Proverbs Chapter 10 Read as one passage

Proverbs 10:17–19

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

17Whoever heeds instruction is on the path to life, but he who ignores reproof goes astray. 18The one who conceals hatred has lying lips, and whoever spreads slander is a fool. 19When words are many, sin is unavoidable, but he who restrains his lips is wise.

What the first hearers heard

For a young man being trained in an Israelite household or school, this saying told him what was at stake when his father or teacher corrected him. Correction was not a humiliation to escape. It was the road. To keep it (guard it, hold it, live by it) was to stay on the path that ends in long life, honour and blessing, the opposite of the early ruin Proverbs 1–9 warns about.

The saying also told him that his response would affect others. In a culture where people learned by imitation (sons copying fathers, pupils copying teachers, households following their head), the man who would not be corrected became a false guide. As a parent, elder or official, he would lead his household and community off the road with him. The teachable man, in turn, became "a path to life" others could follow. The saying works as a warning and as a call: accepting rebuke is the habit that makes a person wise and makes him a safe guide for others.

From the study of Proverbs 10:17.

Verse by verse

  1. 17Whoever heeds instruction is on the path to life, but he who ignores reproof goes astray.

    The person who holds on to correction is a road that comes out at life. The person who walks away from a rebuke sends people wandering off the road, himself first.

    The Hebrew is a terse two-line picture of a journey. It opens with a path and closes with wandering off. In line one, the person who keeps discipline (a guard's word: to hold onto, watch over, treasure) is himself "a path to life." The life in view is the full, long, God-blessed life Proverbs keeps promising, not mere survival. What he keeps is musar: not neutral "instruction" but correction, training that sets you straight and may sting. In line two, the opposite person abandons (not just "ignores") a rebuke. The word for rebuke means a reasoned correction that shows him he is wrong. The last word, matʿeh, is causative: he "causes wandering." Grammatically this most naturally means he leads others astray. Many readers also take it as "he goes astray," and that is certainly involved too, since you cannot lead others off a road you have not already left.

    Read together, the lines say that how you respond to being corrected does not stay private. The teachable person becomes a road others can walk to life. The unteachable person becomes a false guide.

    Full study →
  2. 18The one who conceals hatred has lying lips, and whoever spreads slander is a fool.

    The person who keeps his hatred covered over is speaking with lips made of falsehood. And the person who takes a damaging report about someone and puts it out into circulation — that man is a fool, in the full moral sense: closed to wisdom and a danger to everyone around him.

    The two lines are built on a contrast between covering and bringing out. They describe the only two things a hateful person can do with his hatred: hide it or release it. If he hides it behind pleasant words, his whole friendly manner becomes a lie, even if each sentence he says is technically true. If he releases it as talk passed around about the person he hates, whether invented, exaggerated, or true but used as a weapon, he shows himself to be a kesil, the stubborn fool of Proverbs.

    Neither line offers a way out. The saying sits a few verses after "hatred stirs up strife, but love covers all offenses" (10:12), and it uses the same verb, "cover." The sage is showing the fake version of the virtue he has just praised. Love covers other people's faults. Hatred covers itself. The verse implies that the problem lies further back than either the hiding or the gossip: in keeping the hatred at all. That fits the old Israelite law, "You shall not hate your brother in your heart; you shall surely rebuke your neighbor… you shall not go about as a talebearer" (Lev 19:16–17).

    Full study →
  3. 19When words are many, sin is unavoidable, but he who restrains his lips is wise.

    Where words pile up, offense is never missing. Wrongs that wound and betray other people keep turning up in the stream of talk, as surely as the poor never vanish from the land. But the one who keeps his lips in reserve, holding back words the way a careful man holds back what he owns, is acting with real insight, and that insight pays off.

    The first half does not say that all speech is sinful, or that every talkative person is wicked. It describes what volume does. The more someone says, the more certainly something false, unkind, disloyal or provoking gets out. The word for the wrongdoing is not the general word for "sin." It means a breach of trust, the sort of offense that starts quarrels between neighbours. The verse before (lying lips, slander) shows the kind of thing in view.

