Mark Chapter 7 Read as one passage
Mark 7:18–19
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
18“Are you still so dull?” He asked. “Do you not understand? Nothing that enters a man from the outside can defile him, 19because it does not enter his heart, but it goes into the stomach and then is eliminated.” (Thus all foods are clean.)
What the first hearers heard
For Jewish hearers of the time, this saying cut into a live debate about how far purity reached into daily life: hands, cups, food, the body. The idea that food could carry impurity into a person was not strange. Leviticus 11 itself warns Israel not to make themselves unclean by eating certain creatures, and the Maccabean martyrs died rather than eat "common" food. So a blanket statement that nothing entering from outside can make a person common would have sounded startling, even scandalous. That is why even the disciples needed it explained.
For Mark's readers, probably a mixed community of Jewish and gentile followers of Jesus a generation later, the verse explained why followers of Jesus did not treat hand-washing (and, in Mark's own reading, food itself, v19) as what determines a person's standing before God. It also warned them. The disciples, the insiders, are shown failing to grasp Jesus' teaching. The tone of the rebuke ("even you?") called readers to the kind of understanding Jesus asked of the crowd in v14: seeing that what makes a person truly unfit before God is what comes out of the heart, a list of moral evils (v21–23), not what passes through the stomach.
From the study of Mark 7:18.
Verse by verse
-
18“Are you still so dull?” He asked. “Do you not understand? Nothing that enters a man from the outside can defile him,
Full study →Back in the house, away from the crowd, the disciples ask Jesus to explain his riddle, and he answers with dismay: "Are even you, my own followers, as lacking in insight as everyone else?" A moment earlier he had told the whole crowd, "Listen to me and understand." Now the inner circle turn out to be un-understanding, unable to put the pieces together, like the outsiders Isaiah described. The question that follows expects them to say yes: "Surely you can see that nothing at all that goes into a person from outside has the power to make them 'common'?" "Common" here is the technical word from the dispute that started all this. The Pharisees had complained that the disciples ate with "common", that is unwashed, hands (v2, v5). To be made "common" meant to be ritually impure, put into a state unfit for contact with what is holy. It did not mean being made sinful. Jesus states flatly that the inward route, food passing in through the mouth, simply cannot produce that state in a person. The next verse explains why: food goes to the stomach and out to the latrine, never to the heart. And the following verses say where real "commonness" comes from: what flows out of the heart. The verse is both a rebuke (you should have grasped this) and a sweeping principle (nothing from outside can do it). How far that principle was meant to reach, whether only to hand-washing and impurity carried by food or to the biblical food laws themselves, is the question the passage leaves its readers with. Mark's own aside in v19 answers it in the broadest way.
-
19because it does not enter his heart, but it goes into the stomach and then is eliminated.” (Thus all foods are clean.)
Full study →"Food can't make you impure, because it never gets into your heart, the inner self where you think, choose and intend. It goes into your belly, passes through your gut, and ends up in the latrine." Then Mark adds his own comment for his readers: in saying this, Jesus was pronouncing every food clean.
The verse works through a pointed play on two words. Food goes in (eisporeuetai) and then goes out (ekporeuetai) into the toilet: in by the mouth, out the other end, and the self is untouched. Verse 20 uses the same verb, 'going out', for what really pollutes a person: what comes out of the heart. The coarse word 'latrine' is intentional. Jesus answers a dispute about purity with blunt bodily realism.
The closing words are a participle, 'cleansing all the foods'. Grammatically they most likely refer back to Jesus as the one speaking, and the verb is the one a priest used when he declared someone clean. So Mark presents Jesus' words as a ruling on the purity status of food. How much 'all foods' covers is debated. It may mean every food without exception, including those forbidden in Leviticus 11. Or it may mean all ordinary food, which does not become impure just because it was eaten with unwashed hands, the issue that began the dispute in verses 1–5.
Where the English drifted
-
in v18
defile
koinoō
- What we hear
- To corrupt morally or sexually; to make someone sinful or dirty in character.
- What they heard
- To make 'common' as opposed to holy: to put a person or thing into a state of ritual impurity, unfit for contact with sacred things. In itself this was a matter of status, not of guilt.
-
in v18
a man / the man
anthrōpos
- What we hear
- An adult male.
- What they heard
- A human being of either sex; any person.
-
in v19
meats (KJV, YLT)
brōmata
- What we hear
- Animal flesh, as opposed to vegetables or bread.
-
in v19
purging (KJV)
katharizōn
- What we hear
- Expelling or emptying out, as in purging the bowels.
