Isaiah Chapter 28 Read as one passage
Isaiah 28:8–9
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
8For all their tables are covered with vomit; there is not a place without filth. 9Whom is He trying to teach? To whom is He explaining His message? To infants just weaned from milk? To babies removed from the breast?
What the first hearers heard
To Isaiah's hearers in Jerusalem around 700 BC, the verse would have sounded like a quotation of their own leaders' contempt. Prophets regularly quoted their opponents' words (compare 5:19; 28:15; 30:10–11) in order to turn them back on them.
- It exposed the leaders. The religious elite who should have given torah were drunk (28:7–8). Yet they found the prophet's call insulting and childish: "This is rest; give rest to the weary" (28:12), and "whoever believes will not be in haste" (28:16). They felt too sophisticated to be taught.
- It set up a reversal. God answers in their own terms (28:11–13). Because they mocked plain speech as baby-talk, he will speak to them "by people of strange lips and another tongue", meaning the Assyrian invaders, and the same nursery syllables will become the sound of them stumbling, being broken, snared and taken. And the "message" they refused to "understand" (28:9) will one day be understood as sheer terror (28:19).
- It drew a line in the community. Hearers had to decide whether they stood with the scoffing rulers, who trusted their "covenant with death" (the Egypt alliance), or with the tested cornerstone God was laying in Zion (28:16). This question of whose word you trust runs through Isaiah 28–31.
From the study of Isaiah 28:9.
Verse by verse
-
8For all their tables are covered with vomit; there is not a place without filth.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
9Whom is He trying to teach? To whom is He explaining His message? To infants just weaned from milk? To babies removed from the breast?
Full study →"Who does he think he's teaching knowledge to? Who's he trying to make understand his 'message'? Toddlers just off their milk? Little ones just pulled from the breast?"
On the reading most scholars hold, these are the sneering words of Jerusalem's priests and prophets. Verses 7–8 have just shown them staggering from wine at tables covered in vomit. Isaiah's insistent, simple warnings strike them as a nursery-school lecture.
- "Teach" (yoreh) comes from the root of torah, "instruction," and teaching torah was the priests' own calling. Leviticus 10:9–11 had banned priests from wine so that they could teach. Drunk teachers are mocking the man who is teaching them.
- "Knowledge" is the knowledge of God that Isaiah says will one day fill the earth (11:9). They wave it away.
- "Message" (shemu'ah) is literally "a thing heard": a report, the news the prophet brings from God. It is not "doctrine" in the modern sense of a doctrinal system.
- "Weaned from milk... removed from the breast": in Israel, children nursed until about two or three. The image is of toddlers, not of mature adults ready for solid food. The insult is: he talks to us like babies. Verse 10 goes on to imitate the baby-talk or alphabet drill they hear in his preaching (tsav latsav, qav laqav).
The irony is that the people who call Isaiah's message childish are the ones lying in their own filth. In verses 11–13 God answers them in kind: since they will not hear plain words, he will speak to them through foreign-tongued invaders, and the same "tsav latsav, qav laqav" will become the sound of their stumbling. In verse 19, "to understand the message", the very phrase they scorned here, will be "sheer terror."
(A minority reading hears Isaiah himself asking the question: whom can God possibly teach, when the leaders are drunk? Only babies? Either way, the "weaned" are small children, and the "message" is the prophet's word.)
Where the English drifted
-
in v9
doctrine (KJV)
shemu'ah
- What we hear
- A body of formal theological beliefs, a church's official teaching or system of dogma.
- What they heard
- "Something heard": a report, news, or the prophet's message announced from God. The Latin Vulgate has auditum, "what is heard."
-
in v9
weaned from the milk
gemulei mechalav
- What we hear
- Read through the New Testament's "milk vs. solid food" (1 Cor 3:2; Heb 5:12–14), it can sound like "spiritually mature believers ready for deeper truth."
