Deuteronomy Chapter 20 Read as one passage

Deuteronomy 20:15–18

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

15This is how you are to treat all the cities that are far away from you and do not belong to the nations nearby. 16However, in the cities of the nations that the LORD your God is giving you as an inheritance, you must not leave alive anything that breathes. 17For you must devote them to complete destruction—the Hittites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzites, Hivites, and Jebusites—as the LORD your God has commanded you, 18so that they cannot teach you to do all the detestable things they do for their gods, and so cause you to sin against the LORD your God.

What the first hearers heard

For the first hearers, the verse set a boundary on violence as well as authorising it. It told Israel that the total destruction commanded in verses 16–18 was not the normal way to wage war. That was reserved for one specific, named group of peoples tied to one specific land. Every other enemy city fell under the ordinary rules of ancient warfare. Terms were offered first. Surrender meant subjugation and forced labour rather than death. Resistance meant the conventional (and brutal) fate of a captured city: the men killed, the women and children taken.

The verse also tied Israel's identity to the land. The harsher law depended on the land being Israel's "inheritance" from its God, and on the fear that its former inhabitants' religion would draw Israel away (v. 18). If the book took its main shape in the late monarchy, as many think, its hearers no longer had Hittites or Jebusites to fight. For them the two categories mainly stated how seriously Israel had to stay separate from Canaanite worship. Israel's own story tradition shows the rule was well known: the Gibeonite deception (Joshua 9) only works if everyone knows that "very far off" cities get terms and the cities of "these nations" do not.

From the study of Deuteronomy 20:15.

Verse by verse

  1. 15This is how you are to treat all the cities that are far away from you and do not belong to the nations nearby.

    "In just this way, by the procedure I have laid out, you are to deal with every city that lies very far away from you: cities that do not belong to the cities of these peoples, the ones whose land you are about to inherit."

    The verse is a hinge. Looking back, its "in just this way" covers all of verses 10–14. Israel approaches a city and offers terms. If the city opens its gates, its people become Israel's forced labourers. If it fights, it is besieged, its men are killed, and the women, children, livestock and goods are taken as plunder. Looking forward, the verse limits that procedure to cities "very far off", and its second clause defines what that means: cities that are not among "these nations", the specific peoples of Canaan named in verse 17. For those cities, verses 16–18 give a harsher law: nothing that breathes is to be left alive. The singular "you" addresses Israel as a single person. The double description, far away and not one of these peoples, shows that the real test is not distance in miles. It is whether a city belongs to the land Israel is to inherit. Later Israelite storytellers knew this rule well. In Joshua 9 the Gibeonites, who lived in the land, pretend to come from "a very distant land" in order to be treated under the first law rather than the second.

    Full study →
  2. 16However, in the cities of the nations that the LORD your God is giving you as an inheritance, you must not leave alive anything that breathes.

    "But this case is different. In the cities of these peoples, the ones already living in the land that the LORD your God is now handing over to you as your family's lasting allotment, you must not spare a single living person. No captives, no one kept alive."

    The verse is an exception clause. The verses just before it (20:10–15) set the normal rule of war for Israel: offer a city terms of peace first; if it refuses and is taken, kill the fighting men but spare the women, children and livestock. Verse 16 opens with raq, "only" or "however", and cancels that mercy for one category: the towns inside the land being granted as Israel's naḥălāh. That word does not mean property left at someone's death. It means a hereditary family estate held from its true owner, God. The verb is lō' təḥayyeh, "you shall not let live", the same verb used when midwives "let the boys live" in Exodus 1 and when Israel swore to "let the Gibeonites live" in Joshua 9. So the ban is aimed at sparing and taking captives, the exact things v. 14 had allowed. "Any breath" (kol-nəšāmāh) is idiomatic for "not a soul": in Deuteronomy and Joshua it refers to the human population, while livestock are handled under the plunder rules. Verse 17 names the act: ḥērem, "devoting" these peoples to destruction. Verse 18 gives Deuteronomy's own reason: "so that they will not teach you to do all their detestable things that they do for their gods."

