Job Chapter 6 Read as one passage

Job 6:24–27

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

24Teach me, and I will be silent. Help me understand how I have erred. 25How painful are honest words! But what does your argument prove? 26Do you intend to correct my words, and treat as wind my cry of despair? 27You would even cast lots for an orphan and barter away your friend.

What the first hearers heard

To readers who knew the wisdom tradition, Job's words would sound both humble and pointed. On the surface he takes the proper posture of a pupil: teach me and I will be quiet. Underneath, he turns the friends' authority back on them. Real teachers can point to the specific fault. They had offered only a general rule (the suffering must be guilty) and a mysterious night vision (4:12–21).

The word šāgâ would also register with them. Job is willing to imagine that he wandered off course without knowing it. Their own law treated such straying as real but limited guilt, cleared by ordinary offerings. Nothing about it matched what had happened to him. So the verse puts the reader's sympathies where the book wants them at this stage. The friends must now either produce evidence or admit that their doctrine is driving their verdict. They never do produce it. By the third cycle Eliphaz simply invents sins for Job (22:5–9). The reader, who knows from chapters 1–2 that Job's suffering does not come from any sin, sees how hollow their silence on this point is. Later Elihu takes up Job's very terms, "keep silent, and I will teach you wisdom" (33:33), as if accepting the challenge the friends dodged.

From the study of Job 6:24.

Verse by verse

  1. 24Teach me, and I will be silent. Help me understand how I have erred.

    "All right then, you who speak as my teachers: instruct me, point it out. And I, for my part, will fall silent: I will stop arguing and accept it. In what exactly have I strayed? Where did I wander off the path, even without knowing it? Make me understand it."

    The verse is both an offer and a challenge. Job uses the language of the classroom and the law court. The friends have claimed to pass on wisdom, so he tells them to teach, and promises the pupil's response of silence once he has been answered. But he asks for specifics ("in what?"), and the word he uses for his possible fault is a modest one. It means straying, drifting off course, the word Israel's law used for wrongs done unknowingly. He is not admitting deliberate rebellion. He is saying that even if he slipped somewhere without realizing it, they should name it and make him see it. The unspoken point, made sharp by the surrounding verses (vv. 21–25), is that they have not named anything. They have only reasoned backward from his suffering to his guilt.

    Full study →
  2. 25How painful are honest words! But what does your argument prove?

    "Oh, how words that run straight can sting! But your case against me, what does it actually prove?"

    Job has just said, "Teach me, and I will be silent; show me where I went wrong" (6:24). Now he explains why he is not silent yet. Truly straight speech, words with no twist or slant, can hurt. The Hebrew word is the one used for a "grievous" curse, a blow that lands and stays. Job is not complaining about that kind of pain. Honest words hurt because they hit the truth, and he would accept that wound.

    The second line turns on his friends. The verb Job uses twice belongs to the law court: to argue a case, convict, show who is in the wrong, set the record straight. He says it twice on purpose, with mockery: "What does your arguing argue? What does your proof prove?" The expected answer is nothing. Eliphaz has scolded Job as if he had uncovered some guilt, but he has not named one real wrong. So his words have the sting of honesty without the honesty. They hurt and settle nothing.

    There is irony underneath. The book opened by calling Job yashar, "straight, upright" (1:1). Now the upright man asks for words of straightness and gets only accusations bent to fit a theory.

    Full study →
  3. 26Do you intend to correct my words, and treat as wind my cry of despair?

    "Is that your plan, to put words on trial? Do you count what a man who has given up all hope blurts out as so much wind?"

    Job is answering Eliphaz, his first 'comforter.' In the verse just before, he played on the word for 'reprove' or 'argue a case': what does your reproving actually reprove? Here he uses the same courtroom verb a third time. The friends have turned a visit of comfort into a court case, and what they are prosecuting is not Job's conduct or his suffering but his sentences.

