both hands', meaning both sides. 'Wide of hands' is a Hebrew idiom for land stretching out in every direction (Gen 34:21; Judg 18:10; Ps 104:25). Here it suggests a huge, featureless place where a man disappears.

  39. שָׁ֣מָּה

    shammah · H8033G

    there, thither · v18

    'There', with an ending that points toward a place: out there, in that far country. It is put first for emphasis. There, not in the tomb he prepared at home.

  40. תָמ֗וּת

    tamut · H4191

    you will die · v18

    A plain statement of how his life will end. In Israel, dying and being buried away from your homeland and family grave was a terrible fate. This one cancels the tomb of verse 16.

  41. מַרְכְּב֣וֹת

    markevot · H4818

    chariots · v18

    Chariots used for state appearances and ceremony. Riding in one publicly showed rank close to the king (2 Sam 15:1; 1 Kgs 1:5).

  42. כְּבוֹדֶ֔ךָ

    kevodekha · H3519

    your glory, honor · v18

    'Your glory' means your prestige, your weight in society. 'Chariots of your glory' are the chariots that displayed his importance. It is human status, not divine glory.

  43. קְל֖וֹן

    qelon · H7036

    disgrace, shame · v18

    From a root meaning 'light, of no weight.' It answers kavod ('heaviness, honor') directly: the man of weight becomes a lightweight. It can address Shebna ('you disgrace!') or describe the chariots.

  44. אֲדֹנֶֽיךָ׃

    adonekha · H0113

    your master · v18

    Plural in form but singular in meaning, a common Hebrew way of speaking respectfully of a master. It means the human king (Hezekiah) whom Shebna served, not God. Instead of honoring his master's house, he shamed it.

  45. וַהֲדַפְתִּ֖יךָ

    wahădaptîkā · H1920

    to push, thrust, drive away · v19

    'And I will shove you.' God is speaking, and the verb form points to the future: this continues the threats of vv.17–18. The verb describes a physical push. Shebna is pictured being shoved off the spot where he stands, not quietly reassigned.

  46. מִמַּצָּבֶ֑ךָ

    mimmaṣṣābekā · H4673

    standing place, station, post · v19

    'From your station.' The noun comes from the root 'to take one's stand', so it names the place where someone stands. Here it is the official's post at the king's court, the position Shebna held as the man 'over the house' (v.15).

  47. וּמִמַּעֲמָֽדְךָ֖

    ûmimmaʿămādkā · H4612

    standing, position, attendance, office · v19

    'And from your post.' This one is built on the ordinary verb 'to stand'. In 1 Kings 10:5 it describes Solomon's officials standing in attendance on him. So it pairs with the previous noun: Shebna's place as a courtier standing before the king.

  48. יֶהֶרְסֶֽךָ׃

    yehersekā · H2040

    to tear down, demolish, overthrow · v19

    'He will tear you down.' This verb is normally used for wrecking walls, altars and cities. It treats Shebna like a structure being demolished, which is pointed irony after the grand rock tomb he had carved for himself (v.16). The sudden switch to 'he' is discussed under debates.

The world behind it

When and where. Isaiah 22 belongs to the reign of King Hezekiah of Judah, most likely around 705–701 BC. In those years Jerusalem rebelled against Assyria and braced for Sennacherib's invasion. Verses 8–11 describe the preparations: inspecting weapons, tearing down houses to strengthen the wall, and building a reservoir. Isaiah condemns the city for doing all this without looking to God. Verses 15–25 are the only oracle in Isaiah aimed at a single named official.

The office. "Who is over the house" was the highest civil post at the Judean court, a chief of staff who controlled the palace, the royal estates and access to the king. Its symbols were a robe, a sash and the "key of the house of David" (vv.21–22). Whoever held the key decided who got in to see the king.

Tombs and status. In Judah an important man was buried with his ancestors in a family tomb. Shebna, with no family named, is cutting a new tomb "on the height" and "in the rock" (v.16). That was a monument to his own lasting importance. Archaeology shows exactly this kind of tomb: monumental rock-cut tombs of the 8th century BC in the cliffs of Silwan, facing the City of David. One of them carries an inscription for a man "who is over the house".