    Full study →
  3. 17For you must devote them to complete destruction—the Hittites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzites, Hivites, and Jebusites—as the LORD your God has commanded you,

    "No — instead you must put them under the ḥerem, without exception: give them over irrevocably to Yahweh — the Hittite and the Amorite, the Canaanite and the Perizzite, the Hivite and the Jebusite — just as Yahweh your God has already commanded you."

    The Hebrew doubles its verb, "devoting, you shall devote them." This marks the command as absolute and not open to negotiation. The verb ḥāram does not simply mean "destroy." It means to make something ḥerem: to remove it from human use and hand it over to God for good. Once devoted, it could never be redeemed, sold, enslaved or kept as plunder (Lev 27:28–29). In war the defeated were therefore killed, not taken as captives. The previous verse spells this out: "you shall not let anything that breathes live." The word holds both ideas at once, a sacred transfer to God and the death it required.

    The contrast with vv.10–15 is deliberate. Cities "very far from you" were to be offered peace first. If they resisted, their men were killed, but women, children and livestock became Israel's plunder. The cities of the land Israel is to inherit get no such terms and give no profit. The six names, joined in pairs in Hebrew, are a traditional formula for "the peoples of the land" (Deut 7:1 has seven). The next verse gives the stated reason: so that they would not teach Israel to copy the "detestable things" they did for their gods.

    Full study →
  4. 18so that they cannot teach you to do all the detestable things they do for their gods, and so cause you to sin against the LORD your God.

    "…so that they will not train you to practise everything they treat as worship (the rites Yahweh counts as utterly out of bounds, which they have performed for their gods), and so you end up breaking faith with Yahweh, the God who is yours."

    The verse gives the reason for the harsh command in v.17. In Deuteronomy's war laws, distant cities are first offered peace (vv.10–15). The cities of the land itself are to be put under the ban: devoted wholly to God and destroyed. The reason stated here is not ethnic hatred or loot. It is fear of being taught. The verb is Deuteronomy's own word for teaching and learning God's instruction, so the picture is of the peoples of the land becoming Israel's religious teachers and shaping them, by example and habit, into their practices.

    Those practices are called toʿevot: acts that fall outside what Yahweh accepts. English has "abominations" or "detestable things", but the point is less the feeling of disgust than the line being crossed. The verse identifies them as things "done for their gods", that is, acts of worship. Elsewhere Deuteronomy names them: burning sons and daughters to the gods, divination, sorcery, consulting the dead (12:31; 18:9–12).

    The ending matches "for their gods" with "against Yahweh your God". What others did as devotion to their gods would be, for Israel, sin: a breach of loyalty against the God already bound to them, like a vassal breaking faith with his overlord. The address also widens from the singular "you" of v.17 to a plural "you". The danger is to the whole people.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v15

    the nations nearby (BSB, NIV)

    haggôyim hā'ēlleh

    What we hear
    Any neighbouring peoples close to Israel's borders, as if the rule were simply 'near enemies get destroyed, far ones get terms'.
    What they heard
    'These nations': a closed, named list of peoples living in the land promised to Israel (v. 17; 7:1). Nearness was a symptom; membership in that list and that land was the criterion. Neighbours such as Edom, Moab and Ammon were not in this category (compare 2:4–19; 23:7).
  • in v16

    anything that breathes / nothing that breatheth

    kol-nəšāmāh

    What we hear
    Every living creature, people and animals alike.
    What they heard
    An idiom like English 'not a soul': every human inhabitant. In Deuteronomy and Joshua, livestock are treated separately and often taken as plunder (Deut 2:34–35; 3:6–7; Josh 11:14), unless a text explicitly includes them (Josh 6:21; 1 Sam 15:3).
  • in v16

    inheritance

    naḥălāh

    What we hear
    Property passed on when someone dies.
    What they heard
    A hereditary family or tribal allotment granted by the land's divine owner and meant to stay in the family line permanently. No death is involved.
  • in v17

    utterly destroy / completely destroy

    haḥărēm taḥărîmēm (ḥāram)

    What we hear
    Ordinary annihilation, purely military or political slaughter.
    What they heard
    To make something ḥerem: hand it over irrevocably to Yahweh as 'most holy', taken out of all human use. In war this meant killing the population and allowing no plunder or slaves. The killing is real (v.16), but it is set within a sacred category that English 'destroy' loses.
  • in v17

    devote (BSB, ESV, YLT)

