Isaiah Chapter 44 Read as one passage

Isaiah 44:9–10

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

9All makers of idols are nothing, and the things they treasure are worthless. Their witnesses fail to see or comprehend, so they are put to shame. 10Who fashions a god or casts an idol which profits him nothing?

What the first hearers heard

To Judean exiles surrounded by the splendor of Babylon's gods, this verse was a courtroom ruling delivered with contempt.

  • It answered the fear of verse 8. God had just told them, "Do not tremble or fear… is there any God besides me?" Verse 9 shows why the rival gods need not be feared: their makers are tōhû and the gods themselves accomplish nothing.
  • It reversed their status. Israel, the defeated people, are the qualified witnesses who have heard and know (v. 8). The idol-worshippers of the victorious empire are the witnesses who see nothing. The shame the exiles felt is reassigned to those who trust images (compare 45:16–17).
  • It reinforced identity. Israel is what YHWH "formed". Idols are what humans "form". To turn to Babylon's gods would be to trade the Former for things formed, and the precious, desired images would "not profit".
  • It invited ridicule, not dread. Opening a long satire (vv. 9–20), the verse let hearers laugh at what looked imposing. The tone is mockery that frees them from awe of the empire's religion, more than a moral lecture.

From the study of Isaiah 44:9.

Verse by verse

  1. 9All makers of idols are nothing, and the things they treasure are worthless. Their witnesses fail to see or comprehend, so they are put to shame.

    Everyone who shapes a carved god, every last one of them, is emptiness. The word is tōhû, the formless void of Genesis 1:2 before God spoke. The irony is deliberate. These people are "formers", the same potter's word Isaiah has just used three times for God forming Israel, but they are themselves unformed nothing.

    The things they long for and treasure, the precious, gleaming images they love and maybe covet, are no use to anyone. They bring no help, no profit and no rescue.

    And their witnesses, called to testify for these gods in the great courtroom contest Isaiah has been staging, see nothing and know nothing. In Israel's law a witness is by definition someone who "has seen or known" (Leviticus 5:1). These witnesses have done neither, so their testimony disqualifies itself. (The little word "they" in this clause is one the ancient scribes marked with dots as doubtful. It may mean "their witnesses, they themselves…" or "they are their own witnesses".)

    The result is that they will be put to shame. This is not a private pang of embarrassment. It is public disgrace and bitter disappointment, the moment the thing you trusted fails you in front of everyone and your case collapses.

    Just before this, God said through Isaiah, "You are my witnesses… I know of no other Rock." Here the other side's witnesses "do not know" anything at all.

    Full study →
  2. 10Who fashions a god or casts an idol which profits him nothing?

    "Who would ever shape a god, or cast an idol in metal, when all it comes to is something that cannot help anyone?"

    The question is a jab. It is not asking for names. In the chapter's opening lines YHWH has just called himself the one who formed Israel "from the womb" (44:2, 24). Now the prophet uses the same potter's verb in reverse: a human being stands at the workbench forming a god. The word for "god" here, ʾel, is the ordinary word Isaiah also uses of Israel's God ("I am El, and there is no other", 45:22). So the craftsman really does mean to produce a deity, one who can be prayed to and will rescue. The two verbs, "formed" and "cast", picture the workshop: carving a figure and pouring molten metal into a mould or over the carved core. Both stress that this "god" is made by human hands.

    Then comes the punchline, two short words: le-vilti hoʿil, "so as not to be of use", or "to no avail at all". To "profit" here does not mean financial gain. It means to help, to benefit, to make a real difference. In the prophets it is the standard way of saying what false gods cannot do (1 Sam 12:21; Jer 2:8, 11). All the skill, the gold and the expense end in a god that cannot do the one thing a god exists to do. The next verse finishes the thought: the craftsmen "are only human" (44:11). A god made by a creature can be no more than a creature's handiwork.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v9

    vanity / vain (KJV, WEB)

    tōhû

    What we hear
    Conceit or self-admiration: 'the idol-makers are vain', as if they were proud of their looks or work.
    What they heard
    Emptiness, formless void, nothingness: the chaos of Genesis 1:2. The makers are without substance or reality, not conceited.
  • in v9

    ashamed / disappointed

    bôš

    What we hear
    An inner feeling of guilt or embarrassment ("ashamed"), or a mild let-down ("disappointed").
    What they heard
    Public disgrace and exposure when the thing one relied on fails. It is an objective defeat before others, like losing a lawsuit, not mainly an emotion.
  • in v10

    profits / profitable

    hoʿil (yaʿal)

