Matthew Chapter 2 Read as one passage

Matthew 2:17–18

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

17Then what was spoken through the prophet Jeremiah was fulfilled: 18“A voice is heard in Ramah, weeping and great mourning, Rachel weeping for her children and refusing to be comforted, because they are no more.”

What the first hearers heard

Matthew wrote for a community steeped in Israel's scriptures, most likely Jewish followers of Jesus in the decades after Jerusalem's destruction in AD 70. To them this verse said several things:

  • Jesus relives Israel's story. Israel had gone through Egypt (2:15) and exile (2:17–18), and now the Messiah passes through both. The grief of Rachel's children is not a random tragedy. It belongs to the national story that Jesus takes on.
  • Grief before restoration. Anyone who knew Jeremiah 31 knew that the next lines say "Keep your voice from weeping… your children shall come back" (31:16–17), and that the chapter promises a new covenant (31:31–34). Quoting the lament brings the promise along with it: the exile is about to end.
  • God is not the author of the massacre. By writing "then was fulfilled" instead of "so that it might be fulfilled," Matthew presents the killing as Herod's evil, which scripture mourns, and not as God's plan.
  • Opposition to the true king. A paranoid ruler kills children in an attempt to destroy God's chosen one. That anticipates the hostility of rulers to Jesus later in the Gospel, which ends in the only other "then was fulfilled… Jeremiah" formula (27:9).

From the study of Matthew 2:17.

Verse by verse

  1. 17Then what was spoken through the prophet Jeremiah was fulfilled:

    "At that moment, the word God had spoken through the prophet Jeremiah was filled to its full measure. Jeremiah had said:"

    This verse is a hinge. It comes straight after Herod's slaughter of Bethlehem's little boys (2:16) and opens the quotation of Jeremiah 31:15, Rachel weeping in Ramah (2:18). Three things are packed into it:

    • "Was fulfilled" means "was filled full." Jeremiah's lament first described mothers grieving as their children were taken into exile in Babylon. Matthew's claim is that this old grief reached its fullest instance in Bethlehem. It is not simply that a forecast came true. Israel's long story of suffering under hostile kings came to a head around the infant Messiah.
    • "Then," not "in order that." Everywhere else in these early chapters Matthew writes "this happened so that what was spoken might be fulfilled." Here, and again with Judas's blood money (27:9), he writes "then was fulfilled." The massacre is not presented as something God arranged to make scripture come true. It is Herod's crime, and the lament of the scriptures fits it.
    • "Through Jeremiah the prophet." Jeremiah is the channel and God is the source, though Matthew does not name God here as he did in 1:22 and 2:15. Jeremiah's name brings the exile with it, and the same chapter of Jeremiah moves from weeping to the promise that "your children shall come back" (Jer 31:16–17).

    The verse frames the horror of verse 16 as Israel's old sorrow returning, with the old hope of return close behind it.

    Full study →
  2. 18“A voice is heard in Ramah, weeping and great mourning, Rachel weeping for her children and refusing to be comforted, because they are no more.”

    A sound is heard: a cry carrying from Ramah, the hill-town where Israel's captives were once chained together for the march to Babylon. It is loud weeping and wailing, with no end to it. It is Rachel, Israel's mother, dead and buried by the Bethlehem road for centuries, bewailing her own children. She keeps refusing every attempt to console her, because her children are gone, and the bare words "they are not" are all that can be said.

    Matthew does not tell the slaughter of Bethlehem's boys in gory detail. He lets Jeremiah's words do the mourning. In Jeremiah, the weeping was over sons lost to exile. Matthew hears it again in Bethlehem: Israel's story of loss is repeating around the cradle of the Messiah. Several echoes come with the words. "Refusing to be comforted" recalls Jacob refusing comfort over Joseph, Rachel's son. "They are not" recalls Jacob's "Joseph is not." Ramah calls up the exile. And anyone who knew Jeremiah knew that God's answer comes in the very next lines: "Keep your voice from weeping… your children shall come back" (Jer 31:16–17). The verse itself, though, stays with the grief and does not hurry past it.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v17

    was fulfilled

    eplērōthē (plēroō)

