Luke Chapter 12 Read as one passage
Luke 12:17–19
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
17So he thought to himself, ‘What shall I do, since I have nowhere to store my crops?’ 18Then he said, ‘This is what I will do: I will tear down my barns and will build bigger ones, and there I will store up all my grain and my goods. 19Then I will say to myself, “You have plenty of good things laid up for many years. Take it easy. Eat, drink, and be merry!”’
What the first hearers heard
Jesus' hearers, and Luke's readers after them, would have recognised the man at once: a big landowner in a world of struggling small farmers, facing the kind of 'problem' most of them could only dream of. The verse lets them overhear him, and three things stand out.
- He consults no one. In a culture where a household and village talked over decisions together, a man who talks only to himself about his harvest has cut himself off from the people his wealth was meant to serve.
- He asks the right question. "What shall I do?" is the question of repentance and decision in Luke, and the answer already given in this Gospel is to share (3:10–11; later 18:22). The hearers know the answer he skips.
- He says "my." The land produced the crop (v.16), but he calls it my produce. For Israelites the land belonged to God and its harvest carried duties toward the poor. The 'my' shows the greed (pleonexia, 'the urge to have more') of v.15.
The verse sets up the irony of the next lines. The man thinks his problem is storage, but his real lack is that he has no one to share with and no thought of God. He plans for years (v.19) and has one night (v.20). For a community that, in Luke's second volume, practised sharing goods with anyone in need (Acts 2:44–45; 4:32–35), the scene was a warning about what wealth does to a person who reasons only with himself.
From the study of Luke 12:17.
Verse by verse
-
17So he thought to himself, ‘What shall I do, since I have nowhere to store my crops?’
Full study →The harvest has come in far beyond what he expected. The land has produced it (v.16). And he kept turning it over in his own mind, talking it through with no one but himself: "What am I to do? I have nowhere to gather in my crops, my produce."
On the surface it is a practical worry: there is too much grain and not enough barn. But Luke's wording points to more. The verb for his reasoning is the one Luke usually uses for thinking that goes astray. The debate happens within himself: there are no family, neighbours, workers or poor in the conversation, and no God. His question, "What shall I do?", is the one the crowds asked John the Baptist, and John's answer was "share" (3:10–11). The man never considers that answer. What he notices is that he lacks where to put it, not that he has more than enough. In the original the verse ends on "my": the crop the land produced has become "my crops." The next lines carry it on: my barns, my grain, my goods, my soul (vv.18–19).
A Jewish listener would hear what is missing. Under Israel's law the yield of the land came from God and was owed in part to the poor, the widow, the orphan and the Levite. Joseph's great gathering of grain fed a starving people. This man's gathering is for himself alone. The verse is the moment the parable's sickness, the greed Jesus warned about in v.15, shows itself, before God calls him "Fool" (v.20).
-
18Then he said, ‘This is what I will do: I will tear down my barns and will build bigger ones, and there I will store up all my grain and my goods.
Full study →Talking only to himself, the rich landowner answers his own question ("What shall I do?") with a burst of confident plans: "Here's what I'll do. I'll pull down my storehouses, the granaries I already have, and build bigger ones. Into them I'll gather the whole harvest, every bit of the grain, along with all my other good things, all of it mine."
The Greek gives four "I will" verbs in one breath: do, tear down, build, gather. In v.19 he adds a fifth, I will say to my soul. His speech keeps returning to "my": my crops, my storehouses, my good things, my soul. The words he picks are freighted in Luke's Gospel. "Gather the grain into the granary" is almost exactly how John the Baptist described God's harvest at the judgment (3:17). "Tear down" is the verb Mary used when she sang of God bringing down the powerful (1:52). "Good things" is the word for what God gives the hungry (1:53) and what the rich man in a later parable enjoyed while a beggar starved at his door (16:25).
The man is not dishonest. The land produced the harvest (v.16), and storing grain is not wrong in itself. But faced with more than he needs, he never thinks of God, of his neighbours, or of the poor. He decides to enlarge the building and lock everything inside, as if a future he has planned all by himself were already his. The next verses show he does not even have the night (v.20).
-
19Then I will say to myself, “You have plenty of good things laid up for many years. Take it easy. Eat, drink, and be merry!”’
Full study →The rich farmer finishes his plan with a speech he means to give himself once the bigger barns are full. He calls out to his own life, his appetite, the part of him that hungers and wants: "Soul! You've got plenty of good things lying stored up, enough for many years. Now settle down and rest for good. Eat. Drink. Enjoy yourself and keep on feasting."
