Jeremiah Chapter 31 Read as one passage

Jeremiah 31:38–40

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

38“The days are coming,” declares the LORD, “when this city will be rebuilt for Me, from the tower of Hananel to the Corner Gate. 39The measuring line will once again stretch out straight to the hill of Gareb and then turn toward Goah. 40The whole valley of the dead bodies and ashes, and all the fields as far as the Kidron Valley, to the corner of the Horse Gate to the east, will be holy to the LORD. It will never again be uprooted or demolished.”

What the first hearers heard

For Judeans living through the siege and fall of Jerusalem, or through the exile that followed, this verse spoke to a concrete fear: that the city's destruction was final and that Yahweh had abandoned it. Verse 37 had just said that Israel would be rejected only if the heavens could be measured. Verse 38 answers with a measurement that can be made: the length of a real wall between two named landmarks.

It communicated:

  • Physical restoration. Not only a spiritual renewal, but walls, gates and towers, the actual fortifications they had watched fall.
  • Reversal of judgment. The same formula, verb and measuring imagery that announced ruin now announce rebuilding.
  • A changed status for the city. It would be built "for Yahweh", belonging to him, with holiness extended over the whole area, even its most defiled ground (v. 40).
  • Permanence. The unit ends: "It will never again be uprooted or overthrown" (v. 40), applying to Jerusalem the 'uproot/build' language of Jeremiah's call.

Returning exiles later read their own rebuilding in these terms. Nehemiah's account of the wall begins at the Sheep Gate and the Tower of Hananel (Neh 3:1).

From the study of Jeremiah 31:38.

Verse by verse

  1. 38“The days are coming,” declares the LORD, “when this city will be rebuilt for Me, from the tower of Hananel to the Corner Gate.

    "Look, days are on their way (this is Yahweh's own word) when the city will be built again, built for Yahweh, belonging to him. The survey line will start at the Tower of Hananel and run to the Corner Gate."

    To Jeremiah's hearers this was not vague poetry about a better future. It was a builder's description of a real wall, naming real towers and gates they had walked past, on the north side of Jerusalem: the only side not protected by deep valleys, and the side where the Babylonian siege broke through. The opening formula ("look, days are coming") was the one Jeremiah had used to announce disaster. Now it announces the reverse. The verb "built" echoes his original commission "to tear down… and to build" (1:10): the wall torn down by Babylon is the very wall that will be rebuilt. And it is rebuilt for Yahweh: no longer just a royal fortress, but a city that belongs to God. Verses 39–40 complete the picture. A measuring line, once stretched out to mark a city for destruction, now marks it out for rebuilding, all the way around, until even the defiled valley of corpses is "holy to the LORD" and the city "will never again be uprooted or overthrown."

    Full study →
  2. 39The measuring line will once again stretch out straight to the hill of Gareb and then turn toward Goah.

    "And the surveyor's cord will go out again, stretched taut and running straight ahead from the Corner Gate. It will reach the hill of Gareb, then bend around toward Goah."

    This is one stretch of a boundary walk around a future Jerusalem. Verse 38 sets the line from the Tower of Hananel, on the northeast, to the Corner Gate, on the northwest. Verse 39 carries it west and then around to the south. Verse 40 pulls the valley of corpses and ashes, the fields, and the slope down to the Kidron inside the line and declares all of it "holy to the LORD".

    The picture would have struck the first hearers hard. They had seen the LORD "stretch out the line" over Jerusalem to tear it down (2 Kings 21:13; Lamentations 2:8). Now the same measuring cord goes out to mark where the city will be rebuilt. "Again" may also carry the sense of "further": the new city may take in ground the old city left outside, including its most unclean valley.

    Gareb and Goah are named nowhere else. Their locations are lost. Their names sound like "scab" and "lowing (of cattle)", but we cannot recover what, if anything, the hearers made of that. The verse's force lies in how precise and down-to-earth it is. The promise of restoration is set out as a surveyed plot with real landmarks, not left as a vague hope.

    Full study →
  3. 40The whole valley of the dead bodies and ashes, and all the fields as far as the Kidron Valley, to the corner of the Horse Gate to the east, will be holy to the LORD. It will never again be uprooted or demolished.”

    "And the whole of that valley, the one full of corpses and greasy sacrificial ash, along with every terraced slope running down to the Kidron ravine and around to the corner of the Horse Gate on the sunrise side: all of it will be holiness belonging to Yahweh. It will never again be torn up like an uprooted plant or knocked down like a demolished wall. Not ever."

