Jeremiah Chapter 37 Read as one passage
Jeremiah 37:17–21
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
17Later, King Zedekiah sent for Jeremiah and received him in his palace, where he asked him privately, “Is there a word from the LORD?” “There is,” Jeremiah replied. “You will be delivered into the hand of the king of Babylon.” 18Then Jeremiah asked King Zedekiah, “How have I sinned against you or your servants or these people, that you have put me in prison? 19Where are your prophets who prophesied to you, claiming, ‘The king of Babylon will not come against you or this land’? 20But now please listen, O my lord the king. May my petition come before you. Do not send me back to the house of Jonathan the scribe, or I will die there.” 21So King Zedekiah gave orders for Jeremiah to be placed in the courtyard of the guard and given a loaf of bread daily from the street of the bakers, until all the bread in the city was gone. So Jeremiah remained in the courtyard of the guard.
What the first hearers heard
For people who lived through or remembered the fall of Jerusalem, this scene answered a painful question: did the king not know? The narrator's answer is that he knew. He asked, in private, and was told plainly. The disaster did not come from a lack of prophetic warning or from God going silent. It came from a king who wanted God's word in secret but would not act on it in public.
The scene also sets Jeremiah's steadiness against the moment. The prisoner, fresh from a beating and a long stay in the cell, gives the king exactly the same message that put him there. He does not soften it in return for his release (he asks for better conditions only after delivering the oracle, 37:18–20). For exiles in Babylon, the account confirmed that Jeremiah was a true prophet by the standard of Deuteronomy 18:21–22: what he said happened. That in turn gave weight to his other words, including the promises of a future beyond the exile (chs. 29–33).
The irony would not have been lost on them. A king named 'YHWH is my justice' ends up as the object of YHWH's justice, 'given' like a captured city. Three uses of 'king' in one verse end with the title belonging to the king of Babylon.
From the study of Jeremiah 37:17.
Verse by verse
-
17Later, King Zedekiah sent for Jeremiah and received him in his palace, where he asked him privately, “Is there a word from the LORD?” “There is,” Jeremiah replied. “You will be delivered into the hand of the king of Babylon.”
Full study →King Zedekiah sent for Jeremiah and had him brought up out of the vaulted cells of the cistern-prison where his own officials had thrown him. In the king's own palace, out of sight of the court, the king consulted the prisoner the way kings consult a prophet: "Does any message exist, any word at all, that has come out from YHWH's presence?" He hoped that something had changed now that the Babylonian army had pulled back from the walls.
Jeremiah's answer was one word, an exact echo of the question: "There is." Then he stopped and started again (the narrator marks this with a second "and he said"), and put the weight on the first words: "Into the hand of the king of Babylon you will be handed over."
"Hand" here means power and custody. "Handed over" is passive: Zedekiah will not act but be acted upon, and the one doing the handing over is implied to be YHWH himself. He is a king whose name means "YHWH is my justice". Nebuchadnezzar had installed him, he had sworn loyalty, and then he rebelled. Now he will be returned like a captive to the overlord he betrayed. The word is not new. It is the same word he has heard before (21:7; 34:2–3), unchanged by the brief lifting of the siege.
-
18Then Jeremiah asked King Zedekiah, “How have I sinned against you or your servants or these people, that you have put me in prison?
Full study →Jeremiah has just given the king the one answer he did not want: "You will be handed over to the king of Babylon" (v. 17). Then, still a prisoner standing before the throne, he turns the question round and puts it to the king:
"What wrong have I done to you, or to your officials, or to this people here, that you, all of you, have handed me over into a house of confinement?"
Several things in the Hebrew are worth keeping:
- "Sinned" here means "wronged". The verb is the ordinary Hebrew word for failing an obligation toward someone. The people supposedly wronged are human: the king, his court, the nation. The charge Jeremiah is answering is treason: he was arrested at the city gate and accused of deserting to the Babylonians (vv. 13–14). His question is a defendant's challenge: name my crime.