    What we hear
    Financial return: the idol does not make its owner money.
    What they heard
    To be of use, to help, to benefit, especially to rescue or deliver (1 Sam 12:21 pairs it with 'deliver'). The idol cannot do anything for the one who prays to it.
  • in v10

    a god (lower case)

    ʾel

    What we hear
    A separate, obviously inferior category of 'god', a different word from 'God'.
    What they heard
    The same word Isaiah uses for YHWH himself (43:12; 45:22; 46:9). The craftsman aims to make a real ʾel, and that is why the verse is so sharp.
Every word
  1. יֹֽצְרֵי־

    yōṣərê · H3335

    to form, shape, fashion (as a potter) · v9, v10

    "Those who form." This is the potter's verb, and Isaiah has just used it three times for God 'forming' Israel (44:2, 21, 24). The prophet sets human craftsmen forming a god beside the God who formed his people.

  2. פֶ֤סֶל

    pesel · H6459

    carved image, idol · v9, v10

    A cult image, originally one hewn from wood or stone (from pāsal, 'to hew'), though Isaiah also uses it for metal images (40:19). It is the word banned in the second commandment (Exod 20:4).

  3. כֻּלָּם֙

    kullām · H3605

    all, the whole · v9

    "All of them." It covers every idol-maker without exception, and it sets up the sweeping verdict that follows.

  4. תֹּ֔הוּ

    tōhû · H8414

    emptiness, formlessness, wasteland, nothing · v9

    The verdict on the makers: they are tōhû, the 'formless' of Genesis 1:2. The people who 'form' gods are themselves unformed emptiness, with no substance and nothing real behind them.

  5. וַחֲמוּדֵיהֶ֖ם

    waḥămûdêhem · H2530

    to desire, covet, delight in · v9

    "And their desired things": the treasured images, probably gold- and silver-plated, that their owners love. It comes from the same root as 'you shall not covet' (Exod 20:17), so it hints at desire fixed on the wrong object.

  6. בַּל־

    bal · H1077

    not (poetic negative) · v9

    A strong, poetic 'not'. It appears three times in this verse and picks up 'I know not one' (bal-yādaʿtî) in verse 8.

  7. יוֹעִ֑ילוּ

    yôʿîlû · H3276

    to profit, benefit, be of use · v9, v10

    "They do (not) profit." This is a stock charge against idols in the prophets: they bring no benefit, no help and no rescue. Verse 10 repeats it.

  8. וְעֵדֵיהֶ֣ם

    wəʿēdêhem · H5707

    witness · v9

    "And their witnesses." This is courtroom language. God has just called Israel 'my witnesses' (v. 8). Now the opposing side's witnesses are called, and they turn out to be useless.

  9. הֵׄ֗מָּׄהׄ

    hēmmâ · H1992

    they · v9

    An emphatic 'they'. It can be read as 'their witnesses, they themselves…' or, as in the KJV, 'they are their own witnesses'. The scribes put dots over it to mark it as doubtful (see textual notes).

  10. יִרְא֛וּ

    yirʾû · H7200

    to see · v9

    "They see (not)." A witness has to have seen something. These witnesses saw nothing, much as the idols have eyes but do not see (Ps 115:5).

  11. יֵדְע֖וּ

    yēdəʿû · H3045

    to know, perceive, be acquainted with · v9

    "They know (not)." This is the legal standard for a witness, one who 'has seen or known' (Lev 5:1). It also contrasts with God, who 'knows' that there is no other Rock (v. 8).

  12. לְמַ֥עַן

    ləmaʿan · H4616

    in order that; so that (purpose or result) · v9

    "So that" or "with the result that." It names the outcome of empty testimony: the case collapses and shame follows. The line between purpose and result is debated.