    The second line has two senses that are both present in the Hebrew. On one reading it is Job's own concession: the words of a despairing man are wind. They are the gasps of someone at the end of himself, not a statement of belief to be refuted point by point (he has already admitted in 6:3 that his words have been 'wild'). On the other reading, which follows the verb 'reckon as,' it is an accusation: you treat a desperate man's cries as nothing but wind. Either way the friends are caught in a contradiction. They take Job's words seriously enough to put them on trial, but not seriously enough to hear the anguish of a man who has lost all hope. 'Wind' is a loaded word, too. In the next speech Bildad tells Job that his words are 'a mighty wind' (8:2), which is exactly the dismissal Job predicts here.

    Full study →
  4. 27You would even cast lots for an orphan and barter away your friend.

    "You would go so far as to throw dice over a fatherless child, and haggle over your own friend as if he were goods for sale."

    Job has just accused his three friends of treating his desperate words as so much wind (v. 26). Now he says what that coldness amounts to. The first line pictures people casting lots to decide who takes a helpless child: a child with no father to defend him, the sort a creditor might seize for debt or captors might share out after a raid. The second line moves to the market: they bargain over their companion as though he were cattle or grain. The word for "friend" carries obligation as well as affection; it names the person you owe loyalty to (v. 14). So the charge is that the very people bound to stand by Job are treating him as property: something to divide up, price and trade.

    The verb forms allow "you would": this is mainly a charge about what the friends are capable of, not a report of something they have done. It is hyperbole, deliberate exaggeration in the heat of the argument. Their calm theological reasoning about his suffering, Job says, is as heartless as a slave-dealer's. In the next verse he begs them to look him in the face.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v24

    hold my peace (KJV 'hold my tongue'; WEB)

    ʾaḥărîš

    What we hear
    Some readers hear 'peace' as inner calm or tranquility, as if Job promised to be at peace.
    What they heard
    Simply 'I will be silent / stop talking.' It is the silence of someone who has been answered and gives up the argument.
  • in v24

    erred / my error

    šāgîtî

    What we hear
    Any mistake or wrongdoing in general, or simply 'sinned'.
    What they heard
    'I have strayed', wandered off course. In Israel's law this word-family marked wrong done unknowingly, which still counted as guilt but was distinct from deliberate defiance. Job concedes only that kind of possible fault.
  • in v25

    forcible (KJV, WEB)

    nimretsu

    What we hear
    Done by physical force or violence, as in 'forcible entry'.
    What they heard
    In 1611 'forcible' meant powerful, weighty, convincing. Behind it, the Hebrew means 'grievous, painful, galling': words that hurt because they land.
  • in v25

    reprove / reproof (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    yokhiach hokheach

    What we hear
    Telling someone off morally, a scolding.
    What they heard
    Courtroom and debate language: making a case, proving guilt or innocence, settling who is in the right. Job's question is whether their prosecution has proven anything, not whether they have scolded him enough.
  • in v26

    one that is desperate (KJV)

    no'ash

    What we hear
    Someone frantic, reckless, or badly wanting something ('desperate for help').
    What they heard
    Someone who has given up hope altogether: 'It's hopeless.'
  • in v26

    Do ye imagine to reprove (KJV)

    taḥshovu

    What we hear
    Picturing or fantasizing that they reprove him.
    What they heard
    Planning, intending, or meaning to reprove. The verb also carries 'count as.'
  • in v27

    orphan

    yātôm

    What we hear
    A child who has lost both parents and perhaps lives in an institution; mainly an object of pity.
    What they heard
    A child whose father has died, so it lacks a male legal protector and is exposed to creditors and exploitation. The word names a legal and economic weakness, not only sadness.
  • in v27

    friend

    rēaʿ

    What we hear
    Someone you like and spend time with by choice; friendship is a matter of feeling.
    What they heard
    A companion or neighbour you are bound to treat loyally (ḥesed, 6:14). Betraying a rēaʿ breaks an obligation, not just a feeling.
Every word
  1. הוֹרוּנִי

    hôrûnî · H3384B

    teach, instruct, point out · v24

    A command addressed to all three friends (the verb is plural): 'instruct me, point it out to me.' It is the verb behind the noun torah ('instruction'); the friends have set themselves up as Job's teachers, and he calls on them to actually teach.

