John Chapter 2 Read as one passage
John 2:3–5
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
3When the wine ran out, Jesus’ mother said to Him, “They have no more wine.” 4“Woman, what is that to you and to Me?” Jesus replied. “My hour has not yet come.” 5His mother said to the servants, “Do whatever He tells you.”
What the first hearers heard
John's first readers would have heard a familiar village crisis: a wedding feast was going under, and a family's honour with it. They would also notice that the first of Jesus' "signs" (2:11) begins in a home and at a celebration, with a shortage of the very thing that stood for joy. They would not have expected that to be the setting.
Mary's words would have read as a respectful but clear appeal. She takes the problem to the one person she believes can deal with it and leaves the solution to him. Jesus' guarded reply (v.4) and her calm instruction to the servants (v.5) show the reader both her confidence in him and that he acts on his own terms.
Readers who knew Scripture would also hear a hint in "they have no wine." Israel's prophets had promised that God's coming age would arrive with abundant wine and a wedding-like feast. As the story goes on, Jesus fills the jars that held water for Jewish purification rites with superb wine in huge quantity, so the shortage in this verse sets up the abundance he brings. John calls the result a revelation of Jesus' "glory" that led his disciples to trust him (2:11).
From the study of John 2:3.
Verse by verse
-
3When the wine ran out, Jesus’ mother said to Him, “They have no more wine.”
Full study →And with the feast still going, the wine gave out. The supply the hosts were bound to provide had fallen short. Jesus' mother comes to him and says, "Wine — they have none."
The Greek opens with a background phrase, "the wine having fallen short." Jesus' mother is the one who notices, and she takes the problem straight to her son. John tells it in the present tense ("she says"), which makes the moment feel immediate. She puts "wine" first for emphasis and states the problem in four words without asking for anything. In this setting the statement is itself the request, much like Martha and Mary later sending word, "the one you love is sick" (John 11:3).
The first hearers would have known what was at stake. A wedding feast could last a week. The groom's family had to keep the guests supplied, and if the wine failed, the family would be publicly shamed and the celebration would end in the middle. Wine also stood for joy itself, and the prophets used overflowing wine as the sign of the day God would restore his people. So "they have no wine" is a hosting crisis, and within John's story it also points to a deeper lack that Jesus is about to fill to overflowing.
-
4“Woman, what is that to you and to Me?” Jesus replied. “My hour has not yet come.”
Full study →Jesus answers his mother, and the way he speaks to her matters. He calls her "Woman." In Greek that is a courteous, even respectful address, the way a hero speaks to a queen or Jesus speaks to women he praises or heals. It is not a put-down. But he does not say "Mother," and no son is known to have addressed his mother this way. He is speaking to her from his mission rather than from inside the family.
Then he uses a stock Hebrew expression: "What is there to me and to you?" It means roughly "What does this matter have to do with you and me?" or "This is not ours to settle on these terms." The phrase can be hostile in other settings, but here it simply sets a boundary. She has hinted at a request ("They have no wine"), and he declines to let a family appeal decide what he does.
His reason: "My hour has not yet arrived." The hour is not a time of day. It is the moment his Father has appointed, which in John's Gospel leads to the cross and his being "glorified." "Not yet" means it is coming. Mary is not offended. She tells the servants, "Do whatever he tells you." Jesus does act, on his own terms, with a sign that gives a first glimpse of the glory his hour will reveal. The mother of Jesus appears only twice more in this Gospel, at the foot of the cross. There he again calls her "Woman," and the narrator says "from that hour" the beloved disciple took her home.
-
5His mother said to the servants, “Do whatever He tells you.”
Full study →Jesus' mother then turns to the people waiting on the tables, the attendants who fetch and pour at the feast, and says: "Whatever he tells you, anything at all, do it."
She has just received what sounds like a refusal ("Woman, what is that to you and to me? My hour has not yet come"). She does not repeat her request, explain, or tell Jesus what to do. She steps aside, puts the matter in his hands, and tells the staff to give him unconditional obedience before anyone knows what he will ask. The "whatever" is truly open: she does not predict a miracle or name an outcome. The sentence ends on a single, decisive command, "do!"
