1 Corinthians Chapter 9 Read as one passage
1 Corinthians 9:10–11
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
10Isn’t He actually speaking on our behalf? Indeed, this was written for us, because when the plowman plows and the thresher threshes, they should also expect to share in the harvest. 11If we have sown spiritual seed among you, is it too much for us to reap a material harvest from you?
What the first hearers heard
To the Corinthian believers, many of them artisans, freedmen and slaves, with a few wealthy households, the picture was obvious: no one plows or threshes for nothing. Everyone knew that farm hands and sharecroppers were paid out of the crop.
The verse did three things for them:
- It established Paul's right. Paul's refusal to take their money might have looked like proof that he was a lesser apostle, or that he did not think himself worth paying. Here he shows from the Jewish Scriptures that support for gospel workers is fair and backed by God. His refusal (v. 15) is therefore a free choice, not an admission.
- It taught them how to hear Israel's Scriptures. Many of these were former pagans. Paul tells them that the Law of Moses was "written for our sake": it addresses the new community gathered around the Messiah. He says the same about Israel's wilderness stories in 10:11.
- It prepared the main lesson. Having proved the right so thoroughly, Paul can make his point: he laid it aside "so as not to hinder the gospel" (v. 12). In the same way the "knowing" Corinthians should lay aside their right to eat idol meat when it harms a fellow believer (ch. 8).
From the study of 1 Corinthians 9:10.
Verse by verse
-
10Isn’t He actually speaking on our behalf? Indeed, this was written for us, because when the plowman plows and the thresher threshes, they should also expect to share in the harvest.
Full study →Paul has just quoted the law of Moses: "Do not muzzle an ox while it is threshing" (Deuteronomy 25:4), and asked, "Is it oxen God is worried about?" Now he presses the point:
"Or is it not surely for our sake that he says this? Yes, for our sake it was written, because the one who plows is meant to plow with expectation, and the one who threshes is meant to thresh with expectation of getting his share."
The force of the verse:
- "Surely" (not "only"): Paul is confident the command speaks to people like himself. He is not necessarily saying it has nothing to do with real oxen.
- "It was written for our sake": when the law was put in writing, it already had in view the later people who would hear it. For Paul, Scripture speaks to the present community.
- Plowing and threshing are the first and last jobs of the farming year. From breaking the ground to beating out the grain, every stage of farm work is done looking ahead to a share of the harvest.
- "Ought" / "is meant to" carries the language of debt and obligation. Expecting a return is how labor rightly works. It is a matter of fairness, not greed.
- "Hope" here is not wishful thinking but the plain, confident expectation that a worker will eat from what he works.
- The word "threshes" is the same word used of the ox in the quoted law. Paul moves straight from the animal at the threshing floor to the human worker beside it: if the ox may eat while it works, how much more the man.
All of this sets up v. 11: Paul and his colleagues "sowed" spiritual things among the Corinthians, so a material "harvest" from them would be entirely fair. He is establishing a right, which he goes on to say he has deliberately not used (vv. 12, 15).
-
11If we have sown spiritual seed among you, is it too much for us to reap a material harvest from you?
Full study →"If we ourselves planted among you the things of God's Spirit (the gospel and the Spirit-given life you now have), is it really such a big thing if we ourselves were to gather in a harvest of ordinary bodily goods from you: bread, a bed, the means to live?"
Paul builds the sentence as two matching halves. We → to you → the spiritual things → sowed, and then we → from you → the bodily things → will reap. The repeated, stressed "we" makes the same people the sowers and the reapers. "To you" and "from you" show the goods going both ways. The contrast between spiritual and material is about value: what they received is worth far more than what he could ask in return. "Fleshly" here is not a moral slur. It means physical, material provision, the same word Paul uses in Romans 15:27 for famine-relief money.
The sowing is in the past tense, finished when Paul founded the church. The reaping is in the future, a harvest he could claim. As the next verse makes clear, he has deliberately not claimed it. The whole question is built to get the answer "No, of course that isn't too much," so that his refusal of the right in verse 12 stands out more.
