Luke Chapter 5 Read as one passage
Luke 5:21–22
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
21But the scribes and Pharisees began thinking to themselves, “Who is this man who speaks blasphemy? Who can forgive sins but God alone?” 22Knowing what they were thinking, Jesus replied, “Why are you thinking these things in your hearts?
What the first hearers heard
For Luke's first readers, Jewish and Gentile Christians of the late first century, this verse states the central question of the scene, and of the Gospel, in the mouths of Jesus' critics.
- The objection is taken seriously. Luke does not present the scribes' premise as wrong. That God alone forgives sins was basic Jewish faith, rooted in the Shema and the prophets, and Luke's readers shared it. The tension is real: either Jesus is dishonouring God, or God's own authority is present and active in him.
- "Who is this?" is Luke's running question. The sinful woman scene ends with "Who is this who even forgives sins?" (7:49), the storm with "Who then is this?" (8:25), and Herod asks "Who is this about whom I hear such things?" (9:9). Peter finally answers: "The Christ of God" (9:20). Readers are meant to answer the scribes' question for themselves from what follows.
- The answer comes through demonstration. Jesus knows their unspoken thoughts (v. 22), a power Israel's Scriptures assign to God. He then makes the paralysed man walk as visible proof that "the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins" (v. 24). The title recalls the figure in Daniel 7:13–14 who is given authority by the Ancient of Days. The point is that God's own prerogative is being exercised on earth through this man.
- Foreshadowing. The word "blasphemy" plants the charge that will follow Jesus to his death. It also shows that forgiveness is now being given outside the temple system, a theme Acts develops ("forgiveness of sins" proclaimed in Jesus' name, Acts 2:38; 10:43; 13:38).
From the study of Luke 5:21.
Verse by verse
-
21But the scribes and Pharisees began thinking to themselves, “Who is this man who speaks blasphemy? Who can forgive sins but God alone?”
Full study →The experts in the Law and the Pharisees, devout and learned men who had come from across the land to assess this new teacher, began turning it over in their minds, troubled. "Who is this man? What he is saying is an insult to God. Who has the power and the right to release a person from their sins, to cancel what they owe to God, except God, and God alone?"
Their logic is clear and comes straight from their Scriptures. Sin is a debt owed to God. Only the one to whom a debt is owed can write it off. God had said, "I, I am he who blots out your transgressions" (Isaiah 43:25). A priest at the altar or a prophet like Nathan could announce that God had forgiven. But Jesus had simply told a paralysed man, on his own say-so, "Your sins are released." To these listeners that sounded like a man claiming a right that belongs only to God. That is "blasphemy" in its full ancient sense: speech that dishonours God, here by trespassing on what is his alone. It is not swearing, and it carried a death sentence under the Law (Leviticus 24:16).
Their first question, "Who is this?", carries contempt ("this fellow"), but it is also the question Luke's whole Gospel keeps asking (7:49; 8:25; 9:9, 18–20). Luke lets their premise stand, "only God can do this." He then shows Jesus answering not by denying it but by proving his authority. He reads their unspoken thoughts, and he heals the man so that they may know "the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins" (v. 24).
-
22Knowing what they were thinking, Jesus replied, “Why are you thinking these things in your hearts?
Full study →But Jesus saw straight through to what was going on inside them: the silent case they were building against him ("Who does he think he is? This is blasphemy. Only God can forgive sins!"). Although no one had said a word to him, he answered them. He spoke directly to the men themselves: "Why are you turning these arguments over in your hearts?"
A few things are packed into this short line:
- "Recognized/perceived": Jesus has already grasped their objection before he speaks. Luke does not explain how. But he knows what was meant to stay hidden.
- "Reasonings" / "reasoning": these are not idle thoughts. The word means inner debate, usually suspicious or doubting. The scribes are quietly trying him for blasphemy.
- "Answering": he replies to a conversation they never had with him. Their silent verdict gets a spoken response.
