Hebrews Chapter 5 Read as one passage

Hebrews 5:12–13

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

12Although by this time you ought to be teachers, you need someone to reteach you the basic principles of God’s word. You need milk, not solid food! 13For everyone who lives on milk is still an infant, inexperienced in the message of righteousness.

What the first hearers heard

To its first hearers this was a deliberate jolt. A respected teacher, speaking in the shaming idiom of ancient education, told a community that had been believers for years that they had gone backwards. Their debt was to become instructors of others. Instead they needed their ABCs again and had turned into adults who could only take milk.

The verse works in three ways:

  • Shame meant to provoke, not to dismiss. In an honour-and-shame culture, being likened to infants stung. But the author immediately says, "let us go on to maturity" (6:1), and "we are confident of better things concerning you" (6:9). Then he gives them the solid food anyway. The rebuke is meant to wake them up for what follows.
  • A diagnosis of drift. "You have become" ties their condition to the sermon's main worry: a community slowly losing its grip (2:1; 3:12-13; 10:25, 35-39). Spiritual sluggishness is presented as dangerous, the lead-in to the solemn warning of 6:4-8.
  • A call back to God's speech. The "oracles of God" were the scriptures they knew, which the author keeps reading as God speaking now about the Son. Recovering the basics meant hearing those scriptures again with attention, so that they could follow the argument that Jesus is the eternal high priest of Psalm 110.

From the study of Hebrews 5:12.

Verse by verse

  1. 12Although by this time you ought to be teachers, you need someone to reteach you the basic principles of God’s word. You need milk, not solid food!

    "For in fact, given how long you have been believers, you owe it to others to be teachers by now. Instead you need someone to teach you all over again the ABCs, the very first rudiments of God's own spoken words. You have slid back into being people who need milk, not solid food."

    The verse is built on irony. The word for "ought" comes from the language of debt: they have received years of instruction, and the fitting repayment is to become people who instruct others. Instead the would-be teachers are back on the pupil's bench, needing their letters taught again. "Elements of the beginning" is deliberately doubled for effect: not just basics, but the first basics, like a child reciting the alphabet. What they have lost hold of is not human opinion but "the oracles of God", God's speech in Israel's scriptures, now heard as fulfilled in the Son.

    The second half switches to food. "You have become" signals a slide backwards: they were not always like this, but they have drifted into it, just as 5:11 said they "have become" sluggish of hearing. Milk is a nursing infant's food. Solid food, food you must chew, is for grown people. The shame is not in milk itself but in adults who can take nothing else. In the next two verses the author explains that the "solid food" belongs to those whose senses have been trained by practice to tell good from evil. Then, rather than spooning out milk, he urges them to move on to maturity (6:1) and goes ahead with the harder teaching about Christ's priesthood.

    Full study →
  2. 13For everyone who lives on milk is still an infant, inexperienced in the message of righteousness.

    "Here is what it means to need milk: anyone whose diet is still nothing but milk has no practised skill in handling the word of righteousness, because he is still a baby."

    The verse explains verse 12. The author has just told his hearers that by now they ought to be teachers, yet they have become people who need someone to go over the ABCs of God's message with them again. Now he states the general rule. A person who lives on milk is apeiros: untried, unpractised, like a raw recruit or an apprentice who has never held the tools. What he lacks is skill in the word of righteousness, the teaching about what is right before God. That covers both the deeper teaching about Christ the author is about to give and the trained judgment needed to live it out, which verse 14 defines as telling good from evil.

    Why does he lack it? For he is a nēpios, a small child. Any ancient listener knew the opposite of nēpios: teleios, the full-grown adult, which is the very next word (v. 14). Teachers of the time, from Philo to the Stoic Epictetus, used "milk for infants, solid food for the mature" for stages of education. So the image was familiar, and the sting was obvious. These are not newborn converts. They are adults who should be feeding others and have slid back to the bottle. The verse is a deliberate jolt meant to shame them into growing up. The author's next move confirms it: "let us go on to maturity" (6:1), and he goes straight into the solid food.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v12

    strong meat (KJV)

    stereas trophēs

    What we hear
    Heavy, 'meaty' doctrine, like steak compared with milk: rich, intense or hard-hitting teaching.
    What they heard
    Solid food as opposed to liquid, the ordinary adult diet. It takes chewing and a grown body, not special potency.
  • in v12

    oracles of God (KJV, ESV, NASB)

    logia tou theou

    What we hear
    Mysterious prophetic pronouncements, like the oracle at Delphi or cryptic predictions.
    What they heard
    God's own utterances. In Jewish Greek this especially meant the scriptures of Israel as the speech of God (compare Rom 3:2; Acts 7:38).
  • in v12

