Numbers Chapter 11 Read as one passage
Numbers 11:4–5
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
4Meanwhile, the rabble among them had a strong craving for other food, and again the Israelites wept and said, “Who will feed us meat? 5We remember the fish we ate freely in Egypt, along with the cucumbers, melons, leeks, onions, and garlic.
What the first hearers heard
For Israel hearing this, the verse was a story about who they had been, and a warning to them as a people.
- How the trouble spreads. The complaint starts on the fringe, with the "gathered rabble", but "even the sons of Israel" take it up. The story does not let Israel push the blame onto outsiders. God's anger in v. 10 and the plague in v. 33 fall on the people as a whole.
- Turning down what God gives. Craving more than the daily manna is presented as rejecting the God present among them (v. 20, "you have rejected the LORD who is among you"). It also means looking back fondly at slavery. The story is less about tastes in food than about whether the freed people will trust the one who feeds them.
- A name to remember. The word taʾăwâ survives in the place-name Kibroth-hattaavah, "Graves of the Craving" (v. 34). Every retelling (Ps 78:18–31; Ps 106:14–15, "he gave them what they asked, but sent a wasting disease among them") made the episode a lesson that getting what you crave can ruin you.
- The leadership crisis. The cry "Who will feed us?" pushes Moses close to breaking (vv. 11–15), and it leads to the Spirit being shared among seventy elders (vv. 16–17, 24–30). So the verse also opens a story about how God's people are led and supplied.
From the study of Numbers 11:4.
Verse by verse
-
4Meanwhile, the rabble among them had a strong craving for other food, and again the Israelites wept and said, “Who will feed us meat?
Full study →"The scraped-together crowd living inside the camp gave themselves over to appetite, a craving that took hold of them. Then the weeping started again, and this time the sons of Israel themselves joined in, wailing like mourners: 'If only someone would feed us meat! Who is going to give us meat to eat?'"
The verse moves in a clear direction. It starts with a scornful, one-off name for people on the edge of the community: ʾasapsup, "the gathered-up lot", the hangers-on. It ends with Israel itself taking up their complaint. "Also, even, the sons of Israel" shows the mood spreading inward. Their desire is not mild. Hebrew doubles the root, "they craved a craving", to mean an appetite that has taken control. "Again" points back to earlier complaining (v. 1; compare Exod 16:3), and the literal sense "turned back" fits a people whose memories are already back in Egypt with its free fish, cucumbers, melons, leeks, onions and garlic (v. 5).
Their cry, "Who will feed us meat?", is a wish in standard Hebrew form ("O that someone would…!"). It also carries a jab: it ignores the God who is feeding them manna every morning, as though no one capable were there to provide. Meat was feast food, the kind eaten at festivals and sacrifices. So the request is for a rich man's table in the desert. The words "crave" and "meat" set up the rest of the story: God sends meat until they are sick of it, and the place is named Kibroth-hattaavah, "Graves of the Craving" (vv. 18–20, 31–34).
-
5We remember the fish we ate freely in Egypt, along with the cucumbers, melons, leeks, onions, and garlic.
Full study →"We remember it all: the fish we used to eat in Egypt, meal after meal, and never paid a thing for. Those cucumbers, those melons, the leeks, the onions, the garlic!"
In Hebrew the list moves slowly. Every item gets "the" and a marker of its own, so the speakers seem to taste each one as they say it: the fish, the cucumbers, the melons, the leeks, the onions, the garlic. It is a menu from the Nile valley. There is cheap river fish, the standard protein of Egyptian laborers. There are cool, watery gourds and melons from irrigated fields. There are the sharp leeks, onions and garlic that flavored a worker's bread. Set against the next verse ("our throat is dried up; there is nothing but this manna to look at"), the list is all about moisture and strong flavor, the very things that plain, dry manna did not have.
Two words carry the irony. "Remember" is the verb Israel is told to use for its slavery ("remember that you were a slave in Egypt"). Here it holds on to the food and lets the slavery drop out. "For nothing" (ḥinnām) means at no cost, gratis. It is true in a bitter way: slaves pay nothing for their rations because they own nothing, their own work included. The people remember Egypt as the place where food was free and forget that they were not.
Where the English drifted
-
in v4
fell a lusting / lusted exceedingly (KJV, WEB)
hitʾawwû taʾăwâ
- What we hear
- Sexual desire.