Afterwards. In the narratives of 701 BC (Isaiah 36:3, 22; 37:2; 2 Kings 18:18), Eliakim is "over the house", and a Shebna appears as sōfēr, royal secretary. That looks like the demotion this oracle announces, though the "exile" of vv.17–18 is never reported.

From the study of Isaiah 22:15.

Where scholars differ

in v15

Is the Silwan 'Royal Steward' tomb Shebna's own tomb?

  • Probably yes. The tomb is Shebna's (Shebanyahu's).

    N. Avigad (1953) read the 8th-century inscription as the tomb of '[…]yahu who is over the house' and suggested restoring the name as Shebanyahu, of which Shebna would be a short form. The date, the title and the type of rock-cut tomb all match Isaiah 22:15–16.

  • Possible but unprovable.

    Only the ending '-yahu' survives. Several men held the office in the 8th century, and many names end in -yahu. Also, Isaiah 22:16 speaks of a tomb 'on the height', and a tomb with this title could belong to any holder of the office.

in v15

Was Shebna a foreigner or a newcomer?

  • He was an outsider with no family roots in Jerusalem.

    No father's name is given, which is unusual for a high official. V.16 asks 'who do you have here?', implying no ancestral tomb. Some scholars think the name looks Aramaic or non-Judean.

  • Nothing certain can be concluded.

    Names of the type Shebna/Shebanyahu are attested on Hebrew seals. Leaving out the patronymic may simply be a put-down within this oracle and not a statement about his origin.

in v15

Is the Shebna 'over the house' here the same man as Shebna the secretary in Isaiah 36–37 / 2 Kings 18–19?

  • Same man, demoted.

    Eliakim holds the office 'over the house' in 701 BC, as vv.20–22 predict, and Shebna appears one rank lower as secretary. That fits a partial fulfilment of v.19 ('I will depose you from your office').

  • Possibly two men, or the order of events is different.

    The predicted exile (vv.17–18) is never reported, and the name was not rare. Some argue the oracle comes after 701, or that the two notices are unrelated.

in v15

Does the second preposition ʿal mean 'to' or 'against'?

  • 'To', simply resuming the earlier ʾel.

    ʿal and ʾel often interchange in biblical Hebrew, especially in later texts, and most versions translate it 'to'.

  • 'Against', or a deliberate double meaning.

    ʿal regularly means 'against' with persons, and the passage that follows is an oracle of judgement. NLT's 'Confront' reflects this sense.

in v16

What does 'who is yours here?' (mi lekha poh) ask?

  • Kinship and roots: 'you have no family or ancestors here', implying Shebna is a newcomer (some suggest a foreigner) with no claim to burial in this ground.

    Israelite custom of family tombs used over generations. The emphatic threefold 'here'. Verse 18's sentence of death in a far land. The second question is about persons ('who'), not things. Some note that Shebna's father is never named, which is unusual for a high official, though that is an argument from silence.

  • Right or authority: 'who gave you the right to do this here?'

    'What is to you…?' is a standard formula for challenging someone's standing. Several modern versions (NASB, NIV, BSB) adopt this. The oracle as a whole concerns abuse of office.

in v16

Is the Silwan 'Royal Steward' tomb Shebna's tomb?

  • Probably yes: the inscription's '[…]yahu who is over the house' fits Shebna/Shebanyahu.

    Avigad's reading (1953). The same title as Isa 22:15. A late-8th-century date on letter forms. A prominent rock-cut tomb high on the slope opposite the City of David, matching 'on the height… in the rock'.

  • Possible but unproven.

    The name is broken and only '-yahu' survives. Several men held the 'over the house' office. The inscription mentions a maidservant buried with him, and nothing in Isaiah confirms the link.

in v16

Is the Shebna 'scribe' of Isaiah 36:3 the same man, demoted?

  • Yes: the threatened fall happened in stages, from steward to scribe.

    Same name, same court and period. Eliakim holds the 'over the house' post in ch. 36, as 22:20–22 predicts.

  • Not necessarily: it may be a different Shebna, or the oracle may come from after the events.

