Jeremiah Chapter 3 Read as one passage

Jeremiah 3:21–25

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

21A voice is heard on the barren heights, the children of Israel weeping and begging for mercy, because they have perverted their ways and forgotten the LORD their God. 22“Return, O faithless children, and I will heal your faithlessness.” “Here we are. We come to You, for You are the LORD our God. 23Surely deception comes from the hills, and commotion from the mountains. Surely the salvation of Israel is in the LORD our God. 24From our youth, that shameful god has consumed what our fathers have worked for—their flocks and herds, their sons and daughters. 25Let us lie down in our shame; let our disgrace cover us. We have sinned against the LORD our God, both we and our fathers; from our youth even to this day we have not obeyed the voice of the LORD our God.”

What the first hearers heard

To Jeremiah's hearers in Jerusalem in the late 7th century, the verse would sound like a scene in a drama of judgment and invitation:

  • A haunting sound from familiar hills. The shephayim were known places. Jeremiah had just pointed to them as the scene of Israel's "prostitution" with other gods (3:2). Now he makes his audience hear weeping from those same ridges. The places of false worship turn into places of grief.
  • The north as a mirror. "The sons of Israel" points first to the northern tribes. Their exile showed what unfaithfulness leads to. Judah, which the chapter calls even more treacherous (3:11), was meant to hear that sound and recognize itself.
  • A diagnosis, not just sympathy. The "for" clause names the cause plainly: they twisted their own road and abandoned their own God. Their distress is not bad luck. It comes from broken covenant loyalty, the same charge brought in Deuteronomy and Judges.
  • An opening for return. The verse leads straight into God's call, "Return, faithless sons, and I will heal your faithlessness" (3:22), and a model confession ("Here we are, we come to you"). In public use it gave the community the words and posture for coming back: weeping, pleading for favor, naming the twisted road. The conditions that follow in 4:1–4 make clear that genuine return means abandoning idols and practicing justice.

From the study of Jeremiah 3:21.

Verse by verse

  1. 21A voice is heard on the barren heights, the children of Israel weeping and begging for mercy, because they have perverted their ways and forgotten the LORD their God.

    Listen! A sound! It carries across the bare, windswept ridges. These are the same open hilltops where, a few lines earlier (3:2), Israel lay down with other gods. Now the sound from there is the sons of Israel weeping and pleading for mercy, crying out loud and begging for a favor they have no right to. Why? Because they have twisted their own road crooked. The straight path they were given, they bent themselves. They have forgotten the LORD their God. That means not a slip of memory but turning their backs on their own covenant God, the way an unfaithful wife walks away from her husband (3:20).

    The verse works like a turn in a drama. God has just mourned his betrayal (3:19–20). Then he hears his children crying from the scene of their unfaithfulness, and in the next breath he calls them home: "Return, faithless sons, and I will heal your faithlessness" (3:22).

    Full study →
  2. 22“Return, O faithless children, and I will heal your faithlessness.” “Here we are. We come to You, for You are the LORD our God.

    God calls out to his runaway children with a play on one Hebrew word, shuv, "turn". The sense is: "Turn back, you turned-away sons, and I will heal your turnings-away." The same word names the command, the people's character and their sickness. They are sons, heirs of the house who walked out on their father (v.19, "I thought you would call me 'My Father'"). Their turning away is not a single lapse but a habit, so ingrained that Jeremiah has already used it as a nickname: "Turncoat Israel." God does not only demand that they come back. He promises to heal the turning-away itself, as a doctor treats a disease or a builder mends a broken altar. The promise is not tied on with "if." It stands next to the command as a bare "I will heal," both the result of returning and the reason to dare it.

    Then the people's voice answers, in the words of servants reporting for duty: "Here we are! We have come to you, for you, and no one else, are YHWH, our God." Their "here we are" echoes the "here I am" of Abraham, Samuel and Isaiah. "We have come" is spoken as already done: they stand before him. And "YHWH our God" deliberately reverses the previous verse, where they had "forgotten YHWH their God." Their affirmation is the people's half of the covenant pledge ("I will be your God, you will be my people"), now on their own lips. It is made against the hill shrines, which the next verse calls "a lie."

    Full study →
  3. 23Surely deception comes from the hills, and commotion from the mountains. Surely the salvation of Israel is in the LORD our God.

    "So it is true after all: it was all a lie, everything we looked for from the hills, all that roaring crowd on the mountains. So it is true after all: in YHWH, our own God, is Israel's rescue."

