Acts Chapter 22 Read as one passage

Acts 22:22–23

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

22The crowd listened to Paul until he made this statement. Then they lifted up their voices and shouted, “Rid the earth of him! He is not fit to live!” 23As they were shouting and throwing off their cloaks and tossing dust into the air,

What the first hearers heard

For Luke's readers the scene does several things at once:

  • Paul walks his Lord's road. The cry aire, "away with him", is the cry raised against Jesus before Pilate (Luke 23:18). It also echoes the Greek of Isaiah 53:8, "his life is taken away from the earth", which Luke has already applied to Jesus (Acts 8:33). As with Jesus and Stephen, Paul is condemned by the crowd while his innocence is plain. Agabus had foretold he would be bound in Jerusalem (21:11), and the Lord had warned that Jerusalem would not accept his testimony (22:18). Both now come true.
  • The pattern of the mission. All through Acts, rejection in Jewish settings is followed by a turn to the Gentiles (13:46; 18:6; 28:28). Here the very word "Gentiles" provokes the rejection, which confirms the speech's own point that God was sending Paul "far away."
  • The irony of Rome. The crowd demands that a Roman officer kill a Jew for being too open to non-Jews. In the next verses that officer, a Gentile, becomes Paul's protector. Luke's readers in the Roman world would notice this.
  • What was really at stake. The crowd heard Paul's defence of his loyalty to the Law calmly. What they could not bear was the claim that Israel's God, in Israel's Temple, had authorized a mission to the nations through this man. For them that touched Temple purity, national identity and loyalty to the covenant all at once.

From the study of Acts 22:22.

Verse by verse

  1. 22The crowd listened to Paul until he made this statement. Then they lifted up their voices and shouted, “Rid the earth of him! He is not fit to live!”

    The crowd in the Temple courts had been listening to Paul, really listening. He spoke to them in their own Aramaic and told them how zealous he had been for the Law, how he had been met on the road to Damascus, and how a law-observant man named Ananias had received him. They heard him out up to that one statement: that the Lord, appearing to him in this very Temple, had said, "Go, I will send you far away to the Gentiles." At that word the whole crowd roared as with a single voice: "Take him away — get a man like that off the face of the earth!" The cry is aimed at the Roman commander holding Paul, and in a mob's mouth "take him away" means "kill him." It is the same cry raised against Jesus before Pilate ("Away with this man!"). "A man like that" is contemptuous: they will not use his name, only the type he stands for. Then comes the reason, and its tense matters: "for it was not right for him to be alive." In other words, he ought not to be living at all; he should have been put to death long ago. This is not a remark about his character or "fitness." It says his continued existence is an offence against what is right, a wrong that needs putting right.

    Full study →
  2. 23As they were shouting and throwing off their cloaks and tossing dust into the air,

    While they kept on roaring, flinging or waving their outer cloaks about, and hurling handfuls of dust up into the air at him…

    This verse is not a full sentence on its own. In Greek it is a string of three "-ing" phrases that set the scene for the next verse. The main action comes in v.24: the Roman commander orders Paul taken into the barracks. All three verbs describe actions going on at the same time and continuing. This is not one shout and a single throw. It is a sustained, chaotic display.

    • The roar. The verb is the one the Gospels use for the crowd screaming "Crucify him!" Just before, in v.22, the crowd's cry "Rid the earth of him!" echoes "Away with this man!" from Jesus' trial (Luke 23:18). Luke lets the reader hear Paul going the way Jesus went.
    • The cloaks. These are the heavy outer mantles worn over the tunic. The verb form suggests repeated tossing, so the crowd may be stripping them off as if to stone him, or waving them wildly in fury. Paul had just recalled guarding the cloaks of the men who stoned Stephen (v.20). For him and for Luke's readers, cloaks coming off in an angry crowd carried that memory.
    • The dust. Throwing dust was a known gesture of cursing and contempt, as when Shimei flung dust at David. It may also have been what the crowd could throw in place of stones at a man standing above them under guard. The word is the same "dust" the apostles were told to shake off their feet against those who rejected them. Here the gesture is turned around against the messenger.

