2 Samuel Chapter 21 Read as one passage
2 Samuel 21:4–5
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
4The Gibeonites said to him, “We need no silver or gold from Saul or his house, nor should you put to death anyone in Israel for us.” “Whatever you ask, I will do for you,” he replied. 5And they answered the king, “As for the man who consumed us and plotted against us to exterminate us from existing within any border of Israel,
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers this short exchange made several things clear:
- An oath sworn in YHWH's name binds Israel across generations. Joshua's oath to the Gibeonites still held under Saul and David, centuries later. Breaking it brought national disaster. The God of Israel guards oaths made in his name, even oaths sworn to foreigners and obtained by a trick.
- Blood-guilt cannot be bought off. The Gibeonites' refusal of silver and gold matches Israel's own law (Numbers 35). Hearers would recognise that the land could be cleansed only by the guilty party's blood, not by payment.
- Guilt lay with Saul's house, not with Israel at large. The Gibeonites name 'Saul and his house' and disclaim any general vengeance on Israel. That narrows responsibility to the dynasty v. 1 calls a 'house of blood'.
- David acts as the king who restores order. By binding himself to the wronged party's terms ("whatever you say"), David appears as a king who takes on his predecessor's obligations to lift the curse. Ancient hearers could also see the political edge: the remedy will remove Saul's male heirs. The narrative makes the demand the Gibeonites' and the verdict YHWH's, which answers the suspicion that David was simply clearing away rivals (compare Shimei's accusation in 2 Sam 16:7–8).
From the study of 2 Samuel 21:4.
Verse by verse
-
4The Gibeonites said to him, “We need no silver or gold from Saul or his house, nor should you put to death anyone in Israel for us.” “Whatever you ask, I will do for you,” he replied.
Full study →The Gibeonites answered David's question, "With what shall I make atonement?", with a careful two-part legal statement. First: "This is not a matter for silver and gold between us and Saul and his family line." A killing could sometimes be settled with a payment to the injured party. They refuse that option, however rich the payment, because this is blood-guilt that Israel's own law says money cannot wash out of the land (Numbers 35:31–33). Second: "Nor is it our place to put to death just anyone in Israel." As non-Israelites living under Israel's sworn protection, they are not Israel's judges, and they are not after revenge on the nation at large. Their claim is against Saul and his house, the dead king whose dynasty broke the oath sworn to them in YHWH's name.
With money ruled out and general revenge ruled out, only one remedy is left, and they leave the king to open the door to it. David does: "Whatever you say, I will do for you." This can also be read as the pointed question "What, then, are you asking me to do for you?" Either way the king binds himself in advance to the injured party's terms. That sets up their demand for seven of Saul's descendants in vv. 5–6.
-
5And they answered the king, “As for the man who consumed us and plotted against us to exterminate us from existing within any border of Israel,
Full study →The Gibeonites answer David's open offer with a formal accusation. They do not name Saul. They begin, coldly, with "The man…": the man who finished us off. He did not just harm them. He carried their destruction through to the end. And the man who set his mind against us: it was planned, deliberate policy, not a fit of temper. Then their sentence seems to break, as people's sentences do when they recount a massacre: "we have been wiped out." The word they use is the one Israel's own law used for exterminating the nations of Canaan. That is the fate Israel had sworn to spare the Gibeonites. Saul's aim was that they should have no standing, no foothold, no recognised place anywhere within Israel's borders.
The sentence is left hanging. Its point arrives in the next verse: therefore let seven of his sons be handed over to us (v. 6). The verse works as the charge sheet in a blood-feud case. It sets out deliberate, near-total killing in breach of a sacred oath, a crime the law said no silver or gold could cover (v. 4; Num 35:31–33).
Where the English drifted
-
in v4
We need no silver or gold
ʾein-lanu kesef vezahav
- What we hear
- The Gibeonites aren't greedy or don't want a payoff. It sounds like a personal attitude toward money.
- What they heard
- A formal refusal of a cash settlement for bloodshed. They are saying this is not the kind of case money can settle, in line with the ban on ransom for murder in Numbers 35:31–33.