    ḥāram

    What we hear
    In modern English 'devote' suggests affection or dedication ('a devoted parent'), which can sound gentle or positive.
    What they heard
    An irreversible consecration that bans redemption or use. Applied to people in war it was lethal (Lev 27:29). 'Devote' is a technical term here, not a warm one.
  • in v17

    Hittites

    ḥittî

    What we hear
    The Bronze Age Hittite empire of Anatolia (Hattusa).
    What they heard
    In Deuteronomy, a traditional people of Canaan, the 'sons of Heth' known from Genesis 23. Their link to the Anatolian empire is uncertain.
  • in v17

    Canaanites

    kənaʿănî

    What we hear
    A single race or nation. Sometimes also shorthand for 'the wicked pagans' as a whole.
    What they heard
    Here one item in a traditional list. Elsewhere a broad regional label for the land's inhabitants, and in some texts simply 'merchant'. The verse's own rationale (v.18) is religious practice, and Deut 13 applies the same ḥerem to Israelites who worship other gods.
  • in v18

    That they teach you not to do after all their abominations (KJV; similarly YLT)

    lemaʿan ʾasher lo-yelammedu ʾetkhem laʿasot

    What we hear
    A modern reader can take 'not' with 'to do', as if the verse said 'so that they would teach you to avoid their abominations', which is the opposite of the sense.
    What they heard
    'So that they will not teach you to do…' The negative belongs to 'teach'. The fear is that they would teach Israel these practices.
  • in v18

    abominations / detestable things

    toʿevot

    What we hear
    A label of moral outrage or physical disgust, which in church use is linked mostly to sexual sins.
    What they heard
    Practices outside what Yahweh accepts: acts that cross a boundary he has drawn. Here specifically rites of worship 'done for their gods', such as child sacrifice and divination (Deut 12:31; 18:9–12).
Every word
  1. כֵּ֤ן

    kēn · H3651C

    so, thus · v15

    Points backward: 'in this way', meaning the whole procedure just laid out in verses 10–14 (offer terms, accept surrender, or besiege and take the city). It is the word that turns the preceding paragraph into a rule with a defined scope.

  2. תַּעֲשֶׂה֙

    ta'ăśeh · H6213A

    do, make · v15, v18

    'You shall do', a future-form verb used as an instruction. The 'you' is singular: Israel is addressed as one person, as throughout Deuteronomy.

  3. לְכָל־

    lᵉkol · H3605

    all, every · v15, v16, v18

    'To all'. With the verb 'do', the preposition 'to' gives the sense 'treat': this is how you treat every such city, without exception.

  4. הֶ֣עָרִ֔ים

    he'ārîm · H5892B

    city, town · v15, v16

    'The cities': in this chapter, walled settlements that can be besieged (vv. 12, 19–20), often small by modern standards. The law is framed city by city, not people by people.

  5. הָרְחֹקֹ֥ת

    hārᵉḥōqōt · H7350

    far, distant · v15

    'The far-off ones', a feminine plural adjective agreeing with 'cities' (a grammatically feminine noun). Distance is the first marker of the category.

  6. מִמְּךָ֖

    mimmᵉkā · H4480A

    from · v15

    'From you': far from Israel, the singular 'you', which in this book stands on the edge of the land it is about to enter.

  7. מְאֹ֑ד

    mᵉ'ōd · H3966

    very, exceedingly · v15

    'Very': intensifies 'far'. Some modern translations drop it, but it is part of the phrase that Joshua 9 later echoes word for word.

  8. אֲשֶׁ֛ר

    'ăšer · H0834A

    which, that · v15, v16, v17, v18

    Introduces the second, defining description of the cities: not only far away, but outside a specific group.

  9. לֹא־

    lō' · H3808

    not · v15, v16, v18

    Plain negation: these cities are not among the group named next.

  10. הַגּֽוֹיִם־

    haggôyim · H1471A

    nation, people · v15

    'The nations': peoples or ethnic groups with their own land. Here it means the particular peoples living in the land promised to Israel, named in verse 17 (Hittites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzites, Hivites, Jebusites).