Where the English drifted
-
in v10
altogether (KJV, NASB: "saith he it altogether for our sakes")
pantōs
- What we hear
- 'Exclusively, only': God was not talking about oxen at all, only about preachers.
- What they heard
- 'Surely, certainly, without doubt': a strong statement of confidence that the law applies to gospel workers, which does not by itself deny any literal concern for animals.
-
in v10
in hope
ep' elpidi
- What we hear
- Wishing and hoping things turn out well, with no real assurance.
- What they heard
- Working on the basis of confident, reasonable expectation of a share in the harvest, the normal and rightful expectation of any laborer.
-
in v11
carnal things (KJV)
sarkika
- What we hear
- Sinful, lustful or sexual things, worldly indulgence.
- What they heard
- Bodily or material goods, the physical means of living (food, shelter, money). It carries no moral criticism here.
-
in v11
spiritual (things)
pneumatika
- What we hear
- Things that are inner, non-physical or vaguely religious.
- What they heard
- Things that come from and belong to the Holy Spirit: the gospel, Spirit-taught teaching, and the gifts and life the Spirit gives.
Every word
-
ἢ
ē · G2228
or · v10
Brings in the other option after the question of v. 9 ('Is it about oxen that God is concerned?'). If not oxen only, then who? It sets up the answer Paul wants.
-
δι᾽
di' · G1223
because of, for the sake of · v10
With the accusative it means 'on account of, for the sake of'. The question is whose benefit the command was spoken for.
-
ἡμᾶς
hēmas · G3165
us · v10, v11
'Us': in context mainly Paul and his fellow workers (Barnabas, v. 6) who 'sowed' among the Corinthians (v. 11), though Paul elsewhere says Scripture was written for believers in general (Rom 15:4; 1 Cor 10:11).
-
πάντως
pantōs · G3843
certainly, surely, by all means · v10
An adverb of strong assurance, 'surely, without doubt'. It marks how certain the point is, not that the oxen are excluded. The KJV/NASB 'altogether' can be misheard as 'exclusively'.
-
λέγει
legei · G3004G
says, speaks · v10
Present tense: Scripture still speaks now. The implied subject is God (named in v. 9) or 'the Law' speaking for him; Jewish writers easily moved between 'God says' and 'Scripture says'.
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for, indeed · v10
Here it confirms the answer ('yes indeed') more than it gives a reason.
-
ἐγράφη
egraphē · G1125
was written · v10
Aorist passive (a simple past event): 'it was written'. It points back to the moment Deuteronomy 25:4 was put into writing, and says the writing had later readers like 'us' in view. Compare Rom 4:23–24 and 15:4.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754H
that; because · v10
Either 'because' (giving the reason the law applies to workers) or 'that' (giving what Scripture means, or even introducing a saying). Both readings are possible; see Debates.
-
ὀφείλει
opheilei · G3784
owe; ought, be obligated · v10
A word for debt and obligation. This is how labor rightly works: the plowman is meant to plow with real expectation of a return. Expectation is part of the work, not a selfish extra.
-
ἐπ᾽
ep' · G1909
upon, on the basis of · v10
With the dative it means 'on the basis of'. Hope is the ground the work stands on.
-
ἐλπίδι
elpidi · G1680
hope, expectation · v10
Confident expectation of a future good, here the harvest share. It is not a vague wish that it might turn out well.
-
ὁ
ho · G3588
the · v10, v11
The article turns the participle into 'the one who plows', meaning any plowman, a type of worker.
-
ἀροτριῶν
arotriōn · G0722
plowing · v10
'The plowman': the first job of the farming year, breaking ground before sowing.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v10
Joins the second worker. Plowing and threshing together cover the whole farming year, from start to finish.
-
ἀλοῶν
aloōn · G0248
threshing · v10
The same verb used of the ox in v. 9 ('an ox while it is threshing'). Paul uses the law's own word to move from the ox to the human thresher. The verb 'ought to thresh' is left unsaid and understood.
-
μετέχειν
metechein · G3348
to share, to have a part in · v10
'To have a share': the thresher's portion of the grain he has worked. It points to v. 11, 'reap a material harvest from you'.