    God's word (BSB, NIV)

    logia tou theou

    What we hear
    The Bible as a finished book of Old and New Testaments.
    What they heard
    God's utterances as these hearers had them: chiefly Israel's scriptures, read in light of God's final speaking 'in a Son' (1:2) and the apostolic preaching (2:3). There was not yet a collected New Testament.
  • in v13

    milk (vs. "meat")

    gala

    What we hear
    A neutral label for simple, entry-level teaching suited to new Christians. Being a "milk Christian" is a normal early stage.
    What they heard
    In this passage, a reproach: the foundational teachings of 6:1–2 were meant to be laid once and built on. Adults who should be teaching are still being fed milk, and that is a sign of having slid backwards.
  • in v13

    word of righteousness

    logos dikaiosynēs

    What we hear
    Either a vague "being good" or, in Protestant settings, the doctrine of justification (righteousness credited to the believer by faith).
    What they heard
    Teaching about what is right before God, which mature people can handle and put into practice. Verse 14 defines the skill as discerning good from evil, and Hebrews 12:11 links righteousness to training. It may also point to the coming teaching on Christ as "king of righteousness" (7:2).
Every word
  1. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and, even · v12

    Joined with γάρ it means 'for indeed' or 'for in fact', and it strengthens the explanation that follows.

  2. γὰρ

    gar · G1063

    for · v12, v13

    Introduces the evidence for 5:11's charge that the hearers have become 'sluggish in hearing'.

  3. ὀφείλοντες

    opheilontes · G3784

    to owe, be obligated · v12

    'Though you owe it to be...' The participle concedes a point ('although'). The word comes from the language of debt: being teachers is something they owe, not an optional extra.

  4. εἶναι

    einai · G1511

    to be · v12

    'To be.' It completes 'owe': they should already be in the condition of teachers.

  5. διδάσκαλοι

    didaskaloi · G1320

    teacher · v12

    People able to instruct others. Here this means mature believers who can pass the faith on, not mainly holders of a formal church office.

  6. διὰ

    dia · G1223

    through; because of · v12

    With the accusative it means 'because of' or 'by reason of'. The time that has passed is what creates the obligation.

  7. τὸν

    ton · G3588

    the · v12, v13

    Points to the specific stretch of time since they first believed.

  8. χρόνον,

    chronon · G5550

    time · v12

    The length of time they have been believers. Compare 2:3 and 10:32, 'the former days'. These are not new converts.

  9. πάλιν

    palin · G3825

    again · v12

    'Again.' They were taught once already, and now they need it a second time. It is placed early in its clause for emphasis.

  10. χρείαν

    chreian · G5532

    need · v12

    'Need.' It stands as an ironic counterpart to 'owe': they owe teaching to others, but they need teaching themselves.

  11. ἔχετε

    echete · G2192

    to have · v12

    'You have.' 'Have need' is an ordinary Greek idiom for 'you need'.

  12. διδάσκειν

    didaskein · G1321

    to teach · v12

    'To teach.' It echoes 'teachers' earlier in the verse, so the would-be teachers are back in the pupil's seat.

  13. ὑμᾶς

    humas · G4771

    you (plural) · v12

    'You', the object of the teaching. The whole community is addressed together.

  14. τινὰ

    tina · G5100

    someone; (accented τίνα) what? · v12

    As printed (τινά), it means 'someone', the one who would do the teaching. If accented τίνα, it means 'what': '[to teach you] what the elements are'. See textual notes.

  15. στοιχεῖα

    stoicheia · G4747

    element, rudiment · v12

    The ABCs, the first building blocks of a subject, like the letters a child learns before reading.

  16. ἀρχῆς

    archēs · G0746

    beginning · v12

    'Of the beginning.' Combined with 'elements' it doubles the point: the very first basics. It anticipates 6:1, 'the word of the beginning of Christ'.

  17. λογίων

    logiōn · G3051

    oracle, divine utterance · v12

    God's spoken words. In Jewish usage this especially meant the scriptures of Israel as God's speech, here heard in light of God speaking 'in a Son' (1:2).

  18. θεοῦ,

    theou · G2316

    God · v12

    The oracles belong to God and come from him. The basics they have forgotten are not human theories but God's own speech.