-
in v5
coasts (KJV)
gəbûl
- What we hear
- Seashores, coastlines: as if Saul drove the Gibeonites off Israel's beaches.
- What they heard
- Borders, and the territory inside them. The point is that they had no place anywhere in Israel's land. Gibeon was inland, in the hill country of Benjamin.
Every word
-
וַיֹּאמְרוּ
vayyomeru · H0559
and they said · v4, v5
The ordinary storytelling verb that moves the scene on. Here it opens the Gibeonites' formal reply to David's question in v. 3, 'How shall I make atonement?'
-
לוֹ
lo · H9033
to him · v4
To David, the king who has just asked them to name terms.
-
הַגִּבְעֹנִים
haggivʿonim · H1393
-
אֵין־
ʾein- · H0369
there is not · v4
Negates existence or possession. With 'to us' it means 'we have no…' or 'it is not our business / right to…', which is the phrasing of a legal claim.
-
לָנוּ
lanu · H9035
to us · v4, v5
'For us / ours.' The consonantal text has 'to me', corrected by scribes to 'to us'. Either way it marks what the Gibeonites claim or disclaim as theirs.
-
כֶּסֶף
kesef · H3701G
silver, money · v4
Silver was the ordinary money of the time, weighed out rather than counted as coins. Here it stands for a cash settlement for bloodshed.
-
וְזָהָב
vezahav · H2091
and gold · v4
Paired with silver, it means 'any payment, however rich'. They rule out even a lavish settlement.
-
עִם־
ʿim- · H5973A
with · v4
'With' in the sense of a matter between two parties: 'it is not a silver-and-gold matter between us and Saul.' It defines who the dispute is with.
-
שָׁאוּל
shaʾul · H7586G
Saul · v4
The dead king whose campaign against Gibeon (v. 2) broke Israel's sworn oath. He is named as the guilty party.
-
בֵּיתוֹ
beito · H1004M
his house · v4
Not a building. It means Saul's household and descendants, his dynasty. In v. 1 the divine verdict already names 'Saul and his house of blood'.
-
אִישׁ
ʾish · H0376G
a man, anyone · v4, v5
With a negative it means 'anyone, any man'. They are not asking for random Israelite lives. That leaves room for the precise demand in vv. 5–6.
-
לְהָמִית
lehamit · H4191
to put to death · v4
The causative form of 'die': 'to cause to die, execute'. It is the vocabulary of judicial execution, not murder.
-
בְּיִשְׂרָאֵל
beyisraʾel · H3478
in Israel · v4, v5
Within the people of Israel. The Gibeonites speak as outsiders living among Israel under its protection.
-
מָה־
mah- · H4100
what · v4
Can be a question ('What…?') or mean 'whatever'. That ambiguity is why translations split between a question and an open promise.
-
אַתֶּם
ʾattem · H0859D
you (plural) · v4
The 'you' is stated outright. It puts the choice squarely in the Gibeonites' hands.
-
אֶעֱשֶׂה
ʾeʿeseh · H6213A
I will do · v4
It repeats his own question from v. 3 ('What shall I do for you?'). Now it is a commitment: whatever they name, he will carry it out.
-
לָכֶם
lakhem · H9036
for you · v4
'For you, on your behalf.' The settlement is made for the injured party.
-
אֶל־
ʾel- · H0413
to, toward · v5
Marks who is being spoken to. It is a formal address to the king as the one who must settle the case.
-
הַמֶּ֔לֶךְ
hammelek · H4428
the king · v5
David is called by his office, not his name. The Gibeonites are taking their grievance to the highest judge in Israel, the one who answers for the nation's oath.
-
אֲשֶׁ֣ר
ʾăšer · H0834
who, which · v5
Introduces the first charge against "the man."
-
כִּלָּ֔נוּ
killānû · H3615
finish, bring to an end, consume · v5
"He finished us off" or "made an end of us." The verb describes carrying destruction through to completion. It is a charge of slaughter on a massive scale, not of mistreatment.
-
דִּמָּה־
dimmâ · H1819
liken, imagine; intend, plan · v5
The basic sense is to picture something in the mind. Here it means he set his mind on it, he planned it. The charge is premeditation: Saul's violence was deliberate policy, not a burst of anger.