- What they heard
- A strong appetite for food, here a craving for meat and the foods of Egypt. The doubled wording makes it intense and out of control. Nothing sexual is meant.
-
in v4
flesh (KJV, YLT)
bāśār
- What we hear
- Readers who know Paul's 'flesh vs. Spirit' may hear 'the sinful nature'.
- What they heard
- Meat to eat, especially the feast meat of animals.
-
in v5
freely (KJV, BSB: "ate freely")
ḥinnām
- What we hear
- As much as we wanted; without limits or rationing.
- What they heard
- Without payment, at no cost, gratis. The point is the price (nothing), not the quantity.
-
in v5
cucumbers
qishshuʾîm
- What we hear
- The smooth green salad cucumber (Cucumis sativus) from the supermarket.
- What they heard
- Probably the snake melon or chate melon (varieties of Cucumis melo): long, ribbed, cucumber-like gourds eaten unripe, grown widely in the ancient Near East. The true cucumber may not have reached the region until later.
Every word
-
וְהָֽאסַפְסֻף֙
wəhāʾsapsup · H0628
rabble, riff-raff · v4
A word found only here in the Bible. It doubles the root 'to gather' (ʾasap), so it means something like 'the scraped-together lot' or 'the hangers-on'. It is a scornful word for a fringe group travelling with Israel, and it puts them first as the ones who start the trouble.
-
אֲשֶׁ֣ר
ʾăšer · H0834A
who, which, that · v4, v5
Joins the next phrase to 'the rabble': the rabble 'that was' among them.
-
בְּקִרְבּ֔וֹ
bəqirbô · H7130G
midst, inner part · v4
'In its midst', meaning inside the people (hāʿām, v. 1) or the camp. The rabble are not off at the edge. They are inside the community, which is why their mood spreads.
-
הִתְאַוּ֖וּ
hitʾawwû · H0183
to desire, crave · v4
The verb is in a reflexive-intensive form: they worked up a desire in themselves, they gave in to appetite. Here the desire is for food, not sex.
-
תַּאֲוָ֑ה
taʾăwâ · H8378
desire, longing, appetite · v4
A noun from the same root as the verb before it: 'they craved a craving'. Doubling the root like this makes it stronger, as English translations show with 'had a strong craving' or 'lusted exceedingly'. The same word gives the place its name in v. 34, Kibroth-hattaavah, 'Graves of the Craving'.
-
וַיָּשֻׁ֣בוּ
wayyāšubû · H7725J
-
וַיִּבְכּ֗וּ
wayyibkû · H1058
to weep, wail · v4
Loud public weeping, the kind used in mourning and lament. In v. 10 it is done family by family at every tent door. It is a group protest, not quiet private tears.
-
גַּ֚ם
gam · H1571
also, even · v4
'Also', or 'even'. The complaining spreads from the fringe to the core: even Israel's own tribes join in.
-
בְּנֵ֣י
bənê · H1121G
sons, descendants · v4
'Sons of', a family term. It names Israel as the descendants of one ancestor, the covenant people itself.
-
יִשְׂרָאֵ֔ל
yiśrāʾēl · H3478
Israel · v4
The people as a whole, as opposed to the 'rabble'. The text marks the moment when the central group, not just hangers-on, takes up the complaint.
-
וַיֹּ֣אמְר֔וּ
wayyōʾmərû · H0559
to say · v4
Introduces what they cried out, which runs on into v. 5–6.
-
מִ֥י
mî · H4310
who? · v4
'Who…?' Followed by a future-tense verb, this is a standard Hebrew way of saying a wish: 'Oh, if only someone would…!' (compare 2 Sam 23:15). Under the wish lies a jab: who here can actually provide?
-
יַאֲכִלֵ֖נוּ
yaʾăkilēnû · H0398
to eat; (causative) to feed · v4, v5
A causative form, 'will cause us to eat', i.e. 'will feed us', with 'us' attached. They picture themselves being fed by a provider, and they deny that the one feeding them now is doing it properly.
-
בָּשָֽׂר׃
bāśār · H1320
flesh, meat; body · v4
Simply 'meat'. It is the last word of the sentence and the focus of the craving. It has no moral sense of a 'sinful nature' here, although the story later turns grimly on the word (v. 33, 'the meat was still between their teeth').
-
זָכַרְנוּ
zākharnû · H2142
-
אֶת־
ʾet- · H0853
[direct-object marker] · v5
A grammatical marker with no English equivalent. It shows that 'the fish' is what is remembered. It comes before each food in the list, and the repetition slows the list down.
