Luke Chapter 22 Read as one passage
Luke 22:49–50
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
49Those around Jesus saw what was about to happen and said, “Lord, should we strike with our swords?” 50And one of them struck the servant of the high priest, cutting off his right ear.
What the first hearers heard
Luke's first readers would have heard several things here:
- A question asking for a command. The disciples ask their kyrios whether to fight. Asking is the right instinct. What follows shows the problem: one of them acts before the master answers.
- Old Testament battle language. "Strike with the sword" is the phrase of Israel's wars (Numbers, Joshua, Judges). Some in Luke's audience knew the hope of a messiah who would fight. For them the question touched a live issue: is this the moment the kingdom is won by force?
- The misunderstanding of 22:36–38. Luke has just reported the "buy a sword" saying and the two swords. Verse 49 shows the disciples taking it literally and tactically. Jesus' reply in verse 51 ("No more of this!") and his healing of the wounded man settle what he meant by it for Luke's story.
- Jesus is not a rebel. Luke's account, written for readers in the Roman world, repeatedly shows that Jesus led no uprising (23:4, 14–15, 22). The disciples' question, the rash blow, Jesus' halt and the healing all make the same point: whatever his followers did in panic, Jesus did not resist arrest with violence.
From the study of Luke 22:49.
Verse by verse
-
49Those around Jesus saw what was about to happen and said, “Lord, should we strike with our swords?”
Full study →The men gathered around Jesus took in the scene: Judas stepping forward with a kiss, an armed crowd from the chief priests closing in. They saw what was coming, an arrest and with it a fight. So they turned to their master for orders: "Lord, do we cut them down with the blade?"
The wording is the language of battle, not of a shove. "Strike with the sword" is the Old Testament phrase for killing enemies in war. The "sword" is a short blade or long knife, one of the two they had shown Jesus a few hours earlier (22:38), when he had cut the conversation short with "It is enough." The question asks for a command. Yet the very next verse shows that one of them did not wait: he swung and took off the right ear of the high priest's slave. Luke lets the irony stand. The disciples "see what is going to be", but they read it as a moment for armed resistance. Jesus has just told them it is the fulfilment of Scripture: "he was counted with the lawless" (22:37). His answer, when it comes, is "No more of this!", and he heals the wounded man (22:51).
-
50And one of them struck the servant of the high priest, cutting off his right ear.
Full study →The disciples had just asked, "Lord, shall we strike with the sword?" Before any answer comes, one of them strikes. Luke uses the very same verb, so the question becomes a deed in one move. Luke does not name the man ("a certain one of them"). John later identifies him as Peter. The target is not a random member of the crowd but the high priest's own slave. He was a known man of the household, probably sent along as Caiaphas's personal agent at the arrest. Striking him was in effect striking at the high priest's authority. The blow took off his ear: a real severing, not a scratch. Luke adds that it was the right ear, the kind of exact detail a remembered event keeps. The scene is set up so that the next verse can turn it around. Jesus says "No more of this!", touches the ear and heals the man his own follower has just wounded.
Where the English drifted
-
in v49
sword
machaira
- What we hear
- A long sword like a knight's or a soldier's.
- What they heard
- A short sword or long knife: the blade a traveller, butcher or sacrificing priest might carry. Two such blades among eleven men (22:38).
-
in v50
servant
doulos
- What we hear
- A hired household employee, someone like a butler or attendant who works for wages.
- What they heard
- A slave owned by the high priest's household. As his master's agent he could carry real delegated authority, so he was both of low legal status and socially powerful.
Every word
-
ἰδόντες
idontes · G1492
having seen · v49
Aorist participle: the seeing comes first and leads to the question. They take in the scene: Judas's kiss and the armed crowd closing in (22:47–48).
-
δὲ
de · G1161
and, then, but · v49
A light link that moves from Jesus' words to Judas over to the disciples' reaction.
-
οἱ
hoi · G3588
the (ones) · v49, v50
Turns the phrase "around him" into a noun: "the ones around him".
-
περὶ
peri · G4012
around · v49
With the accusative it means physically or socially around someone. "Those around him" is a common Greek way of saying a person's circle, here the eleven disciples.
-
αὐτὸν
auton · G846
him · v49, v50
Jesus, the center of the group.
-
ἐσόμενον
esomenon · G1510
going to be · v49
A future participle of "to be", rare in the New Testament. Literally "the about-to-be thing". They see an arrest coming and a fight about to break out.
-
εἶπαν
eipan · G2036
they said · v49
Several of them speak, or one speaks for the group. The question is collective.