- "Your servants" are the king's ministers, the same officials who beat him and locked him up (v. 15).
- The "you" shifts from one person to many. He begins "against you" (the king alone) and ends "you all have put me" (plural). The officials did it, but Zedekiah is not allowed to hide behind them.
- The "prison" was an improvised lock-up: an official's house fitted with a pit and vaulted cells, where Jeremiah was held for "many days" without trial and expected to die (vv. 16, 20).
Coming straight after an oracle that sealed the king's fate, the question carries a sharp irony. The king whose name means "YHWH is my justice" is holding an innocent man, while the prophets who promised peace walk free (v. 19).
-
19Where are your prophets who prophesied to you, claiming, ‘The king of Babylon will not come against you or this land’?
Full study →"So where are they now, those prophets of yours, the ones who stood up and spoke to you in God's name, assuring you, 'The king of Babylon will never come against you, or against this land'?"
A prisoner says this to a king. Jeremiah has been taken out of a dungeon for a secret audience with Zedekiah. Instead of begging, he asks a taunting question, the kind Israel's psalms and prophets asked about useless idols ("Where are your gods?"). 'Your prophets' is pointed. These were the court's own prophets, respected and official, who spoke in the LORD's name and told the king what he wanted to hear. Their promise was unconditional: Babylon will not come against the king and his court, nor against this land, the land God had given Israel. But Babylon had come. Its army had already surrounded Jerusalem. The question exposes the failed prophecy and defends Jeremiah, the one prophet who said otherwise and was jailed for it. By implication it asks: why am I in prison, while those proven wrong go free?
-
20But now please listen, O my lord the king. May my petition come before you. Do not send me back to the house of Jonathan the scribe, or I will die there.”
Full study →"So now, my lord the king, please hear me and do something about it. Please let my plea for mercy fall at your feet and lie there in front of you. Don't make me go back to the house of Jonathan, the royal secretary. If I go back there, I will die."
Jeremiah has just told Zedekiah the one thing the king did not want to hear, that he will be handed over to Babylon (v. 17), and he has argued that he himself did nothing wrong (vv. 18–19). Now he speaks as a subject at court. He uses the full formal title, says "please" twice, and makes his request as an appeal for favour (the Hebrew word comes from the root for "grace"), not as a demand for justice. The picture behind the words is physical. His plea is to "fall" before the king's face, as a suppliant falls to the ground. The same verb had just been thrown at him as an accusation, that he was "falling away" to the Babylonians, so this is the only kind of "falling" he will admit to. The danger is real. The "house of Jonathan the secretary" was a senior official's residence turned into a lock-up, where he had been kept in a cistern-like vaulted cell for "many days" (v. 16) under the control of officials who hated him. He is not using a figure of speech when he says "I will die there". He means it literally. The prophet who would not soften God's word asks plainly and humbly not to be sent back to his death.
-
21So King Zedekiah gave orders for Jeremiah to be placed in the courtyard of the guard and given a loaf of bread daily from the street of the bakers, until all the bread in the city was gone. So Jeremiah remained in the courtyard of the guard.
Full study →King Zedekiah gave a royal order, and his men formally handed Jeremiah into the custody of the palace guard. He was taken out of the deadly underground cells of Jonathan the scribe's house and moved to the guarded courtyard of the royal complex. It was an enclosed yard open to the sky. He was still a prisoner, but he was under the king's protection and within sight and hearing of others. The order also set a standing daily ration: one round, flat loaf of bread, a single person's portion for the day, drawn from the bakers' quarter, the lane where the city's professional bakers worked their ovens. The ration had a grim limit. It would continue until all the bread in the city was used up. Jerusalem was under Babylonian siege, and the narrator knows what Jeremiah had predicted: the bread would run out completely (52:6). So the prophet's small daily loaf was tied to the city's dying food supply. He would eat as long as Jerusalem could eat. The verse closes where it began: and Jeremiah stayed there, in the court of the guard. That place would hold him until the city fell (38:28).