  19. γεγόνατε

    gegonate · G1096

    to become · v12

    'You have become.' This Greek perfect describes a present condition that resulted from a change. They slid into this state; they did not start there. It matches 5:11, 'you have become sluggish'.

  20. γάλακτος

    galaktos · G1051

    milk · v12, v13

    The nursing infant's food. It is an image for the first, elementary instruction in the faith.

  21. οὐ

    ou · G3756

    not · v12

    A flat 'not'. In their present state solid food is simply not what they can take.

  22. στερεᾶς

    stereas · G4731

    solid, firm · v12

    'Solid', as opposed to liquid. It is food you have to chew, which needs a grown body to handle it.

  23. τροφῆς.

    trophēs · G5160

    food, nourishment · v12

    The general word for food or nourishment. With 'solid' it means the adult's diet, as opposed to the infant's.

  24. πᾶς

    pas · G3956

    all, every · v13

    "Everyone" who fits the description that follows. It turns the rebuke of verse 12 into a general rule: this is simply what being on milk means.

  25. μετέχων

    metechōn · G3348

    to share in, partake of · v13

    "Partaking of," here in the plain sense of taking food. The present tense pictures an ongoing state: someone whose diet still is milk. "Only" or "lives on" in English versions draws this out correctly.

  26. ἄπειρος

    apeiros · G552

    inexperienced, unskilled · v13

    Literally "untried, without experience" (from peira, trial or experience). The problem is not lack of information but lack of practice. It sets up verse 14, where the mature have senses "trained" by use.

  27. λόγου

    logou · G3056

    word, message, speech, reasoning · v13

    A "word" in the sense of a message or teaching, possibly also the reasoning or speech one practises. Without "the" in Greek it reads "a word/discourse of righteousness," naming a kind of teaching, not a fixed formula.

  28. δικαιοσύνης·

    dikaiosynēs · G1343

    righteousness, what is right, justice · v13

    What is right before God and in conduct. Coming right before verse 14 ("distinguish good from evil"), it most naturally points to teaching that forms a person's sense of right and wrong. Hebrews also uses the word for Christ's own character (1:9; 7:2).

  29. νήπιος

    nēpios · G3516

    infant, young child; naive person · v13

    A small child not yet capable of adult judgment. In Greek teaching and in Paul it is the stock opposite of teleios, "mature, full-grown", the word that opens verse 14. Said to adults who "ought to be teachers," it stings.

  30. ἐστιν·

    estin · G1510

    is · v13

    Present tense, describing the person's present condition. Verse 12 shows it is a condition they "have become" (gegonate), a slide backwards rather than a starting point.

The world behind it

A familiar classroom image. Greek-speaking readers, Jewish ones included, would know the milk and solid food contrast as a stock image of education. Philo of Alexandria and the Stoic teacher Epictetus both use it to shame students who stay at the elementary level. Education began with the stoicheia, the letters of the alphabet recited in order, before moving on to reading, rhetoric and philosophy. Telling adults they need their stoicheia again was a pointed insult, aimed at stirring them.

Weaning as a milestone. In the ancient Mediterranean, children were often nursed until about two or three (compare 2 Maccabees 7:27, "I nursed you for three years"). Weaning was a recognised passage, sometimes marked with a feast (Genesis 21:8, Isaac's weaning). An adult still on milk was an absurd and shaming picture.

The audience. Hebrews addresses an established community of second-generation believers. They heard the message from those who heard the Lord (2:3), had endured public abuse and loss of property in "former days" (10:32-34), and were now in danger of "drifting" (2:1) and growing weary. Many scholars think they were steeped in Israel's scriptures and tempted to fall back on familiar Jewish forms of approach to God. That fits a sermon built on the "oracles of God". The rebuke in 5:11-6:3 is a deliberate rhetorical move before the hardest section of the sermon, the Melchizedek argument of chapter 7.

From the study of Hebrews 5:12.

Where scholars differ

in v12

Were the readers really immature, or is the rebuke a rhetorical device?

  • Rhetorical provocation: the author shames them in order to rouse them, not because they truly can't follow.

    He immediately says 'let us leave the elementary teaching' (6:1), proceeds to his hardest argument (ch. 7), and says 'we are confident of better things concerning you' (6:9). Shaming students was a known teaching technique (Epictetus, Philo). Lane, Attridge and deSilva take broadly this line.