-
הַדָּגָה
haddāgāh · H1710
-
בְּמִצְרַיִם
bəmitsrayim · H4714G
in Egypt · v5
"In Egypt": the place of slavery, now remembered as the place of good food. Saying the name is part of the irony.
-
חִנָּם
ḥinnām · H2600
for nothing, without cost · v5
"For nothing, free of charge." It is the punch line of the complaint. Slaves paid nothing for the food because they got nothing for their work either. The memory leaves out what the food really cost.
-
הַקִּשֻּׁאִים
haqqishshuʾîm · H7180
cucumbers (or snake melons) · v5
"The cucumbers." Most likely the long, thin, cucumber-like snake melon or chate melon grown along the Nile, eaten unripe and crisp. Cool and full of water, which matters given the 'dried-up' throat in v.6.
-
הָאֲבַטִּחִים
hāʾăvaṭṭiḥîm · H0020
melons, watermelons · v5
"The melons." The word appears only here in the Bible. It survives as Arabic baṭṭīkh (watermelon/melon). Watermelons are known from ancient Egypt. Another juicy food.
-
הֶחָצִיר
heḥātsîr · H2682B
leek(s) · v5
"The leeks." Elsewhere this word means 'grass, green growth' ("all flesh is grass," Isa 40:6). Only here does it name a garden vegetable, and the Greek translators read it as leeks. A grammatically singular word used for leeks as a group.
-
הַבְּצָלִים
habbətsālîm · H1211
onions · v5
"The onions." Appears only here in the Bible (compare Arabic baṣal). A staple food of Egyptian laborers, and sharp in flavor, the opposite of the plain-tasting manna.
-
הַשּׁוּמִים
hashshûmîm · H7762
garlic · v5
"The garlic" (plural in Hebrew: bulbs of garlic). Appears only here in the Bible (compare Akkadian šūmū, Arabic thūm). The list ends on the strongest flavor of all.
The world behind it
- Where this falls in the story. Israel has just left Sinai (Num 10:11–12). The first complaint has already ended in fire at Taberah, "Burning" (11:1–3). This is the second crisis in a row, and it opens a section of Numbers (chs. 11–21) that is mostly about complaining and rebellion on the march.
- Who the "rabble" may be. Exodus 12:38 says a "mixed crowd" (ʿerev rav) left Egypt with Israel. These were probably other enslaved or poor people of different origins who joined the exodus. The Torah elsewhere knows of non-Israelites living in the camp (Lev 24:10; Deut 29:11). The rare word here is meant to sneer, so it tells us more about the author's attitude than about their exact origin.
- Meat in the ancient Near East. Herds and flocks were a family's capital: breeding stock, milk, wool. They were not everyday food. Most people ate meat at festivals, sacrifices and hospitality meals. Israel had livestock (Exod 12:38; Num 32:1), and Moses' reply in v. 22 ("Shall flocks and herds be slaughtered for them?") shows that eating them would not meet the demand and would use up their wealth. Wilderness law also tied slaughter to the sanctuary (Lev 17:3–5).
- Egypt's diet. The Nile and its marshy delta were full of fish, and Egyptian workers lived mainly on bread, beer, onions, garlic and leeks. Herodotus (2.125) reports an inscription on a pyramid that recorded what the workers' radishes, onions and garlic had cost. The menu in v. 5 is believable as the ordinary food of the poor, remembered as "free" (ḥinnām) while the slavery that came with it is forgotten.
- Manna. Verses 6–9 explain what they are rejecting: a daily, reliable food that falls with the dew. Their complaint is that it is all they have, not that they are starving.
From the study of Numbers 11:4.
Where scholars differ
in v4
Who were the ʾasapsup, the 'rabble'?
-
The non-Israelite 'mixed crowd' that came out of Egypt with Israel.
Exod 12:38 (ʿerev rav). The Septuagint's epimiktos and the Vulgate's vulgus promiscuum. Jewish tradition (e.g. Rashi). Other non-Israelites in the camp (Lev 24:10; Deut 29:11).
-
A scornful name for a fringe of hangers-on, defined by attitude and position rather than ethnicity, who may have included Israelites.
