Deuteronomy Chapter 14 Read as one passage

Deuteronomy 14:11–20

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

11You may eat any clean bird, 12but these you may not eat: the eagle, the bearded vulture, the black vulture, 13the red kite, the falcon, any kind of kite, 14any kind of raven, 15the ostrich, the screech owl, the gull, any kind of hawk, 16the little owl, the great owl, the white owl, 17the desert owl, the osprey, the cormorant, 18the stork, any kind of heron, the hoopoe, or the bat. 19All flying insects are unclean for you; they may not be eaten. 20But you may eat any clean bird.

What the first hearers heard

To Israelites hearing this on the edge of the land, the verse meant mainly freedom with a boundary. Most of what flies, including the partridge, quail, dove and sparrow, was theirs to eat. The exceptions were few and named. They were mostly hunters, carrion-eaters and haunters of ruins: birds that live on blood and death, which Israel was otherwise taught to keep away from (Deut 12:23; 14:1, 21).

The plural "you" addressed the whole people. A family snaring birds or finding a nest did not need a priest's ruling each time. They only needed to know which birds were on the list. Ordinary meals became a quiet, repeated sign of who they were: a people belonging to YHWH, sorting the created world into "clean" and "unclean" the way the sanctuary sorted what may come near and what may not. The chapter's frame makes the motive plain: "for you are a holy people to YHWH your God" (14:2, 21).

From the study of Deuteronomy 14:11.

Verse by verse

  1. 11You may eat any clean bird,

    "Any bird at all that is clean, one fit for a people who belong to a holy God, you are free to eat."

    The sentence is four Hebrew words, and it opens wide. The word for bird (tsippor) is the everyday one: the sparrow in the snare, the dove, the partridge, the bird whose nest you come across by the road. Here it stands for the whole world of winged creatures. "Every" means any one you choose. The verb is permission, not command: Israel may eat birds. Nothing in the verse obliges them to.

    The limit is the single word clean (tehorah). It does not mean washed or germ-free. It is a word from the sanctuary, naming the state in which something can belong in the life of a people set apart for YHWH (14:2, 21). Unlike land animals (split hoof, chews the cud) and water creatures (fins and scales), birds get no test of physical features. Instead the next verses name the exceptions: eagles, vultures, kites, ravens, owls, hawks, stork, heron, hoopoe, even the bat. Most of these hunt, eat carrion, or live in ruins. Everything else that flies is clean. The verse and its twin in v. 20 ("every clean flying thing you may eat") act as bookends around that list. Generous permission comes first, the exceptions are counted out, and the permission is repeated.

    Full study →
  2. 12but these you may not eat: the eagle, the bearded vulture, the black vulture,

    "But this is what you must never eat among the birds: the great soaring bird of prey (the bird English calls the eagle, though the word just as naturally names the griffon vulture that circles over carcasses), the 'bone-breaker' (the bearded vulture, which drops bones on rocks to crack them), and the third great raptor, a large vulture or sea-eagle whose exact species is now lost."

    The verse starts the list of exceptions to v.11's broad permission, "every clean bird you may eat." The Torah gives no physical signs for clean birds the way it does for land animals (split hoof, chewing the cud) and fish (fins and scales). It simply names the forbidden kinds, and it begins with the biggest and most obvious: the large flesh- and carrion-eating birds. The command is plural and permanent, addressed to the whole people. It rests on Deuteronomy's own stated reason: "you are a people holy to the LORD your God" (14:2, 21).

    Full study →
  3. 13the red kite, the falcon, any kind of kite,

    Continuing the list of birds you must not eat (begun in v. 12 with the eagle and the great vultures): "and the sharp-eyed 'seer' bird, and the hawk-like ayyah, and the swooping dayyah: that bird and every bird like it."

    The verse names a group of medium-sized birds of prey, most likely kites and falcons. They soar high, scan the ground with keen eyes, swoop on prey and readily feed on carcasses. The first name, ra'ah, sounds like 'the one who sees'. The second, ayyah, was proverbial for sharp sight (Job 28:7). The third, dayyah, is a bird that gathers in ruined, desolate places (Isa 34:15). The closing 'according to its kind' turns three names into a whole category, so no Israelite could escape the ban by pointing to a local variety with another name.

    The exact species cannot be pinned down with certainty, and English Bibles differ in which bird gets which name. What the first hearers would have pictured is clear, though: flesh-tearing, carrion-touching raptors circling overhead. A people set apart for God (Deut 14:2, 21) did not put these birds on its table.

    Full study →
  4. 14any kind of raven,

    "And every raven, every bird of the raven's sort," is also forbidden as food.

    The verse continues the list that began in verse 12, "these are the ones you shall not eat." The listener pictures the big black bird found everywhere: in the fields, at the edge of the desert, around carcasses and ruins, recognizable by its croak. Saying "every" and adding "according to its kind" stretches the ban to the raven's whole family: crows, rooks, jackdaws and any similar black scavenger. No one had to decide whether a particular crow counted. It did. In the surrounding list of vultures, kites, hawks and owls, the raven fits as another bird that lives off dead flesh. An Israelite who refused to eat it was marking a line between their table and creatures that feed on death.

