Job Chapter 15 Read as one passage
Job 15:6–9
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
6Your own mouth, not mine, condemns you; your own lips testify against you. 7Were you the first man ever born? Were you brought forth before the hills? 8Do you listen in on the council of God or limit wisdom to yourself? 9What do you know that we do not? What do you understand that is not clear to us?
What the first hearers heard
To Israelite readers trained in wisdom traditions, Eliphaz's line would have sounded like a familiar proverb. The fool's mouth is his ruin (Prov 18:7), and a man convicted "by his own mouth" needs no other witness (compare 2 Sam 1:16). It is the kind of thing a wise elder would say, and on its own terms it is sound.
But the book of Job has given its readers knowledge the speakers lack. The prologue shows God calling Job blameless and upright (1:8; 2:3), and the epilogue says the friends did not speak rightly about God (42:7). Hearers would feel the gap between Eliphaz's confident verdict and the truth. Job is being declared guilty by a principle (suffering proves sin, defiant speech proves guilt) that the book itself puts on trial.
At the same time, the book does not simply clear Job's speech. God later charges Job with "darkening counsel by words without knowledge" (38:2) and asks whether Job would "condemn" God in order to be justified himself (40:8). So the first audience would hear Eliphaz as half-right about the danger of Job's words, and wrong about what they prove: Job's anguished words are not a confession that hidden sin caused his suffering.
From the study of Job 15:6.
Verse by verse
-
6Your own mouth, not mine, condemns you; your own lips testify against you.
Full study →"I don't need to bring any charge against you. Your own mouth is the one finding you guilty, over and over, every time you speak. Your own lips have stepped into the witness box and are giving evidence against you."
Eliphaz is speaking as a prosecutor. The verb is a court verdict ("declares you the guilty party"), not just disapproval. The second half uses the technical phrase for testifying against someone in court. He insists, with a pointed "not I", that he is only reporting what Job has done to himself. Job's bold speeches, especially his demand to put God on trial (13:3, 18), are offered as proof that Job is guilty, since v. 5 says it is guilt that "teaches" a mouth to talk like that.
There is a sharp irony that first hearers of the book would catch. Earlier, Job himself had said, "Though I am in the right, my own mouth would condemn me" (9:20), meaning that no innocent person could hold his own against God in court. Eliphaz picks up almost the same words and turns Job's protest into a literal confession. The reader, who has heard God call Job blameless (1:8; 2:3), knows this verdict is not the last word.
-
7Were you the first man ever born? Were you brought forth before the hills?
Full study →"What, were you the very first human ever born, the one who came before all the rest of us? Or were you birthed, out of the labor of creation itself, before the hills were set in place?"
Eliphaz is speaking with biting sarcasm, and the questions expect a scornful "No." The first half uses the ordinary word for being born and asks whether Job is older than the whole human race. The second half goes further. It uses a vivid birth verb that pictures labor pains and borrows the stock phrase "before the hills", the poetic way of saying "before the world took shape." Those same words are spoken by personified Wisdom in Proverbs 8:25 ("before the hills I was brought forth"). So the jab runs: Do you think you are Wisdom herself, present at creation and privy to God's plans? The point of the question comes in the next verses. Job is a mortal like them, born of a woman, so he has no special access to God's council (v. 8), and the gray-haired among his friends are actually older than he is (v. 10).
-
8Do you listen in on the council of God or limit wisdom to yourself?
Full study →Eliphaz is mocking Job: "Were you sitting in on God's private council, listening in to what is discussed there? Have you drained all wisdom away from the rest of us and kept it for yourself?"
Both halves are scornful questions, and both expect the answer "Of course not." The first line pictures God enthroned among his heavenly advisors, a closed inner circle (Hebrew sod) where God's plans are discussed and decided. Eliphaz asks whether Job attends and listens there regularly. The second line pictures wisdom as a shared supply that Job has "drawn off" and diverted to himself, as if he had cornered the market. The verb is the one Eliphaz used four verses earlier, when he said Job's words "diminish" devotion toward God. So the charge has two sides: Job takes away from piety and hoards wisdom.
