Matthew Chapter 15 Read as one passage

Matthew 15:13–14

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

13But Jesus replied, “Every plant that My heavenly Father has not planted will be pulled up by its roots. 14Disregard them! They are blind guides. If a blind man leads a blind man, both will fall into a pit.”

What the first hearers heard

For Jesus' disciples, and for Matthew's largely Jewish-Christian community, the saying did three things.

  • It settled whose authority counts. The Pharisees were the most respected teachers of the day. By Matthew's time, after the fall of the Temple in 70, they were shaping the synagogue world his church lived alongside. Jesus says that standing, lineage and popularity do not make a planting God's. Only the Father's planting lasts, and Jesus, as the Son, speaks for what the Father planted.
  • It turned a familiar claim upside down. Groups who prized holiness spoke of themselves as God's planting that would never be uprooted. Jesus uses the same language to say that a tradition which overrides God's command (vv.3–9) is a human planting under sentence.
  • It took a burden off the disciples. The passive "will be uprooted," followed by "leave them" (v.14), echoes the weeds parable, where servants must not uproot before harvest. The disciples were not to placate the offended leaders, nor to fight them. Judgment belongs to God. Their task was to stop following blind guides.

From the study of Matthew 15:13.

Verse by verse

  1. 13But Jesus replied, “Every plant that My heavenly Father has not planted will be pulled up by its roots.

    The disciples have just warned Jesus that the Pharisees were deeply offended by what he said about handwashing and defilement. He answers with a short, proverb-like ruling: "Every planting that my Father, the one in heaven, did not plant will be torn out by the roots."

    The picture is a cultivated garden or vineyard owned by God. In Jesus' world, "God's planting" was a well-known name for Israel, and especially for the faithful, righteous core of Israel. Devout groups used it of themselves, confident that God's planting would "never be uprooted." Jesus takes that proud self-image and applies a single test: who put this in the ground? Whatever grew from merely human tradition, the "commandments of men" he has just condemned, was not set there by the Father. That covers the Pharisees' teaching, and the Pharisees themselves as guides of the people. However established it looks, it has no lasting place in God's garden.

    "Will be uprooted" is future and passive. God himself will do it, completely, roots and all, when he judges. It is not a task for the disciples, which is why Jesus goes straight on: "Leave them. They are blind guides." The Pharisees' offence does not need managing. Their future is in the Father's hands.

    Full study →
  2. 14Disregard them! They are blind guides. If a blind man leads a blind man, both will fall into a pit.”

    "Let them go. Don't worry about their offense. They are blind, and yet they are the ones walking blind people along the road. And whenever a blind man takes another blind man by the hand to lead him, the two of them will end up down in the pit together."

    The disciples have just told Jesus that the Pharisees were scandalised by his saying that what goes into the mouth does not defile a person (vv.11-12). Jesus does not soften it. First (v.13) he says that any 'plant' his Father did not plant will be pulled up by the roots. Then (v.14) he tells the disciples to leave them be, using the same command he gave in the parable of the weeds ('let both grow until the harvest'). The disciples do not have to uproot them or win them over. God will deal with them.

    The word for 'guide' is literally a 'way-leader', the person who walks a traveller safely along a road. The Pharisees really did see themselves this way: teachers of how to 'walk' in God's law, guiding ordinary people who did not know it well. Paul uses this very phrase, 'a guide of the blind', for the confident Torah teacher (Rom 2:19). Jesus grants that they guide people but says they cannot see. The repeated word 'blind... blind... blind... blind' piles up like a chant. It also echoes the Isaiah passage Jesus has just quoted, where God's people are blinded because their worship is human rules (Isa 29:9-13).

    The proverb's sting is in 'both'. The guide does not walk away safely while the followers fall. Leader and led tumble into the same open pit, a real danger on ancient roads and a familiar biblical picture of ruin. The future 'will fall' states it as certain.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v13

    plant

    phuteia

    What we hear
    A generic garden metaphor, or a single individual: any one thing that is 'not of God'.
    What they heard
    A deliberately set 'planting', and a recognised title for God's true people (Isa 60:21; 61:3; Qumran's 'eternal planting'; Psalms of Solomon 14:3–4). Hearers would have caught that Jesus was denying a claim to that title made by, or on behalf of, the Pharisees and their tradition.
  • in v14

    the ditch (KJV)

    bothunos

    What we hear
    A shallow drainage channel beside a road: you might get muddy.
    What they heard
    A pit, cistern or hole in the ground that you could be badly hurt or trapped in. It is the same word as the pit a sheep falls into in Matt 12:11, and an Old Testament picture of ruin.
  • in v14

    blind leaders (KJV)

    hodēgoi

    What we hear
    People in positions of authority or leadership.
    What they heard
    Guides who know the road and walk others along it: a teaching role, not a rank.
Every word
  1. Ὁ

    Ho · G3588

    the; he · v13

    Here the article works as a pronoun, 'he', picking up Jesus as the new speaker after the disciples' question in v.12.