Where the English drifted
-
in v17
delivered into the hand
tinnaten beyad
- What we hear
- In church language 'delivered' usually means 'rescued, set free', so 'you will be delivered' can briefly sound like good news.
- What they heard
- Handed over, surrendered into an enemy's custody and power. It is the language of capture in war.
-
in v17
the LORD
YHWH
- What we hear
- A title meaning 'master' or simply 'God'.
- What they heard
- The personal name of Israel's God, the God whose name is built into both 'Zedekiah' and 'Jeremiah'.
-
in v18
sinned
chata
- What we hear
- An offence against God or a religious moral failing.
- What they heard
- To wrong someone, to fail an obligation toward a person. Here it means committing an offence against the king, his officials and the nation, specifically the treason charge of desertion.
-
in v18
your servants
avadekha
- What we hear
- Household staff or attendants waiting on the king.
- What they heard
- The king's officials and ministers, the senior court figures who had arrested and beaten Jeremiah.
-
in v18
prison
beit hakkele
- What we hear
- A state penitentiary where convicted criminals serve a sentence.
- What they heard
- A 'house of confinement': here an official's private house made into a holding place, with a pit and cells, used for detention without trial.
-
in v19
your prophets
nəbîʾêkem
- What we hear
- Obvious charlatans or pagan fortune-tellers, clearly outside the true faith.
- What they heard
- Recognised, official prophets who spoke in the name of Israel's God and were trusted by the king, court and people. Their offence was a false message, not belonging to a different religion.
-
in v20
the scribe
hassofer
- What we hear
- A copyist who writes documents for others, or one of the 'scribes' (Torah scholars) known from the Gospels.
- What they heard
- The royal secretary, one of the king's senior officials, with a house large enough to be used as a detention site.
-
in v20
petition
techinnah
- What we hear
- A formal written request or document submitted through official channels.
- What they heard
- A humble plea for favour or mercy (from the root for 'grace'), asked of someone who is free to refuse. It was usually spoken and was accompanied by bodily humility.
-
in v21
court of the prison (KJV, YLT)
chatsar hammattarah
- What we hear
- A prison yard or cell block, total isolation behind bars.
-
in v21
a piece of bread (KJV)
kikkar lechem
- What we hear
- A scrap or crust of bread.
- What they heard
- A whole round, flat loaf, a standard individual daily portion. Modest, but not a scrap.
Every word
-
וַיִּשְׁלַח֩
vayyishlach · H7971G
and he sent · v17
With no object stated, the verb means 'sent for (someone)'. The king starts the meeting. Jeremiah has sat in the cell 'many days' (v.16) and does not come on his own.
-
הַמֶּ֨לֶךְ
hammelekh · H4428G
the king · v17, v18, v19, v20, v21
Zedekiah's title comes first. The narrator stresses that the man with royal authority is the one who has to ask the prisoner for help.
-
צִדְקִיָּ֜הוּ
tsidqiyyahu · H6667H
Zedekiah · v17, v18, v21
The name means 'YHWH is my righteousness / my justice'. Nebuchadnezzar gave him this throne name when he installed him as a vassal king in 597 BC (2 Kings 24:17).
-
וַיִּקָּחֵ֗הוּ
vayyiqqachehu · H3947H
and he took him · v17
He had Jeremiah fetched, which means taken out of the cell in Jonathan's house (v.15–16). KJV's 'took him out' brings out what is implied. BSB's 'received him' softens a verb that means physically bringing him.
-
וַיִּשְׁאָלֵ֨הוּ
vayyish'alehu · H7592
and he asked him · v17
This is the ordinary verb for asking, and it is also the standard word for consulting a prophet or God for an answer (an oracle).
-
בְּבֵיתוֹ֙
beveito · H1004P
in his house · v17, v18, v20
'His house' is the royal palace complex. The interview happens on the king's own ground, away from the officials' court.