    Full study →
  5. 15the ostrich, the screech owl, the gull, any kind of hawk,

    Continuing the list of birds Israel must not eat ("these are the ones you shall not eat", v. 12), Moses names four more: the "daughter of the ya'anah", a large bird of the desert and of ruins with a mournful, wailing cry, traditionally the ostrich; the taḥmas, a name that may mean "the violent one", probably some kind of owl or night bird of prey; the shaḥaph, "the lean one", which the earliest Greek translators took to be the gull; and the nets, the hawk or falcon, together with every bird of its kind.

    To the first hearers each name called up a living creature they knew. These birds haunted desert wastes and fallen cities, hunted at night, scavenged the shore, or swooped on prey. The last phrase, "according to its kind", turns one name into a whole category. It uses the wording of creation in Genesis 1, so that Israel's food separated what God had already sorted. We can no longer be sure which bird three of the four names mean. The English labels ("ostrich", "screech owl", "gull") are careful reconstructions, not certainties.

    Full study →
  6. 16the little owl, the great owl, the white owl,

    Continuing the list of birds Israel must not eat (v. 12): the little owl that sits on ruins, the larger owl of the dusk, and the "hisser," probably the barn owl.

    The verse has no verb of its own. Each bird is grammatically the object of "you shall not eat" in verse 12, so each name is one more item on a list of birds forbidden at Israel's table. The three names come as a group. Two of them are almost certainly owls, a small one and a large one. The third has a name that means something like "the one that pants or hisses," and in this setting it was probably the barn owl. Hebrew lists sound like this: a group of night birds, grouped together because they look and behave alike.

    To the first hearers, these were not exotic creatures. They were birds you heard at night and saw around abandoned buildings and tumbled walls. Elsewhere in Scripture, places like that are full of grief and judgment (Ps 102:6; Isa 34:11). Placing them off-limits as food was part of what it meant for Israel to be "a people holy to the LORD" (Deut 14:2, 21).

    Be honest about one thing: the exact species are uncertain. Ancient translators already disagreed (Greek and Latin versions give heron, swan and ibis), and English versions still differ. The main point of the verse is clear, and it does not depend on identifying the birds exactly. The precise identity of each bird does.

    Full study →
  7. 17the desert owl, the osprey, the cormorant,

    Verse 12 sets the frame: "these are the ones you must not eat." This verse continues that list of forbidden birds:

    …and the qaʾat (a bird of the wilderness and of ruined places, traditionally "pelican," perhaps a desert owl), and the Egyptian vulture (the small carrion bird that eats dead flesh), and the "plunger" (a bird that dives headlong after fish, traditionally the cormorant).

    The Hebrew is just three bird names joined by "and," two of them marked as objects of the verb "you shall not eat." It contains no reasoning or command of its own. Its force comes from the list it belongs to. The first hearers would have recognised birds that haunted desolate places, fed on carcasses, or killed for a living. All were placed outside what a people "holy to the LORD" (14:2, 14:21) could put on their table. Several of the names cannot be identified with certainty today, and honest translations differ on them.

    Full study →
  8. 18the stork, any kind of heron, the hoopoe, or the bat.

    This verse finishes Deuteronomy's list of winged creatures Israel must not eat. The list began in verse 12 with "but these are the ones you shall not eat". It runs from the great birds of prey down through water birds, and ends here:

    …and the stork, the big migrant whose Hebrew name sounds like "the loyal one"; and the heron, along with every bird of that type; and the crested hoopoe; and the bat.

    Each name is joined by "and", so the list reads as one long roll-call, every item under the same ban. "After its kind" stretches the ban on the heron to every bird an Israelite would class with it. Identifying the heron is the least certain part of the verse. The stork and the bat are secure, and the hoopoe is well supported (the KJV's "lapwing" is a different bird). The bat comes last, so the list is clearly about creatures that fly, not "birds" in today's scientific sense. Verse 19 goes on from there to winged insects. The whole list sits inside a frame that gives the reason: "you are a people holy to the LORD your God" (14:2, 21). Israel's table was to mark it out as belonging to God.

    Full study →
  9. 19All flying insects are unclean for you; they may not be eaten.

    "And the whole swarming part of the winged world, every small flying thing that comes in swarms, is unclean, that is what it is, for you. They are not to be eaten."

    The verse ends Deuteronomy's section on creatures of the air. Verses 11–18 named the birds Israel must not eat (and the bat, which also counts as a "flyer"). Verse 19 then deals with everything small, winged and swarming in one stroke: gnats, flies, beetles, locust swarms. The word for these creatures pictures teeming masses, not single bugs. The word "unclean" puts them in a ritual category. It does not call them dirty or evil. They are off-limits for the people who belong to God in a special way ("you are a holy people," vv. 2 and 21). "For you" matters: the status belongs to Israel's relationship with God, not to the insect itself. The closing phrase is a short, permanent ruling stated in the passive, "they shall not be eaten". Verse 20 then balances it at once with a permission: "every clean flyer you may eat."

    Deuteronomy gives the rule in its broadest form. The fuller list in Leviticus 11:20–23 makes an exception for certain leaping locusts and grasshoppers. Later Jews took that exception for granted. John the Baptist ate locusts (Mark 1:6), and the Dead Sea Scrolls give instructions for cooking them.