  2. δὲ

    de · G1161

    but, and · v13, v14

    A light connective that marks the switch of speaker. It sets Jesus' reply against the disciples' worry, 'but he'.

  3. ἀποκριθεὶς

    apokritheis · G0611

    to answer, respond · v13

    'Having answered'. Together with 'said' it copies a Hebrew way of opening speech ('he answered and said'). It answers the disciples' question directly: yes, he knows the Pharisees are offended.

  4. εἶπεν

    eipen · G2036

    to say · v13

    'He said'. This introduces a short, proverb-like pronouncement.

  5. πᾶσα

    pasa · G3956

    every, all · v13

    'Every'. The saying is put as a general rule with no exceptions, but it is aimed at the case in front of it, the Pharisees and their teaching.

  6. φυτεία

    phuteia · G5451

    plant, planting · v13

    'Planting': something deliberately set in the ground by a planter, not a wild plant. Jewish writings of the time often called Israel or the faithful remnant 'God's planting', so the word carried a lot of weight.

  7. ἣν

    hēn · G3739

    which, that · v13

    'Which'. It is the object of 'planted', so the clause asks who put this planting in the ground.

  8. οὐκ

    ouk · G3756

    not · v13

    A flat factual negative: the Father did not plant it. Everything turns on this word.

  9. ἐφύτευσεν

    ephuteusen · G5452

    to plant · v13

    'Planted', a simple past (aorist) tense looking back at the act of planting. It echoes the noun just before it ('a planting he did not plant'), and the repeated sound underlines the question of origin.

  10. πατήρ

    patēr · G3962

    father · v13

    'Father'. God is the owner and planter of the garden, the one whose decision settles what belongs in it.

  11. μου

    mou · G3165

    my · v13

    'My'. Jesus speaks as the Son who knows the Father's mind, which is why he can tell what the Father did and did not plant.

  12. οὐράνιος

    ouranios · G3770

    heavenly · v13

    'Heavenly'. This is one of Matthew's favourite ways to name God ('my/your heavenly Father'). It sets the Father's planting against human tradition, which Jesus has just called 'commandments of men' (v.9).

  13. ἐκριζωθήσεται

    ekrizōthēsetai · G1610

    to uproot · v13

    'Will be uprooted': pulled out root and all, so nothing grows back. The future passive leaves God as the unnamed one who acts, and it is a promise of coming judgment, not a job for the disciples. Hence the next words, 'leave them' (v.14).

  14. ἄφετε

    aphete · G0863

    let go, leave, permit, forgive · v14

    'Leave them be', 'let them go their way.' A single decisive command (aorist imperative) to the disciples, who have just worried that the Pharisees were offended (v.12): stop worrying about it and don't try to win them back on this point. It has nothing to do with forgiveness here.

  15. αὐτούς

    autous · G0846

    them · v14

    The Pharisees (and the scribes from Jerusalem, v.1) who took offense at Jesus' teaching on what defiles.

  16. τυφλοί

    tuphloi · G5185

    blind · v14

    Placed first for emphasis: 'Blind is what they are.' Used figuratively for being unable to see what God is actually asking, while claiming to see clearly.

  17. εἰσιν

    eisin · G1510

    they are · v14

    Present tense: a statement of what they are now, not a prediction.

  18. ὁδηγοί

    hodēgoi · G3595

    guide, one who leads the way · v14

    Literally a 'way-leader', someone who walks a traveller along a road. It points to the Pharisees' role as teachers who showed people how to 'walk' in God's law.

  19. ἐὰν

    ean · G1437

    if, whenever · v14

    With the subjunctive it states a general rule: whenever this happens, this follows.

  20. ὁδηγῇ

    hodēgē · G3594

    to guide, lead along the way · v14

    The verb form of 'guide'. The present tense pictures guiding as an ongoing act: walking someone along step by step.

  21. ἀμφότεροι

    amphoteroi · G0297

    both · v14

    The sting of the saying: the guide does not escape. Leader and led share the same fate.

  22. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into · v14

    Movement into: they fall down into it, not just stumble at the edge.

  23. βόθυνον

    bothunon · G0999

    pit, hole in the ground · v14

    An open pit: a cistern, quarry hole or trench along the road, the same word as the pit a sheep falls into in Matt 12:11. In Scripture 'the pit' is also a picture of ruin.