Together with v. 7 ("Were you the first man born, brought forth before the hills?"), the verse sarcastically gives Job the status of a primeval being, as old as creation and present when God made his decisions. Only someone like that could claim the certainty Job seems to claim.
The reader catches an irony that Eliphaz does not. Job 1–2 has already shown a heavenly council where Job's case was discussed, and none of the human speakers, Eliphaz included, was present. His question also strikes his own confident claims about how God works.
-
9What do you know that we do not? What do you understand that is not clear to us?
Full study →Eliphaz throws two scornful questions at Job, both expecting the answer "nothing at all": "What have you come to know that we do not know? What do you see into that we don't already have in hand?"
The verse is built from Job's own words. Earlier Job had said, "What you know, I also know; I am not inferior to you" (13:2), and had mocked the friends: "Truly you are the people, and wisdom will die with you!" (12:2). Eliphaz now reverses the boast. If Job claims equality, what superior knowledge does he actually have? The second line, literally "and it is not with us?", uses the language of possession: wisdom is something held, kept, inherited, and Eliphaz insists the friends hold it. In the next verse he names where it came from: the gray-haired elders, men older than Job's father.
"Know" and "understand" together cover the whole range of wisdom, both settled knowledge and discerning insight. The contrast between one man ("you") and a group ("we") frames the dispute as a solitary sufferer presuming against the consensus of the wise. The question comes right after verse 8, "Do you listen in on the council of God?", so Eliphaz is accusing Job of claiming private access to divine secrets that would put him above everyone else.
Where the English drifted
-
in v6
condemns
yarshîaʿ (hirshîaʿ)
- What we hear
- Strongly denounces or disapproves of; or, in church language, dooms to eternal punishment.
- What they heard
- A legal verdict: pronounces you the guilty party in a case, the opposite of being declared in the right.
-
in v7
made (KJV) / formed (YLT)
cholalta (chul)
- What we hear
- Created or crafted, the way a potter shapes clay or a builder makes something.
- What they heard
- Brought forth through labor pains, birthed. The verb pictures childbirth, and in this exact form it is Wisdom's own word for her birth before creation in Proverbs 8:24–25.
-
in v8
secret (KJV), secret counsel (WEB, YLT)
sod
- What we hear
- A piece of hidden information or a mystery that Job might have found out.
- What they heard
- The closed council around God's throne together with the confidential deliberations held there. The image is an assembly room, not a hidden fact.
-
in v8
restrain wisdom to thyself (KJV)
garaʿ ʾeleikha
- What we hear
- Holding wisdom back or keeping it in check, as if Job were being reticent.
- What they heard
- Drawing wisdom off from others to yourself, so that you have it all and they have none.
Every word
-
יַרְשִֽׁיעֲךָ֣
yarshîʿăkā · H7561
declare guilty, condemn · v6
A courtroom verb: 'it pronounces you the guilty party.' Placed first for emphasis, it is the verdict before we even hear who gives it. The form describes something happening now and continuing: every time Job speaks, the verdict is repeated.
-
פִ֣יךָ
pîkā · H6310
mouth · v6
'Your mouth', meaning Job's own speeches. It picks up v. 5, where Job's guilt is said to be 'teaching' his mouth. The mouth is pictured as the witness who convicts him.
-
וְלֹא־
wəlōʾ- · H3808
and not · v6, v9
A flat denial: 'and not…'. Eliphaz says he is not the one bringing the charge.
-
אָ֑נִי
ʾānî · H0589
I · v6
The pronoun 'I' is stated outright for emphasis: 'not I, personally.' Eliphaz presents himself as a bystander reporting a verdict Job has given against himself, not as the accuser.