-
בַּסֵּ֔תֶר
basseter · H5643A
in secret · v17
'In the hiding place / in concealment'. The meeting is kept from the royal officials who had Jeremiah beaten and jailed (v.15). Compare 38:24–27, where Zedekiah again insists on secrecy.
-
וַיֹּ֕אמֶר
vayyomer · H0559
and he said · v17, v18, v19
This introduces the king's direct question.
-
הֲיֵ֥שׁ
hayesh · H3426
is there? · v17
The question marker ha- plus yesh ('there is, there exists'). This is a yes/no question: does a message exist at all?
-
דָּבָ֖ר
davar · H1697G
word, message, matter · v17
An oracle, meaning a specific message from God for this situation. It does not mean a written text. With no article it means 'any word at all', and KJV and WEB add 'any' to show this.
-
מֵאֵ֣ת
me'et · H0854
from with · v17
'From beside, from the presence of'. The word comes out from YHWH's own presence and is not Jeremiah's opinion.
-
יְהוָ֑ה
YHWH · H3068G
YHWH (the LORD) · v17
The personal name of Israel's God. The king asks about the God of Judah by name, the same God his own name invokes.
-
יִרְמְיָ֙הוּ֙
yirmeyahu · H3414L
Jeremiah · v17, v18, v21
The prisoner is now named and holds the floor.
-
בְּיַ֥ד
beyad · H3027H
into the hand of · v17
'Hand' means power and control. To be 'given into the hand' of someone is the stock phrase for being surrendered to an enemy's power, as in war or legal custody. It is placed first for emphasis.
-
בָּבֶ֖ל
bavel · H0894
Babylon · v17, v19
Nebuchadnezzar II's empire. Its army had pulled back from Jerusalem only for a short time (37:5–11).
-
תִּנָּתֵֽן
tinnaten · H5414G
you will be given · v17, v18, v21
A passive verb ('you will be given / handed over'), addressed to Zedekiah himself and set in the future. It does not say who hands him over, but the oracle form implies God. The king is the object, not the actor.
-
אֶל־
el · H0413
to · v18
Marks who is being spoken to. The protest goes straight to the king.
-
מֶה֩
meh · H4100
what? · v18
This opens a set formula of protest, 'What have I done wrong?' It works as a challenge: name the offence, if there is one. It assumes the answer 'nothing'.
-
חָטָ֨אתִֽי
chatati · H2398
I have sinned / done wrong · v18
'Have I wronged', meaning failed in an obligation or committed an offence against a person. Here the injured party would be the king, his court and the people, not God. In context the charge Jeremiah is rejecting is treason by desertion (vv. 13–14).
-
לְךָ֤
lekha · H9031
to/against you · v18
'Against you (singular)', the king himself. With this verb, the preposition marks the person who was wronged.
-
וְלַעֲבָדֶ֙יךָ֙
vela'avadekha · H5650
and to your servants · v18
The king's officials, his ministers and courtiers, not household help. These are the very officials (sarim, v. 15) who beat Jeremiah and locked him up.
-
וְלָעָ֣ם
vela'am · H5971
and to the people · v18
The population of Judah and Jerusalem as a body. Together with the king and the officials it covers the whole community Jeremiah is accused of betraying.
-
הַזֶּ֔ה
hazzeh · H2088
this · v18
'This people': the people right here, now under siege. Elsewhere in Jeremiah God often uses the phrase with a distancing edge. In Jeremiah's mouth here it simply points to the besieged population.
-
כִּֽי־
ki · H3588
that · v18
Introduces the result that needs explaining: 'that you should have…'. The logic runs: what offence could justify this treatment?
-
אוֹתִ֖י
oti · H0853
me · v18, v21
A grammatical marker carrying 'me' as the object. Jeremiah is the one handed over and put away.