    The trigger, in v.21, was Paul's report that the Lord had said, "Go, I will send you far away to the Gentiles."

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v22

    He is not fit to live (BSB, NIV, WEB)

    ou kathēken auton zēn

    What we hear
    He is unworthy or unsuitable as a person, a verdict on his character or 'fitness'.
    What they heard
    An impersonal judgment of propriety, put in the imperfect tense: 'it was not right for him to be alive', meaning he ought not to be living and should already be dead. The focus is on a wrong to be corrected, not on how fit he is.
  • in v23

    cast off their clothes (KJV)

    rhiptountōn ta himatia

    What we hear
    Stripping off their clothing, undressing.
    What they heard
    Flinging off, or waving about, their outer mantles. These were the large cloaks worn over the tunic. No one was undressing.
Every word
  1. Ἤκουον

    Ēkouon · G0191

    to hear, listen · v22

    The imperfect tense shows ongoing action: they kept listening, and for a while they listened attentively (compare 22:2, where they fell quiet because he spoke in their own language). That makes the sudden outburst more striking.

  2. δὲ

    de · G1161

    and, now, but · v22

    A light connective that moves the story on from Paul's speech to the crowd's reaction. Here it means 'now' or 'and'.

  3. αὐτοῦ

    autou · G0846

    him · v22, v23

    'To him', meaning Paul. With this verb the genitive case marks the person being listened to.

  4. ἄχρι

    achri · G0891

    until, as far as · v22

    Marks the limit: they listened up to a certain point and no further.

  5. τούτου

    toutou · G3778

    this · v22

    Points back to the last thing Paul said: the Lord's command, 'I will send you far away to the Gentiles' (22:21).

  6. τοῦ

    tou · G3588

    the · v22, v23

    The definite article with 'statement'. It is not translated separately.

  7. λόγου

    logou · G3056

    word, statement · v22

    An ordinary use of logos for one particular statement or remark. It does not carry the theological sense 'the Word'. The single word 'Gentiles' was the breaking point.

  8. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v22, v23

    Joins the two halves: they listened, and then they exploded.

  9. ἐπῆραν

    epēran · G1869

    to lift up, raise · v22

    An aorist (a single event): all at once they raised their voices. The idiom 'lift up the voice' means to shout out loud, and Luke uses it often (Luke 11:27; Acts 2:14; 14:11).

  10. φωνὴν

    phōnēn · G5456

    voice, sound · v22

    The noun is singular, 'their voice'. The crowd shouts as if with one voice, a single collective roar.

  11. λέγοντες

    legontes · G3004

    saying · v22

    Introduces the words they shouted.

  12. αἶρε

    aire · G0142

    take up, take away, remove · v22

    A present imperative, addressed to one person: almost certainly the Roman tribune (commander) who held Paul. 'Take him away!' In crowd cries like this it means 'get rid of him', in other words 'kill him'. It is the same cry the crowd raised against Jesus (Luke 23:18) and against Paul a day earlier (Acts 21:36).

  13. ἀπὸ

    apo · G0575

    from, away from · v22

    'Away from': removal from where he now is.

  14. γῆς

    gēs · G1093

    earth, land · v22

    'From the earth' means from among the living. The phrase echoes Isaiah 53:8 in its Greek form ('his life is taken away from the earth'), which Luke has already quoted in Acts 8:33.

  15. τοιοῦτον

    toiouton · G5108

    such, of this kind · v22

    'A man like that.' It is contemptuous. The crowd does not even name him but treats him as a type, the kind of person who does such things. KJV's 'such a fellow' catches the tone.

  16. οὐ

    ou · G3756

    not · v22

    Negates 'it was fitting'.