    The verse is a confession, spoken by the people in answer to God's call in v. 22 ("Return, faithless children, and I will heal your faithlessness"). It has two halves that mirror each other, each opening with the same word of sudden recognition, "surely / so it really is."

    • The first half is the "no." The hills and mountains are the high places, the hilltop shrines where Israel had worshipped Baal and other gods of rain and fertility. What came "from" them, together with the loud commotion of crowds and festivals on the heights, was laššeqer. That means "for the lie," and it means "for nothing." It was false and it was futile. The shrines had promised rain, crops, herds and children. The next verse says the opposite happened: "the shameful thing" (a scornful nickname for Baal) devoured all of it.
    • The second half is the "yes." Rescue (təšûʿâ) means real help in real danger: deliverance, victory, safety for land, flocks and families. It is found "in YHWH," and he is named as "our God," taking up again the relationship the people had walked away from.

    The verse sets noise and many shrines against one God, and a promise that cheated against rescue that is real.

    Full study →
  4. 24From our youth, that shameful god has consumed what our fathers have worked for—their flocks and herds, their sons and daughters.

    But the Shameful One, Baal, has eaten up everything our forebears worked for, from the very beginning of our life as a people: their sheep and goats, their cattle, their sons and their daughters.

    Several things in the Hebrew are lost in plain English:

    • "The Shame" is a name for a god. Israel's writers sometimes replaced the name Baal with bōshet, "shame," as a sneer (Jer 11:13; Hos 9:10; Ish-bosheth for Eshbaal). Here the word stands at the head of the sentence as the one acting, set directly against "YHWH our God" in verse 23, the only true source of rescue. It means two things at once: Baal is a disgrace, and Baal produces disgrace.
    • The god who was supposed to feed them ate them. Baal was worshipped as the rain-and-fertility god who made flocks multiply and fields yield. The verb is plain "eat." Instead of feeding his worshippers, he ate their harvest, as the covenant curse in Deuteronomy 28:33 warned a foreign enemy would.
    • The list gets worse as it goes. First the livestock, the family's wealth. Then the children, the family's future. In Jeremiah, sons and daughters given to Baal brings to mind the fires of Topheth, where children were burned (7:31; 19:5).
    • It is an old pattern, not a new mistake. "Our fathers… from our youth" reaches back to Israel's start as a nation, pictured as a young bride.
    • It sets up the next line. Verse 25 answers: "Let us lie down in our shame." The god they ran after has become the disgrace they now lie in. These are words of confession, which God himself puts in the people's mouths.
    Full study →
  5. 25Let us lie down in our shame; let our disgrace cover us. We have sinned against the LORD our God, both we and our fathers; from our youth even to this day we have not obeyed the voice of the LORD our God.”

    "Come, let us throw ourselves down flat in our disgrace, and let our humiliation be pulled over us like a cloak. We have earned it: it is against YHWH, our own God, that we have done wrong. Not only our ancestors but we ourselves, from the very beginning of our life as a people right up to this day. We have never truly listened when the voice of YHWH our God spoke to us."

    Several layers sit under the plain English:

    • A chosen posture. The opening verbs are a wish ("let us… let it…"), not a description. The people decide to take the low place, lying on the ground the way mourners did, instead of defending themselves.
    • Shame with a double edge. The word for "shame" (boshet) was, one verse earlier, a scornful nickname for Baal, "the Shame" who ate up the nation's flocks, herds and children. "Our shame" is both the disgrace they now carry and the shameful god they ran after. In Hebrew, shame is chiefly public: being exposed and let down by what you trusted, not only feeling bad inside.
    • Covered, but not forgiven yet. People normally hope their sin will be "covered". Here they ask to be covered by their disgrace, and they hide nothing.
    • No escape into the past. "We ourselves and our fathers" refuses to blame the previous generation alone. "From our youth", the honeymoon years Israel had appealed to in 2:2 and 3:4, admits that the unfaithfulness goes back to the start.
    • Answering God in his own words. "We have not listened to the voice of YHWH our God" repeats God's charge in 3:13 almost exactly. To "listen to the voice" is the Hebrew way of saying "obey" a personal covenant partner who speaks.
    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v21

    forgotten the LORD their God

    shakheḥu ʾet-YHWH ʾeloheihem

    What we hear
    They absent-mindedly lost track of God, an innocent memory lapse.
    What they heard
    They abandoned their covenant God: they stopped living loyally toward him and turned to other gods (compare Judg 3:7, 'they forgot the LORD their God and served the Baals'). It is a charge of unfaithfulness, which is why it follows the image of a wife betraying her husband.
  • in v21