-
הַכֶּֽלֶא׃
hakkele · H3608
-
וְאַיֵּה֙
wəʾayyēh · H0346
and where? · v19
Opens a rhetorical, taunting question. Jeremiah isn't asking for their address. He is pointing out that the prophets' prediction has failed and they are nowhere to be found.
-
נְבִ֣יאֵיכֶ֔ם
nəbîʾêkem · H5030
-
אֲשֶׁר־
ʾăšer · H0834A
who, which · v19
Relative particle introducing what identifies these prophets: their failed message.
-
נִבְּא֥וּ
nibbəʾû · H5012
to prophesy · v19
'They prophesied': they spoke formally as God's mouthpieces, in his name. Jeremiah grants that they claimed the prophetic role and gave real oracles.
-
לָכֶ֖ם
lākem · H9036
to you · v19
'To you' (plural). It carries a hint of 'for you': a message suited to what king and court wanted to hear.
-
לֹֽא־
lōʾ · H3808
not · v19, v20
Flat negation. The prophets' message was a confident 'he will not come', with no conditions.
-
יָבֹ֤א
yābōʾ · H0935G
come, enter · v19
'He will come.' Combined with 'upon' it means coming in hostile force: invading or attacking.
-
עֲלֵיכֶ֔ם
ʿălêkem · H5921A
upon, against · v19
'Against you' (plural). In this phrase the preposition is hostile: the king and leaders themselves as the target.
-
הָאָ֥רֶץ
hāʾāreṣ · H0776G
land, earth · v19
'The land', meaning the territory of Judah, the land Israel held as God's gift. Here it is not the planet.
-
הַזֹּֽאת׃
hazzōʾt · H2063
this · v19
'This land', the ground they stand on. Its safety was what the false prophets promised.
-
וְעַתָּה
ve'attah · H6258
and now · v20
Marks the turn from argument to request. Jeremiah has just argued his innocence (vv. 18–19); 'and now' brings in what he actually wants, as letters and petitions of the period did.
-
שְׁמַע־
shema' · H8085
hear, listen, heed · v20
A command addressed to the king, softened by 'please'. It means more than letting sound reach the ear: listen and act on it. The narrator has already said that Zedekiah did not 'listen' to the LORD's words (37:2), so this is ironic.
-
נָא
na' · H4994
please, I pray · v20
A particle of entreaty that turns the command into a respectful, urgent request. It comes twice in this verse, which shows how earnestly he is pleading.
-
אֲדֹנִי
adoni · H113
my lord, my master · v20
The normal polite address of an inferior to a superior, here a subject to his king. It is not a title for God. The prophet keeps to court protocol even toward a king he has just told will be handed over to Babylon.
-
תִּפָּל־
tippol · H5307
fall · v20
'May it fall'. This is part of an idiom: a plea 'falls before' the person asked, as the person pleading would fall face-down before him. The narrator has just used the same verb when Jeremiah was accused of 'falling' (deserting) to the Babylonians (37:13–14).
-
תְחִנָּתִי
techinnati · H8467
my supplication, my plea for favour · v20
The noun comes from the root ḥ-n-n, 'show favour, be gracious'. It is a request for something he cannot claim by right and asks as a kindness from someone with power over him.
-
לְפָנֶיךָ
lefaneikha · H6440
before you (lit. to your face) · v20
Literally 'to your face'. The plea is to land in the king's presence, in front of him, where he cannot overlook it.
-
וְאַל־
ve'al · H408
and do not · v20
The negative used for a particular, immediate request or prohibition, not a general rule: 'please don't'.
-
תְּשִׁבֵנִי
teshiveni · H7725
make me return, send me back · v20
A causative form: 'cause me to go back'. The king holds the power to send him back. Jeremiah is under guard and cannot choose where he goes.
-
יְהוֹנָתָן
Yehonatan · H3083
Jonathan ('YHWH has given') · v20
The royal secretary whose house served as Jeremiah's prison. He is known only from this episode.