- What they heard
- Toddlers of about two or three who have just stopped nursing. In context it is an image of being talked down to like a small child.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v9
Isaiah 28:9 isn't about mature believers graduating to deep doctrine
- What's often taught
- Some read Isaiah 28:9–10 (KJV) as a principle: God teaches "doctrine" to those who are "weaned from the milk", meaning spiritually mature believers ready for solid food. They are taught "precept upon precept, line upon line" as a method of building doctrine from Scripture.
- What the text supports
In context, verses 9–10 are most naturally the words of drunk priests and prophets (vv. 7–8) sneering at Isaiah. In effect: "Does he think we're toddlers just off the breast?"
- "Weaned" (gemulei) means children of about two or three (1 Sam 1:22–24; 2 Macc 7:27). The image says "tiny children," not "mature believers." It is the opposite of the New Testament's milk-to-solid-food picture.
- "Doctrine" (shemu'ah) means "a thing heard": the prophet's report or message, not a doctrinal system.
- Verses 11–13 settle it. God takes the same words (tsav latsav, qav laqav) and turns them into judgment: the word of the LORD will be to them "precept upon precept... that they may go, and fall backward, and be broken, and snared, and taken" (v. 13, KJV). The phrase describes how a message sounds to people who refuse to listen. It is not a recommended method of study.
What the popular reading gets right is that Scripture does value growth in understanding and comparing passages carefully. But this verse is not where that teaching comes from.
- Where the English feeds it
- The KJV's "doctrine" sounds like systematic theology. Its bracketed additions ("[them that are] weaned... [and] drawn") turn a scornful retort into a calm answer, as if God had announced whom he teaches. Capitalised "He" in some modern versions can also suggest that the line is a statement about God's teaching method.
Every word
-
אֶת־
'et · H0853
[marks the direct object] · v9
An untranslatable marker showing that the next word is the object of the verb. Here it makes "who" into "whom": the question is about who is on the receiving end of the teaching.
-
מִי֙
mi · H4310
who? · v9
The question word, put first for emphasis: "Whom, of all people...?" In context the tone is scornful, not curious.
-
יוֹרֶ֣ה
yoreh · H3384
to teach, instruct, point out · v9
"Will he teach" or "is he trying to teach." It comes from the same root as torah (instruction). That is pointed, because teaching torah was the priests' own job, and here drunk priests are sneering at someone else teaching them.
-
דֵעָ֔ה
de'ah · H1844
knowledge · v9
Knowledge, especially knowledge of God and his ways. Isaiah uses the same word for the coming age, when the earth will be full of the knowledge of the LORD (11:9). The scoffers think they have no need of it.
-
יָבִ֣ין
yavin · H0995
to understand; (causative) to make understand, explain · v9
"Will he make understand" or "explain." It is the verb of discernment, of telling things apart. The speakers resent being treated as people who need things explained. In 28:19 Isaiah turns the same phrase back on them: understanding the message will be sheer terror.
-
שְׁמוּעָ֑ה
shemu'ah · H8052
report, news, message (something heard) · v9
Literally "a thing heard": a report or piece of news, here the prophet's message from God. It is not "doctrine" in the sense of a system of teaching. The same word comes back in 28:19, and in 53:1: "Who has believed our report?"
-
גְּמוּלֵי֙
gemulei · H1580
weaned (ones) · v9
"Those weaned." In ancient Israel a child was weaned at about two or three years old, so these are toddlers. The point is not "mature people ready for solid food" but "tiny children."
-
מֵֽחָלָ֔ב
mechalav · H2461
from milk · v9
"From milk," meaning breast milk. With "weaned" it paints a child only just off the breast.
-
עַתִּיקֵ֖י
'attiqei · H6267
removed, taken away · v9
"Those taken away." This is a rare word that matches "weaned" in the parallel line: little ones just taken off the breast.
-
מִשָּׁדָֽיִם׃
mishshadayim · H7699
from (the) breasts · v9
"From the breasts." Hebrew uses a special form here for a natural pair. The picture is earthy and on purpose: "Does he think we're nursing babies?"