- What they heard
- Cleansing or making clean, the verb used for ritual purification and for a priest declaring something clean.
-
in v19
draught (KJV)
aphedrōn
- What we hear
- A current of air, or beer on tap.
- What they heard
- A latrine, privy or cesspit.
-
in v19
heart
kardia
- What we hear
- The seat of feelings and emotions, as opposed to the mind.
- What they heard
- The inner self as a whole, where people think, plan, will and choose. Verse 21 begins its list with 'evil thoughts'.
-
in v19
clean (all foods are clean)
katharizō
- What we hear
- Hygienic or germ-free.
- What they heard
- Ritually pure: fit for contact with holy things and holy people under Israel's purity system. It is a status, not a matter of dirt.
Every word
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v18, v19
Simple narrative link, typical of Mark's fast storytelling style; it connects the disciples' question in the house (v17) to Jesus' reply.
-
λέγει
legei · G3004G
says · v18
Present tense used for a past event ('he says' rather than 'he said'), a storytelling device that makes the scene vivid. Grammatically, this verb is the anchor for the participle 'cleansing' in v19 in the best manuscripts.
-
αὐτοῖς
autois · G0846
to them · v18, v19
The disciples, who had come into the house privately to ask about the 'parable' (v17).
-
οὕτως
houtōs · G3779
so, thus, in this way · v18
Can mean 'so (dull) as this' or 'in the same way': either 'Are you that lacking in insight?' or 'Are you, like them, lacking in insight?' Both carry a tone of disappointed surprise.
-
ὑμεῖς
hymeis · G4771
you (plural) · v18
Emphatic, since Greek does not need the pronoun: 'you, of all people,' the ones who had been given the 'secret of the kingdom' (4:11).
-
ἀσύνετοί
asynetoi · G0801
without understanding, senseless · v18
Lacking the ability to put things together and grasp their meaning. It echoes Jesus' command to the crowd in v14, 'hear me, all of you, and understand (synete)', so the disciples are failing exactly what he had just asked for.
-
ἐστε
este · G1510
you are · v18
Present tense: their present state, not a permanent label. It completes the rebuking question.
-
οὐ
ou · G3756
not · v18, v19
In a question, οὐ expects the answer 'yes': 'Surely you grasp…?' It assumes they ought to see it.
-
νοεῖτε
noeite · G3539
perceive, grasp mentally · v18
To see something with the mind and take it in. Mark pairs it with 'understand' again in 8:17, the climax of the disciples' failure to grasp.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754G
that · v18, v19
Introduces what they should have perceived, a restatement of the riddle from v15.
-
πᾶν
pan · G3956
every, all · v18, v19
Paired with the later 'not', it means 'nothing at all.' The claim is sweeping in form, and how far it reaches is the central question of the passage.
-
τὸ
to · G3588
the · v18, v19
Turns the following phrase into a noun: 'the thing that enters from outside.'
-
ἔξωθεν
exōthen · G1855
from outside · v18
Outside the person's body. This sets up the outside/inside contrast that runs through the passage: outer hands, cups and food (v2–4) versus the inner heart (v19, 21).
-
εἰσπορευόμενον
eisporeuomenon · G1531
going in, entering · v18, v19
Present participle: whatever is going in. In context this means food going in through the mouth, and it is answered in v20 by its mirror word ekporeuomenon, 'what comes out.'
-
εἰς
eis · G1519
into · v18, v19
Movement across the body's boundary from outside to inside.
-
ἄνθρωπον
anthrōpon · G0444
human being, person · v18
A person of either sex, the human being as a whole person. The point concerns what affects the person's standing, not the stomach alone.
-
δύναται
dynatai · G1410
is able, can · v18
A statement about what is possible: what enters from outside does not have the power to make a person 'common.' It denies that this mechanism of defilement works at all.
-
κοινῶσαι
koinōsai · G2840
to make common, defile, render impure · v18
In Jewish Greek, to make someone or something 'common', meaning ritually impure and unfit for contact with what is holy. This is the very word behind the dispute about 'common' (unwashed) hands in v2 and v5.
-
καρδίαν
kardian · G2588
heart · v19
The inner self where a person thinks, decides and forms intentions. It is not mainly the seat of feeling. Verses 21–23 list the 'evil thoughts' that come out of it.
-
ἀλλ᾽
all' · G0235
but · v19
A strong 'not this, but that': not heart, but belly.
-
κοιλίαν
koilian · G2836
belly, stomach, bowels, womb · v19
The body's inner cavity: stomach and intestines together. It is set against the heart as the merely physical inside versus the moral inside.