-
וּ֝שְׂפָתֶ֗יךָ
ûśəpātêkā · H8193
lips · v6
'And your lips', in the Hebrew form used for pairs. It is the usual poetic partner of 'mouth': the same idea said a second time with more force.
-
יַעֲנוּ־
yaʿănû- · H6030
answer, respond, testify · v6
Normally 'answer'. In a legal setting, followed by 'against', it means to give evidence in court. The plural verb matches 'lips': Job's lips take the witness stand.
-
בָֽךְ׃
bāk · H9031
in, against (+ you) · v6
With 'answer', this small word means 'against you'. It turns the lips into a hostile witness.
-
הֲרִאישׁ֣וֹן
hari'shon · H7223G
first (with question marker) · v7
The prefix ha- turns the line into a question that expects the answer "No". Ri'shon means first in time or rank. Here it is first in time: the very first human, older than everyone else.
-
אָ֭דָם
'adam · H0120G
human being, humankind · v7
The ordinary word for a human being or for humanity as a whole. Joined with "first" it points to the first human of all, the one Genesis calls 'adam. Whether Eliphaz means the Adam of Genesis or a wider legend of a wise first human is debated (see debates).
-
תִּוָּלֵ֑ד
tivvaled · H3205
to bear, beget; (passive) be born · v7
A passive form, "were you born", addressed to Job ("you", masculine singular). It is the plain everyday word for birth, and it sets up the more vivid birth word at the end of the line.
-
וְלִפְנֵ֖י
velifne · H6440G
and before (literally "and to the face of") · v7
Built from the word for "face". Here it is used for time, "earlier than". The "and" carries the question over from the first half of the line, so the second half is a sharper version of the first.
-
גְבָע֣וֹת
gevaot · H1389I
hills · v7
Hills, high places. In Hebrew poetry the hills and mountains stand for the oldest, most permanent features of the world ("the everlasting hills"). Being born before them means existing before the world was given its shape.
-
חוֹלָֽלְתָּ׃
cholalta · H2342H
to writhe, be in labor; (passive) be brought forth in birth · v7
From a root meaning to writhe or twist, used of a woman in labor. This passive form means "you were birthed through labor pains". It is the same rare form that personified Wisdom uses of herself in Proverbs 8:24–25 ("before the hills I was brought forth").
-
הַבְס֣וֹד
havsod · H5475
council, intimate circle; confidential talk · v8
The prefix ha- turns the whole line into a question, and be- means "in". Sod is the closed circle of trusted insiders and the private discussion that goes on inside it. Here it is God's own council in heaven. The question is sarcastic: "Were you in the room?"
-
אֱל֣וֹהַ
ʾeloah · H0433
God · v8
The singular, old poetic name for God that the book of Job prefers. It suits the speakers' setting outside Israel and gives the debate a formal, lofty tone.
-
תִּשְׁמָ֑ע
tishmaʿ · H8085
hear, listen · v8
"Do you listen?" The verb form describes something ongoing or habitual. The picture is a regular attendee or eavesdropper who keeps hearing what God and his council discuss. It is more than having heard one secret once.
-
וְתִגְרַ֖ע
wetigraʿ · H1639
diminish, take away, withdraw, draw off · v8
Used with "to yourself", it means pulling something away from others and drawing it to yourself, as if Job had cornered the supply of wisdom so that nobody else has any. Eliphaz used the same verb in v. 4 ("you diminish devotion before God"). The repeated word sharpens the charge: Job takes away piety from God and draws off wisdom for himself.
-
אֵלֶ֣יךָ
ʾeleikha · H0413
to, toward (you) · v8
"To yourself" or "toward yourself". It gives the direction of the drawing-off: wisdom flows to Job and stops there.
-
חָכְמָֽה׃
ḥokhmah · H2451
wisdom, skill, insight · v8
In Job, wisdom is insight into how the world and God's ways work. In the Hebrew wisdom tradition it is also linked with God's own plans from the time of creation. Eliphaz mocks Job for acting as if he owns it.