    What we hear
    A specific prediction Jeremiah made about the future has now come true.
    What they heard
    'Was filled full': an earlier word or pattern reached its complete, climactic expression. Jeremiah 31:15 described grief over the Babylonian exile. Matthew says that grief found its fullest instance in Bethlehem.
  • in v17

    the prophet

    prophētēs

    What we hear
    A foreteller whose main job was predicting future events.
    What they heard
    A spokesman for God. Jeremiah mainly addressed Judah in his own crisis, the Babylonian conquest, and grieved over it. 'The prophet' also marks a citation from Israel's scriptures.
Every word
  1. Τότε

    Tote · G5119

    then, at that time · v17

    Ties the fulfilment to the moment of the massacre in verse 16, which also opens with 'Then'. It replaces the 'in order that' Matthew normally uses in these formulas (1:22; 2:15), so it says when the word was fulfilled without saying the event happened for that purpose.

  2. ἐπληρώθη

    eplērōthē · G4137

    to fill, fill up, complete, fulfil · v17

    A passive, one-time action: 'was filled full.' The old words of Jeremiah reached their full measure in this event. It means more than 'a forecast came true'. A pattern in Israel's story found its fullest instance.

  3. τὸ

    to · G3588

    the · v17, v18

    A neuter article that turns the following participle into a noun: 'the thing spoken,' that is, the saying.

  4. ῥηθὲν

    rhēthen · G2046

    to say, speak · v17

    'Having been spoken,' a past passive participle. The saying already existed and is on record. In 1:22 and 2:15 Matthew names the Lord as the one who spoke it. Here he leaves the speaker unnamed.

  5. διὰ

    dia · G1223

    through, by means of · v17

    With the genitive it marks the channel, not the source. Jeremiah is the mouthpiece through whom the word came, and the passive verb assumes God behind it.

  6. Ἰερεμίου

    Ieremiou · G2408

    Jeremiah · v17

    The Greek form of Hebrew Yirmeyahu. This is the first of only two places where Matthew names Jeremiah in a fulfilment formula. The other is 27:9, the price of betrayal and the potter's field. Both introduce grim events.

  7. προφήτου

    prophētou · G4396

    prophet, spokesman for God · v17

    Names Jeremiah's role as God's spokesman. To Matthew's readers, 'the prophets' were also a body of scripture, so this marks a quotation from Israel's sacred writings.

  8. λέγοντος·

    legontos · G3004

    saying · v17

    A present participle in the genitive that agrees with 'the prophet': it is Jeremiah who is 'saying.' It works like a colon and introduces the quotation in verse 18 (Jer 31:15).

  9. φωνὴ

    phōnē · G5456

    voice, sound, cry · v18

    Not a word spoken but a sound: a cry of grief carrying across the countryside. It opens the verse with no speaker named, so you hear the wailing before you learn whose it is.

  10. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in, at · v18

    Places the cry in a particular town.

  11. Ῥαμὰ

    Rhama · G4471

    Ramah · v18

    A town of the tribe of Benjamin about 8 km (5 miles) north of Jerusalem. Its name means 'height'. In Jeremiah it is where the captives were gathered before being marched off to Babylon (Jer 40:1). Naming it brings the exile to mind.

  12. ἠκούσθη,

    ēkousthē · G0191

    to hear · v18

    Passive past tense, 'was heard'. The sound went out and people heard it. Matthew puts it in the past, as an event that has now happened again in Bethlehem.

  13. κλαυθμὸς

    klauthmos · G2805

    weeping, loud crying · v18

    Weeping that can be heard aloud, not quiet tears. It describes what the 'voice' consists of. Matthew uses the same word later in 'weeping and gnashing of teeth' (8:12; 13:42).

  14. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v18

    Joins the two words for grief so that they pile up.

  15. ὀδυρμὸς

    odyrmos · G3602

    wailing, lamentation, mourning · v18

    Grief voiced aloud as wailing and lament. It is rare in the New Testament, found only here and in 2 Corinthians 7:7.

  16. πολύς,

    polys · G4183

    much, great, loud · v18

    'Great', 'much'. It shows how intense the wailing is, and probably also how loud. It stands where the Hebrew has 'bitter' (tamrurim).