    The verse completes a surveyor's walk around the rebuilt Jerusalem (vv. 38–40), and it ends on the worst ground the city had. The "valley of the corpses and the fat-ash" was where Jeremiah had said slaughtered bodies would pile up (the Hinnom Valley and its burning-place, Topheth). It was where greasy burnt remains were dumped. The Kidron slopes were where reforming kings had burned idols. By purity law this was the most defiling ground in the land, the place of corpses and refuse, kept outside anything holy.

    Yet over this ground God writes the same words that were engraved on the high priest's golden forehead plate: "Holiness to Yahweh." The edges of the city, and not only the temple, now belong to God as his set-apart possession. Then comes a guarantee in the words of Jeremiah's own calling. He was sent "to pluck up and to tear down … to build and to plant" (1:10). The plucking up and tearing down are now declared finished for good.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v38

    The days are coming

    hinneh yamim ba'im

    What we hear
    A prediction about the far-off end of history or the final age.
    What they heard
    A stock prophetic formula announcing a decisive turn God is bringing, with no fixed timetable. Jeremiah uses it for near-term judgment as well as for restoration.
  • in v39

    compass about (KJV)

    wənāsav (sāvav)

    What we hear
    A reader may think of the navigation compass, or not know what 'compass about' means at all.
    What they heard
    To turn or bend around. The boundary line changes direction and curves toward Goah.
  • in v40

    holy to the LORD

    qōdeš la-YHWH

    What we hear
    Morally pure, spiritual, or religiously special in a general devotional sense.
    What they heard
    Set apart as Yahweh's own property and brought inside the sacred zone, a status tied to the temple. The phrase repeats the inscription on the high priest's gold plate. Here it is applied to the ground most defiled by corpses.
  • in v40

    ashes

    dešen

    What we hear
    Mourning ashes ('sackcloth and ashes') or the ordinary ash of a fire.
    What they heard
    Fat-soaked ash from burnt flesh and fat on an altar: sacrificial residue that was dumped outside, or the remains of burnings at Topheth.
Every word
  1. הִנֵּה

    hinneh · H2009

    look!, behold · v38

    An attention-grabber that points the hearer at something about to come into view. It opens the oracle like a hand pointing at the horizon.

  2. יָמִים

    yamim · H3117

    days · v38

    'Days' in the sense of a coming period of time, not a specific calendar date. With the next word it forms Jeremiah's stock phrase for a turning point God is bringing.

  3. בָּאִים

    ba'im · H935

    coming, arriving · v38

    A participle (an ongoing '-ing' verb form): the days are already on their way. In this verse the word is supplied by the scribal reading tradition rather than written in the consonantal text (see textual notes).

  4. נְאֻם־

    ne'um · H5002

    utterance, declaration · v38

    The prophet's signature tag marking what follows as Yahweh's own spoken word, not the prophet's opinion. English 'declares the LORD' / 'saith the LORD' captures it.

  5. יְהוָה

    YHWH · H3068

    Yahweh (the LORD) · v38, v40

    The personal name of Israel's God, rendered 'the LORD' in most English Bibles. He is the speaker of the promise.

  6. וְנִבְנְתָה

    venivnetah · H1129

    and it will be built · v38

    A passive future: 'and it shall be built'. The verb covers both first building and rebuilding; spoken to a city facing or already in ruins, it plainly means rebuilding. The builder is not named, but the next word says whom the city is for.

  7. הָעִיר

    ha'ir · H5892

    the city · v38

    'The city', which in Jeremiah's context needs no name: Jerusalem. BSB's 'this city' makes it explicit; the Hebrew simply says 'the city'.

  8. מִמִּגְדַּל

    mimmigdal · H4026

    from the tower of · v38

    'From the tower of…': the starting point of a survey line along the wall. A migdal is a fortified tower built into a city wall.

  9. חֲנַנְאֵל

    Chanan'el · H2606

    Hananel ('God has been gracious') · v38

    A known tower on Jerusalem's northern wall (Neh 3:1; 12:39; Zech 14:10), probably near the northeast corner by the Temple area. The name means 'God has shown favor', though the verse does not play on it.

  10. שַׁעַר

    sha'ar · H8179

    gate (of) · v38, v40

    A city gate, the fortified entryway that was also where legal and civic business happened. Here it is the endpoint of the survey line.

  11. הַפִּנָּה

    happinnah · H6438

    the corner · v38, v40

    'The Corner (Gate)', a gate at a corner of the wall, probably the northwest (2 Kgs 14:13; 2 Chr 26:9; Zech 14:10). Together with Hananel it marks out the whole northern line of the wall.