  17. γὰρ

    gar · G1063

    for · v22

    Gives the reason for the demand: kill him, because...

  18. καθῆκεν

    kathēken · G2520

    it is fitting, proper, one's duty · v22

    An impersonal verb ('it is fitting') in the imperfect. With verbs of duty, this tense describes what ought to be true but is not: 'he ought not to be alive.' The sense is close to 'he should not have been allowed to live this long.'

  19. ζῆν

    zēn · G2198

    to live · v22

    To be alive. The crowd is calling for his death, not just his expulsion.

  20. κραυγαζόντων

    kraugazontōn · G2905

    to shout, scream, cry out loudly · v23

    A loud, raw outcry, not speech. The present tense pictures the shouting as still going on while the other actions happen. The same verb is used of the crowd shouting 'Crucify him!' at Jesus' trial (John 19:6, 15).

  21. τε

    te · G5037

    and, so, then · v23

    A light connecting word, a favourite of Luke's, that ties this scene straight onto v.22: they shouted 'Rid the earth of him!' and so the uproar went on.

  22. ῥιπτούντων

    rhiptountōn · G4496

    to throw, fling, toss · v23

    This spelling comes from the by-form ῥιπτέω, which often suggests throwing again and again: tossing or waving about. It may mean flinging their cloaks off, or waving them wildly. The present tense pictures it as ongoing, repeated motion.

  23. ἱμάτια

    himatia · G2440

    outer garment, cloak, mantle · v23

    The outer wrap worn over the tunic, which was the inner garment. The crowd are handling their mantles, not undressing.

  24. κονιορτὸν

    koniorton · G2868

    dust (stirred up or on the feet) · v23

    Loose dust from the pavement or ground. It is the same word used for the dust the disciples were to shake off their feet against a town that rejected them (Luke 9:5; Acts 13:51).

  25. βαλλόντων

    ballontōn · G0906

    to throw, cast · v23

    Throwing or hurling. Again the present tense shows it as ongoing: handful after handful.

  26. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into, toward · v23

    Shows direction: up into the air.

  27. ἀέρα

    aera · G0109

    air, the lower atmosphere · v23

    The everyday air around and just above them. They throw the dust upward and toward Paul, not onto their own heads as people did in mourning.

The world behind it

Where and when. About AD 57, under the Roman governor Felix. Paul had been seized in the Temple on the charge that he taught "against the people, the Law and this place" and had brought Greeks, specifically Trophimus of Ephesus, into the Temple (21:27–29). The Roman tribune Claudius Lysias pulled him from the mob and let him speak from the steps of the Antonia fortress, the barracks overlooking the Temple courts (21:31–40).

Why "Gentiles" was the trigger. Jews of this period did not generally object to Gentiles in principle. Proselytes (converts) were received, and the prophets foresaw the nations streaming to Zion (Isa 2:2–4; 60). The offence lay in the combination:

  • The Temple barrier. Stone notices on the balustrade around the inner courts warned any foreigner not to go further, on pain of death. Josephus describes them (Jewish War 5.193–194; Antiquities 15.417), and one was found in 1871, a second in fragments in 1935. The charge against Paul was precisely that he had breached this line.
  • The claim itself. Paul said that God, revealing himself in the Temple (22:17), had told him Jerusalem would reject his testimony (22:18) and had sent him away to the nations. To his hearers this sounded like Israel's God turning from Israel's sanctuary to the uncircumcised.
  • The political climate. The 50s saw growing nationalist violence: assassins with daggers (the sicarii), and an Egyptian prophet the tribune had just mistaken Paul for (21:38). Mixing with Gentiles could be read as collaboration and betrayal.

What follows. Verse 23 describes the crowd throwing off or waving their cloaks and flinging dust into the air. These were gestures of furious outrage, and possibly (it is debated) preparation for stoning, as at Stephen's death (7:58).

From the study of Acts 22:22.

Where scholars differ

in v22

What exactly about 'Gentiles' (22:21) provoked the crowd?