Every verb before this one is "I will": I will tear down, I will build, I will gather, and now I will say. The goods are "mine" and the soul is "mine." The only person in the conversation is himself. He talks to his own psychē, which in Greek means his life and living self, as if it were a servant or a dinner guest he can reassure. "Many good things" and "many years" sound alike and sound satisfied: wealth that is real, and time that is only assumed. The commands follow the classic biblical picture of the good life (rest, eat, drink, rejoice). In Israel's law and festivals that was a joy meant to be shared before God with family, servants, the stranger and the poor. Here it is turned in on one man.
Jesus' hearers would also hear the ironies the man misses. First, the very psychē he is comforting is about to be demanded back from him "this very night" (v.20). Second, the "many years" are not his to promise. Third, the rest he hands himself was something God gives. To an ear trained on Sirach and Ecclesiastes, this sounds like the last confident words of a man who does not know he is about to die.
Where the English drifted
-
in v17
bestow (KJV: "no room where to bestow my fruits")
synagō
- What we hear
- To give something as a gift or honour, so the man seems to be wondering where to give his crops away.
- What they heard
- To stow, store or put away. The Greek means to gather the harvest in. He is looking for storage, not someone to receive it.
-
in v17
fruits (KJV, YLT)
karpos
- What we hear
- Orchard fruit such as apples, figs or grapes.
- What they heard
- The whole yield of the land: here mainly grain (v.18, 'my grain'), harvest produce in general.
-
in v18
bestow (KJV: "there will I bestow all my fruits")
synaxō
- What we hear
- To give something as a gift or honour, which makes it sound as though he is handing his harvest out.
- What they heard
- To gather together and put away in storage. In 1611 'bestow' also meant 'to stow, lay up, place,' which is exactly what the man does: the opposite of giving it away.
-
in v18
barns
apothēkas
- What we hear
- Farm buildings for livestock, hay and equipment.
- What they heard
- Storehouses or granaries: buildings for keeping the harvested crop, the farm's stored wealth.
-
in v18
goods
agatha
- What we hear
- Merchandise or commodities, as in 'goods and services.'
-
in v18
fruits (KJV)
genēmata (Byzantine text) / siton (critical text)
- What we hear
- Fruit such as apples, grapes or figs.
- What they heard
- The produce of the field in general, mainly grain. The critical text says simply 'the grain.'
-
in v19
soul ("I will say to my soul, Soul…")
psychē
- What we hear
- The immortal spiritual part of a person, separate from the body, the part that goes to heaven or hell. Or, loosely, the inner emotional self.
- What they heard
- His life, his living self, including his appetite and desires: the self that eats and drinks and can be lost at death. It is the 'life' that, a few verses later, 'is more than food' (12:23).
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v19
"Eat, drink and be merry, for tomorrow we die" isn't in this verse
- What's often taught
- The Bible says, 'Eat, drink, and be merry, for tomorrow we die.' This is often quoted as a biblical motto for seizing the day, and the rich fool is often remembered as saying it.
- What the text supports
The rich man says nothing about dying. His whole speech rests on the opposite assumption: he has goods 'for many years' (etē polla). The irony of the parable is that he does not expect tomorrow to be his last day, and God's 'this very night' (v.20) comes as a shock.
The popular saying is a blend of two other passages:
- Ecclesiastes 8:15: 'nothing is better… than to eat and drink and be merry' (a sober acceptance of God's gifts).
- Isaiah 22:13: 'Let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we die.' This is the defiant slogan of Jerusalemites who feasted instead of repenting. Paul quotes it in 1 Corinthians 15:32 as the logic of people with no hope of resurrection.
None of these passages, and certainly not Luke 12:19, offers the saying as a motto to live by. In Luke the eat-drink-rejoice line is the self-assurance of a man God calls 'Fool!'
- Where the English feeds it
- The KJV's memorable 'eat, drink, and be merry' (Luke 12:19; Eccl 8:15) and its 'let us eat and drink; for to morrow we shall die' (Isa 22:13; 1 Cor 15:32) sound so alike in English that they merged into one proverb.
Every word
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v17, v18, v19
Links the man's inner debate directly to the bumper harvest of v.16. The story moves in a plain chain: the land produced, and he started to reason.
-
διελογίζετο
dielogizeto · G1260
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in, within · v17
Locates the debate inside him. Nobody else takes part.
-
ἑαυτῷ
heautō · G1438
himself · v17
The only person he talks to is himself. In a village culture where big decisions were talked over with family and neighbours, this already marks him as isolated.
