1 Samuel Chapter 17 Read as one passage
1 Samuel 17:13–18
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
13The three older sons of Jesse had followed Saul into battle: The firstborn was Eliab, the second was Abinadab, and the third was Shammah. 14And David was the youngest. The three oldest had followed Saul, 15but David went back and forth from Saul to tend his father’s sheep in Bethlehem. 16For forty days the Philistine came forward every morning and evening to take his stand. 17One day Jesse said to his son David, “Take this ephah of roasted grain and these ten loaves of bread for your brothers and hurry to their camp. 18Take also these ten portions of cheese to the commander of their unit. Check on the welfare of your brothers and bring back an assurance from them.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers this verse did more than supply family data. It placed David within a known Judahite household: the sons of Jesse of Bethlehem were remembered figures, and their descendants appear later in the David story (Jonadab, son of Shimeah, in 2 Sam 13; Jonathan, son of Shimei, the giant-killer in 2 Sam 21). The verse also set the stage for the contest that follows.
The three oldest have done the honourable and expected thing by going to war under the king. Still, the whole army, these brothers included, will stand frozen for forty days in front of Goliath (v.16). Naming them as "the big ones", with the firstborn at their head, prepares hearers for a familiar turn in Israel's story: God passes over the expected heir and works through the youngest and least regarded. In a book that explains why the house of David, not the house of Saul, came to rule, the contrast matters. Saul's loyal soldiers are in the field, and the true king has not yet arrived.
From the study of 1 Samuel 17:13.
Verse by verse
-
13The three older sons of Jesse had followed Saul into battle: The firstborn was Eliab, the second was Abinadab, and the third was Shammah.
Full study →Jesse's three "big" sons, meaning his three oldest, had already left home and joined Saul's army for the war against the Philistines. They had answered the king's call-up and placed themselves under his command. The narrator then lists them formally, in rank order, the way a family record or muster list would: Eliab, the firstborn and heir; next after him Abinadab; and third Shammah.
The heavy repetition ("went … had gone … who had gone to the war") keeps the reader's attention on who went to the front, and so on who did not. The list matches, name for name and in the same order, the brothers Samuel looked over and God turned down in chapter 16. Calling them "the big ones" sets up the next line, where David is "the small one". Without saying so, the verse lays out the chapter's tension: the oldest, tallest and highest-ranking sons are in the army following Saul, the king God has rejected, while the youngest, already anointed in secret, is still at home with his father's sheep.
-
14And David was the youngest. The three oldest had followed Saul,
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
15but David went back and forth from Saul to tend his father’s sheep in Bethlehem.
Full study →Meanwhile David kept shuttling back and forth: he would leave his place at Saul's side and go home to Bethlehem to shepherd his father's flock.
The verse is a background note, not a story event. The verb forms describe a repeated pattern: David kept going and coming back. The three oldest sons of Jesse had gone to war with Saul (v.14). The youngest was not a soldier. He was a part-time attendant at court who regularly went home because the family flock of sheep and goats needed him. To "shepherd" a flock meant leading it to grass and water and defending it from lions and bears (vv.34–35). The narrator uses the same verb that Israel used for kings, who "shepherd" their people. So the line explains why David is in Bethlehem and not at the front when his father sends him with food (vv.17–18). It also quietly points ahead: the boy tending his father's flock is the one who will shepherd Israel.
-
16For forty days the Philistine came forward every morning and evening to take his stand.
Full study →"And the Philistine kept coming out toward Israel's lines, at first light and again as evening fell, and planted himself there, daring them, for forty days."
The verse is short, but every word makes the scene heavier:
- "Came forward / drew near" describes an advance into the open valley between the two armies. He closes the distance and waits to be met.
- "Early and evening" translates two matching Hebrew verb forms used as adverbs, roughly "doing-early and doing-late". The second form was apparently coined for this verse to rhyme with the first. It sounds like a drumbeat: dawn and dusk, the hours when armies formed their battle lines, every day.