    Full study →
  10. 20But you may eat any clean bird.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v11

    clean

    tahor

    What we hear
    Hygienic, sanitary, safe or healthy to eat.
    What they heard
    Having the status of 'fit' within the holiness system: something that may belong in the life of YHWH's holy people, the opposite of tame' (unclean). It is a covenant and ritual category, not a judgment about disease or dirt.
  • in v11

    bird

    tsippor

    What we hear
    A member of the scientific class Aves: feathered, egg-laying, warm-blooded.
    What they heard
    A flying creature, grouped by how it lives (in the air). The forbidden list that follows this verse includes the bat (v. 18).
  • in v12

    the eagle

    nesher

    What we hear
    A majestic hunting eagle, like the golden eagle or the bald eagle, the emblem of nations and the opposite of a scavenger.
    What they heard
    The great soaring bird of prey of the region. It includes, and in many texts most naturally means, the griffon vulture, which feeds on carcasses. Hebrew does not split eagle from vulture the way English does.
  • in v13

    vulture (KJV, YLT)

    dayyah

    What we hear
    A bald-headed carrion bird of the vulture family.
    What they heard
    Most likely a kite (perhaps the black kite), a smaller soaring raptor that both hunts and scavenges.
  • in v13

    after its kind / of any kind

    leminah

    What we hear
    A scientific category: a biological species, or the 'created kind' of modern creation–evolution debates.
    What they heard
    An everyday folk grouping of birds that look and behave alike: 'this bird and others like it'.
  • in v14

    after its kind / any kind of

    ləmînô (mîn)

    What we hear
    A biological species, or a fixed "created kind" in the creation-science sense.
    What they heard
    An everyday grouping by appearance and habit: "the raven and birds like it". It is practical sorting, not scientific classification.
  • in v15

    the ostrich / the screech owl / the gull

    bat hayya'ănāh / taḥmās / šāḥap

    What we hear
    Readers assume the bird is known for certain, a precise species just as named in a field guide.
    What they heard
    Folk names for birds every Israelite knew. Their exact identification is now partly lost, and modern versions reconstruct them from the root meanings of the names, ancient translations and the birds' habits.
  • in v15

    after its kind / any kind of

    ləmînēhû

    What we hear
    "Kind" as a biological species (Linnaean taxonomy, the modern scientific system of naming species), or as a technical creationist category.
    What they heard
    Everyday grouping by look and behaviour: "everything hawk-like". It echoes the wording of creation in Genesis 1.
  • in v16

    swan (KJV, YLT)

    tinšemet

    What we hear
    A large white waterbird, the familiar swan of ponds and parks.
    What they heard
    A bird named from a root meaning "to pant, breathe, hiss." It is grouped here with owls and most likely means an owl such as the barn owl. The same name was used for a small reptile.
  • in v16

    great owl / white owl / horned owl / short-eared owl

    yanšûp, tinšemet

    What we hear
    A precise, field-guide species identification.
    What they heard
    Names of particular birds that Israelites knew by sight. Their exact matches to modern species are lost, and English names are informed guesses.
  • in v17

    gier eagle (KJV, YLT)

    rāḥāmâ

    What we hear
    Some kind of eagle.
    What they heard
    A vulture, almost certainly the Egyptian vulture, which feeds on carrion.
  • in v17

    pelican (KJV, WEB, YLT, NASB)

    qāʾat

    What we hear
    The large water bird with a throat pouch, at home on coasts and lakes.
    What they heard
    An uncertain bird. In the other biblical passages it lives in the wilderness and in ruined cities, which suggests an owl or another bird of desolate places more than a pelican.
  • in v18

    lapwing (KJV, YLT)

    dukhifat

    What we hear
    The lapwing or peewit, a crested plover of fields and marshes.
    What they heard
    The hoopoe, a different bird with a fan crest and a long curved bill, as the Greek (epops) and Latin (upupa) versions show.
  • in v18

    after her kind / after its kind

    le-minah

    What we hear
    A fixed biological unit, as in modern arguments about species and origins.
    What they heard
    'And everything of that sort': an everyday grouping of look-alike birds, used here to widen the ban beyond one bird.
  • in v19

    unclean

    ṭāmēʾ

    What we hear
    Dirty, unsanitary, disease-carrying, or morally sinful.
    What they heard
    Ritually impure: put in a category kept away from holy things and, for food, from the table of a people set apart to God. It is a status within a worship system, not a hygiene rating or a moral judgment on the creature.
  • in v19

    creeping thing (KJV); winged creeping things (WEB)

    sherets

    What we hear
    Something that creeps: slow, crawling, sneaky movement.
    What they heard
    A swarmer: small creatures that come in teeming masses. The same root describes Israel's growth in Egypt in Exod 1:7, so the root carries no built-in disgust. The image is abundance and busy movement, not creeping.
Every word
  1. כָּל־

    kol- · H3605

    all, every, any · v11, v14, v19

    Joined by a hyphen-like mark to the singular noun after it, so it means "every" or "any" bird: whichever one you pick, as long as it is clean. The permission is broad. Birds are allowed by default, and the forbidden ones are then listed by name.