    perverted their way

    heʿevu ʾet-darkam

    What we hear
    Fell into sexual perversion.
    What they heard
    They bent their road crooked, distorting a straight path. The surrounding chapter does use sexual imagery for idolatry, but this verb is about twisting, not sexual vice as such.
  • in v21

    high places (KJV, YLT)

    shephayim

    What we hear
    The 'high places', meaning built hilltop shrines or altars condemned in Kings.
    What they heard
    Bare, treeless ridges and hilltops: the open landscape where such worship happened, not the shrine structures (bamot) themselves.
  • in v22

    backsliding / backslidings (KJV, WEB, NIV)

    shovavim / meshuvot

    What we hear
    An individual believer whose personal devotion has cooled: praying less, skipping church, slipping into old habits.
    What they heard
    A whole covenant people's deliberate, repeated defection from their God to other gods (the Baal cult on the hills, v.23). It is a nation's apostasy, a change of allegiance, and the word shares its root with 'return.'
  • in v22

    faithless (ESV, NASB, BSB)

    shovavim / meshuvah

    What we hear
    Lacking faith: doubting, not believing.
    What they heard
    Disloyal, turned-away. The problem is broken allegiance (like a spouse who left), not intellectual doubt. Israel was quite religious, just toward the wrong gods.
  • in v23

    salvation

    təšûʿâ

    What we hear
    Mainly the individual soul's rescue from sin and eternal judgment.
    What they heard
    Concrete rescue and help for the people: deliverance from danger, victory, safety, the flourishing of land, herds and families. It is grounded in their relationship with YHWH, but it is not mainly about the afterlife.
  • in v23

    orgies (ESV, RSV)

    hāmôn

    What we hear
    Sexual group revelry at the shrines.
    What they heard
    Noise, roar, a surging crowd, possibly 'abundance'. It names the loud commotion of hilltop worship. The word itself does not specify sexual rites.
  • in v24

    shame (KJV: "For shame hath devoured")

    habbōshet

    What we hear
    An inner feeling of guilt or embarrassment. Or a vague abstraction, as if the nation's sense of shame had "devoured" its wealth.
    What they heard
    "The Shame" with the article: a contemptuous name for the god Baal, the Shameful One. The word also carries the sense of public disgrace, being shown up for trusting a god who fails.
  • in v25

    confusion ("our confusion covereth us")

    kelimmah

    What we hear
    Mental bewilderment, being muddled or unsure what is happening.
    What they heard
    Public humiliation, disgrace, the insult of being exposed and lowered in the eyes of others.
  • in v25

    shame

    boshet

    What we hear
    A private, inner feeling of unworthiness, often thought of as a psychological problem to be overcome.
    What they heard
    Mainly an objective, public state: being exposed and discredited, and let down by what one trusted. Here it is also a play on 'the Shame', a nickname for Baal (3:24). The inner feeling is included, but it is not the center.
Every word
  1. ק֚וֹל

    qol · H6963A

    voice, sound · v21, v25

    A sound or voice. Hebrew poetry often puts qol first as a kind of exclamation, 'Listen!' or 'A sound!' (compare Isa 40:3; Jer 10:22). So the verse opens by making the hearer stop and listen.

  2. עַל־

    ʿal · H5921A

    on, upon, over · v21

    'On' or 'over' the heights. It tells you where the sound is coming from, and possibly that it carries across them.

  3. שְׁפָיִ֣ים

    shephayim · H8205

    bare heights · v21

    Bare, treeless hilltops and ridges. Jeremiah used the same word in 3:2 for the places where Israel 'played the prostitute' with other gods, so the place of their unfaithfulness is now the place of their weeping.

  4. נִשְׁמָ֔ע

    nishmaʿ · H8085G

    is heard · v21, v25

    A passive verb: 'is heard' or 'has been heard'. The poet reports the sound as already reaching his ears, which makes the scene vivid and present.

  5. בְּכִ֥י

    bekhi · H1065

    weeping · v21

    Audible weeping, the loud crying of mourning or distress. It is not quiet tears. It is linked to the next word: 'the weeping of pleas'.

  6. תַחֲנוּנֵ֖י

    taḥanunei · H8469

    supplications, pleas for favor · v21

    Pleas for favor or mercy, from the root ḥanan, 'to show grace or favor'. Together with 'weeping' it describes tearful begging. Jeremiah pairs the same two words again in 31:9.

  7. בְּנֵ֣י

    benei · H1121A

    sons, children · v21, v22, v24

    'Sons of', the usual way of naming the people of Israel. Here it also echoes the father-son language around it (3:4, 19 'My Father'; 3:22 'faithless sons').