  12. וְיָצָ֨א

    wəyātsāʾ · H3318

    go out, come out · v39

    'And it will go out.' The verb form points to the future and carries on the promise of v. 38 ('the city will be rebuilt'). It pictures a surveyor's cord being paid out from a fixed point and run across the ground.

  13. ע֜וֹד

    ʿôd · H5750

    still, again, further · v39, v40

    It can mean 'again', so that the line is laid out once more as it was before the city fell. It can also mean 'further', so that the line goes on beyond the point just named. Translations split between 'once again' (BSB) and 'further/farther' (WEB, ESV, NASB).

  14. קָ֤ו

    qāw (ketiv qāwēh) · H6957

    line, cord · v39

    A cord stretched out to mark straight lines and distances in building or surveying. In Jeremiah's world the same image could mean building up or tearing down (see studies).

  15. הַמִּדָּה֙

    hammiddāh · H4060

    measure, measurement · v39

    'The measure.' Joined to the previous word it makes 'the line of the measure', that is, the measuring line. The word is used for the measured size of buildings, walls and land.

  16. נֶגְדּ֔וֹ

    negdô · H5048

    in front of, opposite · v39

    'In front of it / straight ahead of it.' The line runs straight forward, probably from the Corner Gate named in v. 38. KJV's 'over against it' keeps the literal 'opposite'. Modern versions render the direction as 'straight'.

  17. עַ֖ל

    ʿal · H5921

    upon, over, to · v39

    Marks where the line reaches: 'to' or 'over' the hill, perhaps running across its top.

  18. גִּבְעַ֣ת

    givʿat · H1389

    hill · v39

    'Hill of.' A rounded rise of ground, here a named landmark on the edge of Jerusalem.

  19. גָּרֵ֑ב

    gārēv · H1619

    Gareb (place name) · v39

    A hill named only here. Where it was is unknown. The name sounds like the Hebrew word for a scabby skin disease, which has led to guesses (unprovable) that it lay outside the city where unclean people lived.

  20. וְנָסַ֖ב

    wənāsav · H5437

    turn, go around · v39

    'And it will turn' or 'go around.' The boundary changes direction at this point. The line is tracing a loop around the city, not a single straight stretch.

  21. גֹּעָֽתָה׃

    gōʿātāh · H1601

    Goah (place name) · v39

    'Toward Goah.' The ending -āh means 'toward'. Goah appears nowhere else and its location is unknown. The name looks like a verb meaning 'to low' (the sound cattle make).

  22. וְכָל־

    wəkhol · H3605

    and all, the whole · v40

    'And the whole of…' This opens the last stretch of the boundary list in vv. 38–40. 'All' insists that not one corner of the ground is left out.

  23. הָעֵמֶק

    hāʿēmeq · H6010

    valley, broad lowland · v40

    'The valley.' This is almost certainly the Hinnom Valley south and southwest of Jerusalem, which Jeremiah had already renamed 'the Valley of Slaughter' (7:32; 19:6). The Hebrew puts 'the' on a word that is linked to the words after it, which is unusual. It reads like 'the valley, the one of corpses and ash'.

  24. הַפְּגָרִים

    happəgārîm · H6297

    corpses, carcasses · v40

    'The corpses.' The word is used for bodies of the slain, often left unburied and dishonoured. It names the place by what lay there: the dead of judgment that Jeremiah foretold in 7:32–33 and 19:6–7.

  25. וְהַדֶּשֶׁן

    wəhaddešen · H1880

    fat; fat-soaked ash · v40

    'And the fatty ash.' This is the greasy ash left from burning animal flesh and fat. The word belongs to altars and sacrifice, not to mourning. Here it marks a place where burnt remains were dumped or where burning rites happened.

  26. הַשְּׁדֵמוֹת

    haššədēmôt · H7709

    terraced fields, cultivated slopes · v40

    'The terraced fields.' These are cultivated plots, often vineyards, on the hillsides. In 2 Kings 23:4 King Josiah burned idolatrous objects 'in the shedemot of Kidron', so these slopes were remembered as a place where unclean things were burned and dumped. The written consonants read hasseremot (see textual notes).

  27. עַד־

    ʿad · H5704

    as far as, up to · v40

    'As far as.' It marks the outer edge of the area being claimed.

  28. נַחַל

    naḥal · H5158

    wadi, seasonal stream-valley · v40

    'The wadi of.' This is a ravine with a stream bed that runs only in the rainy season. It is not a year-round brook.