  2. צִפּ֥וֹר

    tsippôr · H6833

    bird, small bird, sparrow · v11

    The ordinary word for a bird, often a small bird that is snared or eaten (Amos 3:5; Deut 22:6). Here it stands for the whole class of flying creatures that the following list (vv. 12–18) sorts through. That list even includes the bat.

  3. טְהֹרָ֖ה

    ṭehōrāh · H2889

    clean, pure · v11

    The word marks a status: fit to be part of the life of a people who belong to a holy God. It does not mean hygienic. It is feminine to agree with tsippor. What makes a bird clean is not defined by features. The list of forbidden birds that follows defines it.

  4. תֹּאכֵֽלוּ׃

    tōʾkēlû · H0398

    to eat · v11, v12, v19

    "You will eat," plural, addressed to all Israel. The Hebrew verb form for unfinished action is used here as a permission ("you may eat"), not a command to eat birds. Its partner is the prohibition in v. 12: "but these you shall not eat."

  5. וְזֶ֕ה

    wezeh · H2088

    and this · v12

    A singular 'this' standing for the whole list that follows: 'and this is what…'. The 'and' sets the list against v.11 ('every clean bird you may eat'), so English rightly turns it into 'but these'.

  6. אֲשֶׁ֥ר

    ʾasher · H834

    which, that · v12

    Introduces the description 'that which you shall not eat'. It works together with 'from them' later in the clause, which is how Hebrew says 'of which'.

  7. לֹֽא־

    lo · H3808

    not · v12, v19

    This negative, paired with the imperfect verb, is the form of a lasting, categorical prohibition (the same form as 'you shall not murder'), not a one-time request.

  8. מֵהֶ֑ם

    mehem · H4480

    from them, of them · v12

    'Of them' points back to the birds of v.11 and completes the relative clause: 'which you shall not eat of them' = 'of which you shall not eat'. It does not add a sense of 'any' (the supplied contextual gloss 'any of the them' overtranslates).

  9. הַנֶּ֥שֶׁר

    hannesher · H5404

    eagle / griffon vulture · v12

    The largest, most visible soaring raptor of the region. The word covers what English separates into 'eagle' and 'vulture', and in many passages the bird described is most naturally the griffon vulture. The article ('the') marks the bird as a kind, not one bird.

  10. וְהַפֶּ֖רֶס

    wehapperes · H6538

    bearded vulture (lammergeier) · v12

    Probably from a root meaning 'to break'. This fits the bearded vulture, which drops bones from a height to shatter them and eat the marrow, hence the old English 'ossifrage' ('bone-breaker'). The identification is likely but not certain.

  11. וְהָֽעָזְנִיָּֽה׃

    wehaʿozniyyah · H5822

    a large raptor (black vulture? osprey?) · v12

    A large bird of prey that cannot be securely identified. Ancient Greek translators took it as a 'sea-eagle'. Modern proposals include the black (cinereous) vulture, the osprey and the short-toed eagle. What is clear is that it belongs with the big flesh-eating birds that open the list.

  12. וְהָרָאָה֙

    vehara'ah · H7201

    glede, kite (a bird of prey) · v13

    'And the ra'ah.' The name looks like it comes from the verb 'to see' (ra'ah). That fits a high-soaring, sharp-eyed raptor, and the Talmud explains the name this way. It is usually identified as a kite, often the red kite. It continues the list of birds Israel may not eat, which began in v. 12.

  13. וְאֶת־

    ve'et · H0853

    [marker of a definite direct object] · v13, v14, v15, v16, v17

    An untranslatable grammar word marking the next noun as a definite object. Here it carries on the sense of 'you shall not eat' from v. 12. It has no meaning of its own in English.

  14. הָ֣אַיָּ֔ה

    ha'ayyah · H0344

    falcon, kite (a keen-sighted bird of prey) · v13

    'The ayyah.' Elsewhere this is the bird whose eye has never seen the hidden path to wisdom (Job 28:7), so it was proverbial for sharp sight. Falcon and kite are both defended identifications. The name may imitate the bird's cry.

  15. וְהַדַּיָּ֖ה

    vehaddayyah · H1772

    kite, hawk (a bird of prey) · v13

    'And the dayyah.' Elsewhere this bird gathers in pairs among the ruins of a devastated land (Isa 34:15), a picture of scavengers taking over a wasteland. It is often taken to be the black kite, a common scavenger in the Levant. Some take it as a doublet of the Leviticus name da'ah.

  16. לְמִינָֽהּ׃

    leminah · H4327

    kind, sort · v13, v14, v15, v18

    'According to its kind.' The feminine 'its' agrees with dayyah, so the phrase strictly covers that bird and every bird like it. In practice it widens the ban from one named bird to the whole group of similar raptors.

  17. עֹרֵ֖ב

    ʿōrēb · H6158

    raven · v14

    The large black bird of the crow family. To an Israelite it was a familiar scavenger that ate carrion and lived in wild or ruined places. Here it stands for the whole family of crow-like birds.

  18. בַּ֣ת

    bat · H1323G

    daughter (of) · v15

    Literally "daughter of". Here it is part of a fixed bird name, "daughter of the ya'anah". Hebrew often uses "son of" or "daughter of" to name a type or member of a class. It does not refer to a young or female bird in particular.