  2. וַאֲנִי

    waʾănî · H0589

    and I · v24

    The pronoun is spelled out even though the verb already contains 'I', which puts weight on it: 'and I, for my part, will...' It sets Job's promised response against what the friends must do first.

  3. אַחֲרִישׁ

    ʾaḥărîš · H2790B

    be silent, keep quiet · v24

    'I will fall silent,' the posture of a pupil or a defendant who has been answered. It is conditional on the first verb: if you show me, I will stop protesting.

  4. וּמַה־

    ûmah · H4100

    and what? · v24, v25

    'And what / in what respect.' It asks for specifics: name the actual point where I went wrong, not a general theory that suffering proves guilt.

  5. שָּׁגִיתִי

    šāgîtî · H7686

    go astray, stray, err · v24

    'I have strayed.' The word pictures wandering off the path, like a straying sheep or a staggering drunk, and in Israel's law it is the word-family for wrongdoing done unknowingly, not deliberate rebellion. Job allows only that he might have slipped without knowing it.

  6. הָבִינוּ

    hābînû · H0995

    make understand, explain · v24

    Plural command, 'make me understand / make it clear to me.' Job wants to be shown and convinced, not merely told he is guilty.

  7. לִי

    lî

    to me · v24

    'To me': the explanation is to be given to Job personally. The verse ends on the sufferer who is waiting to be answered.

  8. נִּמְרְצוּ

    nimretsu · H4834

    be sick, grievous, painful · v25

    'They are grievous / painful / galling.' The same form describes Shimei's 'grievous curse' (1 Kgs 2:8), and the root shows up in Job 16:3 for what 'provokes' or stings. Honest words hurt, and they get through.

  9. אִמְרֵי־

    imrei · H0561

    word, saying · v25, v26

    'Sayings of', a poetic word for spoken words. It is bound to the next word, so the pair means 'words of straightness'.

  10. יֹשֶׁר

    yosher · H3476

    straightness, uprightness · v25

    The picture is of a straight, level path. Speech that is 'straight' is honest and true, with nothing bent or slanted for effect. Job sets this against what his friends have been offering.

  11. יּוֹכִיחַ

    yokhiach · H3198

    decide, prove, reprove, argue a case · v25, v26

    'Does it prove / set right / convict?' This is courtroom and debate language: showing who is in the right and exposing the one in the wrong.

  12. מִכֶּם

    mikkem · H9036

    from you (plural) · v25

    'From you all.' The preposition min ('from') points to where the arguing comes from: the three friends, with Eliphaz as their speaker.

  13. מִלִּ֣ים

    millim · H4405

    words, speech · v26

    Just 'words,' with no 'my.' Job is saying the friends are going after his wording when they should be looking at the man and what has happened to him. The word sounds slightly Aramaic and poetic, and nearly every use of it in the Old Testament is in Job.

  14. תַּחְשֹׁ֑בוּ

    taḥshovu · H2803

    think, plan, intend; reckon, regard as · v26

    'Do you mean to / are you planning to.' The verb can also mean 'count something as,' and many readers think it does a second job in the next line: 'and do you count the words of a despairing man as wind?'

  15. וּ֝לְר֗וּחַ

    ulruaḥ · H7307

    wind, breath, spirit · v26

    'And to/as wind.' The meaning here is wind: something empty and passing that blows away and leaves nothing. It has nothing to do with the Spirit. In Job, 'wind' becomes the insult the speakers throw at each other's words (8:2; 15:2; 16:3).

  16. נֹאָֽשׁ׃

    no'ash · H2976

    one who despairs, has given up hope · v26

    A participle used as a noun: 'a despairing one,' someone who has given up all hope. Job speaks of himself in general terms, as 'a man like that.' This picks up his own words in 6:11 ('What strength do I have, that I should hope?').

  17. אַף־

    ʾaf · H0637

    also, even, indeed · v27

    Marks a step up: 'you would go so far as to…'. It turns Job's complaint in verse 26 (you treat my words as wind) into a sharper charge.