  11. הָאֵ֖לֶּה

    hā'ēlleh · H0428

    these · v15, v16

    'These': it points to a known, specific set, the nations Deuteronomy keeps referring to as the ones Israel is dispossessing (7:1; 19:1), and that verses 16–17 are about to name. It is not 'nations in general'.

  12. הֵֽנָּה׃

    hēnnāh · H2007

    they (feminine) · v15

    'They [are]': a feminine pronoun referring back to the cities. Hebrew uses it here where English uses the verb 'are', closing the clause: 'which are not of the cities of these nations'.

  13. רַ֗ק

    raq · H7535

    only, except, however · v16

    A hinge word that sets up a sharp exception. It marks a break from the rules just given in vv. 10–15 for distant cities (offer peace first; if war, spare women, children and livestock): 'But in this case it is different.'

  14. הָֽעַמִּים֙

    hā‘ammîm · H5971A

    people, kin-group, nation · v16

    'The peoples': population groups thought of as kin-based communities. Verse 17 names them: Hittites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzites, Hivites, Jebusites.

  15. יְהוָ֣ה

    YHWH · H3068G

    the LORD (the divine name) · v16, v17, v18

    Israel's God, named by his personal name. The giving of the land, and the war rule attached to it, are put down to him.

  16. אֱלֹהֶ֔יךָ

    ’ĕlōheykā · H0430G

    God; your God · v16, v17, v18

    'Your God'. The 'you' is singular, as all through Deuteronomy: Israel is addressed as one person bound to its God by covenant.

  17. נֹתֵ֥ן

    nōtēn · H5414G

    give · v16

    A participle, 'is giving' or 'is about to give'. The grant is under way but not yet complete; Israel stands on the border.

  18. לְךָ֖

    ləkā · H9031

    to you · v16

    'To you' (singular), the people of Israel as a whole.

  19. נַחֲלָ֑ה

    naḥălāh · H5159

    inheritance, hereditary allotment · v16

    The land as a family holding granted by its divine owner and meant to pass down the generations within Israel's clans. It is not a bequest left at someone's death.

  20. תְחַיֶּ֖ה

    təḥayyeh · H2421

    (Piel) keep alive, let live, spare · v16

    'You shall let live' or 'spare'. With the negative it rules out sparing anyone, including taking them as captives, which v. 14 had allowed for distant cities.

  21. נְשָׁמָֽה׃

    nəšāmāh · H5397

    breath; a breathing (living) being · v16

    'Breath' standing for a living person, much as English 'soul' can mean a person ('not a soul survived'). In Deuteronomy and Joshua this phrase points mainly to human inhabitants (see the studies).

  22. כִּֽי־

    kî · H3588A

    for, because; but rather; indeed · v17

    It follows the negative command of v.16 ("you shall not let anything that breathes live"). After a negative, kî often means "but rather" (KJV, WEB: "But"). It can also give the reason (BSB, YLT: "For"). Either way it opens the positive side of the same command.

  23. הַחֲרֵ֣ם

    haḥărēm · H2763A

    to devote (irrevocably to God), to put under the ban · v17

    A verb form that names the action without tense, placed before the finite verb for emphasis: "devoting, you shall devote." It stresses that the command is absolute and not to be softened.

  24. הַחִתִּ֤י

    haḥittî · H2850

    Hittite · v17

    Singular with 'the', used for the whole group: 'the Hittite' as a people. In Genesis–Joshua these are a local group in Canaan, the 'sons of Heth' (Gen 23). How they relate to the Hittite empire of Anatolia is unclear.

  25. וְהָאֱמֹרִי֙

    wəhāʾĕmōrî · H0567

    Amorite · v17

    'And the Amorite'. The word is sometimes a specific people (Sihon and Og east of the Jordan, Deut 3) and sometimes a general name for the land's earlier inhabitants (Gen 15:16).

  26. הַכְּנַעֲנִ֣י

    hakkənaʿănî · H3669A

    Canaanite · v17

    Here one group in a list. Elsewhere it is the umbrella term for everyone living in Canaan. The 'and' pattern pairs it with the Perizzite.

