Numbers Chapter 33 Read as one passage
Numbers 33:16–29
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
16They set out from the Wilderness of Sinai and camped at Kibroth-hattaavah. 17They set out from Kibroth-hattaavah and camped at Hazeroth. 18They set out from Hazeroth and camped at Rithmah. 19They set out from Rithmah and camped at Rimmon-perez. 20They set out from Rimmon-perez and camped at Libnah. 21They set out from Libnah and camped at Rissah. 22They set out from Rissah and camped at Kehelathah. 23They set out from Kehelathah and camped at Mount Shepher. 24They set out from Mount Shepher and camped at Haradah. 25They set out from Haradah and camped at Makheloth. 26They set out from Makheloth and camped at Tahath. 27They set out from Tahath and camped at Terah. 28They set out from Terah and camped at Mithkah. 29They set out from Mithkah and camped at Hashmonah.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelites hearing this list, each place name brought a memory with it. Most entries in Numbers 33 are names we know nothing else about, but this one points to a well-known story. Hearing "they set out from the wilderness of Sinai and camped at Graves-of-the-Craving" would remind them:
- The journey began well and quickly went wrong. Right after leaving the mountain where God had given the covenant and lived among them in the tabernacle, the people rejected his daily provision of manna and longed for Egypt.
- Appetite can kill. The name keeps alive the point of Numbers 11: wanting the comforts of slavery more than God's provision in the wilderness ended in graves. Deuteronomy 9:22 lists the place alongside Taberah and Massah as places where Israel provoked the LORD, and Psalms 78 and 106 retell it as a warning.
- The list is God's record. Numbers 33:2 says Moses wrote the stages "at the command of the LORD". The list records God's leading, stop after stop, and also the places where Israel failed.
The verse itself gives no comment. It just records the move. The lesson is carried by the name.
From the study of Numbers 33:16.
Verse by verse
-
16They set out from the Wilderness of Sinai and camped at Kibroth-hattaavah.
Full study →They pulled up their tent pegs and left the open country around Mount Sinai, where they had camped for nearly a year and received the covenant. They pitched camp next at a place called "Graves of the Craving."
The sentence follows the formula that runs through all of Numbers 33: they set out from X and camped at Y. Here, though, the name of the stop is a story. Kibroth-hattaavah is not just a label. It means "the graves of the appetite," and it marks where the people, tired of manna, craved meat, were given quail, and were struck by a plague while the meat was "still between their teeth" (Numbers 11:4–34). They buried their dead there and named the place for what killed them.
So the first stop after leaving the mountain of the covenant is remembered as a graveyard of desire. The list itself says nothing more. To a hearer who knew the story, the name said the rest.
-
17They set out from Kibroth-hattaavah and camped at Hazeroth.
Full study →"Then they pulled up their tent pegs and moved on from Graves-of-the-Craving, and they pitched camp at Enclosures (Hazeroth)."
On the surface this is one line in a travel log. Numbers 33 lists about forty stopping places, each with the same two-part formula: they set out from X and camped at Y. To a Hebrew listener, though, the names were not foreign labels. Kibroth-hattaavah meant "the graves of the craving." It brought back the story in Numbers 11. The people grew tired of manna and "craved a craving" for meat. God sent quail. A plague struck while the meat was still between their teeth, and "there they buried the people who had craved." Leaving that place meant leaving graves behind.
Hazeroth, "enclosures" or "camps," was probably a watered spot with herders' pens. It is where the camp stopped next (Numbers 11:35). There Miriam and Aaron spoke against Moses, Miriam was struck with a skin disease, and the whole people waited seven days until she was brought back into the camp (Numbers 12).
So in two short clauses the verse records a stage of a march directed by God (33:1–2; 9:17–23) and quietly recalls two episodes of complaint and judgment.
-
18They set out from Hazeroth and camped at Rithmah.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
19They set out from Rithmah and camped at Rimmon-perez.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
20They set out from Rimmon-perez and camped at Libnah.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
21They set out from Libnah and camped at Rissah.
Full study →"Then they pulled up their tent pegs and broke camp at Libnah ('White-place'), and they settled down and made camp at Rissah."