For hearers who knew the Greek Scriptures, the words had a familiar ring. They almost exactly repeat Pharaoh's words in the famine of Genesis 41:55: "Go to Joseph; whatever he says to you, do." In a moment of shortage, the needy are sent to one man, told to obey him, and find abundance. At Cana the shortage is wine, and the one to obey is Jesus.
Where the English drifted
-
in v3
when they wanted wine (KJV)
hysterēsantos oinou
- What we hear
- When the guests wanted (desired) more wine.
- What they heard
- When the wine had fallen short or given out. The supply was lacking. The guests' desire is not the point.
-
in v4
Woman
gynai
- What we hear
- A curt, cold or disrespectful way to address one's mother.
- What they heard
- A polite, respectful form of address for a woman. What is unusual is that a son uses it rather than 'mother,' which marks distance from the family role, not contempt.
-
in v4
what have I to do with thee?
ti emoi kai soi
- What we hear
- A disowning or rejection: 'I have nothing to do with you.'
- What they heard
- A Hebrew set phrase meaning roughly 'what does this matter have to do with us?' or 'that's not for you to direct.' Here it sets a boundary on the request. It does not reject the person.
-
in v4
hour
hōra
- What we hear
- A clock time: 'it isn't the right moment yet.'
- What they heard
- In John, the appointed time of Jesus' death and glorification, a theme word that runs through the whole Gospel.
Every word
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v3, v4
Links the verse to the scene just set (Jesus and his disciples invited to the wedding). It moves the story along without implying contrast.
-
ὑστερήσαντος
hysterēsantos · G5302
to lack, fall short, give out · v3
"Having fallen short." The wine supply did not last. The tense presents this as something that has already happened in the background when Mary speaks. The verb can mean the wine was running low or that it had given out completely.
-
οἴνου
oinou · G3631
wine · v3
The ordinary fermented grape wine served at feasts, normally mixed with water. Together with the verb before it, it sets the scene: "the wine having failed."
-
λέγει
legei · G3004
says · v3, v4, v5
The Greek uses a present tense ("says") inside a past narrative. Storytellers did this to make a moment feel immediate, and John uses it often. Most English versions turn it into "said".
-
ἡ
hē · G3588
the · v3, v4, v5
The article ("the") with "mother".
-
μήτηρ
mētēr · G3384
mother · v3, v5
John never names Mary. She is always "the mother of Jesus". Her identity in this Gospel comes entirely from her relationship to him, and she appears only here and at the cross (19:25–27).
-
Ἰησοῦ
Iēsou · G2424
Jesus (Joshua) · v3, v4
"Of Jesus". This is the Greek form of the Hebrew name Yeshua/Yehoshua.
-
πρὸς
pros · G4314
to, toward · v3
"To". She speaks directly to Jesus. It is a private word to her son, not an announcement to the guests.
-
αὐτόν·
auton · G0846
him · v3, v4, v5
"Him", meaning Jesus.
-
οὐκ
ouk · G3756
not · v3
A plain factual negative: they do not have it.
-
ἔχουσιν.
echousin · G2192
they have · v3
"They have". The subject is the hosts, the wedding household. Mary does not say "we", so she speaks as an observer or helper and not as the host. She reports the problem without asking for anything outright.
-
τί
ti · G5101
what? · v4
Opens the fixed expression 'what [is it] to me and to you?', a set phrase borrowed from Hebrew. It is not a real request for information.
-
ἐμοὶ
emoi · G1473
to me · v4
'To me': the first half of the paired 'to me and to you.' It sets out the relationship between the two parties in the matter being raised.
-
σοί
soi · G4771
to you · v4, v5
'To you': the mother is the second party. Several English versions drop it ('what does this have to do with me?'), but the Greek names both.
-
γύναι
gynai · G1135
woman (as a form of address) · v4
A polite, even respectful way to address a woman in Greek, not a curt one. What is striking is that a son uses it to his mother instead of 'mother.' That signals a new footing, not rudeness.
-
οὔπω
oupō · G3768
-
ἥκει
hēkei · G2240
has come, is here · v4
The verb is present in form but means 'has arrived and is now here.' The point is that the hour is not yet present.
-
ὥρα
hōra · G5610
-
μου
mou · G3165
my · v4
'My hour': the time belongs to him and his mission. Others' needs or wishes, even his mother's, do not set it.