  27. וְהַפְּרִזִּ֔י

    wəhappərizzî · H6522

    Perizzite · v17

    'And the Perizzite'. Possibly connected with pərāzî, 'people of unwalled villages' (Deut 3:5), which would make it a description of how people lived rather than an ethnic name. That is uncertain.

  28. הַחִוִּ֖י

    haḥiwwî · H2340

    Hivite · v17

    A group linked with Gibeon and Shechem (Josh 9; Gen 34). Some scholars connect it with the Horites/Hurrians. In Joshua 9 the Hivite Gibeonites survive by tricking Israel into a treaty.

  29. וְהַיְבוּסִ֑י

    wəhayəbûsî · H2983G

    Jebusite · v17

    'And the Jebusite', the people of Jebus/Jerusalem. They held the city until David took it (2 Sam 5:6–9) and were still living there afterwards (2 Sam 24:18).

  30. צִוְּךָ֖

    ṣiwwəkā · H6680

    he commanded you · v17

    A completed action ('has commanded you') pointing back especially to Deut 7:1–2, where the same emphatic 'devoting, you shall devote' appears, and to Exod 23:23–33; 34:11–16.

  31. לְמַ֗עַן

    lemaʿan · H4616

    for the sake of, in order that · v18

    Opens a purpose clause. It ties this verse straight back to the command in v.17 and gives the reason for it: this is why the command exists.

  32. יְלַמְּד֤וּ

    yelammedu · H3925G

    teach (Piel) · v18

    'They will teach.' This is the same verb Deuteronomy uses again and again for Israel learning and teaching Yahweh's instruction. The danger is that the peoples of the land become Israel's teachers in worship.

  33. אֶתְכֶם֙

    ʾetkhem · H0853

    object marker + 'you' (plural) · v18

    'You all.' Verse 17 spoke to Israel as a single 'you'. Here the address switches to the plural and spreads the risk across the whole people.

  34. תּֽוֹעֲבֹתָ֔ם

    toʿavotam · H8441

    abomination, abhorrent thing · v18

    'Their abominations': practices that fall outside what Yahweh will accept. Deuteronomy elsewhere names them as burning children to the gods, divination, sorcery and consulting the dead (12:31; 18:9–12).

  35. וַחֲטָאתֶ֖ם

    vaḥataʾtem · H2398

    to sin, fail, offend against · v18

    'And so you would sin.' This continues the purpose clause and names the result: a breach against the party Israel is bound to.

The world behind it

The structure of Deuteronomy 20. The chapter is a set of laws for war. Verses 1–9 cover morale and who is exempt from fighting. Verses 10–18 cover how to treat enemy cities. Verses 19–20 forbid cutting down fruit trees during a siege. Verses 10–18 set out two categories of city:

  • Distant cities (vv. 10–15): Israel first proclaims "peace" (šālôm), here meaning terms of surrender. If the city accepts, its population becomes mas, forced or corvée labour, the unpaid state work that ancient kingdoms imposed on subject peoples (compare 1 Kings 9:20–21). If it refuses, the city is besieged, its males are killed, and the rest of the population and property are taken as spoil. This matches standard practice in the ancient Near East. Assyrian and other royal inscriptions describe cities that submit becoming tribute-paying subjects and cities that resist being sacked.
  • Cities of "these nations" (vv. 16–18): In the cities of the peoples whose land is Israel's "inheritance", Israel is to "devote to destruction" (ḥērem) everything that breathes. The stated reason is religious: so that they cannot teach Israel their worship practices (v. 18; compare 7:1–5; 12:29–31). The idea of devoting a conquered population to a god is not unique to Israel. King Mesha of Moab's inscription (9th century BC) says he devoted Israelite Nebo to his god Ashtar-Chemosh.

Verse 15 is the sentence that divides the two categories.

The Gibeonite test case. Joshua 9 is told with this law in view. The Gibeonites are Hivites (9:7), one of the listed peoples. They disguise themselves as travellers from "a very distant land" to get a treaty. When the trick comes out, Israel keeps its oath but makes them woodcutters and water-carriers, the forced-labour outcome of 20:11.