  19. הַֽיַּעֲנָ֔ה

    hayya'ănāh · H3284

    ostrich (traditional); possibly an owl · v15

    The full name bat ya'anah means a bird of the desert and of ruined places, known for a loud mournful cry (Mic 1:8). The traditional identification is the ostrich. Some scholars suggest a large owl instead.

  20. הַתַּחְמָ֖ס

    hattaḥmās · H8464

    an unclean bird, identity uncertain (owl? nightjar?) · v15

    This word appears only here and in the parallel list at Lev 11:16. The name may come from the root ḥ-m-s, "violence", which would suit a predator. The Greek translation (LXX) has an owl, and the KJV has "night hawk". Nobody knows which bird it is.

  21. הַשָּׁ֑חַף

    haššāḥap · H7828

    gull (per LXX); identity uncertain · v15

    Probably "the lean one". It comes from the same root as šaḥepet, the wasting disease of Lev 26:16 and Deut 28:22. The LXX made it a gull, which fits a slender seabird. The KJV's "cuckoo" comes from later guesswork.

  22. הַנֵּ֖ץ

    hannēṣ · H5322B

    hawk, falcon · v15

    A small to medium bird of prey: hawk, falcon, kestrel. Job 39:26 describes it flying south, and many of the region's hawks and falcons migrate. This is one of the safer identifications in the list.

  23. הַכּ֥וֹס

    hakkôs · H3563B

    owl (probably the little owl) · v16

    A small owl, very probably the little owl (Athene noctua), which is common in Israel and often seen perched on ruins in daylight. It is spelled the same as the ordinary word for "cup," but it is a separate word.

  24. הַיַּנְשׁ֖וּף

    hayyanšûp · H3244

    owl (a larger owl, species uncertain) · v16

    A bigger owl, often identified with the eagle owl or the long-eared owl. The name may be related to נֶשֶׁף (nesheph, "twilight"), so possibly "the dusk bird." Isaiah places it in ruined Edom (Isa 34:11).

  25. וְהַתִּנְשָֽׁמֶת׃

    wəhattinšāmet · H8580

    a bird (barn owl?); elsewhere a reptile (chameleon?) · v16

    The name probably comes from the root נשׁם ("to breathe, pant, snort"), so roughly "the panting/hissing one." As a bird it is most often taken to be the barn owl, which hisses and snores. The same word names a small reptile in Lev 11:30, which is why the supplied lexicon glosses it "chameleon." Here, in a list of birds, a bird is meant. Here it carries no object marker, which is a stylistic variation and does not change the meaning.

  26. וְהַקָּאָ֥ת

    wəhaqqāʾāt · H6893

    qaʾat (a bird: pelican? owl?) · v17

    An unclean bird that must not be eaten. Everywhere else it appears, it is a bird of the wilderness and of ruined cities (Isaiah 34:11; Zephaniah 2:14; Psalm 102:6), so many scholars think of a desert owl. The older rendering 'pelican' comes from the Greek translation and from a possible link to a verb meaning 'to vomit' (pelicans bring food back up for their young). We do not know for certain which bird it is.

  27. הָרָחָ֖מָה

    hārāḥāmâ · H7360

    the raḥam bird (Egyptian vulture) · v17

    Almost certainly the Egyptian vulture, a small white-and-black scavenger common in the Levant. Its Arabic name, rakham, is the same word. Here it has the form raḥamah. Leviticus 11:18 has raḥam.

  28. הַשָּׁלָֽךְ׃

    haššālāk · H7994

    the shalak (cormorant or another diving bird) · v17

    The name probably comes from the verb shalak, 'to throw, hurl down', so it means 'the plunger.' That suggests a bird that dives headlong into water after fish. The cormorant is the traditional guess, but a gannet, tern or kingfisher would also fit.

  29. וְהַחֲסִידָה

    veha-ḥasidah · H2624

    stork · v18

    The big migrating stork, almost certainly the white stork. It is still governed by 'you shall not eat' (v. 12). The name looks like it comes from ḥesed, 'loyal love', which the rabbis later took to mean 'the kind bird'.

  30. וְהָאֲנָפָה

    veha-'anafah · H601

    heron (identification uncertain) · v18

    A wading or water bird. 'Heron' is the traditional guess, but the Greek translators took it as a plover-type bird. It appears only here and in Leviticus 11:19, so certainty isn't possible.

  31. וְהַדּוּכִיפַת

    veha-dukhifat · H1744

    hoopoe · v18

    The crested hoopoe, a striking bird living all year in the land, that probes the ground and dung for grubs. The Greek and Latin versions support this identification. The KJV's 'lapwing' is a different bird.

  32. וְהָעֲטַלֵּף

    veha-'atalef · H5847

    bat · v18

    The bat. It closes the list because the list is of winged, flying creatures, not 'birds' in the modern scientific sense.

  33. שֶׁ֣רֶץ

    sherets · H8318

    swarming thing, teeming creature · v19

    Small creatures that come in masses and move in a busy, teeming way. Here it is linked to the next word: "the swarmers of the flying world", that is, small winged things that swarm, mainly what we call insects.

  34. הָע֔וֹף

    hāʿôph · H5775

    flyer, winged creature, birds (collective) · v19

    "The flyers": every creature with wings, taken as one group. The same word was used for the birds and the bat in vv. 11–18. Here it names the group the swarmers belong to: they are the swarming part of the winged world.