- "Took his stand" means he deliberately set himself in place, a defiant posture. The same verb appears in God's promise that "no one will be able to stand before you" (Deut 7:24; Josh 1:5), and in Israel's old fear, "Who can stand before the sons of Anak?" (Deut 9:2). Here someone does stand before Israel, a giant from Gath, and nobody answers.
- "Forty days" is the Bible's number for a full period of testing. It may echo the spies' forty days that ended in terror of giants (Num 13). The standoff is long, complete and humiliating.
Coming right after the aside about David going back and forth to his father's sheep (v. 15), the verse picks the battle scene up again and lets time pass. The challenge has hardened into a routine of daily disgrace for Israel and its tall king Saul. That is the situation the shepherd boy is about to walk into (v. 17).
-
17One day Jesse said to his son David, “Take this ephah of roasted grain and these ten loaves of bread for your brothers and hurry to their camp.
Full study →So Jesse said to his son David: "Now then, take this sack of roasted grain for your brothers, a full ephah (about twenty litres), and these ten loaves I have ready here, and get them to the camp fast, to your brothers."
The scene is ordinary on purpose. An old father cannot go to war himself (v.12), and he is worried about the three sons who did go (v.13). He has packed the field soldier's basic rations: roasted grain that needs no cooking, plus home-baked flatbread. Ten cheeses for their commander follow in the next verse. He gives the job to the youngest, the boy who otherwise looks after the sheep. The words of his order carry warmth and urgency together. The small word na softens the command ("go on, now"). The verb means "make it run": do not dawdle. "To your brothers" is said twice, at the start and at the end, so the errand is framed as care for family, not an army chore. Hebrew readers would also hear an echo of Jacob sending his youngest-but-one son Joseph out to check on his brothers in the field (Gen 37). That errand also ended with an older brother resenting the younger (compare Eliab in v.28) and with the younger rising far above them all. The bread errand is how the shepherd boy ends up on the battlefield.
-
18Take also these ten portions of cheese to the commander of their unit. Check on the welfare of your brothers and bring back an assurance from them.
Full study →"And these ten cut pieces of fresh cheese, these right here, deliver to the officer over your brothers' unit (their 'thousand'). As for your brothers, go and look in on them and see that they are whole and safe. Then bring back something from them I can hold onto, a token that proves they are alive and got what we sent."
Old Jesse (v. 12) is speaking to his youngest son. He is completing the parcel begun in v. 17: grain and bread for the sons, and dairy food from the family's flocks as a gift for their commander. In a tribal army that had to feed itself, that gift helped keep the officer well disposed toward three young men from Bethlehem. The verb for "look in on" is the one used for mustering troops and for a father taking stock of his household. The phrase "see to your brothers' well-being" echoes Jacob sending young Joseph to his brothers (Gen 37:14), a story whose readers knew a youngest son's errand can change everything. The "pledge" is not a promise. It is a physical token, the kind of thing handed over as surety, so the father at home gets proof and not just word.
Where the English drifted
-
in v15
to feed (KJV, WEB)
lir'ot (ra'ah)
- What we hear
- Giving the animals food, as you would feed a pet.
- What they heard
- To pasture and shepherd: leading the flock to grazing and water, protecting it and keeping it together. The same verb is used for rulers caring for their people.
-
in v15
sheep
tson
- What we hear
- Only sheep.
- What they heard
- A mixed flock of small livestock, sheep and goats together.
-
in v16
presented himself (KJV, WEB)
wayyityatsev
- What we hear
- Made an appearance, showed up, or introduced himself, as in 'presenting oneself' at an interview or a social occasion.
- What they heard
- Deliberately planted himself in position facing the enemy. It is a defiant, combative stance that dares the other side to come and move him.
-
in v17
parched corn (KJV)
qālî
- What we hear
- Roasted maize, like corn kernels or corn on the cob.