The world behind it
When and where. Isaiah 28 opens with a woe against the "proud crown of the drunkards of Ephraim", meaning Samaria, the capital of the northern kingdom, which fell to Assyria in 722 BC (28:1–4). Then verse 7 turns: "These also reel with wine." The focus moves to "the rulers of this people in Jerusalem" (28:14). Most scholars place this section in Hezekiah's reign, around 705–701 BC. At that time Judah's leaders were negotiating an anti-Assyrian alliance with Egypt, which Isaiah mocks as a "covenant with death" (28:15; compare chs. 30–31).
Drunken teachers. Priests and prophets were Judah's religious experts. Priests gave torah, rulings and instruction (Deut 33:10; Mal 2:7), and prophets gave oracles. Leviticus 10:9–11 forbade priests wine on duty precisely so they could "distinguish between the holy and the common" and "teach" the people. Isaiah 28:7–8 pictures them at the very moment of judgment ("they stumble in giving judgment"), at tables covered with vomit. This was perhaps a cultic banquet or feast.
Weaning and the schoolroom. Hebrew children were usually nursed for two to three years (1 Sam 1:22–24; 2 Macc 7:27), and weaning could be marked with a feast (Gen 21:8). A "weaned child" was a small child just beginning to learn. Verse 10's tsav latsav, qav laqav is often explained as baby-talk, or as a teacher drilling the letters of the alphabet. In the Hebrew alphabet tsade and qof stand next to each other. The scoffers feel Isaiah is treating national leaders like toddlers learning their letters.
From the study of Isaiah 28:9.
Where scholars differ
in v9
Who is speaking in 28:9–10, and who is "he"?
-
The drunken priests and prophets of verses 7–8 are mocking Isaiah. "He" is the prophet, and through him God's message. This is the majority view of modern commentators.
There is no change of speaker after verses 7–8, so the natural speakers are the drunkards just described. The tone of offended dignity fits them. Verses 11–13 take up the scoffers' own words (tsav latsav...) and turn them into judgment, which only works if verse 10 was their mockery. Verse 14 calls them "scoffers" outright, and verse 19 echoes "understand the message."
-
Isaiah is speaking, lamenting: whom can God teach, since the adults are drunk and senseless? Only small children? Some older Jewish and Christian interpreters, including Calvin in substance, take it this way.
The question can be read as the prophet's own rhetorical frustration following verse 8. On this view verse 10 describes God's patient, step-by-step teaching suited to children.
-
A positive principle: God imparts knowledge to those "weaned", that is, ready and mature. This is a traditional devotional reading influenced by the KJV.
It rests mainly on the KJV's bracketed answer and on the New Testament's milk/solid-food imagery. It has little support in the Hebrew context. Verses 11–13 present tsav latsav as a judgment, not a commended method, and "weaned" in Hebrew means toddlers, not mature adults.
in v9
What does the nursery imagery point to in verse 10, which follows directly?
-
Babbling or baby-talk: meaningless sounds mimicking how they hear Isaiah.
Tsav and qav are short, repetitive syllables. Verse 11 speaks of "stammering lips."
-
An alphabet lesson: a teacher drilling the letters tsade and qof, which are adjacent in the Hebrew alphabet, with ze'eir sham ("a little there") as the teacher's coaxing.
It fits verse 9's picture of just-weaned children being taught. Other scholars translate the words as real nouns, "command" (tsav) and "line/measuring cord" (qav), which fits the "line" of 28:17.
Sources
- BDB s.v. יָרָה, שְׁמוּעָה, גָּמַל, עַתִּיק
- HALOT s.v. שְׁמוּעָה; s.v. בִּין
- J. N. Oswalt, The Book of Isaiah 1–39 (NICOT)
- J. Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 1–39 (Anchor Bible)
- H. Wildberger, Isaiah 28–39 (Continental Commentary)
- B. S. Childs, Isaiah (OTL)
- Vulgate, Isaiah 28:9
- Septuagint, Isaiah 28:9
- 2 Maccabees 7:27 (duration of nursing)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.