  29. קִדְרוֹן

    qidrôn · H6939

    Kidron · v40

    The valley along the east side of Jerusalem, between the city and the Mount of Olives. The name probably comes from a root meaning 'dark'. Kings who reformed worship destroyed idols there (1 Kgs 15:13; 2 Kgs 23:4, 6, 12).

  30. הַסּוּסִים

    hassûsîm · H5483

    horses · v40

    'The horses': the Horse Gate. It was on the east side near the temple and the palace (Neh 3:28; compare 2 Kgs 11:16). It was probably where royal horses were brought in.

  31. מִזְרָחָה

    mizrāḥāh · H4217

    toward the sunrise, eastward · v40

    'Eastward.' The word means 'toward where the sun rises'. It places the Horse Gate on the eastern line and closes the circuit of the boundary.

  32. קֹדֶשׁ

    qōdeš · H6944

    holiness, a holy thing · v40

    'Holiness', and it is a noun, not an adjective. The whole area becomes something holy, set apart as God's own property. It is the same wording as the inscription on the high priest's gold plate (Exod 28:36).

  33. לֹא־

    lōʾ · H3808

    not · v40

    A plain, firm 'not'. It begins the guarantee.

  34. יִנָּתֵשׁ

    yinnātēš · H5428

    be uprooted, pulled up · v40

    'It will be uprooted.' This is the first verb of Jeremiah's call in 1:10 ('to pluck up'). The picture is of a plant torn out of the ground, and here it is ruled out for good. The verb is masculine, so 'it' most naturally means the whole area just described, not 'the city', which is a feminine word in Hebrew.

  35. יֵהָרֵס

    yēhārēs · H2040

    be torn down, overthrown · v40

    'It will be torn down.' This verb is also in Jeremiah's call (1:10, 'to overthrow'). The picture changes from a plant to a building or wall being demolished.

  36. לְעוֹלָם

    ləʿôlām · H5769

    for perpetuity, for all time · v40

    'For all time to come.' With 'not … again' it means 'never, from now on'. The point is that this will last with no end in sight.

The world behind it

When and where. Jeremiah 30–33 is often called the "Book of Consolation": a block of promises of restoration placed in the middle of a book mostly about judgment. Chapter 32 is explicitly set during the Babylonian siege of Jerusalem (588–586 BC), when Jeremiah was in custody and bought a field as a sign that "houses and fields will again be bought in this land" (32:15). Verses 38–40 belong to that horizon: a city about to be, or already, broken open.

Why the north wall. Jerusalem sat on ridges bounded on the east by the Kidron valley and on the west and south by the Hinnom valley. Only the north lay open on fairly level ground, so it was where the city was most vulnerable and most heavily fortified. The Tower of Hananel (probably near the northeast, by the Temple) and the Corner Gate (probably northwest) mark out exactly this stretch. Starting there means starting at the wound.

Measuring as a sign. Verse 39 continues with a "measuring line". In Israel's prophetic imagery, a line could be stretched over a city to mark it for demolition: "I will stretch over Jerusalem the line of Samaria" (2 Kgs 21:13), and "the LORD determined to lay in ruins the wall of the daughter of Zion; he stretched out the measuring line" (Lam 2:8). Here the same surveyor's act marks the city out for building, a deliberate reversal.

Holiness spreading outward. In Israel's purity system, holiness was concentrated in the Temple, and corpses and refuse made places unclean. Verse 40 names the "valley of the dead bodies and the ashes" (the Hinnom area, which Jeremiah had linked to child sacrifice and slaughter, 7:31–32; 19:6) and declares it "holy to the LORD". The phrase "for Yahweh" in verse 38 is the first step toward that claim.

From the study of Jeremiah 31:38.

Where scholars differ

in v38

Where exactly were the Tower of Hananel and the Corner Gate, and what part of the city does the line describe?

  • The line runs along the north wall, from the northeast (Hananel, near the Temple and Sheep Gate) to the northwest (Corner Gate).

    Neh 3:1 and 12:39 place Hananel beside the Sheep Gate near the Temple. 2 Kgs 14:13 links the Corner Gate with the Ephraim Gate, which faced north. Zech 14:10 pairs the two as boundary points. This is the most widely held reconstruction.

  • The exact positions cannot be fixed, and the Corner Gate may have been on the west or another corner.

    No gate has been securely identified archaeologically by these names. Jerusalem's walls changed between the monarchy and Nehemiah, and the 'hill of Gareb' and 'Goah' in v. 39 are otherwise unknown.

in v38

What fulfillment did the promise envision?

  • A historical rebuilding of Jerusalem after the exile.

    The landmarks are real pre-exilic fortifications, and Nehemiah's wall-building begins at the same point (Neh 3:1). Returning exiles understood their restoration in these terms.