- What they heard
- Roasted grain, usually barley or wheat. Maize was unknown in the ancient Near East.
-
in v18
pledge (KJV)
ʿarubbah
- What we hear
- A promise, or a commitment to give money.
- What they heard
- A concrete token or surety, an object that stands in for someone's word or presence. Here it is proof from the brothers that they are alive and got the supplies.
-
in v18
captain of their thousand
sar ha'elef
- What we hear
- An officer in charge of exactly 1,000 soldiers.
- What they heard
- The commander of a major unit of the tribal levy, a unit called an 'elef. The word also meant a clan, and the actual size may have been much smaller than 1,000.
Every word
-
וַיֵּ֨לְכ֜וּ
vayyelkhu · H1980
and they went · v13, v15
The usual verb form for moving a story forward ('and they went'). Here it sits awkwardly beside the same verb a few words later, so the clause reads like background: the brothers had already left for the war.
-
שְׁלֹ֤שֶׁת
shloshet · H7969
three · v13
'The three of', tied grammatically to 'sons'. The number matters: three sons are at the front, and v.14 counts them again.
-
בְּנֵֽי־
bnei · H1121
sons of · v13, v17
Literal sons. In this setting it also means men answerable to their father's household, which is why Jesse sends David to check on them (v.18).
-
יִשַׁי֙
yishai · H3448
Jesse · v13, v17
David's father, a Bethlehemite of Judah. The previous verse says he was too old to go to war himself.
-
הַגְּדֹלִ֔ים
haggedolim · H1419
the great ones; the older · v13
Literally 'the big ones', the ordinary Hebrew way of saying 'the oldest'. It is set against David, 'the small one' (haqqatan), in the next verse, and the big/small contrast runs through the whole Goliath story.
-
אַחֲרֵי־
acharei · H310
after, behind · v13
'Go after' someone means joining them as a follower. Here it means mustering under Saul as their commander.
-
שָׁא֖וּל
sha'ul · H7586
Saul · v13, v15
The reigning king. By this point the reader knows God has rejected him (ch. 15) and that David has been secretly anointed (ch. 16), so 'following Saul' is ironic.
-
לַמִּלְחָמָ֑ה
lammilchamah · H4421
to the battle/war · v13
'To the war': the standoff with the Philistines in the Valley of Elah (vv.1–3).
-
וְשֵׁ֣ם׀
veshem · H8034
and the name of · v13
Singular 'name' used before a list of several people, a normal Hebrew way of saying 'and their names were'.
-
אֲשֶׁ֤ר
asher · H834
who, which · v13
Introduces the description 'who had gone'.
-
אֱלִיאָ֣ב
eli'av · H446
Eliab · v13
'My God is father'. He is the tall firstborn Samuel thought must be God's choice (16:6–7), and he will scold David in v.28.
-
הַבְּכ֗וֹר
habbekhor · H1060
the firstborn · v13
The son with the highest standing and the double inheritance. Naming his rank sets up the reversal: the youngest, not the firstborn, will be the champion.
-
וּמִשְׁנֵ֙הוּ֙
umishnehu · H4932
and his second · v13
Literally 'his second', meaning the one next to him in birth order: 'next after him'.
-
אֲבִ֣ינָדָ֔ב
avinadav · H41
Abinadab · v13
'My father is generous/noble'. He is the second son Samuel passed over (16:8).
-
וְהַשְּׁלִשִׁ֖י
vehashlishi · H7992
and the third · v13
The ordinal number 'third', completing the ranked list.
-
שַׁמָּֽה׃
shammah · H8048
Shammah · v13
The third son, also passed over in 16:9. Elsewhere he is called Shimea/Shimeah (2 Sam 13:3; 1 Chr 2:13).
-
וְדָוִ֛ד
vedavid · H1732
and David · v15, v17
Putting David's name first, before the verb, breaks away from the brothers just listed in v.14 and sets him in contrast: they stayed with Saul, but David moved back and forth. The 'and' here works like 'but' or 'meanwhile'.