-
ἀφεδρῶνα
aphedrōna · G0856
latrine, privy, toilet · v19
A blunt, earthy word for the place where waste goes. Jesus makes his point with deliberately crude bodily realism: food ends up in the toilet, not in the soul.
-
ἐκπορεύεται
ekporeuetai · G1607
to go out · v19
'It goes out.' This is the same verb verse 20 uses for what 'comes out of a person' and does defile. The pun is intentional: what goes out of the body is harmless waste, but what goes out of the heart is the real pollution.
-
καθαρίζων
katharizōn · G2511
to cleanse, make or declare clean · v19
A masculine participle, 'cleansing'. It is most likely Mark's own aside to readers: by saying this, Jesus was pronouncing all foods clean. It could also be read as describing digestion 'purging' the food (see debates).
-
βρώματα
brōmata · G1033
food, foods · v19
Food in general, anything eaten, not 'meat' in the sense of animal flesh. Whether a Jewish speaker would count forbidden animals as 'food' at all is part of the debate.
The world behind it
The dispute (Mark 7:1–13). Pharisees and scribes from Jerusalem object that Jesus' disciples eat bread with "common, that is, unwashed" hands. Mark explains to readers unfamiliar with the custom (7:3–4) that "the Pharisees and all the Jews" wash hands, cups, pots and vessels according to "the tradition of the elders." Washing hands before ordinary meals was not commanded in the Torah, the law of Moses. Torah purity rules mainly concerned priests, the temple and its holy food. Many Pharisees, however, sought to eat even ordinary food in a state of purity, extending priestly-style care into daily life. Later rabbinic texts treat hands as easily made impure, able to pass impurity to food, and that food as able to make the eater impure (see e.g. m. Yadayim; m. Zavim 5:12 on eating impure food). Jesus answers by contrasting human tradition with God's command (the Corban example, v9–13).
The riddle (v14–15). Jesus then tells the crowd: "There is nothing outside a person which by going into him can make him common; the things that come out of a person are what make him common." Mark calls this a parabolē (v17), which, like Hebrew mashal, covers riddles and puzzling sayings as well as stories.
The house. In Mark, a private setting "in the house" is where Jesus explains things to insiders (4:10–20; 9:28; 10:10). Mark's readers know the disciples were given "the secret of the kingdom" (4:11), which makes their incomprehension here all the more striking. It belongs to a running thread that peaks in 8:17–21.
Ritual vs. moral impurity. In biblical and Second Temple Judaism, ritual impurity (from corpses, bodily discharges, certain animals, etc.) was not sin. It was a normal, often unavoidable condition, removed by washing and time, and it mattered mainly for approaching the holy. Alongside it the Bible speaks of moral impurity: idolatry, sexual sin and bloodshed "defile" the land and the people (Leviticus 18; Ezekiel 36). Jesus' list in v21–22 is moral impurity. The question of this passage is how the two relate.
From the study of Mark 7:18.
Where scholars differ
in v18
How far does 'nothing from outside can make a person common' reach: the elders' hand-washing tradition, or the biblical food laws as well?
-
Mark presents Jesus as setting aside the distinction between clean and unclean foods (Leviticus 11) altogether.
The sweeping 'every… not' form; Mark's comment in v19 that 'he declared all foods clean' (taking καθαρίζων with 'he says'); Mark's gentile-inclusive setting (7:3–4 explanations, followed by the Syrophoenician woman in 7:24–30); and early Christian debates over food (Acts 10; Romans 14:14, 'nothing is common in itself'). Held by many commentators (e.g. Marcus, Collins, Guelich).
-
The saying originally targeted the Pharisaic idea that impurity passes from hands to food to the body, and did not abolish kosher law. Any wider application is Mark's (or later) interpretation, or the 'cleansing' in v19 refers to digestion.
The dispute is explicitly about 'common' (unwashed) hands and the elders' tradition, not about pork. Matthew 15:20 concludes about unwashed hands. Furstenberg (NTS 2008) argues the saying answers a specific Pharisaic theory that food carries impurity into the body. Crossley and Boyarin read καθαρίζων as describing the bodily process. Acts 10 shows Peter still did not eat unclean food after Jesus' lifetime, which is hard to explain if Jesus had openly abolished the food laws.
in v18
Is the 'not this… but that' contrast (v15, explained in v18–20) absolute or relative?
-
Absolute: external things truly have no power to make a person impure.
The wording 'is not able' (οὐ δύναται) in v18 states impossibility, and v19 gives a physical explanation for why.
-
Relative, a Semitic way of ranking ('not so much what goes in as what comes out').