  8. יִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל

    Yisraʾel · H3478

    Israel · v21, v23

    In this chapter 'Israel' refers first to the northern kingdom, exiled by Assyria a century earlier (3:6–12). Judah is also drawn in, and 3:18 imagines the two reunited.

  9. כִּ֤י

    ki · H3588A

    for, because · v21, v22, v25

    'For' or 'because'. It gives the reason behind the weeping. That could be what the people themselves are confessing, or the prophet's diagnosis of why they are in distress.

  10. הֶעֱוּוּ֙

    heʿevu · H5753A

    make crooked, twist, pervert · v21

    'They have made crooked' or 'twisted'. The picture is a road bent out of line. This root is the source of ʿawon, a standard Hebrew word for 'iniquity, guilt'.

  11. אֶת־

    ʾet · H0853

    [object marker] · v21, v24

    This word is not translated. It marks 'their way' as the direct object of the verb.

  12. דַּרְכָּ֔ם

    darkam · H1870G

    way, road; conduct · v21

    'Their way'. Literally a road or path, and here their whole course of life. The idea is that the road they walk is one they bent themselves.

  13. שָׁכְח֖וּ

    shakheḥu · H7911

    forget · v21

    'They have forgotten'. In covenant language this means neglecting God, ceasing to treat him as their God and living as if he did not matter. It does not mean a lapse of memory. There is no 'and' before it, which makes the line abrupt.

  14. יְהֹוָ֥ה

    YHWH · H3068G

    the LORD (Yahweh) · v21, v22, v23, v25

    Israel's God named by his personal, covenant name, the name he gave at the exodus. English Bibles usually render it 'the LORD'.

  15. אֱלֹהֵיהֶֽם׃

    ʾeloheihem · H0430G

    God · v21, v22, v23, v25

    'Their God'. This is covenant language ('I will be your God, you will be my people'), and it sharpens the charge: the one they forgot was their own God.

  16. שׁ֚וּבוּ

    shuvu · H7725G

    return, turn back · v22

    A plural command: 'Turn back!' Spoken by YHWH to the whole people. It is the basic Hebrew word for coming back to where you belong. In the prophets it is also the word for repentance, pictured as turning your steps around rather than as a feeling.

  17. שׁוֹבָבִ֔ים

    shovavim · H7726

    turning back, apostate, wayward · v22

    An adjective from the same root as 'return': 'turned-away' or 'turning-away' sons. It describes a settled habit of defection, not one slip. The command and the description use the same word, so they point in opposite directions: turn back, you who turned away.

  18. אֶרְפָּ֖ה

    erpa · H7495

    to heal · v22

    'I will heal.' God speaks in the first person and promises to act. No 'and' or 'if' joins it to the command. It stands as a bare promise right after it, so it can be read as both the result ('return, and I will heal') and the motive for returning.

  19. מְשׁוּבֹֽתֵיכֶ֑ם

    meshuvoteikhem · H4878

    turning away, apostasy, disloyalty · v22

    'Your turnings-away' (plural: repeated, many acts of defection). This is the third word in a row from the same root. What God promises to heal is the turning-away itself, treated as a sickness in the people and not only as a debt to cancel.

  20. הִנְנוּ֙

    hinnenu · H2005

    behold, here (we are) · v22

    'Here we are!' This is the pointing word 'behold' with 'us' attached. It is the plural of the 'Here I am' (hinneni) that Abraham, Samuel and Isaiah say when they present themselves to God. It is the stance of someone reporting for duty.

  21. אָתָ֣נוּ

    atanu · H0857

    to come · v22

    'We have come.' This is a rare, poetic verb for 'come' (common in Aramaic, rare in Hebrew prose). The past-tense form presents the arrival as already done: we are here, standing in front of you.

  22. לָ֔ךְ

    lakh · H9032

    to you · v22

    'To you,' that is, to YHWH. The form looks feminine, but here it is the ordinary masculine 'to you' as it is pronounced at a pause in the verse. It is addressed to God, the destination of the return.

  23. אַתָּ֖ה

    attah · H0859A

    you (masc. sing.) · v22

    'You.' The pronoun is spelled out where Hebrew could leave it unstated, so it is emphatic: you, and no other. This prepares for v.23, which says the hills (the Baal shrines) were a lie.

  24. אָכֵ֥ן

    ʾākēn · H0403

    surely, truly, indeed · v23

    A word for strong affirmation that often marks a sudden realization ('so it really is true!'), sometimes against what the speaker had assumed before (Gen 28:16; Exod 2:14). It opens the confession: the people now see what they would not see before.