  18. עַל־

    ʿal · H5921A

    upon, over, concerning · v27

    'Over' or 'for': it marks what the lots are cast for, as in a sale or a share-out. The same word comes back in the second line, which makes the two lines match.

  19. יָת֥וֹם

    yātôm · H3490

    orphan, fatherless child · v27

    A child whose father has died. Such a child had no male protector and no legal standing, and was the classic easy victim in Israel's world. Job compares himself to such a child: stripped of everything and at the mercy of others.

  20. תַּפִּ֑ילוּ

    tappîlû · H5307I

    to fall; (causative) to make fall, cast (lots) · v27

    'You make fall' is short for 'you cast lots'. The object (lots) is left out, as in 1 Samuel 14:42. The picture is people throwing lots to decide who gets a helpless child, as if dividing up slaves or loot. The verb form can mean 'you would', so this is a charge about what they are capable of.

  21. וְ֝תִכְר֗וּ

    wətikrû · H3739A

    to trade, buy, bargain · v27

    'And you haggle': the word for doing a deal, as in buying food and water (Deuteronomy 2:6) or buying a wife back (Hosea 3:2). With 'over' it means bargaining over goods, exactly as traders 'bargain over' Leviathan in Job 40:30 (41:6 in English Bibles).

  22. רֵֽיעֲכֶֽם׃

    rêʿăkem · H7453

    friend, companion, neighbour · v27

    'Your friend', meaning Job himself. The word covers a close companion as well as a neighbour, and it carries the duty of loyalty that Job invoked in 6:14. Treating such a person as something to sell turns the relationship upside down.

The world behind it

Where this falls in the book. Job 6–7 is Job's reply to Eliphaz's first speech (chs. 4–5). Eliphaz rested on a general rule: the innocent do not perish, and people reap what they sow (4:7–8). Job's suffering therefore implied hidden sin, and Job should seek God and accept discipline (5:8, 17). Job has just compared his friends to desert streams that look full in winter and vanish in the heat, when the thirsty caravan arrives (6:15–20). Then come his sarcastic questions: did I ever ask you for a gift or a bribe, or ask you to ransom me from a tyrant (6:22–23)? I asked only for loyalty. Verse 24 turns to the substance of the argument: if I am guilty, show me where.

How wisdom disputes worked. In the ancient Near Eastern wisdom tradition, instruction ran from the teacher who speaks to the pupil who listens and keeps quiet. Silence meant you had received the teaching or lost the argument. Job reminds them later that in his better days men "kept silent for my counsel" (29:21). By promising silence, Job accepts the pupil's role and so calls their bluff as teachers. The next verse sharpens it: "How painful are honest words! But what does your arguing actually prove?" (6:25).

Inadvertent sin in Israel's law. The Torah distinguished between wrongs done unknowingly or by straying (šegāgâ), which were dealt with by sin offerings (Lev 4–5; Num 15:22–29), and sin done "with a high hand", meaning open defiance (Num 15:30). A Hebrew-speaking reader would hear Job's choice of šāgâ as a limited concession. It names the kind of fault that ordinary ritual covered, not the kind of crime that could justify catastrophe. (The book of Job is set outside Israel, in Uz, but its author and first readers lived in this vocabulary.)

From the study of Job 6:24.

Where scholars differ

in v24

Is Job's offer sincere or rhetorical?

  • Sincere openness: Job genuinely would accept correction if a specific fault were shown.

    The language is the ordinary vocabulary of a teachable pupil (teach / be silent / make me understand). Elsewhere Job asks God the same question ('Make me know my transgression and my sin', 13:23), and he concedes that unknown error is possible (19:4; 7:21).

  • Primarily a challenge: Job is calling the friends' bluff, confident they cannot name anything.

    The immediate context is sarcastic (6:22–23 on bribes and ransoms), and the next verse asks 'what does your arguing prove?' (6:25). The prologue (1:1, 8; 2:3) establishes his integrity, and the friends never answer with specifics. Many commentators read both: real willingness, said with an edge.

in v24

Does šāgâ here concede actual inadvertent sin, or only a hypothetical?