- "In your hearts": in biblical language the heart is where a person thinks, weighs and decides, not mainly where they feel. In the Scriptures these men knew, the hidden heart is the place God alone fully sees (1 Kgs 8:39; Jer 17:10). They have just insisted that forgiving sins belongs to "God alone", and Jesus now shows he can read the inner place God searches.
- "Why?": this is a challenge, not a request for information. It brings their objection into the open and leads straight into his test in the next verse: "Which is easier: to say 'Your sins are forgiven,' or to say 'Get up and walk'?"
Where the English drifted
-
in v21
blasphemy / blasphemies
blasphēmia
- What we hear
- Swearing, using God's name as a curse word, or saying something offensive about religion.
- What they heard
- Speech that insults or dishonours someone's honour. Toward God, any speech that diminishes his honour, including a human being claiming God's unique rights. The scribes' charge is that Jesus is speaking as if he were in God's place. It was a capital accusation under Leviticus 24.
-
in v21
scribes
grammateis
- What we hear
- Copyists or clerks who wrote documents out by hand.
- What they heard
- Recognised experts in the Law of Moses, the people's legal scholars and teachers, in the tradition of Ezra.
-
in v21
Pharisees
Pharisaioi
- What we hear
- Self-righteous hypocrites and legalists; 'pharisaical' as an insult.
- What they heard
- A respected, popular movement of devout Jews committed to careful observance of the Law and its traditions. Many people saw them as the most exact interpreters of Scripture. Their objection here comes from zeal for God's honour.
-
in v21
forgive
aphiēmi
- What we hear
- An inner emotional act: letting go of resentment, choosing not to be angry any more.
- What they heard
- To release or cancel, as a debt is written off or a prisoner set free. Here it means God's cancelling of what a person owes him for their wrongs. The question is who holds the right to cancel that debt, not who can stop feeling offended.
-
in v22
hearts
kardia
- What we hear
- The seat of emotion, as opposed to the "head" that thinks. A reader may picture the scribes feeling resentment.
- What they heard
- The inner self where a person reasons, plans, judges and decides. The scribes are *thinking through an argument* (a charge of blasphemy) inside themselves.
-
in v22
What reason ye / Why are you reasoning
dialogizomai
- What we hear
- Calm, logical thought, a neutral or even good activity.
- What they heard
- Debating something inwardly, here in the sense of doubting or objecting. They are quietly building a case that Jesus has blasphemed.
Every word
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v21
Simple narrative link. It ties the scholars' reaction straight to Jesus' words in v. 20, "your sins are forgiven you."
-
ἤρξαντο
ērxanto · G0757
began · v21
"They began to…" is a favourite storytelling phrase in Luke. It marks the start of a reaction rather than stressing a precise moment. The objection is just starting to form.
-
διαλογίζεσθαι
dialogizesthai · G1260
to reason, deliberate · v21, v22
To turn something over and weigh it, whether in one's own mind or in discussion with others. Verse 22 ("in your hearts") shows Luke means inward deliberation, probably with a shared sense of alarm. Ongoing action: they keep working at it.
-
οἱ
hoi · G3588
the · v21, v22
Definite article: a known group, the ones already present according to v. 17.
-
γραμματεῖς
grammateis · G1122
scribes · v21
Trained experts in the Law of Moses: its interpreters and teachers, the legal scholars of Jewish society. They are not mere copyists. In v. 17 Luke calls them "teachers of the law."
-
Φαρισαῖοι
Pharisaioi · G5330
Pharisees · v21
Members of a respected lay movement devoted to careful keeping of the Law and its traditions. This is their first appearance in Luke (v. 17), where they come from all over Galilee, Judea and Jerusalem to evaluate Jesus.
-
λέγοντες·
legontes · G3004
saying · v21
Introduces the content of their reasoning. Luke uses the same word for inner speech (Luke 12:17, the rich man "reasoned within himself, saying…"), so it need not mean they spoke aloud.
-
τίς
tis · G5101
who? · v21, v22
The first of two "who?" questions. Here it asks about Jesus' identity: what kind of person talks like this?
-
ἐστιν
estin · G1510
is · v21
Present tense "is." The question is about who he is, not only what he did.