  25. לַשֶּׁ֛קֶר

    laššeqer · H8267

    lie, falsehood, deception · v23

    With the prefix la- ('for, to') this is a fixed idiom: 'for nothing, in vain, to no purpose' (compare 1 Sam 25:21; Jer 8:8). It also keeps the sharper sense of 'a lie': the hill shrines did more than fail. They betrayed the trust placed in them.

  26. מִגְּבָע֖וֹת

    miggəbāʿôt · H1389I

    hill(s) · v23

    'From hills': the hilltop shrines where Baal and other gods were worshipped (Jer 2:20; 3:2, 6). The 'from' means whatever was looked for or received from these places.

  27. הָמ֣וֹן

    hāmôn · H1995A

    noise, roar, crowd, abundance · v23

    The loud, crowded commotion of worship at the mountain shrines: festival crowds, shouting, perhaps the noise of the rites themselves. The word can also mean 'multitude' (KJV) or 'abundance' (LXX 'power'), so the exact shade is debated.

  28. הָרִ֑ים

    hārîm · H2022G

    mountains · v23

    'Of mountains': it pairs with 'hills', as is standard in Hebrew poetry, and names the same high places of worship. The main pause of the verse comes here: the first half is the 'no', the second half the 'yes'.

  29. תְּשׁוּעַ֖ת

    təšûʿat · H8668G

    deliverance, rescue, victory, help · v23

    Concrete rescue from distress: safety, victory, help when crops, herds, children or the nation are at risk. That kind of help is exactly what the fertility shrines had promised and failed to give.

  30. וְהַבֹּ֗שֶׁת

    vehabbōshet · H1322

    and the shame · v24, v25

    With the article, "the Shame" is a name for the god Baal, swapped in on purpose to mock him. It puts the false god first in the sentence as the one doing the act. The "and" (here more like "but") sets it against verse 23, where Israel's rescue comes from YHWH alone.

  31. אָֽכְלָ֛ה

    ʾākhlāh · H398

    it has eaten, devoured · v24

    Literally "has eaten." The irony is pointed: the god people trusted to feed them with rain and crops has eaten up their food and their children instead. The verb form looks at the whole history as one finished act.

  32. יְגִ֥יעַ

    yegîaʿ · H3018

    toil; the product of toil · v24

    Not the effort itself but what the effort produced: earnings, harvest, livestock, the family's wealth. The verse goes on to list what this was.

  33. אֲבוֹתֵ֖ינוּ

    ʾavôtênû · H1

    our fathers · v24, v25

    Earlier generations of the nation, the forebears. The speakers are confessing a pattern that runs back through their whole people, not only their own households.

  34. מִנְּעוּרֵ֑ינוּ

    minneʿûrênû · H5271

    from our youth · v24, v25

    "From our youth" means from the start of the nation's history. Jeremiah pictures Israel as a young bride (2:2; 3:4), so the phrase looks back to Israel's earliest days in the land.

  35. צֹאנָם֙

    tsōʾnām · H6629

    their flock (sheep and goats) · v24

    Sheep and goats, the everyday wealth of a family. They were also the main animals used in sacrifice.

  36. בְּקָרָ֔ם

    beqārām · H1241

    their herd (cattle) · v24

    Cattle, the costlier livestock. "Flock and herd" together is a stock phrase for all of a household's animals.

  37. בְּנוֹתֵיהֶֽם׃

    benôtêhem · H1323

    their daughters · v24

    Their daughters. "Sons and daughters" sums up the family's whole future. The list builds to this as its worst loss.

  38. נִשְׁכְּבָה

    nishkevah · H7901

    let us lie down · v25

    A first-person-plural verb with a 'let us' ending: the people urge one another to lie flat. It is the posture of grief and collapse (as in 2 Sam 12:16; 13:31). The same root is behind the spoken reading of 3:2 ('where have you not been lain with?'), so the bed of unfaithfulness becomes a bed of shame.

  39. וּתְכַסֵּנוּ

    utekhassenu · H3680

    and let it cover us · v25

    An intensive verb form used here as a wish, matching the 'let us' of the first verb. Disgrace is pictured as a garment or blanket pulled over the people lying on the ground.

  40. כְּלִמָּתֵנוּ

    kelimmatenu · H3639

    our disgrace / humiliation · v25

    Humiliation in front of others, the insult of being exposed and lowered. It is the usual partner word to boshet. Together the two say 'total disgrace'.

  41. חָטָאנוּ

    chata'nu · H2398

    we have sinned · v25

    A completed action: 'we have done wrong'. The root means failing an obligation or missing the mark. Here it is failing in loyalty to a covenant partner.