  • Hypothetical: 'in what (if anything) have I strayed?', a question expecting the answer 'nothing'.

    The Septuagint makes it conditional ('if I have strayed'). Job maintains his integrity throughout (27:5–6; ch. 31).

  • A real, limited concession: Job accepts he may have committed unwitting faults, but denies they could warrant his suffering.

    Job 19:4 ('even if I have erred, my error remains with me') and 7:21 ('why do you not pardon my transgression?') show he can imagine minor guilt. The choice of the 'inadvertent' word rather than words for rebellion (pešaʿ) is deliberate.

in v25

What does nimretsu mean: 'painful' or 'forceful'?

  • 'Painful, grievous, galling'

    BDB and HALOT. Fits 1 Kgs 2:8 ('grievous curse'), Mic 2:10 ('grievous destruction') and Job 16:3 ('what galls you'). Followed by BSB, NIV and NASB.

  • 'Forceful, strong, compelling'

    Medieval Jewish interpretation, which took 'grievous curse' as 'strong curse'. Followed by KJV ('forcible'), YLT ('powerful') and ESV ('forceful'). In context, it suits the contrast with arguments that prove nothing.

  • Emend to nimletsu, 'how pleasant'

    Psalm 119:103 uses the same pattern ('how sweet are your words'). It would make Job say honest words would be welcome. It has no manuscript support and is a minority view.

in v25

Is the first line sincere or ironic?

  • Sincere concession: honest words do sting, and Job would accept that

    Fits 6:24 ('teach me and I will be silent') and the wisdom ideal of the faithful wound (Prov 27:6).

  • Sarcasm: 'How painful your so-called upright words are!'

    The Septuagint's 'as it seems' and the Vulgate's 'why have you disparaged words of truth' both read an edge into the line. It also fits Job's bitterness toward the friends in 6:14–27.

in v26

Is Job admitting that his words are 'wind,' or accusing the friends of treating them as wind?

  • Admission. A despairing man's words are wind: emotional outbursts that should not be prosecuted as doctrine (KJV, WEB, ESV, NASB).

    The second line reads naturally as a separate statement with no verb. Job has already conceded that his words were 'wild/rash' (6:3, lā'û), so asking for allowance fits.

  • Accusation. The verb 'reckon' does double duty: 'do you regard the words of a despairing man as wind?' (BSB, NIV, many modern commentators).

    The idiom ḥashav + le- ('count as') is frequent in Job (13:24; 19:11; 33:10; 41:27). Bildad's reply in 8:2 calls Job's words 'a mighty wind,' which shows the friends really did dismiss them that way.

  • Both senses are deliberately held together.

    Hebrew poetry often lets one verb serve two lines, and the irony works either way. The friends both prosecute Job's words and dismiss them, which is the contradiction Job exposes.

in v27

What does Job say the friends 'make fall' on or over the orphan?

  • Lots: they cast lots for the child, as if sharing out slaves or loot.

    The causative of nāfal is the standard phrase for casting lots, and the noun is left out in 1 Samuel 14:42. Casting lots for people appears in Joel 3:3 and Nahum 3:10. It matches the trading verb in the second line. Followed by BSB, WEB, NIV, ESV and NASB.

  • An attack: they 'fall upon' or overwhelm the orphan.

    The Septuagint ('you fall upon') and the Vulgate ('you rush upon') read it this way, and KJV's 'overwhelm' is similar. However, this needs the simple form of the verb or a different construction, and it weakens the matching of the two lines.

in v27

Does the second verb mean 'bargain' or 'dig'?

  • 'Bargain over, trade' (kārâ II).

    The identical construction kārâ ʿal appears in Job 40:30 [41:6], and kārâ means 'buy' in Deuteronomy 2:6 and Hosea 3:2. This is the majority view of modern lexicons and translations.

  • 'Dig [a pit]' (kārâ I).

    Digging a pit as a trap is a common image (Psalm 7:15; 57:6). KJV and some medieval Jewish interpreters read it this way, but 'pit' has to be added and the preposition ʿal fits awkwardly.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).