-
οὗτος
houtos · G3778
this (one) · v21
"This man" or "this fellow". In an indignant question it can carry a note of contempt or distance. NIV's "this fellow" catches the tone.
-
ὃς
hos · G3739
who · v21
Relative pronoun connecting the man to his offending speech.
-
λαλεῖ
lalei · G2980
speaks · v21
Present tense: "is speaking." The offence is located in what he has just said aloud.
-
βλασφημίας;
blasphēmias · G0988
blasphemies, slanders · v21
Plural: "blasphemous things." Speech that insults God's honour, here by claiming a right that belongs only to God. Under Leviticus 24:16 this was a capital charge.
-
δύναται
dynatai · G1410
is able, can · v21
Has the power and the right. This prepares for Jesus' answer about "authority" (exousia) in v. 24.
-
ἁμαρτίας
hamartias · G0266
sins · v21
Plural: the specific wrongs that stand against a person before God, pictured in Jewish thought as debts owed to God.
-
ἀφεῖναι
apheinai · G0863
to release, forgive · v21
To let go, release, cancel, as when a debt is written off. The tense presents it as a single decisive act. It echoes Jesus' own word in v. 20 (aphéōntai, "have been released").
-
εἰ
ei · G1487
if · v21
First half of the idiom ei mē, "if not," which means "except."
-
μὴ
mē · G3361
not · v21
Completes "except."
-
μόνος
monos · G3441
alone, only · v21
"Alone". It stresses that this right belongs to God alone. Mark 2:7 has "except one, God," which echoes the Shema ("the LORD is one"). Luke's "alone" makes the same point in plainer Greek.
-
θεός;
theos · G2316
God · v21
The God of Israel, who in Scripture announces "I, I am he who blots out your transgressions" (Isaiah 43:25).
-
Ἐπιγνοὺς
Epignous · G1921
to recognize, perceive, come to know · v22
"Having recognized / perceived." The past-tense participle presents the perceiving as complete before he speaks: he has already seen what is going on in them. Luke does not say how he knew.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, and, now · v22
A light connecting word that moves the story from the scribes' silent objection (v. 21) to Jesus' response. It sets up a mild contrast: they reason, he perceives.
-
Ἰησοῦς
Iēsous · G2424
Jesus (Greek form of Yeshua/Joshua) · v22
The subject. His name sits right after the verb of knowing, so the sentence puts his perceiving first.
-
διαλογισμοὺς
dialogismous · G1261
reasonings, inner deliberations, questionings · v22
The arguments and objections they were turning over inside. In Luke this word nearly always carries a note of doubt or suspicion, not neutral thinking.
-
αὐτῶν
autōn · G0846
of them, their · v22
"Their": the scribes and Pharisees of v. 21. The reasonings belong to them and were hidden from view.
-
ἀποκριθεὶς
apokritheis · G0611
to answer, respond · v22
"Answering." No one had said anything to Jesus, so he is answering thoughts that were not spoken to him. The phrase "answering, he said" is a common biblical way of speaking, but here it does real work.
-
εἶπεν
eipen · G2036
said · v22
"He said." The main verb of the sentence. What was hidden is now brought into the open.
-
πρὸς
pros · G4314
to, toward · v22
"To" them. Luke likes "say to" (pros) with the person addressed. Jesus speaks directly to his critics, not about them.
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in · v22
"In." It places the debate inside them, not out loud in the room.
-
καρδίαις
kardiais · G2588
heart (inner self: mind, will, intention) · v22
The heart in the biblical sense: the inner place where a person thinks, weighs and decides. The verse is about their reasoning minds and hidden judgments, not their feelings.
-
ὑμῶν;
hymōn · G4771
of you (plural), your · v22
"Your," plural. He addresses the whole group of critics together.
The world behind it
The scene. Jesus is teaching in a house, apparently in Capernaum (cf. Mark 2:1). Luke says Pharisees and "teachers of the law" had come "from every village of Galilee and Judea and from Jerusalem" (5:17). This was a serious delegation, there to evaluate a teacher drawing crowds. Friends lower a paralysed man through the roof tiles. Jesus, seeing their faith, says, "Man, your sins have been forgiven you" (v. 20).