-
λέγων
legōn · G3004G
saying · v17
Brings in his inner speech as direct quotation. This is one of Luke's typical soliloquies, where the audience overhears a character thinking.
-
τί
ti · G5101
what? · v17
Opens a real question about what to do. He is genuinely stuck.
-
ποιήσω
poiēsō · G4160G
to do, make · v17, v18
'What am I to do?' The form is a deliberative question: someone asking himself which way to act. Luke puts the same words in the mouths of the shrewd manager (16:3) and the vineyard owner (20:13). The crowds asked John the Baptist a similar question, and his answer was to share (3:10–11).
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754H
because, since · v17
Gives the reason for his dilemma. The problem as he sees it is too much, not too little.
-
οὐκ
ouk · G3756
not · v17
Plain negation: 'I do not have.'
-
ἔχω
echō · G2192
to have · v17, v19
He has more than enough. Yet the only thing he notices is what he lacks, a place to put it. That is an irony in his words.
-
ποῦ
pou · G4226
where? · v17
'Where' to put it. The only option his reasoning sees is storage. The same 'have nowhere' wording appears in 9:58, where the Son of Man has nowhere to lay his head.
-
συνάξω
synaxō · G4863
-
τοὺς
tous · G3588
the · v17, v18, v19
The definite article: the particular crops just harvested.
-
καρπούς
karpous · G2590
fruit, produce, crop · v17
The farm's produce as a whole, mainly grain (v.18 names σῖτος, wheat). It does not mean fruit in the modern sense. Verse 16 said the land produced it.
-
μου
mou · G3165
my, of me · v17, v18, v19
'My crops.' This is the first in a run of 'my' words: my barns, my grain, my goods, my soul (vv.18–19). Verse 16 credits the land with the yield, but in his speech it has become his alone.
-
εἶπεν
eipen · G2036
he said · v18
He 'said' it, but only to himself. Verse 17 has already told us he was reasoning 'within himself.' Nobody else hears this speech: no family, no village elders, no God.
-
τοῦτο
touto · G3778
this · v18
Comes first for emphasis: 'THIS is what I'll do.' It sounds like a man pleased to have found the answer by himself.
-
καθελῶ
kathelō · G2507
I will tear down · v18
The first of a run of confident 'I will' verbs. It means to take down or demolish a structure. In Luke the same verb is used of God 'bringing down' the powerful (1:52).
-
ἀποθήκας
apothēkas · G596
-
μείζονας
meizonas · G3173
bigger, greater · v18
A comparative ('bigger ones') placed before its verb for emphasis. His answer to plenty is more capacity, not sharing it out.
-
οἰκοδομήσω
oikodomēsō · G3618
I will build · v18
An ordinary word for building. Paired with 'tear down,' it calls to mind the familiar biblical pairing of demolishing and building (Greek Ecclesiastes 3:3).
-
ἐκεῖ
ekei · G1563
there · v18
'There,' in the new, bigger buildings: one locked-up place where all his wealth will be kept.
-
πάντα
panta · G3956
all · v18
'All' of it. None is held back for anything or anyone else.
-
σῖτον
siton · G4621
grain, wheat · v18
Grain, mainly wheat: the basic food of the Mediterranean world and the main form of rural wealth. Withholding it from the market or from the needy had moral weight (Proverbs 11:26).
-
ἀγαθά
agatha · G18
-
ἐρῶ
erō · G4483
I will say · v19
Future tense. Even his satisfaction is something he has scheduled. He is planning a speech he will give himself once the barns are full, and every part of his future is assumed to be in his control.
-
ψυχῇ
psychē · G5590G
soul, life, self · v19
His own living self: his life, his appetites, the 'me' that wants and enjoys. He is not speaking to an immortal spiritual part. This same word comes back in v.20 when God says 'your psychē is demanded from you.'
-
πολλὰ
polla · G4183
many · v19
'Many' goods. It is the first of two uses of polla in the sentence (many goods, many years), and the repetition sounds satisfied.
-
κείμενα
keimena · G2749
lying, laid up · v19
A present participle: 'lying there,' stored, put by. The goods sit idle in the barn. They are not moving toward anyone else.
-
εἰς
eis · G1519
into, for · v19
'For' a stretch of time. The store is measured against the future he expects.
-
ἔτη
etē · G2094
years · v19
'Years.' He counts his future in years. God's answer in v.20 counts it in a single night ('this very night').