When this was heard. Deuteronomy presents itself as Moses' speech on the plains of Moab before the conquest. Many scholars date the book's main composition to the late monarchy (7th century BC), when the listed Canaanite peoples no longer existed as distinct groups. For that audience the "these nations" category worked largely as a statement about Israel's identity and its separation from Canaanite worship, not as a current military order. This dating is debated (see Debates).

From the study of Deuteronomy 20:15.

Where scholars differ

in v15

Does 'thus you shall do' (v. 15) restrict the whole procedure of verses 10–14, including the offer of peace, or only the sparing of women and children?

  • The whole procedure, including the offer of terms, applies only to distant cities. The cities of 'these nations' are not offered peace.

    The plain order of the text: verse 15 follows verses 10–14 as a block, and verse 16 begins with the contrasting 'However' (*raq*). Rashi (on 20:10) reads verses 10–15 as covering optional wars, citing verse 15. Deuteronomy 7:2 says 'make no covenant with them'. Joshua 9 treats a treaty with Hivites as obtained only by deception.

  • Peace was to be offered even to the cities of the seven nations. Verse 15 limits only the sparing of women and children (v. 14), or the terms after a city refuses.

    Ramban (Nahmanides) on 20:10, followed by Maimonides (Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings 6:1), cites Joshua 11:19–20: 'there was not a city that made peace with Israel except the Hivites of Gibeon... for it was from the LORD to harden their hearts', which suggests peace was possible. Rabbinic tradition (e.g., Leviticus Rabbah / Jerusalem Talmud traditions about Joshua sending messages to the Canaanites) supports this view.

in v15

Is the 'these nations' category a practical military law or a later ideological construction?

  • It reflects instructions given at Israel's entry into the land, as the book presents them (Moses on the plains of Moab).

    The book's own setting, and the narratives in Joshua that apply these categories (Jericho, Ai, Gibeon).

  • It was largely shaped in the late monarchy (7th century BC), when the listed peoples no longer existed. It worked mainly as a statement about Israel's identity and religious separation.

    The stereotyped lists of peoples. The stated reason in verse 18 is religious rather than military. Deuteronomy 7:3 forbids intermarriage with the same peoples, which assumes they are still around rather than wiped out. The book shares themes with the Josianic reform (Weinfeld; Nelson; Lohfink on *ḥērem*).

in v16

Was this command meant, or carried out, literally?

  • Literal command, presented as carried out at least in part

    The wording is unqualified ('not any breath'). Joshua 10:40 and 11:11–14 echo it word for word as fulfilled. Deut 2:34 and 3:6 describe similar total destruction east of the Jordan. Ancient Near Eastern parallels such as the Mesha Stele show that whole populations were in fact massacred under ḥērem-type bans.

  • Stereotyped war rhetoric, meant as hyperbole (exaggeration)

    Ancient conquest accounts habitually claimed total annihilation while the enemy survived (K. L. Younger, Ancient Conquest Accounts). Joshua says 'no breath' remained but also that much land and many inhabitants remained (Josh 13:1–6; 15:63; 16:10; Judg 1). Deut 7:2–3 bans intermarriage with the same peoples it orders destroyed, which assumes they would still be around. Proposed by e.g. Wolterstorff; Copan and Flannagan.

  • Late, idealised law that was never a working policy

    Many critical scholars date Deuteronomy to the 7th century BCE, when the listed peoples no longer existed as distinct groups. Archaeology mostly points to Israel emerging gradually within Canaan rather than through a sweeping conquest. On this view the law expresses an ideology of religious purity and separation (e.g. Lohfink in TDOT; Nelson; Collins), whatever its ethical implications.

  • Ḥērem in Deuteronomy as a symbol of religious separation

    R. W. L. Moberly and others note that in Deut 7 ḥērem stands alongside 'make no covenant, do not intermarry, tear down their altars'. They read it as total exclusion of rival worship from Israel's life. Critics answer that 20:16 concerns killing people in actual war, not only symbols.

in v16

Does 'any breath' (kol-neshamah) include animals?

in v16

Could the Canaanite cities be offered peace or be spared?