-
מַה־
mah · H4100
what? · v9
Opens a rhetorical question that expects the answer "nothing." It probably governs both halves of the verse, so the second line is also a "what" question even though the word is not repeated.
-
יָּדַעְתָּ
yāḏaʿtā · H3045
to know · v9
"You have come to know / you know" (completed form, second person singular). It points at knowledge Job claims to have gained: what does he possess as settled knowledge?
-
תָּבִין
tāḇîn · H995
to understand, discern · v9
"You understand / discern." A near-synonym of "know" in the parallel line, with more of the sense of insight, of seeing through to how things are. With no question word of its own it leans on the "what" at the start of the verse.
-
עִמָּנוּ
ʿimmānû · H5973
-
הוּא
hûʾ · H1931
he, she, it · v9
"It": the thing Job supposedly understands. Hebrew needs no "is" here, so the line literally reads "and not with us [is] it."
The world behind it
Where this sits. Job 15 opens the second round of speeches. Eliphaz, the oldest and most measured of the three friends, has dropped the gentleness of his first speech (chs. 4–5). In 15:2–6 he attacks the way Job talks: windy words (v. 2), speech that undermines reverence for God (v. 4), crafty language (v. 5), and now self-incrimination (v. 6).
The courtroom frame. In chs. 9–13 Job increasingly uses the language of a lawsuit (rîb). He wants to "argue his case" with God, has "prepared his case", and expects to be "declared in the right" (13:3, 18). In an Israelite village court at the gate, a case was settled by witnesses' testimony (Deut 19:15), and the judges then declared one party "in the right" (ṣaddîq) and the other "in the wrong" (rāshāʿ) (Deut 25:1). Eliphaz takes over this setting. He casts Job's speeches as the decisive testimony and the verdict as already given.
The verb across the book. "Declare guilty" (hirshîaʿ) is a thread through Job. Job fears his mouth would condemn him (9:20). He begs God not to condemn him (10:2). Eliphaz says Job's mouth does condemn him (15:6). Elihu is angry that the friends "condemned Job" without answering him (32:3). God finally asks Job, "Would you condemn me so that you may be justified?" (40:8). The book keeps asking who is really declaring whom guilty.
From the study of Job 15:6.
Where scholars differ
in v6
Is Eliphaz's verdict on Job's words correct?
-
No. The book presents Eliphaz's charge as an unjust condemnation of an innocent man.
God calls Job blameless (1:8; 2:3). Elihu faults the friends for 'condemning Job' without answering him (32:3, using the same verb). God says the friends did not speak rightly about him 'as my servant Job has' (42:7–8).
-
Partly. Eliphaz is wrong that Job's words prove hidden sin, but right that Job's speech has gone too far.
God rebukes Job for 'words without knowledge' (38:2) and asks, 'Will you condemn me so that you may be justified?' (40:8, same verb). Job then withdraws or repents of his words (40:4–5; 42:3–6). On this view Job's mouth did, in a limited sense, put him in the wrong. It did not convict him of the sin the friends assumed.
in v7
Who is the "first human" Eliphaz has in mind?
-
The Adam of Genesis 2–3: Eliphaz is simply asking whether Job is as old as the first human.
*'Adam* is the Genesis word for the first human, and the plain sense needs no other background. Saying "older than Adam" is a natural way to mock someone's claim to be ancient.
-
A wider tradition of a primeval, wise first human who had access to the divine council.
Verse 8 at once links the question to listening in on God's council. Ezekiel 28:12–17 describes a perfectly wise figure in Eden on God's mountain. Commentators such as Pope and Habel point to traditions of a first human with special wisdom who then fell.
-
No specific figure is meant: it is hyperbole for "the oldest person alive", and the second half adds an allusion to Wisdom.
The argument in vv. 9–10 is about relative age ("older than your father"), which suggests the main point is seniority, with the language of origins used for rhetorical effect.
in v7
Is Eliphaz quoting Proverbs 8 or drawing on a shared tradition?