  42. אֲנַחְנוּ

    anachnu · H587

    we · v25

    A separate pronoun added for emphasis even though the verb already says 'we'. It works like 'we ourselves', so the speakers cannot shift the blame onto the ancestors alone.

  43. וְעַד־

    ve'ad- · H5704

    and until · v25

    Marks the end-point of an unbroken span of time.

  44. הַיּוֹם

    hayyom · H3117

    the day · v25

    Part of the fixed phrase 'until this day', meaning the speakers' own present moment.

  45. הַזֶּה

    hazzeh · H2088

    this · v25

    'This very day.' The phrase is common in Deuteronomy and Jeremiah for a pattern that has never stopped.

  46. וְלֹא

    velo · H3808

    and not · v25

    A flat negative. The confession ends on what was never done.

The world behind it

The chapter. Jeremiah 3:1–4:4 is a long appeal built on the Hebrew verb shuv, "turn back, return". It uses two pictures: a marriage betrayed (3:1–5, 20) and a family of sons who have abandoned their father (3:4, 19, 22). The prose section dates the material to the reign of Josiah (3:6), late 7th century BC. It speaks first to "Israel", the northern kingdom that Assyria had deported about a century earlier (722 BC), and holds it up as a warning to Judah (3:6–12). The poem in 3:19–25 is laid out like a liturgy: God speaks (19–20), the sound of weeping is heard (21), God calls (22a), and the people answer with a confession (22b–25).

The bare heights. Open hilltops were favored places for worship of Baal and of fertility gods ("on every high hill and under every green tree", 3:6; compare Hos 4:13). Jeremiah 3:2 sends the hearer's eyes to these same shephayim as evidence of Israel's unfaithfulness. Hilltops were also where public laments were raised (Jer 7:29), and a cry from there carried far. An Israelite hearing 3:21 would catch the reversal: the place of illicit worship has become the place of mourning.

Weeping in public. In ancient Israel, mourning and supplication were loud, public and bodily: crying aloud, often with fasting, torn clothes and gestures. "Weeping of pleas" names that kind of noisy appeal, the sound of a community in distress, not private sorrow. Hosea 7:14 shows a prophet could treat such wailing with suspicion when it was aimed at crops rather than God. That is why commentators ask what kind of weeping this is (see debates).

Echo in Jeremiah's book of comfort. The verse has a close twin in 31:15–20: "A voice is heard in Ramah, lamentation, bitter weeping", followed by Ephraim (northern Israel) confessing and God's compassion. In 31:9 the returning exiles "come with weeping (bekhi)" while God leads them "with pleas for mercy (taḥanunim)", the same two nouns as 3:21.

From the study of Jeremiah 3:21.

Where scholars differ

in v21

What kind of weeping is this: real repentance, pagan ritual lament, or grief over disaster?

  • Repentance: the first stirrings of a genuine turning back to God.

    The 'for' clause names their own sin as the cause. God answers at once with 'Return… I will heal' (3:22), and the people reply with a confession (3:22b–25). Jer 31:9, 18–19 uses the same weeping and pleading vocabulary for Israel's real return.

  • Misdirected or cultic weeping: wailing on the same hills where they worshiped other gods, possibly still aimed at them or at the land's fertility.

    The setting is the shephayim of 3:2. Hosea 7:14 condemns Israel for wailing 'on their beds' for grain and wine rather than crying to God. Ritual weeping for a dying god is attested (Ezek 8:14, Tammuz). Some commentators read the verse as deliberately ambiguous, with the prophet turning this weeping toward God.

  • Grief over judgment: the cries of a people in exile or disaster, which the prophet then interprets theologically.

    The 'for' clause can be the prophet's diagnosis rather than the people's own words. Elsewhere Jeremiah links the bare heights with drought and devastation (4:11; 12:12; 14:6). The conditions in 4:1–4 ('If you return…') suggest that real repentance has not yet happened.

in v21

Is the confession in 3:22b–25 a real response or an ideal script that Israel has not yet spoken?

  • An ideal or hoped-for liturgy: words placed in the people's mouths, showing them how to return.

    Chapter 4 opens with a conditional ('If you return, O Israel…', 4:1–2), and Jeremiah elsewhere doubts that Judah's repentance is genuine (3:10, 'not with her whole heart, but in pretense').

  • A real or anticipated response, especially from the northern tribes, matching Jeremiah's hopes in chapters 30–31.