  35. טָמֵ֥א

    ṭāmēʾ · H2931

    unclean, impure (ritually) · v19

    Ritually off-limits. These creatures are in the 'impure' category of Israel's holiness system, which rules them out as food for the holy people. It is a status, not a statement about dirt or germs.

  36. ה֖וּא

    hûʾ · H1931

    he, she, it · v19

    "It": the pronoun points back to the whole group ("every swarmer") and works like "is". It gives the ruling some weight: "unclean, that is what it is, for you."

  37. לָכֶ֑ם

    lākhem · H9036

    to you, for you (plural) · v19

    "For you": the status applies to Israel as a people. The text does not say these creatures are bad in themselves, only that they are unclean for this people. The "you" is plural, the whole community.

The world behind it

Where the verse sits. Deuteronomy 14 is part of Moses' covenant speech on the plains of Moab, to Israel about to enter Canaan. The chapter opens with identity: "You are sons of YHWH your God… you are a holy people… chosen to be his treasured possession" (14:1–2). Then comes the rule: "You shall not eat any detestable thing" (14:3). The food laws follow in three zones of creation: land (vv. 4–8), water (vv. 9–10) and air (vv. 11–20). The chapter closes by repeating "you are a holy people" (v. 21). The food rules are framed as the way a holy people eats.

Birds have no physical test. For land animals and fish the Torah gives criteria anyone could check. For birds it gives only a list of forbidden kinds (here vv. 12–18; compare Lev 11:13–19). The Talmud notices this: the Torah counts the unclean birds rather than the clean ones (b. Hullin 63b). Because many of the ancient bird names cannot be identified with certainty, Jewish practice came to rely on received tradition for which birds may be eaten. The Mishnah supplies working signs: a bird that seizes prey is unclean, and clean birds have an extra toe, a crop and a gizzard whose lining peels off (m. Hullin 3:6).

Birds on the Israelite table. Ordinary people snared or netted small birds (Amos 3:5), gathered eggs (Deut 22:6–7, the same word tsippor), and ate quail (Num 11:31–32) and partridge (1 Sam 26:20). Doves and pigeons were also the poor person's sacrifice (Lev 5:7; 12:8). Every bird that could go on the altar was clean, but not every clean bird went on the altar. The table and the altar overlapped. Israel's ordinary meals echoed, on a smaller scale, the holiness of the sanctuary.

From the study of Deuteronomy 14:11.

Where scholars differ

in v11

Why are some birds clean and others not?

  • Predation and blood: the forbidden birds kill prey or eat carcasses, so they are tied to blood and death.

    Most named birds in vv. 12–18 are raptors, scavengers, or creatures of ruins. *Letter of Aristeas* §§145–149 already reads it this way (2nd century BC or so). The Mishnah's working rule is that a bird that seizes prey is unclean (m. Hullin 3:6). The view fits the Torah's strong ban on consuming blood (Deut 12:23) and on contact with corpses. It is developed by Jacob Milgrom (Anchor Bible, Leviticus).

  • Order of creation: unclean creatures are ones that do not fit their category neatly.

    Mary Douglas (*Purity and Danger*, 1966) argued that holiness means wholeness and that creatures that cross categories are unclean. This works better for land and water animals than for birds. Douglas herself later revised her approach (*Leviticus as Literature*, 1999).

  • Hygiene: God steered Israel away from unhealthy food.

    This is popular in modern writing and had some medieval support (Maimonides partly gives health reasons). The text itself gives holiness as its reason (14:2, 21), and many clean and unclean birds do not differ in any obvious way as food.

  • No stated reason: the list tests and marks obedience and identity.

    The Torah gives no reason for the bird list, only the frame "you are a holy people." Some rabbinic voices treat such laws as decrees whose reason is not given.

in v11

Why does Deuteronomy state the permission twice (v. 11 and v. 20)?

  • It is a literary frame (bookends) around the list of forbidden birds.

    The same permission/prohibition pattern runs through the chapter (vv. 4, 7, 9, 10). The change from *tsippor* to *'of* is ordinary variation of style.

  • The two verses refer to different things.

    Rabbinic interpretation reads v. 11 as including the released bird of the purification rite (b. Kiddushin 57a; Rashi). Some interpreters, ancient and modern, suggest that v. 20's "every clean flying thing," coming straight after the ban on winged swarming creatures (v. 19), quietly covers the permitted locusts of Lev 11:21–22, which Deuteronomy does not otherwise mention.

in v12

Does nesher mean 'eagle' or 'griffon vulture'?

  • Mainly the griffon vulture, or at least including it.

    Aramaic and Arabic cognates name the griffon. The bird of Micah 1:16 is 'bald'. In Job 39:30 it gathers where the slain are, and in Prov 30:17 its young eat eyes. Matt 24:28's aetoi gather at a carcass. Griffons were the most common great raptor of the region.

  • A general word for large raptors, eagles included.

    Texts about speed, soaring and high nests (2 Sam 1:23; Jer 49:16; Isa 40:31) suit eagles as well as vultures. The ancient Greek and Latin translations chose 'eagle'. Ancient Hebrew probably did not draw the eagle/vulture line at all.

in v12

Which bird is the ʿozniyyah?