-
ἀναπαύου,
anapauou · G0373
rest, take your ease · v19
A present imperative, 'keep resting': stop working and settle into ongoing leisure. Rest was a real biblical good (Sabbath, rest in the land). Here he hands it to himself as something his stockpile has bought.
-
φάγε,
phage · G5315
eat · v19
An aorist imperative, a crisp command: 'eat.' Together with 'drink' it is a stock pair for feasting and well-being.
-
πίε,
pie · G4095
drink · v19
'Drink.' Also aorist imperative. It is the second half of the familiar eat-and-drink pair, which here means a life of plenty.
-
εὐφραίνου.
euphrainou · G2165
The world behind it
The occasion. A man in the crowd asks Jesus to make his brother divide the family inheritance (12:13). Jesus refuses to act as judge and warns: "Watch out and guard yourselves against every kind of greed, because one's life does not consist in the abundance of possessions" (12:15). This parable (vv.16–21) illustrates the warning. Right after it comes the teaching on not worrying (vv.22–34), which points to ravens that have "no storeroom or barn" (v.24), using the same word for barn as v.18.
Agrarian economy. In first-century Galilee and Judea most people were small farmers or tenants living close to subsistence. A man whose land (chōra, v.16, can mean a whole estate) produces a surplus too big for his existing barns is a large landowner. People in that world tended to assume there was only so much good to go around, so an unusual surplus raised a question: what do you owe your community? Holding back grain was a known abuse. Proverbs 11:26 says "people curse the one who hoards grain, but blessing is on the head of the one who sells it." Storing grain could also mean waiting for prices to rise in a lean year, though the parable does not say so.
Law and land. Torah treated the land as God's (Lev 25:23) and built sharing into the harvest itself: leaving the edges and gleanings (Lev 19:9–10; Deut 24:19–22), tithes for the Levite, stranger, orphan and widow (Deut 14:28–29), and firstfruits offered to God (Deut 26). A wealthy landowner was also expected to act as a patron and benefactor. Hearers would notice that none of these duties enter his deliberation.
Soliloquy. Luke likes to let readers overhear a character's private thoughts at a crisis: the prodigal (15:17–19), the steward (16:3–4), the judge (18:4–5), the vineyard owner (20:13). The inner speech shows what the person really is.
From the study of Luke 12:17.
Where scholars differ
in v17
Is the man already at fault in this verse, or only in his answer (vv.18–19)?
-
The dilemma itself is morally neutral. A large harvest really does need storage, and the fault appears only in his self-indulgent plan (v.19) and his forgetting of death and God (vv.20–21).
Storing grain is not condemned in itself (compare Joseph, Gen 41). God's verdict in v.20 answers v.19 ('eat, drink, be merry'), and v.21 sums up the fault as storing treasure 'for himself' rather than being 'rich toward God.'
-
The verse already shows the sickness: he talks only to himself, calls the crop 'my' produce, and assumes storage is the only option.
In Luke the verb dialogizomai often marks thinking that goes astray. 'Within himself' points to isolation, which Bailey notes would stand out in village culture. The 'my' series begins here. Luke's earlier answer to 'What shall we do?' is sharing (3:10–11).
in v17
Does the parable picture hoarding grain for profit, or simply securing a life of ease?
-
Market hoarding: storing grain to sell when scarcity drives prices up, a known abuse.
Proverbs 11:26 condemns withholding grain. Ancient sources record speculators holding stock in famine. Big barns would allow this.
-
Personal security and ease, with no speculation in view.
Verse 19 states the purpose: 'many years' of rest, eating, drinking and merriment. The text never mentions selling. The warning in v.15 is about trusting in possessions for life itself.
in v18
What exactly is wrong with the man's plan in v.18?
-
The fault is greed and withholding: he keeps a surplus that, by Israel's standards, should have benefited others.
The setting is a warning against pleonexia, the drive to have more (v.15). Proverbs 11:26 curses whoever holds back grain. Luke 3:10–11 tells those with extra food to share it. Luke 12:33 commands selling possessions and giving alms. The speech is full of 'my' and never mentions anyone else.
-
The fault is not storage itself but presumption and forgetting God: he plans as though his life and future were his to command.
Scripture praises storing grain wisely (Genesis 41; Proverbs 6:6–8). God's verdict in v.20 concerns his life being demanded that very night, and v.21 contrasts laying up for oneself with being 'rich toward God.' Sirach 11:18–19 and James 4:13–16 likewise condemn confident planning that leaves out mortality and God.
-
Both together: in the biblical framework, ignoring God and ignoring the needy are a single failure.