-
וָשָׁ֖ב
vashav · H7725
and returning · v15
Another participle, paired with the first. 'Going and returning' is a Hebrew way of saying 'back and forth, to and fro'. It describes a regular shuttle, not one departure and one return.
-
מֵעַ֣ל
me'al · H5921
from upon, from beside, away from · v15
A compound of 'from' + 'upon/over/beside'. With a person it means leaving that person's side. A servant was said to 'stand over' a seated master, so it may hint that David was stepping away from waiting on the king.
-
לִרְע֛וֹת
lir'ot · H7462
to pasture, to shepherd · v15
'In order to shepherd.' This gives the reason David kept going home: to lead the flock to grazing, water it and guard it. It is the same verb Israel later uses for a king ruling his people (2 Sam 5:2).
-
אֶת־
et- · H0853
(object marker) · v15, v18
An untranslatable word that marks 'the flock' as the definite object of the verb 'shepherd'.
-
צֹ֥אן
tson · H6629
flock, small livestock · v15
A collective word for a mixed flock of sheep and goats. It does not mean sheep only. Here it is the family's working wealth.
-
אָבִ֖יו
aviv · H1
his father · v15
Jesse. The flock belongs to the head of the household, and the youngest son is the one sent to look after it (compare 16:11).
-
בֵּֽית־
beit- · H1035
house of · v15
First half of the place name Bethlehem. With no preposition, the name tells us where the shepherding took place: 'at Bethlehem'.
-
וַיִּגַּ֥שׁ
wayyiggash · H5066
and he drew near, approached · v16
The ordinary storytelling verb form ('and he did X'), here used for an action repeated day after day. Nagash is the word for closing the distance, often to engage in battle; the Philistine walks out from his lines toward Israel's.
-
הַפְּלִשְׁתִּ֖י
happelishti · H6430
the Philistine · v16
Goliath is named only twice in the chapter (vv. 4, 23). Most of the time the narrator just calls him 'the Philistine', so he stands for the whole enemy people and their threat.
-
הַשְׁכֵּ֣ם
hashkem · H7925
rising early, doing early · v16
A verb form used as an adverb: 'early, in the morning'. It means he came at first light, as the armies formed up.
-
וְהַעֲרֵ֑ב
weha'arev · H6150
and doing evening, at evening · v16
The same construction made from the word for 'evening'. It is used this way only here in the Bible, coined to rhyme with 'hashkem': 'early and late', morning and evening.
-
וַיִּתְיַצֵּ֖ב
wayyityatsev · H3320
and he stationed himself, took his stand · v16
A reflexive form: 'he set himself in place'. It describes a deliberate, defiant planting of oneself, the posture of someone who dares an opponent to move him.
-
אַרְבָּעִ֥ים
arba'im · H705
forty · v16
In Israel's stories forty is the standard number for a full period of testing or waiting (the flood, Moses on the mountain, the spies, Elijah). It may also be meant literally, but either way it tells the hearer that this went on for a long, complete stretch.
-
יֽוֹם׃ פ
yom · H3117
day · v16
Singular after a number, which is normal Hebrew for 'forty days'. The פ after the word is a scribal paragraph marker in the Hebrew manuscripts, not a word of the text.
-
וַיֹּ֨אמֶר
vayyōmer · H0559
and he said · v17
The usual Hebrew way of moving a story forward: 'and then (he) said.' It starts a new scene after the stand-off described in v.16.
-
קַח־
qaḥ · H3947G
take · v17, v18
A plain command: 'take.' Here it means pick up these supplies and carry them.
-
נָ֤א
nāʾ · H4994
please / now · v17
A small word added to commands. It softens the order or adds a sense of 'go on, now.' A father speaking to his son does not need to beg, so 'please' may be too polite. It is more like a warm 'now, take…'.