  • Osprey or sea-eagle.

    The Septuagint's haliaietos and the Vulgate after it. This is the older English tradition (KJV).

  • Black (cinereous) vulture.

    A modern zoological suggestion that the first three names form a group of large vultures native to the Levant. Followed by BSB, ESV and NIV.

  • Short-toed eagle or another large raptor.

    Proposed by some lexicographers. The root of the word is unclear, so certainty is impossible.

in v12, v13

Why are these birds forbidden?

  • Association with blood and carcasses.

    The forbidden birds are mostly flesh-eaters and scavengers. Israel had strong taboos on eating blood (Deut 12:23) and on contact with corpses. Later Jewish law made 'a bird that seizes prey is unclean' a rule (m. Ḥullin 3:6). Held by scholars such as Milgrom.

  • A symbolic order of creation and identity.

    The anthropologist Mary Douglas argued that the food laws trace out an ordered world that matched Israel's set-apart status. Deut 14:2, 21 put the list under the heading of holiness.

  • A command without a stated reason, shaping identity through obedience.

    The text itself gives no reason beyond 'you are a holy people'. A strand of rabbinic thought treats such laws as decrees to be kept even without a known rationale.

in v13

Is 'ra'ah' an original bird name or a copying variant of 'da'ah' (Lev 11:14)?

  • Copying variant: the original was da'ah, and ra'ah (and perhaps dayyah) arose from the near-identical letters ד/ר or from merging two readings.

    Ra'ah appears only here as a bird name; the parallel list has da'ah; the Samaritan Pentateuch reportedly reads da'ah; Leviticus lists two birds where Deuteronomy lists three.

  • Genuine name: ra'ah was a real name, 'the seer', for a sharp-sighted raptor, kept alongside related names.

    The name fits the bird's behaviour, and the Talmud (Hullin 63b) explains it by the bird's keen sight. Deuteronomy's list differs from Leviticus elsewhere as well, so a fuller list is plausible.

in v14

Why are ravens (and the other listed birds) forbidden?

  • They eat carrion and blood. Most of the listed birds are birds of prey or scavengers, and eating them would mean taking in the blood and death the Torah keeps away from Israel's table.

    Nearly every bird in the list eats flesh or carrion. The Torah strongly forbids consuming blood (Lev 17:10–14; Deut 12:23). The Letter of Aristeas (2nd century BC, §§145–149) explains that the forbidden birds are wild and flesh-eating and prey on others, while the permitted ones eat grain. The Mishnah (Hullin 3:6) treats a bird that seizes its prey as unclean. Many modern scholars, notably Jacob Milgrom, connect the system to respect for life and blood.

  • They don't fit the categories. Unclean animals are ones that don't fit neatly into the created order's categories, and the lists express ideas about order and wholeness.

    This argument fits the land and water animals well, since they come with defining features. It fits birds poorly, because no test for birds is given. Its main proponent, the anthropologist Mary Douglas, later revised her view.

  • Identity is the main function, whatever the reasons for particular birds. The lists mainly mark Israel off as a holy people, and the reasons for individual species may be mixed or no longer recoverable.

    Deuteronomy itself frames the chapter with "you are a holy people" (14:2, 21) and gives no reason for any specific bird.

in v15

Is the bat ya'anah the ostrich or a large owl?

  • Ostrich

    The LXX's strouthos and the Vulgate's strutio both point to the ostrich, and ostriches lived in the region's deserts. Lam 4:3 calls the ya'ēnîm cruel to their young "in the wilderness", which matches ostrich folklore (compare Job 39:13–16), and the ostrich's booming cry fits Mic 1:8.

  • Eagle-owl or another large owl

    The bird lives in ruined cities with other creatures of the night (Isa 13:21; 34:13; Jer 50:39), and it wails at night. Its place among birds of prey in the list also fits. This view was argued by G. R. Driver and is followed by the NIV and NLT.

in v15, v17

Why are these birds unclean?

  • Birds of prey and carrion-eaters: a link with blood and death

    Most of the identifiable birds are raptors or scavengers. The Mishnah (Ḥullin 3:6) makes seizing prey with claws a mark of the unclean. Milgrom links the ban to the reverence for life expressed in the blood prohibition.

  • Symbolic order and categories

    Mary Douglas and others read the food laws as marking off creatures that do not fit their category or that belong to the realm of chaos and wasteland. These birds' homes in ruins and deserts are cited in support.

  • Hygiene or health

    Carrion-eaters can carry disease. Critics answer that the text never gives health as a reason and instead frames the laws as a matter of holiness and identity (Deut 14:2, 21).

in v16

Which bird is the tinshemet?

  • Barn owl (*Tyto alba*)

    The root נשׁם ("breathe, hiss") fits the barn owl's hissing and snoring calls. It is listed beside two other owls. HALOT and most modern versions (ESV, NLT, and the BSB's "white owl") favor this view.

  • A waterbird (purple swamphen) or swan

    The Septuagint has *porphyriōn* in Lev 11:18, and the Vulgate has *cygnus*, which became the KJV's "swan." These are early witnesses, but they may already be guesses, and they break up the group of owls.