-
נִשְׁמַ֕דְנוּ
nišmadnû · H8045
be exterminated, be wiped out · v5
"We have been destroyed." This is the strong word for wiping out a people, the same word used for the destruction of Canaanite nations in Deuteronomy. In the traditional Hebrew text it comes in abruptly, as if the speakers break off mid-sentence. It can be read as what Saul planned ("that we be wiped out") or as what actually happened ("we have been wiped out").
-
מֵֽהִתְיַצֵּ֖ב
mēhityaṣṣēb · H3320
take one's stand, station oneself, hold one's ground · v5
"So as not to stand / from having any standing." Here the prefix "from" works as a negative: they were cut off from holding any place at all. The verb means a settled, legitimate presence, not just being alive.
-
בְּכָל־
bəkol · H3605
all, any · v5
"In all / in any." It stresses how total the plan was: there was to be no corner of Israel where Gibeonites could remain.
-
גְּבֻ֥ל
gəbul · H1366
border; territory enclosed by a border · v5
The land within Israel's borders. The Gibeonites lived inside Israel's land under a sworn guarantee (Josh 9), and Saul tried to remove them from it.
The world behind it
The famine and the broken oath. 2 Samuel 21–24 is an appendix of episodes that are not in time order. Here a three-year famine strikes Israel. When David asks YHWH why, the answer is: "because of Saul and his house of blood, because he put the Gibeonites to death" (v. 1). Generations earlier, Joshua and Israel's leaders had sworn by YHWH to let the Gibeonites live (Joshua 9:15–20), even though they got the treaty by a trick. Saul, "in his zeal for Israel and Judah", tried to wipe them out (v. 2). This event is not narrated anywhere else.
Why a broken oath means famine. In the ancient Near East an oath sworn in a god's name called that god in as witness and enforcer. Breaking it brought a curse on the land, which often lasted beyond the generation that broke it. The closest parallel is the Plague Prayers of the Hittite king Mursili II (14th century BC). Mursili learns from divination that a plague is ravaging his land because his father broke a sworn treaty with Egypt. He confesses and offers restitution to undo the guilt his father inherited and passed on.
Blood money and its limits. Many ancient legal systems let a killing be settled by a payment to the victim's family. Israel's law allowed a 'ransom' (kofer) in some cases (Exodus 21:30) but forbade it for murder: blood "pollutes the land, and no atonement can be made for the land for the blood shed in it except by the blood of the one who shed it" (Numbers 35:31–33). In v. 3 David uses that same verb, 'make atonement' (kipper). So when the Gibeonites rule out silver and gold, they are speaking in the terms of that law.
The Gibeonites' standing. They were a protected non-Israelite group, assigned menial service at the sanctuary (Joshua 9:27). Such a group could not on its own authority execute Israelites. Any remedy had to come through the king. Their two-part answer is both legally careful and diplomatically polite. Like the bargaining in Genesis 23, it leaves the more powerful party to make the explicit offer.
From the study of 2 Samuel 21:4.
Where scholars differ
in v4
What do the Gibeonites mean by 'it is not ours to put to death any man in Israel'?
-
A statement of legal incapacity: as a protected non-Israelite group they have no authority to execute Israelites, so the king must authorise any execution.
Their subordinate status in Joshua 9:21–27. The construction 'there is not to us' can mean 'we have no right' (compare 2 Sam 19:28). In v. 6 they ask David to 'give' them the men, which shows the authority is his.
-
A disclaimer of general vengeance: they are not seeking reprisals against Israel at large, only against the guilty house.
'Any man… in Israel' contrasts with 'Saul and his house' in the first clause, narrowing the target. Verses 5–6 then name Saul's descendants specifically.
-
A diplomatic opening in a negotiation: a polite refusal that invites the stronger party to make the explicit offer.
David immediately says 'whatever you say', and they then state their demand. This matches bargaining scenes such as Genesis 23. Most commentators combine this view with one of the other two.
in v4
Is David's final line a question or a promise?
-
An open promise: 'Whatever you say, I will do for you.'
In Hebrew, mah can mean 'whatever' (an indefinite relative). It is followed by a plain first-person verb. Adopted by KJV, BSB, WEB and NASB.