This is one line in a long list of stops on Israel's wilderness route (Numbers 33:1–49). Every line uses the same two verbs. The first pictures a whole people taking down their tents and moving out. The second pictures them halting and setting up the ordered camp again, with the tabernacle at its centre. Numbers 9 says this happened whenever God's cloud lifted or settled. The verb form tells the story as one event after another: and then… and then…
Libnah probably means "whiteness". Rissah's meaning is unclear: "dew-drops" and "ruin" have both been suggested. Neither place is mentioned anywhere else in the Bible's wilderness stories, and today nobody knows where either was. The verse does not teach a lesson of its own. It records that Israel was really there, at a remembered place on a remembered road, during the long years between the Sinai departure and the approach to Canaan. According to Numbers 33:2, Moses wrote these stages down at the LORD's command.
-
22They set out from Rissah and camped at Kehelathah.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
23They set out from Kehelathah and camped at Mount Shepher.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
24They set out from Mount Shepher and camped at Haradah.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
25They set out from Haradah and camped at Makheloth.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
26They set out from Makheloth and camped at Tahath.
Full study →"They pulled up their tent pegs and broke camp at Makheloth ('Gathering-places'), and pitched camp again at Tahath ('Low-place')."
This is one line in the list of Israel's wilderness camps in Numbers 33. Verse 2 says Moses wrote it down "by the command of the LORD." Like every line in the list, it has two verbs. Nasa' pictures the whole camp being taken down and loaded up. Ḥanah pictures it being set up again in its ordered tribal layout. The place names probably described the sites: Makheloth comes from the root for "assembly," and Tahath is the ordinary Hebrew word for "below." Neither place can be located today. Neither appears in the stories of Exodus or Numbers, and nothing is reported as happening at either one. That silence is part of the meaning. These are the unrecorded years of moving from stage to stage. The list keeps them on record anyway, as steps a remembered people took one after another, under God's direction, on the way to the land.
-
27They set out from Tahath and camped at Terah.
Full study →They pulled up their tent pegs at Tahath, moved on as a people, and pitched camp again at Terah.
This is one line in a list of about forty-two stopping places, running from Egypt to the plains of Moab. The list is written as a steady rhythm: they set out from X and camped at Y. Each verb brings a picture. The first is tents coming down, stakes pulled from the ground, the whole community packing up. The second is a camp spreading out again at a new site. Earlier in the book this happened whenever the cloud over the tabernacle lifted or settled (Numbers 9:17–23).
Neither Tahath ("below"?) nor Terah (meaning uncertain) is mentioned anywhere else. We do not know where they were, what happened there, or how long Israel stayed. The verse makes no comment. Its whole point is that the stop was remembered and written down: even an unremarkable stage of the wilderness years counted as part of the journey God led.
-
28They set out from Terah and camped at Mithkah.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
29They set out from Mithkah and camped at Hashmonah.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
Where the English drifted
-
in v16
desert (KJV)
midbar
- What we hear
- A barren expanse of sand dunes with no vegetation.
- What they heard
- Open, unsettled land: dry steppe and scrub where flocks could graze, but where towns and grain fields were absent.
-
in v16
Kibroth-hattaavah ('graves of lust', KJV margin at Num 11:34)
qivrot hatta'avah
- What we hear
- Either a meaningless foreign name, or, if read as 'graves of lust', something to do with sexual desire.
- What they heard
- 'Graves of the craving/appetite': named for people who craved meat and died in the plague that followed.
-
in v21
removed (KJV)
nāsaʿ
- What we hear
- Taken away or eliminated, as in 'the stain was removed'.
- What they heard
- Pulled up tent pegs and moved on: broke camp and set out.
-
in v26
removed (KJV)
nasa'
- What we hear
- Took something away or got rid of it.
- What they heard
- Moved away, departed: they broke camp and moved on.
Every word
-
וַיִּסְעוּ
vayyis'u · H5265
to set out, pull up (tent pegs), break camp · v16, v17, v21, v26, v27
The standard verb for a whole camp moving on. The Hebrew form ('and they set out') is the ordinary way of telling the next event in a story, linking this stop to the one before.