-
לְאַחֶ֙יךָ֙
ləʾaḥêḵā · H0251G
for your brothers · v17, v18
'For your brothers.' These are the three oldest, Eliab, Abinadab and Shammah (v.13), who are with Saul's army.
-
אֵיפַ֤ת
ʾêp̄aṯ · H0374
ephah (of) · v17
A standard dry measure. Most estimates put it at about 20 litres, though estimates range from about 10 to 22. That is a sizeable sack of grain for one young man to carry about 25 km.
-
הַקָּלִיא֙
haqqālîʾ · H7039
the roasted grain · v17
Grain kernels roasted over a fire. They keep well and can be eaten without further cooking, which makes them ideal field food for soldiers.
-
הַזֶּ֔ה
hazzeh · H2088
this · v17
'This' roasted grain. Jesse points at grain that has already been made ready, as if it is sitting in front of them.
-
וַעֲשָׂרָ֥ה
vaʿăśārâ · H6235
and ten · v17, v18
'And ten.' This matches the ten cheeses in v.18. The two groups of ten make a tidy, generous package.
-
לֶ֖חֶם
leḥem · H3899H
bread · v17
Grammatically singular ('ten bread'), but after a number it means loaves. These were probably flat, round loaves baked at home.
-
וְהָרֵ֥ץ
vəhārēṣ · H7323G
and bring quickly · v17
Literally 'and make run.' The verb form means 'cause to run,' so 'get these to them fast.' It stresses urgency: the food should arrive quickly.
-
הַֽמַּחֲנֶ֖ה
hammaḥăneh · H4264
the camp · v17
The army's encampment in the Valley of Elah (v.2). Hebrew uses no preposition here. The word on its own means 'to the camp.'
-
חֲרִצֵי
ḥaritsei · H2757
something cut; slice · v18
"Cuttings of." It comes from a root meaning "to cut, cut into." Here it means cut pieces or slices of a dairy product. Elsewhere the same noun names sharp iron cutting or threshing tools (2 Sam 12:31).
-
הֶחָלָב
heḥalav · H2461
milk · v18
"The milk." Together, "cuttings of the milk" is a Hebrew way of describing solidified milk cut into pieces: soft or pressed fresh cheese or curd, not drinkable milk.
-
הָאֵלֶּה
ha'elleh · H0428
these · v18
"These." Jesse is pointing at the actual food in front of him, the way v. 17 says "this ephah… these loaves."
-
תָּבִיא
tavi' · H0935
bring (causative of 'come') · v18
"You will bring / deliver." The Hebrew future form here works as a father's instruction: deliver these personally.
-
לְשַׂר־
lesar- · H8269
to the chief/officer of · v18
"To the chief of." A sar is any official or commander. Here it is the officer over the unit the brothers serve in.
-
הָאָלֶף
ha'alef · H0505
thousand; clan/military unit · v18
"The thousand." This was the standard name for a large unit of the tribal levy (the men called up to fight). It may stand for a clan-based contingent rather than exactly 1,000 men.
-
תִּפְקֹד
tifqod · H6485
visit, attend to, inspect, muster · v18
"You will look in on / see to." Paqad means going to someone and taking stock of how they are. The same verb is used for mustering troops, so a father's word sits naturally in a military camp.
-
לְשָׁלוֹם
leshalom · H7965
well-being, wholeness, safety · v18
"For their well-being." David is to check that his brothers are whole and unharmed. Shalom here is their physical and general welfare in a war zone, not inner peace.
-
עֲרֻבָּתָם
ʿarubbatam · H6161
pledge, surety, token · v18
"Their pledge / token." This is something from the brothers that Jesse can trust. It could be a sign that they are alive and got the supplies, or an item tied to a pledge. The exact sense is debated.