  24. πεσοῦνται

    pesountai · G4098

    they will fall · v14

    A plain future: not 'might fall' but 'will fall'. The outcome is certain.

The world behind it

The quarrel behind the verse. In Matt 15:1–11, Pharisees and scribes from Jerusalem object that Jesus' disciples do not wash their hands before eating, as the "tradition of the elders" required. These were the oral rules the Pharisees saw as a protective fence around the Law. Jesus turns the charge back on them: their tradition lets them dodge the command to honour father and mother (vv.3–6). He quotes Isaiah 29:13 about worship built on "commandments of men," then tells the crowd that what defiles a person comes out of the mouth, not what goes in (v.11). The disciples report that the Pharisees were "offended", literally "caused to stumble" (v.12). Verses 12–14 appear only in Matthew. Mark's parallel (Mark 7) has no such saying.

"God's planting" as a badge of identity. Jews of Jesus' day knew the prophets' picture of Israel as the garden or vineyard God planted (Isa 5; 60:21; 61:3; Jer 2:21; Ps 80). Several Second Temple groups claimed to be that true planting. The Qumran community called itself an "eternal planting" (1QS 8:5). 1 Enoch and Jubilees speak of the "plant of righteousness." The Psalms of Solomon, which many scholars (though not all) link to circles close to the Pharisees, promise that the planting of the Lord's devout "will not be plucked up all the days of heaven" (14:3–4). To call a respected religious party a planting the Father did not plant, one bound for uprooting, was a sharp reversal of exactly this kind of claim.

Uprooting as judgment. Since Jeremiah (1:10; 24:6; 45:4), "plant" and "uproot" had been a pair of words for God building up and tearing down nations and people. Matthew's own Gospel has already pictured the end-time harvest in which weeds sown by the enemy are gathered and burned. The servants were explicitly told not to uproot them early (13:24–30, 36–43). Matthew's first readers would have heard v.13 against that parable.

From the study of Matthew 15:13.

Where scholars differ

in v13

What is the 'planting' that will be uprooted: the Pharisees themselves, or their teaching and tradition?

  • The Pharisees as a group, the leaders of the people

    The next verse says 'Leave them; they are blind guides', with persons as the subject. Old Testament and Second Temple 'planting' imagery is about people (Isa 60:21; 61:3; 1QS 8:5; Pss. Song of Songs 14:3–4). In the weeds parable the weeds are 'the sons of the evil one' (13:38). Many commentators, such as Davies & Allison, Hagner and France, take this as primary.

  • Their teaching, the 'tradition of the elders' or 'commandments of men'

    The quarrel in vv.1–11 is about tradition. The Pharisees were offended by a 'word' (v.12). Matt 16:12 later calls the 'leaven of the Pharisees' their teaching.

  • Both together: the teachers and the system they planted

    Matthew does not separate teachers from teaching (cf. 23:2–4, 13–15). Ignatius applies the saying to false teachers and their doctrine at once. Most recent commentators allow both senses.

in v13

When does the uprooting happen?

  • At the final judgment

    Future passive with God as the actor. The link to the harvest uprooting in 13:29–30, 40–43. Matthew's strong interest in the end-time judgment.

  • Also in history, including the loss of the leaders' authority and the events of 70 CE

    In Jeremiah, plant/uproot language covers God's acts in history. Matthew elsewhere links the leaders' rejection of Jesus with judgment on 'this generation' and the Temple (21:43; 23:36–38).

in v14

What does 'leave them' mean here?

  • Don't be troubled by their offense. Don't try to smooth it over or argue them round on this point.

    It answers the disciples' worry in v.12 directly. Jesus goes on engaging Pharisees afterwards (16:1-12; 19:3-9; 22-23), so it cannot be a permanent ban on contact.

  • Leave them to God's judgment: don't uproot them yourselves.

    It follows v.13's 'will be uprooted' and uses the same command form as 13:30 ('let both grow together until the harvest'), where judgment is left to God.

in v14

Is the 'pit' ordinary ruin or final judgment?

  • Mainly a proverb about the obvious result of bad guidance: shared disaster.

    Proverbial use in Luke 6:39 and Greek and Latin literature. The everyday image of a pit by the road.

  • It has the overtones of God's judgment.

    Next to v.13's uprooting; the LXX uses βόθυνος for falling into judgment (Isa 24:18; Jer 48:44); Matthew 23 threatens judgment on the 'blind guides'.

in v14

Who are the 'blind' being led?

  • The crowds and ordinary Israelites who follow Pharisaic teaching.

    Jesus has just called the crowd (v.10). Josephus describes the Pharisees' influence over the people.

  • Specifically the Pharisees' own disciples and followers.

    'Guides of the blind' names those who already accept their guidance. Compare 23:15 on converts.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).