-
διακόνοις·
diakonois · G1249
servants, attendants · v5
The people serving at the banquet: table attendants who fetch, pour and carry at the host's direction. Not the church office later called "deacon"; they are the working staff of the feast, and they become the only people (besides disciples) who know where the wine came from (v. 9).
-
ὅ
ho · G3739
what, which · v5
Relative pronoun, joined with τι and ἄν to make "whatever". Some printed editions write it as one word (ὅτι), others as two (ὅ τι); early manuscripts had no word spacing, and the meaning is the same.
-
τι
ti · G5100
any(thing) · v5
Indefinite word that widens "what" into "whatever, anything at all".
-
ἂν
an · G0302
(-ever); particle of contingency · v5
Small particle that, with the following subjunctive verb, makes the clause open-ended: whatever he may turn out to say. Mary does not specify what he will do.
-
ποιήσατε.
poiēsate · G4160G
do! · v5
Plural command in the aorist (a form that presents the action as a single, complete deed): "carry it out". The clause ends on this one word, giving it weight: whatever it is, do it.
The world behind it
Village weddings in Galilee. Cana was a small village near Nazareth, probably modern Khirbet Qana. A Jewish wedding centred on the bride being brought to the groom's family home, followed by a feast that often lasted around seven days (Judg 14:12; Tobit 11:18). Guests came and went, and the whole village and wider family could be involved.
Hospitality and honour. Providing food and drink was the groom's family's duty, and how well they did it was judged in public. Running out of wine was more than an inconvenience. It was a public failure that guests would remember and talk about, a loss of honour in a society where honour was a kind of social currency. Some scholars point to later rabbinic customs in which wedding gifts were treated as reciprocal obligations, so a shortfall could even have social or legal consequences. Those sources are later than the Gospel, though, and the idea remains suggestive, not proven.
Wine as joy and as promise. Wine "gladdens the heart" (Ps 104:15). A wedding without it was a wedding without joy. The prophets pictured God's coming restoration as mountains dripping with new wine (Amos 9:13; Joel 3:18) and a feast of "aged wine" for all peoples (Isa 25:6). A Jewish reader who heard "they have no wine" at a wedding could hardly miss those overtones, especially since the prophets also used marriage as a picture of God and his people.
Mary's position. Mary is there before Jesus arrives (2:1–2), she notices the shortage, and she gives orders to the servants (2:5). This suggests she was close to the family, perhaps a relative helping with the feast, though the text never says so. Joseph's absence is often taken to mean he had died by this time, which is also an inference.
From the study of John 2:3.
Where scholars differ
in v3
What was Mary asking Jesus to do?
-
She expected a miracle or some extraordinary action.
Jesus' reply about his "hour" (v.4) answers more than a request to run an errand. Her instruction "Do whatever he tells you" (v.5) shows she expected him to act. John 11:3 shows the same pattern of reporting a need in order to ask for help.
-
She was asking for ordinary practical help, without necessarily expecting a miracle.
John says this was Jesus' first sign (2:11), so Mary had no earlier miracle to base an expectation on. She may only have wanted him to arrange more wine or to help the hosts somehow. Some early interpreters, and Bengel, even suggested she was hinting it was time to leave.
-
The words also work at a symbolic level, whatever Mary consciously meant.
John often gives everyday words a second meaning. The empty wine sits beside the stone purification jars (2:6), and the prophets promised abundant wine in the age to come (Amos 9:13; Isa 25:6). Many commentators (e.g. Brown, Keener) read the lack of wine as hinting at a spiritual shortage that Jesus' coming meets. Others warn against pressing details too far.
in v3
Does Mary's role here have wider significance?
-
She models trusting intercession and anticipates her role at the cross.
In John she appears only at Cana and at the cross. Both times Jesus calls her "Woman" and his "hour" is in view, which suggests the two scenes are deliberately linked. Catholic and Orthodox interpreters have long drawn on this scene for Mary's intercessory role.
-
The scene mainly shows that Jesus acts on his own initiative and not under family pressure.
Jesus' reply in v.4 distances him from her request. Elsewhere in John, Jesus also refuses to act at the prompting of his brothers (7:3–10) and then acts in his own time.
in v4
How sharp is Jesus' reply to his mother?
-
A real, if gentle, rebuke or correction: Mary is overstepping by presuming on family ties.
The idiom always marks some distance between parties, and calling his mother 'woman' rather than 'mother' has no known parallel. John 7:3–10 shows Jesus refusing family pressure in a similar way (R. E. Brown and others).