-
הַסֹּפֵר
hassofer · H5608
the scribe, the secretary · v20
The title of a senior royal official, the king's secretary. He was a powerful member of the court, not a humble copyist.
-
אָמוּת
amut · H4191
-
שָׁם
sham · H8033
there · v20
Points back to Jonathan's house. The verse closes on the place he fears.
-
וַיְצַוֶּ֞ה
vayetsavveh · H6680
and he commanded · v21
A royal order. The verb has no object, so the narrative moves straight to what was done: the king speaks and his men act.
-
וַיַּפְקִ֣דוּ
vayyafqidu · H6485
and they committed / deposited · v21
This form of paqad means 'to hand over into someone's keeping', the way a valuable is deposited. Jeremiah is moved into official custody. 'They' is impersonal: the king's servants.
-
בַּחֲצַ֣ר
bachatsar · H2691
in the court of · v21
An enclosed courtyard, open to the sky. This is not an underground cell or a pit.
-
הַמַּטָּרָה֒
hammattarah · H4307
the guard / watch · v21
From the root 'to watch, keep'. It means the guard post or guarded area, part of the royal palace complex (Neh 3:25).
-
ל֨וֹ
lo
to him · v21
Jeremiah is the person who receives the ration.
-
כִכַּר־
kikkar- · H3603
round (loaf) of · v21
Literally 'a round thing'. Joined to 'bread' it means a flat, round loaf: one person's basic daily portion.
-
לֶ֤חֶם
lechem · H3899
bread · v21
Bread, the staple food. Its supply is the measure of the city's survival in this verse.
-
לַיּוֹם֙
layyom · H3117
per day · v21
'For the day', meaning a daily allowance. This is the language of rations.
-
מִח֣וּץ
michuts · H2351
from the street of · v21
Chuts means 'outside', and from that a public street or market lane.
-
הָאֹפִ֔ים
ha'ofim · H0644
the bakers · v21
A participle, 'those who bake', used as a noun. The bakers' street was a trade quarter where commercial bakers worked.
-
עַד־
ad- · H5704
until · v21
Sets the limit of the provision. The ration lasts only as long as the city's food does.
-
תֹּ֥ם
tom · H8552
the finishing of · v21
An infinitive: 'the coming to an end'. The bread will run out entirely, and the narrator knows it (52:6).
-
כָּל־
kol- · H3605
all · v21
Total. Not a shortage but complete exhaustion.
-
מִן־
min- · H4480
from · v21
'From the city': the bread disappears out of Jerusalem.
-
הָעִ֑יר
ha'ir · H5892
the city · v21
Jerusalem under Babylonian siege.
-
וַיֵּ֣שֶׁב
vayyeshev · H3427
and he sat / stayed · v21
Yashav means 'sit, dwell, stay'. It sums up Jeremiah's condition: he stayed put there.
The world behind it
When: about 588–587 BC, during Nebuchadnezzar's final siege of Jerusalem. An Egyptian army under Pharaoh Hophra (Apries) had marched north, and the Babylonians temporarily lifted the siege to meet it (37:5, 11). Many in Jerusalem took this as rescue. Jeremiah said the Babylonians would come back and burn the city (37:6–10).
Why Jeremiah was in prison: during the lull he tried to leave the city to deal with family land in Benjamin (37:12; compare ch. 32). An officer arrested him for deserting to the Babylonians. The royal officials (sarim) beat him and locked him in the house of Jonathan the secretary, which had been made into a prison with an underground cistern and vaulted cells (37:13–16).
Why secrecy: power in Zedekiah's court lay largely with these officials, a pro-Egyptian, anti-Babylonian party. Zedekiah is shown as weak and afraid of them (38:5, 19, 24–27). Consulting the man they considered a traitor had to be done off the record. One of the Lachish letters, military letters from Judah in this same period, complains of words that 'weaken the hands' of the people. That is the same charge the officials bring against Jeremiah in 38:4, and it shows how such speech was viewed in wartime (the link is in vocabulary, not a reference to Jeremiah himself).