  17. Ῥαχὴλ

    Rhachēl · G4478

    Rachel · v18

    Jacob's beloved wife, mother of Joseph and Benjamin, who died in childbirth on the road near Bethlehem (Gen 35:16–19). Here she stands for Israel as a mother, grieving centuries after her death.

  18. κλαίουσα

    klaiousa · G2799

    to weep, wail, bewail · v18

    A present participle, which shows ongoing action: she is caught in the middle of weeping. With a direct object, as here, κλαίω means to 'bewail' someone, to mourn them as dead.

  19. τέκνα

    tekna · G5043

    children, offspring · v18

    'Children', a warm family word for those one has given birth to. The Septuagint (the ancient Greek translation of the Old Testament) has huioi, 'sons', here. Matthew's softer word fits the infants of Bethlehem.

  20. αὐτῆς,

    autēs · G0846

    her · v18

    'Her own' children. It makes the loss a mother's personal loss.

  21. οὐκ

    ouk · G3756

    not · v18

    Negates 'was willing'.

  22. ἤθελεν

    ēthelen · G2309

    to want, be willing · v18

    This past tense describes continuing action: 'she would not', 'she kept refusing'. Her refusal is a settled state that goes on and on, not one moment of saying no.

  23. παρακληθῆναι

    paraklēthēnai · G3870

    to comfort, console; to urge, appeal · v18

    'To be comforted', meaning to receive the consolation that friends and family offered to someone in mourning. She will not accept it. Matthew's verb follows the Hebrew 'to be comforted' (lehinnaḥem), not the Septuagint's 'to stop' (pausasthai).

  24. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    because · v18

    Gives the reason she cannot be consoled.

  25. εἰσίν.

    eisin · G1510

    to be, exist · v18

    'They are not': a stark biblical way of saying 'they are dead and gone'. It echoes Jacob's grief over Rachel's own son, 'Joseph is not' (Gen 42:36).

The world behind it

Matthew's "fulfilment formulas." About ten times Matthew pauses the story to say an event "fulfilled" what a prophet said (1:22; 2:15, 17, 23; 4:14; 8:17; 12:17; 13:35; 21:4; 27:9). Chapter 2 has four of them in a row, and each ties a place or event in Jesus' infancy to Israel's history: Bethlehem, Egypt, Ramah and Nazareth.

A new Pharaoh. Jewish readers would have recognised the shape of the story. A king feels threatened by a promised child and orders the killing of the boys, but the child escapes. That is the Exodus story (Exod 1:15–22; 2:1–10). Josephus even tells a version in which Pharaoh is warned by a scribe about a coming deliverer (Antiquities 2.205–209). Herod plays Pharaoh, and Jesus relives Israel's story.

Herod. Herod the Great (ruled 37–4 BC) had his own wife Mariamne and three of his sons executed. According to Josephus (Antiquities 17.174–179), he ordered leading men to be killed at his death so that there would be mourning. No other source records the Bethlehem killings. Bethlehem was a small village, so scholars estimate a small number of infant boys, perhaps a dozen or two. That would be a horror to the village but a minor event by Herod's standards.

Jeremiah, Ramah and Rachel. Jeremiah 40:1 says the Babylonians held the captives in chains at Ramah, north of Jerusalem, before deporting them. Rachel, the mother of Joseph and Benjamin and the ancestress of the northern tribes, is pictured weeping over her descendants. One tradition places her tomb on the road to Bethlehem (Gen 35:19; 48:7), which links her grief to Bethlehem's mothers. Naming Jeremiah also evokes the setting of Jeremiah 31: chapters 30–33, sometimes called the "Book of Consolation," where weeping gives way to return and a new covenant.

From the study of Matthew 2:17.

Where scholars differ

in v17

Why does Matthew write 'then was fulfilled' here instead of his usual 'in order that it might be fulfilled'?

  • A deliberate theological choice. Matthew avoids saying that an evil act happened for God's purpose of fulfilling scripture.

    The 'then' form appears only here and at 27:9, and both are wicked human deeds: the infant massacre and Judas's betrayal money. Elsewhere Matthew consistently uses 'in order that.' Here he also drops 'by the Lord,' which he included in 1:22 and 2:15. This view is widely held among major commentators (e.g., Davies & Allison, France, Luz).