  • No: v. 16 overrides the peace offer of v. 10

    Raq ('only, however') marks vv. 16–18 as a separate case. Deut 7:2 says 'make no covenant with them'. The Gibeonite treaty in Josh 9 is told as an exception gained by trickery.

  • Yes: the peace offer and the possibility of repentance applied to them too (rabbinic reading)

    Sifre, the Jerusalem Talmud and Maimonides extend v. 10 to all cities. Rashi reads v. 18's purpose clause as leaving room to accept Canaanites who abandoned their gods. Rahab (Josh 2; 6:25) is cited as an example.

in v17

Was the ḥerem command meant literally, and was it carried out?

  • A literal command of total destruction, at least partly carried out in the conquest.

    The plain wording of v.16 ('anything that breathes'). Joshua's narratives (6:21; 10:40; 11:11–14). The Mesha Stele shows ḥerem as a real ancient practice. 1 Samuel 15 treats Saul's partial compliance as disobedience.

  • Stock war rhetoric exaggerated on purpose, with the real goal of driving the peoples out and breaking their worship.

    Deut 7:3 forbids marrying the same peoples, which assumes survivors. Exod 23:28–30 and Deut 7:22 speak of driving them out 'little by little'. Judges 1 and 1 Kgs 9:20–21 report the peoples still living in the land. Ancient conquest accounts habitually claim total annihilation in sweeping terms (K. L. Younger, *Ancient Conquest Accounts*). Associated with scholars such as Younger and with Copan and Flannagan.

  • A late, idealised program: a statement of identity and exclusive loyalty, not a record of events or an operative law.

    Most scholars date the core of Deuteronomy to the 7th century BC, when these nations no longer existed. The stated rationale is religious (v.18). The same ḥerem is turned on Israelite apostates (Deut 13). Archaeology does not show a single wave of destruction matching Joshua (e.g. Jericho, Ai). Associated with readings by Lohfink, Nelson and Moberly (ḥerem as a picture of uncompromising loyalty to Yahweh). Critics of this view argue it removes the moral difficulty too quickly, since the text's own wording is still lethal.

in v17

What is ḥerem at root: sacrifice, punishment, or protection?

  • Ḥerem as an offering to the deity.

    Lev 27:28–29 calls ḥerem 'most holy to Yahweh'. Mesha devotes Nebo 'to Ashtar-Kemosh'. Plunder at Jericho goes to Yahweh's treasury (Josh 6:19). S. Niditch, *War in the Hebrew Bible*, calls this the 'ban as sacrifice' ideology.

  • Ḥerem as divine judgment on guilty peoples.

    Gen 15:16 ('the iniquity of the Amorite'). Deut 9:4–5 ('because of the wickedness of these nations'). Lev 18:24–28 (the land 'vomiting out' its inhabitants). Niditch calls this the 'ban as God's justice' ideology.

  • Ḥerem as removing a threat to Israel's worship and order.

    The purpose clause in v.18 here, and Deut 7:4, 25–26 ('lest it be a snare'). P. D. Stern, *The Biblical Ḥerem*, reads it as the defeat of chaos to establish divine order. These views can overlap, and Deuteronomy itself puts the most weight on the third.

in v18

Does the ḥerem command reflect real practice, or is it mainly an ideological and religious program?

  • It reflects actual war practice in Israel's early period, in line with ANE customs.

    Similar 'devotion' of cities to a god is attested on the Mesha Stele. Joshua 6–11 narrates ḥerem. The command is phrased as law to be carried out.

  • In Deuteronomy it works mainly as a theological or idealised call for exclusive loyalty to Yahweh, written for a later audience.

    Deuteronomy's likely late-monarchic setting, when the listed peoples no longer existed. Deut 7:2–3 bans treaties and intermarriage with the same peoples, which assumes they survive. Judges 1 and Joshua's own notes say many inhabitants remained (Josh 13:13; 15:63). The rationale in v.18 is about worship, not territory. (So e.g. Weinfeld, Nelson, Lohfink, Stern in different forms.)

in v18

What is the main reason given for destroying the peoples of the land?

  • Protection: preventing Israel's apostasy.