Zedekiah's position: Nebuchadnezzar had placed him on the throne in 597 BC in place of his nephew Jehoiachin, renamed him from Mattaniah, and bound him by an oath sworn in YHWH's name (2 Kings 24:17; Ezek 17:13–19; 2 Chr 36:13). His rebellion broke a sworn treaty. 'Into the hand of the king of Babylon' is therefore not a random defeat. It means the vassal is returned to the lord whose oath he broke.
What happened: Zedekiah fled when the wall was breached, was caught in the plains of Jericho, and was brought to Nebuchadnezzar at Riblah. He saw his sons killed, was blinded, and was taken to Babylon in chains (39:4–7; 52:7–11; compare Ezek 12:13).
From the study of Jeremiah 37:17.
Where scholars differ
in v17
Are the secret meetings in Jeremiah 37:17–21 and 38:14–28 two separate events, or two versions of one meeting?
-
Two separate events in sequence
The narrative presents them in order. After ch. 37 Jeremiah is moved to the court of the guard (37:21). The officials then have him thrown into a muddy cistern (38:6), and he is rescued by Ebed-melech before the second meeting at the temple's third entrance (38:14). The settings, the details and the content of the conversations differ. A frightened king consulting a prophet more than once is entirely plausible.
-
Parallel accounts of a single meeting
The two scenes share a striking set of features: a cistern-prison, a secret royal summons, the same oracle, and above all Jeremiah's plea not to be sent back to 'the house of Jonathan' (37:20), which reappears as the cover story in 38:26. Some scholars think the editors combined two traditions about one interview.
in v18
Was Jeremiah's protest of innocence entirely fair, given his public message urging surrender?
-
He was innocent of the specific charge brought against him.
The arrest was for desertion (37:13). Jeremiah called this a lie (37:14). He was going to Benjamin on family business during a lull in the siege (37:12). The narrator presents the charge as false, and the formula 'What have I done?' is the language of a wrongly accused person.
-
From the officials' point of view, his preaching gave real grounds for suspicion.
He publicly told people that those who went out to the Chaldeans would live (21:9; 38:2). The officials later said he was 'weakening the hands of the soldiers' (38:4). Defections did happen (38:19; 39:9). Scholars such as Holladay and Lundbom note that the officials' fear was understandable, even if the specific charge was false and the treatment unjust.
in v18
Are Jeremiah 37:11–21 and 38:1–28 two accounts of one imprisonment, or two separate episodes?
-
Two versions of the same event.
Both have imprisonment in a pit or cistern, a secret meeting with Zedekiah, Jeremiah's fear of dying in Jonathan's house, and transfer to the court of the guard (37:20–21; 38:26). Some critical scholars, following older source analysis, see parallel traditions.
-
Sequential episodes.
The text as it stands places them in order. Jeremiah is in the court of the guard at the start of ch. 38 (38:1, 13), having been moved there in 37:21. The cisterns are different (Jonathan's house vs. Malchiah's cistern). 38:26 has Jeremiah cite his request from 37:20 as a cover story, which presupposes the earlier episode. Many commentators (e.g. Bright, Lundbom) read them as consecutive.
in v20
Are Jeremiah 37:11–21 and chapter 38 two separate imprisonments or two tellings of one event?
-
Two successive episodes: first Jonathan's house, then the court of the guard, then Malchiah's cistern, then the court of the guard again.
38:26 explicitly refers back to the request in 37:20. In 38:6 Jeremiah is moved from the court of the guard, where 37:21 left him, into a different cistern (Malchiah's). The narrative reads as a continuous sequence.
-
Parallel or overlapping accounts of a single arrest and rescue, later arranged in sequence.