    The second half is not a call to silence. The verse after praises the tongue of the righteous as "choice silver." The wise person restrains his lips: he spends words sparingly and deliberately. The Hebrew describes him as someone doing something prudent, a habit of conduct and not just a quality of mind, and in Hebrew thinking such prudence tends to succeed.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v17

    instruction (KJV, BSB, ESV)

    mûsār

    What we hear
    Teaching, information, directions: being told how to do something.
    What they heard
    Correction and discipline: training that sets a person right, sometimes painfully and sometimes with the rod.
  • in v17

    He is in the way of life (KJV)

    ʾōraḥ leḥayyîm

    What we hear
    He has a certain lifestyle or way of living.
    What they heard
    He is (or is on) a road that leads to life, the destination at the end of the path of wisdom.
  • in v17

    erreth (KJV)

    matʿeh

    What we hear
    Makes a mistake.
    What they heard
    Causes wandering: leads others off the road (and wanders off it himself).
  • in v17

    ignores reproof (BSB, NASB, NLT)

    ʿôzēv tôkaḥat

    What we hear
    Doesn't pay attention to criticism, a passive oversight.
    What they heard
    Abandons, leaves behind, a reasoned rebuke he has received: a deliberate turning away.
  • in v18

    slander

    dibbah

    What we hear
    A false spoken statement that damages someone's reputation (the legal sense). The implication is that if it's true, it isn't slander.
    What they heard
    A damaging report or whispered talk about someone, put into circulation. It may be false, distorted, or true but spread to harm.
  • in v18

    fool

    kesil

    What we hear
    A silly, unintelligent or foolish-acting person.
    What they heard
    A stubborn, self-sure person who has rejected wisdom and whose behavior harms the community. It is a moral category, not a measure of intelligence.
  • in v19

    there wanteth not sin (KJV)

    lōʾ yeḥdal pešaʿ

    What we hear
    A modern reader may take "wanteth" as "wants, desires" and come away with something like "sin does not want to be there," or find the line simply unclear.
    What they heard
    "Is not lacking." In 1611 English "want" meant "lack." The line means offense is always present where words are many.
  • in v19

    sin

    pešaʿ

    What we hear
    A general moral or religious failing, mainly a private matter between a person and God.
    What they heard
    A breach of trust or loyalty, an offense that injures someone and breaks a relationship. In Proverbs it is closely tied to quarrels and to wrongs that need to be "covered" between people (10:12; 17:9, 19).
Every word
  1. אֹ֣רַח

    ʾōraḥ · H0734

    path, way, road · v17

    A road you actually walk, the kind of route travellers use. Coming first in the sentence, it puts the picture of a journey up front: the person who accepts correction is a road that ends in life.

  2. לְ֭חַיִּים

    leḥayyîm · H2416E

    to life · v17

    'To' or 'toward' life, the place the road comes out. In Proverbs 'life' means a full, long, secure life under God's blessing, and it is the opposite of the early death that folly brings. The same phrase ends the previous verse (10:16), which links the two sayings.

  3. שׁוֹמֵ֣ר

    shômēr · H8104J

    keeping, guarding, heeding · v17

    A participle (a verb used like a noun: 'one who keeps'), describing an ongoing habit. Shamar is a watchman's or guard's word. It means holding on to correction and protecting it, not just hearing it once.

  4. מוּסָ֑ר

    mûsār · H4148G

    discipline, correction, training · v17

    Training that corrects. It comes from a root meaning 'to discipline, chastise', and it covers spoken warnings as well as the rod. What the person 'keeps' here is correction that may sting, not neutral information.

  5. וְעוֹזֵ֖ב

    weʿôzēv · H5800H

    and one forsaking, abandoning · v17

    'And the one who abandons.' ʿAzav means leaving something or someone behind, the same verb used for forsaking God or a spouse. It is an active walking-away, stronger than 'ignore'. This is the second habit, set against shomer.

  6. תּוֹכַ֣חַת

    tôkaḥat · H8433B

    reproof, rebuke, correction, argument · v17

    A rebuke that makes a case against you. It comes from the root ykḥ, 'to set right, argue, decide a case', so it is reasoned correction, like a judge or a parent proving you are wrong. It pairs with musar: one word stresses training, the other the confrontation.

  7. מַתְעֶֽה׃

    matʿeh · H8582

    causing to wander, leading astray · v17

    A causative form of taʿah, 'to stray, wander off', used of lost sheep or a drunk staggering. Taken strictly it means 'makes (someone) wander': he leads others off the road. It may also mean he strays himself. See debates.