Hebrew and Aramaic idiom often uses 'not X but Y' to mean 'Y matters more than X' (e.g. Hosea 6:6, 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice'). Some scholars (e.g. J. D. G. Dunn) suggested the original saying worked this way before being sharpened in transmission.
in v18
Whom are the disciples being compared to in 'you too'?
-
The crowd, who were told to 'understand' in v14.
The immediate echo of synete (v14) and asynetoi (v18), and the shift from public riddle to private explanation.
-
The Pharisees and scribes, whose failure to understand Jesus drives v1–13.
Mark elsewhere warns the disciples against the 'leaven of the Pharisees' amid their incomprehension (8:15–21), linking their dullness with that of the opponents.
in v19
Who or what is 'cleansing all the foods'?
-
Jesus. It is Mark's parenthetical comment: 'by saying this, he declared all foods clean.'
The best manuscripts have a masculine nominative participle, which fits 'he' (Jesus) of verse 18 and nothing nearer. The verb is the priestly term for declaring clean (Lev 13; Mark 1:40–44). Mark comments to his readers elsewhere (e.g., 7:3–4; 13:14). This reading goes back to Origen and Chrysostom and is followed by most modern commentators and translations.
-
The digestive process. Elimination 'purges' the food, separating waste from what nourishes.
This is the natural reading of the neuter variant (KJV). Some older interpreters held it, and it keeps the clause inside Jesus' physiological explanation. Weaknesses: it fits the better-attested masculine text badly, and the thought ('the latrine cleanses the food') is odd.
in v19
Does 'all foods' set aside the food laws of Leviticus 11, or only rule out impurity passed through unwashed hands?
-
Mark means every food without exception: Jesus' saying makes the Levitical distinctions between clean and unclean animals irrelevant.
'All' (panta) is placed first for emphasis. Verse 15 states a sweeping principle ('nothing outside'). Mark's audience was partly Gentile and he explains Jewish customs for them. Early churches faced live food disputes (Gal 2; Rom 14). The Matthean parallel omits the clause, which suggests Matthew found it too sweeping. Held by many commentators (e.g., Marcus, France, Collins, Guelich).
-
Mark's comment stays within the dispute over handwashing: all (permitted) food is clean even when eaten with unwashed hands.
The chapter's vocabulary is 'common' (koinos), the language of secondary impurity by contact, rather than Leviticus 11's 'unclean' (akathartos). The opening issue is handwashing and the 'tradition of the elders', set against 'the commandment of God' (7:8–13), so it would be strange for Jesus to cancel a commandment of God in the same breath. To a Torah-observant Jew, forbidden animals were arguably not 'food' (brōmata) at all. Peter's protest in Acts 10:14 suggests no such ruling was known. Argued by scholars such as J. G. Crossley, Y. Furstenberg, D. Boyarin and M. Thiessen.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. κοινόω, κοινός
- BDAG s.v. ἀσύνετος
- BDAG s.v. νοέω
- Septuagint: 1 Maccabees 1:47, 62; 4 Maccabees 7:6; Psalm 91:7 LXX; Deuteronomy 32:21 LXX
- Mishnah Yadayim; m. Zavim 5:12
- Joel Marcus, Mark 1–8 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- Adela Yarbro Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
- Yair Furstenberg, 'Defilement Penetrating the Body: A New Understanding of Contamination in Mark 7.15', New Testament Studies 54 (2008)
- Jonathan Klawans, Impurity and Sin in Ancient Judaism (2000)
- James G. Crossley, The Date of Mark's Gospel (2004)
- Daniel Boyarin, The Jewish Gospels (2012)
- Roger P. Booth, Jesus and the Laws of Purity (1986)
- J. D. G. Dunn, 'Jesus and Purity: An Ongoing Debate', New Testament Studies 48 (2002)
- Vulgate, Mark 7:15, 18
- BDAG s.v. καθαρίζω, βρῶμα, ἀφεδρών, κοιλία, καρδία
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ἀφεδρών
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Mark 7:19
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Mark 7:19
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC)
- Robert A. Guelich, Mark 1–8:26 (WBC)
- Yair Furstenberg, 'Defilement Penetrating the Body: A New Understanding of Contamination in Mark 7.15', NTS 54 (2008)
- James G. Crossley, The Date of Mark's Gospel
- Daniel Boyarin, The Jewish Gospels, ch. 3
- Matthew Thiessen, Jesus and the Forces of Death
- Septuagint, Leviticus 11 and 13; 1 Maccabees 1:47, 62
- Mishnah, tractate Yadayim
- Vulgate, Mark 7:19
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).