-
κύριε
kyrie · G2962
Lord, master, sir · v49
Addressing Jesus as their master. Disciples use it in Luke to ask for his command. It is respectful and deferential, and in Luke's Gospel as a whole it carries more weight than a polite "sir".
-
εἰ
ei · G1487
-
πατάξομεν
pataxomen · G3960
strike, smite · v49, v50
A future indicative used to ask what to do: "Shall we strike?" The verb means a hard, often deadly blow. In the Greek Old Testament it is the standard word for cutting enemies down in battle.
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in; with · v49
Here it marks the instrument, "with". This use echoes Hebrew style and the Septuagint phrase "strike with the sword".
-
μαχαίρῃ
machairē · G3162
short sword, large knife · v49
Singular with no article: "with sword", meaning with the weapon as such. It points back to the two μάχαιραι they showed Jesus a few hours earlier (22:38).
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v50
A plain 'and' that ties the blow directly to the disciples' question in v. 49. Luke goes straight from 'Lord, shall we strike?' to 'and he struck', with no answer from Jesus in between.
-
εἷς
heis · G1520
one · v50
'One' of the group, a single person acting alone. The others only asked.
-
τις
tis · G5100
a certain, someone · v50
Together with heis it means 'a certain one'. The phrase deliberately leaves him unnamed. Luke, like Mark and Matthew, does not identify him. Only John (18:10) names him as Simon Peter.
-
ἐξ
ex · G1537
out of, from · v50
Picks him out from the group: 'one out of them'.
-
ἀρχιερέως
archiereōs · G749
high priest, chief priest · v50
In the singular, the ruling high priest, at this time Caiaphas (Luke 3:2 names Annas and Caiaphas). The Greek puts this word first, before 'slave', so it stresses whose man was hit.
-
δοῦλον
doulon · G1401
slave · v50
A slave who belonged to the high priest's household. Such household slaves could act as their master's agents with real power. He is probably there as the high priest's personal representative at the arrest.
-
ἀφεῖλεν
apheilen · G851
to take away, remove, take off · v50
Literally 'took away' or 'took off'. Used of a body part, it means the ear was severed. Mark and Matthew use the same verb; John uses the blunter 'cut off' (apekopsen).
-
οὖς
ous · G3775
ear · v50
The ordinary Greek word for 'ear'. Mark and John use a smaller-sounding form (ōtarion), and Luke switches to another one (ōtion) in v. 51. In everyday Greek of the time these forms had mostly lost any sense of 'little', so they cannot prove that only an earlobe was lost.
-
δεξιόν
dexion · G1188
right (side) · v50
Only Luke and John say which ear. This kind of exact detail marks the story as a remembered event. Whether 'right' carried any symbolic meaning is debated (see Debates).
The world behind it
The night and the place. It is the night of Passover, on the Mount of Olives outside Jerusalem (22:39). The arresting party includes chief priests, officers of the temple guard and elders, carrying swords and clubs (22:52). This is a temple police action backed by the Jerusalem priestly leadership, not a Roman military operation in Luke's telling.
Why disciples had blades at all. Travellers in first-century Palestine often carried a knife or short sword against bandits. Josephus notes that even the Essenes, a strict and peaceful Jewish group, carried weapons on journeys (Jewish War 2.125). Earlier that evening Jesus had said, "the one who has no sword should sell his cloak and buy one" (22:36). The disciples produced two swords and Jesus replied "It is enough" (22:38). He tied the saying to Isaiah 53:12: "he was counted with the lawless" (22:37). Verse 49 shows the disciples taking that earlier saying as a call to fight.
Only in Luke. All four Gospels report the ear being cut off. Only Luke records the disciples first asking whether to strike, and only Luke records Jesus healing the ear. John names the swordsman as Peter and the slave as Malchus (John 18:10). Luke leaves both unnamed: "one of them".
What armed resistance would have meant. In the decades around Jesus, Judea saw several armed movements against Roman rule and its local collaborators. Men who drew blades against the temple authorities would be treated as rebels or bandits (λῃσταί). Jesus himself protests, "Have you come out as against a bandit?" (22:52). A fight here would have made Jesus look like exactly what his accusers later claimed (23:2).
From the study of Luke 22:49.
Where scholars differ
in v49
What did Jesus mean by the "buy a sword" saying (22:36–38), which the disciples act on here?
-
Literal permission for self-defence or travel protection, in the new and hostile conditions after Jesus' departure.
22:36 contrasts the earlier mission, sent out with no purse (22:35), with a new situation. Travellers routinely carried blades (Josephus, War 2.125). Jesus does not order the two swords thrown away.