    The name is attested more than once in the period. Chapter 36 does not mention an exile, and the exile foretold in 22:18 is not narrated anywhere.

in v17

How does gāber ('man') function in the sentence?

  • Direct address: "O man!" / "you strong man!", probably ironic.

    Its position after the verb-plus-noun pair, with a pause marker in the Masoretic accents. It fits the direct, second-person taunt of vv.16–19. Followed by most modern versions (ESV, NIV, NASB, BSB) and commentators such as Oswalt.

  • Describes the hurling: "a mighty hurling" or "as a strong man hurls".

    KJV ("a mighty captivity") and some older interpreters. It needs either an unusual construction or a slight emendation (e.g. 'like a strong man'). Some critical commentators have proposed such emendations.

  • A different word or sense entirely (e.g. the Vulgate's 'rooster').

    Jerome's Latin, based on later Hebrew/Aramaic usage. It is not supported by biblical-period usage and is generally rejected.

in v17

What does ‘āṭāh mean here: 'wrap' or 'grasp'?

  • 'Wrap up, roll up', so God bundles Shebna like a cloth or ball for throwing.

    This is the normal, well-attested meaning of the root (Ps 104:2; Lev 13:45; 1 Sam 28:14). It is followed in v.18 by ṣānap 'wind (like a turban)… like a ball'. LXX and Vulgate both seem to have understood a garment image.

  • 'Grasp, seize firmly'.

    BDB lists a second root with this sense for Isa 22:17, and Jer 43:12 has sometimes been read this way. Followed by ESV, NIV, NASB, WEB, BSB. It makes good sense as gripping before throwing.

  • 'Pick clean, delouse', i.e. God strips him thoroughly.

    Proposed from Jer 43:12 (a shepherd and his garment) and Arabic cognates. Listed in some modern lexicons, but less commonly adopted for this verse.

in v17

Was the oracle fulfilled?

  • Partly fulfilled in Shebna's demotion. The exile and death abroad are not recorded.

    In 2 Kgs 18:18 and Isa 36:3 Eliakim is 'over the house' and Shebna is 'scribe', matching vv.19–21. No text reports Shebna's deportation.

  • The scribe Shebna of 701 BC may be a different man, or the oracle was later applied and updated.

    Some critical scholars (e.g. Wildberger, Blenkinsopp) see layers in vv.15–25, especially the Eliakim material in vv.20–25 and its reversal in v.25. They debate how the pieces relate to historical events.

in v18

Who or what is the 'disgrace of your master's house': Shebna himself, or his chariots?

  • It is words addressed to Shebna: 'you disgrace to your master's house!'

    The whole oracle speaks to Shebna directly ('you... your'). Hebrew often ends a pronouncement with a scornful address. Many modern versions read it this way (NIV, ESV, WEB).

  • It describes the chariots: his parade chariots become the disgrace of the royal house.

    It follows straight after 'the chariots of your glory', and the kavod → qelon reversal works neatly if the 'glory' object itself becomes the 'disgrace'. KJV and BSB read it this way.

in v18

Is the Shebna 'scribe' of 2 Kings 18–19 / Isaiah 36–37 the same man, and was the oracle fulfilled?

  • Same man, demoted: the oracle was carried out in stages.

    In 701 BC Eliakim is 'over the house' and Shebna is 'the scribe', which fits the transfer of office in Isa 22:19–22. The prophecy of exile and death abroad may have followed later, or remained a threat.

  • Different man, or the exile was never carried out literally.

    Shebna is a common name type (compare Shebanyahu on seals). No source records this Shebna's deportation or death abroad. Some scholars think the oracle was reshaped later (vv. 24–25 also predict Eliakim's fall), so its threats may work as warnings rather than recorded history.

in v18

Does 'wind you up' deliberately play on Shebna's turban of office?

  • Yes, a deliberate pun.

    The root tsanaf is the root of tsanif/mitsnefet, 'turban'. The surrounding verses deal with the clothing of office (robe and sash, v. 21). The Septuagint and Vulgate both translated the word with headwear ('crown').

  • Possible, but not certain; the main image is simply rolling him into a ball.