  13. יֵבֹֽשׁוּ׃

    yēbōšû · H954

    to be ashamed, put to shame, disappointed · v9

    "They will be put to shame." This is public disgrace that comes when what you relied on lets you down in front of everyone, like a litigant who loses because his witnesses had nothing to say.

  14. מִֽי־

    mi · H4310

    who? · v10

    Opens a question meant to sting, not to get information. The answer it is fishing for is 'nobody with any sense', or 'only a fool'. Some read it as 'whoever', which would make the verse a statement: 'whoever forms a god... does it for nothing.'

  15. אֵ֖ל

    ʾel · H0410K

    god, God · v10

    The ordinary word for a deity. It is the same word Isaiah uses for Israel's God ('I am El', 43:12; 45:22). The craftsman sets out to make a real ʾel, and the verse mocks the idea that you can manufacture one.

  16. נָסָ֑ךְ

    nasakh · H5258A

    to pour out; to cast (metal) · v10

    Pouring molten metal into a mould, or over a core. The same root gives the usual words for a drink-offering and for a 'molten image' (massekhah). Together with 'formed' it names the two craft techniques used to make a cult statue.

  17. לְבִלְתִּ֖י

    le-vilti · H1115

    so as not, without · v10

    Negates the infinitive that follows: 'so as not to...', 'to no...'. It marks the outcome (and, sarcastically, almost the purpose) of all that effort: nothing comes of it.

The world behind it

A courtroom contest of gods. Isaiah 40–48 repeatedly stages a trial in which YHWH summons the nations and their gods to prove their divinity, chiefly by predicting the future and then bringing it to pass (41:21–29; 43:8–13). Each side brings witnesses. Israel, having heard YHWH's earlier predictions, are "my witnesses" (43:10; 44:8). Verse 9 opens the prose-like satire of 44:9–20 by examining the opposing side's witnesses and finding them blind and ignorant.

Babylon and its cult statues. Most scholars place chapters 40–55 among the Judean exiles in Babylon in the mid-sixth century BCE, before Cyrus of Persia took the city in 539. Traditional interpreters attribute them to Isaiah of Jerusalem speaking ahead of time. In either case the backdrop is the Babylonian cult of Marduk (Bel) and Nabu (Nebo, 46:1). Their richly adorned statues were carried in great processions such as the New Year (akītu) festival. To deported Judeans, a defeated people whose temple lay in ruins, these splendid gods of the winning empire could look convincing.

What the satire refuses. Mesopotamian temple texts describe "mouth-washing" and "mouth-opening" rituals (mīs pî, pīt pî) that consecrated a new statue. In them the craftsmen ritually declared that they had not made the god, and their tools were symbolically disowned, so the image counted as born of the gods. Isaiah insists on the opposite: human hands formed it, from start to finish (44:12–17). Calling the makers tōhû and their witnesses blind is a deliberate refusal to grant that any divine presence entered the image.

From the study of Isaiah 44:9.

Where scholars differ

in v9

Who are 'their witnesses'?

  • The idol-makers and worshippers, who act as witnesses for their gods.

    In the trial scenes the nations are told to 'bring their witnesses' (43:9). Verse 18 says the idolaters 'do not know nor understand… their eyes are shut', the same blindness as here.

  • The idols themselves, which 'witness' for their makers but have eyes that cannot see.

    Idols are described as having eyes that do not see (Ps 115:5; 135:16), and the 'desired things' named just before are the idols. Some commentators read 'their witnesses' as the images.

  • Both, deliberately blurred: makers and images share the same blindness and end.

    Psalm 115:8: 'Those who make them become like them.' Verses 9–20 move freely between the blind image and the blind worshipper.

in v9

Is 'they' (hēmmâ) original?

  • It is a secondary addition, which is why the scribes dotted it.

    The extraordinary points mark doubt, the word seems to be supralinear in 1QIsaᵃ, and the line reads smoothly without it.

  • It is original and emphatic ('they themselves' or 'they are their own witnesses').

    It is present in the Masoretic consonantal text and the Vulgate. Emphatic pronouns are common in Isaiah's polemic, and the KJV/YLT reading makes good sense.

in v9

Does 'lemaʿan' express purpose or result?