-
Figurative language for coming hostility, which the disciples misread literally. "It is enough" (22:38) is an exasperated end to the conversation.
Two swords would be useless against an armed party. Jesus forbids their use the moment they are drawn (22:51) and heals the injury. Luke often shows the disciples misunderstanding Jesus (9:45; 18:34).
-
The swords serve to fulfil Isaiah 53:12, so that Jesus is "counted with the lawless".
22:37 explicitly links the saying to that prophecy. Two swords are "enough" to make the group look like bandits (cf. 22:52), with no intention of fighting.
in v49
Is the question a real request for permission, or a rhetorical lead-in to an attack already decided?
-
A real request for orders.
Direct questions introduced by εἰ in Luke–Acts are real questions (13:23; Acts 1:6). The address κύριε asks for a ruling.
-
It shows the group's impulse, which one member acts on before any answer.
Verse 50 follows at once with καί ("and") and no reply from Jesus between them. John 18:10 presents Peter's blow as his own initiative.
in v50
Why does Luke (with John) say it was the right ear?
-
Just a detail of a remembered event. A right-handed swordsman facing his opponent would most easily catch the left side, so a right-ear wound may suggest the slave turned away or the blow came at an odd angle. Either way, it is simply what happened.
Mark and Matthew lack the detail, and nothing in Luke draws attention to it. Exact physical details are common in eyewitness-based accounts.
-
A deliberate insult or 'disqualifying' mutilation aimed at the high priest through his representative.
Josephus (Antiquities 14.366; War 1.270) tells of Hyrcanus II's ears being mutilated to bar him from the high priesthood under Leviticus 21. The right side was the side of honour. Proposed by David Daube and discussed by R. E. Brown, The Death of the Messiah. Against it: the victim is a slave, not a priest, and no Gospel hints at symbolism.
-
A literary detail added to heighten the story.
Details sometimes grow in later retellings (e.g. John adds the names Peter and Malchus). But Luke and John probably used separate sources, which makes pure invention less likely.
in v50
Was the disciple trying to kill the man and missed, or aiming for the ear?
-
A killing blow that missed, perhaps because the slave dodged. This is a common reading in sermons.
Patassō with a sword usually means a wounding or deadly blow, and v. 49 suggests a fight. But the text says nothing about aim, so this is inference.
-
A deliberate, limited blow (a warning or insult).
It fits the mutilation parallel above, but again the text does not say so.
-
The text does not tell us, and Luke is not interested in the question.
Luke's focus is the contrast between the disciple's blow and Jesus' healing in v. 51, not the swordsman's intent.
in v50
How were the 'two swords' of 22:36–38 meant, given what happens here?
-
Figurative: Jesus warned of coming hostility, the disciples took him literally, and 'It is enough' ends the conversation.
Two swords could hardly protect twelve men. Jesus stops the violence at once in v. 51. Many commentators (e.g. Fitzmyer, Green) take this view.
-
Literal but limited: the swords were needed so that Jesus would be 'counted among the lawless' (Isa 53:12), not for actual fighting.
V. 37 links the swords directly to the fulfilment of Isaiah 53:12, and v. 52 has Jesus treated 'as against a bandit'.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. μάχαιρα
- BDAG s.v. πατάσσω
- BDAG s.v. εἰ (use in direct questions)
- Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. πατάσσω
- Josephus, Jewish War 2.125
- Septuagint: Gen 22:6, 10; Num 21:24; Josh 8:24; Judg 1:8; Zech 13:7
- NA28 / SBLGNT apparatus for Luke 22:49
- Vulgate, Luke 22:49
- Joseph A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke X–XXIV (Anchor Bible), on 22:35–51
- I. Howard Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC), on 22:49–51
- Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Luke 22
- BDAG s.v. πατάσσω, ἀφαιρέω, δοῦλος, οὖς, ὠτάριον
- Josephus, Antiquities 14.366; Jewish War 1.270 (mutilation of Hyrcanus II's ears)
- Josephus, Antiquities 20.181, 20.206–207 (high priests' slaves seizing tithes)
- Leviticus 21:16–23 (physical defects and priestly service)
- R. E. Brown, The Death of the Messiah, vol. 1 (arrest scene, ear detail)
- J. A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke X–XXIV (Anchor Bible)
- J. B. Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT)
- D. L. Bock, Luke 9:51–24:53 (BECNT)
- Gospel parallels: Mark 14:47; Matthew 26:51–52; John 18:10–11
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).