How forgiveness normally worked. In the Law of Moses, forgiveness of sin was tied to the sanctuary. A person brought a sacrifice, the priest made atonement, and "it shall be forgiven him" (Leviticus 4:20, 26, 31; 5:10). The verb is passive, with God as the one who forgives. The Day of Atonement (Leviticus 16) cleansed the nation. Prophets could declare God's pardon ("The LORD has put away your sin," 2 Samuel 12:13). But Scripture consistently presents forgiveness as God's own act (Exodus 34:6–7; Psalm 103:3; 130:4; Isaiah 43:25; 44:22; Micah 7:18). Jesus speaks in a private house, with no sacrifice, no priest, no temple, and no "the LORD says."
Blasphemy as a legal charge. Leviticus 24:10–16 orders death by stoning for one who "blasphemes the name of the LORD." Rabbinic law written down later (Mishnah Sanhedrin 7:5) limits the capital offence to actually pronouncing the divine Name. The Gospels suggest that in Jesus' day the accusation could be made more broadly, for speech or claims that insulted God's honour (Mark 2:7; 14:64; John 10:33). The scholars' silent verdict here is therefore grave. It is the same accusation that will later be used against Jesus.
Sin and sickness. Many people of the time assumed a link between illness and sin (John 9:2; cf. the Dead Sea Scrolls' Prayer of Nabonidus, 4Q242). So a word of forgiveness spoken to a paralysed man would not have sounded unrelated to his condition.
From the study of Luke 5:21.
Where scholars differ
in v21
Did first-century Judaism allow any human being to forgive sins, or was this strictly God's act?
-
Forgiveness was God's prerogative alone. Priests and prophets could only announce or mediate it, so Jesus' unmediated pronouncement was unprecedented and sounded like claiming divine status.
The Torah's sacrificial formula is passive, 'it shall be forgiven him' (Leviticus 4:20 etc.), with God as the actor. Nathan says 'the LORD has put away your sin' (2 Samuel 12:13). Exodus 34:6–7, Isaiah 43:25 and Psalm 130:4 make forgiveness God's own act. D. Johansson's survey (JSNT 2011) finds no clear Second Temple case of a human forgiving sins against God in his own right. Mark 2:7's Shema echo ('one, God') supports this reading.
-
Some Jews could imagine a human agent pronouncing forgiveness. The scandal was more that Jesus bypassed the temple, priesthood and sacrifice than that he claimed to be God.
The Dead Sea Scrolls' Prayer of Nabonidus (4Q242) says a Jewish 'diviner' (gāzar) 'forgave my sin.' The Aramaic is ambiguous about whether God or the diviner forgave. Jesus' words in v. 20 use a passive ('have been forgiven'), which can be read as announcing God's act. Scholars such as E. P. Sanders and N. T. Wright stress that Jesus offered forgiveness outside the temple system.
in v21
Was Jesus' word in v. 20 itself a claim to divine authority, or an announcement of what God had done?
-
An announcement using the 'divine passive' (God is the unstated forgiver), like a prophet declaring God's pardon. The scribes over-read it.
ἀφέωνται ('have been forgiven') is passive with no stated agent, a common Jewish way of referring to God's action without naming him.
-
Luke presents it as Jesus exercising the authority himself, as God's appointed agent.
Jesus does not correct the scribes' premise. He answers that 'the Son of Man has authority (exousia) on earth to forgive sins' (v. 24) and proves it by healing. He also reads their hearts (v. 22). Daniel 7:13–14 has the Son of Man receiving authority from God. Luke 7:48–49 repeats the claim and the question. Commentators such as Bock, Marshall and Green read the scene as a deliberate statement about Jesus' identity.
in v21
Did the scribes voice their objection aloud or only think it?
-
Only inwardly.
Verse 22: 'Why are you reasoning in your hearts?' Mark 2:6, 8 says the same. Luke 12:17 uses 'reasoned… saying' for purely inner speech. So Jesus' knowledge of their thoughts is itself part of the point.
-
Possibly murmured among themselves.