-
מִמִּדְבַּר
mimmidbar · H4057
wilderness, open grazing land · v16
'From the wilderness of…'. Here it means the region around Mount Sinai, where Israel had camped for about a year (Exodus 19:1 to Numbers 10:11). It is unsettled land, not sand dunes.
-
סִינָי
sinai · H5514
Sinai · v16
The mountain where the covenant was given, and the area around it. Leaving Sinai is the great turning point of Numbers: the people stop receiving law and start marching.
-
וַיַּחֲנוּ
vayyachanu · H2583
to camp, pitch camp · v16, v17, v21, v26, v27
'And they camped.' This is the other half of the formula repeated about forty times in Numbers 33: set out, camp.
-
בְּקִבְרֹת
beqivrot · H6914
at Kibroth ('graves of') · v16, v17
The first half of the place name: 'graves' (plural of qeber, a grave or burial place). An Israelite hearer would hear the meaning, not just a label.
-
בַּחֲצֵרֹֽת׃
baḥăṣērōṯ · H2698
at Hazeroth ("enclosures") · v17
The prefix ba- means 'at' or 'in.' Ḥăṣērōṯ is the plural of ḥāṣēr, an enclosure, courtyard, or unwalled settlement, so the name probably points to pens or campsites at a watering place. It is the place where Miriam and Aaron challenged Moses (Numbers 11:35–12:16).
-
מִלִּבְנָ֑ה
millivnāh · H3841
Libnah (place name), from the root meaning 'white' · v21
'From Libnah', the place of the previous camp (v. 20). The name probably means 'whiteness', perhaps after white rock or soil, or possibly the white poplar tree (livneh). It is a wilderness stop, not the Judahite town of Libnah in Joshua 10:29.
-
בְּרִסָּֽה׃
bərissāh · H7446
Rissah (place name) · v21
'At Rissah', a stopping place mentioned only here and in verse 22. Nobody knows where it was. The meaning of the name is also uncertain: some link it to a root meaning 'drops (of dew)' or 'to moisten', others to 'ruin' or 'breaking'.
-
מִמַּקְהֵלֹ֑ת
mimmaqhēlōt · H4722
Makheloth (place name) · v26
'From Makheloth.' The camp named in verse 25. The name probably comes from the root q-h-l, 'to assemble,' and so means something like 'gathering places' or 'assemblies.' The site is unknown.
-
בְּתָֽחַת׃
bəTāḥat · H8480
Tahath (place name) · v26, v27
'At/in Tahath.' The name is the same as the common Hebrew word for 'beneath, below.' As a place name it may mean 'low place' or 'depression.' The location is unknown. It is the starting point of the next leg in verse 27.
-
בְּתָרַח
betaraḥ · H8646
Terah / Tarah (place name) · v27
'At Terah.' The word has the prefix be- ('in, at'). The vowels here are the 'pausal' form, the slightly lengthened shape a word takes at the end of a verse, which is why the KJV and YLT write 'Tarah'. The spelling is the same as the name of Abraham's father (Genesis 11:24–32), but the text gives no sign of a link. The place appears only here and in v. 28 and has not been located.
The world behind it
An itinerary chapter. Numbers 33:1–49 lists Israel's camps from Egypt to the plains of Moab, and verse 2 says Moses recorded "their starting points by their stages." Lists of stopping places were a known genre in the ancient Near East. Assyrian royal records, for example, list military campaigns in the same pattern: "from X I set out, at Y I spent the night." The repeated formula gives the chapter its steady marching rhythm.
Leaving Sinai. Israel arrived at Sinai in the third month after the Exodus (Exodus 19:1) and left on the twentieth day of the second month of the second year (Numbers 10:11). Everything from Exodus 19 to Numbers 10 takes place at that one camp. This verse is the first step of the journey toward Canaan.
The episode behind the name. In Numbers 11, a "rabble" (asafsuf, probably the mixed crowd who came out of Egypt with Israel) began to crave food, and the Israelites joined in, weeping for Egypt's fish, cucumbers, leeks and garlic. God sent a huge flock of quail, but a plague broke out as they ate. "So that place was called Kibroth-hattaavah, because there they buried the people who had craved" (11:34). In a world where place names were often given to remember events (compare Massah and Meribah, Exodus 17:7), the name kept the warning alive.