    The verb can mean wrapping in general. 'Like a ball' and the throwing of v. 17 control the picture, and the turban link is suggestive but not stated outright.

in v19

Who is the 'he' who tears Shebna down in the second line?

  • God, spoken of in the third person by the prophet. Hebrew prophecy often slides between 'I' and 'he' for God.

    V.17 already refers to 'the LORD' in the third person in the middle of the threat. The ancient versions that turn both verbs into 'I' read it this way too, as do NASB-type translations.

  • An unnamed 'one': in effect a passive, 'you will be pulled down'.

    Hebrew often uses a third-person singular with no named subject for a general 'someone'. BSB, WEB, ESV and NIV translate this way, and the Septuagint's passives point the same direction.

  • The king (Hezekiah) as the human agent who actually carries out the demotion.

    Only the king could formally remove a royal steward, and Shebna's 'master' is mentioned in v.18. But the text never names the king, and vv.20–23 present God as the one who installs the replacement, so this view has fewer supporters.

in v19

Was the oracle fulfilled by Shebna's later appearance as 'the scribe'?

  • Yes, partly: Shebna was demoted from 'over the house' to secretary, and Eliakim took his place.

    2 Kings 18:18 and Isaiah 36:3 list Eliakim 'over the house' and Shebna(h) 'the scribe' during the 701 BC siege.

  • Uncertain: it may be a different man, or the severer threats in vv.17–18 (exile and death abroad) were not literally carried out.

    The name is spelled slightly differently (Shebna / Shebnah). No record exists of his exile. Some scholars date vv.19–23 or vv.24–25 as later additions reflecting events after the original oracle.

Sources
  • HALOT s.v. סכן I and סֹכֵן
  • BDB s.v. סָכַן
  • BDB/HALOT s.v. בַּיִת ('palace, household'; title אֲשֶׁר עַל־הַבַּיִת)
  • N. Avigad, 'The Epitaph of a Royal Steward from Siloam Village', Israel Exploration Journal 3 (1953)
  • H. Wildberger, Isaiah 13–27 (Continental Commentary)
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 1–39 (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • J. N. Oswalt, The Book of Isaiah, Chapters 1–39 (NICOT)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Isaiah 22
  • Septuagint, Isaiah 22:15 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Isaias 22:15
  • Amarna letter EA 256 (Canaanite gloss zukini); Phoenician Baal of Lebanon inscription (skn)
  • BDB s.v. חָצַב, חָקַק, מִשְׁכָּן, מָרוֹם
  • HALOT s.v. חקק; s.v. סֶלַע
  • D. Ussishkin, The Village of Silwan: The Necropolis from the Period of the Judean Kingdom (1993)
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 1–39 (Anchor Bible)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Isa 22:15–19
  • Gesenius–Kautzsch §90 (the connecting -i ending on participles)
  • BDB s.v. טוּל, טַלְטֵלָה, גֶּבֶר, עָטָה (I and II)
  • HALOT s.v. טול, טַלְטֵלָה, עטה
  • STEPBible / OSHB morphology data (supplied)
  • J. N. Oswalt, The Book of Isaiah 1–39 (NICOT)
  • N. Avigad, "The Epitaph of a Royal Steward from Siloam Village," Israel Exploration Journal 3 (1953)
  • D. Ussishkin, The Village of Silwan: The Necropolis from the Period of the Judean Kingdom
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Isaiah 22:17
  • Vulgate, Isaias 22:17
  • Mishnah Yoma 1:8 (gever = rooster)
  • BDB s.v. צָנַף, צְנֵפָה, כַּדּוּר/דּוּר, קָלוֹן
  • HALOT s.v. צנף, כַּדּוּר, קָלוֹן, כָּבוֹד
  • J. J. M. Roberts, First Isaiah (Hermeneia)
  • Septuagint, Isaiah 22:17–18 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Isaias 22:18
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Isa 22:15–25
  • BDB s.v. הָדַף, הָרַס, מַצָּב, מַעֲמָד
  • HALOT s.v. הדף, הרס, מַצָּב, מַעֲמָד
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Isaiah 22:19; Vulgate Isaiah 22:19
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Isaiah 22:15–25

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).