The world behind it
- How Israel went to war. In Saul's day Israel had no large professional army. The king had a core of picked men (1 Sam 14:52) and called up men from the tribes when war came. Households sent their able sons, and families supplied them with food. That is why Jesse sends David with grain, bread and cheese, and why he wants a token back to show his sons are safe (17:17–18). Jesse himself was "old and well along in years" (v.12), too old to serve, so his three oldest went in his place.
- Birth order mattered. The firstborn son carried the family's honour and stood to inherit a double portion. Listing sons by rank was normal, and an ancient hearer would expect the firstborn to lead. Israel's own stories, though, kept reversing that expectation (Jacob over Esau, Joseph over his older brothers).
- Echo of chapter 16. In 16:6–10 Jesse paraded his sons before Samuel, Eliab first, then Abinadab, then Shammah, and God rejected each one, warning Samuel not to judge by appearance or height. Hearers who knew that scene would recognise the same three names in the same order here.
- Why David is introduced as if for the first time. Verse 12 introduces David and Jesse almost as though the reader has never met them, even though ch. 16 has already done so. This is one sign that the chapter draws on more than one account of how David came to Saul (see textual notes).
From the study of 1 Samuel 17:13.
Where scholars differ
in v13
Why does the oldest Greek text lack this verse (and all of 17:12–31)?
-
The Hebrew combines two once-separate accounts of how David came to Saul. The shorter Greek preserves an earlier form of the text before the second account (which includes this verse) was added.
Verse 12 re-introduces David and Jesse as if they were new characters. In 17:55–58 Saul asks who David is, even though David has already served him in 16:14–23. Without the extra verses the Greek tells a smooth single story. This view is held by E. Tov, J. Lust and P. K. McCarter.
-
The Greek translator, or the Hebrew text he worked from, deliberately shortened the chapter to remove apparent contradictions.
The Septuagint of Samuel generally translates its source closely, but harmonizing omissions are known elsewhere in ancient texts. The longer Hebrew narrative reads coherently as a literary whole with deliberate retelling. This view is argued by D. W. Gooding and D. Barthélemy in *The Story of David and Goliath* (1986).
in v15
Is v.15 an original part of the story, or an editorial bridge joining two different accounts of how David came to Saul?
-
It is an editorial bridge in a combined text.
The oldest Greek lacks the whole 17:12–31 unit, including this verse. Chapter 17 introduces David and Jesse again as if they were new (17:12), and in 17:55–58 Saul does not know David, even though David is his armor-bearer in 16:21. On this view, v.15 smooths the seam by saying David's court service was intermittent. This is the position of many critical scholars, e.g. P. Kyle McCarter (Anchor Bible) and Emanuel Tov.
-
It belongs to the original narrative, and the shorter Greek is an abridgement.
Some scholars, such as D. W. Gooding and D. Barthélemy in their joint study with Tov and Lust, argue that a translator or earlier editor cut passages to remove apparent contradictions. On this view the longer Hebrew story is coherent: David served Saul only occasionally, and Saul's question in 17:55 concerns David's family background, which matters because the victor was promised Saul's daughter (17:25).
in v15
Do the participles describe a regular shuttle or a past return home?
-
A regular, repeated movement ('kept going back and forth').
Participles in a background clause usually describe ongoing or habitual states. The 'going and returning' pairing elsewhere means to-and-fro motion (Gen 8:7; Ezek 1:14). Most modern versions read it this way.
-
A flashback: David had left Saul's service and gone back home.
The Vulgate's past-perfect verbs and Josephus's retelling, in which Saul sent David home when the war began, take it as a situation already completed when the battle story opens. This also fits David being at home in v.17.
in v16
Is the shorter Greek version of the David and Goliath story (which lacks this verse) older than the longer Hebrew version, or a shortened form of it?
-
The Greek preserves an earlier, shorter story. The Hebrew (Masoretic) text later wove in a second, independent account of David's introduction (17:12–31, 55–58), and v. 16 is part of that added material or a join between the two.