-
εἰ
ei · G1487
if · v11
Opens a condition Paul treats as true: 'if, as is the case, we sowed…'. It is not a real question about whether he did.
-
ὑμῖν
humin · G4771
to you / for you · v11
'For you' or 'among you'. The Corinthians were the field and the ones who benefited from the sowing.
-
πνευματικὰ
pneumatika · G4152
spiritual · v11
Things that come from and belong to God's Spirit: the gospel message, teaching, and the Spirit's gifts that came with it (compare 2:12–13). In this letter it is a word the Corinthians prized.
-
ἐσπείραμεν
espeiramen · G4687
we sowed · v11
Past tense: the sowing is a finished event, Paul's founding mission in Corinth (Acts 18). It continues the farm pictures of verses 7–10 and echoes 3:6, 'I planted'.
-
μέγα
mega · G3173
great · v11
'A big thing', meaning 'too much to ask' or 'a big deal'. Paul's rhetorical question expects the answer 'No, of course not.'
-
σαρκικὰ
sarkika · G4559
fleshly, material · v11
Things that belong to bodily life: food, lodging, money, the means of living. It carries no moral judgment here. It means 'physical' or 'material', not 'sinful'.
-
θερίσομεν
therisomen · G2325
we will reap · v11
Future tense, with harvest imagery. Paul speaks of a harvest he could rightly take, not one he has taken. Verses 12 and 15 say he has not used this right in Corinth.
The world behind it
The argument of 1 Corinthians 8–10. Paul is dealing with food offered to idols and with "rights" (ἐξουσία). Chapter 9 is his own example: as an apostle he has every right to be supported, to eat and drink, and to bring a wife along (vv. 4–6). He proves this right from soldiers, vineyard workers and shepherds (v. 7), from the Law (vv. 8–10), from temple practice (v. 13), and from a command of Jesus (v. 14). Then he says he has given it up (vv. 12, 15–18), as a model for the Corinthians to give up their "right" to eat idol meat for the sake of weaker believers.
Why support was a sore point in Corinth. In a Roman city, accepting money from a wealthy household often made the receiver that household's client, socially obligated to the patron. Travelling teachers and philosophers were judged by how they were paid (fees, patronage, begging, or a trade). Paul worked with his hands in Corinth (Acts 18:3; 1 Cor 4:12), and some there seem to have held this against him. Verse 10 shows he is not refusing support because he thinks it wrong; it is fully legitimate.
Farm work in the ancient world. Plowing (with an ox-drawn wooden plow) began the agricultural year after the autumn rains; threshing on an open hard-packed floor ended it in early summer. Farm laborers and sharecroppers were commonly paid with a portion of the produce. The ox of Deut 25:4 walked over the sheaves on the threshing floor, and an unmuzzled ox could snatch mouthfuls of grain as it worked.
How Jews read Deut 25:4. Some Jewish interpreters took the law literally as kindness to animals (Josephus, Antiquities 4.233; Philo, On the Virtues 145). Philo elsewhere could say that laws about animals are really about rational human beings (Special Laws 1.260). Rabbinic tradition (cf. Mishnah Bava Metzia 7) discussed a laborer's right to eat from the produce he works with, and reasoned by analogy between animal and human workers. Paul's move from ox to apostle would have sounded like a familiar kind of argument, especially the "lesser to greater" reasoning (if this holds for an ox, how much more for a person). Deut 25:4 also sits among laws about human justice and dignity (Deut 24–25), which may be part of why Paul hears it as a law about people.
From the study of 1 Corinthians 9:10.
Where scholars differ
in v10
Is Paul denying that Deut 25:4 is about real oxen (allegory), or extending it from lesser to greater?
-
Allegorical or 'spiritual sense' reading: Paul, like Philo, holds that God's real concern in the law is rational people, not animals.
The rhetorical question in v. 9 expects the answer 'no' ('Is God concerned about oxen?'), and KJV/NASB 'altogether for our sake' can be read as 'exclusively'. Compare Philo, Special Laws 1.260, 'the law is not for irrational creatures but for those who have mind and reason.'