διαλογίζομαι can mean discussion between people (cf. Luke 20:14), and 'began to reason… saying' can describe a group exchange. But v. 22 favours inner thought, and most translations follow that.
in v22
How did Jesus know their thoughts? Was it divine knowledge, prophetic insight, or ordinary perceptiveness?
-
Luke presents a knowledge of the heart that Scripture reserves for God, fitting the scribes' own words "God alone".
The thoughts were "in their hearts" (v. 22). Israel's Scriptures make heart-knowledge God's prerogative (1 Sam 16:7; 1 Kgs 8:39; Jer 17:10; Ps 94:11). Luke himself calls God "heart-knower" (Acts 1:24; 15:8). The scene pairs heart-reading with forgiving sins, as Solomon's prayer does (1 Kgs 8:39).
-
Luke presents prophetic insight, the kind of hidden knowledge expected of a true prophet.
Luke often portrays Jesus as a prophet (4:24; 7:16; 24:19). Elisha knew hidden deeds and words (2 Kgs 5:26; 6:12). In Luke 7:39 a Pharisee assumes a prophet would know hidden things, and Jesus then answers his unspoken thought. Luke drops Mark's "in his spirit" and does not specify a source.
-
Jesus read their faces and murmurs. No supernatural knowledge is required by the text.
Luke 5:21 says they "began to reason, saying…", which could mean low talk among themselves. The verb *epiginōskō* can mean simply "notice". Against this: Luke's "saying" can introduce purely inner speech (12:17), and Jesus himself locates the reasoning "in your hearts". Most commentators (e.g. Marshall, Bock, Bovon) take Luke to present more than shrewd observation.
in v22
Was the scribes' objection silent, or spoken among themselves?
-
Silent, inward reasoning.
Mark 2:6, 8 says plainly "in their hearts / within themselves". Jesus' own words in Luke are "in your hearts". Luke uses "reasoned… saying" for a purely inward monologue in 12:17.
-
Muttered discussion among the group.
*Dialogizomai* can mean debating with others (e.g. Luke 20:14). The plural group and "began to reason, saying" in v. 21 allow quiet talk among themselves. Even on this view, Jesus addresses what they had not said to him.
Sources
- BDAG (Bauer–Danker–Arndt–Gingrich, Greek-English Lexicon of the NT), s.v. βλασφημία, ἀφίημι, διαλογίζομαι, γραμματεύς, Φαρισαῖος
- Louw–Nida, Greek-English Lexicon Based on Semantic Domains, 33.400 (blasphemy), 40.8 (forgive)
- Septuagint: Leviticus 4–5; 24:10–16; Isaiah 43:25; Psalm 130:4; Exodus 34:6–7
- Mishnah Sanhedrin 7:5 (rabbinic definition of blasphemy)
- 4Q242 Prayer of Nabonidus (Dead Sea Scrolls)
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.171–173, 297–298; 17.41–42; 18.12–15; Jewish War 2.162–166
- J. A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke I–IX (Anchor Bible)
- D. L. Bock, Luke 1:1–9:50 (BECNT)
- J. B. Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT)
- I. H. Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC)
- J. Nolland, Luke 1–9:20 (WBC)
- D. Johansson, "'Who Can Forgive Sins but God Alone?' Human and Angelic Agents, and Divine Forgiveness in Early Judaism," JSNT 33 (2011)
- C. S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Luke 5:17–26 / Mark 2:1–12
- BDAG s.v. ἐπιγινώσκω
- BDAG s.v. διαλογισμός
- BDAG s.v. διαλογίζομαι
- BDAG s.v. καρδία
- BDAG s.v. ἀποκρίνομαι
- Moulton & Milligan, Vocabulary of the Greek Testament, s.v. ἐπιγινώσκω, διαλογισμός
- TDNT s.v. καρδία (J. Behm)
- Septuagint: Ps 93:11 (MT 94:11); 3 Kgdms (1 Kgs) 8:39; Lev 4:26
- F. Bovon, Luke 1 (Hermeneia)
- Synoptic parallels: Mark 2:6–8; Matthew 9:3–4
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).