-
A question: 'What are you saying that I should do for you?'
mah is ordinarily a question word, and it echoes the question 'What shall I do for you?' in v. 3. The Greek tradition and ESV/NIV read it this way.
in v4
Does the narrative cover for a political purge of Saul's heirs?
-
The episode, intentionally or not, served David's interest in removing Saulide rivals, and the narrator frames it to defend him.
Seven male descendants of Saul are executed (vv. 8–9). Shimei accuses David of being a 'man of blood' against Saul's house (2 Sam 16:7–8). Historical-critical commentators (for example McCarter's Anchor Bible commentary) explore this reading.
-
The text presents it as a genuine resolution of oath-breaking guilt, driven by divine verdict and the injured party's demand.
YHWH names the cause (v. 1). The Gibeonites refuse other options (v. 4) and set the terms (vv. 5–6). David spares Mephibosheth because of his own oath to Jonathan (v. 7), and the famine ends after he gives the dead a proper burial (v. 14).
in v5
Did Saul actually massacre the Gibeonites, or only plan to?
-
He carried out a real, large-scale killing.
"Finished us off" (killānû) and "we have been destroyed" (nišmadnû, perfect tense) describe completed events. Verse 1 calls Saul's house "bloodstained" and says "he put the Gibeonites to death."
-
It was a partly carried-out plan, described in the strongest terms by the wronged party.
The second charge is about intent (dimmâ, "planned"). The Gibeonites still exist as a group able to make demands. The Septuagint may read the destruction as a demand rather than a past fact. Victims' accounts of what was done to them are naturally given at full strength.
in v5
What historical event lies behind the accusation?
-
Saul cleared Gibeonite towns to settle his own tribe, Benjamin.
The original people of Beeroth fled to Gittaim, and Beeroth was later counted as Benjaminite (2 Sam 4:2–3). Gibeon is linked to Saul's family line (1 Chr 8:29–33; 9:35–39).
-
It is connected to the massacre at Nob (1 Sam 22:18–19).
Some suppose that Gibeonite temple servants (Josh 9:27) died with the priests of Nob. There is no direct textual support, so the view is speculative.
-
The episode partly serves as a defence of David, explaining why Saul's heirs were wiped out.
Scholars such as McCarter and Brueggemann note that the story clears David of guilt for the deaths of Saul's sons (compare Shimei's charge in 2 Sam 16:7–8, "all the blood of the house of Saul"). This concerns why the story was told, and does not mean it was invented.
in v5
Is the traditional Hebrew wording original, or does the Septuagint keep a better reading?
-
The traditional Hebrew "we have been destroyed" is original.
The harder reading is more likely to be original, and a broken sentence suits emotional speech. YLT and many commentators follow it.
-
The Septuagint's "let us destroy him" is original.
It differs from the Hebrew by only one letter (י). It makes the sentence complete and leads smoothly into v. 6, so that the phrase about "no place in Israel" becomes the demand.
Sources
- BDB and HALOT s.v. כֶּסֶף, אַיִן, מוּת (hiphil), כֹּפֶר
- Numbers 35:31–34; Exodus 21:30; Joshua 9; Genesis 23
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 21:1–14
- Mursili II, Plague Prayers (ANET, ed. Pritchard, pp. 394–396)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Samuel 21
- Masoretic marginal note (Qere) at 2 Sam 21:4, as reported in BHS
- BDB s.v. כָּלָה, דָּמָה I, שָׁמַד, יָצַב, גְּבוּל
- HALOT s.v. דמה I (piel 'to intend, plan'), כלה, שׁמד, יצב (hitpael)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible 9), notes on 21:1–14
- A. A. Anderson, 2 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 11)
- A. Malamat, 'Doctrines of Causality in Hittite and Biblical Historiography: A Parallel,' Vetus Testamentum 5 (1955)
- Plague Prayers of Mursili II (ANET 394–396; COS 1.60)
- Septuagint, 2 Reigns (2 Samuel) 21:5
- Vulgate, 2 Samuel 21:5
- Joshua 9; Numbers 35:31–34; 2 Samuel 4:2–3
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).