  • Mainly stylistic variation, with little theological weight.

    Matthew varies his formulas elsewhere too. The passive 'was fulfilled' still implies that God's word governs history. The 'then' also ties neatly to the 'then' that opens 2:16. The sample of two cases is small.

in v17

In what sense was Jeremiah 31:15 'fulfilled'?

  • Pattern or typological fulfilment: Israel's exile grief reaches its climactic instance in Bethlehem, with the restoration promise of Jer 31:16–34 in view.

    In context, Jeremiah 31:15 is plainly about the exile (Ramah as the deportation camp, Jer 40:1). *Plēroō* covers 'fill up, complete.' Matthew 2 as a whole reads Jesus as reliving Israel's history (Egypt, 2:15, citing Hosea 11:1, which in Hosea looks back on the Exodus). Most modern commentators hold this view.

  • A direct predictive prophecy, or a prophecy with a double reference: the exile first, then the massacre.

    'Fulfilled' in ordinary usage implies prediction. Some interpreters hold that a prophet's words can carry a fuller divinely intended sense than he knew. This view is held especially in traditional conservative exegesis.

in v18

Does Matthew mean readers to hear the hope in the rest of Jeremiah 31?

  • Yes. The quotation points to its whole context: Rachel's grief is answered by the promise of return (31:16–17) and the new covenant (31:31–34).

    Matthew often quotes one line to call up a whole passage, and Jeremiah 31:16 begins straight away with 'Keep your voice from weeping'. The next scene (2:19–21) brings Jesus back 'into the land of Israel'. Matthew's frame of exile (1:11–17) and his later use of covenant language (26:28) fit too. This view is held by R. T. France, D. A. Carson and Richard Hays, among others.

  • The main point is lament and connection: Rachel, Bethlehem and the grief of exile. A message of hope is not clearly intended in this verse.

    The quoted lines end in grief that refuses comfort. The formula 'then was fulfilled' (no 'in order that') marks a tragedy rather than a hopeful plan. Matthew's link to the text may rest mainly on Rachel's tomb near Bethlehem and the theme of mothers losing children. Davies & Allison, for example, stress the lament while allowing the wider context some role.

in v18

Did the massacre at Bethlehem happen?

  • It is historically plausible, though no other source confirms it.

    It fits Herod's documented character: he killed his own sons and, according to Josephus (*Ant.* 17.174–179), ordered leading men executed at his death so that there would be mourning. Bethlehem was so small that a handful of infant deaths would hardly be recorded by historians focused on Jerusalem and the royal court.

  • It is a story told to shape Jesus as a new Moses, not a recorded event.

    Josephus, who details Herod's crimes, does not mention it. The story closely follows Pharaoh's killing of Hebrew boys and Jewish retellings of Moses' birth. Matthew 1–2 is built around Old Testament fulfilments.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. πληρόω
  • BDAG s.v. διά
  • Septuagint, 2 Chronicles 36:21; 3 Kingdoms 2:27
  • Jeremiah 31:15–34; 40:1
  • Josephus, Antiquities 2.205–209; 17.174–179
  • 1QpHab (Qumran Habakkuk Commentary) col. 7
  • W.D. Davies & D.C. Allison, Matthew 1–7 (ICC)
  • R.T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT, 2007)
  • U. Luz, Matthew 1–7 (Hermeneia)
  • C.S. Keener, The IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament
  • Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed. (NA28) at Matt 2:18
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Jeremiah 38:15
  • Masoretic Text, Jeremiah 31:15
  • BDAG s.v. ὀδυρμός, κλαίω, παρακαλέω, κλαυθμός
  • Thayer s.v. Ῥαμᾶ, Ῥαχήλ
  • B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Matt 2:18
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT)
  • W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 1
  • D. A. Carson, 'Matthew' in Expositor's Bible Commentary
  • C. S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 2:16–18
  • Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 2.205–216; 15–17 (esp. 17.174–179)
  • Genesis Rabbah 82:10; Lamentations Rabbah, proem 24
  • Targum Jonathan to Jeremiah 31:15
  • Vulgate, Matt 2:18 and Jer 31:15

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).