Location. The site is unknown. Numbers 10:33 puts it about three days' journey from the mountain. Some nineteenth-century explorers proposed sites in the Sinai peninsula, but nothing is confirmed, and the location of Mount Sinai itself is debated.
From the study of Numbers 33:16.
Where scholars differ
in v16
Why does Numbers 33 omit Taberah (Numbers 11:1–3)?
-
Taberah and Kibroth-hattaavah were the same area or the same camp; 'Taberah' named an incident (a fire at the edge of the camp), not a separate station.
Numbers 11:1–3 records no departure or camping, and 11:35 has the people leaving Kibroth-hattaavah directly. The 'set out… camped' formula is never used for Taberah.
-
Taberah was a separate stop that the itinerary leaves out, because the list is selective or comes from a different source than the narrative.
Deuteronomy 9:22 lists Taberah separately from Kibroth-hattaavah. Comparison with Numbers 21 and Deuteronomy 10:6–7 shows the itineraries do not line up perfectly elsewhere either.
in v16
Where was Kibroth-hattaavah?
-
In the Sinai peninsula, northeast of the traditional Mount Sinai (Jebel Musa), on the route toward Hazeroth (sometimes linked with ʿAin Hudra).
Nineteenth-century surveys (e.g. E. H. Palmer) proposed sites along this route. Numbers 10:33 gives a three-day journey from the mountain.
-
It cannot be located, especially since the location of Sinai itself is disputed (proposals include southern Sinai, northern Sinai and northwest Arabia).
No inscription or tradition securely identifies the site. The name describes an event rather than surviving as a later Arabic place name.
in v16
How was the itinerary in Numbers 33 composed?
-
It is a record kept during the journey, as 33:2 states (Moses wrote the stages at the LORD's command).
The claim in 33:2 itself, and the fact that ancient Near Eastern campaign itineraries were also written up from travel records.
-
It is a later compilation that draws on narrative traditions and possibly on an older road itinerary.
Several stations appear nowhere else in the narrative, and others are named in the narrative but not here. Some scholars (e.g. G. I. Davies) compare it with written route lists from the ancient Near East.
in v17
Where was Hazeroth?
-
At ʿAin Khadra (Ain Hudra), an oasis in eastern Sinai on the way toward the Gulf of Aqaba.
The Arabic name is similar (Khadra ~ Ḥaṣērōṯ). It suits a traditional southern location for Mount Sinai (Jebel Musa), and the spring and surrounding enclosures fit the meaning 'enclosures.'
-
The location is unknown; it may have been in northwest Arabia or elsewhere.
The name resemblance is loose, and names built on ḥāṣēr were common. Where Hazeroth was depends on where Sinai was, which is disputed (southern Sinai, northern Sinai, or Midian/Arabia). No archaeological remains tie the site to Israel's camp.
in v17
How was the Numbers 33 itinerary composed?
-
It was compiled later from the narrative stations in Exodus and Numbers, with other material added.
Many stations repeat names from the stories. Older critical scholars such as Martin Noth argued for a late editorial compilation.
-
It draws on an older, independent itinerary source, or on genuine route traditions.
About a dozen stations in Numbers 33 appear nowhere else. The fixed formula matches ancient Near Eastern itinerary genres (Assyrian campaign records, Egyptian route lists), as argued by Graham Davies and others.
in v21
Where were Libnah and Rissah?
-
The locations are unknown.
Neither name appears outside Numbers 33. No ancient site with a firmly matching name has been confirmed, and most standard dictionaries mark both as unidentified.
-
Rissah may match a later 'Rasa' in the southern Negev or Arabah region.
A similar-sounding name appears in late Roman road and garrison lists. However, the gap of a thousand years or more and the loose match in sound make this a tentative suggestion at best.
in v21
What kind of document is the station list?
-
An old route record preserved largely as written.
Numbers 33:2 says Moses recorded the stages. The list resembles ancient Near Eastern campaign and route lists, and it includes obscure stations that later writers had no reason to invent.
-
A later editorial compilation drawing on several sources, possibly including known trade routes.