  • Bat or other night creature

    Rashi glosses it with the Old French word for "bat." The bat ends the Torah's bird list (Deut 14:18), and it was counted among the birds there. This is a later, uncertain tradition.

in v16

Why were these birds forbidden?

  • They are birds of prey, eat carrion or consume blood

    Most birds on the list eat flesh or carrion, and the Torah forbids eating blood (Deut 12:23; Lev 17:10–14). This view is associated with Jacob Milgrom (Leviticus, Anchor Bible) and others.

  • Symbolic order and categories

    Mary Douglas (*Purity and Danger*) argued that unclean creatures did not fit their category neatly. Her view works better for the land-animal tests than for the bird list, and she later modified it.

  • Association with death and desolation

    Owls and ravens appear in prophetic pictures of ruin (Isa 34:11–15; Zeph 2:14; Ps 102:6), so avoiding them kept Israel apart from what belonged to death.

  • Covenant identity, with no explanation needed

    Deuteronomy frames the whole chapter with "you are a holy people" (14:2, 21) and gives no reason for each bird. Some interpreters therefore see the list chiefly as a boundary marker of Israel's distinct identity. Health explanations do not come from the text, which never mentions health.

in v17

Which bird is the qaʾat?

  • A pelican.

    The Septuagint and Vulgate render it this way. A possible derivation from qyʾ, 'to vomit,' would fit pelicans bringing up food for their young.

  • An owl or another bird of desolate places (desert owl, scops owl, little owl).

    In Isaiah 34:11, Zephaniah 2:14 and Psalm 102:6 it lives in the wilderness and in ruins, alongside owls and ravens. Pelicans are water birds.

in v18

Why are these particular winged creatures unclean?

  • Flesh-eaters and carrion-eaters: most forbidden birds kill prey or eat dead animals, which connects to the ban on eating blood.

    Most birds in Leviticus 11:13–19 / Deuteronomy 14:12–18 are raptors, carrion birds or fish-eaters (storks, herons). Mishnah Chullin 3:6 makes 'a bird that preys' the first sign of an unclean bird. Medieval Jewish commentators and modern scholars (e.g. Jacob Milgrom) tie this to the blood prohibition. The hoopoe and bat fit less neatly.

  • Classification and boundaries: the laws mirror an ordered creation, and creatures that don't fit their realm neatly are excluded, as Israel itself is set apart.

    Mary Douglas, Purity and Danger (1966), later revised in her own work. This reading draws on the holiness frame in Deuteronomy 14:2, 21 and the creation categories of Genesis 1. Critics note that it explains the bird list poorly, because there are no stated criteria for birds.

  • Separation from surrounding religions: some animals were linked to foreign cults or omens.

    Some listed birds had religious associations in Egypt and Mesopotamia. The evidence is uneven for individual species.

  • Health and hygiene.

    Proposed by some medieval thinkers (e.g. Maimonides, in part) and many modern writers. The text never gives this reason, and it explains few of the bird entries. See popular_drift.

in v18

What bird is the 'anafah?

  • Heron.

    Medieval Jewish tradition (Rashi), followed by most English versions. It fits the setting next to the stork among wading birds.

  • Plover or another shore bird.

    The Septuagint's charadrios and the Vulgate's charadrion.

  • Uncertain or another bird (cormorant, hawk).

    The word occurs only twice and has no description. Its root is unclear (possibly '-n-p, 'snort / be angry').

in v19

Does Deuteronomy 14:19 forbid all winged insects, including the locusts Leviticus allows?

  • No. Deuteronomy assumes the fuller law, and v. 20 ('every clean flyer you may eat') covers the clean locusts.

    Lev 11:21–22 explicitly allows four kinds of leaping locust. Rabbinic interpretation reads Deuteronomy together with Leviticus. Second Temple practice assumed locusts were allowed: CD 12:14–15 gives rules for cooking them, and Mark 1:6 says John the Baptist ate them.

  • Taken by itself, Deuteronomy's wording is a blanket ban, and it may come from a separate or simpler form of the tradition.

    The verse says 'every swarmer of the flyers' with no qualifier and no mention of locusts. Some critical scholars think Deuteronomy 14 and Leviticus 11 grew separately from a common list, with Leviticus adding the detailed exception.

in v19

Why were swarming flyers classed as unclean?

  • Category or 'anomaly' theory: creatures that do not fit the normal pattern of their area of creation are unclean.

    Mary Douglas (*Purity and Danger*) argued that flyers should fly, while these swarm and walk along the ground 'on all fours' (Lev 11:20). The locusts allowed are the ones that hop, which fits ordinary movement on land. Douglas later revised parts of her theory.

  • Holiness and identity: the main function is to mark Israel off as a people set apart, whatever the reason behind each individual rule.

    The framing statements of the chapter (14:2, 21, 'you are a holy people'). Lev 20:24–26 links separating clean from unclean animals to God separating Israel from the nations.

  • Ethical restraint: the system limits which animals may be killed for food, teaching respect for life.

    Jacob Milgrom (Anchor Bible *Leviticus*) points to the small number of permitted animals and to the blood prohibition.

  • Health or hygiene.

    Some forbidden creatures do carry disease risks. But the text never gives that reason, and it allows locusts and lets foreigners eat carcasses that Israelites may not (14:21). Most modern commentators therefore treat health as at most a side effect.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.