  • Genuine diagnosis: the community really had regressed and was in real danger.

    The perfect 'you have become' (5:11, 12), the repeated warnings against drifting and hardening (2:1; 3:12-13), the neglect of meeting together (10:25), and the severe warning of 6:4-8 suggest a real condition, not merely a pose.

  • Both: a real tendency, deliberately exaggerated for effect.

    Many commentators combine the two. The sluggishness is real enough to warn against, and the 'you need milk' line is hyperbole, since the author does not actually supply milk.

in v12

What are 'the oracles of God' here?

  • The scriptures of Israel as God's speech.

    This is standard Jewish-Greek usage of λόγια (LXX; Philo; Rom 3:2; Acts 7:38). Hebrews constantly quotes the scriptures as God or the Spirit speaking (1:5-13; 3:7; 10:15).

  • The basic Christian message about God's revelation in Christ.

    Hebrews 6:1 speaks of 'the word of the beginning of Christ'. God has spoken 'in a Son' (1:2), and the salvation was declared by the Lord and confirmed by those who heard (2:3).

  • Combined: the scriptures as read in the light of Christ.

    The 'solid food' that follows is an exposition of Psalm 110 and Genesis 14 about Christ. This suggests the basics include the elementary Christian reading of Israel's scriptures.

in v13

What is the "word of righteousness"?

  • Moral instruction and the trained ability to judge right from wrong.

    Verse 14 immediately defines maturity as discerning "good and evil" through practice. Hebrews 12:11 ties "the fruit of righteousness" to being "trained." Polycarp (*Philippians* 9.1) uses the same phrase for Christian ethical teaching. NLT adopts this reading.

  • Advanced teaching about Christ, especially the coming argument on Melchizedek, "king of righteousness".

    The digression (5:11–6:20) begins because the Melchizedek teaching is "hard to explain" to sluggish hearers (5:10–11), and 7:2 translates Melchizedek as "king of righteousness." Solid food in context is that teaching.

  • The Christian message generally, as the word that brings righteousness (or, in older Protestant reading, the doctrine of justification).

    "Word" is common shorthand for the gospel message, and dikaiosynē is central to early Christian preaching. Against the justification version: Hebrews never develops Paul's justification language, and the context stresses practice, not a forensic doctrine.

  • "Right/competent speech": an infant cannot yet handle adult discourse.

    Fits the infant image (babies cannot speak properly), and ancient grammarians connected nēpios with "not speaking." But this sense of dikaiosynē ("correctness") is weakly attested, and most commentators find it strained.

in v13

Is the author describing their real state or exaggerating to provoke them?

  • Largely rhetorical provocation.

    Right after the rebuke he says "let us go on to maturity" (6:1), declares confidence in them (6:9), and proceeds to give the advanced teaching in chapter 7. He would not do that if he truly thought them incapable.

  • A genuine diagnosis of dangerous stagnation.

    The severe warning of 6:4–8 follows, and the letter repeatedly fears drifting (2:1) and falling away (3:12). Their immaturity is real enough to threaten their perseverance.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. ὀφείλω, στοιχεῖον, λόγιον, στερεός, γάλα
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. στοιχεῖον, λόγιον
  • Philo, De agricultura (On Husbandry) 9
  • Epictetus, Discourses 2.16.39
  • LXX Numbers 24:4, 16; Psalm 118 (119); 2 Maccabees 7:27
  • H. W. Attridge, The Epistle to the Hebrews (Hermeneia)
  • W. L. Lane, Hebrews 1–8 (Word Biblical Commentary 47A)
  • D. A. deSilva, Perseverance in Gratitude: A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary on Hebrews
  • C. R. Koester, Hebrews (Anchor Bible)
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed.
  • BDAG s.v. ἄπειρος, γάλα, μετέχω, νήπιος, δικαιοσύνη
  • LSJ s.v. ἄπειρος (two distinct words: 'inexperienced' vs. 'boundless')
  • Philo, De agricultura 9
  • Septuagint, Numbers 14:23; Zechariah 11:15
  • Polycarp, To the Philippians 9.1
  • 1 Corinthians 2:6–3:2; 13:11; Galatians 4:1–3; 1 Peter 2:2
  • W. L. Lane, Hebrews 1–8 (WBC 47A)
  • C. R. Koester, Hebrews (Anchor Bible 36)
  • D. A. deSilva, Perseverance in Gratitude (honor-shame reading of Hebrews)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).