    The close verbal links with 31:9, 15–20 (weeping heard, Ephraim's confession, God's compassion) suggest Jeremiah truly expected the north to return.

in v22

Is the people's answer ('Here we are, we have come…') a real repentance, or a model or even a hollow confession?

  • It is a model liturgy: the prophet supplies the words Israel *ought* to say, in hope.

    The section reads like a scripted call and response (vv.22–25), much as Hosea 14:2 tells Israel to 'take words with you.' God's reply in 4:1–2 is conditional ('If you return…'), which suggests the return has not yet actually happened (e.g., Holladay, Hermeneia).

  • It is a sincere response presented as already happening.

    The verb 'we have come' is in a completed form. The confession in vv.23–25 is thorough (naming the hills as 'a lie', accepting shame). Nothing in 3:22–25 itself rejects it.

  • It is deliberately ambiguous or under suspicion, like the shallow repentance song of Hosea 6:1–3.

    Jeremiah elsewhere attacks easy words of repentance (3:4–5, 'you have spoken, but you have done all the evil you could'; 3:10, Judah returned 'not with her whole heart but in pretence'). God's 'if' in 4:1–2 demands deeds as well as words.

in v22

Who is being addressed: the old northern kingdom, or Judah?

  • Originally northern Israel (Ephraim), in Jeremiah's early ministry under Josiah.

    'Children of Israel' (v.21), the contrast between 'Israel' and 'Judah' in 3:6–13, the call 'toward the north' (3:12), and the heavy use of the northern prophet Hosea's language.

  • In its present form the oracle speaks to Judah (and later readers in exile) through the example of Israel.

    3:18 envisions Judah and Israel coming together. The chapter's warnings are aimed at 'treacherous Judah' (3:7–11). The edited book of Jeremiah addresses a Judean audience facing or living in exile.

in v23

What does hāmôn hārîm ('hāmôn of mountains') mean?

  • The noise or tumult of worship on the mountains (festival crowds, cultic shouting).

    This is the most common sense of hāmôn (sound, roar, noisy crowd). Followed by BSB, NASB, WEB and NIV; many commentators (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom).

  • The 'multitude of mountains', i.e. the many hill shrines.

    Vulgate multitudo; KJV and YLT. hāmôn can mean 'great number'.

  • The 'abundance/wealth' or 'power' the mountain cults promised or consumed.

    Septuagint dynamis. hāmôn means 'wealth, abundance' in Ps 37:16 and Eccl 5:10, and v. 24 lists the goods 'devoured'. Jeremiah uses hāmôn for the 'roar' of rain that YHWH gives (10:13), which some see as an ironic contrast with Baal the rain god.

in v23

Should the Hebrew 'from the hills' be kept or corrected to 'the hills [are]'?

  • Keep the Masoretic text: '[what is] from the hills is in vain'.

    The Hebrew makes sense with a supplied subject (help, rescue), anticipating təšûʿâ in the second half. Correcting the text without manuscript support is a last resort.

  • Correct it to 'the hills are a lie', following the Septuagint.

    The Septuagint seems to reflect this text, and it gives a cleaner parallel with the second half. Adopted by RSV, ESV and NASB.

in v23

Is this confession sincere repentance or a model the prophet puts in the people's mouth?

  • It is the prophet's ideal liturgy of return: the words God invites, not a report of what Judah actually said.

    The whole of 3:21–25 reads as a scripted call and answer. Jeremiah 4:1–2 immediately sets conditions ('if you return... if you remove your abominations'), and the rest of the book shows Judah did not turn.

  • It is a deliberate contrast with shallow repentance like Hosea 6:1–3, presenting what genuine confession sounds like.

    Hosea's people say 'let us return' and assume quick healing, and God rejects it (Hos 6:4). Here the people name the specific false source and own their shame (vv. 24–25), which marks it as deeper.

in v24

Does "the Shame" refer specifically to Baal, or to idolatry in general?

  • It is a name for Baal.

    Jer 11:13 sets "the Shame" and "Baal" side by side. Hos 9:10 uses it of Baal-peor. The names Ish-bosheth and Mephibosheth replace "-baal." The article ("*the* Shame") and the contrast with "YHWH our God" in v. 23 point to a particular rival god. The context also concerns hilltop worship of fertility gods.

  • It is a general label for false worship, the "shameful thing."

    The word is simply the common noun "shame." Jeremiah condemns many gods (2:28; 11:13a "as many as your cities"), and the hills of v. 23 suggest many shrines. Translations such as ESV/NASB ("the shameful thing") and NIV ("shameful gods") read it this way. Either way, Baal is the main figure in view.

in v24

Does "has eaten… their sons and their daughters" mean child sacrifice?