  • Result: 'so that, with the outcome that, they are put to shame.'

    ləmaʿan sometimes expresses consequence. Shame is the natural result of failed testimony (BSB 'so they are put to shame').

  • Purpose: 'in order that they be put to shame', within God's plan.

    ləmaʿan normally expresses purpose, and Isaiah elsewhere has God hardening or blinding with a purpose (6:9–10; 44:18 'he has shut their eyes').

in v10

Is 'who?' a rhetorical question or an indefinite 'whoever'?

  • A sarcastic rhetorical question: 'Who would be so foolish as to make a god that cannot help?' The expected answer is 'no sensible person', and the passage goes on to show that idol-makers are not sensible (44:18–20).

    It matches the many rhetorical 'who?' questions in Isaiah 40–55 (40:12–14, 18, 25; 44:7). The Masoretic punctuation and most English versions read it this way.

  • An indefinite or conditional 'whoever': 'Whoever forms a god or casts an idol, it is to no profit.' That makes v. 10 a statement continuing v. 9.

    Hebrew mi can sometimes mean 'whoever' (compare Exod 32:24, 26; Judg 7:3). The Septuagint also takes the verse as a statement. The meaning comes out almost the same either way.

in v10

Is Isaiah's portrait of idol-worship fair to how Babylonians understood their statues?

  • It is deliberate caricature. Mesopotamians did not think the wood and metal were the god. They held that the god came to dwell in the statue through ritual (mīs pî). Isaiah ignores that distinction for polemical effect.

    The mīs pî texts (ed. Walker and Dick) show a careful theology of the god's presence, including the craftsmen ritually denying that they made the statue.

  • It is pointed but fair satire. It attacks the visible practice ordinary people saw and the claim that a made object could carry divine power. The ritual's own need to deny the craftsmen's work shows how vulnerable that claim was.

    The ritual's insistence that 'I did not make it' admits the problem Isaiah exposes. Isaiah 46:1–7 also targets the statues' dependence on being carried, as a matter of function rather than metaphysics.

in v10

Is 44:9–20 original to the surrounding poem?

  • A later prose or semi-prose insertion, perhaps from the same circle, expanding the anti-idol theme.

    The style shifts toward prose, it is longer than the other idol passages (40:19–20; 41:6–7), and 44:21 joins smoothly to 44:8. Scholars such as Westermann have argued this line.

  • An integral part of the prophet's argument, with the change of style chosen for satirical effect.

    The shared vocabulary ties it in: yatsar (44:2, 9–10, 21, 24), 'witnesses' (44:8–9), 'be ashamed' (44:9, 11). The 'formed/forming' wordplay depends on its present position. Some commentators (e.g. Baltzer) treat the section as integral.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. תֹּהוּ, יָצַר, חָמַד, עֵד, בּוֹשׁ, יָעַל
  • HALOT s.v. תֹּהוּ, בּוֹשׁ, עֵד
  • Emanuel Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible (on the extraordinary points and 1QIsaᵃ)
  • Joseph Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 40–55 (Anchor Bible)
  • Klaus Baltzer, Deutero-Isaiah (Hermeneia)
  • John N. Oswalt, The Book of Isaiah, Chapters 40–66 (NICOT)
  • Brevard S. Childs, Isaiah (OTL)
  • C. Walker and M. B. Dick, The Induction of the Cult Image in Ancient Mesopotamia: The Mīs Pî Ritual
  • Lev 5:1; 1 Sam 12:21; Ps 115:4–8; Isa 41:21–29; 43:8–13; 45:16–19
  • BDB s.v. יָצַר, נָסַךְ, יָעַל, פֶּסֶל
  • HALOT s.v. יצר, נסך I–III, יעל, פֶּסֶל, אֵל
  • Gesenius–Kautzsch–Cowley, Hebrew Grammar, on לְבִלְתִּי with the infinitive (§114s) and indefinite מִי (§137c)
  • C. Walker and M. B. Dick, The Induction of the Cult Image in Ancient Mesopotamia: The Mesopotamian Mīs Pî Ritual (2001)
  • C. Westermann, Isaiah 40–66 (OTL)
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 40–55 (Anchor Bible)
  • K. Baltzer, Deutero-Isaiah (Hermeneia)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Isa 44:9–20

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).