  • An idealized or end-time Jerusalem that goes beyond any historical rebuilding.

    Verse 40 promises that the whole area, including the defiled valley, will be 'holy to the LORD' and 'never again uprooted', a permanence and holiness the post-exilic city did not fully see. Compare Zech 14:10–11, 20–21.

  • Christian readings that see a new Jerusalem or the people of God as the final horizon.

    The new-covenant oracle beside it (31:31–34) is applied to the church in Heb 8. Rev 21 describes a holy city with measured walls and gates. This is a later reading of the chapter's hope, not something the verse itself states.

in v39

Where were the hill of Gareb and Goah?

  • West or southwest of the city, outside the pre-exilic walls.

    The boundary runs in order from the Tower of Hananel (northeast) to the Corner Gate (northwest), then Gareb and Goah, then the Hinnom valley (south and southwest), then Kidron and the Horse Gate (east). That puts Gareb and Goah on the west and southwest. Most commentaries follow this.

  • The locations cannot be recovered at all.

    Both names occur only here and in no other ancient source. Specific modern identifications (for example, with parts of the western hill) are guesses.

in v39

Does ʿôd mean 'again' (restoring the old boundary) or 'further' (expanding it)?

  • 'Again': restoration of the city as it was.

    Jeremiah repeatedly uses ʿôd for renewal in this chapter ('again I will build you', 31:4; 'again you will plant', 31:5; 'once again they will say', 31:23). BSB, KJV and YLT read it this way.

  • 'Further/farther': the line goes on beyond the Corner Gate, possibly enlarging the city.

    The line continues from the point named in v. 38, and v. 40 takes in unclean ground (the valley of corpses) that lay outside the old city. Compare Zech 2:4, Jerusalem so large it has no walls. WEB, ESV and NASB read it this way.

in v39

Are vv. 38–40 from Jeremiah or a later addition?

  • A later addition from the exile or after.

    It is prose rather than the poetry around it, its topography resembles Nehemiah 3 and 12 and Zechariah 14:10, and it shows interest in rebuilding walls typical of the Persian period. Many critical commentators, such as Holladay and Carroll, hold this view.

  • From Jeremiah or his circle.

    It uses Jeremiah's own vocabulary ('uproot… demolish', 1:10; 31:28), names Topheth and Hinnom, which he condemned (7:31–33; 19), and fits the land purchase of ch. 32, which looks ahead to rebuilding. Defended by commentators such as Lundbom and Thompson.

in v40

Which valley is 'the valley of the corpses and the fat-ash'?

  • The Hinnom Valley and its burning-place, Topheth (majority view).

    Jeremiah repeatedly names Hinnom/Topheth as the place of child sacrifice and future mass death, the 'Valley of Slaughter' (7:31–33; 19:2–14). Pegarim and dešen fit both the predicted slaughter and the fires of Topheth. The boundary sequence (west/southwest, then the Kidron on the east) fits Hinnom's position.

  • A dump in or near the Kidron for ash from the temple altar, or a combined Hinnom–Kidron refuse area.

    Leviticus required altar ash to be taken outside to a 'clean place' (Lev 4:12; 6:11). The Kidron, just below the temple, is the obvious outlet, and Josiah burned cult objects there (2 Kgs 23:4, 6). The verse moves straight on to the Kidron terraces.

in v40

What does šedemot mean?

  • Cultivated terraces or fields, especially vineyards.

    Parallels with vines in Deut 32:32 and Isa 16:8, and with crops in Hab 3:17. This is the majority lexical view (BDB, HALOT).

  • A compound meaning 'fields of death' (šdmt = 'field of Mot', the Canaanite death-god), or a term for burial or cult fields.

    Suggested on the basis of Ugaritic šd mt and of the funerary and idolatrous settings in 2 Kgs 23:4 and here. The Vulgate's regionem mortis ('region of death') reads it in a similar way. The suggestion is debated and not widely accepted, but it would fit the verse's theme of death-ground made holy.

in v40

Is the promise about the physically rebuilt Jerusalem, or an idealised, final Jerusalem?

  • A concrete promise of rebuilding after the exile.

    The detailed, surveyable landmarks match the city's actual layout, and the Horse Gate was in fact repaired under Nehemiah (Neh 3:28).

  • An idealised or end-time vision.

    The claim that the city would never again be uprooted, and the extension of temple-level holiness to the whole city, go beyond any historical restoration. Close parallels are Zech 14:20–21 and Ezek 48, and later Rev 21:2, 27.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).