    Deut 20:18 and 7:4 state this explicitly. The verb 'teach' and the focus on rites 'done for their gods'.

  • Judgment: punishment for the peoples' own wickedness.

    Deut 9:4–5 ('because of the wickedness of these nations'); Gen 15:16 ('the iniquity of the Amorites is not yet complete'); Lev 18:24–28 (the land 'vomits out' its inhabitants).

  • Both, combined with the idea of devoting things to God.

    Deuteronomy gives several reasons side by side, and ḥerem as 'devotion' to the deity (Mesha Stele; Lev 27:28–29) is a third, sacral strand. Most commentators (e.g. Tigay) read these as complementary rather than competing.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. רָחוֹק, גּוֹי, עִיר, כֵּן
  • HALOT s.v. רָחוֹק, גּוֹי, עִיר
  • Rashi on Deuteronomy 20:10
  • Ramban (Nahmanides) on Deuteronomy 20:10
  • Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings and Wars 6:1
  • Jeffrey H. Tigay, JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (1996)
  • Richard D. Nelson, Deuteronomy (OTL, 2002)
  • Moshe Weinfeld, Deuteronomy and the Deuteronomic School (1972)
  • N. Lohfink, 'ḥāram', Theological Dictionary of the Old Testament vol. 5
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament (Walton, Matthews, Chavalas), on Deut 20
  • Mesha Inscription (Moabite Stone), lines 14–17
  • BDB s.v. נְשָׁמָה, חָיָה, נַחֲלָה
  • HALOT s.v. נְשָׁמָה; נַחֲלָה; חרם
  • TDOT s.v. ḥāram (N. Lohfink); s.v. nešāmâ
  • Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone), lines 14–17
  • K. Lawson Younger, Ancient Conquest Accounts (1990)
  • Philip D. Stern, The Biblical Herem: A Window on Israel's Religious Experience (1991)
  • R. W. L. Moberly, Old Testament Theology (2013), ch. on Deut 7
  • Richard D. Nelson, Deuteronomy (OTL)
  • Sifre Deuteronomy on Deut 20; Rashi on Deut 20:18; Maimonides, Hilkhot Melakhim 6
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Deut 20
  • BDB s.v. חָרַם
  • HALOT s.v. חרם I
  • N. Lohfink, "ḥāram, ḥērem," Theological Dictionary of the Old Testament vol. 5
  • Mesha Stele (KAI 181), lines 14–18
  • S. Niditch, War in the Hebrew Bible: A Study in the Ethics of Violence (1993)
  • P. D. Stern, The Biblical Ḥerem: A Window on Israel's Religious Experience (1991)
  • J. H. Tigay, The JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (1996)
  • R. D. Nelson, Deuteronomy (Old Testament Library, 2002)
  • M. Weinfeld, Deuteronomy 1–11 (Anchor Bible, 1991)
  • R. W. L. Moberly, Old Testament Theology (2013), ch. on Deuteronomy 7 and ḥerem
  • K. L. Younger, Ancient Conquest Accounts (1990)
  • P. Copan and M. Flannagan, Did God Really Command Genocide? (2014)
  • T. Ishida, "The Structure and Implications of the Lists of Pre-Israelite Nations," Biblica 60 (1979)
  • Septuagint, Deuteronomy 20:17
  • Vulgate, Deuteronomy 20:17
  • Mishnah Yadayim 4:4; Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Hilkhot Melakhim 6:1–4
  • BDB s.v. תּוֹעֵבָה, לָמַד, חָטָא, מַעַן
  • HALOT s.v. תּוֹעֵבָה; חטא; למד
  • TDOT, 'ḥāram' (N. Lohfink) and 'tôʿēbâ' (H. D. Preuss)
  • Tabnit sarcophagus inscription, KAI 13
  • Mesha Stele, KAI 181
  • J. H. Tigay, JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (1996)
  • M. Weinfeld, Deuteronomy and the Deuteronomic School (1972)
  • R. D. Nelson, Deuteronomy (OTL, 2002)
  • P. D. Stern, The Biblical Herem: A Window on Israel's Religious Experience (1991)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Deut 20:18; Vulgate, Deut 20:18

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).