In the longer text, vv. 12–31 and 55–58 sit awkwardly with 16:14–23. David is introduced as if unknown, and Saul does not recognise him, though David was already Saul's armour-bearer. Vv. 15–16 look like a deliberate bridge. Advocates include E. Tov, P. K. McCarter and J. Lust (Barthélemy, Gooding, Lust and Tov, The Story of David and Goliath, 1986).
-
The Greek translator, or the Hebrew text he worked from, deliberately shortened a longer original to remove apparent contradictions.
The Old Greek of Samuel is generally literal, which makes wholesale cutting unusual, but these omissions remove exactly the passages that cause tension. Their removal can be read as harmonisation. Advocates include D. Barthélemy and D. W. Gooding. Some literary readers argue the longer text is a coherent narrative that is deliberately repetitive.
in v16
What does 'morning and evening' signify?
-
A literal military routine: he appeared at the two times the armies drew up in formation.
17:20 shows the army going out to the battle line in the morning. Midday heat made dawn and dusk the natural times for display and action.
-
A paired expression ('early and late') meaning 'all day, every day', that is, relentlessly.
The matching pair of infinitives hashkem/ha'arev, with the second coined to rhyme with the first, reads like an idiom of persistence. Hashkem alone carries the sense 'persistently' in Jeremiah (7:13; 25:3–4).
-
A deliberate echo of Israel's twice-daily worship (the morning and evening offerings, Exod 29:38–42; Num 28:3–8), or in later tradition the twice-daily Shema.
The phrase 'morning and evening' is closely tied to the daily offering in the Torah. Rabbinic interpretation (b. Sotah 42b) took Goliath's timing as an attack on Israel's morning and evening devotion. There is nothing in the immediate context of 1 Samuel 17 that points to worship, so this is best seen as a later interpretive reading rather than the plain sense.
in v17
Why does the oldest Greek text lack this verse and the whole errand scene (17:12–31)?
-
The shorter Greek reflects an older Hebrew text. The Masoretic text combined it with a second, separate account of how David came to the battle, in which he is an unknown shepherd sent with food.
The longer text introduces David again in 17:12 as if he were new, even after 16:18–23. Saul does not recognise him in 17:55–58. Elsewhere the Old Greek of Samuel is a fairly literal translation, so large cuts would be unusual for it. Held by Emanuel Tov, P. Kyle McCarter Jr., Johan Lust and others.
-
The Greek translator, or the Hebrew text he worked from, deliberately shortened the story to remove apparent contradictions. The longer Masoretic account is the more original form.
The omissions match exactly the passages that cause tension with ch. 16. Ancient editors were known to smooth such tensions. The longer story is literarily unified, for example the Joseph echo and the 'running' motif. Argued by Dominique Barthélemy and David W. Gooding (in Barthélemy et al., The Story of David and Goliath, 1986).
in v17
What does the particle na' add to Jesse's command?
-
It is a politeness marker, roughly 'please.'
Common in requests to superiors and in respectful speech. Traditional grammars and KJV/YLT 'now / I pray thee' reflect this.
-
It marks a command that follows from the situation or adds gentle urgency ('go on, then'), and is not mainly about deference.
It is often used by superiors to people under them, as here from father to son, where pleading makes no sense. Proposed by Thomas Lambdin and refined in later studies of Hebrew politeness and urgency (e.g. Joüon–Muraoka §105c discussion; Shulman; Christiansen).
in v18
What is the "pledge" (ʿarubbah) David is to bring back?
-
A token proving the brothers are alive and received the supplies.
The ʿ-r-b root's sense of "surety, guarantee," and the context of a father anxious for his sons. Compare Gen 37:14 "bring me back word." ESV "token" and BSB "assurance" follow this.
-
A pledge item to be redeemed or exchanged, in the sense of settling the brothers' affairs: what they owe, need, or left as security.
ʿArubbah / ʿeravon elsewhere means an item given as security (Gen 38:17–20; Prov 17:18). The Septuagint's "whatever they need" may point in the same practical direction.