  • Temple purity: the word confirmed the charge that Paul brought Gentiles into the sanctuary.

    The accusation of 21:28–29 (Trophimus); the warning inscriptions on the Temple barrier that threatened Gentile intruders with death (Josephus, War 5.193–194; Ant. 15.417).

  • National loyalty: in a tense nationalist climate, a mission to Gentiles on equal terms looked like treason against Israel.

    Unrest under Felix (sicarii, the Egyptian prophet of 21:38); the charge of teaching 'against the people' (21:28); later Jewish Christians' worries about Paul (21:20–21).

  • Theological offence: Paul claimed that God, in the Temple, foretold Jerusalem's rejection and sent him away from Israel to the nations, which implied judgment on Jerusalem.

    22:17–21: the vision takes place in the Temple, 'they will not accept your testimony', 'far away'. Luke's repeated pattern of rejection followed by a turn to the Gentiles (13:46; 28:28).

in v22

How strong is the imperfect καθῆκεν?

  • It expresses a present unmet obligation: 'he ought not to be alive (but he is).'

    The standard grammatical treatment of imperfects of necessity or propriety without ἄν (BDF §358; compare ἔδει).

  • It looks back: 'he should have been put to death long ago.'

    Commentators such as F. F. Bruce render it this way. It fits a crowd that sees Paul as a long-standing apostate; the ESV and NASB 'should not be allowed to live' lean in this direction.

in v23

What exactly were the crowd doing with their cloaks?

  • Throwing them off to get ready to stone Paul.

    Acts 7:58, where garments were removed before Stephen's stoning, and Paul's mention of that scene in 22:20. The crowd's cry in v.22 is explicitly a call for his death. Most modern English versions read it this way.

  • Waving or tossing them about in agitation and protest.

    The ῥιπτέω form often implies repeated tossing. Cadbury's collection of ancient parallels shows crowds waving garments as gestures of intense excitement. Stoning was not practical with Paul under Roman guard. YLT and RSV render it this way.

  • Shaking out their garments as a sign of cutting themselves off from Paul.

    Compare Acts 18:6, where Paul 'shook out his garments' against the synagogue, using a different verb, ἐκτινάσσω. Possible, but the verb here is not the one used for shaking out.

in v23

What did throwing dust signify?

  • A curse and gesture of contempt aimed at Paul.

    Shimei cursing David with stones and dust (2 Sam 16:13). Throwing dust at someone was a recognised insult.

  • Dust thrown in place of stones.

    No stones were at hand on a paved temple court, and the target was above them under guard. Several commentators (e.g. Bruce, Keener) take this view.

  • A general outburst of uncontrolled rage, with no fixed symbolic meaning.

    Cadbury concluded that the parallels show excitement and anger rather than one technical ritual. The verse lists the actions side by side with the shouting.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. καθήκω
  • BDAG s.v. αἴρω
  • BDAG s.v. τοιοῦτος
  • Blass–Debrunner–Funk, Greek Grammar of the NT §358 (imperfect of obligation)
  • B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Acts 22:22
  • F. F. Bruce, The Acts of the Apostles: Greek Text with Introduction and Commentary
  • C. S. Keener, Acts: An Exegetical Commentary, vol. 3
  • Josephus, Jewish War 5.193–194; Antiquities 15.417 (Temple warning inscriptions)
  • Septuagint, Isaiah 53:8
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Acts 21–22
  • BDAG s.v. κραυγάζω
  • BDAG s.v. ῥιπτέω / ῥίπτω
  • BDAG s.v. ἱμάτιον
  • BDAG s.v. κονιορτός
  • H. J. Cadbury, 'Dust and Garments', in The Beginnings of Christianity, vol. 5 (1933)
  • F. F. Bruce, The Acts of the Apostles (Greek text commentary)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Acts 22:22–24
  • Josephus, Jewish War 2.224–227 (temple riot under Cumanus)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).