  8. מְכַסֶּ֣ה

    mekhasseh · H3680

    to cover, conceal · v18

    An intensive participle: one who keeps covering, keeps hidden. This is the same verb as "love covers all offenses" six verses earlier (10:12), but here it means camouflage. What is covered is his own hostility, not someone else's fault.

  9. שִׂ֭נְאָה

    sin'ah · H8135

    hatred, enmity · v18

    Real hostility toward a neighbor, kept as an inner attitude. It is the object of the covering: ill will he does not show.

  10. שִׂפְתֵי־

    sifte- · H8193

    lips · v18, v19

    "Lips of" (the Hebrew is in the form for a pair). In Proverbs, lips stand for what someone says. Here they are the mask: a friendly surface laid over the hatred.

  11. שָׁ֑קֶר

    shaqer · H8267

    falsehood, deception · v18

    What these lips are made of. Sheqer is speech that betrays the truth and the listener, more than speech that gets a fact wrong. The man's pleasant words do not match his heart.

  12. וּמוֹצִ֥א

    umotsi · H3318

    and one who brings out · v18

    A causative participle of "go out": one who brings out, puts into circulation. "Bringing out a report" is a set phrase (Num 14:36; Deut 22:14, 19). It pairs with "covering" in line one: one man hides, the other airs.

  13. דִ֝בָּ֗ה

    dibbah · H1681

    (evil) report, whispered talk, defamation · v18

    Damaging talk about a person, passed around behind their back. It may be false or only one-sided. Either way its aim is to lower someone's standing.

  14. ה֣וּא

    hu · H1931

    he · v18

    An emphatic pronoun that points back to the spreader: "that one, he is…" It singles out the person who spreads the report for the verdict.

  15. כְסִֽיל׃

    kesil · H3684

    fool · v18

    In Proverbs the kesil is the stubborn, self-sure fool who will not learn and who harms the people around him. This is a moral verdict, not a comment on his intelligence.

  16. בְּרֹב

    bə-rōv · H7230

    in abundance, multitude · v19

    "In a great quantity of": the prefix bə- ("in, when") sets the scene where talk is piled high. It names sheer volume, not any particular kind of speech.

  17. דְּבָרִים

    dəvārîm · H1697G

    words; matters, things · v19

    Plural "words." Davar can also mean "matter" or "affair," but the parallel with "lips" makes spoken words the sense. The plural stresses how many there are.

  18. לֹא

    lōʾ · H3808

    not · v19

    Plain negation of the verb that follows. Together they say "does not stop" or "is never missing."

  19. יֶחְדַּל־

    yeḥdal · H2308

    to cease, stop, leave off; be absent · v19

    "Does not cease / is not absent." The same phrase, lōʾ yeḥdal, appears in Deuteronomy 15:11 ("the poor will never cease from the land"). The idea is that offense keeps turning up wherever talk overflows.

  20. פָּשַׁע

    pāšaʿ · H6588

    transgression, offense, breach, rebellion · v19

    The grammatical subject: an offense that breaks faith with someone, a wrong that damages a relationship. Here, after verse 18's lying and slander, it means the wounding, untrue, or disloyal things that slip out when someone talks too much.

  21. וְחֹשֵׂךְ

    wə-ḥōśēḵ · H2820

    to hold back, withhold, spare, restrain · v19

    "But the one who holds back." It is a participle, so it describes a habit and not a single act. The verb means keeping something in reserve, as Abraham "did not withhold" his son (Gen 22:12). This is restraint, not permanent silence.

  22. מַשְׂכִּיל

    maśkîl · H7919A

    to act with insight, be prudent; succeed · v19

    "Is acting with insight." It is an active participle describing conduct, not just a mental quality. In Hebrew the verb carries the idea that insight pays off: prudent action tends to turn out well (Josh 1:8; Prov 10:5).