Both chapters feature a hostile arrest, a cistern-like prison, a secret interview with Zedekiah, the same message (surrender to Babylon), and both end with 'Jeremiah remained in the court of the guard' (37:21; 38:28). Some commentators take these repeated elements as signs of two traditions about one event.
in v20
Why did Jeremiah expect to die in Jonathan's house?
-
Physical conditions: the underground cell and siege shortages.
37:16 describes a 'cistern-house' with vaulted cells where he stayed 'many days'. 37:21 shows food was rationed and running out, and 38:6–9 shows how quickly a man could perish in a cistern.
-
Hostile custody: the officials who held him wanted him dead.
The officials beat him (37:15). In 38:4 they ask the king to put him to death for weakening morale. Jonathan himself was one of the court officials. The two explanations can both be true.
in v21
Are Jeremiah 37:11–21 and 38:1–28 one sequence of events or two accounts of the same imprisonment?
-
Two parallel accounts of a single episode, later placed one after the other.
Both stories involve arrest by officials, a cistern, rescue, a secret interview with Zedekiah, and an ending in the court of the guard. In 38:26 Jeremiah is told to say he had begged not to be returned to Jonathan's house, which is exactly the request of 37:20. Several critical commentators take this as a doublet (the same story told twice).
-
A real sequence: Jeremiah is moved to the court of the guard (37:21), then thrown by the princes into a cistern inside that court (38:6), then rescued back to the court (38:13).
38:6 explicitly places Malchiah's cistern 'in the court of the guard', which fits the move in 37:21. 38:26 can be read as Zedekiah telling Jeremiah to repeat his earlier, real petition as a cover story. Commentators such as Lundbom read the chapters in sequence.
Sources
- BDB and HALOT s.v. דָּבָר, סֵתֶר, יָד, נָתַן, שָׁאַל
- Supplied STEP/TAHOT morphological data (lemma, Strong's, morphology)
- William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia)
- Jack R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 37–52 (Anchor Bible)
- John Bright, Jeremiah (Anchor Bible)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 37
- Lachish Ostraca (Letters 3, 4, 6), as discussed in standard Jeremiah commentaries
- Septuagint, Jer 44:17; Vulgate, Jer 37:17
- BDB s.v. חָטָא
- HALOT s.v. חטא; s.v. כֶּלֶא
- HALOT s.v. עֶבֶד
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia)
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 37–52 (Anchor Bible)
- J. Bright, Jeremiah (Anchor Bible)
- Rahlfs, Septuaginta, Jeremias 44:18
- Walton, Matthews & Chavalas, IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 37
- Supplied source text with morphology (OSIS Jer.37.18)
- BDB s.v. אַיֵּה; HALOT s.v. אַיֵּה, אַיּוֹ
- HALOT s.v. נָבִיא
- BDB s.v. בּוֹא (with עַל, of hostile coming)
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, Ketiv/Qere note at Jer 37:19
- Lachish Ostraca (Letter 3), c. 588 BC
- Lundbom, Jeremiah 37–52 (Anchor Bible)
- BDB s.v. תְּחִנָּה, נָפַל, סֹפֵר
- HALOT s.v. תְּחִנָּה; s.v. נָא
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jeremiah 37
- Yavneh-Yam (Meṣad Ḥashavyahu) ostracon, late 7th c. BC (KAI 200)
- Lachish ostraca (c. 588 BC), epistolary formulae
- Septuagint Jeremiah 44:20 (Ziegler, Göttingen edition)
- BDB s.v. פָּקַד, מַטָּרָה, כִּכָּר, חוּץ
- HALOT s.v. פקד (Hiphil: 'entrust, deposit'), מַטָּרָה, כִּכָּר
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 37–52 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- W. McKane, Jeremiah (ICC), vol. 2
- P. J. King & L. E. Stager, Life in Biblical Israel (bread, baking, urban quarters)
- Arad ostraca (Eliashib archive), ration texts, c. 600 BC
- Septuagint Jeremiah 44:21; Vulgate Jeremiah 37
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).