-
Direct allusion to Proverbs 8:25.
The phrase is identical apart from the person ("I was brought forth" becomes "you were brought forth"), and the verb form is rare.
-
Shared poetic stock about pre-creation beings.
The dates of both Job and Proverbs 8 are uncertain. Psalm 90:2 shows the same "before the mountains were born" language used independently of Wisdom, so both texts may draw on a common formula.
in v8
Does v. 7–8 allude to a specific myth of a primeval wise man who sat in God's council?
-
Yes. Eliphaz is drawing on a tradition, also reflected in Ezekiel 28:12–15 (the wise being in Eden on God's mountain), of a first human who had access to the divine council and divine wisdom, and possibly took wisdom for himself.
Ezekiel 28 and Job 15:7–8 share wisdom, Eden or primeval origins, and nearness to God. The sense "draw off for yourself" of garaʿ fits a story of seizing wisdom. Commentators such as Pope and Habel discuss this background.
-
No specific myth is needed. The lines are ironic exaggeration built from Israel's own wisdom tradition, especially personified Wisdom in Proverbs 8.
"Brought forth before the hills" repeats Proverbs 8:25 almost word for word. The divine-council image is common in Israel's own scriptures (Jer 23; Ps 89; 1 Kgs 22). Several commentators, including Clines, are cautious about reconstructing a lost myth.
in v8
What exactly does garaʿ + "to yourself" mean here?
-
"Draw off, take for yourself": Job has seized or monopolised wisdom.
Numbers 36:3–4 (an inheritance taken from one and added to another); Job 36:27 ("draws up" drops); the preposition "to yourself". This is the reading of most modern commentators and is reflected in idioms like "monopoly".
-
"Limit or restrict wisdom to yourself": Job confines wisdom to his own person.
This keeps closer to the common meaning "diminish, reduce" and is the choice of KJV, ESV, BSB and WEB. The practical sense is close to the first view.
-
"Diminish" with wisdom as the subject: wisdom (God's) becomes less than you.
Apparently the Vulgate's reading. It uses the basic meaning of the verb but requires taking ḥokhmah as the subject, which the Hebrew word order does not favour.
Sources
- BDB s.v. רָשַׁע (Hiphil: 'condemn as guilty')
- HALOT s.v. רשׁע hif. and ענה I (with בְּ, 'testify against')
- Septuagint, Job 15:6
- Vulgate, Job 15:6
- Cross-references: Job 9:20; 10:2; 13:3, 18; 32:3; 38:2; 40:8; 42:7; Deut 19:15–18; 25:1; 2 Sam 1:16; Exod 20:16; Prov 18:7
- BDB and HALOT s.v. חוּל / חִיל (Polal: be brought forth in birth)
- HALOT s.v. רִאשׁוֹן
- HALOT s.v. גִּבְעָה
- Proverbs 8:22–31; Psalm 90:2; Ezekiel 28:12–17; Job 12:2–3, 12; 14:1; 38:4, 21
- M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible), on 15:7–8
- N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (OTL), on 15:7–8
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (WBC), on 15:7
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) and Vulgate, Job 15:7 (wording cited from memory; check against an edition)
- BDB s.v. סוֹד; גָּרַע; אֱלוֹהַּ
- HALOT s.v. סוֹד; גָּרַע
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (Word Biblical Commentary), on 15:7–9
- N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (OTL), on ch. 15
- Supplied source text with lemma/Strong's/morphology (Job 15:8)
- BSB, KJV, WEB, YLT (supplied)
- BDB s.v. יָדַע
- HALOT s.v. יָדַע
- BDB s.v. בִּין
- HALOT s.v. בִּין
- BDB s.v. עִם (possession sense)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs-Hanhart), Job 15:9
- Vulgate, Job 15:9
- Supplied interlinear data (lemma, Strong's, morphology)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).