-
Conditional divorce documents, so wives would not be left unable to remarry if husbands went missing (rabbinic).
b. Ketubot 9b; b. Shabbat 56a. This is a later legal interpretation with no support in the narrative itself.
in v18
Does 'elef mean a literal thousand here?
-
A unit nominally of 1,000 men.
The standard number word, and the decimal military organisation in Exod 18:21 and 1 Sam 8:12.
-
A clan-based unit of variable, possibly much smaller, size.
'Elef means "clan" in Judg 6:15 and 1 Sam 10:19. Some scholars (e.g. G. E. Mendenhall) argue that early military 'elef units were tribal contingents and not literal thousands.
Sources
- BDB and HALOT s.v. הָלַךְ (idiom הָלַךְ אַחֲרֵי)
- HALOT s.v. גָּדוֹל
- HALOT s.v. מִשְׁנֶה
- S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel (2nd ed., 1913), on 1 Sam 17:12–13
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8), on 1 Sam 17
- D. Barthélemy, D. W. Gooding, J. Lust, E. Tov, The Story of David and Goliath: Textual and Literary Criticism (1986)
- E. Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible, on 1 Samuel 16–18
- R. W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
- Septuagint (Codex Vaticanus, Codex Alexandrinus); Vulgate 1 Reg 17:13
- BDB and HALOT s.v. רָעָה (to pasture, shepherd; figuratively to rule)
- BDB and HALOT s.v. צֹאן (small livestock, sheep and goats)
- BDB s.v. עַל, מֵעַל
- Waltke & O'Connor, An Introduction to Biblical Hebrew Syntax, on participles describing ongoing or repeated action
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 17:12–31 and the Septuagint
- E. Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
- Josephus, Jewish Antiquities book 6
- Code of Hammurabi, prologue (the king as 'shepherd')
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 16–17
- BDB s.v. נָגַשׁ, שָׁכַם, עָרַב II, יָצַב
- HALOT s.v. שׁכם hif., ערב II hif., יצב hitp.
- Waltke & O'Connor, An Introduction to Biblical Hebrew Syntax §35.4 (adverbial use of the infinitive absolute)
- Gesenius–Kautzsch–Cowley, Hebrew Grammar §113 (infinitive absolute)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8), 1980
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
- D. Barthélemy, D. W. Gooding, J. Lust, E. Tov, The Story of David and Goliath: Textual and Literary Criticism (OBO 73), 1986
- Emanuel Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible (on 1 Sam 17–18 in LXX)
- H. A. Hoffner, 'A Hittite Analogue to the David and Goliath Contest of Champions?', CBQ 30 (1968)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 17
- Babylonian Talmud, Sotah 42b
- BDB s.v. קָלִי, אֵיפָה, רוּץ, מַחֲנֶה, נָא
- HALOT s.v. קָלִי; אֵיפָה; רוּץ hif.
- Joüon–Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew §105c (on נָא)
- T. O. Lambdin, Introduction to Biblical Hebrew (on נָא)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 17:12–31
- E. Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible (on LXX 1 Sam 17–18)
- P. J. King & L. E. Stager, Life in Biblical Israel (food, measures, warfare)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Sam 17:17–18
- Robert Alter, The David Story (on the Joseph echo)
- BDB s.v. חָרִיץ, עֲרֻבָּה, פָּקַד, אֶלֶף
- HALOT s.v. חָרִיץ, עֲרֻבָּה, פקד, אֶלֶף
- Septuagint 1 Kingdoms 17 (Codex Alexandrinus / Lucianic text; absent in Codex Vaticanus)
- Vulgate 1 Samuel 17:18
- Babylonian Talmud, Ketubot 9b; Shabbat 56a
- P. Kyle McCarter, I Samuel (Anchor Bible) on 17:12–31
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, 1 Sam 17
- G. E. Mendenhall, "The Census Lists of Numbers 1 and 26," JBL 77 (1958)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.