Luke repeatedly ties love of God to use of wealth (16:13 'you cannot serve God and money'; 16:19–31; 18:22). 'Rich toward God' (v.21) is explained in vv.33–34 as giving to the poor, so the vertical and horizontal readings meet.
in v18
Is the man suggested to be a grain speculator?
-
Yes, implicitly. Hearers in an agrarian economy would assume that hoarding grain meant holding it back to sell at higher prices in scarcity.
Proverbs 11:26; Amos 8:4–6; later rabbinic condemnation of hoarders (b. Bava Batra 90b). Social-scientific studies of ancient Mediterranean economies stress that wealth was thought to be limited, so one person's stockpile came at others' expense.
-
Not stated: the parable focuses on his self-absorption and death, not on market manipulation.
The text never mentions selling, prices or the poor. He plans to consume the goods himself ('eat, drink, be merry,' v.19), not to trade them. Reading speculation into the story goes beyond its wording.
in v19
What exactly is the rich man's fault in this speech?
-
Presumption about the future and forgetting God: he treats life and time as his own possessions.
The contrast 'many years' / 'this very night' (v.20). The parallel with Sir 11:19 and Prov 27:1. God's 'Fool!' (aphrōn) recalls the fool of Ps 14:1 who lives as if there were no God.
-
Greed and hoarding with no concern for others: the surplus should have been shared.
The setting is a warning against 'all covetousness' (12:15). The verdict is 'stores up treasure for himself' (12:21). The sequel commands 'sell your possessions and give alms' (12:33). Deuteronomy expects harvest joy to be shared with the poor.
-
Isolation and self-centredness: the parable's sharpest touch is that he consults and celebrates with no one but himself.
The exclusive self-address ('I will say to my soul'), the repeated 'my' in v.18, and the communal decision-making norms of village culture (stressed by K. E. Bailey). These views overlap, and most commentators combine them.
in v19
Is the eat-drink-rejoice language itself being condemned?
-
No. Enjoyment is a biblical good. The fault lies in the framing (self-sufficiency, presumption, keeping it for himself).
Eccl 8:15 and Deut 14:26 commend eating and rejoicing. Luke uses euphrainō positively for the feast over the lost son (15:23–32), and Jesus himself was criticised for eating and drinking (7:34).
-
The phrase deliberately echoes the slogan of those who live for the present and deny accountability.
Isa 22:13 ('let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we die') and its use in 1 Cor 15:32, together with Wisdom 2:6–9, show 'eat and drink' working as a hedonist slogan. The rich man's tone fits that pattern even though he lacks the 'tomorrow we die' clause.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. διαλογίζομαι, συνάγω, καρπός
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. διαλογίζομαι
- Kenneth E. Bailey, Through Peasant Eyes (Eerdmans, 1980), on Luke 12:13–21
- Joseph A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke X–XXIV (Anchor Bible)
- Joel B. Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT)
- Darrell L. Bock, Luke 9:51–24:53 (BECNT)
- Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Luke 12:16–21
- Sirach 11:18–19; 1 Enoch 97:8–10; Gospel of Thomas 63
- Basil of Caesarea, Homily 'I Will Tear Down My Barns' (Homilia in illud Lucae, Destruam horrea mea)
- Vulgate, Luke 12:17
- Oxford English Dictionary s.v. 'bestow' (sense: to stow, place)
- BDAG s.v. ἀποθήκη, καθαιρέω, συνάγω, ἀγαθός
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ἀποθήκη, συνάγω
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Luke 12:18
- Kenneth E. Bailey, Through Peasant Eyes (on the Rich Fool's soliloquy)
- Klyne Snodgrass, Stories with Intent (on Luke 12:16–21)
- Sirach 11:18–19 (LXX)
- Ecclesiastes 3:3 (LXX)
- 1 Enoch 94–97
- Gospel of Thomas, logion 63
- Babylonian Talmud, Bava Batra 90b
- Oxford English Dictionary s.v. 'bestow', 'barn'
- BDAG s.v. ψυχή, ἀγαθός, ἀναπαύω, εὐφραίνω, κεῖμαι
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ψυχή
- Septuagint: Ecclesiastes 8:15; Sirach 11:18–19; Deuteronomy 14:26–29; Isaiah 22:13; Tobit 7:10
- 1 Enoch 97:8–10
- Gospel of Thomas 63
- Kenneth E. Bailey, Through Peasant Eyes (on the rich fool's soliloquy)
- I. Howard Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC)
- NA28 critical apparatus on Luke 12:19
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).