Some stations duplicate or differ from the narrative accounts, the order is hard to fit onto a single geography, and stations like those in vv. 19–29 appear only here.
in v26
Is the stations list a record of a real route, or a literary composition?
-
It preserves an old itinerary of actual stations, in the manner of ancient Near Eastern route lists.
The fixed formulas match Egyptian and Assyrian itinerary texts (G. I. Davies). It is hard to explain why someone would invent so many obscure names that serve no story.
-
It is a later scribal compilation that harmonizes and expands the narrative routes.
Many stations, including Makheloth and Tahath, appear nowhere else. The list's total of about 40–42 stations looks schematic, and the list draws on names from Exodus and Numbers along with other sources.
in v27
Where were Tahath and Terah, and which part of the wilderness period do they belong to?
-
They belong to the unrecorded wandering years after the spies' report.
Verses 19–29 name stations that appear nowhere in the stories of Numbers 13–20. The list moves from Hazeroth/Rithmah, near the Kadesh region, to Ezion-geber (v. 35) and then to Kadesh (v. 36). That leaves room for a long period with no stories, which fits Numbers 14:33–34.
-
Their locations, and even their route, cannot be recovered.
No ancient source outside the Bible names them, no archaeological site has been firmly identified, and the names give no clear hint of geography. Maps in Bible atlases that place them are educated guesses.
in v27
Do the station names carry meaning?
-
Some names may describe the place (e.g. Tahath, 'below', perhaps a low-lying spot).
Many Hebrew place names describe the landscape or something that happened there (e.g. Marah 'bitter', Kibroth-hattaavah 'graves of craving').
-
For these two names, any meaning is speculation.
Terah's meaning is unknown, and the sound of Tahath may be coincidence. Later allegorical readings that give each station a spiritual meaning (as in some early Jewish and Christian writers) come from outside the text.
Sources
- BDB s.v. נָסַע, מִדְבָּר, חָנָה, תַּאֲוָה, קֶבֶר
- HALOT s.v. מִדְבָּר; קִבְרוֹת הַתַּאֲוָה
- Septuagint, Numbers 11:34; 33:16 (Μνήματα τῆς ἐπιθυμίας)
- Vulgate, Numbers 33:16
- G. I. Davies, The Way of the Wilderness (1979)
- J. Milgrom, JPS Torah Commentary: Numbers (1990)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Numbers 11 and 33
- BDB s.v. נָסַע, חָנָה, קֶבֶר, תַּאֲוָה, חָצֵר
- HALOT s.v. קִבְרוֹת הַתַּאֲוָה; חֲצֵרוֹת
- G. I. Davies, 'The Wilderness Itineraries: A Comparative Study,' Tyndale Bulletin 25 (1974)
- J. Milgrom, JPS Torah Commentary: Numbers (1990), on Num 11 and 33
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Numbers 11–12, 33
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Numbers 11:34; 33:16–17
- Vulgate, Numbers 33:17
- BDB s.v. נָסַע, חָנָה, לִבְנָה, רִסָּה
- HALOT s.v. נסע, חנה, רִסָּה
- Numbers 9:15–23; 10:11–28; 33:1–2 (context)
- Septuagint, Numbers 33:20–22
- Vulgate, Numbers 33:21
- Standard Bible dictionaries (e.g. Anchor Bible Dictionary) on 'Libnah' and 'Rissah'
- BDB s.v. נָסַע, חָנָה, תַּחַת
- HALOT s.v. מַקְהֵלֹת, תַּחַת
- G. I. Davies, The Way of the Wilderness (Cambridge, 1979)
- Jerome, Epistle 78 (to Fabiola), on the mansiones
- Origen, Homilies on Numbers 27
- J. Milgrom, JPS Torah Commentary: Numbers
- BDB s.v. נָסַע, חָנָה, תַּחַת, תֶּרַח
- HALOT s.v. נסע, חנה, תֶּרַח
- STEPBible / TAHOT lemma and morphology data (as supplied)
- Numbers 9:17–23; 33:1–2 (internal parallels)
- Standard commentaries on Numbers 33 (e.g. Milgrom, JPS Torah Commentary: Numbers; Levine, Anchor Bible Numbers 21–36) on the itinerary genre
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
9 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.