-
Lesser-to-greater (qal wa-ḥomer) reading: Paul accepts the literal law and argues that if God secures food for a working ox, he all the more secures it for human workers.
πάντως usually means 'surely', not 'only'. Paul's wording in v. 9 can mean 'is God's concern merely for oxen?' The 'how much more' style of argument was standard in Jewish interpretation, and Paul elsewhere upholds the literal force of the Law.
-
Contextual or literal-human reading: Deut 25:4 was already understood as a law about just treatment of workers, and Paul reads it in its setting.
Deut 25:4 sits among laws about human justice (Deut 24:14–15, wages paid promptly; 25:1–3, limits on beating). Instone-Brewer (NTS 1992) argues that Jewish interpreters applied it to human laborers, which would make Paul's use close to a plain reading.
in v10
What does ὅτι introduce?
-
Causal, 'because': it gives the reason the law was written for us, namely that labor is rightly done in expectation of a share.
Followed by BSB, NIV and ESV; fits the flow of argument into v. 11.
-
Explanatory or content, 'that': it states what the Scripture means (KJV, 'that he that ploweth…').
After 'it was written', ὅτι naturally introduces content; compare Rom 4:23, 'it was not written for his sake alone that…'.
-
Introducing a quotation from an unknown source.
The rhythmic, proverb-like shape of the clause and the farming parallels in Sirach 6:19 and 2 Tim 2:6. No source has been identified, so this remains a minority view.
in v10
Who is 'us'?
-
Paul and fellow apostolic workers.
The immediate context is about the rights of Paul and Barnabas (v. 6), and v. 11 says 'we sowed… among you'.
-
Christians generally, as readers of Scripture.
Paul's general principle that Scripture was 'written for our instruction' (Rom 15:4; 1 Cor 10:11). Many interpreters see both senses: written for the church, and applied here to its workers.
in v11
Why did Paul refuse support in Corinth when he says he had every right to it?
-
To avoid becoming a client of wealthy patrons, which would tie the gospel to their status and interests.
Corinth's patronage culture. Paul's insistence on being free from all (9:19). In 2 Cor 11:9–12 he refuses to be a 'burden' and wants to cut off opportunity from rivals. Associated with scholars such as Gerd Theissen and Peter Marshall (who argues that refusing gifts broke friendship conventions and caused hostility).
-
To present himself on the model of the self-supporting teacher and show his message was not for sale.
Ronald Hock's work on Paul's tentmaking and the debates among philosophers about how teachers should earn a living. Compare 1 Thess 2:5–9 and 2 Cor 2:17 ('not peddlers of God's word').
-
Mainly as a personal 'boast' and example: freely giving up a right, as a model for the 'strong' in the idol-food dispute.
The structure of chapters 8–10: 9:12b, 15–18 ('my reward is to offer the gospel free of charge') and 9:19–23 sit inside the argument about giving up rights for others (8:9–13; 10:23–33).
Sources
- BDAG s.v. πάντως, ἐλπίς, ὀφείλω, μετέχω, ἀλοάω
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. πάντως
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on 1 Cor 9:10
- Nestle-Aland 28th edition / SBLGNT, 1 Cor 9:10
- Gordon D. Fee, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NICNT)
- Anthony C. Thiselton, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NIGTC)
- David E. Garland, 1 Corinthians (BECNT)
- David Instone-Brewer, '1 Corinthians 9.9–11: A Literal Interpretation of "Do Not Muzzle the Ox"', New Testament Studies 38 (1992)
- Philo, On the Special Laws 1.260; On the Virtues 145
- Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 4.233
- Mishnah Bava Metzia 7
- Vulgate, 1 Cor 9:10
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on 1 Cor 9
- BDAG s.v. σαρκικός, πνευματικός, μέγας, θερίζω, σπείρω
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. σαρκικός
- NA28 critical apparatus at 1 Cor 9:11
- Ronald F. Hock, The Social Context of Paul's Ministry: Tentmaking and Apostleship
- Peter Marshall, Enmity in Corinth
- Gerd Theissen, The Social Setting of Pauline Christianity
- Vulgate, 1 Cor 9:11
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).