The word comes from 'gather' and has a doubled, contemptuous form. It is not the ʿerev rav of Exodus, and the text never says outright that they are foreign. It also seems chosen to play on the 'gathering' words later in the chapter (vv. 16, 22, 24, 32). Several modern commentators (e.g. Milgrom, Levine) note that the word is uncertain.
in v4
What earlier weeping does 'again' refer to?
-
The complaint at Taberah just before (11:1), or the wider pattern of grumbling about food since Exodus 16.
Shuv before a second verb normally means repetition. Exod 16:3 has a complaint about the 'pots of meat'.
-
It should be read 'they sat and wept', and no earlier weeping is meant.
The Septuagint (and Vulgate) read the same consonants as yashav, 'sit'.
-
It also hints at 'turning back' toward Egypt.
YLT's literal rendering. The Egypt-centred speech in v. 5 and v. 20 ('Why did we ever leave Egypt?').
in v5
In what sense was the Egyptian fish 'free' (ḥinnām)?
-
Slave rations: state laborers were fed at the employer's expense, so the food literally cost them nothing.
Egyptian ration systems for work gangs (e.g., Deir el-Medina records listing grain, fish and vegetables). Herodotus 2.125 on food supplied to pyramid workers.
-
Abundance and cheapness: Nile fish were so plentiful that they could be caught or bought for almost nothing.
Herodotus 2.77, 92–93 on Egyptian fish-eating. Isa 19:8–10 on Egypt's fishing industry. Abundant fish in the Nile canals and marshes.
-
Nostalgic exaggeration that the narrator means the reader to see through, since slaves had nothing free (Pharaoh would not even give straw).
Exod 5:7–18. The parallel exaggeration in Exod 16:3 ('we sat by the pots of meat and ate bread to the full'). The ironic contrast with the command to 'remember you were slaves.'
-
Rabbinic reading: 'free of commandments,' meaning food eaten without the obligations of the covenant.
Sifre Numbers 87; Rashi on Num 11:5. This is a theological interpretation rather than the plain sense, but it starts from the same puzzle.
in v5
What exactly were the 'cucumbers' and 'melons'?
-
The qishshuʾîm were snake melons or chate melons (Cucumis melo varieties), not true cucumbers.
Paris, Daunay & Janick (2012) on the absence of Cucumis sativus in the ancient Mediterranean. Arabic qiththāʾ = snake melon. Ancient depictions.
-
A general term for cucumber-like gourds, possibly including true cucumbers.
Traditional identification (LXX σικύας, Vulgate cucumeres). Uncertainty about when the true cucumber spread west.
-
The ʾăvaṭṭiḥîm were watermelons (Citrullus lanatus), possibly also other melons.
Arabic baṭṭīkh. Watermelon remains in Egyptian tombs, including Tutankhamun's. Some scholars note that early Egyptian watermelons may have been grown partly for their seeds.
Sources
- BDB s.v. אֲסַפְסֻף, אָוָה, תַּאֲוָה
- HALOT s.v. אֲסַפְסֻף, אוה, בָּשָׂר
- Gesenius–Kautzsch–Cowley, Hebrew Grammar §151a (wishes expressed by מִי + imperfect)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Numbers 11:4
- Vulgate, Numeri 11:4
- J. Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary)
- B. A. Levine, Numbers 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
- T. R. Ashley, The Book of Numbers (NICOT)
- G. J. Wenham, Numbers (Tyndale OT Commentaries)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Numbers 11
- Herodotus, Histories 2.125
- Rashi on Numbers 11:4
- BDB s.v. זָכַר, חִנָּם, חָצִיר, קִשֻּׁאָה, אֲבַטִּחִים, בָּצָל, שׁוּם
- HALOT s.v. חִנָּם; חָצִיר II; קִשֻּׁאָה; אֲבַטִּחִים
- Septuagint, Numbers 11:4–6
- Vulgate, Numbers 11:5
- Herodotus, Histories 2.77, 2.92–93, 2.125
- Sifre Numbers 87; Rashi on Numbers 11:5
- J. Milgrom, The JPS Torah Commentary: Numbers (1990)
- T. R. Ashley, The Book of Numbers (NICOT, 1993)
- J. H. Walton, V. H. Matthews, M. W. Chavalas, IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Num 11:4–6
- M. Zohary, Plants of the Bible (1982)
- H. S. Paris, M.-C. Daunay, J. Janick, 'Occidental diffusion of cucumber (Cucumis sativus) 500–1300 CE', Annals of Botany 109 (2012)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).