-
A respectful redirection, not a rebuke: he sets a boundary on the request while honouring her.
γύναι is courteous (compare 19:26, said in tender care). Mary immediately tells the servants to obey him (v. 5), so she does not take it as a refusal, and Jesus then acts. The idiom has a non-hostile, disengaging use (2 Sam 16:10; 2 Kgs 3:13).
in v4
What is the 'hour' that has not yet come?
-
The hour of his death and glorification, as everywhere else in John.
John's consistent use (7:30; 8:20; 12:23, 27; 13:1; 17:1), and the link with 19:25–27, where Mary reappears and 'from that hour' is said.
-
The time for his public self-revelation or miracle-working, which begins at Cana.
The sign that follows 'revealed his glory' (2:11), and the 'time' (καιρός) for public manifestation is at issue in 7:4–8. Many combine the two views: the signs anticipate the full glory of the hour.
in v4
Is the second sentence a statement or a question?
-
Statement: 'My hour has not yet come.'
It matches John's repeated 'his hour had not yet come' (7:30; 8:20) and is the reading of almost all editions and translations.
-
Question: 'Has not my hour now come?' (or 'Is not my hour come?')
Possible in unpunctuated Greek and favoured by Gregory of Nyssa and a few modern scholars, since Jesus then acts. A minority view.
in v5
What did Mary understand from Jesus' reply in v. 4 when she spoke v. 5?
-
She took his reply as an implicit yes and expected him to act.
She immediately prepares the servants, which suggests she anticipated an instruction. Some read the "not yet" of his hour as leaving room for action now.
-
She accepted his refusal of her terms and simply placed the matter in his hands without presuming an outcome.
The open-ended grammar ("whatever he may say") specifies nothing. John's recurring pattern of request, apparent refusal, then action on Jesus' own initiative (4:47–50; 7:3–10; 11:3–6) stresses that he acts independently of human pressure. Her words give way to his authority rather than steering it.
in v5
Is the wording a deliberate allusion to Genesis 41:55 (Joseph)?
-
Yes: a conscious echo presenting Jesus as a new Joseph, the provider in a time of lack.
Near-identical Greek wording and the same narrative shape (shortage, sending to one man, unconditional obedience, abundance). John frequently draws on Old Testament imagery.
-
Possibly only a natural turn of phrase; the parallel may be coincidental or faint.
"Whatever he says, do" is an ordinary way to give an instruction, and John does not flag a citation here. Some prefer a Sinai background (Exodus 19:8; 24:3, 7) because of the "third day" in 2:1, though that wording is less close.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ὑστερέω
- BDAG s.v. οἶνος
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on John 2:3
- Raymond E. Brown, The Gospel According to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
- Craig S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
- D. A. Carson, The Gospel According to John (Pillar)
- Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on John 2:1–11
- Babylonian Talmud, Pesahim 109a
- Vulgate, John 2:3
- BDAG s.v. γυνή, ὥρα, ἥκω, οὔπω
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. γυνή, ὥρα
- BDB s.v. מָה (idiom מַה־לִּי וָלָךְ)
- Septuagint: Judg 11:12; 2 Kgdms 16:10; 19:23; 3 Kgdms 17:18; 4 Kgdms 3:13; 2 Chr 35:21
- Homer, Odyssey 19 (Odysseus' address to Penelope)
- Dio Cassius, Roman History 51.12 (as cited by commentators)
- R. E. Brown, The Gospel according to John I–XII (Anchor Bible 29)
- C. S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
- D. A. Carson, The Gospel according to John (PNTC)
- J. R. Michaels, The Gospel of John (NICNT)
- C. S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on John 2:1–11
- BDAG s.v. διάκονος
- BDAG s.v. ἄν
- LSJ s.v. διάκονος
- Septuagint, Genesis 41:55; Exodus 19:8; 24:3, 7; Esther 1:10; 6:3
- J. N. Collins, Diakonia: Re-interpreting the Ancient Sources (1990)
- R. E. Brown, The Gospel According to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
- C. H. Giblin, "Suggestion, Negative Response, and Positive Action in St John's Portrayal of Jesus," NTS 26 (1980)
- B. Olsson, Structure and Meaning in the Fourth Gospel (1974)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on John 2:1–11
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).