  • Yes, mainly the sacrifice of children by fire.

    Jeremiah elsewhere speaks of burning sons and daughters to Baal/Molech at Topheth (7:31; 19:5; 32:35). 2 Kgs 16:3, 21:6 and 23:10 record the practice in Judah. "Eat" is used of fire (Lev 10:2).

  • Children lost to the results of idolatry (war, famine, exile), perhaps including sacrifice.

    Jer 5:17 has an invading nation "eat" sons, daughters, flocks and herds with the same vocabulary. Deut 28:32–33 links lost children and "eaten" toil as covenant curses. The four-part list (flocks, herds, sons, daughters) reads like a sweeping summary of everything lost. Many commentators allow both senses.

in v25

Is this confession presented as genuine and sufficient, or as words that still fall short?

  • It is the model confession the prophet longs to hear: complete, and accepted in principle.

    It answers God's invitation in 3:22a and repeats his demand of 3:13 almost word for word ('know your iniquity… you have not listened to my voice'). Jer 31:18–20 shows a similar repentance by Ephraim that God receives with compassion.

  • It is liturgy, the right words, which God answers with conditions, implying that words alone are not yet enough.

    4:1–4 opens with repeated 'if' clauses (if you return, if you remove your idols, if you swear truly). Compare Hos 6:1–3, where an eloquent penitential song is met with 'your love is like the morning mist' (6:4). Jer 3:10 explicitly condemns Judah's return 'in pretense'.

in v25

What does 'lying down' evoke?

  • Mainly the posture of mourning and humiliation.

    Lying on the ground in grief: 2 Sam 12:16; 13:31. Paired with being 'covered', which echoes covering the head or face in mourning (2 Sam 15:30; Jer 14:3–4).

  • It also echoes the sexual 'lying' of 3:2: the bed of infidelity becomes the bed of shame.

    The traditional spoken reading of 3:2 uses the same root (shukkavt, 'you were lain with'), and chapters 2–3 are built on adultery imagery. This is a literary echo, so it is suggestive rather than provable.

  • It hints at lying down in death or collapse.

    'Lie down' is used for death ('lie down with one's fathers'), and v. 24 describes the people's life being devoured. Few commentators make this the main sense.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. שְׁפִי, תַּחֲנוּן, עָוָה, שָׁכַח
  • HALOT s.v. שְׁפִי; תַּחֲנוּן; עוה; שׁכח
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
  • J. A. Thompson, The Book of Jeremiah (NICOT)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 3
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs/Göttingen), Jer 3:21
  • BDB s.v. שׁוּב, שׁוֹבָב, מְשׁוּבָה, רָפָא, אָתָה
  • HALOT s.v. שׁוב, מְשׁוּבָה, רפא
  • W. L. Holladay, The Root ŠÛBH in the Old Testament (Brill, 1958)
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia, 1986)
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible, 1999)
  • M. L. Brown, Israel's Divine Healer (Zondervan, 1995)
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 3:22
  • Vulgate, Jeremiah 3:22
  • Damascus Document (CD) 2:5 on 'those who turn from transgression'
  • BDB s.v. אָכֵן, שֶׁקֶר, הָמוֹן, תְּשׁוּעָה
  • HALOT s.v. שֶׁקֶר, הָמוֹן, תְּשׁוּעָה
  • William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
  • Jack R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
  • William McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC)
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 3:23 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Jeremiah 3:23
  • Stephanie L. Budin, The Myth of Sacred Prostitution in Antiquity (2008)
  • HALOT s.v. בֹּשֶׁת
  • BDB s.v. בֹּשֶׁת, יְגִיעַ, אָכַל
  • Jer 11:13; Hos 9:10; 2 Sam 2:8 / 1 Chr 8:33–34 (Baal/bosheth name substitution)
  • Deut 28:32–33; Jer 5:17 (eating of toil, children, flocks as curse)
  • Jer 7:31; 19:5; 32:35; 2 Kgs 16:3; 21:6; 23:10 (child sacrifice)
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 3:24 (aischynē)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 3:21–25
  • BDB s.v. בֹּשֶׁת, כְּלִמָּה, שָׁכַב, כָּסָה, שָׁמַע
  • HALOT s.v. בֹּשֶׁת; כְּלִמָּה; נְעוּרִים
  • W. McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC)
  • L. M. Bechtel, 'Shame as a Sanction of Social Control in Biblical Israel', JSOT 49 (1991)
  • J. Stiebert, The Construction of Shame in the Hebrew Bible (2002)
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 3:25 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Jeremias 3:25

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).