The world behind it

Proverbs 10:1 begins the main "Proverbs of Solomon" collection (10:1–22:16). It is made up mostly of two-line sayings whose second line contrasts with the first. Musar and tôkaḥat belonged to a world where wisdom was passed on in the household, and probably in court or scribal schooling, by a father or teacher correcting a son or pupil (Prov 1:8; 4:1; 13:1). Being corrected was the normal way to become wise, and the rod was part of musar (22:15; 23:13). The road picture comes from chapters 1–9, which set two ways before the young man: the path of wisdom that leads to life and the path of folly that leads to death (2:12–22; 4:18–19). An ancient hearer would hear "path to life" and "wandering off" as those two familiar roads. Verse 16 just before ends with the same word "to life," which deliberately joins the two sayings. 10:16 is about what a righteous person's labour produces; 10:17 is about what his teachability produces.

From the study of Proverbs 10:17.

Where scholars differ

in v17

Does matʿeh mean 'leads others astray' or 'goes astray (himself)'?

  • Causative, 'leads others astray' (WEB, NIV, ESV; many modern commentators, e.g. Waltke).

    Elsewhere the Hiphil of taʿah plainly means to cause someone else to wander (Mic 3:5; Jer 23:13, 32; 2 Kgs 21:9). Read this way, line one is also about influence: the disciplined person 'is a path to life' for others.

  • Inner or self-directed, 'goes astray, errs' (KJV, BSB, NASB, NLT; the Septuagint and Vulgate).

    The ancient versions translate it as intransitive. The contrast with someone who is 'on the path to life' suggests a personal outcome. Some grammarians allow the Hiphil to mean 'make oneself stray', and some scholars propose repointing to the Qal tōʿeh.

in v17

Is the disciplined man 'on' the path to life, or himself 'a path to life' for others?

  • He is on, or in, the path ('is on the path to life', BSB, ESV, NASB).

    A natural way to read a Hebrew sentence that has no verb, and it fits the many sayings about one's own road and its end (15:24).

  • He is, or shows, a path to life for others (NIV 'shows the way to life').

    The Hebrew simply sets 'a path to life' next to 'one who keeps discipline', with no preposition for 'on'. If matʿeh is causative, the parallel suggests his influence on others.

in v18

How is the first line built: "the one who conceals hatred has lying lips" or "one who conceals hatred with lying lips [is a fool]"?

  • Two separate verdicts: line one says that whoever hides hatred has lips of falsehood, and line two says the spreader is a fool (BSB, ESV, NASB, WEB, and many commentators such as Waltke).

    The Hebrew has no word for "with." The main pause in the traditional Hebrew text (the accent marks) falls after "falsehood," closing line one. The emphatic "he" in line two points back only to the spreader.

  • One combined verdict: concealing hatred with lying lips and spreading reports are both what a fool does (KJV, YLT, NIV).

    Hebrew can leave out a preposition such as "with," and Proverbs elsewhere pictures the hater disguising himself "with his lips" (26:24). Reading the verse as one sentence gives a single conclusion for two kinds of misused speech.

in v18

Is the first line condemning hidden hatred (Hebrew text) or commending restraint (Greek text)?

  • Keep the Hebrew: hidden hatred is falsehood.

    It is the harder reading. It agrees with Prov 26:24–26, where the hater disguises himself with his lips and covers his hatred with deceit. It also sets up a deliberate contrast with 10:12 by repeating "cover."

  • Follow or prefer the Greek's sense, that righteous lips cover enmity.

    It makes line one a positive opposite of line two, a common pattern in Proverbs 10, and it matches "love covers" in 10:12. Most scholars think the translator produced this harmony rather than finding it in his Hebrew manuscript.

in v19

Does the first line mean offense is never absent from much talk, or that much talk never ends an offense?

  • Offense is never absent: excess talk reliably produces wrongs (the majority view).

    The identical phrase lōʾ yeḥdal in Deuteronomy 15:11 means "will always be present." The Septuagint ("you will not escape sin") and the Vulgate ("sin will not be lacking") both read it this way. It also fits Proverbs 12:13 and 17:27–28, which warn about the dangers of the lips, and it gives a clean contrast with "restrains his lips." Followed by KJV, ESV, BSB, NASB, WEB.

  • Offense does not end: piling up words will not put an end to a wrong or a quarrel (the NIV 2011 reading).

    "To cease, come to an end" is the most common meaning of ḥādal. Nearby verses speak of offenses being "covered" by love (10:12; 17:9), suggesting that wrongs are settled by restraint, not by argument. On this reading, the person who holds back his lips is prudent because he does not inflame the dispute.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).